---
title: "THORSwap Updates Space ⚡️ $THOR | Registrazione di Twitter Space | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Registrazione di Twitter Space del 2024-01-25 con THORSwap ⚡ #BetterThanCEX, Chad Barraford, mogaᚱchy, Olivier Leprohon, k^coefficient | 0xVenturesDAO, paperX ⚡, Milton Bankman, f(💩 Sn⁵⁰) = 🍟🧀🧉"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/thorswap-updates-space-thor"
---

# THORSwap Updates Space ⚡️ $THOR

Registrato: Jan 25, 2024 Durata: 2:36:36

## Registrazione dello Space

[Apri lo Space originale](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1lDGLPqqZvQGm)

0:00 2:36:36

### Trascrizione completa

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Hey, guys.

Hey, man.

Glad to be back.

G to the M.

How are you?

G to the M.

Doing great.

Excited to chat updates.

What's been going on?

Yeah.

Good to be back on here.

I feel like it's been a bit.

Yeah, for sure.

I'm trying desktop audio, so let me know if it's all right.

Yeah, good to be back on here.

I feel like it's been a bit.

Yeah, for sure.

I'm trying desktop audio, so let me know if it's all right.

Loud and clear.

The beautiful voice of Mogarki.

The only one giving me a run for my money on that.

Yeah.

Cool, cool.

Should we get right into it?

Looks like we got a handful of people in here.

Yeah.

I'm just going to talk a little bit about that.

Yeah.

Cool, cool.

Should we get right into it?

Looks like we got a handful of people in here.

Yeah.

I'm just going to tweet out links to some of the proposals we might cover today, so you

can easily pin them when we get to those.

But yeah, feel free to get started.

Sure, yeah.

We can start there.

Maybe we'll see if a few more people come in for that, I guess.

Maybe we can start with some of the recap stuff, and then as people get in, we can get

into some of the current proposals and focuses and things like that.

What do you think?

Yeah, sounds good.

Cool, cool.

So you were mentioning the recap.

Is the recap up or not yet?

It'll be up shortly.

You can just cover it in this space.

Okay, cool.

And if you'd like to.

Let me get that pulled up if there's a draft I can find.

Or feel free to kick it off.

What's on the list there?

Sure.

Yeah.

Sorry, guys.

This is a very belated 2023 overview post we're going to make.

Happy New Year.

Happy New Year.

Happy New Year.

Happy New Year.

Yeah.

Well, hope you won't have found the scavenger hunt fun.

We did the easter egg hunt before.

But yeah, this one was pretty interesting.

I think there was a few at the end that was slightly harder to find.

But yeah, hopefully we can do more cool things like that soon.

Any highlights from that?

Like what were some of the weird ones, if you remember?

Hard to find.

I think most of them were found within an hour or two.

The hardest one was probably, I think it's like Sin's E to Sin's Thor.

That's like double Sin.

I think that caused people a bit, took like a day or two.

Well, yeah.

Just like one specific pair.

That's, yeah.

Yeah, yeah.

I had dropped some hints like, you know, in there.

Nice.

But yeah, that's fine.

That's cool.

Hopefully some people in here got some Thor out of that.

Yeah, hopefully that made a few people read the terms and conditions.

Because that paid you on.

There was a few heads on that page.

Nice.

But yeah, let me just quickly cover some of the key things.

You know, key highlights of 2033.

Obviously, as expected, you know, I think everyone knows that a stream source was like a major game-changer feature.

And if you check on Thor yield, like, you know, ever since the launch of streaming swaps, we saw like a massive volume increase.

So overall, quite exciting to see the total volumes from 2033.

We had about 271 and a half, like million rune in volume, which equated to about like, 1.1 billion or 1.2 billion.

Yeah, almost 1.2 billion, like US dollar value.

So quite a big improvement for sure.

Especially considering most of the year was spent in the depth of the bear.

Yeah, not a bad bear market year for sure.

Looking forward to dwarfing it this year, hopefully.

But I was pretty excited to see that we crossed over a billion for the year.

Yes, and we're starting off really strong.

It's like, we've already, what is it?

It's like 100 something percent, 139% right now of the monthly volume target.

So I know some folks are concerned about like, you know, maybe the target being hard to reach as we keep smashing it.

But yeah, it seems to be doing great so far.

Yeah, no doubt that was like the breakthrough feature of 2023.

And yeah, it seems like it seems like that's just going to be dwarfed.

You know, hopefully in time, we'll, we'll be seeing what was daily as or what was monthly as daily or something, you know, like, not just on ThorSwap side, but just for ThorTrain as a whole, like that was kind of the, I think, long term, that'll be looked back on as like such a turning point feature.

Yeah, sure.

I think like, so overall, we generated 1.62 million USD affiliate fee earnings, making us still making ThorSwap the top ThorChain interface of 2023 by volume.

And I mean, the top swap route was still BTC with Room.

So overall, in terms of the TVL for ThorStakers, we also saw that jumped about a 50% increase from last year.

I'm sorry, from 2022.

So it's now, so we just hopped over 100 million ThorStakes.

It's 107 million Thor right now.

So yeah, and of course, alongside the governance, we burned 64.47 million Thor.

So yeah, exciting times.

Yeah, I think last year at this time, maybe I got my timeline wrong, but I think Thor burning was just an idea still, right?

We were just getting started on that path.

So to see, you know, more than 10% of the max supply burned in one year is pretty significant.

You know, I'm sure we'll get into that more with the proposals.

But personally, I'm feeling like, okay, we burned a lot.

Maybe we got to think about slowing down soon.

I know other people have the opposite idea where they just want to burn everything.

So it'll be an interesting thing to discuss.

Yeah, for sure.

I think that'll be a theme for this space, actually, as we kick off the year.

We have a lot of community proposals and discussions.

So we thought it would be good.

You know, we can get through some of those for sure.

For sure.

Yeah, that's something we've always planted the seed on, on these spaces is like, how else can the community incentives be used really to just like, you know, spread adoption and get this thing out there.

So, yeah, definitely want to continue to encourage that conversation and not necessarily just have that be burn it all, though that is sometimes fun and has been fun.

But yeah, I think I think I would personally agree with with what Moog just said is probably probably close to time to start considering some other things and hopefully see some of these other things that have kind of been back burner for a while.

Like, like, like, like, we've talked maybe affiliate program things like that that could be tied in with with community incentives.

So hopefully we'll be seeing some of those things kind of kind of get back in the spotlight.

Yeah, for sure.

Yeah, for sure.

But before we get to that, though, because I think when we get to the community discussions, it'd be good for some of the, you know, we'll be putting out, you know, door holder slash community member hat on.

And, you know, rather than trying to sway, obviously, people's opinions with as contributors.

So we'll definitely definitely, you know, put your hand up to like, you know, you know, lead, take the lead of conversations if you want to, if you feel very strongly about certain proposals.

And of course, as always, if you have good questions and, you know, for anyone who sort of hop on space, we'll pick to win itself, like, you know, merge to get out at the end.

So, but yeah, before we hop into that, do you want to cover sort of some of the focuses, areas of focus for sort of like Q1, Q2, like early 2024?

Sure. Did we get through everything we wanted to just on recap stuff?

I mean, there's a lot of other highlights, too, for sure.

So, you know, a big one was we started formally introducing, like 2023, like sort of formal introduction of Socket, our own like API and SDK suite of like cross-chain products.

So, so far, you know, we had like, we still have been used in Edge Wallet, Coinbot, there's SQL Finance, there's a few others that we're yet to announce and a lot of partnerships, our integrators like currently working on, you know, integrating SwapKit.

So I think this will be a very exciting year to start like running out, you know, more news and more integrations.

I think one interesting goal to keep in mind would be like, like, when will a SwapKit integrator outpace ThorSwap's own volume?

That'll be a cool milestone.

Looking forward to it.

Yeah, that's something we should have as a North Star for the whole community. That'll be cool.

Yeah, for sure.

Help my memory, was Savers 2023 or was it before that? I guess it was before and then Staples got added?

Yeah, it was before that. I was going to print like, oh, exactly when? I can't remember. I was going to tune to, but yeah, definitely Savers, Staples got added and which was like a massive one for a lot of people.

And now that you can also stream into Savers and stream out of Savers, that's also made it really, you know, easy and accessible to use.

Yeah, I mean, streaming just generally, actually, like sort of was a huge game changer last year.

For sure. I mean, that definitely led to a lot of scaling in Savers, even if it launched before that. But yeah, definitely like felt like the year that it kind of found its fit in the market for sure.

Yeah, I can't say I've ever seen another feature, like come to an existing protocol and make actually such a ginormous impact on, you know, the market adoption of that protocol like streaming swaps has.

There's always noise around like every EIP, every bit like, oh, this is going to be the game changer. This is going to be the one that, you know, reduces gas by 100x or whatever.

And it's very rare to see those things come to fruition. But with streaming swaps, streaming Savers, like that feature has really just skyrocketed the whole protocol. So that's been pretty sweet.

Totally.

Yeah, I think the surprise was just the fact that like, it was so organic, like, because we all love the idea, but it was the market that really like showed us how powerful the feature actually was.

Yep.

Yeah, and it's still like really just getting started. I mean, when did that launch? Three, four months ago or something? I don't even, my timelines are all screwed up. But it feels like it hasn't been that long.

I think it was October.

Okay. So, so yeah, it was approximately right. But yeah, I mean, as we kind of see, like, you know, use like, the last few months have been kind of wild and like, in just in terms of broader like usage kind of kicking back in and like, that is a feature that's going to be like, come in handy so strongly when things are in full swing, you know, so like, that's great to have that foundation set. Like, there was so much building.

happening through through the depths of the bear and that's going to be like, something that just pays off so well, like when big users are coming in kind of ties into one of the things we were going to get into for areas of focus. This one is kind of just happened. But I feel like a lot of the things we were going to get into for areas of focus.

this one is kind of just happened. But I feel like it fits in right here is like the swapper cloud and network improvements. Because that kind of came out of out of streaming swaps led to then, essentially congestion due to like so much more usage, right? And like now just in the recent what week or two,

like swapper cloud rolled out rolled out and now 90x improvement to median transaction.

time. So no longer waiting for like hours and hours and hours when everyone's doing streaming swaps. So I feel like that's another one of these like small things that doesn't feel super sexy or super exciting. But when you kind of think about it and look at look at like, just the average user's experience, it's like a massive, massive shift in, in that. So that's another really, really pretty big one, actually.

Yeah, for sure. I think, you know, the impact on the outbound delays is going to be amazing for just the overall experience. And even for ARBs, like to be able to ARB these big swaps where we've seen in the past, like,

oh, someone came in and, you know, did a $4 million swap, and that threw the pools out of balance. For the ARBs to be able to use their swapper cloud and, you know, make more trades faster and keep those pools balanced is, you know, going to lead to more accurate price

execution, happier users, more volume, etc.

Totally. Yeah, ultimately comes down to like keeping the user experience good for people. And as it's getting integrated into like, so many mainstream wallets and stuff like can't have people waiting 12 hours for a swap or something like that. So yeah, that's a huge, huge one. Big improvement.

What else did we have from 2023? I think I just saw something a minute ago that was pretty cool.

You know, we did a lot in the ThorSwap UI. You know, the transaction tracker was a big one, being able to see what's going on with your transaction. I think a lot of people already forgot by now. But for, you know, probably two years, all we had was a spinning circle to find out what was up with your transaction. And, you know, now you can see what leg is your transaction in? How many streaming swap segments has it completed?

What's the estimated time of arrival? What's the estimated time of arrival? I think that was a great improvement overall. Definitely, we've had some technical challenges with that feature, but I think it's in a better state and getting better all the time. So I think that was a great addition to the UI this year.

And then another one that I'm really more excited about than most is the streaming swap settings or just the regular swap settings that we recently updated. So now it just makes it much easier and more intuitive to adjust your slippage.

Or, you know, if you're a power user and you want to choose, you know, how fast you want your swap to complete, how many sub-swaps you want to happen. If you want to DCA up to 24 hours, you can control all that right from the UI. So you get pretty granular control over those swap parameters.

I'm curious how you guys feel the feedback has been on that. And I'm curious even just to throw that out to the community. Like, have you guys been using that feature, tweaking that, or are you kind of just going with the default? Or is anyone, any contributors kind of like monitoring how many streaming swaps are having non-default settings? Just kind of curious, like, how that's been since launching that?

Yeah, that's a great question. We should try to pull some reports on what's different than the defaults and how many people are with it.

Yeah. Still new, but yeah, that'd be really cool to see, just to kind of figure out, like, oh, what are, like, what are users actually trying to do? Like, what are they generally trying to optimize for? But it's also great, just even if it's only a small percentage, that's kind of the point, too, is, like, the default should be what people generally want.

But then to be able to do these, like, edge case scenarios is still, like, hugely useful for when that's what you want.

Yeah, I think, like, after Swapper Cloud, you know, is launched, I think it actually came at a really good time, because now that, you know, with the, with less, like, outbound delays, you know, now people will actually have a better choice between, you know, like, speed versus price.

Right.

So, yeah, I'm curious to see what the configurations are. Actually, Chad, you know, it is the tweet that we made about it, the flop settings is pinned still, but on the ThorSwap, like, Twitter X page.

But you can pin it to this, like, space if you want, just so that folks know what we're talking about.

Cool.

Yeah, I'll pin that up right now if anyone hasn't, hasn't seen that.

Yeah, so, like, it'll automatically pop up if your swap size is actually, you know, benefits from streaming swaps.

But, yeah, normally, you'll see slippage adjustments now.

It's that slider that should show up.

Very cool.

Yeah, we've had, yeah, we've had, like, some users, I think, when we just launched it, did mention that maybe, you know, it could be, like, an advanced feature.

And then we go back to the, like, the classic sort of speed versus price.

Yeah, I think we're open to all feedback on that front.

For sure.

Yeah.

Yeah, I think we have a small tweak in coming for that, or we're just going to kind of minimize that section for most people.

And then you can expand it if you want to.

That way, the defaults, you know, you don't feel like you have to make a choice.

I think a lot of times it's intimidating when you're, like, I don't know what to do here.

So, if we make it seem like you don't need to choose, then you can just proceed.

And then if you know what's up, you can just expand it and make whatever changes you want.

Yeah, I'd agree with that.

You know, most users just want it, like, simple without kind of even needing to know every, yeah.

I mean, how many people truly even understand all of the little intricacies there?

But, yeah, good to have the options.

One of the cool things that we did behind the scenes that I don't think has gotten any publicity,

I don't know if we even mentioned it publicly, was just changing the default slippage settings.

I'm not sure if Oleg's in here.

Maybe he could dive into a little bit more of exactly how that works.

But, you know, what we're doing basically in the back end now is,

depending on what your swap is and what your swap pairs are and how large the swap is,

the API is making a recommendation of what the default slippage should be.

Instead of, in the past, like, we just tried to pick a number.

It used to be 1%, and then there was too many refunds, so we raised it to 3%.

Now there's a bit more intelligence behind determining what those automatic slippage settings should be.

Hey, guys.

Yeah, exactly.

So one of the main things that we're trying to do in the back end is also making sure that the defaults are super safe.

So with all the data that we've collected from all the streaming swaps,

but really since we were the first interface to integrate with streaming swaps,

we've got tons of data to kind of make the best decisions.

And basically, if you're doing a super large swap, then we're going to tweak the settings so it's a bit safer for you, the defaults.

