Neutron Grants Program is Live 🚀

録音日: Nov 30, 2023 時間: 1:02:21

スペースの録音

元のスペースを開く
0:00 1:02:21

全文書き起こし

hey guys just uh getting set up now sending out some requests people to come up
hello hello who we got there is that is that amir yep amir here how you doing sir
doing good doing good how about you i'm good man good you're uh you're sort of my neck of the woods
are you you're uh asia uh yes right uh at midnight yeah yeah well you're even even like uh what an
hour ahead of me so yeah late one for us just bring in d in now looks like lamre's with us
hey guys
is david gonna make it
so i think he said yesterday he could let me just uh give him a ping and and see
i know it is quite late his time so
two
Yeah, David should be here
shortly as well
Yep
I see him now
Let's try and get him up
And I think we have David
Can you hear us, David?
Yeah, I can hear you guys
Perfect
Okay, cool
I think we've got everyone
Spade, you
Oh no, it looks like Spade dropped down as listener again
On my screen anyway
Spade, are you with us?
Nope
I think it seems like it might have a little bit of trouble getting Spade up
Hopefully
Just be one more minute
One more minute
And we'll get started
Hey, hey
Can you hear me now?
We hear you
Great
Yep, loud and clear
I just realized I had been speaking alone for like five minutes before then
Because like I showed up as a speaker on my screen
But apparently that wasn't the case for other versions of reality
So, oh well
Oh nice
That might have had something to do with me sending you a co-host invite
So let's just not do that
And hope the space doesn't die with no co-host
Crazy
Yeah, indeed
Indeed
He's got bigger fish to fry at the moment
You see all the thing about advertising and telling people to
Tell Disney to F off earlier today or something
Yeah, surely that was more important than shipping a decent product
Yeah, for sure
For sure
Anyway
It's not too bad
And hopefully it'll survive the course of this space
So fingers crossed
Let's get cracking
So yeah
Welcome everybody to another Neutron Spaces today
Today we're joined by the Neutron Grants team
Kind of feels like a long time ago
Since we laughed at the space of the Grants team
But yeah, it's now live and considering applications
So good to get you guys on
And we'll have a little chat about the Grants program
And what it's going to be doing
And all that kind of good stuff
Of course we've got Spade
Our co-founder from Neutron
Here today too as well
And at some point I'll be able to speak English
I'm sure
Anyway, just before we get going
A quick disclaimer
I need to let you know that
We may discuss the NTRN token
And that NTRN is not registered as a security in the US
And is therefore not available to US residents or citizens
And also nothing here today should be considered financial advice
It's just a discussion for educational purposes only
Okay, cool
So yeah, welcome guys
I think we'll basically start off with a brief round of intros
And then I'll get Lan Ray to take us through
And give us a bit of a refresher on the Grants program
Sort of how that all came to be
And we'll talk about RFPs, reporting and the application process
And open up to any questions at the end
So yeah, like I said, welcome guys
It's really, really cool to see the program won't be
Awesome, yeah
Thank you and thanks for taking the time
I'm kind of really excited to talk a bit about
The NTRN grants program
What we've done thus far
Give everyone a recap of what we're trying to do
And kind of encourage people to apply
Or just ask us questions
As, you know, at the end of the day
The program's here to serve the NTRN community
So I'll start with the intro
And then we can, I guess, go around to the other reviewers
So I'm Lan Ray, I've been working in the crypto space for a while
Currently leading the grants program
Which means that dealing with a lot of the operations
Of both the grants program and also the foundation
And then also kind of working alongside the other three reviewers
To review all the applications that come into the program
So yeah, really excited to be here today
Cool
And so who is the first reviewer to give their intro?
Amir?
Yeah, yeah, sure thing
Yeah, so role here is as a reviewer
And, you know, supporting Lan Ray
When it comes to reviewing the applications
Also has a small hand
When it comes to, like, setting up the operations as well
But yeah, super excited
On top of, you know, being part of this committee
Also work as a program lead in Longhash X
Which is the accelerator arm of Longhash Ventures
You know, one of the exciting things that we have going on right now
Is running the world's first atom economic zone accelerator
Of course, also alongside Neutron and AEDAO
So that's an exciting thing that I also do in my other life
So excited to, you know, be on the spaces and speak to you all
Busy man, busy man
Then we've got Effort Capital from Blockworks
When he's not saving Atom
He's reviewing grants for Neutron, aren't you?
Yeah, I mean, I couldn't have said the introduction better myself
Just like Amir
I'm a reviewer for Neutron Grants program
Full-time I'm working at Blockworks Research as a research analyst
And just a long-time Cosmos community member
So, I'm really happy to be here
What's your hot seat to Cold Throne for the day?
Ooh
I don't know
I'll put Jaquan on the hot seat, I guess
And the Adams
I guess the original Cosmos hub is on the Cold Throne
Starting the space with some spice, I like it
Okay
Yeah, indeed, try and follow that
We have David Park from Cosmos Station
Yeah, hey everyone, nice to meet you
My name is David
I'm one of the reviewers at NGP
And as a full-time job
I'm working on strategy at Cosmos Station
And yeah, really excited to be here
And finally get this rolling
Dude, I feel a bit self-conscious
Like with this spectacular panel here
Well, I was just about to say
Like quite the team that Landray's assembled here
So yeah, Landray
Just give us a bit of an overview
About what the program involves
And how you, you know
Work with the guys at your disposal here
Awesome, yeah, sure
And it really is a great team
And the goal was to try to find people
From across the Cosmos
And also in the Neutron community
That I think could best be in position
To judge what needed funding
Specifically to help grow Neutron
And kind of the wider Cosmos ecosystem
So kind of, yeah
It's been a great team
And it's been a great process thus far
Just to take a step back
And explain exactly for people
Who may not know what the grants program is
Essentially, the Neutron grant program
Is a DAO adjacent program for Neutron
To issue grants for Neutron-related
Technical research and development
And other initiatives
Which we judge to be beneficial
To the Neutron ecosystem
We carried out an on-chain proposal
Prop 14
Which allocated to the grant program
A sum of 20 million Neutron tokens
The vast split between 16 million
Within a grants fund
Which essentially is a sub-DAO
Of the Neutron main DAO
And 4 million for the operational fund
To deal with day-to-day operations
Of running the Neutron grants program
And its foundation
A Cayman's entity
Which we can talk about
Very briefly in a bit
But essentially we're set up
In a way to hold
The meatspace Cayman's entity
Accountable to the main DAO
At all time
In terms of, for example
The main DAO
And if you guys read the bylaws
Which are posted on the forum
Is able to remove the directors
Or the members of the reviewer team
If we're judging not to
We do no job appropriately
And we're really trying to hold ourselves
Accountable to the main DAO
In the highest possible way
And the goal is just ultimately
With the Neutron grants program
To fund different initiatives
Within Neutron
Which we think can grow the ecosystem
And this comes in
A lot of different ways
So our areas of focus
We set out
Six different things
Developer tooling and experience
Protocol development
User-based infrastructure
User-based applications
Joint funding
And research and education
And we have been
Putting a lot of thought
Or we had put a lot of thought
Into the grants program
For I think months
Before the prop
Even officially went on chain
We have sent
The prop officially passed
In early October
And then as of November
We've been officially accepting grants
And people can just go
To neutrongrants.com
And there's an application form
In the top right corner
Of that page
Which allows people
To easily apply
That application takes
About 10 minutes
And we're really excited
To give people grants
From as small as $1,000
To in theory
Up to $500,000
To help build
Things that fit
Within these various mandates
On Neutron
And kind of things
That help benefit Neutron
And we think this is
A really key way
To help grow the ecosystem
And grow the Neutron ecosystem
And kind of try to make it
The best, you know
Cosmos sub-consumer chain
We can make it
I don't know if there's anything else
That other reviewers
Want to add to that
Or anything I've missed out
Before we kind of go on to
Talking a bit more about specifics
I thought that was
Get over to you, Mon, right?
