---
title: "Music Ownership - Web3 Solves This | Twitter-Space-Aufnahme | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Twitter-Space-Aufnahme vom 2024-03-07 mit PopEx, Cohost, Luke Padfield, Katie Waissel, LayerOneX, Adam, Kreatorhood, JenMarie.eth/lens/tez 🔜 ETHDENVER 🔜 #NFTNYC2024, RealLucas™, TropicVibes, the Nifty guy 🇯🇲, King Julian 〽️, Spicy Capital"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/music-ownership-web3-solves-this"
---

# Music Ownership - Web3 Solves This

Aufgezeichnet: Mar 7, 2024 Dauer: 1:23:42

## Space-Aufnahme

[Original-Space öffnen](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1jMJgmyoQrqKL)

0:00 1:23:42

### Vollständiges Transkript

A singer in a smoky room, a smell of wine and cheap perfume, for a smile they can share

the night. It goes on and on and on and on. Strangers waiting, up and down the boulevard, there's shadows, searching in the night, streetlights deeper, living just to find the most I'm

outing, somewhere to find.

I'm outing, somewhere to find.

Letting hard to get my fill

Everybody wants a thrill

Playing anything to roll the dice

Just one more time

Some will win, some will lose

Some of all just sing the blues

What a pussy never ends

Just on and on and on and on

Hey everyone

Good evening, hope everyone is doing well

I wasn't sure if the music was playing

So if someone can react with an emoji

Is there a thumbs down?

I don't know if there is a thumbs down

Good to have you all here

I see some familiar faces

So that's good

That's good

Guys

Today I had a parcel coming in

From Amazon

I bought a t-shirt

And on it says

I told you so

With the Bitcoin logo

So I'm going to wear this

To family gatherings

In the next couple of months

They definitely will be happy with that

I think

Let me see

Is everyone

We've got co-host here

Might have some issues technically

With inviting the co-host

Today we have Luke here

From PopX

CTO

Musician

Very good musician

He's also very good in design

Like

Today in the call

He blew my mind

Showing something

With AI

That I've never seen before

So

It's really cool

Okay

Let's get some speakers on

And start with a little round

How are you doing?

Layer

One

Hey

Can you hear me?

Yes

Yes

Can you hear you

Clearly

All right

Perfect

My name is Cody

I'm the

Chief Experience Officer

At Layer 1X

Thanks for having us

If you're not familiar

With Layer 1X

We're a Layer 1

Blockchain

That is fully decentralized

And

We're looking to help

Transform the Web3 experience

And

Particularly

In the music

Industry

So

We're definitely excited

To

To kind of jump in

Today's conversation

Thanks for having us

Good

Good

Good

Good to have you on

And

We pinned the post

Of the

The Twitter

Space

So

To this

To this space

And

If you haven't yet

I know

Jean-Marie

You did

You did like

Quote

Quote

Tweeted the Twitter space

Really appreciate that

So if others could

Could also share the love

That would be

Would be great

So let's see

Who else do we've got

We've got on here

Adam

I know Adam

You co-tweeted the Twitter space

As well

How are you doing buddy?

I'm good

Hello

And I've just realized

I spent three minutes

At the start

On my desktop

And you know when

Twitter just completely

Rugs you

And I'm just like

Why are these guys

Not saying anything

And then I realized

That I need to rejoin

And everyone is here

So yeah

Great to be here

My name's Adam

It's my second time

On PopX

Really enjoyed the first one

I'm co-founder of Spark

We're working on

Some of crypto's

Hardest payment problems

Basically helping players

And users

Get onto games

And products

Without worrying about

What chain they're on

Or what token they're using

We're most famous

For handling

The 28 million dollar

Portal coin

ICO

Who you may have seen

On Twitter

At some point

And we're also working

On their

Kind of wider

Payments infrastructure

But also 20 other games

Metaverses

And entertainment products

As well now

And previously

I've also founded

A gaming studio

Before this as well

So that's a bit about me

And look forward to

Chatting with you guys

Sounds great

Adam

Big moves you're making

In Web3

Creator Hoot

Good to see you buddy

Yeah it's good to be back

I really enjoy

You all spaces

So yeah we're

NFT Marketplace

And creator

Launchpad

Just announced our token

You know

Come earn some points

And also

I've been a music producer

For the last

I don't know

A little over a decade

So I think I have

Some good input

Here as well

And yeah we hope

You guys use our marketplace

Good

Yeah definitely

Check it out

Gemma Rhee

Nice to have you on again

As well

Hey y'all

It's Ben Marie

I am a

Recording artist

A songwriter

Also a digital artist

In the Web3 space

But I also own

A catalog

From a family member

That passed away

Years ago

So I understand

The importance

Of music ownership

And especially

Moving into the Web3 space

And how we can

You know

Create solutions

I'm totally

On board

To be at the front

Helping build out

Tooling for that

So I look forward

To the conversation

Good stuff

Good stuff

Gemma Rhee

Tropic

Nice to have you

On mate

How are you doing?

I'm doing great

Can you hear me?

A little mic issue there

Yes

Yes

Awesome

I can hear you

I podcast about the space

All the benefits

Cool things

That's happening

With an NFT

Blockchain technology

However

The music area

Really interests me

As more so

As a collector

Someone who just

Loves music

Supporting the various

Artists that are doing

Some cool things in there

And just the whole

Discoverability process

And sharing music

With friends

And that's sort of

Something

You know

I miss from the

Quote unquote

Olden days

Right when you had

Albums and CDs

And booklets

And all those things

Just a social aspect

Of it

So I'm more so here

As the fan of the music

The collector of the music

And those things

And that's what I love

About this space

We love that

We definitely love that

At PopX

You might have something

Cool for you later on

King Julian

Good to see you back

Hello

Hello

Thank you for

Having me on

Yes

I'm the founder

And co-founder

Of MassMap

We're a

Web3 Everything app

Yeah

I won't go too

Deep into it

Again today

But yeah

Happy to be here

Super excited

To talk about

Ownership

Good stuff

Spicy

Nice to

Have you on

Yo

What's up man

Thanks for having me

On The Space

Appreciate you guys

I think it's our

First time on PopX

This is Shibzy Baker

Behind here

I am the CMO

Of Spicy Capital

We're a VC fund

In The Space

And we are

Regularly investing

Into projects

You know

We're pretty much

On the streak

At the moment

And once we do

Partner with people

We like to

Offer marketing support

As well

And take it from there

And that's across

All platforms

Social media

On social media

So Telegram

Twitter

And what not

It's actually really cool

To be connected

With some people

In this space

As well

We're seeing

Layer 1x

Dope guys

Their spaces are sick

Man

I've joined a few of theirs

And it's cool

To see Jo Marie

As well man

She probably doesn't

Remember who this is

But we connected

At East Denver

Very briefly though

Very very briefly

I think you were

Introducing your friend

To the space

For the first time

Our partner was there

And everything as well

It was at the

L-Bank event

So yeah man

Cool to see some people

And it's dope

To always meet people

IRL as well

I love it

I love the community vibes

And last but not least

Luke

How are you doing Luke?