But if you're making, like, a very normal swap, then we'll just try and get the fastest and the one that will lead to the less refunds.

But then also there are a couple of things.

If you are swapping against pools that don't have a strong secondary market, then we change those settings as well again.

And also we have an automatic switch that if for some reason the TorChain network itself,

like if sins are paused or whatever happens on the network,

then automatically it switches to the safest settings for everyone.

So again, it's really in the details, but we're just trying to make sure that all the users,

no matter their swap size, get the best and safest experience, no matter their network conditions.

Nice.

That's awesome.

Love that.

Kind of just curious, though.

So does this mean, like, in pretty much, because for a while when streaming swaps came out,

it kind of went to just, like, the no price protection, right?

Because, like, at first there was a bunch of failing.

I guess now that's rare unless you actually just intentionally choose no price protection, right?

Like, meaning, like, now we kind of have the data such that, like, for different swap sizes,

it intelligently understands, like, where to place a cap slip on that size.

So now there is price protection in most cases.

Is that right?

Exactly.

So there is price protection in all cases if you don't tweak the settings.

But if you tweak the settings so you can go past optimal and to slower, sort of into a DCA,

in that case, we remove the limit because you're explicitly choosing to make the swap longer

than necessary and explicitly choosing to, yeah, just DCA over sometimes.

So then it really doesn't make sense to have a limit.

But for all other scenarios, by default, you have a limit depending on the pools you're interacting with

and the size of your swap.

Right.

That makes sense.

If you're going for slowest, you're basically saying,

I want to be exposed to the price movement over this period of time.

Exactly.

So obviously we can't put a limit there because it's pointless.

And regarding DCA or longer swaps or past the optimal point,

so right now the limit is 24 hours.

That's a limit defined by TorChain the network.

It is actually possible to do longer swaps than that,

I think up to a year for Synth assets, but you have to be coming from Synthetix.

We don't allow it yet on TorSwap just because we have like doubts

and we're a bit stressed about the user experience

because right now TorChain does not support cancelling a streaming swap.

So say you're swapping, I'll take round numbers,

like one Bitcoin for USDT and you want to stream that

and do a DCA over, I don't know, a month,

then we have no ability to let you cancel that swap

within two weeks or after three weeks.

We have to just let it go through.

So since the UX might be a bit hard to lend,

we don't allow it, but it's technically possible.

That's interesting.

Also, you don't get the assets like throughout the swap, right?

You get it all at the end, right?

So like you'd be essentially like stuck waiting.

Exactly.

Yeah.

Interesting feature though.

And yeah, maybe if, I don't know if cancellations or something

that's still kind of in the works are coming,

but yeah, it makes sense to, I feel like, yeah,

people would be hesitant to use that probably anyways

if there's no cancellations

because yeah, you're making quite a commitment to do that.

So it makes sense to kind of like limit it to the 24 hours.

Yeah.

I've been pushing for streaming swaps V2

with the V2 being mainly the ability for users to cancel.

I think it's just, it has fallen into the nice to have category

and it's not being prioritized and I understand.

But yeah, until the Torchain commits to improving the possibilities

with streaming swaps, I think the current user experience

is as advanced as we can push it reasonably.

Yeah.

I could see like, I don't know,

I could probably imagine some downsides

or like why you would hesitate to do that,

but maybe it could be like only cancellations

that are for really long-term swaps anyways,

just so there's not like stuff, everything being,

a bunch of things being canceled for whatever reason

and just causing a bunch of confusion.

But like if it was,

even if it was only 24 hour plus streaming swaps

that could be canceled, that would be cool.

Cool, cool.

What else we got here?

Oh, I can cover a few more.

Obviously, we saw the launch of lending.

It's been a bit, you know, of a,

like it's been quiet just because of the massive,

the massive like swaps and stuff like volume recently.

But, you know, at the moment,

borrowers have exceeded the lending cap of Bitcoin

and I still get people asking, you know,

on a day-to-day basis about like, you know,

oh, when can I still take a lot of loans using Bitcoin?

So, yeah, it'll be interesting to see how that,

how the feature of like the product evolves like this year.

Yeah, it feels like that gets into,

it feels like that definitely gets into the whole like,

how risky should the thing be?

Endless question in the Thornton community.

Because, yeah, I mean,

I think it's capped out because of the constraints, right?

Like it, so it hit the caps, but,

but overall like, yeah,

as far as on like the, the, the interface side,

like, I don't know,

I haven't heard of any, any like issues,

stuff like that.

So I would say that's been,

that's been a success as well.

Seems to be working, working well.

Yep, always, obviously, you know,

looking for feedback on,

on the UX interface side of things.

I think there is a minor issue recently of like,

users sort of getting stuck with like a penny,

like worth of,

worth of like loans.

And then it has to be sort of resolved using memo.

I don't know if you,

you have much idea around that, Oleg.

Sorry, I made that by,

could you repeat that please?

Oh, I think I was just saying like, you know,

we could always obviously improve the UX.

I just like recently,

I think there's an issue where like users might get stuck

with like one penny with,

when they're trying to replay the loan,

the loan,

just because the way like,

I think actually,

what was the course for it again?

But yeah,

if you don't know what I'm talking about,

like, it's okay.

You mean like they pay back the loan,

but it doesn't like fully zero it out.

So there's still like a one penny loan,

like open that they're trying to close.

Yeah, that's,

that's a tough problem.

So for everything lending,

Thornode and Torchain devs have been really,

really great in that they provide us with endpoints

that we can quote,

but obviously Torchain being a faster chain

at a block time of six seconds,

basically the on-chain price of each asset

can fluctuate mostly faster

than all the external assets

or the ones that are enabled for lending.

So obviously it's a bit hard

for everyone to nail that experience.

But yeah,

I definitely hear,

and I have seen some of the complaints

or reports from users saying,

well,

I'm trying to close the loan,

but I'm stuck with like a two cent repayment needed now.

But to be honest,

on our end,

it's really hard

or next to impossible

unless we just bump the amount

and ask for everyone

to repay a little bit more

than what they owe.

And because of gas fees,

as well,

yeah,

it's just a hard experience to nail.

Yeah,

the,

you know,

our amazing community member,

Koitsu Aiki,

wrote like a really detailed tutorial

for basically doing a manual loan repayment

through memos,

which has been great

to help users

sort of get their last penny out

and get the collateral back.

But yeah,

like just wanted to let everyone know

but we're definitely like looking into it.

It's not something we're not aware of.

But of course,

you know,

any feedback is always welcome.

You know,

feel free to like at me,

at my,

at PepperX on the Discord

if you ever have any,

you know,

other issues.

Other than that,

I think we,

oh,

one other thing is obviously

we saw Binance Smart Chain

being added in 2003.

It was the only

L1 block,

new block of chain integration,

but obviously a much requested one.

And,

oh,

actually,

I was going to ask like the 4 Chain account

because I saw it like

on the space just now.

But yeah,

it's interesting timing

because we've saw recently

that

Airbnb is considering

like deprecating

the BEP2 chain.

So,

I think we,

you know,

4 Chain added

Binance,

BNB's smart chain

at kind of like the perfect time.

we'll probably see

like a plan

like announced soon

in regards to like

how the BEP2

like beacon chain

will be,

you know,

rack and rock

and sort of deprecated

on the 4 Chain side.

but yeah,

now that we've got

BSC

and also we launched

like ThorSwap launched

with PancakeSwap

DexEgregation.

So you obviously

like on ThorSwap

we support all the

like hundreds of BEP20 assets

now as well.

Yeah,

it's

quite

important

I think milestone

as well

for 2023.

Sorry,

I didn't realize

I was talking on mute

for a second.

Oh,

literally same here.

Go ahead.

Yeah,

I was going to say

am I the only one

that is passionate

about BSC?

No,

I did see

I will think

a couple weeks back

Pluto said,

you know,

let's get the network

back up and running.

AVAX was halted.

you know,

churn wasn't happening.

Get all that handled

and then we'll start

addressing the BNB plan

going forward.

I think,

yeah,

Binance did make

that announcement

that the

the old BEP2 chain

is not long

for this world.

So

kind of sad

to see it go

just for nostalgia reasons.

But

yeah,

good timing

adding BSC

so it'll be

an easier transition.

Yeah,

actually while

this is happening,

I guess

like

essentially

Thorswap

is

like one of the only ways

you can still bridge,

you know,

you can still move the fund

from BEP2 to BEP20.

So

there's a

I guess

big public service

announcement here as well.

Like if you haven't

started yet,

maybe,

you know,

it's worth

thought to kind of

start looking into it.

Yeah,

Thorswap got a mention

in their

announcement,

right?

That was kind of cool.

You definitely

don't want to end up

like how I ended up

right now.

I still have

a whole bunch,

thousands of dollars

of Synth UST

and Synth Luna

in my wallet.

Oh man,

those might be

collectibles someday.

extra collectible.

When we're all

billionaires,

you know,

those will have some.

Just kidding,

of course.

Not.

But

that's cool.

Yeah,

I think there's a couple

of like

centralized

exchanges

that still support

BEP2

rune

and some users

I think they help

like people swap

you know,

their rune

just for tax reasons

I think I heard.

But anyway,

yeah,

definitely just

FYI to like

users if you still

have like

BEP2 assets

or even,

you know,

for some reason

BEP2 rune

best to look into

how to like,

you know,

move that to BSC

or just swap

your rune to

native rune

if you can

because obviously

we don't know

the BNB timeline

but

do it soon.