Yeah, yeah
And kind of
I think kind of
Then to dive into
A little bit more
About strategy
And I think maybe
How we kind of
Are trying to distinguish ourselves
Especially from our experience
Looking at how
Other grants programs have gone
People have fortunately
Been involved in quite a lot
Of this stuff
Even within the
Kind of review committee
Is one thing
I guess there's two parts
Two approaches
That grant programs
Take
It can be very kind of
Passive
And accept applications in
And fortunately
Even since we've opened
That application
A door
We've had a lot of
Really high quality
Applications
We've had about
30 applications
And we're in the process
Of reviewing them
With the goal of
Giving out the first batch
Of funding
Hopefully within the next
Few weeks
But one thing we've noticed
Is that we kind of
Especially want to be
As intentional as possible
With our grants
As opposed to giving out
You know
20, 30 small grants
Per month
To things
Which aren't necessarily
Going to add
A ton of value
To Neutron
And justify
The grant
That has been given
To us
By the main DAO
Or given to the
Grants by the main DAO
We're really focused
On working out
Exactly what are
The main tenets
Of what could be
Of different
Kind of applications
And different projects
Which could really
Add a lot of value
To Neutron
And so
In that line
We kind of came up
With the idea
Of what we call
Core RFPs
Which are visible
On our website
As a blog post
And then also visible
On the project page
Of our website
Also where
A bit more information
About each of these
Core RFPs
Is visible
And the idea
With Core RFPs
A request for proposal
Was essentially
To earmark
Largest sums of money
For people working
On specific things
We think can add
Significant value
To Neutron
And we're really
Trying to prioritize
These applications
And things that fit
With them
Under these RFPs
And are both
Actively searching out
Teams to build
These projects
And also projects
That fill this
Criteria
That apply to
The Neutron Grants
Program
Will also be
Prioritized
So I'll quickly
Touch on a few
Of the RFPs
There's a lot
Of writing
A lot of detail
On some of these
So I recommend
Anyone to
And this is something
I'll post a link
To the blog post
After this
Trader space
Is I recommend
Anyone to actually
Read the blog post
To get the full
Meet of the context
So I'm just
Going to give
An overview
So the six RFPs
Are as follows
So the first one
Is Neutron
As a sediment
Layer for RFPs
So sponsoring
Development
That makes Neutron
A more appealing
Stediment layer
For rollups
And the modular
Economy in general
Second is
Staked assets
Fixed rates
And other
Advanced vault
Strategies
So finding ways
To sponsor
The democratization
Of advanced
DeFi strategies
Which build
And connect to
Neutron as a
Settlement layer
For that
And also to
The wider
Interchain
The third
Is tooling
To improve
Neutron's
Governance
And governance
In general
We're very
Kind of interested
In finding ways
To improve
And further
The way
Neutron exists
As a governance
Entity
And kind of
The Neutron
Grant program
I think is an
Example of
Governance
Innovation
I think
To a degree
And we're
Looking for
Ways to
Help further
That
And further
Aims
Which I think
Can reverberate
For the rest
Of the cosmos
And then
The fourth
Would be
Stable coins
And synthetics
And derivatives
As we see
One of the
Biggest use cases
In DeFi
And crypto
Right now
Are things to do
With derivatives
Stable coins
And synthetics
It's one of
The first
Products
In crypto
Which I think
Have a strong
Product market
Fit
And there isn't
Enough of that
Within the cosmos
And also Neutron
Are directly
And we want to
Help incubate
Novel proposals
Which help
Bootstrap a
Neutron native
Ecosystem for
Those applications
And I think
There's a lot
More that we
Could do
There than
We currently
Have
And then
Fifth
To significantly
Improve the
Ease of
Developing
Cosmosm
Applications
On neutrons
So right
Now
Obviously
The cosmos
Ecosystem
Is great
And it
Continues
To grow
There's a lot
We can learn
From other
Ecosystems
For example
I think
The most
Popular
Ecosystem
For developing
App smart
Contracts
Is Solidity
And that
Ecosystem
Has a lot
Easier to
Use tooling
I think
Than the
Cosmosm
Applications
At least
In my
Point of
View
And there's
A lot
Of work
I think
We can
Do
There
To make
It
Easier
For
Both
New
And
Experienced
Developers
To quickly
And easily
Build safe
And reliable
Cosmosm
Applications
And we're
Looking forward
To funding
Initiatives
There
And the
Final thing
Is
Social apps
For users
In the
Interchain
I think
One thing
We've
Started to
See
Successfully
In some
Cases
And less
Successfully
In other
Cases
Is the
Rise of
Prominence
Of social
Applications
And other
Consumer
Applications
Within
Crypto
I think
Maybe
In 2021
2022
The main
Application
That exists
Was DeFi
And it's
Down to see
A new
Trend of
Social
And consumer
Applications
Which aren't
Necessarily
Overly
Financialized
And we
Really want
To promote
Those both
Within the
Cosmos
And specifically
Within Neutron
And we'll
Look to
Fund those
Actively
So I know
I've said a lot
But those are
The main
Six core
RFPs
In addition
We're very
Excited to
Find ways
To improve
Distribution
Of getting
Users involved
In Neutron
Generally
And those
Six RFPs
Are generally
Earmarked for
Some of the
Largest sums
You'll be
Willing to
Find in a
Given month
Within a
Given batch
But yeah
I've spoken
A lot
I know
Kind of
The other
Viewers
Are quite
Passionate
Or interested
In some
Of these
Particular
Core RFPs
If any of
You guys
Have anything
Else you
Want to
Add or
Spade
If you
Want to
Add anything
Else feel
Free to
And I'll
Just take a
Minute
I think
I think
One thing
To add
On top
Of the
Core RFPs
Of course
These are
Some of
The explicit
Areas that
We're interested
In
But we're
Also very
Much aware
Of
Other
Areas that
We could
Be supporting
With
We're
Open
Minded
To
Knowing
That
Some of
The
Folks here
Might be
Innovating
Some new
And interesting
Directions
That could be
Beneficial to
Neutron and
The cosmos
Ecosystem as
A whole
And we're
Totally supportive
Of those
Different
Narratives
Or those
Different
Applications