Yeah good

Hi everyone

Yeah so I'm Luke

I'm co-founder here

At PopX

And not CTO

As Robert introduced me

I head up kind of

Product and design here

And my background

Before getting involved

In this was

I was in a band

With Matt

The CEO

And we have been

For like 15 years

And then yeah

You know

Kind of just done

All of these things together

Been on a mad trip

In the music industry

From

You know

Being fans

And owning music

That way

To releasing music

And the advent

Of things like Napster

And then

You know

And all the way up

To this now

So it's kind of

Been

You know

In my time

Seeing

Like a kind of

Full cycle of

Ownership coming

Going

And starting to

Kind of come back

As well

So it's really exciting

And yeah

Looking forward to it

Yeah you're right

You're right

There are those cycles

I remember Napster

Luke

That was my first time

Downloading

Or should I say that

Oh yeah

I think

I remember the

I remember the label

Calling us in

And being like

Oh you guys have had

You know

50,000 downloads

Of your album

On this new platform

Like oh amazing

What's the platform

Called

Napster

And then

We found out

What Napster was

So

Those kind of like

Imaginary

Or those kind of

Like flights of fancy

Of like

We can all get

Ferraris and stuff

Kind of quickly

Turn into

I mean we still got

Ferraris

They were just

Hot Wheels versions

Instead of

The proper one

Sounds like Spotify

No I'm joking guys

I'm joking

The topic of today

Music ownership

And

Raptory solves this

I mean

We don't have to

Stick with just music

Only I think in general

Like Raptory does

Solve some

Ownership

Issues

Or

Maybe even

Create some other

Kind of ways

Of having ownership

And things

So I would love to

Hear from anyone

What their view is

On Raptory

And ownership really

So maybe from

The music people

First kind of

If anyone wants

To join in

And also guys

Like you don't

Have to raise your hand

If you want to

You know

Jump into something

Just jump in something

People will shut up

In this space

You know

Haven't

Haven't had

An issue

Where I have to

Mute everyone

Like you know

It's not

It's not

It's not

It's not that type

Of vibe

In this space

So yeah

Just go ahead

Grab the mic

And do your thing

Really

So yeah

Ownership guys

What do we believe

About that

In

Raptory

I'll go ahead

I'll go ahead

And go

So I

Currently

Right now

I work

For a company

Called community

Labs

Which

They build

Is basically

A blockchain

Storage

Or data

On the

Arweave network

And one of

The things

That I was

Talking about

Was as a musician

What does this

Look like

For people

That have

Their music

On

On chain

Whether we're

Talking about

Optimism

Whether we're

Talking about

Sounds

Or whatever

One of the

Hardest things

Is to keep

Track of

Who's all

Collecting

Who's making

Like the most

You know

Who's spending

The most money

If you will

And we have

These

Different places

Where we can

Gather everybody's

You know

Wallets

But we all

Know

That anybody

Can get a

Wallet

Drain

Whatever

Switch

Wallet

So

I'm

Oftentimes

In meetings

Now

Wondering

Like how

Can we

All have

Like a

Centralized

Space

No matter

What happens

To your

Wallet

No matter

What wallet

You connect

The music

From

How can

We

Store that

Data to

Where we

Can actually

Get to

It

And it

Never

Expires

I think

Once we

Figure out

How to

Really

Do that

One

As a

One-stop

Shop

I feel

Like the

Rest of

The conversation

As far as

Onboarding

More music

Producers

And artists

In the

Space

As well

As collecting

Like publishing

And stuff

Like that

I feel

Like that

Might

Like be

More easier

Once we

Get the

Fundamentals

Down

Of how to

Gather the

Data that we

Already have

From collectors

As a musician

Yeah

Yeah that's

Nice

I'll

Jump in

I like

I like

What you

Said

Jen

You know

For us

When we

Look at

You know

Ownership

Of music

But

But even

Just ownership

Of nfts

Ownership

Of our

Own data

You know

Things like

That

That

That is

The true

Ethos

Of

Web3

Right

Is to

Own your

Data

Own your

Assets

And

You know

That's

Something that

We're

Working

Towards

At layer

One X

And one

Of the

Things that

We've

Built

Is

You know

A

Bridgeless

Interoperability

Experience

Which we

Call

Xtalk

And

The reason

Why we

Call it

Xtalk

Instead of

Using

Interoperability

Is because

It's such

A cliche

Word being

Thrown

Around

In

Crypto

And

Web3

Right

Now

And so

Xtalk

Goes a lot

Further

Than just

Being able

To transfer

Assets

Across

Chain

Bridgeless

But

It also

Allows you

To move

Data

And

As

Excuse me

Logic

And one

Of the

Things that

We've

Built

For

Our

Gaming

Platforms

Which can

Resonate

Over to

The

Musicians

To

Pretty much

Anything

Is

No matter

What chain

You're

Built

On

If you

Integrate

With

Like

Our

Blockchain

You'll

Basically

Be able

To

For an

Example

Let's

Just

Say

Had

A

Spotify

Type

Of

Project

That's

On

Ethereum

But

All

Of

Jen

Marie's

Music

Is

All

Over

On

Avalanche

Or

Or

You know

Binance

Or

Something

Like

That

Where

Where

Do

Go

Right

How

We've

Designed

It

Is

Is

That

If

Come

To

Layer

One

X

You'll

Basically

Be

Able

To

Play

That

Jen

Marie's

Music

Off

Of

Her

Chain

That

She's

Currently

On

Through

The

Platform

That

Is

On

Ethereum

And

Experience

It

All

Through

The

Layer

One

X

So

Basically

Lose

The

Agnostic

Feel

Of

Having

To

Know

Where

To

Put

Your

Content

Where

To

Where

To

Drive

Your

Users

To

Because

Now

It

Opens

Up

A

Borderless

Chain

Kind

Of

Experience

Where

To

Be

Honest

In

Our

Opinion

We

Feel

That

In

The

Future

Of

Web

Three

No

One

Will

Care

What

Chain

You're

On

Because

Everybody

Will

Be

United

And

That's

The

Vision

That

We're

Working

For

Love

It

Yeah

And

That's

Yeah

And

Just

To

Jump

In

On

That

That's

A

Really

That

That

Phrase

Like

No

One

Will

Care

It

Sounds

Like

A

Really

Negative

Way

To

Phrase

It

But

Whenever

Listen

To

Any

Songs

And

I

Sure

Kind

Of

Really

Into

The

Production

Side

Of

Things

Most

People

Won't

Know

What

Microphone

The

Vocal

Is

Done

Through

Or

What

The

Channel

Strip

Use

Or

The

Console

That

Was

Used

Or

Whether

The

Whether

The

Producer

Like

Coffee

Or

Tea

When

He

Mixed

In

Germany

So

It's

That

Thing

Of

Know

Focusing

On

As

Much

As

Getting

The

Artists

Over

It's

As

Well

As

Getting

The

Fans

Across

Is

The

Big

One

Know

Because

There's

Streaming

Platforms

Out

There

That

Pay

Better

Than

For

example

Spotify

But

Artists

Will

Have

To

Still

Use

Spotify

Because

That's

Where

The

Fans

Are

Predominantly

So

I

Think

It's

A

Case

Of

Creating

A

Way

Of

Fans

Being

To

Use

It

In

Intuitive

Way

And

That

Way

Of

It

Doesn't

Matter

What

Chain

The

Music

Is

On

If

The

Fan

Can

Access

It

And

It's

Seamless

Intuitive

Thing

For

Them

To

Do

That

That's

A

Huge

Part

Of

Being

Able

To

Bring

The

Whole

Know

Educating

People

On

The

Further

Benefits

Of

This

Can

Give

Yeah

I

Love

That

I

Think

Know

It

Kind

Of

Links

Accessibility

To

Ownership

As

Well

Right

Like

When

There

Is

More

Ownership

There

Is

More

Ways

To

Know

Allow

For

Accessibility

I

Guess

And

That's

Quite

Nice

Like

Layer

About

Know

When

Someone

Assets

Or

Someone

Content

Is

On

One

Chain

Someone

Else

Should

Be

Able

To

Access

That

No

Matter

Where

They

Behave

Behavior

Really

Is

Right

And

It

Reminds

Me

A

Little

Bit

About

Like

The

Web

To

Space

Where

Know

I

Don't

Have

Apple

Music

So

If

Something

Goes

On

There

First

I

Can't

Access

It

Right

So

Know

Web

3

Can

Definitely

Solve

For

That

I

Like

That

Angle

I

Didn't

Even

Think

About

That

Angle

But

That

That

Really

Interesting

I

Want

To

Know

A

Little

Bit

More

About

The

Musicians

Here

If

They

Believe

That

Music

NFTs

Is

Something

That

Really

Can

Improve

Ownership

In

Music

Because

When

I

Think

Yeah

Go

On

Cray

Do

Oh

So

Yeah

So

I'm

Torn

On

That

So

Obviously

I'm

Massively

Into

NFTs

In

Crypto

But

Like

I

Mentioned

Earlier

I've

Been

Know

I've

Been

Producing

My

Own

Music

For

A

Little

Over

A

Decade

Now

And

So

I

Love

The

Idea

Of

Ownership

And

How

Can

Truly

Own

Your

Music

With

The

Blockchain

The

Only

Problem

Is

I

Think

That

Would

Work

Really

Well

For

Very

Well

Established

Artists

But

It's

So

Difficult

For

A

Lot

Of

Smaller

Artists

To

Find

An

Audience

As

It

Is

So

Like

Spotify

For

In

So

One

Of

The

Reasons

Why

I

Think