Have we seen

like,

have we seen

BSC

kind of

cannibalize

BEP2

a bit on

ThorChain

or like

I haven't really

looked at how

that's shifted

over time

but like

I remember

the theory

was kind of

like

oh well

maybe

because it's

like

BUSD

was so popular

on

BEP2

but like

I wonder

how that's

compared

to

BSC

I'm trying

I'm trying

to pull

that out

well

the

BNB

like

savers vault

is filled

more than

the BNB

the BEP2

one

sorry

so

the

BSC

yeah

BNB

savers vault

that's a mouthful

and

it's more

it's like

twice as filled

as the

like

beacon chain

BNB

like BEP2

BNB

savers

so

there's one

metric

it looks like

there's been

more volume

on the

BSC

BNB

if I

know which

icon is which

at least

recently

yeah

I mean

more volume

on less

liquidity

so yeah

there's probably

a lot of

like old

liquidity

just hanging

around

though

that will

I mean

they'll need

to figure

themselves out

yeah

if any

users still

LPing

like

beacon chain

BNB

or

like

the

other

BEP2

assets

yeah

I would say

like

probably

start a

migration

soon

yeah

it's still

one of the

deeper pools

really

or just

look around

to the end

and you know

get some

extra

LP

rewards

from

everyone

moving in

it

the assets

so

so

I wouldn't

be surprised

if you know

like BNB

has to make

an announcement

of like

oh yeah

use store

chain to

like

move these

assets

because

I think

they don't

even have

their own

bridge

anymore

I do

think

there is

some

bridging

functionality

built into

some of

those

tokens

so

don't quote

me on

that

but I

read

one of

the

articles

and

I

think

using

their

own

wallet

can

there's

like

a

transfer

for

some

tokens

so

just

make

sure

do

your

research

before

attempting

any

of

that

stuff

but

I

happen

to

have

some

TWT

from

the

beacon

chain

and

I

might

have

to

look

into

how

I

can

get

the

tokens

moved

to

BSC

but

I'm

pretty

sure

that's

a

functionality

offered

within

their

wallet

nice

I

think

those

are

the

most

mainly

the

key

features

one

other

thing

I

wanted

to

mention

was

like

actually

I

have

this

like

I

had

this

wallet

interface

update

medium

article

I

had

drafted

for

months

and

the

thing

is

I

think

maybe

folks

haven't

realized

this

yet

but

we

added

a lot

of

wallets

support

over

2023

so

this

article

just

kept

getting

updated

and

it

never

got

posted

because

we

had

so

many

at

one

point

so

yeah

we

now

support

13

wallets

across

browser

mobile

and

hardware

but

that's

not

including

we

updated

to

Wallet

Connect

V2

and

so

on

the

mobile

wallet

front

through

Wallet

Connect

V2

there's

obviously

I can't

remember

how many

but

there's

pages

of

wallets

that

they

support

so

yeah

obviously

that chart

is getting

ridiculous

but

with more

chains

and more

we've

got quite

a few

to look

at

as well

shout out

to

Toan

for

being

our

wallet

master

but

yeah

I think

that really

helped

with like

user

accessibility

as well

last year

yeah

for sure

definitely

yeah

that's

getting

to be

a pretty

long

list

there

hopefully

it gets

to a

point

where

I mean

pretty much

is already

there

but like

any wallet

that people

are really

using

is

supported

which

pretty much

there

I don't

are there

any

that have

been

like

highly

requested

that are

not

supported

there's

actually

some

that are

already

in

SwapKit

which

haven't

quite

made

it

to

our

UI

so

if

want

to

check

GitHub

can

probably

see

them

there

but

there's

another

hardware

wallet

coming

very

soon

that

is

KeepKey

so

KeepKey

has been

an OG

hardware

wallet

that was

at some

period

in time

owned by

ShapeShift

not anymore

but there's

a lot

of crypto

native users

and I

really love

the UX

on KeepKey

because

you don't

have to

switch

your apps

all the

time

you can

access

all of

your wallets

like if

you had

a keystore

connected

or

XD5

and you

can have

them all

in a

hardware

wallet

so I'm

excited

to add

that

one

another

PR I

saw

raised

was

for

MetaMask

snaps

so that'll

be an

interesting

addition

to see

as well

into

course

well

that

UX

you just

described

of

KeepKey

sounds

awesome

because

that's

definitely

one of

the main

hurdles

with

multi-chain

swaps

and hardware

wallets

is it's

like

connect

one

then

disconnect

then

connect

the other

and

there's

just

been

some

convoluted

steps

involved

with

that

so

I'm

gonna

have

to

pick

one

of

those

up

that

sounds

really

awesome

and

will

that

support

oh

yeah

oh

nice

okay

so

yeah

they

support

like

what

looks

like

every

Thor

chain

so

check

your

dms

chat

I'll

send

a

free

code

dude

sweet

yeah

shout out

to

Highlander

from

the

team

who's

like

been

contributing

a lot

of code

to

SwapKit

actually

I was

gonna

say

like

I see

this

account

actually

in

this

space

oh

Rose knows

that

KeepKey

Dev

they

heard

the

bat

signal

of us

talking

about

KeepKey

and

got

an

automatic

notification

to join

the

space

that's

amazing

yeah

it's

crazy

yeah

there

clearly

some

high

powered

devs

there

to

work

that

one

out

yeah

I mean

if

anyone

wants

to

share

anything

as

we

mentioned

go

through

these

topics

feel

free

to

put

your

hand

up

as

well

oh

yeah

for

sure

people

people

are

welcome

to

join

and

like

paper

said

earlier

we'll

give

away

a couple

of

Thor

swap

merch

items

so

people

that

stick

around

or

especially

people

that

come

up

and

ask

some

questions

or

give

thoughts

or

whatever

so

that's

coming

yeah

yeah

how do

you guys

want to

do this

because

the final

thing

I was

going

to

mention

was

like

obviously

we

saw

know

a

proper

process

being

made

for

governance

community

but

now

we

have

a

formal

system

of

community

ideas

on

the

discord

moving

to

temperature

check

polls

on

the

forum

and

then

move

on

to

on

chain

voting

so

that

matured

quite

a lot

which

led

to

burn

being

quite

successful

and

even

an

amendment

made

to

the

burn

proposal

but

now

I

think

this

space

we

could

cover

the

recent

ones

we

got

three

or

four

major

proposals

going

on

recently

draft

proposals

before

we

jump

into

the

specifics

of

those

proposals

could

just

quickly

review

the

changes

that

we're

doing

around

removing

the

requirement

for

connecting

your

wallet

to

vote

in

the

forum

and

then

the

quorum

rules

yep

yep

I was

going

to

ask

do

guys

want

to

go

through

the

proposals

first

and

then

wrap

this

space

up

with

our

areas

focusing

the

areas

of

focus

for

Q1

Q2

or

should

we

do

that

let's

save

those

for

the

end

yeah

save

that

that's

fun

cool

so yeah

so as

Mo mentioned

we've got

our forum

for

temperature check

polls

and

one

big feedback

a lot of

users

have given

us

recently

is the

fact that

previously

it was

token gated

so you have to

connect your

wallets and

verify you have

Thor or

V Thor

and to

be able

to vote

on

those

polls

but

there's

a lot

of

hurdles

to

jump

and

sometimes

there's

technical

issues

and all

that

so

we've

updated

the

process

like

the

post

and as

well as

the

tutorial

on how

to make

a

Thor

draft

proposal

so now

you just

need to

anyone can

vote

as long

as you're

a member

of the

forum

but

we

you know

sort of

recommend

you know

well

sorry

not

recommend

we

want to

put in

just like

a

you know

quorum

which means

like you

need at

least 50

votes

on any

temperature

check

poll

to be

able to

move on

to

then move

on to

on-chain

governance

so that

should

the

recent

two

draft

proposals

that

were

polls

running

should

fall

under

those

rules

like

anyone

can

vote

on

those

and

correct me

if I'm

wrong

Moog

like

it's

it's

just

like

the

amount

of

participants

right

or

or

it's

like

say

vote

yes

or

no

is

it

overall

like

50

or

just

50

on

like

yes

necessary

yeah

I would

say

it's

overall

participants

but

if

it's

no

then

know

you're

going to

have

what

like

maybe

could

have

40

no's

and

10

yeses

so

we're

not

going to

make

it

the

other

way

around

need

to

have

50

yeses

just

just

some

participation

because

it

doesn't

make

sense

for

someone

to

make

a

proposal

no

one

to be

interested

in

it

three

people

vote

and then

we have

to go

to an

on-chain

vote

just

because

two

people

voted

yes

so

yeah

just

trying to

push

some

level

of

hey

this has

a little

bit of

traction

before

we put in

any legwork

to say

this is worth

an on-chain

snapshot

yeah

exactly

yeah

just wanted to

double check

that

but

yeah

okay

Chad

can you

help

pin

some of

the

recent

drafts

so we can

sort of

go through

them

yeah

sure

did you

tweet them

or where

have they

been

tweeted

yeah

I tweeted

it

from

the

okay

sweet

let me

find

those

I'll

pin

them

up

cool

I guess

we can

start

with

the

one

that's

already

completed

the

poll

which

is

potentially

expand

a

proposal

to

expand

thought

and

I guess

thought

staking

to

arbitram

yeah

this is

a big

topic

I'm glad

Oleg

is here

to help

us

discuss

it

I just

pinned

the whole

thread

because

there's

a few

underneath

there

so

just

click

into

the

thread

and

then

you'll

see

several

links

there

so

probably

easier

than

pinning

each

one

I

think

oh

I was

thinking

we could

pin

each

one

as

we

go

like

onto

that

yeah

we can

we can

do

that

I can

do

that

let me

just

remove

the

main

maybe

my

app

is

delaying

so

first

the

arbitram

yeah

yeah

okay

yeah

so

hop onto

the

forum

you'll

see

you know

all the

recent

ones

anyway

all the

context

is there

in the

proposal

but

you know

so this

is kind of

based on

community

feedback

and concerns

around potential

like motivation

that's basically

high gas fees

right

and

so you know

the community

is suggesting

we move

on to

a lower

gas fee

chain

or

sort of

deploy

so not

move

on to

we still

got the

ethereum

mainnet

thought

obviously

but the

potential

deployment

of

expansion

onto

another

chain

so

arbitram

sort of

took the

lead

as in

terms

of

like

you know

the

community

feedback

and I

think

Oleg

you know

you were

quite

involved

in the

discussion

around

this

right

if you

have

anything

to add

so

definitely

I'm a

fan of

having

thor

token

I think

it's just

fitting

to have

it on

another

chain

since we

are a

multi-chain

and cross-chain

platform

I'm not

my uninformed

opinion

is

arbitram

is great

but to be

honest

I'm not

necessarily

sold

it could be

AVAX

could be

well maybe

not BSC

that's

not my

favorite

chain

but I

would be

open

to any

other

L2

that is

desirable

and that

the

community

is

involved

with

so

a couple

of

things

so

I

think

first

it's

a

matter

of

being

ready

for

the

next

goal

run

I

clearly

remember

Ethereum

being

unusable

for

weeks

if not

months

at a

time

and

it

really

isn't

inclusive

or

it's

just

not

very

flexible

if

we

are

only

on

Ethereum

and

then

some

random

morning

where

NFTs

come

back

to

life

or

something

else

happens

or

everyone

Blackblock

launches

their

iShares

on

Ethereum

whatever

the network

is

unusable

and

then

people

can't

buy

sell

stake

whatever

they

can't

use

door

so

I

think

it's

just

because

the

contract

already

exists

what

I

would

like

to

see

if

it

has

community

support

is

we

burn

say

25

million

door

from

say

the

community

incentive

open

a

new

contract

on

this

secondary

chain

where

it's

cheaper

with

a

25

million

limit

so

basically

the

tour

tokenomics

don't

really

change

and

then

it

facilitates

a lot

of

stuff

while

also

future

proofing

so

the

token

remains

usable

and

affordable

and

it's

more

inclusive

of

smaller

traders

or

smaller

players

and

also

it

really

helps

us

whenever

we

want

to

do

those

Easter

eggs

or

airdrops

or

whatever

we

figure

out

okay

but

how

do

we

minimize

costs

or

we'll

need

to

make

this

contract

so

that

people

pay

the

gas

themselves

because

it's

going

to

cost

us

$10,000

if

we

airdrop

to

everyone

so

I

think

having

this

other

chain

just

removes

the

shackles

of

so

many

cool

stuff

that

we

can

do

and

it

also

enables

more

flexible

staking

options

I

think

where

we

can

have

contracts

that

it's

really

reasonable

for

us

to

investigate

obviously

it

comes

with

some

cost

some

time

we

need

to

make

sure

that

the

incentives

are

correct

so

that

arbitrageurs

can

rebalance

the

price

between

the

chains

and

also

we

probably

have

to

cede

some

liquidity

so

it's

definitely

not

just

snatch

your

finger

and

it's

done

but

still

I

think

it's

really

worth

exploring

by

the

community

yeah

there's

a lot

of

different

directions

to

take

the

discussion

about

living

on

another

chain

I

think

the

universally

agreed

upon

benefit

by

everyone

is

cheaper

gas

my

question

fundamentally

is

what

are we

going to

do

with

the

cheaper

gas

right

so

buying

and

staking

Thor

that's

interesting

but

it's

not

that

compelling

how

often

are

buying

and

staking

Thor

most

people

not

doing

that

every

day

know

can

usually

wait

for

ETH

gas

to

be

low

the

other

thing

is

that

there's

there's

no

such

thing

as

like

a

chain

that's

fully

resistant

to

gas

spikes

we

saw

that

with

avalanche

recently

know

we're

used

to

paying

pennies

for

transactions

on

avalanche

but

then

all

of a

sudden

know

we

were

paying

$20

a few

weeks

ago

so

I

think

we

need

to

carefully

consider

that

and

know

there's

also

some

challenges

around

like

if we

burn

50 million

or 25

million

or however

many

Thor

you know

we don't

have the

ability

to

remint

them

it's

it's a

little bit

different

than

you know

if you

think

about

the

Thor

chain

protocol

like

when

they

do

lending

there's

burning

and

minting

of

Rune

we

don't

have

a

mechanism

to

mint

more

Thor

if

we

decide

that

this

was

the

wrong

idea

in

the

future

so

I'd

be

interested

to

hear

if

there

are

other

ideas

maybe

this

is

just

my

ignorance

of

maybe

this

already

exists

like

is

there

a

contract

that

we

can

lock

ETH

into

before

it

gets

created

on

Arbitrum

and

then

the only

way

Arbitrum

back

to

a

locked

position

or

something

like

that

so

that

we

can

keep

those

things

in

balance

and

we

have

an

undo

button

what

if

the

Arbitrum

chain

gets

very

expensive

what

if

for

some

reason

it

fails

then

we

have

10

or

20

percent

of

our

supply

there

that

could

be

problematic

in

the

long

run

so

there's

a lot

of

interesting

questions

to

think

about

but

overall

I

think

your

creativity

can run

a lot

more

wild

and

can

introduce

more

interesting

things

like

gas

refunds

or

rewards

for

small

amounts

so

there's

definitely

some

reasons

to do

it

it's

not

a

super

easy

push

that

button

type

of

TIP

if

we

have

any

folks

really

knowledgeable

about

that

feel

free

to put

your

hand

up

and

join

the

space

but

on

the

actual

governance

front

I

just

want

to

let

everyone

know

that

the

poll

passed

and

I

told

Slicex

who

led

this

initiative

that

the

actual

on-chain

vote

will

happen

soon

and

the

only

changes

that

we

made

to

the

draft

proposal

is

a

specification

around

the

execution

part

because

right now

it

is

really

the

proposal

is

focused

on

the

idea

of

it

right

and

so

the

on-chain

vote

would be

to

really

do

R&D

and

planning

to

actually

do

this

expansion

if

possible

but

in

terms

of

how

to

execute

it

because

we

haven't

had

an

actual

technical

analysis

of it

yet

so

there's

a lot

we

can't

actually

not

really

promise

but

haven't

actually

looked into

the

details

that

being

said

we

do

have

contact

with

the

off-chain

labs

team

and

I've

already

approached

them

for

some

recommendations

as well

as examples

of other

protocols

doing

such a

move

so

yeah

I'm

sure

if the

actual

proposal

is

adopted

is

passed

then

we'll

be able

to

spend

some

time

and

give

some

better

breakdown

of how

this

would

work

if we

actually

go ahead

with

this

yeah

a bridge

or some

locking

mechanism

could be

desirable

also

I

think

a

great

use

case

for

having

Thor

on

a

cheaper

chain

would

be

maybe

to

incentivize

voting

especially

in the

beginning

so

our

governance

some

TIPs

have

had

great

participation

some

of them

the

participation

has been

a bit

lower

so

having

cheap

gas

also

and

tokens

coming

from

a

community

incentive

pool

also

enables

for

small

and easy

rewards

vote

you get

I don't

know

100

or

something

like

that

it

makes

it

super

easy

to

incentivize

such

ecosystem

participation

yeah

for sure

I think

having

better

gas

efficiency

will

definitely

open up

