---
title: "DEV🕶️TIME: Privacy Architecture Debate | Gravação de Twitter Space | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Gravação de Twitter Space de 2026-03-19 com Vara Network, Vadim, Dmitrii Novikov"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/devtime-privacy-architecture-debate"
---

# DEV🕶️TIME: Privacy Architecture Debate

Gravado em: Mar 19, 2026 Duração: 0:44:03

## Gravação do Space

[Abrir o Space original](https://x.com/i/spaces/1MJgNgjvzrMGL)

0:00 44:03

### Transcrição completa

Music Thank you. Thank you. I'm going to go to the next video. Music Okay, hello, hello. Can you hear me, guys? Yes, Dima. Hi.

Yeah, yeah. Hi, how are you doing?

I'm good. How are you?

I'm good. How are you?

A bit injured, you know, but not dead.

A bit sick, so I'm going to be slightly passive today.

So I hope Vadim is going to handle it.

Yeah, I was waiting for Vadim to join us.

And now I'm trying to send him.

Okay, here he is. Hello, Vadim.

Claire, hey, Dima.

What's up?

Alright, so all of us are here.

I hope, Dima, you're feeling every day better and better.

And hopefully, Vadim can step in if you will not how to answer or whatever and Vadim how are

you by the way all good working a lot playing with AI okay it seems like

everyone is playing with AI so welcome everyone on today's Dev Time, which is a session with the core devs from Vara.

Every month we go through some topic and today's topic is privacy architecture.

It's going to be amazing if all of you who are now listening can write some message under the Twitter space, share the Twitter space,

so we get more engagement and more people to join in.

And yeah, we will talk about privacy today.

So if anyone would have any questions, feel free to raise your hand and you can ask the

question uh i think we can start uh it's actually been two months we've met all here so very

exciting and i think we can start with the first question if you guys are ready

so are you yes vadadi yes i'm ready

we're just on the lower start you know you only give our like you know

both in the air and we're gonna go answering all the stuff okay

Okay.

All right.

So, guys, when you think about privacy in the blockchain,

what's the first thing actually which comes to your mind?

It could be a feature or something that should be woven into the protocol

from the day one or anything relevant to web-free blockchain technology,

what is the first thing you think about?

Okay, Dima, start, please.

Hey, I was about to start with some joking about

when we start talking about privacy in crypto.

There is a lot of guys that

are like right now in jail due to this fact due to due to the fact that they are trying to bring

more privacy first thing that comes to my mind is the all the tornado cache developer or the

related guys who just end up in jail and this is just the first thing that you can think of

about privacy but this is the cost of privacy actually yeah because actually it's not the

original meaning of blockchain it's not the original aim to be achieved, the privacy, because we had privacy like before.

And right now we have a new market like access on privacy.

We have new market willing to have privacy.

And it's something that you need to build on top of that already exists.

And we need to think how it should be integrated because the pipto is already

integrated in the world so we have some you know regulations uh we have some common protocols we

have some adoption maybe it's like it's not that early as it was like 10 years ago but anyway

we have some adoption and we are moving forward with everything we already have. We are trying to improve the tech. We are trying to

like bring some new solutions like bridge-less solutions, more performance solutions,

more maybe even AI-oriented and stuff. And the privacy here is some add-on feature for me

that should be in the market, but it's not necessary like because i do

enjoy having everything transparent because i can check whatever i want everybody could check

whatever they want about me if they know my address but it's like your responsibility to hide your Yeah, for example, privacy at the protocol level.

So if you talk about Ethereum, Bitcoin or any kind of general purpose smart contracts

chain, they don't have privacy at the core and protocol level, but other projects like

we have privacy built in and that's their main purpose

to be private blockchains and use them as private

transactions or whatever

and for general purpose blockchains that

do kind of compute and a lot of people

use it, Usually privacy is just

that someone builds and who needs privacy that people use it.

So in my mind the general purpose blockchains should find some kind of balance that you can

opt-in feature for privacy but anyone who starts to use privacy will like will get suspicious

so you can always distinct like people who just use blockchains and people who use privacy

tools and you can just find them by different ways, by metadata, by other connections.

So privacy is just very hard topic.

Yeah, to be honest, I think we are a couple of

steps ahead

in this topic because we didn't

yet figure out

what's privacy.

We can discuss some questions,

we can answer them, yeah.

But if you want

having some good debates

about some topic, we need to

realize fully what's the topic.

So basically, we can share some thoughts about it.