That we
Are yet
To see
Or uncover
So yeah
These are
Just some
Examples of
Things that
We'd be
Super bullish
On
Yeah just
To add
To that
I think
One thing
That we're
Doing is
We're
Obviously
We're taking
A focus
On those
Core RFPs
Obviously
We're also
Like accepting
General applications
But outside
Of just
Proactive
Grant
Applications
We're also
Heavily in
Favor of
The idea
Of retroactive
Grant
Funding
Too
Right
So I
Think
Optimism
Has done
A really
Good job
At this
A lot
Of other
Ecosystems
Have done
A good
Job
At this
But if
There's
That are
Building
Products
Or services
On Neutron
That find
Product market
That they
Bootstrapped
It themselves
But it
Becomes
Like a
Killer
Application
That bringing
In that new
Developers
And that new
Users into
Neutron
Like we
Are going
To like
Reach out
Outbound
And reach
Out to
Those teams
And obviously
Try to
Encourage them
To apply
For retroactive
Funding
Through Neutron
Because we
Think it's
Important to
Build that
Kind of
Culture
And obviously
We'll also
Accept inbound
Retroactive
Funding too
So I think
We're trying
To balance
Core RFP
General applications
From a
Proactive
Approach
But retroactive
As well
I think
That makes
A lot of
Sense
One thing
That I
Heard being
Mentioned
And which
I think
Is like
Exactly the
Right approach
But also
Something that's
Like very
Difficult to do
In practice
Is like
How do you
Evaluate
Applications
And teams
Right
Like what
Are
Sort of
Like the
Things that
You look
For
What are
Sort of
Like the
Green and
Red flags
That you
Sort of
Like built
Up a
Playbook for
So far
And yeah
Like can
You tell us
More about
Like all
Of this
Essentially
Yeah sure
Like as
Kind of
And great
Question
I think
Hopefully
This will
Kind of
Give
People
A lot
More
Context
In terms
Of
Like
How to
Design the
Best
Application
To stand
The best
Chance
And how
To make
The best
Project
To stand
The best
Chance
To give
Them funding
So for
Example
I'd take
A step
Back
And reviewers
Feel free
To chime
In if
Anything
I missed
But take
A step
Back
Our
Kind of
General
Mandate
Is we're
Trying
To fund
Initiatives
That can
Add tangible
Value
To Neutron
And we're
Willing to
Put a lot
Of money
Behind that
As opposed
To smaller
Ticket sizes
And the way
We go
About it
Is I can
Explain the
Application
Process
First
And then
Exactly
What we're
Looking at
So people
Can apply
By the
Application
Type
Form
Where
Ask
Various
Questions
About
The team
The project
Your team
Motivation
Your history
In cosmos
A breakdown
Of the
Milestone
Your
Current
Traction
Your
Fundraising
And the
Grant
Goals
And trying
To eke
Out exactly
What exactly
Is this
Grant
Trying to
Build
And what
Is its
Tangible
Benefit
To the
Neutral
Ecosystem
And we're
Very
Conscious
Of
Grantees
That are
Able
To
Disambiguate
This
And make
It very
Clear
Exactly
What the
Benefit
Is
Because
I think
That's
Something
It was
Important
For us
As we
Justify
Our
Operations
To
The
Main
Dial
And
Every
Single
Review
In a
Given
Application
As it
Comes
In
Via
Application
Form
And
Various
Amounts
Of
Different
Metrics
We
Allocate
Across
When someone
Reviews
The
Score
So we
Have
Team
Our
Team
Score
So team
Score
A cross
Chain
Score
Product
Score
A vertical
Score
Positioning
And
Traction
Where we
Rate
Quite
Highly
On
Both
Team
And
Product
Where
At
The
End
Of
The
Day
Can
Have
An
Extremely
Great
Idea
Extremely
Ambitious
Idea
Game
Changing
But
The
Ability
Of
The
Team
To
Actually
Execute
On
That
I
Think
Is
A
Major
Determinant
In
The
Chance
Of
This
Grant
Being
A
Success
And
So
Kind
Of
Very
Much
Like
To
Understand
What
Is
The
Team
Motivations
How
Can
They
Justify
The
Skills
To
Build
Whatever
Grant
This
Is
So
They
Trying
To
Build
A
Stable
Coin
Synthetrics
They
Trying
To
Build
A
Synthetrics
Another
Part of
The
Team
Is
To
Work
Out
Especially
I
Think
One
Thing
That's
Quite
Common
In
Other
Grants
Programs
Is
There
A lot
Of
Teams
That
May
Apply
Opportunistically
To
Different
Grants
Programs
Despite
Having
Very
Little
Allegiance
To
A
Given
Ecosystem
And
That
Is
Something
We
Try
To
Work
Up
With
The
Team
Motivation
And
Then
Moving
On
As
I
Said
Both
The
Product
Vertical
And
Position
School
Or
Relate
To
How
This
Given
Product
Or
Application
Or
Research
Project
Or
Whatever
Works
And
How
Can
We
Judge
How
Useful
And
Viable
That
Product
Is
And
Also
I
Think
One
Thing
Is
Important
Can
Have
A
Good
Product
But
It
Is
Very
Competitive
Space
Or
In
A
Space
Where
There's
A
Bunch
Of
Different
Leaders
It
May
Harder
For
That
Product
To
Find
Strong
Product
Market
Or
Maybe
Harder
For
That
Research
Initiative
To
Find
A
Strong
To
Have
A
Tangible
Impact
If
There
Are
A
Ton
Of
Other
Really
Good
Projects
There
So
We
Both
Try
To
How
Good
The
Application
Is
Objectively
And
How
Good
The
Application
Is
Relative
To
Its
Wider
Position
And
How
Valuable
The
Vertical
Is
Because
Not
Every
Single
Vertical
That
Fund
Is
Necessarily
As
Beneficial
To
The
Neutral
Ecosystem
And
Then
I
Think
The
Final
Bucket
Would
Be
Traction
And
Funding
So
Traction
Is
Measures
How
Much
Traction
Does
This
Team
Have
For
The
Thing
They
Trying
To
Build
We
Do
As
In
This
Isn't
Always
The
Case
But
I
Think
It
Is
A
Good
Sign
Where
The
Team
Have
To
Make
Some
Effort
To
Begin
Development
Of
Whatever
It
Shows
That
That
May
Be
Something
They
Still
Continue
And
Then
Secondly
Funding
Is
I
Think
One
Approach
This
Is
Something
We
Talked
About
Internally
And
After
This
I
Would
Love
To
Hear
The
Review
Team
Is
Like
The
Ideal
Goal
Is
I
Think
That
Public
Goods
Which
Aren't
Necessarily
Always
May
Have
To
Rely
On
Some
Kind
Of
Public
Good
Fund
Or
Grants
Funding
But
To
The
Extent
That
We
Can
Fund
A
Project
Which
Can
Then
Stand
On
Its
Own
Two
Legs
And
Find
A
Way
To
Sustainability
Outside
Of
Funding
From
The
Grants
Program
We
Think
That's
Also
Pretty
Cool
Right
As
In
Because
The
Grants
Program
Has
A
Mandate
For
The
First
Year
Kind
Of
Subsequent
Years
Who
Knows
Exactly
What
Happened
A
Lot
Of
It
Be
Based
Feedback
From
The
Community
And
We
Want
To
Fund
Projects
That
We
Think
Even
Regardless
Of
Whether
The
Nutrient
Ground
Program
Can
Fund
Them
Next
Year
The
Year
After
They
Are
Able
To
Sustainably
Still
Add
Value
To
Metron
And
Both
The