a lot

of ideas

around

utilities

for

Thor

and

V Thor

for sure

yeah

hard to

disagree

with the

overall

direction

I think

the points

you guys

made

are great

though

it requires

some

thought

it's not

just

push

a

button

and

it's

all

solved

but

directionally

I think

leads to

a lot

of

good

things

a lot

easier

to

stake

unstake

swap

as well

as all

the other

things

that could

be

built

that's

exciting

like

little

rewards

or

the gas

stuff

could be

really

interesting

and

who knows

what else

could

emerge

way down

the line

on a

chain

where gas

is not

$300

in the

future

I just

brought up

SM50

I don't

know if

you had

something

on this

topic

but feel

free to

chime in

I brought

that subject

in Discord

regarding

Tor on

our return

or another

chain

if there

was to be

used

so I

guess

it's just

to be

mindful

or careful

about

that possibility

too

that we

saw

like

what

X-Rune

dodged

with the

multi-chain

hack

or rug

whatever

that was

because

they

used

the

all

bridge

or I

don't

remember

I think

they were

using

all bridge

for their

token

so they

dodged

that bullet

but if

all that

X-Rune

would have

been

bridged

via

multi-chain

that would

have basically

rugged

everybody

that had

X-Rune

right

so that

exposes

us to

another

risk

doing

that

yeah

that's a

great point

and kind

of an

interesting

thing

to think

about

philosophically

right

we built

ThorSwap

around this

idea

that

bridges

aren't

safe

and

trustworthy

and then

for our

own

token

we're

like

oh

if you'd

have

a

bridge

it's

just

something

to be

mindful

of

and

especially

if you

go

on

Arbitrum

too

Arbitrum

is

by

itself

is

another

security

layer

like

another

security

point

I guess

to think

of

as

an

extra

layer

on top

of

Ethereum

but then

you've got

basically

two

bridge

there

that

you have

to be

mindful

of

that's

just to

consider

because

I had

some

experience

I mean

I saw

that

go

not

like

I mean

they had

their own

problems

now

with the

price

and what

they're

doing

but

just

the

premise

of the

bridge

aspect

there

so

I guess

that's

to be

mindful

of this

that was

the only

point

there

I was

thinking

about

when you

guys

were

saying

that

but

also

when you

might

mention

though

if there

was any

mechanism

though

that made

me think

of

do you

remember

when we

used

to

burn

BEP2

or

ERC20

to

native

rooms

it was

a one

way

basically

burn

but I

mean

is there

like

could you

do that

as a

two way

street

there

and do

it

like

let's

say

on

AVAX

burn

and

mint

and

on

boat

ways

that way

so you

keep

that

kind

of

I

don't

know

just

regarding

what you

were

saying

is it

possible

to do

it

both

ways

instead

of

just

one

way

if

we

had

thought

of

leaving

room

for

extra

chains

and

you know

minting

and

burning

Thor

a little

earlier

on in

this

process

like

way

before

Thor

was

created

before

I

was

even

around

in

this

project

that

might

be

something

that

was

really

good

to

think

about

know

at

this

point

the

Thor

contract

doesn't

have

any

ability

to

change

the

supply

which

in

a

lot

of

ways

is

a

good

thing

but

in

these

situations

you know

makes

it

a

little

bit

difficult

to

kind

of

code

around

these

things

so

the

only

way

that

I

would

know

of

would

be

to

do

some

kind

of

rebase

token

but

I'm

not

sure

if

there's

any

other

creative

solutions

out

there

yeah

that's

beyond

my

capability

of

understanding

I'll

let you

guys

figure

that

one

out

if

I

may

add

to

for

guys

I

just

want

to

I

was

thinking

about

that

for

guys

that

I

wanted

to

sell

and

buy

cheap

tour

especially

when gas

was expensive

it's not

that bad

right now

but

what I

was

doing

is

I

was

just

using

the

version

there

to

accumulate

and

so

I

keep

a

bag

that

I

sell

when

the

price

goes

up

and

I

buy

back

when

the

price

goes

down

so

that

that's

one

way

to

do

it

for

cheap

I

mean

it's

just

pennies

for

people

that

want

to

speculate

on

price

can

still

use

the

same

version

for

basically

for

free

right

I

wondered

who

was

responsible

for

all

that

Synth

Thor

so

now

I

yeah

yeah

thanks

a lot

cool

thanks

man

does

anyone

else

have

any

thoughts

on

this

topic

definitely

Thor

Synth

version

of

Thor

is

great

I'm

using

it

a little

bit

as

well

it's

just

say

last

year

or

a couple

months

ago

when

we

wanted

to

do

a

more

significant

airdrop

we

were

faced

with

the

issue

of

basically

minting

a

Thor

put

in

Thor

into

the

pool

and

that

basically

creates

pressure

so

that's

one

of

the

issues

that

I

think

we

did

an

airdrop

where

we

planned

like

2

million

Thor

or

something

like

that

and

minting

2

million

worth

of

Thor

into

cents

to

facilitate

an

airdrop

which

just

caused

a lot

of

price

movement

which

is

just

a

side

effect

of

using

synthetic

version

of

Thor

and

having

a

dedicated

token

on

a

cheaper

chain

just

solves

that

issue

both

ways

yeah

for sure

like

we'll get

into

this

I think

when we

discuss

the

Thor

chain

university

proposal

but

yeah

when we

kind of

brainstorm

like

rewards

or

like

just

interesting

community

engagement

programs

like

gas

efficiency

has

always

been

like

a

huge

barrier

so

I

think

know

definitely

this

will

go

a

long

way

to

coming

kind

of

open

the

door

for

more

interesting

innovative

ideas

and

utility

should

we

move

on

to

the

next

proposal

folks

I

mean

we

could

always

swing

back

if

people

have

thoughts

to add

yeah

sure

let's

go

on

to

the

next

one

but

yeah

if

people

have

comments

on

that

we

can

always

circle

back

so

next

up

I'll

pin

the

next

one

in

that

same

thread

which

is

change

in

monthly

burn

logic

parameterization

parameterization

yeah

this is

basically

the

change

burn

volume

target

from

rune

to

usd

like

the

proposal

crypto

actually

I don't

know

we

see here

but

yeah

he came

up with

a really

technical

title

for this

proposal

typical

actuary

yeah

parameterization

rolls off

for sure

yeah

this is

interesting

because

you know

obviously

we

considered

with the

initial

burn

proposal

to

have

the

volume

targets

in

usd

and

settled

on

rune

to

honestly

make it

more

challenging

because

the

thought

was

hey

if

the

Thor

chain

protocol

as a

whole

is

succeeding

and

blowing

up

and

seeing

a lot

more

volume

how

do

we

ensure

that

Thor

swap

is

keeping

pace

with

that

and

know

continuing

to

improve

because

if we

set

a

say

we set

a

1 million

target

just as

an

example

and

usd

and

then

the

volume

on

Thor

chain

goes

up

5x

but

our

target

is only

increasing

whatever

it's

set to

like

a

100k

a month

or

something

you know

we're

just

basing

it

on

usd

versus

on

the

growth

of

the

network

then

it

seemed

like

you know

maybe

a little

bit

too

easy

so

I

think

that's

why

we

initially

went

for

that

rune

goal

we

thought

as

the

network

grows

as

know

the

competition

increases

inside

the

Thor

chain

space

which

we've

definitely

seen

how

do

we

create

a

metric

that

kind

of

keeps

us

on

pace

with

that

network

growth

so

that's

how

we

landed

on

the

rune

target

for

burning

Thor

there's

a few

problems

with

it

obviously

one

of

the

problems

is

the

rune

price

doesn't

always

match

the

network

growth

so

know

some

months

the

volume

goes

up

like

this

month

and

the

rune

price

goes

down

other

months

maybe

the

volume

is

flat

and

the

rune

price

doubles

so

it's

not

a

perfect

predictor

and

it

can

be

difficult

in

that

way

the

other

thing

is

just

confusion

among

the

community

so

could

have

a

lot

of

people

Thor

swap

probably

not

the

kind

of

people

that

are

in

this

space

but

know

normies

who

see

that

burn

meter

see

oh

the

volume

target

it's

this

much

rune

they're

going to

think

rune

is

being

burned

I

can't

blame

them

for

that

that's

a

reasonable

conclusion

but

know

there's

just

a

little

bit

of

confusion

around

that

because

it's

how

much

Thor

is

being

swapped

to

burn

rune

then

we

get

into

the

whole

extra

piece

of

this

argument

which

is

like

about

how

measure

volume

and

the

way

that

USD

volume

is

measured

in

the

Thor

chain

protocol

is

like

if

I

swap

a

million

dollars

in

rune

to

a

million

dollars

in

Bitcoin

that's

a

million

dollars

in

volume

but

if

I

swap

a

million

dollars

in

USDC

into

a

million

dollars

in

Bitcoin

that's

two

million

dollars

in

volume

according

to

the

Thor

chain

protocol

because

that's

a

double

swap

right

it

swaps

into

rune

and

then

the

rune

swaps

into

Bitcoin

for

the

Thor

swap

specific

metrics

we

thought

well

no

one's

going

to

think

of

it

that

way

from

a

UI

perspective

from

a

Thor

swap

perspective

they

don't

care

how

the

pools

work

in

the

background

so

this

rune

volume

burn

target

is

actually

only

single

counted

so

it's

a bit

different

than

the

other

volume

numbers

that

look

at

if

look

at

know

that

rune

to

Bitcoin

and

USDC

to

Bitcoin

in

the

Thor

swap

burn

measurement

it's

counted

only

once

instead

of

twice

in

one

scenario

and

once

in

the

other

so

those

are

all

kind

of

just

broad

thoughts

and

considerations

on

this

topic

I

do

agree

that

overall

it's

more

simplistic

and

makes

more

sense

to

do

the

USD

volume

increase

I'm

not

sure

if

there's

maybe

some

other

mechanism

we

could

think

of

to

use

like

a

moving

average

or

figure

out

a

method

to

try

to

incentivize

Thor

swap

to

grow

with

cross

chain

swaps

in

general

with

the

protocol

those

are

my

thoughts

nice

that

that

was

a

really

good

breakdown

okay

yeah

definitely

put your

hand up

if you

have any

thoughts

around

this

otherwise

this

poll

on the

forum

ends

in

two

days

so

yeah

you can

definitely

let us

know

well

let us

let everybody

in the

community

know

how you

feel

about

it

and

you know

the space

we

recorded

so

yeah

that was

a really

good

breakdown

to the

details

I just

had a

thought

actually

would it

be possible

to

what if

the target

was like

you know

like the

affiliate fees

generated

instead of

the overall

volume

you mean

in USD

terms

uh

I guess

yeah

if that

solves the

messaging

part of

it

yeah

I don't

know how

that's

different

than

volume

I

I

guess

yeah

I

don't

know

like

would

that

still

account

for

double

swaps

because

I

think

when we

calculate

our

affiliate

fees

it's

like

at

the

point

of

the

swap

right

yeah

the

affiliate

fee

is

based

on

the

inbound

amount

so

it's

it's

not

doubled

for a

double

swap

for sure

liquidity

providers

will get

paid

twice

on a

double

swap

but

affiliates

will

not

yeah

that's

why

I

was

thinking

like

maybe

this

was

kind

of

two

birds

one

stone

situation

like

solution

but

yeah

they

just

like

the

thought

just

occurred

to me

so

probably

need

some

more

thinking

around

it

yeah

I

mean

however

it

needs

to

get

done

but

but

overall

it

just

feels

like

easier

to get

your

head

around

USD

versus

this

like

floating

rune

price

I

think

that's

probably

like

the

main

advantage

here

the

main

reason

to

do

it

so

yeah

yeah

one thing

I would

add

though

is that

we

haven't

really

seen

the

full

mechanisms

like

actually

play

out

because

we've

been

you know

we've

reached

the

volume

target

like

every

single

month

since

the

burn

started

but

obviously

folks might

be

concerned

that

hey

have

ruined

triples

in price

what if

we don't

meet the

target

this month

but also

I would say

that is

the actual

by design

the gamification

of

hey let's try

to get

this target

reached

let's get

the word

out there

encourage

more people

to use

so

cloth

so

yeah

I wouldn't

really

say

that's

a bad

thing

necessarily

because

we just

haven't

seen

the actual

mechanism

of it

play out

yet

even

yeah

and I

guess

volume

really

went

with it

because

we

kind of

sort of

did

see

that

play out

I guess

a little

because

when

the

earnings

yeah

true

true

true

right

well

but if

it went

down

then

the

targets

go down

so

then

yeah

but I

guess

these

things

kind of

move

in tandem

sometimes

or at

least

they

have

but

yeah

I'll

just

put

one

other

point

on

this

topic

in

this

actual

proposal

from

actuary

he

said

know

the

options

were

to

increase

and

decrease

the

amount

of

the

target

by

like

a

fixed

amount

so

it's

either

like

1

million

2

and

a

half

million

5

million

10

million

whatever

I

think

a

more

sustainable

way

to

do

that

might

be

based

on

percentage

so

instead

of

know

setting

it

fixed

at

1

million

well

if

move

from

10

million

to

11

million

that's

a

big

move

but

if

move

from

100

million

to

101

million

that's

a

pretty

small

move

so

I

think

if

we

can

put

that

as

a

percentage

it'll

kind

of

help

track

over

time

a

little

bit

easier

than

yeah

oh

yeah

just to

add

like

he

also

crypto

actually

also

added

a

poll

for

removing

the

300%

extra

multiply

cap

to

this

proposal

I

don't

know

how

that

will

work

in

tandem

with

I

think

that

kind

of

is

dependent

on

whether

the

proposal

changes

the

amount

of the

target

is

increased

or

decreased

so

the

two

together

kind

of

it's

hard

to

vote

on

because

yeah

I

think

it's

kind

of

like

what

chicken

and

egg

really

like

know

linking

to

what

just

said

yeah

maybe

there's

something

we

can

do

around

future

proposals

where

maybe

it's

one

proposal

one

poll

per

proposal

because

I

think

it

gets

a

bit

convoluted

and

difficult

if

have

multiple

polls

and

a

proposal

was

agreed

upon

do

we

just

move

that

forward

as

it

is

or

I

don't

know

I

think

it's

just

a lot

cleaner

and

easier

for

people

to

understand

if

have

one

poll

per

draft

and

then

see

what

people

think

yeah

exactly

I

mean

this

will

tie

into

the

next

one

we

discussed

which

is

whether

to

add

fees

on

savers

or

not

but

members

have

asked

why

don't

we

do

the

proposal

will

be

for

savers

LP

I

think

it's

just

so

much

cleaner

to

have

proposals

for

a

specific

topic

and

then

the

vote

goes

for

yes

or

no

ideally

it's

just

as

simple

as

yes

or

no

or

let's

change

this

idea

tweak

it

somehow

versus

like

there's

three

ideas

here

so

yeah

like I

said

the polls

end

in

two

days

so

definitely

please

vote

on

that

so

everyone

can

get a

new

draft

which

is fine

you know

we saw

that

with the

previous

you know

expanding

to another

chain

so that

started

with

just

discussing

between

AVAX and

Uptrim

eventually

you know

another one

was made

just for

Uptrim

specifically

so

I think

it's

okay

like

for

the

process

to

go

through

these

like

you know

brainstorming

phases

right

like

that's

what

the

drafts

are

for

and

that's

what

the

temperature

check

polls

are

for

cool

ready

for the

next one

yeah

like

if we don't

have any

hands

being raised

looks like

no

not

currently

so

I'm

getting

this

pinned

up

but

the

next

one

is

for

adding

a

Thor

swap

affiliate

fee

on

savers

which

is

kind

of

self

explanatory

but

yeah

there's

been

no

fee

on

that

ever

since

launching

a

year

plus

ago

no

Thor

swap

fee

so

this

is

the

current

temperature

check

poll

is

whether

it

should

be

still

free

or

how

many

basically

what

level

of

fee

should

be

applied

and

it

would

still

as

per

this

proposal

it

would

still

be

the

same

V Thor

split

that

everyone's

already

accustomed

to

with

swap

fees

and

the

probably

the

one

less

intuitive

part

of

this

is

that

the

fee

just

based

on

how

Thor

chain

is

currently

would

have

to

be

applied

on

entering

rather

than

like

on exit

or

based

on

the

earnings

over

time

so

that's

kind

of

like

the

one

sort

of

caveat

perhaps

to it

but

yeah

I've got

it pinned

up if

people want

to give

that a

deeper

look

yeah

I added

FAQ

section

to the

draft

just to

kind of

answer

some

of those

questions

but yeah

specifically

to the

you know

whether to

apply the

fee on

deposit

or withdrawal

right now

it's only

possible

on deposit

and so

if this

proposal

is passed

and

like

thought

chain

updates

on a

protocol

level

to allow

applying

fees

on withdrawal

or applying

fees

only on

the

earnings

amendment

can be

easily

made

to

you know

for

this

like

another

TIP

proposal

to

address

that

so

that's

just

the

current

technical

limitations

of it

and you

know

we've

seen

other

interfaces

apply

fees

on

deposit

for

LPEs

and

savers

as well

so

it's

definitely