It's

Great

Is

For

The

Discover

Ability

Know

Like

If

Can

Get

On

Discover

Weekly

Your

Music

Will

Automatically

Get

Sent

To

People

Who

Like

The

Genre

That

Create

And

It's

Really

Easy

For

To

Build

A

Fan

Base

And

They

Already

Have

That

Platform

So

What

Makes

For

Them

To

Support

Because

Maybe

They

Don't

Have

A

Wallet

They

Don't

Really

Understand

What

An

NFT

Is

And

So

In

Addition

To

Worrying

About

Gaining

Your

Audience

And

Finding

Your

Voice

And

Getting

Your

Music

Out

There

Now

Have

This

Extra

Friction

That's

Created

With

Having

To

Adopt

These

People

Into

The

Web

World

So

I'm

Torn

On

It

Because

I

Want

To

Believe

In

And

I

Want

It

To

Work

But

I

Don't

Think

That

It's

Realistic

For

Smaller

Artists

Now

When

Have

Grimes

And

Blau

And

A few

Of

These

Other

Artists

That

Already

Have

A

Massive

Established

Fan

Base

It's

Great

For

Them

They

Can

Make

More

Money

From

Their

Music

But

For

Smaller

Artists

I'm

Just

Not

Sure

It's

Going

To

Work

Not

Yet

Anyways

It's

An

Interesting

Take

Yes

As

Somebody

That

Has

Music

On

Chain

It's

Great

To

Build

Fans

That

Are

Already

Crypto

Native

Or

Are

Interested

In

The

Space

But

If

I

Have

Like

I

Do

A

Bunch

Of

Fans

That

Are

Not

On

Chain

Have

No

Idea

What

A

Wallet

Is

Don't

Know

What

A

C

Phrase

Is

It

Is

Really

They

Much

Rather

Go

On

To

Spotify

Or

Apple

Music

To

Listen

To

My

Music

Or

Buy

Merch

From

My

Shop

Then

Get

On

Chain

And

Support

Me

Via

That

Way

And

I

Think

And

I

Will

Always

Go

Back

To

It

One

The

Mass

I

Looked

I

Don't

Know

If

All

Saw

The

Forbes

Web

Three

That

They

Did

The

Rollout

But

It

Was

Only

Like

Two

Or

Three

Music

Or

Artists

That

Were

In

The

Space

That

They

Even

Highlighted

So

Even

In

Web

Three

Music

NFTs

Are

Kind

Of

Like

Oh

That's

Cool

But

It's

Not

Art

Because

Essentially

People

Are

Still

Like

What

NFT

Can

Pump

My

Bag

As

Opposed

To

Saying

Hey

Me

Buying

This

Person's

NFT

As

A

Musician

I'm

Supporting

Them

Know

Sustaining

Their

Livelihood

To

Create

More

Music

To

Go

On

Tour

What

Have

But

I

Just

Think

People

In

General

Unless

Are

The

Technology

Are

Really

Not

Checking

For

Music

NFTs

Which

Makes

It

That

Much

Harder

For

Us

As

Artists

To

Onboard

Fans

Into

This

Space

As

Well

As

Even

Be

In

The

Conversation

Amongst

Know

Other

Crypto

Artists

Or

Digital

Artists

That

Are

In

This

Space

That

Are

Building

So

It's

Just

Like

It's

A

Double

Edged

Sword

I

Collect

Music

NFTs

But

If

I

Go

Outside

To

Ask

My

Neighbour

She

Is

Like

I

Don't

Know

What

That

Is

So

We

Have

A

Disconnect

To

Where

It's

Like

If

Know

Know

But

For

The

Most

Part

Most

People

Just

Don't

Know

And

That's

Their

Life's

A

Problem

I

Think

I

Was

Going to

Say

I

Think

It's

Kind

Of

A

Waste

This

Is

In

My

Opinion

This

Is

In

My

Opinion

And

Also

Seeing

It

From

An

Investor

Standpoint

Obviously

Music

Art aren't

Asking

For

Investment

But

I

See

It

From

A

Way

Of

Investment

Because

Your

Investors

Are

The

Community

They're

Buying

Your

Music

They're

Buying

Your

NFTs

I

Think

It's

A waste

Of

Time

And

A waste

Of

Resources

If

Are

Focusing

On

Building

A

Music

Brand

In

Web3

And

Just

Trying

To

Build

Over

There

Because

Whilst

Web3

And

NFTs

Have

This

Really

Cool

Technology

It's

Amazing

We

Have

This

Tech

And

All

This

Great

Stuff

But

Come on

Let's

Be

Realistic

You're

Going

To

Grind

And

Grind

To

Do

All

That

Stuff

At

The

End

Of

If

Can

Put

Your

Artwork

Up

At

An

Event

The

Easiest

Thing

Could

Probably

Do

Is

To

Say

If

Like

Especially

If

You're

Trying

To

Build

In

Web3

Especially

Web2

If

Someone

Attends

Your

Event

Give

Them

Something

For

Attending

I

Think

Artists

Especially

In

This

Industry

In

Web3

Have

This

What's

It

This

God

Complex

That

They

Deserve

Coming

Let's

Slow

Down

For

A

Second

Yesterday

We're

Here

Because

We're

Not

Just

Supporting

But

We're

Supporting

The

Potential

That

Music

And

Art

Has

In

This

Industry

The

Potential

Of

What

The

Blockchain

Tech

Can

Do

For

In

The

Future

So

I

Think

If

Artists

Started

To

Look

At

It

From

Okay

Cool

I'm

A

Music

Artist

I

Might

Be

Performing

At

NFT

Beards

Or

NFT

Whatever

It

May

Be

NFC

Lisbon

It

Might

Be

A

Side

Event

15

Minute

Set

Doesn't

Even

Need

To

Be

An

Hour

15

Minute

Set

Rap

Two

Songs

Or

Sing

Two

Songs

Say

Thank

Very

Much

Get

Everyone

To

Scan

A

QR

Code

And

The

QR

Code

Drops

In

A

Po

App

And

Say

Everyone

That

Has

This

Po

App

You're

Going

To

Get

Something

In

The

Future

Whatever

It

Is

It

Might

Not

Be

Remember

When

Po-Ups

Got

Released

Through

Decentraland

The

Hype

Behind

Po-Ups

Was

Insane

They

Were

Freaking

Free

We

Didn't

Use

Them

For

Anything

I'm

Still

Looking

On

My

Po-Ups

Today

And

It's

Been

Two

Years

I

Have

Them

I

Have

Over

70

Or

Something

I

Still

Look

At

Them

Today

And

I'm

Still

Like

This

Is

So

Sick

Because

These

Are

My

Badges

For

Joining

The

Event

Can

Literally

Go

On

To

Po-App

And

See

The

Amount

Of

People

That

Collected

Your

Po-App

Then

Can

Go

To

Someone

That

Want

To

Back

Like

A

Sponsor

For

An

Event

And

Say

Look

These

Are

My

Numbers

This

Isn't

People

That

Listen

To

My

Music

No

This

Is

People

That

Attended

My

Event

Look

How

Many

And

Each

Wallet

Address

Is

Like

A

Unique

One

Look

At

The

End

Of

The

Day

A

Backer

Is

A

Backer

Need

To

Explain

To

Them

That

One

Person

Might

Have

Three

Wallet

Dresses

Fuck

All

That

Shit

Right

Just

Say

To

Them

That

This

Is

The

Amount

Of

Wallet

Dresses

These

Amount

People

That

Attended

My

Events

Look

How

Many

People

Attended

I

Had

100

In

The

First

One

I

Had

12

In

The

One

I

Had

50

That

Scanned

The

Second

One

I

Had

100

That

Scanned

This

One

And

Before

Know

Have

Hundreds

That

Scanned

Your

Po

App

Again

Goes

The

Same

For

People

That

Create

Physical

Artwork

Or

Digital

Artwork

Put

In

A

Gallery

Do

The

Same

Thing

It's

A

Great

Way

To

Track

Your

Progress

Over

Time

But

It's

Also

A

Great

Way

To

Track

Your

Community

And

What

You're

Building

And

Just

Duplicate

It

Into

Web

2

Just

Do

The

Same

Thing

In

Web

2

And

Build

Both

And

Eventually

It's

Going

To

Overlap

But

I

Get

Why

People

Are

Building

On

It

But

I

Don't

See

The

Point

Of

All

Results

Into

It

Find

A

Free

Way

To

Build

A

Community

And

Just

Do

That

Because

It's

Going

To

Be

A

Long

Journey

Until

The

Day

Where

We

Have

An

Actual

Music

Artist

From

Web

3

That's

Got

NFTs

And

Whatever

That

Has

Millions

Of

Listens

On

Platforms

We're

Out

We're

A long

Way

Away

From

That

We're

Just

Getting

Into

RWAs

We're

A long

Way

From

The

Music

Scene

Really

Taking

Off

So

Yeah

That's

What

I

Would

Say

I'm

Going

To

Say

One

Little

Thing

And

Then

I'm

Going

To

That

Is

An

Amazing

Point

I

Don't

Know

If

Any

Of

All

Know

Jaden

Violet

But

He

Did

Like

A

Poe

App

For

His

Daily

Weekly

Spaces

For

Like

A

Year

Straight

Now

Mind

He's

A

Web

2

Artist

Or

Whatever

But

In

His

Quest

To

Onboard

More

Art

Like

More

People

Into

The

Crypto

Space

All

Have

To

Do

Is

Have

A

Secret

Word

Mention

A

Poe

App

And

Call

It

A

Day

Like

Two

Different

Nights

Because

He

Utilized

The

Technology

As

An

Example

Of

This

Is

Like

A

Way

To

Start

In

The

Web

Three

Space

To

Onboard

Consumers

Whereas

Artists

Like

Myself

Could

Do

The

Poe

App

Message

Could

Do

That

Other

Artists

Like

Myself

We're

Know

Working

On

Different

Art

Projects

We're

Learning

New

Skills

Because

The

Ultimate

Goal

Is

To

Know

Be

In

A

Place

To

Where

We

Can

Make

Our

Full

Time

Job

But

In

Order

For

Us

To

Do

That

We're

Having

To

Know

Expand

Our

Skill

Sets

We're

Having

To

Learn

How

To

Use

AI

We're

Having

To

Learn

How

To

Animate

Music

Videos

Because

We

Don't

Want

To

Shoot

Them

Or

We're

Learning

How

To

Go

Into

The

Gaming

Industry

To

Figure

How

To

Get

Our

Music

Out

There

And

Building

Fan

Bases

Yes

We

Are

A

Long

Way

From

Math

Adoption

But

I

Think

The

Skills

That

We're

Learning

Along

The

Way

Will

Help

Curate

A

Bigger

Fan

Base

So

Once

Math

Adoption

Happens

Like