Traction
And
The
Fund
Funding
Elements
Of
Our
Review
Process
Are
Great
Way
To
Ascertain
That
And
This
Is
An
Initial
Review
We
Conduct
Further
Due
Diligence
Especially
If a
Project
Is
More
Technical
Undergo
Interviews
With
The
Team
And
Those
All
Help
Us
Work
Out
These
Aspects
Of
Whether
This
Product
Makes
Sense
And
Whether
It's
Worth
Funding
Exactly
How
Much
Makes
Sense
And
Obviously
That's
Where
It
To
The
Marlstone
And
Also
How
Much
Funding
Should
Be
Received
And
How
That
Funding
Should
Be
Received
Across
Different
Milestones
But
I'm
Sure
I'm
Missing
Something
So
David
Effett
Feel
Free
To
Add
Anything
If
Want
The
Only
Major
Thing
I
Want
To
Bring
Up
Is
How
I
Personally
I
Think
We
As a
Team
Are
Looking
At
Teams
Is
We're
Not
For
Neutron
Ecosystem
We're
Not
Trying
To
Said
Already
Obviously
There's
Certain
Verticals
That
Are
Incredibly
Competitive
And
If
You're
Building
A
Dex
If
You're
Building
A
Lending
Market
If
You're
Building
Something
That
Other
Ecosystems
Have
Had
Have
To
Have
Really
Good
Historical
Context
To
Know
What
Has
And
Has
Not
Worked
In
That
Vertical
And
Why
Your
Product
Is
Different
And
What
Is
That
Secret
Sauce
That
Make
Your
10x
Better
Than
The
Unisops
Of
The
World
As
An
Example
Right
So
It's
Okay
We're
Obviously
Accepting
Applications
For
Some
Of
DeFi
Primitives
That
You've
Seen
Throughout
The
Cosmos
And
Other
Ecosystems
But
There
Needs
To
Be
That
Secret
Sauce
And
Need
To
Have
Really
Good
Historical
Context
And
Good
Understanding
What
Makes
Your
I
Guess
Another
Way
To
Look
At
It
Is
And
This
Is
Actually
Me
In
An
Attempt
To
Rehash
Whatever
What
Effet
Mentioned
Earlier
It's
We're
Also
Looking
For
Peaks
And
We
Do
Have
Like
A
Metric
That
Know
Categorizes
Or
Tries
To
Quantify
Those
Different
Metrics
The
Team
Product
Vertical
Etc
But
Of
Course
Know
We
Try
To
Give
The
Benefit
Of
The
Doubt
Whenever
There's
A
Peak
In
Any
Of
These
Certain
Areas
Aka
If
It's
Like
An
Outstanding
Team
But
From
An
Application
From
The
Application
Form
We
Don't
Quite
Understand
How
The
Products
Differentiate
It
From
Its
Potential
Competitors
We
Usually
Will
Try
To
Get
More
Information
Either
Via
Call
But
That's
Also
One
Thing
We
Look
Out
For
Peaks
To
Convince
Ourselves
That
There's
Some
Potential
Here
Yeah
And
Just
I guess
I had
One
More
Thing
Is
When
We
Are
And
Again
It's
Not
Specific
To
Any
Given
Application
But
If
The
Team
Is
Asking
For
A
Certain
Larger
Sum
Of
Money
I
Think
One
Thing
We're
Going
To
Be
Interested
In
Doing
Is
We're
Very
Pro
Milestone
Based
Payments
And
Also
Working
With
The
Team
To
Develop
KPIs
That
We
Think
Are
Going
To
Important
For
That
Specific
Vertical
That
Specific
Product
So
Let's
Say
Dex
Dex
As
An
Example
Just
Because
It's
The
Easiest
Like
We're
Going
To
We
Might
Not
Be
Willing
To
Fund
Everything
Up
Front
It
Has
To
To
Milestone
Based
But
In
To
Hit
Those
Key
Milestones
Toward
The
End
Of
The
Roadmap
We're
Going
To
Try
To
Work
With
The
Team
To
Figure
Out
What
Are
Those
Key
Metrics
That
Should
Be
Looking
At
So
For
Dex
Should
It
Be
Turnover
Like
The
Amount
Of
Volume
Per
TVL
For
Example
Like
TVL
Itself
Is
Mostly
About
Any
Metric
So
That's
Not
Necessarily
The
Right
Metric
We
We're
Trying
To
Retroactive
Funding
Milestone
Based
It's
Specific
To
Certain
KPIs
That
We
Feel
Is
How
We
Know
Whether
Or
Not
We're
Doing
A
Good
Job
On
Behalf
Of
The
Neutron
Community
Just
To
Add
To
That
I
Think
One
Of
The
Vertical
Specific
Metrics
Could
Be
Something
Like
Cross
Chain
Activity
Which
Is
Something
That
We're
Also
Looking
Into
As
One
Of
The
Categories
In
Our
Evaluation
Matrix
Anything
That
Brings
More
Cross
Chain
Activity
Towards
Neutron
And
Puts
Neutron
At
The
Center
Piece
Would
Be
Something
That
Would
Be
Beneficial
To
The
Neutron
Grants
Program
Yeah
All of
These
Are
Really
Great
Point
Actually
It's
Awesome
To
See
That
Like
I
Mean
As
You've
Said
You've
Been
Putting
A
Lot
Of
Work
Behind
The
Scenes
For
Month
Now
But
Still
It's
Very
Early
In
The
Program
Like
Thought
Long
And
Hard
About
These
Things
So
Like
It
Makes
Me
Extremely
Bullish
About
The
NGP
In
General
I
Think
Like
One
Of
The
Points
Guys
All
Sort
Of
Like
Milestoning
Right
I
Think
That's
Also
Complex
Science
In
General
Like
What's
Your
Approach
To
Milestoning
How
Do
Break
Up
Funding
And
Deliverables
And
Such
Yeah
I
Mean
It's
A
Good
Question
And
I
Straight
Answer
To
It
Because
As
Said
It
Is
Complex
In
Terms
Of
We
Really
Treat
It
Like
Take
A
Step
Back
So
When
Any
Applicant
Applies
They
Do
Submit
Their
View
On
What
The
Potential
Milestone
Could
Be
20%
Up
Front
30%
Upon
A
Certain
KPI
And
50%
At
The
End
And
We
Take
That
Into
View
Because
Generally
Especially
For
And
Take
Them
At
Their
Word
And
Then
Past
That
Point
It
Really
Is
An
Iterative
Process
Of
Working
Out
Firstly
What
Exactly
Do
These
People
Need
The
Funded
For
If
A lot
Of
It
Is
Just
Upfront
Cost
Which
Can't
Be
Avoided
So
They
Need
To
Hire
Some
People
To
Do
This
Audit
And
They
Need
To
Pay
X
Amount
Of
Money
Up
Front
That
May
Skew
A
Certain
Of
Payment
If
We
Want
To
Allocate
A
Significant
Part
Of
The
Grant
To
Certain
KPIs
Such
As
We
Think
This
Adds
A
Lot
Of
Value
To
Neutron
If
It
Hits
X
Y
Z
Metrics
X
Amount
Of
TVL
Or
X
Amount
Of
Volume
That
Is
Something
We
Can
Also
Ascribe
To
Payments
And
We
Are
Generally
Just
A
Big
Fan
Of
Okay
Like
I
Think
It
Generally
Makes
Sense
Especially
For
Some
More
Ambitious
Grants
To
Give
A
Third
Man
Up
Front
Just
To
Hold
People
Accountable
And
Especially
Obviously
Grant
Based
Funding
Is
Milestone
And
I
Think
Is
The
Main
Way
To
Hold
People
Accountable
As
Opposed
To
Some
Other
Kind
Of
XG
Based
Fund
Or
Debt
Based
Funding
Milestone
Payments
Are
The
Key
Way
And
Payments
Further
Than
That
I
Think
Should
Be
Tied
To
Very
Discreet
And
Obvious
And
Easy
To
Track
Milestones
In
A
Project
History
So
Main
Net
Deployment
And
Then
Specifically
Big
KPIs
And
So
We
Give
Them
Enough
Funding
To
Get
Set
Up
And
Then
Past
That
What
Is
The
Tangible
Value
Can
Show
Us
After
The
Initial
Payment
But
It's
A
Communicative
Process
We
Love
To
Applicants
Think
About
Prospective
Milestones
And
How
They
Think
About
Why
They
Should
Get
Funded
X
Amount
At
These
Various
Points
And
Then
We
Go
Back
And
Work
On
That
By
Ourselves