Thor

swap

wouldn't

be the

first

one

to

do

this

but

yeah

definitely

open to

amendments

and discussions

around that

when it's

technically

possible

to do

on patrol

I'll just

throw in

my two cents

on that

you know

Thor

swap

if you

if you

zoom out

and look at

the project

as a

whole

I would

say

it's

it's

hard

to argue

that

hasn't

been

a

very

successful

project

we talked

about

at the

beginning

of this

call

that

we

had

over

a

billion

dollars

in

volume

last

year

but

the

current

mechanism

is

that

75%

of

all

the

fees

collected

go

to

Thor

stakers

that's

great

for

Thor

stakers

it's

not

great

for

running

a

sustainable

team

and

paying

everyone's

salaries

and

hosting

bills

and

doing

R&D

and

all

that

kind

of

expense

so

rather

than

you know

talk about

raising swap

fees

fees

or

changing

the

split

of

how

much

Thor

goes

to

stakers

versus

how

much

Thor

goes

to

the

treasury

my

thought

is

what

about

the

things

that

Thor

swap

is

providing

in

mass

for

free

can

we

put

nominal

fees

on

them

that

know

for

most

users

won't

make

an

impact

it's

know

a few

bucks

if

charge

five

basis

points

it's

like

a

20th

of

a

percentage

point

it's

a

very

insignificant

fee

for

the

user

but

as

it

accumulates

over

time

it

can

make

a

big

difference

for

know

the

health

and

sustainability

of

the

project

overall

so

that's

kind

of

my

perspective

is

these

things

that

we

give

away

for

free

there's

not

a

compelling

reason

to

do

so

it

doesn't

harm

the

user

to

add

really

nominal

fee

there

and

it

can

make

the

project

more

sustainable

in

the

long

run

so

that's

why

I

would

be

in

favor

of

this

type

of

change

but

definitely

open

to

others

perspective

know

we

see

other

projects

charging

more

than

double

and

we

see

others

charging

less

than

half

so

we

can't

say

that

there

is

like

one

way

to

skin

this

cat

I

do

think

from

the

Thoriswild

perspective

we've

tried

to

be

extremely

on top

of

the

innovation

side

of

things

bringing

in

more

roots

and

more

chains

and

just

being

a

first

mover

in

this

space

and

in

order

to

continue

to

do

so

the

project

needs

to

be

sustainable

and

if

do

a

billion

dollars

in

volume

but

have

trouble

looking

at

your

sustainability

then

maybe

need

to

take

a

look

at

the

fee

structures

yeah

one

thing

I

mentioned

and

I

added

to

the

proposal

as

well

is

like

as

Chad

mentioned

we've

just

passed

the

milestone

for

over

a

year

for

savers

which

historically

we

you know

ThorSwap

provided

like

swap

custom

swaps

with no

fees

for

about

a

year

as

well

before

we

applied

fees

so

I

think

it's

a

good

milestone

we've

definitely

approved

the

UX

and

now

it's

quite

a

mature

feature

and

I

think

we'll

definitely

continue

to

upgrade

the

experience

and

obviously

we

provide

our

mods

and

contributors

provide

I

would

say

a

very

powerful

support

for

users

on

Discord

so

in

order

to

continue

making

that

sustainable

with

every

feature

we

add

it

makes

sense

to

launch

to

celebrate

launches

we keep

it free

and we

improve

the feature

but once

it matures

it makes

sense to

have a

proper

fee structure

across all

our product

stack

yeah

that's a

great

point

one

small

thing I

would add

on that

is

streaming

streaming

savers

made a

big

difference

in

how

popular

the

savers

feature

was

before

we saw

some

resistance

to

savers

because

of the

slippage

but now

that the

slippage

is

basically

reduced

to five

basis

points

it makes

the savers

product a

lot more

compelling

and

that's

driven

volume

into

savers

and it

makes

it more

of a

potential

revenue

stream

than it

was

for the

last year

plus

yeah

oh and

one thing

you know

to add

is

you know

this

fee

structure

proposal

whatever

the fee

may be

we'll

just

apply the

same

you know

veto

discount

tier system

as with

swaps

and there'll

be no

fees charged

for deposits

under like

hundred dollar

value as

well so

same system

as with

swaps

so it

should be

pretty easily

you know

understandable

and communicated

to

users

and just

generates

you know

more utility

for vthought

as well

i would

just add

that

savers

is already

a long-term

oriented

product

like you

don't go

in and

out of

savers

within a

week

so really

it's really

just a few

days worth

of yield

for most

pools

so

and it's

also very

comparable

to the

protocol fee

so when

you're

minting

a savers

position

you are

actually

paying a

little bit

to the

pool

in liquidity

fee

and that

slippage

is around

five basis

point as

well

it's not

always a

guarantee

but that's

what the

protocol is

aiming

with streaming

savers

so it's

really just

taking the

exact same

fee that

the protocol

is taking

and also

in most

cases

it will

still be

much lower

than the

gas fee

to just

send that

position

so it's

really

yeah

it's

just

a few

days

worth

of

yield

that

is

going

to

both

TorSwap

the treasury

and TorSwap

committee

in the form

of VTOR

buybacks

I would

just add

the current

vote

has

different

tiers

so it's

not

necessarily

set in

stone

what the

fee

would be

yet

but the

current

vote

is

0

5

10

or

15

basis

points

so

yeah

yeah

so

that

ranges

from

0.05

percent

to

0.15

percent

just for

those who

don't think

are basis

points

so we're

talking about

a very

nominal

figure

here

yeah

I think

we definitely

haven't reached

a quorum

on that

one

I think

we've

got

nine

votes

so

if you're

listening

please

go vote

you don't

need to

connect

a wallet

I know

a lot

of people

get nervous

if a

forum

asked them

to connect

their wallet

like why

am I

giving a

forum

access to

my wallet

so we

remove that

requirement

just

log in

in any

method

use your

email

whatever

and

place your

vote there

and

hopefully

we can

we can

get some

movement

on that

one

and

yeah

I think

from my

perspective

5 bips

is

beautiful

but

if you

want to

give 15

that's

great

too

yeah

obviously

it depends

like you

know

what

is

kind

of

like

what

other

interfaces

and stuff

like end

up at

over time

but

in a lot

of ways

it's a lot

easier to

justify

like a

higher fee

in this

context

than even

even swaps

maybe

because it's

like this

is this

is like a

yield bearing

product that

you're getting

into

you know

so like

you know

hypothetically

if it was

like if it

could be

charged on the

overall earnings

then it

would probably

be like

over time

and like

accruing

and realistically

would probably

end up being

more than

those options

I would

imagine

whereas this

is just

kind of

like the

one time

fee

to then

earn

yield

so

it's

like

there's

an obvious

ROI

on the

fee

versus

just

like

spending

a fee

you know

what I

mean

for sure

I don't

know

I think

sometimes

we

get too

deep

in the

weeds

of

where

we

operate

and we

forget

that

probably

not everyone

listening

knows

what

we're

talking

about

so

just

to

recap

real

quick

the

ideal

scenario

from

Thor

swap

perspective

at least

from

my

perspective

of how

it

should

operate

is

if

put

in

your

money

to a

saver's

position

say

deposit

one

bitcoin

and

wait

for

eight

months

and

then

withdraw

1.02

bitcoin

whatever

it is

Thor

swap

could

take

a

fraction

of

a

percentage

of

the

profit

that

made

along

the

way

maybe

a

percentage

I

don't

know

what

that

number

would

be

but

it

would

only

occur

after

you've

already

made

your

profit

and

when

try

to

claim

that

profit

versus

what's

possible

with

the

protocol

today

is

have

to

take

the

fee

up

front

so

when

deposit

your

one

bitcoin

we

take

that

percentage

at

the

beginning

and

then

wait

to

break

even

essentially

so

we've

had

discussions

with

the

Thorchain

devs

about

this

over

time

I

think

that

will

happen

in

time

it's

just

not

been

an

easy

thing

to

prioritize

with

everything

else

going

on

the

protocol

so

if

that

changes

in

the

future

and

we

get

the

ability

from

the

protocol

to

take

a

percentage

of

the

profit

on

the

position

instead

of

taking

the

fee

up

front

it's

already

in

this

proposal

like

paper

mentioned

I

think

that

makes

it

a lot

more

easy

to

swallow

for

everybody

so

I

think

that

would

be

the

ideal

way

to

do

it

but

like

Oleg

said

in

the

current

implementation

you're

already

going

to

pay

some

fee

to

enter

so

you're

going

to

deposit

one

bitcoin

maybe

won't

start

breaking

positive

or

earning

yield

for

the

first

eight

days

I

don't

know

what

the

number

is

on

that

today

know

because

have

to

pay

some

slip

fee

to

enter

have

to

pay

your

gas

to

enter

so

after

eight

days

year

you'll

become

profitable

if

we

add

a

Thor

swap

fee

maybe

you'll

become

profitable

after

10

days

or

11

days

so

if

you're

looking

at

a

long

term

yield

bearing

product

do

care

that

much

if

know

gained

a

dollar

in

those

three

days

or

know

is

the

long

term

what

really

got

your

sights

set

on

so

yeah

those

are

just

kind

of

some

details

around

we

could

take

it

on

only

profit

one

reason

I

think

it's

much

better

to

do

it

on

only

profit

is

maybe

put

in

one

bitcoin

and

for

some

reason

your

life

circumstance

changes

change

your

mind

need

to

get

your

money

out

before

it's

profitable

if

that

happens

and

need

to

pull

your

money

out

after

two

days

it

would

be

better

if

Thor

swap

wasn't

charging

a fee

for

that

right

it

would

be

better

if

could

just

get

the

funds

back

that

put

in

and

worry

about

the

fee

later

know

if

you're

in

profit

so

those

are

just

some

of

the

small

nuances

there

yeah

I also

think

had that

been

possible

a

fee

probably

would

have

already

been

charged

for

the

past

six

months

so

that

prolonged

the

promotional

period

could

say

so

but

yeah

I

definitely

think

long

term

that'll

be

the

ideal

and

I

would

imagine

that

would

that

as a

proposal

would

pass

with

flying

colors

to

amend

this

in

the

future

but

yeah

I

just

need

to

update

first

yeah

I

think

like

philosophically

you know

Thor's

focus

should

really

just

be

on

user

experience

and

providing

know

the

most

compelling

platform

to

use

because

know

I'm

thinking

from

the

user

perspective

if

you're

providing

because

this

is

basically

yes

it's

very

powerful

feature

but

it's

like

it's

still

a

non

custodial

feature

with

know

you're

giving

your

assets

to

a

protocol

right

and

there's

obviously

this

own

risk

vector

associated

with

that

and

so

I'm

just

thinking

from

user

perspective

if

you're

providing

know

like

a

Bitcoin

worth

of

know

value

or

like

five

figures

six

figures

worth

of

value

to

earn

would

want

to

use

the

most

mature

platform

with

the best

customer

support

and

user

experience

and

stability

and

paying

a

normal

fee

for

that

is

something

that

I

think

the

market

has

shown

people

are

okay

with

so

our

focus

really

just

be

on

know

making

sure

that

we

have

the

best

platform

the

best

support

the

best

user

experience

is

that

all

the

drafts

we

have

right

now

there

is

one

last

one

one

last

quick

one

yeah

I'll

pin

it

up

paper

want

to

cover

that

one

yeah

so

fortunately

baloney

bones

from

14

university

couldn't

join

us

today

he

was

really

excited

to

sort

of

give

the

pitch

directly

to

everyone

but

yeah

some

personal

matters

sort

of

affected

that

he

sends

his

apologies

but

if you

take a

look at

the

pin

and

obviously

if any

members

from

14

university

want

to

put

their

hand

up

and

discuss

this

feel

free

to

do

so

at

any

time

I

feel

like

I

might

do

a

bad

job

of

this

but

if

can

see

the

pinned

proposal

at

the

moment

the

TLDR

is

ThorChain

university

previously

LP

university

you know

OGs of

the

ThorChain

ecosystem

we're all

familiar

with

them

they're

currently

building

a

ThorChain

centric

learn to

earn

like

program

educational

program

so

TCU

have

made

a

draft

proposal

to

seek

support

from

ThorSwap

as a

key

ecosystem

partner

amongst

many

other

ThorChain

ecosystem

projects

and

recommend

some

Thor to

be

allocated

from

community

centres

to

support

this

initiative

and

grow

awareness

for

ThorSwap

and the

Thor

community

so

the

details

are

on

the

template

check

poll

so

it's

slightly

more

complicated

than

usual

poll

as

well

but

essentially

it's

three

parts

it's

like

how

much

Thor

should

be

allocated

from

the

community

census

pool

for

rewards

for

this

program

like

what

time

frame

should

the

rewards

be

used

for

and

would

community

members

be

okay

with

a

portion

of

the

reward

supporting

TCU

and

its

developers

to build

this

program

oh

that

was

my

TLDR

on

the

proposal

yeah

nothing

to add

on

for me

on that

one

but

yeah

that

one's

up

for

vote

as

well

so

people

can

check

that

out

yeah

if

anyone

on

TCU

wants

to

put

their

hand

up

to

kind

of

like

elaborate

a bit

further

feel

free

to

do

so

yeah

he

told

me

the

so

obviously

the

program

is still

being

in

development

but

you know

we're

providing

feedback

in terms

of

you know

along

with

other

ecosystem

partners

to build

it out

and I

think

from

ThorSWAT's

perspective

obviously

we would

like to

highlight

obviously

the

swap

features

as well

as

deck

segregation

and

just

things

that

make

ThorSWAT

platform

unique

and I

suppose

if

the

fees for

earn

program

for the

savers

program

is

passed

we

could

know

it

benefits

us to

highlight

that

as well

but

exactly

how the

raw

system

will be

executed

is

something

that's

still

being

worked

on

and

this

ties

into

the

previous

suggestions

about

gas

efficiency

right

because

it's

all good

to say

let's

allocate

10,000

USD

value

worth

of

Thor

but

how

do

distribute

that

without

each

know

like

someone

does

the

course

maybe

they

do

a

successful

swap

on

ThorSWAP

they learn

how to

do it

and

they're

able to

claim

a reward

how do

they claim

the reward

without

paying

more

and

gas fees

to

do

the

claim

that

needs

to

be

designed

and

maybe

we

can

use

the

scavenger

HUD

system

where

you enter

your

wall

address

and

we

do

one

airdrop

to

everyone

who

does

complete

the

course

but

that

needs

to

be

designed

out

but

overall

I

think

TCU

is a

massive

OG

in

the

space

and

having

something

like

this

to

onboard

more

new

users

is

always

beneficial

it's

crazy

it says

very

close

to

100%

confirmed

participation

from

Thorchain

ecosystem

projects

which

numbers

17

that's

crazy

that

there's

17

ecosystem

projects

now

yeah

that's

really

cool

to

see

love

seeing

the

community

come

together

on

something

like

this

my

vote

is

for

10k

plus

for

sure

know

we

burnt

so

much

Thor

we

keep

talking

about

what

kind

of

community

incentives

can

we

do

I

think

this

is

a

great

one

I

don't

know

how

get

better

than

community

education

so

yeah

it's

a

great

use

of

some

Thor

we

can

figure

out

the

distribution

we

could

use

our

airdrop

scripts

or

whatever

so

there's

a lot

of

ways

around

that

but

I

think

this

is

a

great

use

of

community

incentive

funds

yeah

we've

seen

a lot

of

influencer

marketing

people

or

projects

come

onto

the

discord

and

sort

of

just

basically

pitch

for

hey

pay

me

to

show

right

so

I

think

if

community

incentives

were

used

for

anything

like

supporting

TCU

which

has

obviously

been

like

the

premier

education

like

protocol

in

ThorChain

and

obviously

already

having

the

wealth

of

educational

content

and

the new

ones

being

developed

specifically

for

ThorChain

is

yeah

I think

the most

compelling

proposal

in terms

of

marketing

education

so far

for

for

for

company

incentives

for

sure

agreed

this is

what it's

all about

do you have

anything to add

Reed

I see you in there

sorry what was that

oh I see Reed

in this

in this space

I know that

he's

I think going to be

contributing to

this program

if I'm not

mistaken

gotcha yeah

he's welcome to

come up if

he if

he would

like

thumbs down

not

interested

let me know

that the

likely rollout

is sort

of around

April May

so we've

got you

know

some time

to kind

of plan

around how

do we

want to

you know

actually

execute

this

if this

proposal

is

passed

I'm

sure we

can come

up

some

interesting

ideas

I think

Crypto Actuary

he's not here

so I'll pass

on his idea

like he

mentioned

oh maybe

you know

once the

user has

completed

like a

you know

four swap

specific part

of the course

to actually

you know

do some

of these

actions

such as