Everybody

Can

Feel

Like

They

Have

A

Piece

Of

The

Pie

But

Artists

Especially

Smaller

Independent

Artists

Have

Got

To

Start

Getting

More

Creative

In

Their

Hustle

And

Just

Think

Like

No

I'm

Just

Not

Making

Music

I'm

Actually

Creating

An

Experience

For

Fans

To

Want

To

Be

A

Part

Of

And

I

Think

That's

Know

What

We

Need

To

Get

To

In

Order

For

Mass

Adoption

To

Happen

But

Yeah

Totally

Agree

Totally

Agree

Yeah

That's

That's

Really

Good

Like

The

Word

Experience

And

I

Think

There's

Certain

Kind

Of

Genres

Out

There

That

Have

Historically

Been

Better

Before

The

Advent

Of

Web

3

Or

Digital

Trace

It

Back

To

Kiss

Is

Probably

The

Best

Example

A band

That

Is

Music

But

They

Create

An

Entire

Experience

Around

Them

To

The

Point

Where

It's

Bordering

On

Ridiculous

The

Merch

And

Things

That

They're

Selling

But

A

Couple

Of

Things

Like

There's

Something

Say

Earlier

Essentially

It

Comes

Down

To

A

Lot

Of

The

Accessibility

And

People

Like

The

Word

Grinding

And

Struggling

To

Get

Involved

In

The

Space

Or

Use

It

That's

A

Big

Thing

That

Is

Going

To

Be

A

Driver

Of

When

This

Starts

To

Really

Propel

Into

Mass

Adoption

Parallels

With

The

Advent

Of

Napster

And

Morpheus

And

All

Those

Download

Insights

Is

That

They

Were

Not

Particularly

Intuitive

So

I've

Heard

Before

I

Get

Myself

In

My

Show

It

Wasn't

Really

Until

The

iPod

Come

Out

And

The

User

Experience

Was

Really

Easy

To

Get

And

Understand

For

People

And

I

Think

That's

The

We're

At

The

Advent

Of

Those

Kind

Of

Things

Where

Like

Said

If

Know

Know

How

Good

This

Is

Or

How

Revolutionary

It

Can

Be

It

Just

Needs

To

Be

Put

In

Musicians

And

Fans

Like

They

Kind

Of

Put

In

The

Center

Of

The

Thinking

Around

That

Experience

And

How

They

Can

Interact

With

It

Because

Speaking

From

An

Artist

Point

Of

View

We

Would

Merch

Things

Online

Through

Big

Cartel

Or

Whatever

But

We

Were

Only

Able

To

Do

That

Because

The

Experience

Of

Being

Of

Going

To

The

Stores

Was

Simple

Enough

For

People

To

Grasp

A

Couple

Of

Clicks

And

They

Were

Done

So

I

Don't

Think

It's

Necessary

Until

The

Kind

Of

Ability

To

Do

That

Whether

It's

With

NFTs

Or

With

Any

Other

Kind

Of

New

Product

Or

Whatever

Is

That

Simple

Artists

Aren't

Going

To

Mind

Whether

They've

Built

Their

Fan

Base

On

Platform

Like

Spotify

Or

They've

Built

It

On

Some

Other

Platform

They

Will

That

Audience

Will

Know

Of

That

Band

And

That

Band

Uses

Whatever

They

Feel

Is

Their

Best

With

Communicating

To

Their

Fans

Whether

That

Is

Through

You know

Some

Fans

Mailing

List

Is

Probably

Their

Biggest

Collection

Of

Their

Fans

They

Can

Get

Hold

Or

Probably

More

Effective

Than

Facebook

Or

Twitter

Or

Anything

Else

Like

But

They're

Still

Not

Going

To

Be

Against

Driving

Fans

To

Say

An

NFT

Sale

If

They

Know

The

Experience

Their

Fans

Is

Simple

And

And

Intuitive

And

There's

Parallels

Between

Them

Sending

Them

To

A

Big

Cartel

Store

So

I

Think

That's

A

Big

Challenge

And

That's

Going

To

Help

Bring

Artists

Over

Who

Will

Bring

Fans

Over

And

Everybody

Comes

Over

To

This

Kind

Of

Distinction

Between

A

Web

2

Or

A

Web

3

Artist

Or

Musician

I

Think

It's

Just

You're

Describing

More

So

The

Tools

That

You're

Deploying

To

Try

And

Gain

Fans

Rather

Than

Know

It's

I

Know

It

Just

Feels

Like

That's

The

Kind

Of

Thing

I

Think

If

Start

Making

That

Split

It

Just

Kind

Of

Blurs

It

Just

Kind

Of

Confuses

The

Matter

In

My

Opinion

I

Think

Like

At

What

Point

Does

Somebody

Turn

From

A

Web

2

To

Web

3

Artist

Making

Music

Creating

Art

That

Want

To

Share

With

The

World

And

Generally

You're

Really

Great

Example

Of

Somebody

Who's

Learning

All

Of

These

New

Tools

And

Amazing

Things

To

Be

Able

To

Maximize

Your ability

To reach

Fans

One

Thing

Was

Just

Said

A

Second

Ago

Which

Know

I

Want

To

Jump

In

On

Which

I

Thought

Was

Really

Cool

Like

The

Experience

As

The

Fan

And

Connecting

All

Of

These

Different

Things

Because

Know

Like

Luke

Just

Said

Honestly

It

Doesn't

Matter

Where

The

Music

Is

If

The

Music

Is

Good

I'm

Going

Find

It

As

Far

As

Know

It

Gets

Before

My

Face

I'm

Going

To

Listen

To

It

And

Even

Just

This

Morning

I

Was

In

The

Creator

Head

Discord

Just

Speaking

To

Some

People

And

I

Was

Like

Hey

Have

Heard

About

Marty

Ray

Project

He

Is

Best

Known

For

This

Mix

Of

Our

Cover

For

Vanilla

Ice

Ice

Baby

Blew

Up

On

YouTube

My

Friend

Sent

It

To

Me

All

That

Stuff

That

Experience

Is

Cool

However

One

Of

My

Biggest

Goals

In

Web

3

As

Far

As

Music

Goes

Is

To

Have

A

Collaboration

Between

Him

And

Sammy

Ariega

I

Found

Him

Through

Strictly

Through

Web

3

During

Lockdowns

And

Pandemics

He

Was

Going

From

Room

To

Room

With

All

The

NFT

Communities

And

He

Was

Singing

Right

Through

The

Night

And

That

He

Grew

His

Fan

Base

So

Both

Of

These

Guys

Don't

Really

Fit

Into

A

Particular

Genre

Right

Marty

He's

Kind

Of

Soul

He's

Kind

Of

Country

He's

Kind

Of

Blues

And

He's

Got

A

Little

Bit

Of

Gospel

And

Hip

Hop

Sprinkled

In

Now

Have

Sammy

Ariega

Who

Is

A

Cuban

Country

Singer

From

Miami

That

Moved

To

Nashville

Got

Kicked

Off

Of

Sony

Because

He

Just

Doesn't

Fit

The

Mole

Right

So

Have

These

Two

Groups

Of

These

Like

Things

Of

The

People

That

Are

Not

Fitting

Into

The

Box

Of

The

Music

Industry

Right

Independent

Artists

And

Regardless

Of

If

They're

On

Spotify

Or

If

They're

Having

NFTs

On

These

Various

Platforms

Or

Whatever

I

Think

They're

Amazing

Music

Artists

And

Me

As

A

Fan

Now

Collecting

Sammy's

NFTs

And

Just

Listening

to

Marty

On

Spotify

And

All

These

Different

Things

I

Just

See

The

Opportunity

As

A

Fan

To

Have

The

Communication

Between

Both

Ends

And

Just

Kind

Of

Bridge

The

Gap

Now

It

Was

Easier

For

Sammy

Because

He

Was

In

Web3

And

A lot

Of

Artists

Who

Are

Web3

Natives

And

Such

Yeah

It

Makes

Sense

To

Build

There

Have

The

Opportunity

For

Communities

And

So

Find

us

But

Someone

Who

Has

No

Knowledge

Whatsoever

Of

Web3

It

Is

Hard

Sell

Because

It

Is

Hard

For

Me

To

Now

Approach

Marty

Like

Hey

I

See

That

Responded

To

A

Couple

Of

My

DMS

And

So

For

And

I

Want

To

Tell

About

NFTs

That's

A

Hard

Sell

However

I

Just

Said

Hey

Here's

This

Artist

That

Doesn't

Fit

A

Just

Like

That

Would

Be

Awesome

To

Have

A

Collab

And

Surprisingly

He

Just

Responded

He

Was

Like

Yeah

I

Be

Down

For

It

So

Now

It's

Like

One

Of

My

Goals

In

Life

Is

To

Just

Get

These

Two

To

Collab

I

Don't

Care

If

It's

On

Spotify

Or

If

It's

It's

For

Sale

The

Old

Fashioned

Way

If

It's

A

CD

I

I

Don't

Care

They're

Getting

My

Money

I'm

Spending

It

Because

I

Think

That

That

Is

One

Things

Is

Being

Bridged

Together

And

I

Don't

Care

Where

The

Music

Is

I

Just

Want

Good

Music

To

Happen

I

I

Agree

With

That

I

Definitely

Agree

With

That

Good

Music

That's

What

It's

All

About

Know

Just

Kind

Of

Listening

To

A

Couple

Of

The

Speakers

Share

Their

Thoughts

And

Insights

Two

Things

Really

Are

Starting

Patterns

Are

Starting

To

Form

For

Me

In

My

Mind

And

I'm

Going

To

Talk

About

It

From

More

Of

A

Developer

Kind

Of

Layer

One

Strategy

From

An

Infrastructure

Strategy

I'm

Going

To

First

Ask

Jen

Marie

What

Kind

Of

Genre

Of

Music

Do

Sing

Because

I'm

Going

To

Use

As

A

Use

Case

So

I

Actually

Sing

A

Lot

Of

Pop

In

R&B

But

I'm

Oklahoma

Gal

So

I've

Dabbled

In

The

Country

Way

Before

Beyonce

No

Shade

But

Mainly

Pop

In

R&B

Perfect

All

Right

Well

I

Hope

Don't

Mind

Me

Picking

On

But

I

Am

So

Know

Everybody

Everybody

Has

Been

Talking

About

Spreading

And

Splitting

Web

Two

And

Web

Three

Know

It's

It's

It's

Interesting

Being

A

UI

UX

Designer

For

Over

Two

Decades

And

Bringing

My

Talents

And

Experience

Over

To

Web

Three

Has

Been

Phenomenal

Because

It's

Been

A

Real

Eye

Opener

And

However

I

Think

That

A lot

Of

People

In

Web

Two

Space

User

Wise

Don't

Really

Realize

That

There

Are

Big

Companies

That

Use

Blockchain

Technology

Helping

Helping

These

Companies

Make

That

Transition