And
Hopefully
By
The
End
Of
The
Process
Especially
If
We're
Willing
To
Fund
Someone
We
Can
Work
Out
What
Kind
Of
Milestone
Based
Approach
Makes
Sense
But
Yeah
We
Just
Understand
That
It
Is
The
Best
Way
To
Hold
People
Accountable
I
Don't
Know
If
Anyone
Else
Was
To
Add
Anything
On
This
Awesome
Cool
Yeah
Thank
For
That
Avril
We
Have
Community
Questions
At
The
End
But
So
At
This
Point
This
May
Be
A
Good
Time
To
Move
On
To
Just
A
General
Update
About
What's
Happened
So
Far
With
The
Grants
Program
So
I'll
Keep
This
High
Level
And
We
Do
Publish
A lot
Of
Content
On
Our
Website
Which
Gives
People
We
Will
Continue
To
Especially
After
The
First
Batch
Is
Produce
A
Lot
Of
Content
To
Give
People
An
Overview
Of
What
Exactly
We're
Doing
So
As
I
Mentioned
We
Received
The
Grant
Program
The
Grant
Foundation
Was
Officially
Live
As
Of
Early
October
And
We
Started
Accepting
Grants
About
A
Month
After
That
In
Early
November
And
Right
Now
We've
Received
About
30
Grants
And
Conversations
With
Other
Teams
Who
Potentially
Could
Apply
For
Grants
And
This
Is
Initial
Review
Of
These
Initial
Batch
Of
Grants
Within
The
Next
Week
Or
Two
Which
Will
Allow
Us
To
Make
A
Decision
On
The
First
Batch
Probably
By
Mid
December
And
I
Add
Caveats
That
All
Of
These
Are
Potentially
And
Hopefully
Because
There
Could
Be
Delays
For
Various
Operational
And
Legal
Reasons
And
So
That
Is
A
Big
Part
Of
Our
Focus
Right
Now
On
Getting
Getting
This
To
Prospect
Applicants
For
Taking
The
Time
To
Do
This
Concurrently
There's
Been
A
Lot
Of
Operational
Work
Done
In
The
Background
Since
October
Such
As
Setting
Up
The
Grants
Foundation
Ensuring
That
We
Have
Our
Finances
On
Check
To
Handle
All
The
Operations
For
Legal
Fees
Operational
Fees
Software
And
The
Like
And
Also
Have
The
Legal
Set
Up
To
Give
People
Grants
In
A
Legally
Compliant
And
Safe
Way
And
That
Is
Something
That
We
Have
On
The
Back
Burners
And
One
Big
Initiative
I
Think
We're
Trying
To
Aim
For
Especially
With
The
Grant
Programs
Is
Several
So
In
Our
Initial
Governance
Post
We
Had
Indicators
That
We
Give
Up
Quarterly
Financial
And
Operational
Reports
On
The
Operations
Of
The
Grant
Program
We're
Going
To
Do
This
Every
Month
So
We've
Already
Given
Posted
The
Operational
Finance
Update
For
October
Which
Goes
Over
The
Four
Operations
And
The
Four
Update
And
Operations
And
All
The
Financial
Transactions
Carried
Out
By
The
Grants
Program
In
The
Month
Of
October
We'll
Shortly
Also
Have
One
For
November
And
Every
Single
Month
Following
We'll
Have
The
Same
Along
Along
A
Longer
Bi-annual
Report
Which
Go
Into
A
Bit
More
Detail
About
These
Things
At
The
Same
Time
Obviously
All
Our
On
Chain
Wallets
Where
All
Our
Activity
Is
Handled
By
Will
Also
Allow
People
To
Very
Easily
View
Exactly
All
The
Transactions
But
The
Monthly
Reports
Will
Add
More
Context
And
Help
People
Make
Sense
Of
What
The
Outflows
Into
Our
Wallet
And
To
The
Grant
Program
Are
In
Addition
Hopefully
Quite
Soon
We
Will
Have
A
Live
Dashboard
On
Our
Website
It's
Currently
Work
In
Which
Will
Give
People
A
Real
Time
Update
About
All
The
Things
That
Was
Talked
About
So
The
Amount
Of
Applications
Reviewed
How
Many
Are
Approved
How
Many
Funded
A
Context
For
Every
Transaction
Which
Goes
In
And
Out
Of
Each
Of
Our
Wallets
And
Also
Details
About
All
The
Applications
With
Either
Reviewed
Rejected
Accepted
And
Funded
So
The
Idea
Is
Even
Before
A
Monthly
Report
Before
The
Bi-Annual
Report
Anyone
In
The
Community
Will
Be
A
Full
And
Transparent
Understanding
Of
What
The
Operation
Of
Neutral
Grant
Program
Is
Because
I
Think
A
Big
Element
Of
The
Genesis
Of
The
Program
Is
To
Really
Promote
Transparency
And
Communication
And
This
Is
Why
For
Example
Anytime
We
Want
To
Approve
A
Back
To
Transactions
For
Grant
Given
The
Main
Dile
Will
To
Veto
Any
Of
Transactions
They
Disagree
With
And
The
Best
Way
To
Hold
Us
Accountable
Is
To
Why
Did
These
Guys
To
Fund
This
Grant
And
Why
Did
This
Money
Leave
The
Wallet
In
This
Month
So
We
Try
To
As
Much
Transparency
And
Context
About
All
Our
Operations
As
Possible
It's
Still
A
Work
In
Progress
And
We're
Trying
To
Find
Ways
To
Constantly
Improve
Transparency
And
Communications
Around
Operations
But
I
Think
We're
Off
To
A
Decent
Start
And
I
Look
To
Share
The
November
Update
After
The
End
Of
The
Month
And
Also
The
Dashboard
Which
Should
Give
A
Bit
More
Live
Context
But
For
People
That
Have
Already
Applied
Stay
Tuned
And
Hopefully
We'll
Get
Back
To
Everyone
About
Next
Steps
We're
Applicable
And
To
Give
Out
The
First
Batch
Of
Grant
Funding
Sometime
In
The
Next
Few
Weeks
Cool
Mentioned
Earlier
On
That
Said
I
Think
Something
Like
30
Applications
So
Far
I
Was
Just
Wondering
What
Are
Those
Applications
Sort
Of
Generally
Looking
Like
What
Kind
Of
Categories
Are
They
Falling
Into
Are
They
Sort
Of
Matching
With
DRFPs
Like
How
Is
It
All
Looking
In
The
Early
Stages
Yes
So
This
Will
Be
Easier
To
Answer
Once
We
Have
Our
Dashboard
But
We
Do
Have
Some
Internal
Tooling
Which
Is
A
Messy
Hence
Why
We
Aren't
Sharing
It
I
I
Can
The
Clean
Up
But
Yeah
So
It
Eight
For
Developer
Tooling
Two
For
Research
And
Four
For
Infrastructure
And
One
Protocol
Development
And
One
That
Fists
Into
That
Other
Category
So
Relatively
Evenly
Split
I
Guess
For
There
Are
A lot
Of
Things
Around
User
Facing
Application
Developer
Tooling
I
Think
That
Makes
Sense
Especially
Given
Three
Out
Of
The
Six
Core
RFPs
Are
Actually
For
Applications
Because
I
Think
One
Thing
We
Are
Very
Keen
On
Is
Interest
Into
Neutral
Of
The
Cosmos
So
Yeah
As
In
That
Is
Where
The
Main
Gist
Of
The
Focus
Is
We
Imagine
This
Would
Change
Especially
In
The
Coming
Months
I
Think
Certain
Sectors
Maybe
Such
As
Protocol
Development
Or
Research
These
May
Require
A
Bit
More
Time
Before
The
Application
Would
Make
Sense
So
We
Can
Anticipate
Maybe
Those
Applications
Will
Come
After
The
First
Few
Month
But
Yeah
That
Is
The
Breakdown
If
That
Answers
Your
Question
Yeah
Yeah
It
Definitely
Does
Like
I said
It's
Just
I
Know
Said
All
The
Reporting
Is
Coming
Out
Soon
On
The
Dashboards
But
Just
Yeah
I
Just
Wondered
If
There
Was
Any
Insight
As
To
Maybe
Any
Particular
Projects
That
Are
Getting
Excited
Or
Anything
Like
That
So
Far
Yeah