a swap

or what

have you

maybe

they get

rewarded

and be

thought

so that

they

sort of

get the

base tier

of these

discounts

so they

you know

get sort

of get

started

as a

as a

community

member

that's

an

interesting

idea

I don't

know

whether

yeah

again

like you

know

you know

efficiency

I think

it's not

a good

idea

to

airdrop

VTHOR

just because

if someone

if it goes

to a wallet

that's not

active

then you

basically

have

VTHOR

stuck there

forever

right

which is

you know

it's

accumulating

rewards

but if it

never gets

you know

redeemed

then that's

just wasted

so that's

something to

consider

but I

like the

idea

and theory

I don't

know what

you guys

think

sorry yeah

no I

mean if

there's no

kind of like

technical

problems there

I think it's

cool to

give VTHOR

rather than

just regular

Thor kind of

gets them

gets them

yeah if it

could get them

to that base

tier that'd

be cool

kind of like

immerses them

into the

project a bit

more than

just like

random Thor

tokens

yeah I think

we need to

probably just

redeploy another

version of the

airdrop contract

but there's

actually a

mechanism built

into our

airdrop contract

you know

if someone

doesn't claim

within a given

period of time

then that

VTHOR could

be clawed

back so

you know

you could

say you

have 60

days to

claim your

airdrop

if you

don't claim

it then

it's going

to get

unstaked

and put

back into

community

incentives

for something

else in

the future

cool we've

got a

we've got

k coefficient

up here

can you

hear me

you guys

hear me

okay

sure can

what's up

I just

got a few

questions

regarding

learning

first ones

learn to

earn

how many

how many

users

does ledger

have

currently

anybody

have any

idea

I don't

know I'd be

guessing

yeah I

don't know

the answer

to that

question

I do

recall

something

like

when

when we

visited

their HQ

last year

they said

something

like

one-fifth

of all

crypto

was stored

on ledger

devices

which is a

pretty big

number

but I'm

not sure

about

user-wise

okay

I just

I didn't

know if it

was like

10 million

or 5

million

or 20

million

I don't

have no

idea

but

isn't

that the

intended

audience

for

learn to

earn

is ledger

integration

correct

that's

definitely

a big

one

I mean

the main

one

right

okay

so plan

accordingly

with a lot

of thought

according to

their website

it says

6 million

units sold

but I

don't

know

how

often

they

update

that

figure

but

yeah

Bernoulli

Bones

has

mentioned

that

ledger

like

they

want

to

also

join

in

on

this

program

and

plug

it

into

their

ledger

academy

which

has

80k

users

80k

students

passing

through

in

about

a year

so

it'll

get

like

you know

a lot

of

eyes

on

it

and

I

think

if we

can

put our

best

forward

as

well

to

sort

of

expose

users

to

obviously

we've

got

the

ledger

discover

app

but

also

you know

ledger

is

pretty

well

supported

on

ThorSwap

for

functionality

so

yeah

that's

just

on that

topic

I suppose

okay

second

question

is

how

much

how

much

debt

has

been

borrowed

via

ThorSwap

or

maybe

also

how

much

collateral

has

been

deposited

to

borrow

debt

using

ThorSwap

and

why

couldn't

we

charge

a fee

for

that

not

call

it

an

origination

fee

because

that's

probably

not

something

you want

to get

into

but

I

haven't

looked

up

those

numbers

recently

so

I

need

to

do

that

there's

there's

already

some

flip side

queries

maybe

I'll

try

to

pull

them

up

in

the

next

couple

minutes

here

to

see

what

those

numbers

are

last

I

checked

they

were

not

significant

from a

fee

collection

perspective

you know

on a

good day

of

swapping

we can

see

10-20

million

of volume

easily

I think

the

total

of

volume

that was

borrowed

was something

in that

neighborhood

of 10-20

million

but I'll

take a look

and try

to get

you an

updated

number

have you

all

considered

that

as a

source

of

revenue

for the

project

for the

decks

I think

similarly

to when

we were

talking

about

adding

the

saver's

fee

there's

kind

of

just

been

the

usual

path

has been

to

run

it

without

a

fee

for a

period

of

time

get

everything

running

smoothly

get

all

hopefully

attract

the

majority

of

the

users

and

then

if

it

becomes

significant

then

yeah

roll

that

out

in

the

future

so

yeah

I

remember

we

did

talk

about

this

at

one

point

and

yeah

I

think

it's

just

like

the

small fry

compared

to

savers

so

I

think

that's

where

the

focus

is

first

but

I

definitely

don't

think

it's

off

the

table

by

any

means

and

that

could

be

a

future

proposal

probably

doesn't

make

any

sense

until

uh

until

like

Thorchain

lending

caps

are

raised

and

that's

kind of

because

like

yeah

I mean

as of

right now

there's

nothing there

but

exactly

like

yeah

Chad's

on

I think

Chad's

on

but

you know

the

caps

will

I mean

God only

knows

right now

everybody's

fucking

bitching

and moaning

left and

right about

everything

so

uh

you know

like

if

things

progress

and the

caps are

lifted

and we

have

CR

you know

ratios

more

favorable

I think

that could

explode

just

looking at

the

nine

realms

dashboard

right now

the

collateral

value

of

all

rune

in loans

is 5.2

million

so

multiply

that

by

four

dollars

and

you know

you get

a little

over

20

million

so

right

yeah

not

significant

from a

fee

collection

perspective

even

if

charged

you know

100

basis

points

you're

talking

about

catching

up to

you know

a week

and a

half

worth

of

swaps

sure

okay

Chad B

do you

do you

guys

want to

ask me

something

about

caps

or

whatnot

or

not

even

really

important

topic

I

guess

not

we're

just

discussing

the

fees

on

you know

possibly

a fee

on

borrowing

you know

assets

that

could

be

a

future

revenue

source

or

they

were

talking

about

the

did

hear

the

discussion

on

a

fee

on

savers

deposits

and

how

that's

coded

in

ThorChain

a fee

like an

affiliate fee

or an

additional fee

for the

protocol

this

would be

like an

affiliate fee

like for

ThorSwap

as a

platform

fee

yeah

I mean

I think

you can

already

take a

fee

today

but I

think

there

was

some

discussion

around

like

changing

the way

the

fee

mechanism

works

so that

it

only

applies

on

withdrawals

and it

only

applies

against

the

yield

of

the

withdrawal

rather

than

the

principle

it would

be like

you can

say

10%

of

whatever

yield

that

was

earned

in

that

time

frame

whatever

that

is

yes

yes

yeah

it's not

currently

designed

that way

to my

knowledge

no it's

not

I think

that's

something

that I

think

ThorSov

has been

kind of

advocating

for

and I

think

Iridanus

has been

probably

the biggest

or most

active

dev

involved

with this

concept

and to

be honest

I'm fine

with it

personally

if people

want to

change

to that

kind

of

structure

I'm

perfectly

fine

with it

it's

just a

matter

of

getting

a dev

to write

it

and get

merged

and stuff

like that

all right

thank you

one sec

here

Mo

disconnected

there

he is

I realized

after a

second

I couldn't

hear

Chad

I think

we're good

now

I was

going to

say

actually

while we

have

Chad

here

if anyone

doesn't have

any thoughts

to add

to the

TCU

proposal

we can

move on

to the

topic

of

discussing

areas

of focus

for

Q1

Q2

and

there's

a lot

of

upcoming

ThorChain

updates

we'll

cover

first

in

this

area

so

yeah

it's

good

to have

Chad

here

as

all

to

chime

in

on

that

I

have

two

questions

for

Chad

since

he's

graced

us

with

his

presence

first

question

is

when

memo

list

and

second

question

is

is

it

possible

with

memo

list

instead

of

basing

the

identification

of

an

inbound

transaction

on

the

amount

to

generate

new

addresses

based

on

the

same

private

key

so

that

could

just

have

a

dedicated

address

for

your

deposit

and

any

amount

send

there

would

go

through

the

swap

channel

that

decided

before

as

so

so

what was

the

first

question

again

I

forgot

the

first

one

already

it

was

just

win

memo

list

oh

what

memo

list

I

think

the

next

thing

that's

probably

going to

be

in

version

128

is

trade

accounts

and I

think

after

trade

accounts

the

next

main

thing

will

probably

be

memo

list

so

I

think

we'll

probably

have

memo

list

on

main

net

and

running

by

maybe

end

of

February

possibly

give or

take

a couple

weeks

so

that

should

be

out

eventually

the

question

about

can

work

with

like

know

different

addresses

so

like

within

crypto

is

this

idea

of

what's

called

hierarchical

deterministic

wallets

which is

basically a

fancy way

of saying

that you

can

generate

many

addresses

from a

single

private

key

and

this

is

how

a

lot

of

know

exchanges

do

this

utilize

this

kind

of

methodology

I

think

shape

shifted

and

it's

actually

quite

nice

little

tool

the

reason

we

are

not

doing

it

that

way

is

just

because

to

do

it

in

our

case

is

a

lot

more

complicated

because

of

special

signatures

and

other

kind

of

things

and

for

example

like

a

Bitcoin

core

the

full

node

have

to

like

it

doesn't

track

how

much

know

doesn't

track

as well

like

wallets

very

well

can

give

it

a

wall

to

track

it

can't

give

it

10,000

it

doesn't

work

that

way

and

so

there's

a lot

of

technical

challenges

it

is

possible

to

do

I'm

not

saying

it's

impossible

it

just

it's

a lot

more

complex

to do

it

that

way

and

do

it

the way

we

are

doing

it

is

a lot

simpler

cleaner

a lot

less

risk

involved

and

easier

to

maintain

these

kind

of

things

but

we

can

always

like

try

it

out

here

with

this

way

and

see

how

it

goes

and

if

it's

a

really

big

adoption

of

that

feature

like

it's

heavily

utilized

and

we're

running

into

bugs

or

problems

where

people

are

having

issues

with

that

particular

implementation

we can

always

go back

to the

drawing

board

and

try

to

re-implement

it

the

more

complicated

or

difficult

way

which

is

the

way

I'm

not

against

it

at

all

I

just

want

to

start

with

the

simpler

and

cleaner

solution

first

and

see

how far

that

gets

us

it

sounds

like

a good

excuse

for you

to make

your first

bitcoin

corp

you are

yeah

they wouldn't

they wouldn't

accept it

for sure

I mean

this has been

a well-known

thing within

bitcoin world

since the

beginning

I don't know

why it's

that way

but I mean

if we wanted

to go

deeper

we would

have to

use

something

like

unchained

or

something

like

this

it's

not very

performant

for

Bifrost

to be

monitoring

many

we actually

ran into

a problem

a while

back

maybe

six months

ago

or a year

ago

where

we started

to monitor

like basically

all the

Asgards

even the ones

that are

inactive

so in the

event that

somebody sends

like you know

a bitcoin

to an old

Asgard address

from like

last month

the network

will make

best efforts

to try to

like do a

refund from

that old

address

yeah

but the

act of

doing so

caused a

lot of

like you

know

optimization

issues

performance

issues

and we

just ran

into like

Bifrost

kind of

like

slowing

down

using a

lot more

resources

and it

just became

like

problematic

so we

ended up

just like

you know

not monitoring

as many

we still

monitor

inactive

addresses

but just

not as

far back

anymore

to address

that

so that's

the problem

is that

like

memos

transactions

you know

you could

have

somebody

could thrash

the network

with you

know

with a

DOS

and start

you know

generating

tons of

addresses

and bitcoin

addresses

and ethereum

addresses

and whatever

else

and that

could just

you know

create a lot

of performance

issues for

Bifrost

so that's

part of the

concern

I definitely

understand that

side of the

concern

I just try to

think of it

from the

UX perspective

like I have

a thousand dollars

in USDC

I want to swap

it into bitcoin

and then it

tells me

I need to

transfer

999.97248

USDC

and I'm like

what's going on

yeah

I get that

concern

it's legitimate

I think

the important

thing here

is really

just the UX

making sure

that people

you know

when you

go to

some website

mentalist

thorchain

dot com

whatever the fuck

it's going to be

called

and you put

in your data

of what you're

looking to do

and it does a

QR code

and you can

scan it

on your phone

and transfer

the funds

and be done

with it

without needing

to input

anything yourself

that's the

cleanest

safest way

to do it

but you should

also just put

like a note

there

like you know

please do not

alter the address

or amount

at all

and doing so

you know

may cause

loss of funds

or some

I don't know

some sort of

like notice

so they understand

that the amount

and the address

are very specific

and not to

fuck around

with it

yeah

for sure

sorry to

jump on you

and derail

but I've just

been curious

about that

question

yeah

yeah

that's the best

answer I can

give you

at least

I don't know

if it's a good

answer or not

but it's the best

one I got

but I say

we just try

it with the way

the way it's

designed now

and you know

see how it goes

and we can always

adjust later

shipping is bad

so we sort

of

yeah

I was just

going to say

before we

go in further

I just wanted

to circle back

a little bit

just to say

like

just to provide

some context

for the non-engineers

or like

first-timers

here potentially

we've moved

on to discussing

areas of focus

for ThoughtSwap

in Q1

Q2

and one of the

you know

obviously

some key areas

of upcoming

ThoughtChain updates

so when we

say Chad

I forgot to

sort of break

this down

we say Chad

like Chad

the road

is running

the ThoughtSwap

account

running the

hosting the

space

but Chad

B

here is

ThoughtChain

and he just

got through

in terms of

Memolist

transactions

which is

really exciting

when we say

Memolist

that's what

we're talking

about

so Memolist

transactions

is a new

upcoming

exciting way

to be able

to register

a memo

before a swap

is made

so essentially

I think what

that means

for ThoughtSwap

users

is you'll

be able

to like

perform

cross-chain

swaps

without having

to connect

wallets

and like

you know

find

figure out

which wallets

to use

interface

to use

and all

that stuff

so we're

waiting for

this feature

to be deployed

and the UX

to be designed

and you know

as mentioned

like one idea

is like

you just scan

a QR code

send the tokens

you want to swap

and ask

you know

and get

you know

and what

you want

to receive

I don't

yeah

on that

I was going

to ask

Moog a question

which is like

what do you

memo lists

on ThorSwap

like do you

think this is

something ThorSwap

will use

like do you

think it'd be

like a separate

swap interface

or like

I'm just curious

if you have

like a vision

for that yet

yeah definitely

I see

just in my head

maybe we'll

improve this

or change it

but right now

you know

if you go to

ThorSwap

without connecting

your wallet

you can

put in

any amount

and get a quote

but instead

of a swap button

at the bottom

of the screen

you see a connect

wallet button

next to that

connect wallet

button

you could just

have a QR code

button

and you see

that QR code

it just pops up

a QR

you scan that

with your phone

whatever your

preferred wallet

is

it preloads

the address

to send to

the amount

to send

and all you

need to do

is press send

on your phone

after you scan

the QR code

and your swap

is done

you don't have

to log into

anything

you don't have

to worry

about extensions

you don't have

to worry about

is my wallet

supported here

just scan the QR

code

you're done

so I see it

kind of running

in parallel

to everything

we have now

and just giving

another method

to interact

with really

any wallet

that supports

a QR code

or even

if you just

say send

exactly this

amount

to this

address

that works

too

but it's

a little bit

harder to

execute

than a QR

code

but still

pretty simple

yeah

this is a

super exciting

feature

I think

when we

actually

start executing

on this

feature

as per

tradition

we should

probably

do some

beta

testing

as we've

done in

the past

got a lot

of community

members

have done

that in

the past

and

they'll be

good to

get some

community

feedback

before we

formally launch

it

or at least

put it

out in

beta

first

one

interesting

problem

to solve

around

that

is going

to be

there's a

cost to

generating

a QR

code

you have

to create

the channel

on the

third chain

protocol

before

you can

give the

user this

QR code

so we've

got to

figure out

some good

spam

prevention

mechanisms

just to

make sure

that there's

a cost

control

there

around

someone

coming in

and trying

to generate

hundreds of

thousands of

QR codes

and drain

all of our

wallets

yeah the

way that

I'm planning

on addressing

that because

once memos

transactions

are like

launched

and it's

out in

the wild

I'm planning