Has

Been

Kind

Of

My

Gateway

Into

This

System

As

Well

Into

The

Crypto

Into

Web

Three

And

It's

Primarily

In

The

Healthcare

Industry

That's

Doing

It

And

Know

If

If

We

Look

At

How

We

Can

Make

Tools

I

Think

It

Was

Luke

That

Brought

Up

The

Tools

That

Need

To

Be

Developed

That

Needs

To

Start

In

My

Opinion

At

The

Blockchain

Level

That's

What's

Going

To

Be

Scalable

For

Layer

2s

Layer

3s

As

They

Start

Building

On

A

Blockchain

To

Have

The

Infrastructure

For

Them

To

Be

Able

To

Create

That

Discover

That

Seems

To

Come

Up

Quite

A

Bit

In

A

Lot

Of

The

Speakers

Comments

And

Know

One

Thing

That

We're

Doing

That

We've

Been

Working

On

For

Quite

A

Few

Almost

A

Year

Now

Is

What

We

Call

Comment

It's

A

Content

Media

Tag

That

Automatically

Gets

Baked

Into

NFTs

That

Get

Minted

And

It's

Almost

Like

Metadata

Labels

Right

And

Those

Things

Are

Discoverable

Regardless

Of

The

You're

On

So

As

I

Mentioned

Before

Know

It'll

Help

With

The

Discovery

Of

New

Artists

That

Are

Coming

In

Versus

The

Well

Established

Ones

That

Are

On

Various

Platforms

The

The

The

Reason

The

Tool

Is

To

Help

The

Smaller

People

But

Likewise

If

Go

To

Social

Media

If

Go

To

Spotify

Apple

Know

And

Allow

Their

Algorithms

To

Influence

What

To

Play

Next

If

Haven't

Built

Your

Own

List

At

Their

Mercy

By

Implementing

This

Comment

Tag

Thing

It

Allows

People

To

Really

Create

Their

Own

Algorithms

And

Be

Able

To

For

An

Example

Tap

Into

Jen

Marie

Genres

That

She

Sings

With

Pop

I'll

Just

Use

The

Hashtag

Analogy

Of

Pop

Right

I

Can

Pull

In

Like

On

Twitter

Or

X

I

Can

Pull

In

All

The

Conversations

Around

That

Specific

Hashtag

And

It

Allows

Me

To

Discover

New

Things

As

Well

And

So

Really

People

Don't

Understand

The

Power

Of

That

And

How

Twitter

Has

Always

Been

That

Way

Sorry

X

I'm

An

Old

School

Twitter

Guy

But

Can

See

How

Can

Actually

Create

Your

Own

Algorithms

And

Listen

To

The

People

That

Want

To

Listen

Consume

The

Data

That

Want

To

Consume

In

A

Way

That

Want

To

Experience

It

And

That

Is

All

About

And

So

Like

I

Was

Know

Just

To

Wrap

This

Up

Is

It

All

Coming

Down

To

Artists

Like

Yourself

Jen

Talking

About

What

Need

As

An

Artist

To

Survive

Allow

Us

To

Make

Those

Products

For

So

That

Can

Focus

On

Being

What

Do

Best

An

Artist

Being

A

Singer

I'm

A

I'm

An

Artist

As

Well

And

I

Love

Doing

Art

And

I'm

A

Firm

Believer

That

Art

Comes

In

So

Many

Different

Forms

Not

Just

Music

Not

Just

Art

Know

I

Even

Like

To

Say

There

Are

Some

Real

Artists

Out

There

When

It

Comes

To

Crafting

Good

Quality

Twitter

Means

Know

That

Is

An

Art

In

Itself

So

Definitely

Open

Your

Mouth

Jump

Into

These

Groups

Because

There's

People

That

Like

Myself

That

Are

Developing

For

The

Future

And

We

Love

To

Hear

This

Feedback

Because

It

Helps

Drive

Us

And

Allows

Us

To

Know

Where

To

Go

Next

That's

Great

I mean

Yeah

Like

What

Would

Just

Explained

Sounded

A bit

Like

The

Community

Feature

On

Twitter

X

I

Mean

I'm

Also

Twitter

The

Guy

I

Like

To

Say

Twitter

Instead

Of

X

But

Within

That

Community

Group

Then

Kind

Of

Decide

How

The

Algorithm

Works

Is

That

Do I

Understand

It

Correct

So

Basically

Your

Audience

Will

See

Whatever

Think

Is

More

Important

Instead

Of

That

It's

Based

On

The

Likes

And

Clicks

Because

Someone

Know

Hands

Up

Clicking

A bit

Way

More

Than

Someone

Else

Basically

100%

Regardless

Of

Power

Of

What

We're

Trying

To

Build

100%

That

Sounds

Great

I

Mean

It

Sounds

Like

To

Keep

Drawing

Analogies

To

Where

We

Are

At

The

Moment

It's

Know

I

Know

I'm

Sure

Most

People

Won't

On

Say

For

Spotify

Check

What

Label

The

Tracks

Released

On

But

It's

All

Gathered

There

For

Them

To

Discover

So

We

Just

To

Be

To

Do

That

And

Kind

Of

Fragmentation

Of

Different

Chains

And

People

Being

Able

To

Deploy

Different

Things

In

Different

Places

It

At

The

End

Of

The

It's

Amazing

To

Open

Up

Those

Kind

Of

Opportunities

And

Choices

And

That's

Another

Byword

For

The

Ownership

Of

The

Music

Of

Where

Want

It

To

Be

And

How

Know

Whether

That's

One

Part

Of

It

But

That

Kind

Of

It

Also

Creates

That

Fragmentation

Of

The

User

Experience

Know

If

Somebody

Wants

To

Listen

To

Say

One

Band

They

Love

And

They

Want

To

The

Next

One

Are

They

Realistically

Going

To

Jump

Between

Different

Places

With

Different

User

Experiences

And

Different

They're

Not

Going

To

Do

It

Like

That's

The

One

Thing

As

Much

As

Know

The

Streaming

Services

From

An

Artist

Point

Of

Have

Been

Good

In

Building

The

Exposure

They've

Been

Detrimental

In

The

Financial

Sense

Potentially

They

Have

Created

That

Unified

Experience

For

Fans

Who

Are

The

Most

Important

Ones

Anyone

Could

Be

A

Musician

Or

Artist

But

It's

Almost

Pointless

If

You've

Not

Got

Fans

To

A

Certain

Degree

If

That's

What

You're

Looking

To

Do

In

Life

And

That's

Why

Fans

Have

Always

Got

To

Be

Kept

At

The

Forefront

Of

The

Thinking

Around

All

Of

This

All

The

Time

Yeah

I

Mean

Also

To

Touch

Up

On

The

Point

That

I

Mean

Spicy

And

Layer

One

X

Have

Been

Putting

Out

Is

Really

Like

Know

The

Infrastructure

Layer

Of

The

Business

Models

Really

Need

To

Be

Set

Here

Right

Like

If

We

Think

About

Know

Early

2000s

Like

And

We

Kind

Of

See

Where

We

Are

Today

Know

We're

Right

Now

We

We're

Grinding

We're

Putting

Our

You're

Putting

Your

Content

In

Terms

Of

Music

Right

Now

Everywhere

You're

Trying

All

These

New

Different

Things

People

Doing

The

Same

Thing

Early

2000s

They're

Ripping

Off

Their

CDs

Or

Mixtapes

And

Just

Like

Going

Everywhere

To

Try

To

Put

Their

Places

Using

The

Newest

Technologies

Which

Was

Know

For

Mixtapes

And

Figuring

Out

How

To

Rip

CDs

But

Then

Comes

I

Want

To

Make

Music

Accessible

To

Everybody

Like

I'm

Not

Sure

If

Everyone

Watched

The

Spotify

Movie

Right

Because

During

That

Time

If

One

Was

Pirating

Move

Music

And

Then

Pirate

It

From

Your

Computer

And

Then

Download

It

Into

Your

MP3

Or

Your

iPod

Or

Whatever

And

Then

Spotify

Comes

Out

Simplifies

That

Whole

Process

Makes

The

User

Experience

Very

Beautiful

It's

The

It's

The

Business

Models

Right

And

Somebody

Basically

Leading

The

Space

So

Know

I

Think

That

Is

Going

To

Be

Very

Important

For

Us

To

Find

These

People

Who

Are

Looking

To

Change

The

World

Right

Can

Have

And

It's

Usually

Just

One

Person

Just

Need

Somebody

Who

Really

Wants

To

Create

A

Platform

For

People

To

Utilize

This

New

Technology

To

Have

This

X

Y

Z

Benefits

Know

So

It's

The

Same

Thing

Same

Thing

With

Instagram

Right

Like

Instagram

Created

A

Platform

Now

We

All

Use

It

Twitter

Created

A

Platform

We

All

Use

It

And

Those

Of

Us

Who

Benefit

From

It

Right

Like

Your

Creator

Or

Your

X

Y

Z

It's

The

Platforms

That

Or

I guess

Business

Models

That

Are

Going

To

Know

Enable

This

For

The

Common

Person

Right

Same

Thing

With

McDonald's

Like

McDonald's

I mean

McDonald's

Is a

Kind of

Weird

Example

But

You know

They

Have

Systems

Put

In

Place

That

Enable

14

Year

Olds

17

Year

Olds

To

Run

A

Whole

Operating

Crazy

Business

So

And

That's

Going

To

Create

You know

New

Jobs

I

Don't

Know

I

Think

We

Should

Really

Be

Trying

To

Support

People

Who

Have

This

Vision

So

If

We

Have

If

Hear

Somebody

In

Your

Network

Hey

We

Want To

Do

X

Y

And

Z

Really

Right

Now

Spending

Your

Time

Maybe

10%

Of

Your

Time

To

Actually

Join

Their

Twitter

Join

Their

Discord

Really

Talk

To

The

Founders

And

Give

Them

That

Leg

Up

So

That

They

Can

Actually

Bring

This

Vision

There's

A lot

Of

People

Can

Try

Thousands

Of

Business

Models

Not

All

Of

Them

Are

Going

To

Work

But

If

We

Dog

Food

All

Those

Business

Models

We're

Going

To

Find

One

And

That

One

Is

Going

To

Enable

All

Of

The

Musicians

To

Actually

Succeed

In

This

Space

Won't

Be

Able

Do

It

By

Yourself

Right

So

We

Have

To

Kind

Of

Know

One

Artist

Is

Not

Going

To

Change

The

Whole

Entire

Space

Unless

You're

Like

Beyonce

Or

Taylor

Swift

Actually

She's

Propping

Up

The

U.S.