I
I
Hold
Off
On
Commenting
On
The
Specific
Grants
Before
We
Give
Out
Any
Of
The
Initial
Batch
Funding
I
Think
One
Thing
I
Will
Say
Is
That
Yeah
There
Are
A lot
Of
Really
Great
Projects
That
Have
Applied
One
Thing
Is
Prioritizing
And
Working
Out
Which
Projects
Make
Sense
To
Fund
In
The
First
Batch
First
Ladder
Batch
And
What
Short
Term
Longer
Term
Priorities
Are
For
Neutron
But
One
Thing
I
Will
Say
There
Are
A lot
We
Always
Knew
There
Would
Have
To
A
Outreach
To
Get
The
Highest
Quality
Projects
To
Build
Neutron
But
We
Been
Happy
With
The
Projects
That
Have
Applied
So
Stay
Tuned
When
We
Have
A
Bit
More
Information
About
The
Projects
We
Want
To
Fund
For
Batch
One
So
We'll
Have
A
Bit
More
Information
On
Our
General
Theses
Of
Three
Or
Four
Projects
Or
Whatever
That
Number
Is
That
We
Want
To
Fund
For
Batch
One
Before
That
Goes
Live
Onto
Agora
I'll
Hold
Up
On
On
Specific
On
Just
To
To
Prevent
Any
Biases
Yeah
Yeah
When
Do
Think
We'll
Start
To
See
The
First
Neutron
Grants
Funded
Applications
On
Neutron
When
Will
We
See
It
With
Our
Eyes
Yeah
So
This
Is
A
Good
Question
We
Want
To
Fund
Things
That
Can
Like
It's
A
Mix
Of
Things
If
A
Project
Takes
A
Bit
Long
To
Develop
And
Build
On
Neutron
That
Doesn't
Me
We're
Not
Going
To
Fund
It
But
We're
Also
Very
Keen
On
Projects
Which
Have
Reasonable
Timelines
And
We
Can
See
Them
At
Tangible
Impact
To
Neutron
In
The
Short
Term
And
One
Thing
I
Will
Say
There
Are
A lot
Of
Really
Interesting
Projects
That
We
Could
Fund
Even
In
This
First
Batch
But
I
Think
Could
Make
Their
Deployments
Or
Launch
Whatever
They're
Trying
To
Launch
In
Neutron
We
Would
Love
A
Few
Synthetics
Platforms
To
Launch
Neutron
Before
The
End
Of
The
Year
That's
The
Reason
We're
Trying
To
Experdite
Applications
Which
We
Think
Are
Short
Term
Priorities
And
Hopefully
Soon
After
The
Funding
We
Will
Be
A
Some
Of
Funded
Projects
Will
Be
Launch
Neutron
And
The
Cool
Thing
As
We
Said
A
Lot
Of
These
Projects
It's
Not
Like
They're
Only
Contingent
On
Them
Receiving
Funding
For
The
Grants
Program
Fortunately
A lot
Of
Teams
Are
Really
Building
Already
And
Just
Want
To
Launch
And
If
They
Get
Funded
That's
Great
And
We
Also
Are
Very
Much
A
Big
Fan
Of
Projects
That
Have
Traction
Or
Have
A
Roadmap
To
Launch
And
If
They
Just
Have
To
Get
Funded
That
May
Expedite
That
Help
That
But
That
Isn't
A
Necessary
Factor
Yeah
I
Think
That
All
Sort
Makes
Sense
One
Thing
I
Wanted
To
Ask
Spade
Earlier
On
Actually
Was
Like
What
Do
Think
About
The
RFPs
That
We
Talked
About
Before
From
The
Top
Of
My
Head
I
Think
There
Was
There
Was
Anything
That
Particularly
Stands
Out
To
From
An
Outside
The
Grants
Program
Perspective
On
What
Would
Like
To
See
Being
Funded
And
Focused
On
Mean
Like
If
I
Had
To
Add
RFPs
So
If
We
Go
Through
The
Six
RFPs
Now
I
Mean
I
Will
Just
Recap
Them
I
Got
In
Front
Me
Here
So
We
Staked
Assets
Fixed
Rates
And
Other
Advanced
Vault
Strategies
Tooling
To
Improve
Neutron
Governance
Stable
Coin
Synthetics
Derivatives
And
Other
Similar
Applications
Significantly
Improving
The
Ease
Of
Cosmosm
Applications
On
Neutron
And
Social
Apps
For
Uses
In
The
Interchain
So
If
Had
To
Emphasize
One
Category
That
Would
Like
To
See
Funded
And
For
Us
To
Receive
Applications
For
What
Would
Of
These
Sticks
I
Think
Probably
The
One
That
Makes
The
Most
Short
Midterm
Sort
Like
Difference
On
The
Platform
Is
Probably
The
Stable
Coin
Synthetics
Derivatives
And
Other
Similar
Applications
Because
It's
Really
Something
That's
Like
Sorely
Needed
In
Order
To
Kickstart
DeFi
Activity
And
Bring
It
To
The
Next
Level
On
The
Chain
So
That's
One
That
I'll
Be
Definitely
Keeping
An
Eye
On
I
Do
Think
That
The
The
RFPs
Are
Actually
Quite
Well
Balanced
I
Think
Obviously
They're
Probably
Also
Living
Documents
That
Will
Continue
To
Be
Refined
Over
Time
I
Think
Personally
I've
Been
Trying
To
Think
About
This
More
And
More
I
Know
Other
Contributors
Like
Elijah
For
Example
Are
Also
Very
So
Like
Mentally
Keen
On
Thinking
About
What
Should
Be
The
Best
Strategies
And
The
Are
Of
Focus
And
But
I
Do
Think
They're
Pretty
Balanced
Because
There's
A
Number
Of
Things
Here
That
Like
Directly
Target
The
Development
Of
The
Chain
Like
Of
The
Chain
Ecosystem
Sorry
There's
A few
That
Are
More
Like
Other
Areas
That
The
Network
Should
Position
Itself
For
In
The
Future
Like
Thinking
Mainly
About
Like
Neutron
As a
Selma
Layer
For
Rollup
I
Think
This
One
Is
It's
An
Incredible
Opportunity
But
At
The
Same
Time
It's
Also
Very
Risky
Bet
And
So
Like
Betting
The
Entire
Family
Farm
On
Neutron
Being
A
Very
Appealing
Settlement
Layer
For
Rollups
Could
Be
Something
That's
Risky
If
The
Entire
Contributor
Base
Of
The
Chain
Was
Solly
Focused
On
This
At
Such
An
Early
Stage
And
So
Finding
Projects
That
Have
This
Mentality
Already
And
I'm
Thinking
About
Projects
Shogun
Like
Shogun
Is
A
Cow
Matching
And
Interchain
Aggregating
And
Router
And
Liquidity
Router
Protocol
Which
Is
Launching
Know
Like
Interchain
Routing
On
Neutron
As
Smart
Contracts
As
Well
As
A
Sovereign
ZK
Rollup
That
Settles
On
Neutron
And
Uses
Celestia
For
DA
I
Think
That
Kind
Of
Project
Is
Super
Interesting
Because
It's
Sort
Of
Demonstrating
And
Building
Up
Both
The
DeFi
ZK
Aggregations
And
Such
I
Think
There
Might
Be
Very
Interesting
Bridging
Technologies
On
The
Fundamental
Contribution
Thing
I
Think
This
RFP
Can
Also
Be
Resolved
With
Things
Like
Hey
Is
There
A
Team
Out
There
That
Wants
To
Contribute
Upstream
To
Rollkit
To
Enable
People
To
Use
This
Framework
To
Build
Their
Rollups
But
Also
Have
The
Ability
To
Easily
Have
Their
Rollkit
Rollups
Settle
To
I
Think
This
Would
Be
Like
A
Very
Sort
Like
Massive
Like
A
Fairly
Meaningful
Undertaking
But
Something
That
Would
Definitely
Move
The
Needle
For
The
Ecosystem
At
Large
And
Then
There
Is
Also
More
Long
Term
Targets
Here
Whereby
Improving
The
Ease
Of
Developing
Cosmosom
Applications
Is
Obviously
Super
Important
For
Nuchant
To
Become
The
Best
Possible
Place
For
Builders
To
Be
But
It
It
Is
More
Long
Term
Thing
I
Think
Because
There
There's
Definitely
Going
To
Be
Iterations
On
The
Devacks
And
The
Tools
That
Are
Being
Used
I
Think
There's
A bunch
Of
Contributors
In
The
Ecosystem
Like
Confio
That
Are
Also