on building

a new

like

Golang

daemon

that it

becomes

the thing

that registers

you know

QR codes

or swaps

or whatever

and the way

that I'm

planning on

handling this

is just

re-implementing

the Bitcoin

mining logic

that's like

global across

this particular

daemon

so that with

each

relative to

the number

of requests

made in the

last I don't

know five

minutes or

20 minutes

or whatever

the hell

the thing

is the

amount of

mining that

you have to

do your

browser has

to do to

be able to

provide a

proof that

you know

you've done

a bunch of

computations to

whatever

that's my

methodology

I have in

my head

to deal with

this

that scenario

then that

way

it's

really

smart

that's

really cool

now you

got me

thinking like

okay can

we make

them do

proof of

work

90% of

the work

goes to

the transaction

and 10%

goes to a

fee collection

but maybe

I'm just

being overly

selfish

I mean you

can obviously

do what you

want

I think

I think

generally like

the mining

that's happening

will be so

fast that you

won't even

really notice

that it's

actually

happening

yeah it's

not

significant

enough

yeah

like most

times like

99% of

the time you

wouldn't even

know that it

happened it

would just be

a click and

done but it

would only

start to kick

in once like

you know there's

some sort of

DOS attack of

some kind or

whatever and

you can configure

the server to

be like you

know how

sensitive you

want that

mining you

know inclined

to be right

the curve of

the difficulty

of mining

blah blah blah

you'll be able

to like have

that kind of

configuration of

it but one

of the things I

find very kind

of fascinating

from a wallet

perspective on

Memolus is that

like ThorSwap

it's almost the

opposite of

ThorSwap in

some ways like

ThorSwap has

put together like

a really good

and large team

and it's built

this really kind

of like advanced

interface with a

lot of

functionality and

usability and

you know and

with that comes

a lot of cost

like it costs

a lot of money

to keep the

lights on you

know at the

ThorSwap you

know team and

so forth and

I think one of

the things I

find really

fascinating about

this is that

somebody could

build which is

not going to

be me but

somebody I

think I think

TCB is

interested in

doing this but

like somebody

can build a

very basic

very simple UI

that has no

real maintenance

to it has you

know almost no

very little

development and

very little

maintenance to

it but it's

you can run

the whole thing

by you know

for $50 a

month you know

in operational

costs and then

maybe you have

one person that

you know just

responds to

to you know

outages and

that kind of

thing but like

there really is

no need to

keep up with

the latest

Thorchain thing

or whatever

like it you

could just do

fucking swaps

doesn't you

could use them

a list to do

loans and like

other savers and

like other

things in

theory but

it would just

be designed to

do this one

thing with this

very simple

very clean UI

and then the

affiliate fee would

be like one

bit you know

or something

extremely small

because it costs

so little to

build it and it

costs so little

to maintain it

you can you

know have a

really really

cheap system

which case that

would hopefully

in theory that

should mean that

the trade volume

of Thorchain

should you know

increase significantly

because it's

so it's so

cheap to use

it rather

than being

like rather

than opting

for like trust

wallet 70

bit you know

expense that

they put on

you you could

just use trust

wallet but then

just scan the

QR code and

do the same

trade for one

bit instead of

70 bits like

it's 70x less

in fees that

you're paying and

just the fact that

you're paying less

in fees also

should inherently

mean that the

volume is increasing

right because it's

cheaper

yeah pretty

interesting

I'm thinking

about like all

the infrastructure

stuff and one

of the big things

is like when you

connect someone's

wallet you've got

to be able to

check the balances

you've got to be

able to find out

what's happening

across 10 different

blockchains for

their wallets

so that means

you've got to

either run those

nodes connect to

those centralized

providers for all

those chains but

if you're doing

memo lists you

don't care what

their wallet balance

is you don't need

to know you don't

have to look any

of that information

up so it just

takes a lot of

overhead away

right you can

just I mean if

they want to send

a thousand bitcoin

in their swap they

can go ahead and

try you know

obviously it's not

going to be sent

right so

obviously put it

put in a reasonable

amount that you

actually want to

be sending like

one bitcoin or

half a bitcoin or

whatever you're

trying to do

right and so

just removing all

that overhead and

being a super

clean super

simple this

bare minimum

thing just be a

very clean swap

you I believe I

think that's going

to be really

positive for the

protocol in general

I think there may

be some implementation

challenges across

different platforms

like how does it

work when your

iOS device scans

the QR code

versus your

Android device

how do you

choose what the

default wallet is

does your OS

provide a good way

to do that

does every wallet

maintain every single

detail or do they

did some of them

round off the

numbers so that we

lose the important

information about

like how many sats

are included

so those kind of

things are going to

take some time to

iron out I think

we're going to have

to make sure like

we test this with a

whole bunch of

different wallets

that you know

there's not some

edge case where

oh this wallet when

you scan the QR code

it drops the last

four digits so now

memos doesn't work

at all we have to

think about all

those little things

as we go through

an implementation

but overall I

still think it's

really exciting

yeah I think

you're right

there's definitely

going to be a

fair share of

like oddities

and edge cases

I can even like

for example even

if your Bitcoin

wallet uses

Taproot

Taproot addresses

it wouldn't work

for Thorchain

so the

that kind of

Golang game

that registers

memos

would you

probably supply

the address

that you're

sending from

even though it's

not really used

it just doesn't

some quick

validations to

make sure that

that the address

you're sending

from is

something that

Thorchain you

know can parse

or understand

you know but

you're right

there's probably

going to be a

whole myriad of

you know edge

cases that are

you know problematic

and we'll have to

make some changes

and edits to

address that

win hard fork

win hard fork

you mean forking

Thorchain into a

new Thorchain

no no I just

mean uh

the noise

around Taproot

has been

it's not

possible without

the next

hard fork

so

Taproot

yeah

um

I don't

to be honest

I don't have a

good I don't have

a good answer

to this

it's hard to

for me to

prioritize it

because I don't

really have a

good sense of

like how

important

Taproot really

is

I know some

wallets use it

and that's great

and everything

but like

I don't know

it would be

obviously a bunch

of work

and it's

something we've

been meaning

to do for a

long time

but it's always

just get

deprioritized

because there's

always something

more important

you know like

memo transactions

like order books

like you know

affiliate fee

improvements

for to be able

to lock

TrustWallet

into using

Thorchain

because it's

making a million

dollars a month

or something like

this like there's

always just something

that seems just

more important

than a hard fork

it always gets

deprioritized

but is it

aren't all the

inscriptions

everything's based

on Taproot

correct

yes

I believe so

we don't really

use inscriptions

ourselves of course

so we're not really

I know

I know

the problem

with inscriptions

is that

is that the

mempool

blows up

and so you

need to make

sure that

Bifrost is like

you know

Johnny on the

spot

of making

sure that

the mempool

is scanned

to the tip

of the mempool

you know

we're not

falling behind

because there's

like 200,000

transactions

sitting in

mempool

in which

most are

inscriptions

so we made

a lot of

improvements

to the

performance

of Bifrost

so that

it could

keep up

with

you know

a very

thick

and large

mempool

that inscriptions

would give

on that note

while we have

you here

Chad

just two

other

updates

I think

would be

really interesting

for

four swap

users

would be

I think

like

batch

outbounds

which

you know

potentially

will help

lower gas fees

even further

like in throughput

and limit

order like

order books

I think

that's been

developed for

a while

do you have

any sort

of like

updates

on those

two

yes

order books

will probably

it may

come out

in Q1

probably

more likely

to be

Q2

at this

point

to be

honest

and

there's

going to

be some

like

kind of

reworking

of that

code

most of

the code

is already

done

there's

some

kind of

cleanup

to do

and some

kind of

wires

to connect

and we have

to refactor

for streaming

swaps

and we have

to refactor

for using

trade assets

instead of

synthetics

but I

think

it'll

probably

get done

at the

end of

Q1

maybe

Q2

what was

the other

question

you asked

oh yeah

a batch

outbound

batch

outbound

it was

something

that came

up

because

we ran

into a

situation

where

you know

this

some

guy

stole

a whole

bunch

of

money

and was

throwing

it

through

a

third

chain

and it

caused

the

outbound

Q2

to

become

hundreds

of

deep

and was

having

a hard

time

keeping

up

with

it

and so

batch

outbound

allows

you to

put

multiple

transactions

multiple

transfers

in a

single

transaction

so it

is

much

higher

throughput

and then

at that

point

our

signing

speed

of what

Thorchain

is capable

of doing

is basically

infinite

and the

limiting

factor

really is

not so

much

Thorchain

it's

really

more

on

the

remote

chain

like

how

many

transactions

how many

UTXOs

can we

have

how many

Vouts

or UTXOs

can we

create

on the

other side

of a

Bitcoin

transaction

same thing

for BNB

and other

things

and so

we can

basically

have like

an infinite

signing

speed

and effect

which is

what

almost every

centralized

exchange

in the

world

does

to deal

with the

throughput

they need

to deal

with

even though

they don't

actually use

social signatures

for this

so

but that

is like

not a

critical

thing

like

we're

fine

we don't

have to

worry

about

you know

except for

like extreme

scenarios

like somebody

just pumping

through 40

million dollars

of ETH

within like

10 minutes

or something

fucking ludicrous

like this

except for

times like

that

you know

we have

the throughput

we need

so

I've been

trying to

push for

batch out

bonds to

be done

like to

be like

a slow

burn

meaning that

like we'll

do like a

small PR

like every

release or

something like

this

kind of

over time

get it

and it'll

be just

you know

very slow

process

but we'll

get it

through

eventually

just doing

chain by

chain

in the

end

it'll

probably

take

you know

probably

10 or

12

PRs

to get

all that

batch

up on

functioning

and working

and then

and then

it's also

going to

have its

own

capping

mechanism

so

on day

one

we'll

probably

just

cap

it

at

like

two

transactions

and

two

transfers

within

a

transaction

just

so

that

if

there's

any

bugs

or

misreading

of the

contents

of a

transaction

or something

happens

that the

risk is

you know

quite low

and you

have to be

very careful

with this

stuff

because

we're

signing

data

out

signing

funds

out

so

if

fuck

it

up

could

double

spend

yourself

could

do

all sorts

of

terribleness

you could

lose

a lot

of

money

so

this

has

to

be

done

with

a lot

of

caution

and

one

of

the

reasons

I

want

to

do

slow

burns

make

sure

it

happens

very

slowly

and

very

cautiously

and

we

take

our

time

with

it

and

that

kind

of

stuff

but

in

the

end

it's

going to

take

probably

like

10

or

12

different

PRs

over

the

time

span

of

three

or

six

months

to

be

honest

with

but

at

the

end

we'll

have

just

basically

infinite

scalability

in terms

of

signing

speed

and

that's

part

of

one

of

the

targets

that

I

have

I

just

want

to

make

sure

that

Thor

chain

stays

competitive

in the

market

of

cross

chain

swaps

I

want

to

make

sure

that

there's

no

leg

to

stand

on

of

any

other

project

in

the

space

who

can

say

oh

we

got

faster

signing

speeds

and

I'm

just

like

nope

no

don't

we

can

do

swaps

faster

wait

no

swap

clout

can't

do

that

either

know

just

constantly

just

trying

to

create

improvements

to the

protocol

that

just

makes

us

the

obvious

and

clear

winner

of

any

trade

or

swap

nice

stand

one

step

ahead

and

then

that

makes

makes

the

job

easier

for

the

interfaces

giving

a

good

experience

to

users

yep

absolutely

can

I

bug you

for one

more

thing

can

give

us

an

Eli

five

of

the

trade

assets

yes

so

a

trade

asset

is

another

form

of

a

synth

but

it's

not

actually

a

synth

I

don't

even

know

what

to

call

it

to

be

honest

with

I

guess

could

call it

a

wrapped

asset

but

that's

actually

not

accurate

either

I

really

don't

know

what

phrase

to

use

to

call

it

nothing

kind

of

correlates

to

it

but

it's

basically

the

idea

that

can

take

know

an

asset

like

bitcoin

and

can

mint

a

trade

asset

onto

the

network

which

sits

outside

of

the

pool

and

then

can

use

that

to

swap

bitcoin

to

eth

or

rune

whatever

as

an

arb

instead

of

using

synthetics

and

the

reason

why

that's

really

nice

is

because

when

arb

with

a

synthetic

if

somebody

does

like

a

$200

trade

from

eth

to

bitcoin

for

example

or

rune

to

bitcoin

in

order

to

arb

the

other

direction

and

put

the

pool

back

to

the

ratio

that

it

should

be

would

need

to

swap

$400

worth

of

bitcoin

to

ruin

to

counter

it

and

so

there's

a little

bit of

capital

inefficiency

with

synthetics

so

by

going

to

trade

assets

make

it

increase

the

capital

efficiency

of

arbitrage

to be

two

times

more

efficient

so

the

same

amount

of

capital

can

arb

trading

and

swapping

on the

network

and

that's

going

for

the

idea

of

making

the

network

as

efficient

as

possible

so

that

they

can

keep

the

pool

price

and

the

market

price

locked

up

with

each

other

we

saw

that

happen

with

that

30

or

40

million

dollars

that

came

to

the

network

in

a

very

short

period

of

time

he

just

dumped

he

didn't

care

about

fees

at

all

he

just

yolo

just

dumped

huge

quantities

in

a

very

short

period

of

time

which

no

logical

actor

would

really

generally

do

but

this

guy

wanted

to

shotgun

blast

tons

of

funds

and

so

we

saw

the

Bitcoin

price

on

the

network

go

from

I

think

at

the

time

it

was

like

$35

or

$30,000

to

$52

or

$55,000

Bitcoin

which is

obviously

not

correct

and

so

it

just

took

so

long

for

ARBs

to

ARB

that

and

it

was

partially

because

comp

counting

was

taking

too

long

it

was

partially

because

the

signing

time

because

TSAS

was

being

slow

in

signing

things

it

was

partially

because

we

burned

through

all

the

synthetics

that

were

there

for

arbitrage

were

emptied

and so

there was

a whole

myriad

of

reasons

of

why

ARBs

had

a

hard

time

ARBing

that

system

and

we

made

a lot

of

changes

to

make

arbitrage

much

more

faster

much

more

efficient

and

I

think

this

trade

accounts

thing

is

probably

the

last

at least

in the

short

term

or

midterm

probably

the last

arbitrage

change

we'll

make

to

make

arbitrage

as fast

and efficient

as powerful

as possible

so they

can

keep

the pool

of prices

correct

not just

for large

trades

like we

saw

that

$30

or $40

million

but also

for when

streaming

swaps

are happening

if ARBs

are twice

as efficient

the price

execution

of a

streaming

swap

should

increase

and it's

twice

efficient

as that

as well

right

so we

should

have

better

price

execution

on

trades

and

swaps

just

because

of this

trade

accounts

thing

as well

theoretically

very

interesting

all right

I think

we're

almost

two and a

half

hours

in

so

we

should

probably

try

to

hit

the

remaining

2024

highlights

and

then

wrap

this

thing

up

exactly

what I

was

thinking

we did

just

get

one

request

from

somebody

to

come

up

so

we

can

see

what

that's

about

as

well

real

quick

got

muddy

connecting

hey

I think

I'll

mute

yeah

you there

oh yeah

sorry

that's weird

when I

click on

your name

it shows

a different

name

weird

but

can you

hear me

now

yeah

okay

you're

good

great

since

Arbin

was just

mentioned

and I

am just

putting

together

like

is

there

currently

like

room

for

more

arbors

to

enter

the

space

because

I

have

a

friend

who's

who's

like

a

trader

and

he's

like

telling

me

about

like

he

wants

to

do

machine

learning

like

stuff

on

centralized

exchanges

to try

to make