Economy

As

It's

A funny

Joke

Everyone

Know

If

You're

A

Creator

Know

Really

Go

Out

Of

Your

Out

Of

You're

Looking

To

Kind

Of

Know

Get

Involved

In

The

Space

Be

An

Early

Adopter

In

The

Space

Continue

To

Try

New

Things

Right

It's

Really

Important

It's

Not

Just

For

Yourself

It's

For

It's

For

Everybody

Other

People

Are

Going

To

The

Space

That

Don't

Have

To

Go

Through

The

Shit

That's

Kind

Of

Interesting

That

Said

That

Mentioned

The

Business

Models

Because

That's

One

Of

The

Things

That

Most

People

Throw

Back

At

The

Space

And

Say

It

Doesn't

Make

Any

Sense

Because

The

Business

Models

Aren't

Really

There

But

Those

Two

Examples

That

Use

Is

Kind

Of

Interesting

Because

Number

One

Spotify

Is

Profitable

For

The

Record

Companies

But

Spotify

Hasn't

Figured

Out

How

To

Make

And

Of

Course

We

Know

How

The

Artists

Are

Being

Treated

On

The

Platform

That's

Why

They

Dove

Into

Podcasting

So

Much

Is

Because

They're

Like

All right

There's

Less

People

To

Pay

If

We

Bring

On

Joe

Rogan

Right

We

Just

Cut

One

Big

Check

And

Everything

With

Ads

Is

On

Top

Of

That's

Profit

So

They're

Trying

A

Dabbling

All

Over

These

Different

Places

So

Even

The

Big

Average

Artist

But

Also

Even

McDonald's

Right

McDonald's

Had

That

Issue

When

They

Weren't

Really

Making

The

Money

From

The

Burgers

They

Had

To

Actually

Make

Money

From

Real

Estate

Most

People

Don't

Know

That

McDonald's

Corporation

Is

Really

A

Real

Estate

Company

And

The

People

That

Are

Running

The

Restaurants

Are

Making

The

Money

From

Selling

The

Food

But

That's

Another

Topic

In

Itself

So

Going

To

This

Whole

Thing

With

Music

Right

The

Gold

Goal

Of

It

Is

To

Get

Music

In

The

Ears

And

As

A

Fan

I

Know

It

Sucks

To

Hear

Artists

That

Are

Pouring

Their

Heart

Out

Into

Their

Their

Work

And

They're

Not

Being

Compensated

From

It

And

It

Really

Sucks

And

I

Would

Just

Say

That

People

That

Are

Exploring

To

Solve

These

Problems

Might

Think

Of

Something

Absolutely

Crazy

And

If

Ray

Kroc

Listened

To

People

And

Said

Hey

Become

A

Real

Estate

Company

And

Only

Focused

On

Burgers

And

Milkshakes

McDonald's

Wouldn't

Be

What

It

Would

Be

Today

Right

Or

With

In

The

Case

Of

Spotify

Well

Guys

Aren't

Making

Any

Money

Shut

Down

So

Just

Keep

Exploring

And

I

Think

It's

Really

Cool

And

Eventually

The

Music

Will

Find

Ears

And

I

Believe

I

Hope

That

Things

Will

Work

Itself

Out

Know

Yeah

I

Think

So

I

Think

A

Very

Interesting

Point

That

Made

There

About

How

The

Big

Companies

Are

Still

Figuring

Out

Themselves

Know

And

See

That

Like

Even

Something

Very

Successful

As

Starbucks

Is

Eventually

Experimenting

With

Web3

So

And

That's

Only

Because

Of

Us

Really

Right

It's

Only

Because

Of

The

What's

Going

On

About

Three

And

They

Kind

Second

Something

Is

Going

On

There

That

Is

Actually

Maybe

Valuable

To

Our

Customers

So

I'm

Quite

Interested

To

See

How

Like

Yeah

The

Big

Labels

And

Such

Will

Actually

Adapt

To

What's

Coming

Because

They

Have

To

Adapt

At

Some

Point

Right

Yeah

I

Just

Want

To

Add

One

More

Point

On

To

What

Tropic

Was

Saying

Especially

With

Spotify

I

Mean

With

That

Specific

Business

Model

That

Worked

I

That

They're

Currently

Using

Is

That

In

Web

Two

A

Lot

Of

It

The

Value

Does

Get

Placed

On

The

End

User

Like

Who

Actually

Is

The

Consumer

And

Then

Because

It's

Web

Two

The

Businesses

Obviously

Because

They

Own

All

The

Servers

They

Own

Obviously

Then

The

Emphasis

On

The

Customer

Is

Right

Customer

Know

The

Customer

Is

Always

Right

But

Now

What's

Cool

With

Web

Three

Is

That

The

Business

Model

Now

That

We

Can

Figure

Out

Is

Like

It

Actually

Now

Provides

Value

Back

To

The

People

Who

Own

It

Right

Because

That's

Obviously

Like

Know

Web

Own

It

Now

But

Yeah

And

Going

Back

Business

Model

Is

Everything

McDonald's

Would

Have

Failed

If

They

Didn't

Do

The

If

They

Didn't

Pivot

Into

The

The

Real

Estate

Business

Because

Obviously

Scaling

A

Business

Is

Really

Really

Difficult

And

So

For

Them

It

Was

Like

In

California

That's

Where

McDonald's

Started

It

Was

Very

Profitable

Very

Good

But

Like

Know

They

Couldn't

Scale

It

Because

The

The

Issue

Was

The

Quality

The

Consistency

Which

Is

Why

They

Had

To

Create

That

System

And

Then

Basically

They

Created

The

System

And

Their

Customer

Was

Actually

Selling

Entrepreneurs

The

Ability

To

Replicate

This

Business

But

They

Would

Actually

Own

The

Establishments

So

They

Made

Money

Off

The

Real

Estate

And

The

End

User

Set

Up

All

These

McDonald's

Because

Now

Have

Hundreds

Of

Thousands

Of

People

Want

McDonald's

So

The

Business

Model

Is

Very

Key

Here

Yeah

And

Just

To

Just

To

Follow

Up

On

That

I

Think

There's

Not

There

Was

The fear

With

The

Advent of

The

Streaming

Platforms

That

They

Like

Somebody

Was

Going

To

Lose

Out

Somewhere

Along

The

Line

Financially

And

Okay

Like

The

Scales

Kind of

Tipped

Against

The

Artist

If

Just

Look at

It

Purely

From

Streaming

Revenue

But

The

Upshot

For

An

Artist

Is

The

Ability

To

Get

To

More

People

Quicker

With

Much

Lower

Spend

Know

Can

Put

Stuff

On

Spotify

For

Know

Whatever

It

Cost

To

Put

Stuff

Through

Distro

Kid

Or

Whatever

And

Then

It's

On

Like

There's

A bit

Of

Like

A

Responsibility

On

The

Artist

As

Well

To

Adapt

Know

That

That's

The

Thing

Not

To

Be

To

Sit

In

Your

Bedroom

Play

Some

Stuff

And

The

World

Is

So

We

Built

A

Bigger

We've

Got

A

Bigger

Set

Of

Years

Listening

To

Us

We

Can't

Generate

The

Revenue

For

Ourselves

Here

So

We'll

We'll

Direct

Fans

To

Go

To

Merch

Or

Know

Which

Is

Still

Going

To

Be

An

Amazing

It's

Still

Really

Important

For

Artists

And

I

Imagine

We'll

Be

Forever

more

But

Then

They

Can

They

Got

That

Bigger

Audience

Or

Potential

Customer

Base

About

Artists

Being

Inventive

And

Adapting

They're

The

Ones

Who

Are

Going

To

See

The

Potential

Or

They're

Going

To

Think

Of

Uses

For

This

Stuff

That

Nobody

Has

Imagined

Yet

That's

Always

Going

To

Be

A

Really

Good

Thing

For

It

So

When

Somebody

First

Approached

Matt

And

I

A

And

Said

About

Doing

An

NFT

Drop

We

Didn't

At

The

View

Of

Them

At

The

Time

From

What

We

Understood

Them

To

Be

Just

Really

Expensive

JPEGs

And

Then

We

Saw

The

Underlying

Technology

Was

The

Important

Bit

Really

And

We

Started

To

See

The

Potential

Of

How

We

Could

Use

That

And

That

Is

Where

The

Really

Big

Innovations

Are

Going

To

Come

In

This

Space

Is

Somebody

Looking

at

It

From

A

Bit

Of

A

Skewed

Angle

That

Nobody

Else

Ever

Thought

Of

And

It's

Probably

It's

Going

To

Be

An

Artist

Somewhere

Along

The

Line

Who

Is

Going

To

Think

Of

That

Because

There's

Like

A

Certain

Type

Of

Screw

Have

To

Have

Loose

To

Want

To

Be

An

Artist

Anyway

So

Yeah

That's

That's

My

Take

On

That

Yeah

And

That's

A

Great

Point

I

Mean

That's

What

I'm

Saying

Have

To

Be

It's

Interesting

Because

Right

Now

We

Got

To

Understand

That

It's

Only

I

Think

It's

Only

Like

2.5

Or

5%

Of

All

Global

Engineers

Actually

In

Web3

It's

Very

Like

Web3

Engineers

Like

The

Engineers

In

The

Space

Is

So

Tiny

Compared

To

The

Actual

World

Right

And

If

Look

At

The

The

Just

Like

The

Power

Rule

Right

Know

The

More

People

In

The

Space

You're

Going

To

Have

More

People

With

Know

Screws

Loose

To

Actually

Want

To

Try

Something

Crazy

The

Cool

Part

Is

That

We

Are

All

Here

Building

The

Infrastructure

Right

We're

Building

D-Pens

Or

Know

D-Rens

And

All

This

Crap

Right

The

Cool

Part

Is

That

Once

We

Do

Hit

We

Start

Moving

More

Into

Mass

Adoption

Right

So

About

Two

Years

Bitcoin

Is

Over

100,000

It

Becomes

More

Legitimate

All

This

Blah

Blah

Blah

You're

Going

To

Have

Now

All

The

Engineers

That

Have

Never

Want

Like

Oh

Man

Web3

Is

Bullshit

Right

Because

Know

Sometimes

A lot

Of

Engineers

Think

That

Way

A lot

Of

Engineers

Are

More

They

Don't

Like

Know

They're

Very

Like

Not

All

The

Time

Multifaceted

Like

They're

Just

Like

They

Love

To

Just

Look

At

One

Problem

And

Just

Do

That

So

Know

Once

That

Happens

You're

Going

To

Start

Pouring

In

From

Two

To

Five

Percent

And

That

Fifteen

Percent

Twenty

Percent

Twenty

Five

Maybe

At

Twenty

Percent

Right

You're

Just

Going

To

Unlock

That

One

Engineer

And

Now

He

Comes

In

The

Space

He

Really

Understand

All

And

He

Might

Be

Someone

Who's

Actually

In

The

Music

Industry

And

Engineer

In

The

Music

Industry

Probably

Spotify

He's

Like

Oh

Yeah

I

See

All

He

Knows

How

To

Build

All

The

Infrastructure

Which

Is

Interesting

Because

My

CTO

Actually

Was

A

Staff

Engineer

At

Spotify

But

Is

That

They're

Going

To

Come

In

They

Automatically

Just

Be

Like

Oh

Wow

Like

Everyone

Knows

How

To

Use

Deep

Ends

Everybody

Knows

How

To

Use

X

Y

And

Z

There

There

There

There

This

API

There

This

Infrastructure

They

Just

Put

It

All

Together

Try

It

And

Boom

Now

There's

That

The

Solutions

Out

There

I

Love

That

I

Think

It's

Well

Like

Know

Like

Said

Like

That

Share

Of

Engineers

Developers

Is

Going

To

Grow

And

People

Are

Going

To

See

More

And

More

Opportunity

With

The

Technology

While

They