Working
Very
Actively
On
This
Which
I'm
Super
Excited
About
And
Yeah
I
See
I
Don't
Know
Who
Added
This
One
But
I
Think
It's
A
Great
Idea
Like
The
Social
Apps
For
Users
In
The
Interchain
Is
Kind
Of
Like
This
Like
This
One
Is
Probably
The
Most
Spicy
RFP
In
My
opinion
Because
It's
Kind
Of
Like
There
Has
Been
Tremendous
Success
There
But
It's
Also
Something
That
I
Think
The
Industry
Hasn't
Figured
Out
How
To
Make
Sustainable
And
So
I'm
Very
Curious
To
See
What
Kind
Of
Traction
This
RFP
Is
Going
To
Get
Because
Ecosystem
As
A Whole
Essentially
Right
So
Like
This
One
Feels
Like
A
Bit
Of
A
Gamble
For
Me
Not
In
Terms
Of
Like
Having
The
RFP
But
In
Terms
Of
Like
What
You'll
Get
As
A
Submission
But
I
Think
It's
Going
To
Be
Super
Interesting
Basically
So
Yeah
I
Think
This
Is
The
First
Time
That
The
NGP
Publishes
RFPs
I
Do
Think
They're
Already
Very
Polished
I
Do
Think
That
They'll
Evolve
Over
Time
But
I
Think
It's
Up
To
A
Strong
Start
Just
To
Add
My
Personal
Take
Obviously
I'm
Objective
I'm
Excited
About
Any
Kind
Of
Application
That
Comes
To
NGP
And
I
Think
That
Can
Add
Value
To
The
Neutron
Ecosystem
But
Just
To
Double
Down
On
What
Spade
Said
Personally
I
Think
The
Atom
Economic
Zone
Neutron
Specifically
Needs
It's
Own
Stable
Coin
There's
Obviously
Multiple
Stable
Coins
Out
There
In
The
Cosmos
Ecosystem
And
I'm
Nothing
Against
Them
But
I
Think
The
AEZ
Needs
It's
Own
Stable
Coin
So
I
Think
That's
To
Me
Clear
We
Need
That
But
We
Need
A
Strong
Team
To
Build
The
Best
Stable
Coin
In
Cosmos
Ecosystem
On
Neutron
Second
Going
Back
To
That
Does
This
Whole
Thing
But
I
Would
Love
A
Team
That
Will
Be
Able
To
Integrate
A
Decentralized
Stable
Coin
Into
A
Social
FI
Application
That
Also
Leads
To
Real
World
Payments
To
Me
Those
Three
Things
Combined
Decentralized
Stable
Coin
Plus
Social
FI
Plus
Real
World
Payments
That
Is
Going
To
Be
The
Thing
That
Find
The
Most
Product
Market
FIT
Stable
Coins
Have
Obviously
Found
Most
Product
Market
Fit
Crypto
Social
FI
I
Think
Is
A
Gamble
But
I
Think
It's
The
Right
Like
That's
Probably
The
Next
Like
100x
Thousand
Next
Opportunity
In
Crypto
Whoever
Can
Figure
Out
Like
The
Right
Yeah
I
Guess
Like
Whatever
The
Right
Like
Product
Is
Or
Know
Specific
Use
Case
But
Something
Like
That
So
Kind
Of
A
Call
To
Arms
For
Me
Personally
Right
Now
Anyone
Listening
That
Wants
To
Build
A
Decentralized
Fable
Coin
And
Also
Work
With
Another
Team
That
Wants
To
Build
Like
A
Social
FI
Like
Application
That
Has
Like
Real
World
Micro
Payments
Built
In
That
I
Think
Could
Make
Neutron
Like
Put
Neutron
On
The
Map
As
Like
The
Layer
One
In
All
Of
Cosmos
And
That
Sounds
Like
A
Lofty
Goal
But
I
Think
Like
Something
Like
That
Integrated
With
Those
Different
Applications
Could
Really
Bring
In
The
Next
Billion
Users
On
Champ
Yeah
I
Really
Couldn't
Agree
More
To
Be
Fair
On
The
Stable
Coin
Bit
Especially
Like
I
Think
Not
Only
The
AZ
Needs
Its
Own
Stable
Coin
I
Think
We're
Also
Like
As
An
Ecotism
We
Might
Be
A
Bit
Traumatized
By
The
UST
Thing
But
As
A
Result
Of
That
We've
Lost
The
Plot
On
Centralized
Table
Coins
They're
Very
Convenient
They're
Great
For
Building
Liquidity
Up
They
Have
Good
UX
But
They're
Still
Centralized
Table
Coins
If
We
Achieve
Everything
But
This
In
10
Years
We'll
Still
Have
Decentralizing
Finance
So
Couldn't
Agree
More
On
This
Point
With
Regards
To
The
AZ
Bit
And
This
Is
Not
Necessarily
Related
To
Neutron
Grants
But
I'd
Love
To
Have
Guys
Opinion
On
This
But
One
Thing
I've
Noticed
In
The
Time
I've
Been
Working
On
Neutron
Is
Due
To
The
Hubs
Decentralization
Which
Is
Great
There
Is
No
Easy
Counter
Party
To
Go
Towards
And
Get
Things
Moving
Right
And
I
Think
In
General
This
Is
A
Great
Thing
But
It
Has
Made
One
Thing
That
For
The
Health
Of
The
Neutron
As
Well
Which
Is
Really
Making
Atom
A
Base
Bear
On
The
Ecosystem
And
So
One
Thing
That
I've
Been
Thinking
About
Is
Shouldn't
There
Be
Some
Kind
Of
A
Facility
Somewhere
Either
Built
On
Neutron
With
Some
Contracts
And
Stuff
Maybe
It
Could
Be
A
Borg
Of
The
Hub
Shouldn't
There
Be
Somewhere
A
Facility
That
Allows
New
Projects
That
Are
Launching
Like
This
To
Easily
Access
Small
Amounts
Of
Credit
Or
Protocol
Owned
Liquidity
Depending
On
How
Want
To
Frame
It
To
Bootstrap
Their
Own
Tokens
And
Protocols
E.G.
I
I'm
A
Dapp
I'm
Launching
Whatever
DeFi
Protocol
Maybe
There's
Some
Basic
Due
Diligence
To
Make
Sure
That
I'm
Not
Going
To
Rug
There's
Not
An
Embedded
Exploit
Or
Something
There
Should
Be
Some
Criterias
Like
It
Needs
To
Be
Audited
And
Such
But
Still
With
Reasonable
Amounts
Of
Efforts
It
Shouldn't
Be
A
30
Month
Process
But
With
Reasonable
Efforts
I'm
Able
To
Get
Some
Like
To
Get
The
Hub
Or
Entity
That
Represents
It
To
Deploy
Some
Amount
Of
Atom
Which
I
Pair
With
My
Token
And
Becomes
Like
Liquidity
That
The
Hub
Controls
Right
Like
Or
It's
Representative
Or
However
It's
Structured
And
The
Idea
Is
That
If
Can
Do
This
In
A
Way
That's
Fairly
Scalable
Then
Over
The
Next
Year
When
10
20
50
100
Protocols
Like
Suddenly
You've
Created
Like
With
Very
Minor
Risk
And
Cost
To
The
Hub
You've
Created
Like
Hundreds
Of
Pairs
For
Atom
And
You've
Made
Sure
That
It's
Very
Ubiquitous
In
This
Liquidity
Graph
Therefore
There's
A lot
Of
That
We
Haven't
Done
And
That
I
Think
Would
Like
Really
Move
The
Needle
For
Both
The
AZ
Like
And
Not
Just
Neutron
Here
Like
Stride
As
Well
Right
Because
I
Think
Liquid
Staking
Derivatives
Of
Atom
Should
Also
Probably
Be
But
This
Way
Allow
DApps
That
Launch
On
The
AZ
To
Not
Only
Have
A
Little
Bit
Of
Atom
Liquidity
From
The
Get
Go
But
Also
A
Bit
Of
The
Staking
Derivatives
And
This
Way
Also
Make
The
Staking
Derivatives
A
Lot
More
Money
Like
And
Enable
Liquid
Staking
To
Have
More
Penetration
Which
Is
Great
For
The
Hub
Because
It
Potentially
Helps
Reduce
Inflation
All
Of
These
Things
Right
And
So
I
Don't
Know
I
Have
Been
Thinking
More
About
This
Facility
Lately
And
Was
Curious
To
Hear
Your
Thoughts
I
I'll
Put
My
Cosmos
Hub
Community
Member
Hat
On
Right
Now
So
I
Strongly
Agree
I
Think
The
Hub
Need to
Double
Down
On
This
Idea
Of
Protocol
And
Liquidity
Bundling
It
With
The
Shared
Security
It
Offering
For
The
Out
Economic
Zone
And
I
Think
The
Way
We're
Doing
The
Hubs
Doing