trading

strategies

and I'm

telling

him

no way

dude

there are

so many

imbalanced

pools

out there

right now

I think

there's a

huge

opportunity

that a

lot of

people

don't

know

about

with

these

cross

chain

DEXs

so

is

there

still

space

or

has that

been

filled

yet

there's

always

more

space

and

this is

actually

one

thing

that

very

few

people

in

our

industry

actually

know

about

but

one

of

the

benefits

of

the

swap

queue

where

it

prioritizes

based

upon

the

size

of

the

trade

if

have

a

situation

where

have

an

ARB

opportunity

and say

there's

like

three

different

ARBers

and they

all

want

to

ARB

this

trade

they

all

want

to

ARB

this

pool

right

if

they

all

submit

the

trade

at

the

same

time

in

the

same

block

which

is

more

or

less

the

swap

is

the

one

that's

going

to

get

the

ARB

opportunity

right

but

basically

the

one

that

opts

to

pay

the

most

in

fees

is

the

one

that

will

actually

win

it

right

so

have

this

kind

of

situation

where

because

of

the

swap

queue

have

this

race

to

the

bottom

of

arbitrage

bots

right

whoever's

willing

to take

the

least

amount

of

know

whoever's

willing

to put

the

most

into

the

pools

and

leave

it

there

is

the

one

that

will

win

right

and

so

have

one

guy

that

will

say

know

I'll

do

it

for

a

$10

profit

and

the

guy

says

I'll

do it

for a

$7

profit

and

everybody

just

bids

each

other

down

in a

matter

of

speaking

and

so

honestly

the

ARBs

of

Thorchain

is

probably

not

the

most

powerful

thing

in

the

industry

and

there's

not

a

lot

of

them

and

there's

probably

a

good

amount

of

space

I

think

some

are

even

using

streaming

swaps

right now

which is

really

ineffective

uncompetitive

it's

not

it's

still

effective

but

it's

just

not

very

it's

not

a

competitive

way

of

going

at

if

wanted

to

get

somebody

else

wanted

to

ARB

as

well

yeah

well

so

there's

yeah

yeah

yeah

yeah

well

so

I have

I have

a math

guy

who

can

basically

you know

like

flip all

these

ratios

in his

head

and do

like

like

you know

find the

profit

just

you know

without

and I'm

more of

the coder

and more

of like

the guy

that knows

that there

are

opportunities

to ARB

in places

where he's

like more

of a

traditional

centralized

trader

yep

so

in the

whole

like

deck space

especially

cross

decks

cross

decks

are you

saying

that there's

room

for

competition

or

are you

guys

good

on that

I mean

in the

general

crypto

space

there

there is

some

room

I mean

it's a

very highly

competitive

space

and so

there's

not

a lot

of

margin

like

if you

want

to

ARB

like

Binance

for example

you're

probably

not going

to get

very good

margins

you probably

don't have

enough capital

to even do

it to be

honest with

most people

don't

but the

lesser known

protocols

like you

know that

are you

know have

lesser volumes

there's probably

some meat

in the bone

there and I

would say

that Thorchain

is one of

them

yeah

yeah that

we would

target

Thorchain

and my

and I

don't even

know if

if it's

even possible

yet on

Chainflip

or if

it's even

a thing

on Chainflip

since they

have a

USDC

middle asset

but anyway

thank you

yeah

no you can

totally do it

on Chainflip

as well

oh okay

they use

JIT

they use

JIT there

which is

kind of like

it's not really

ARBing per se

but yeah you

can totally

ARB between

Chainflip and

Thorchain

you could actually

do that too

right like look

at the Bitcoin

price on Thorchain

look at the

Bitcoin price

on Chainflip

you know

especially if we

can get some

DEX aggregation

between Chainflip

and Thorchain

that would be

yeah yeah

so we got

we got accounts

all across

like Kraken

International Binance

Coinbase

those

sexes

and then

the DEXes

Maya

Thorchain

Chainflip

I'm kind of

the person

who knows

all these

things

and has

the API

keys

and stuff

for all

of it

but I

kind of

need like

a trading

guy

and a

math guy

which I

am

which I

do have

and they're

like down

to

they're down

but I

just want

to make

sure

before we

start the

work

that it's

even worth

even worth

starting

definitely

you should

totally do

it

I'm not

an arbitrager

but I

would say

look at

the number

of times

that the

pools have

been in

disagreement

with major

centralized

exchanges in

the last

year

and they

have been

not insignificant

so that to

me is a

pretty strong

signal that

we could use

more arms

I actually

did some

manual

arbitring a

while back

and I

made four

bitcoin in

a single

day

that's cool

yeah like

I think

I don't

like

I'm an

economics

guy so

I like

to think

of it as

you know

you're making

the market

price discovery

better

you're making

markets more

efficient

you know

like

you know

you're

basically the

customer is

being screwed

over but

you're also

making a lot

of money

at the same

time

one of the

one of the

funny things

that is one

of like the

long-term

like holy

grail goals

of the

project

is that

that

Thorchain

becomes the

biggest exchange

in the world

by volume

right and so

a majority

of the largest

exchange by

volume of

bitcoin trading

spot trading

happens on

Thorchain

and if that's

the case

the price of

bitcoin is

established on

Thorchain

which is kind

of a mind

blowing concept

of like

if you

want to know

the price

of bitcoin

the best

place in the

world to look

is actually

at Thorchain

and that

tells you the

actual fucking

price because

that's where

most of the

weight is

as I'm hoping

happens one

day

yeah that's

my dream

too

well thank

thank you

no worries

no worries

you're a little

poor bitcoin

in a day

humble brag

drinks are

on you

next time

I see

yeah god

damn

Mogarki I owe

you a lot

more than

a drink

I'll be happy

to buy you

a drink

next time

I see

you're going

to eat

Denver

by the way

yes I

will be

in East

Denver

I'll probably

be in I

think Boulder

before East

Denver

hanging out

with a couple

buddies of

mine

but I'll be

in East

Denver

I'll be

hanging around

are you

going to be

there too

we can

we can

grab a beer

or whatever

yeah for

sure

there's a

event coming

up that

we're going

to be

sponsoring

with

coinage

media

okay

Thorchain

plus

coinage

media

kind of

collaborative

event

where we're

just going

to rent

out a bar

or something

like this

and just

kind of a

meet up

people can

come out

and have

a drink

and talk

all things

Thorchain

awesome

all right

I'm going to

try to pass

back to

Chad Thoreau

and get

away from

the

bear for

distractions

for a

minute

sounds

good

yeah

I actually

have to

run

any

minute

now

so

let's

just

run

through

a couple

of these

last

things

we kind

of covered

the areas

of focus

that are

Thorchain

related

already

like

Memolus

network

improvement

swap for

cloud

other

upcoming

stuff

limit

orders

trade

assets

but yeah

paper

30 seconds

on

maybe

non

Thorchain

things

and

don't

have

like

any

big

announcements

to make

anything

or anything

like that

here yet

but

I would

say

that

you know

in the

last

two

years

you've

seen

ThorSwap

expand

to

supporting

a lot

of other

providers

so

we've

added

you know

everyone

from

Uniswap

and

OneInch

and

ZeroX

and

Trader Joe

and

Pangolin

all

these

different

providers

which

have

been

pretty

much

limited

to

EVMs

apart

from

Thorchain

so

I would

say

2024

is a

year

to

look

out

for

that

getting

outside

of

EVM

land

for the

first

time

and

maybe

seeing

some

providers

that

can

provide

other

more

novel

more

interesting

chains

that

don't

see

elsewhere

or

maybe

you know

even

different

liquidity

routes

to

liquidity

you can

already

get

but

more

deeper

access

better

routes

better

paths

for

the

user

for

all

the

API

users

so

that's

going

to be

a big

focus

for

us

this

year

yeah

potentially

layer

truth

as well

right

definitely

for sure

yeah

that's

the big

exciting

one

so

definitely

I know

I'm glad

to hear

that

that's

one

of

the

main

focuses

so

yeah

lots

of

cool

stuff

to

come

with

that

and

hopefully

getting

some

routes

to

other

assets

that

are

kind

of

stranded

or

harder

to

access

with

current

interfaces

or

just

by

Thorchain

so

yeah

and then

at

the

end

of

the

year

Chad

is

going

to

bring

us

Solana

and

we'll

finally

make

it

to

Valhalla

that

would

be

nice

yeah

I'm down

for Solana

I have

some

things I'm

concerned

about

but

I think

overall

I'm down

for it

sweet

sweet

yeah

at some

point

like

I feel

like the

Bitcoin

community

should

just

consider

us

like

the

biggest

layer

two

just

for

the

fact

that

we're

spreading

like

native

Bitcoin

to

all

these

well

basically

across

the

entire

crypto

which

is

like

still

not

really

being

valued

enough

I think

so

yeah

actually

I got

an

email

the other

day

from

Bitcoin

magazine

who

runs

a

famous

Bitcoin

conference

and

actually

emailed

me

and

Voorhees

together

because

we both

did

the

Bankless

podcast

together

but

they

were

asking

if

Thorchain

was

interested

in

engaging

with

the

Bitcoin

conference

and

getting

involved

as a

sponsor

or

whatnot

or

whatever

so

we

started

a

conversation

because

you're

right

we need

the

Bitcoin

community

to see

Thorchain

as

a

Bitcoin

project

in a

sense

100%

free

mine

shit

coin

yeah

I had

a huge

debate

with

Bitcoin

Maxi

in

Japan

like

a while

ago

and

I

just

it's

still

shocking

like

how

little

Bitcoin

Maxis

like

know

what

Thorchain

does

so

yeah

I

still

remember

that

panel

chat

that

were

on

hopefully

next

time

you know

you're

part of

Bitcoin

event

or any

of us

are

really

you know

the

perception

has

changed

otherwise

yeah

more work

needs to

be done

and that

was a

painful

one of

the more

painful

talks I've

given in

my

lifetime

it was

pretty

ridiculous

oh you

handled it

great though

I don't

even

dude I

would have

that would

have been

gnarly

handled it

well but

that was

iconic

that'll be a

fun clip to

like pull

back up in

like five

years

yeah I

couldn't even

hear the guy

for some

reason like

there was

like four

people on

stage I

could hear

myself and

the guy

next to

me but I

couldn't hear

the other

two guys

like it

was very

hard like

I don't

know what

was wrong

with the

audio for

me on

stage I

just could

barely hear

anything so

I could barely

hear the insults

that he was

throwing at

me to be

honest with

you you're

just like

smiling I'm

just like yeah

I don't know

what you're

saying I

think I

joked it

like should I

come over

there and

slap you like

Will Smith

style or

something like

that oh

yeah I

think that had

just happened

like that

was yeah

yeah I

will slap

your ass

Will Smith

style

keep my

protocols name

out your

MF in

mouth

that would

have been

amazing that

would have

been like the

perfect meme

right there

all right

guys let's

wrap it up

thanks a lot

real quick we

didn't give

away any

stuff so

let's pick a

couple people

real quick

I'll pick

one you

pick one

paper I'll

pick

Chris CDC

I've seen

you in

here the

entire

space so

shoot a

DM to

ThorSwap

account grab

some some

free some

free merch

you want to

pick one

paper

sweet yeah

I'll pick

shit emoji

it's been

fine

yeah thank

you for

contributing

to our

dude he's

got a

dude he's

got a whole

closet full of

merch by now

I think

no I'm

just kidding

but he's

always he's

always a good

one so he's

got I would

imagine he's

probably had

some but it's

all good

yeah yeah

you know we

gotta get more

like community

engagement though

yeah no

totally no

he's yeah he

he more than

deserves it he

should have a

full closet of

ThorSwap merch

for for the

level of

engagement and

activity so

yeah totally

but yeah I

think that covers

it oh he wants

to come up let's

see he's gonna

he's gonna

comment on

his on his

closet

so a one

thing I you

can't give it

away to somebody

I literally have

everything so

you guys

give it to

somebody that

that you know

needs more

merc I I can

literally dress

like from my

shoe to my I

have caps

everything so

don't I'll

make somebody

else happy

there

love it let's

pass it on

appreciate that

and by the

way just to

say that you

made you guys

made me laugh

but that guy

was Jack

Muller I should

remember and

he's a if an

idiot I'm sorry

like he's very

smart like he's a

good talker but

he's an idiot and

he's in he's a

bit he's a maxi

right but he's in

love with his

lightning thing

they're always

striking I think

so oh my god

that was painful

to hear but it

was funny

for sure

all right you

too uh yeah

let's I guess

let's pick one

more then um

let me see who's

been in here

I want to give

it to Chad B

but he doesn't

respond to our

DMs I remember

we gave it to

Chad B like um

I think one of

the previous

spaces but he

never claimed

it wow I know

I gotta do that

I actually don't

have much for

like merch of

the protocol that

I helped design

build an architect

I barely have

and the things

that I do have

my wife just

made you know

on her own

of some funny

t-shirt or

something you

got the Thor

Force ones that's

the that's my

that's the legend

date yeah I've

got I've got

those that's

about it yeah

that's my best

that's the thing

I like I barely

even touch them

just because I

don't want to

ruin them

same ruin them

I think my

ruin suit is

tough to beat

yeah that one

was legendary

I remember

I remember

those that

picture

you know

what's funny

is like the

other day I

saw um

Brian Pellegrino

I think his

name is from

the from

layer zero

layer zero

the uh

sparkling water

no I'm just

kidding

he posted a

video like the

new offices they

have and I

don't know what

city was in but

they're just like

really beautiful

like you know

some high tower

rise and

whatever I was

like watching

like oh these

offices are

amazing and I

remember like

thinking myself

like yeah

Thorchain will

fucking never

have this

we've just

always been

such a uniquely

very tiny tiny

tiny tiny king

distributor around

the world

you know what

Chad neither

will Bitcoin

exactly

that's exactly

you'll never

have to see a

Bitcoin office

anywhere and

that's kind of

like the right

way to do it

in a sense

you know

right yeah

who's signing

the lease on

that thing

exactly

how's it being

paid like how

many employees

do you actually

have in order

to fill that

up hundreds I

guess right

I mean to be

fair like they've

had huge amounts

of investment

like ridiculous

like fucking

ridiculous amounts

of investment

and they've

gotten they

paid out a

huge amount

of money to

like to like

you know

Tom Brady

and like other

kind of famous

faces to be

sponsors and

such like they

just have a

huge capital

behind them

so they can

do that stuff

and not really

be concerned

about but we

have just a

shoestring budget

ourselves we

have so few

people people

take very low

salaries to be

honest with you

relative to what

you can get in

the market today

it's just we're

just so efficient

you know and

very very

protective of

whatever capital

we have

totally good

way to be

anyways

yeah this

was fun

we'll do it

again

later guys

all right

see you

everyone

peace

thanks everyone

thank you

so

### Host

- [THORSwap ⚡ #BetterThanCEX](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/thorswap.md) di [THORSwap](https://alphagrowth.io/it/thorswap.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/THORSwap)

### Relatore

- [Chad Barraford](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/chad-barraford.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/CBarraford)
- [mogaᚱchy](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/mogarchy.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/mogarchy)
- [Olivier Leprohon](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/olivier-leprohon.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/ol3gpetrov)
- [k^coefficient | 0xVenturesDAO](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/rankinsj.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/RankinsJ)
- [paperX ⚡](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/paperx_art.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/paperX_Art)
- [Milton Bankman](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/universalmills.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/universalmills)
- [f(💩 Sn⁵⁰) = 🍟🧀🧉](https://alphagrowth.io/it/spaces/participant/f-sn50.md)
  [Profilo X](https://twitter.com/UUDDLRLRBASeSt)

## Vuoi più TVL per il tuo protocollo o la tua blockchain?

AlphaGrowth fa crescere il TVL di protocolli e blockchain attraverso l'acquisizione e l'integrazione di asset, grant, incentivi e accordi LP. Abbiamo costruito questi dati e li manteniamo gratuiti.

[Come aumentiamo il TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/it/defi/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo) [Parla con AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/it/contact-us/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo)