Can

And

On

What

Luke

Touched

On

The

Artist

It's

Also

Their

Responsibility

Right

Like

Know

It's

It's

Not

Enough

To

Just

Be

Like

I'm

A

Really

Good

Artist

I

Make

Music

In

My

In

My

Batroom

And

No

One

Listen

To

It

Right

So

It's

Also

Up to

Them

To

Experiment

With

Whatever

Is

Available

To

See

What

Connect

Next

But

Also

I

Think

Very

Importantly

Like

What

Converts

Because

If

Have

A

Platform

Spotify

Where

Can

Get

A

Lot

Of

Streams

That's

Just

Eyeballs

So

That

Doesn't

Necessarily

Have

To

Convert

Into

Know

A

Certain

Amount

Of

Dollar

Value

But

If

Have

Those

Eyeballs

It's

Up

To

To

Then

Convert

It

Into

Value

Right

And

Whether

That

Is

Know

With

Other

Things

Like

Merge

Whether

It's

With

Things

Like

Know

NFTs

It

Could

Be

It

Could

Be

That

Create

Something

Very

Simple

Very

Accessible

That

Fans

Can

Can

Actually

Access

And

Own

And

Then

Back

Into

This

Like

Music

Ownership

And

Maybe

Hand

Over

Some

Of

Your

Ownership

Of

The

Music

To

Fans

And

In

That

Way

Might

Be

Able

To

Increase

That

Value

Not

Of

Your

Own

Music

Piece

Initially

But

Of

That

Customer

Or

That

User

There's

A

Lot

Of

Way

Where

Could

Utilize

Web3

To

Solve

Ownership

Or

The

Other

Issues

That

Music

Might

Face

Katie

I

See

Got

Your

Hand

Up

Just

Want

To

Add

Something

Oh

Hi

And

Thank

So

Much

For

Having

Me

As

A

Speaker

I

Believe

That

Spicy

Had

The

Hand

To

Me

So

If

They

Want

To

Speak

I

Happy

To

Wait

My

Turn

I

Appreciate

That

Man

Thank

So

Much

Katie

Yeah

No

I

Just

Wanted

To

Say

I

Didn't

Want

To

Drop

Out

The

Space

But

I

Do

Have

To

Go

I

Got

Another

Call

And

I

Got

Another

Space

In

15

Minutes

But

This

Was

A

Dope

Space

I

I

Will

Definitely

Follow

Everyone

Here

Thanks

For

Having

Us

As

A

Guest

But

Yeah

Definitely

Look out

For

More

Pop

X

Spaces

In

The

Future

Man

This

Is

A

Really

Cool

One

I

Haven't

Dabbled

A

Lot

Into

The

Music

Spaces

But

I'm

Definitely

Going to

Utilise

Pop

X

As

One

Of

Those

For

Sure

I

Feel

Like

I

Got

A

Lot

Of

Value

From

This

Thank

So

Much

Spaces

Yeah

Like

Your

Contribution

Was

Really

Appreciated

I

Think

Yeah

Dropped

A

Few

Good

Things

And

If

You're

If

You're

Dropping

Off

Now

Join

Our

Discord

We're

Dropping

Some

Announcements

Which

Might

Like

Yeah

Pop

X

Thanks

For

Thanks

For

Having

Us

Thanks

Okay

Katie

Thank

So

Much

And

I'm

So

Pleased

That

Spicy

Again

I'm

Just

Calling

Out

By

Your

Username

Spicy

But

I'm

So

Pleased

That

They

Got

To

Speak

And

Give

Their

Thanks

And

Say

Bye

But

This

Is

A

Really

Interesting

Topic

And

Obviously

I've

Already

Just

Jumped

On

And

I

Appreciate

Having

Me

Up

Here

As

A

Speaker

But

It's

Something

I'm

Incredibly

Passionate

About

Especially

With

The

Future

Of

Music

And

The

Trajectory

Of

Where

It's

It's

Almost

Foreseeable

Where

It's

Going

To

Go

In

That

Digital

Space

Especially

With

The

Project

Such

As

Stems

NFTs

And

So

On

And

So

Forth

And

One

Of

The

Big

Questions

I

Often

Find

Myself

Asking

Is

Know

In

The

Music

Industry

There

Are

The

Likes

Of

ASCAP

BMI

That

In

The

USA

Are

Well

What

Would

I

Describe

Them

As

They're

The

No

They're

Not

Publishers

But

Somewhat

Of

The

Facilitators

For

The

Royalties

To

Be

Collected

Well

Facilities

For

The

Royalties

To

Be

Collected

And

Also

Have

PRS

And

MCPS

So

When

Write

Your

Song

Copyright

That

And

Almost

Digitally

Stamp

It

In

So

Which

Shape

Or

Form

I

Speak

From

Experience

Just

Those

That

Don't

Know

I'm

As

Historically

A

Songwriter

I've

Been

With

PRS

And

MCPS

Well

Like

From

The

Beginning

Many

Many

Years

But

Prior

To

Them

I

Used

To

Put

My

CD

Into

An

Envelope

And

Send

It

To

Myself

Recorded

Delivery

And

That's

How

One

Would

Copyright

It

And

The

Song

Splits

Etc

But

Now

That

The

Music

Is

Now

That

Music

Is

Being

So

Like

Split

And

Broken

Apart

Which

Is

Not

Necessarily

A

Bad

Thing

It's

Very

Very

Very

Important

For

The

Creators

Or

The

Creatives

Be

It

The

Writers

The

Musicians

The

Vocalists

So

On

And

So

Forth

To

To

Rightfully

Be

Paid

And

Have

Some

Type

Of

Licensing

To

Use

Those

Stems

So

I

Had

Spoken

To

The

Guys

That

Are

Currently

Building

Out

My

Company

Owl

OWHL

Platform

We're

Here

To

Oversee

The

Welfare

Human

Rights

And

Liberty

For

All

Those

In

The

Creative

Industry

Sector

And

I

Said

How

Can

There

Be

A

Digital

Way

A

Web

Three

Way

Shout

Out

Pop

X

To

Almost

Blockchain

This

So

That

People

Feel

That

There

Is

Legitimacy

And

Know

A

Clear

Channel

Of

Ownership

Over

What's

Rightfully

Yours

But

Then

The

Ability

To

Independently

License

That

So

Everybody

Can

Benefit

Know

From

A

Monetary

Standpoint

As

Well

As

A

Usage

Standpoint

So

How

Do

Track

That

So

I

Find

This

Incredibly

Fascinating

I'm

Again

New

To

The

Space

And

Loving

Listening

Thank

For

Letting

Me

Speak

I

Will

Continue

To

Listen

And

I'm

Having

Been

In

The

Music

Industry

For

Decades

Wow

I'm

So

Old

I

Really

Am

Oh

My

God

I'm

More

Than

Happy

To

Answer

Any

Questions

That

Anyone

May

Have

Also

So

Thank

For

Letting

Me

Share

Share

Share

With

100%

Katie

No

Are

Yeah

And

Yeah

Just

To

Kind

Of

To

Talk

About

What

Katie

Was

Saying

About

The

PRS

The

MCPS

They

Do

Amazing

Work

For

Artists

They

They're

On

The

Artist

Side

They

Make

Sure

That

People

Are

Paying

They

Even

Down

To

The

Local

Salon

Who

Has

Got

The

Radio

Play

And

They

Make

Sure

They

Pay

Their

Memberships

Because

That

Money

Will

Feedback

To

Artists

And

Support

Artists

That

Way

And

Them

And

All

The

Around

The

World

They've

Been

Able

To

That

With

Web

2

Technology

So

I

See

Web

Technology

As

Something

That's

Going

To

Make

It

Even

Easier

For

Them

To

Do

And

I

Know

There

Are

People

In

This

Space

Already

Working

On

That

Where

They

Can

Almost

Provide

Real

Time

Data

About

Where

A

Particular

Song

Is

Being

Played

Luke

I'm

So

Sorry

To

Jump

In

Here

Don't

Mute

Yourself

Please

Be

Up

Here

With

Me

I

Think

That

The

Way

That

Web

Three

Is

Going

To

One

Million

Percent

Benefit

People

Or

Creators

Or

Creatives

Musicians

Artists

Is

That

It

Eliminates

The

Record

Labels

And

Publishing

People

And

Platforms

That

Know

Have

The

Deals

With

Them

To

Take

Oh

What

Do

Call

It

Know

When

Somebody

Takes

An

Old

School

Track

And

They

Sample

It

It

Puts

The

Power

Or

The

Rightful

Ownership

Back

Into

The

Creator

Or

Creatives

Hands

Where

It's

It's

Not

Necessarily

Coming

From

The

Industry

And

You're

Right

ASCAP

BMI

PRS

MCPS

PPL

All

Of

The

Shout

Out

To

All

Of

The

Acronyms

But

They

Are

On

The

Artist

Side

Absolutely

However

It's

A

Very

It's

A

Difficult

Situation

When

The

Actual

Creator

Or

The

Artist

It

Has

Either

A

Session

With

When

They

Are

Have

They've

Got

A

Contract

With

The

Record

Label

And

Perhaps

That

Is

Sneakily

Put

In

There

That

The

Record

Label

Owns

Copyright

For

NFTs

Or

Stems

And

You're

Basically

Signing

Where

Your

Licensing

Right

So

Nobody

Wants

To

Do

That

Ever

It's

A

Bigger

Systemic

Problem

But

I

Think

That

The

Way

That

Web3

Can

Fix

This

Is

By

Putting

The

Ownership

Back

Into

The

Creators

Or

Creatives

Hands

help break that artist which historically with an artist would get that funding from otherwise

is you know it just wouldn't be there so they they still have their place they're still part

of the music community because it's one of the very few kind of endeavors that humans go around

that the word community is often kind of put straight after the kind of thing of music so

they they do have a part to play i think but i think they've also as you know as well as

artists being caught out with the advert of streaming and downloading all that kind of

labels got caught out by it and got terrified by it and they reacted in a certain way to make deals

with the kind of streaming places to kind of protect their business model which you can completely

understand but the before like the artists going forward now they're yeah there's going to be

the ability for you know when you go into a session you do the songwriting or whatever that

the contracts around that are kind of done and dusted and dealt with and minted on the blockchain

while the session's happening so that everyone in the room's comfortable everyone's just everyone

knows that they're being looked after and being paid and everyone go off and do the bit they really

enjoy because you know artists probably the last thing they want to do is talk legals and stuff but

it is very very important i think having the ability to kind of have technology underpinning this that

again it comes back to the experience of being able to use the technology the moment that that

that kind of moment comes is when artists will use it and then they once they understand the use case for

this kind of thing and how it can help them whether it's protecting them legally financially creatively or

however else then they will start to use it but for the moment it's for an artist who isn't in the

space doesn't you know understand it potentially to make that leap between them writing a song in a

room with a load of people and an nft or any kind of other web3 based product that would

help facilitate that kind of agreement it's such a leap for them to make that they're not necessarily

going to make that at the moment and it's a part of the job of people who are in the space and