Protocol
Liquidity
Is
Not
Right
Being
Governance
Gated
Is
Slow
And
We
Need
A
Market
Mechanism
To
Other
Chains
In
The
Wider
Like
AEZ
And
Honestly
There's
Obviously
This
Argument
About
What
Is
The
AEZ
And
What's
Not
And
I'm
Not
Going
To
Go
There
But
I
Think
There
Should
Be
An
Opportunity
For
Chains
Outside
Of
Leveraging
The
Hub
Security
To
Have
The
Opportunity
To
Get
Protocol
Liquidity
But
There
Need
To
Be
A
Market
Mechanism
To
Do
This
So
I'm
Writing
Up
A
But
One
Of
The
Best
Distribution
Mechanisms
In
Crypto
That
I
Think
Has
Gotten
A
Lot
Of
Love
And
A
Lot
Of
Hate
Is
VE
Tokenomics
And
I
Think
The
Problem
With
VE
Tokenomics
Is
It
Has
The
Distribution
Mechanism
Is
Really
Elegant
But
What
It
Does
Is
It
Gives
Away
The
Liquidity
It
It's
Like
Curve
It's
Literally
Paying
Protocols
And
Essentially
A lot
Of
Liquidity
Providers
Are
Dumping
The
Curve
Rewards
And
It's
Obviously
Causing
Downward
Pressure
On
Curve
Price
Action
But
Why
Hasn't
Anyone
Built
A
VE
Tokenomics
For
Protocol
And
Liquidity
So
Get
Protocols
To
Bribe
Atom
Stakers
Or
Atom
Lockers
So
Instead
Of
Staking
Atom
For
21
Days
What
If
Locked
Your
Atom
For
A
Longer
Period
Of
Time
And
In
Doing
So
To
Direct
Protocol
And
Liquidity
To
Applications
That
Are
Launching
On
Neutron
And
By
Doing
That
Get
Percentage
Allocation
Get
Potential
Rev
Share
If
You're
Able
To
Direct
Protocol
And
Liquidity
To
These
Given
Protocols
On
Neutron
I
Definitely
Think
There's
Something
Here
With
Time
Wave
Deploying
On
Neutron
I
Know
Binary
Builders
On
Cosmos
Hub
Are
Building
This
Atom
Alignment
Treasury
That
Obviously
Has
Governance
Aspect
To
It
I
Think
The
Pieces
Are
Coming
Together
We
Need
To
Come
Up
With
A
Really
Good
Market
Mechanism
Between
Neutron
And
The
Hub
To
Deploy
This
Pol
So
I
Couldn't
Agree
More
I'm
Kind
Of
Writing
Up
Something
Right
Now
That
Will
Go
On
The
Form
In
The
Next
Couple
Weeks
But
This
Is
How
Create
Demand
For
Atom
And
Make
The
Base
Pair
In
All
Neutron
So
I'm
Really
Excited
About
This
Idea
But
Again
As
Of
Right
Now
It's
Kind
Like
A
High
Level
Idea
I'm
Still
Figuring
It
Out
In
My
Head
That
Makes
A lot
Of
Sense
I
Would
Like
Constructive
Feedback
I
Would
Be
Concerned
About
One
Thing
For
The
Purpose
Of
Bootstrapping
New
Protocols
Which
Is
That
New
Protocols
Won't
Have
Large
Amount
Resources
To
Bride
With
And
So
I
Think
This
Mechanism
Works
Super
Well
For
Larger
Allocations
To
Protocols
That
Are
A bit
More
Established
Like
Stride
Would
Be
To
Participate
In
This
And
Especially
Since
It's
Probably
A better
Way
To
Approach
This
Than
Just
Distributing
Instances
On
Dexes
So
Yeah
I
Agree
I
Think
It's
A
Super
Interesting
Idea
But
Anyway
Sorry
For
Derailing
The
Conversation
Yeah
Interesting
Ideas
For
Sure
But
Absolutely
Nothing
To
Do
With
Neutron
Graph
So
Let's
Just
Sort
Of
Bring
It
So
Bring
Back
To
Grants
Program
We
Obviously
Covered
A lot
Of
The
RFPs
A lot
About
What
The
Program
Is
All
About
So
Lam
Ray
If
Want
To
Get
Back
On
Track
And
Just
Tell
Us
If
I
Have
An
Idea
And
I
Want
To
Get
Some
Funding
And
Come
To
Neutron
And
Apply
For
A
Grant
How
Do
I
Go
About
Doing
That
Sure
Sure
Thanks
Yeah
I
Think
The
Very
Simple
Answer
Is
It
Is
Very
Simple
Can
Simply
Just
Go
On
The
Neutron
Grants
Dotcom
Page
Click
The
Apply
Button
Are
Met
By
Type
Form
Which
Just
Essentially
Just
Asks
For
A
Few
Simple
Questions
So
Like
As
I
Said
About
10
Minutes
Or
So
And
About
One
Or
Two
Weeks
After
That
After
Click
The
Application
Form
We'll
Get
Back
To
With
Next
Steps
Whether
That
Be
A
Follow
Up
Question
By
Email
Whether
That
Be
Interview
And
We
Anticipate
Most
People
For
Larger
Funds
Larger
Grant
Ask
Maybe
Be
Expected
To
Conduct
Two
Interviews
But
For
Smaller
Amounts
It
May
Be
Back
And
By
Single
Interview
And
Obviously
Even
Before
Apply
Some
Teams
Have
Reached
Out
To
Us
To
Have
A
Conversation
Ask
Questions
About
The
Feasibility
Of
The
Grants
And
Our
General
Approach
We're
Very
Keen
To
And
Happy
To
Discuss
With
People
Things
Before
They
Apply
For
Grants
In
General
But
Yeah
We'll
Try
To
Make
Initial
Application
Process
As
Small
As
Quickly
And
Streamlined
As
Possible
And
Obviously
Most
Work
Any
Applicant
Is
Doing
On
The
Project
And
The
Thing
They're
Trying
To
Get
Funded
For
As
Opposed
To
Making
Them
Spend
Hours
Going
Through
This
Grant
Process
So
Streamline
As
Possible
And
Can
Simply
Go
To
Neutron
Grants
And
Apply
By
There
And
It's
All
Quite
Similar
To
What
Other
Grant
Programs
May
Look
Like
Great
Thanks
For
Clearing
All
That
Up
I've
Also
Just
Added
About
The
Program
Links
To
The
Neutron
Grants
Website
In
There
For
Anyone
Who
Does
Want
To
Apply
I'm
Not
Seeing
Any
Particular
Community
Questions
Or
Anything
Right
Now
So
Does
Anybody
Have
Any
Final
Comments
Before
We
Wrap
Up
The
Space
If
No
One
Has
Anything
Else
I
Just
Want
To
Say
Thank
Guys
For
Taking
The
Time
We've
Been
Really
Excited
With
The
Quality
And
The
Context
Of
The
Applications
As
Far
And
If
Anyone
Has
Any
Questions
Is
Thinking
About
Applying
For
A
Grant
Feel
Free
To
Reach
Out
To
Any
Of
Us
We're
All
Active
On
Twitter
And
Telegram
We'll
Send
Us
An
Email
And
We'll
Be
To
Get
Back
To
We're
Looking
Forward
To
Giving
The
First
Grants
And
I
Think
It's
A
Constant
Iterative
Process
We have
Our
Operations
And
Procedures
Things
That
Will
Get
Funded
We
Also
Don't
Build
We
Have
To
Build
On
This
Core
RFP
We
Have
That
Can't
Get
Funded
We're
Very
Open
And
Looking
For
The
Best
Teams
To
Build
Thank
For
Taking
The
Time
Perfect
Thank
To
The
The
The
The
Neutron
Grants
For
Coming
Along
And
To
Us
Today
Conscious
With
Time
And
People
Have
Meets
To
So
We'll
Call it
End
Of
The
Space
So
Yeah
Thank
Very
Much
For
Everyone
For
Coming
Along
Today
We
Will
Have
More
Spaces
And
Stuff
Coming
Up
Soon
So
If
Got
Any
Questions
About
Grants
Or
Anything
Anything
Looks
Like
That
Then
Come
Along
To
Say
Hello
In
The
New
Strong
Community
Telegram
And
We'll
Be
Happy
To
Direct
If
Can't
Find
The
Answers
Need
From
The
Grants
Website
But
Yeah
As
I
Said
Thank
To
Everyone
For
Coming
Along
Today
And
We'll
See
Again
On
The
Next
Space
Thank
Thank
You guys
Thank
Folks
That
Was
Great

プロトコルやチェーンのTVLを増やしたいですか?

AlphaGrowthは資産の獲得と統合、助成金、インセンティブ、LPディールによって、プロトコルとチェーンのTVLを伸ばします。このデータは私たちが構築し、無料で公開しています。