at the forefront of this to kind of do that education piece i'm a bit confused because i

understand what i'm so sorry but i i understand and i know i see you real um and king and you guys

got your hands up i i'll land my plane i promise i uh listen i understand when it comes to record labels

um historically back in the day prior to this whole deconstruction of uh a record um you only have

to put into your your web browser and search what's going on in in the music industry in the future of

um concerts music festivals i see this music music festivals and entertainment the digitization of

everything that's the future so the record labels and publishers they're not okay i can't say that

um not everybody that works for these companies are big bad wolves but at the end of the day they are

businesses and they have um uh you know a company where they also want to make a profit unfortunately

there is such a lack of transparency with artists i've been there myself um and i'm not resentful if

anything i want to make it better just as much as you do so i guess the question i have for you

is if you're stating that this technology is going to be great for you know educating people then even

um as to what you guys provide and so on and so forth in the studios really isn't it shouldn't you be

speaking to the record labels and and and presenting it to them um because i get when somebody is not

and they are not signed or to either a record label or a publisher and you can just go and do a writing

session with your friend um you know turn up someone's house sure and then you're like okay

it's a 50 50 split but you know if that's in an email even that still stands in the court floor

from a copyright standpoint but when that person then further maybe is signed to a publisher and

then that publisher has done a deal with whomever to to take some of the stems from the track that

you've written and then yet that person's on your blockchain but the other person isn't like how

does this all work in the grand scheme of things or do you think that you you might be best seen

doing a deal with say for example prs and mcps that you can provide them the service so they can

onboard your services to then advance forward because i don't believe they're doing this yet

no i mean so i mean we've we've spoken to and we we have done stuff with labels directly um

because obviously with different artists of different levels the artist may want to do it

but they have to get the labels agreement so we've we've done that piece of kind of speaking to labels

and i'm sure a lot of people here have had the same kind of thing where you you approach uh somebody

who hasn't kind of interacted with the technology yet you say nft blockchain smart contract or any of

the kind of words that they've seen on the news and they just put the barriers up straight away

the job that we've had then and our responsibility is to kind of say right

strip strip that away a minute this is what it enables so you know we've done a couple of drops

where bands or artists have released nfts that have also come with a copy of the album

completely owns no kind of thing around it like you know you you own it but you only as long as we say

you do kind of thing but the fans actually own the music once they they've got it they've got a copy

of it it's like they bought the cd but it also was one-to-one counted as a sale for the official uk charts

so the same as somebody so somebody buying that nft essentially added one album sale to that artist

and we had like you know skin dreads at number two and sleep token at number three so that then and

they're both on like labels who you know we had to speak to labels and the labels then saw actually

okay so there is a a use case to this where the artist can do something innovative the fans can get

something new and exciting and i'm idea so the label made some money as well and you know so there's

everybody's everybody's a stakeholder in this in some way or another and you know we you know as an

artist obviously want artists to be looked after massively from this as a fan and remembering being

like in the shop buying the cd again it's signed by the for the band i love i can i want to make

sure that experience is saxophone and somebody right at the top said about you know owning a cd and like

you know that experience like opening the cd and reading the album sleeve back to back and oh that's

nice he thanked his mum or he thanked his dad that kind of stuff like that's an experience so we just

need to create those kind of feelings and those experiences but for every stakeholder in music

and i'm going to stop talking now because i see a few people got their hands up

yeah great conversation

katie and luke um really because you've got your hand up for a while and

after that we go to king julian

hey how you guys doing um thanks for inviting me up uh just a tiny bit of background i've been i've

been producing um my company's been producing concerts in virtual reality for about six or seven

years and i've worked with um billy eilish post malone paul mccartney kanye offset young thug sort

of a a large list of the of the music industry and we clear we clear all our own rights um so i have

i have a i have a a pretty deep knowledge base um i'm not a music supervisor but i have a pretty deep

knowledge base in in how to clear how to clear music for um unusual platforms and we have done

we have cleared rights for blockchain streaming concerts with uh we did one of the angels and

airwaves where we where we issued nfts during the concert and cleared them and cleared the streaming

rights so you know i i love the concept of of web3 and of web3 and blockchain rights and nft rights

and being able to do that i can see very clearly the path that it takes um i also have a very very

realistic um idea of the hurdles that it faces in becoming truly accepted for an artist that is a new

artist that is coming onto the scene now it's it is it is easier but it is still very much not

straightforward if you want to be both if you wanted to be part of the performer if you want to

if you want to do bmi ascap um you have to first of all do you have to deal with that and then if you

want to do publishing rights then you have to deal with the publishing rights organizations and to be

able to get your and to be able to register there and be able to do everything there and also um every

you know take hip-hop is a good example um we did a we did a show with post malone and post malone

has there was one song i remember that had 23 writer 23 writer credits um every single one is

is a publishing distribution and every single one has to be tracked down by a music supervisor and most

of those people most of the rights holders most of the people that are listed as rights holders

are not technical people they are not people that are going to be on a that are going to be on a

block chain or know how to access uh or know how to how to access that so if you have single songwriter

if you have songwriters or bands where the rights are fairly straightforward then you can put those

on a chain and have those distributed and you can create sort of a new ecosystem of how to deal with

rights management um across web3 but as soon as you talk about anything that that becomes legacy

or honestly as soon as those artists get to the point where they are dealing with labels and

they are dealing with um some kind of a worldwide distribution network and you at a certain point

as a big artist you kind of have to deal with labels and you have to deal with the infrastructure

that exists because there's too much work to do to keep your career going as an artist for you and

your small team to handle it the business of being a big artist is a big business it's it requires a team

of dedicated professionals to make sure that your career is continuing to move forward so that you can

focus on being a creative so you know i i do love it and i want to and i'm i'm trying to help solve

those problems we have done a lot of a lot of work in clearing rights in in a web3 world at a very

realistic level with big artists but my god it was it's it is it is difficult and the existing

infrastructure really needs to be ripped down and rebuilt um everybody anybody who's dealt with

large-scale publishing and has cleared rights for distribution like i have everybody knows that

that especially publishing rights is a giant rickety cluster of a system but it is the only one

we've got and nobody has yet come up with a good way to to replace things that has buy-in from the

label side management side and artist side so it's it is it is a very very it's a hard problem

it's not a hard problem technically it's a it's a hard problem at a human level it is a hard problem

technically when you start thinking about the sheer amount of transactions that would have to take

place um for the music industry writ large to to move into some kind of a web3 infrastructure so

thanks guys i i like i love the conversation i love hearing solutions and trying to figure this out

because i do think it's important because publishing is is creaky and rickety and deserves

to be replaced but uh how to do it is going to be hard lovely guys a great contribution there um

king julian do you want to add something enough that i'm going to wrap it up for tonight

yeah yeah i mean definitely should wrap it up but uh yeah that was a beautiful uh explanation there

um real luck um yeah i completely agree with you i mean the technical side of it is um not the problem

it's the human side and it probably goes in line with that you know music is um by nature very human

right there's not much there's not a lot of technical stuff that goes into music like we like to enjoy

music just as humans it's it's quite uh native to um you know every culture um and uh going back with

like the you know the label i just wanted to add just for you know just a small snippet that um

um even in web 3 on the d5 side um obviously it moves a lot faster because it's more technology

driven and um a lot of uh money as well um is that you you we still have it's the same thing as

when you're looking at the the wall street and you're looking at um you know decentralized finance

or there's always going to be the centralized element there um and then the decent and then

the decentralized element and you basically split the world into like there's two different worlds

there right um you can't be on fiat and and on chain at the same time so people do have to make

a cross there um so probably with the publishing i'm not i'm not i'm not in the music space i'm in

defy but um is that you're going to start finding more native label um publishers right they're more

like web 3 native um and uh so a lot of the maybe the the artists that uh want to go on web 3 they're

going to have to deal more with the native artists versus traditional because there is a whole

infrastructure there that everything needs to be re um redone right for that actually to work which

is basically what we're building right now in web 3 you're rebuilding all the infrastructure for web 3

but then all the people who actually you know have all the connections they're all already um you

know used to a specific uh infrastructure so um yeah that's that's one my only point there but

like yeah that's a good point you know i think i think yeah like the it's different segments really

uh what i hear and um that will be there for a while you know and who knows maybe maybe we'll

have a centralized and a decentralized uh a second for forever now um it's it's interesting

a really really really good conversation i think we need to keep uh we need to bring this topic back

about music and ownership um i don't think the last word has been sad about it um yeah this space

has been running over more than an hour so i'm gonna wrap it up for tonight but every week um same

time we'll be back next week we'll be back and if anyone is interested in owning a piece of music

uh we'll drop something tomorrow so just join our discord and we'll be

an announcement tomorrow and um yeah like for music fans and collectors

you will like it i think so um hope to see everyone next week

thank you so much thanks everyone

### Host

- [PopEx](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/popexnet.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/popexnet)
- [Cohost](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/deg3ns.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/XCohost)
- [Luke Padfield](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/popex_luke.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/popex_luke)

### Sprecher

- [Katie Waissel](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/katiewaissel24.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/katiewaissel24)
- [LayerOneX](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/layeronex.md) von [Layer One X](https://alphagrowth.io/de/layer-one-x.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/LayerOneX)
- [Adam](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/adamft.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/AdamFDF_)
- [Kreatorhood](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/kreatorhood.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/kreatorhood)
- [JenMarie.eth/lens/tez 🔜 ETHDENVER 🔜 #NFTNYC2024](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/jenmarieinc.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/jenmarieinc)
- [RealLucas™](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/lucasgw.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/lucasgw)
- [TropicVibes, the Nifty guy 🇯🇲](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/tropicvibes.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/TropicVibes)
- [King Julian 〽️](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/julianauxm.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/julianauxm)
- [Spicy Capital](https://alphagrowth.io/de/spaces/participant/scgroupvc.md)
  [X-Profil](https://twitter.com/SCGroupVC)

## Mehr TVL für dein Protokoll oder deine Blockchain?

AlphaGrowth steigert den TVL von Protokollen und Blockchains durch Asset-Akquise und -Integration, Grants, Incentives und LP-Deals. Wir haben diese Daten aufgebaut und halten sie kostenlos.

[So steigern wir TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/de/defi/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo) [Sprich mit AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/de/contact-us/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo)