For example, Claire, what do you think is privacy on chain?

Oh, you asked me a question. This is not okay.

Why is it not okay? It's our AMA, it's not your AMA, you know?

So for me like generally

privacy is like a rabbit hole honestly i think like it's very complex topic and i met a lot of

people who were like super hard on privacy and stuff uh i found myself and one time when I was trying to like use, I don't know, some apps instead of the people are using and be part of the majority, it's very hard to think about privacy all the time.

So obviously, I'm not a technical person, so I don't know if this answer is accurate for this topic.

I'm just responding as mostly as a user who can care about privacy in apps,

which I would use.

And I still don't know what's the right direction

and if what I'm doing is the right direction.

Yeah, but I'm more like about the fact what what is privacy not how to achieve it not how to support

it for stuff so for example why isn't the privacy the fact that everything is represented by by some

addresses like 20 or 32 bytes addresses in hex uh without any knowledge about who am I, where am I from, how old I am, am I a girl or a boy or stuff like this.

Why isn't this...

...this whole process, we have been trying to create some more transparent solutions.

So, for example, you could find Bouterin's address with just like two clicks.

You just go to the other scan and you type like vitalik.eth and there is like,

there is his name associated with his account because we have been achieving it.

So why isn't't the original privacy?

I think there is a difference between privacy and anonymity.

If you want to stay anonymous, you always tend,

but if someone just tracks you or you have some connections,

that break your an anonymous state so you will be like a public

you will be in a public space so and your address for example will be connected to

your real name for example and there will be no anonymous state but privacy is more about like

what do you do maybe what's inside your address what's inside your profile so if we talk about

privacy i think it's more about about data actually the information behind some

kind of public address for example so basically the ability to keep to keep

anonymous something like this yeah for example if we know the Vitaly Buterin

address and we can track all of his transfers for example what is he doing

but privacy enables the thing that if you know his address with privacy option

we shouldn't see any of his like movements any of his uh data insights

but that would be up to him no yeah so basically it reduces like it removes like uh the original

idea of transparency of um being able to verify uh everything and find all the connections

um being able to verify uh everything and find all the connections it was about this

the blockchain world just evolves and you can always add privacy or disable privacy

doesn't matter so the initial thing for blockchains it was not possible to make something private

and now we have some zk technology for example example, that can enable privacy, for example, Monero, Zcash.

And of course, there is always a debate between who

uses private tools.

They always like suspicious persons,

or they just care about their data leakage.

So for example, if Claire uses Instagram,

Instagram knows everything about Claire.

And if Claire decides to just cut off this track,

she will be like suspicious

why she want to keep

something in private

but I don't know

we can go to the next question

because we just said what privacy

is and the first thing

that comes to my mind is just

yeah it's already said

private data.

I mean, we never need to follow questions, guys.

So if the discussion gets into something else, it's okay.

That's what we do here.

So don't worry about the questions.

Don't worry about the questions.

But, I mean, I probably agree with Vladim's perspective or the opinion.

I feel like crypto wasn't ready when it started.

I think the main point of crypto at the beginning or Web3 was to mostly get decentralized

and it was focused on like the ownership but the privacy

got a little bit later after that but it's just like very i would say it's a big rabbit hole

on how you decide how you behave yeah that's an able privacy like in any application any protocol you just need to build it from

the ground to like to have some kind of overview and architecture before

implementing something that's why we have a lot of privacy tools and

technologies and in this modern world, the demand for privacy is just getting bigger.

Yeah, I mean, from my point of view, it's like obvious that from the very first steps,

they haven't been able to reach privacy because there was like a lot of other tasks or questions

to be solved.

For example, how to build consensus, how to like adopt it, how to interact with it, how

to make it secure.

Hey guys, what about some executions in here?

Oh, contracts and stuff.

So it was about this initially.

And now we have all of this like you know uh already um beaten in the stones

because it's like some basis everybody knows how it works everybody knows how to build it so there

is a lot of player ones a lot of player twos and stuff but um and of course we could move forward

we could move to some security uh like more economical, interesting security concerns.

We can move to some privacy considerations.

But I think the privacy, if we're going to achieve the full privacy in crypto,

we will not be able to adopt it in the world just because everybody will be not just against it

because it's uncontrollable stuff, because it's like uncontrollable stuff,

but it's like totally uncontrollable stuff.

And we're going to come to the just dark market of crypto in the world,

despite the fact that we are like already super close to be like fully understood

and represented on some classic markets like in the same way as the stocks do.

So let me actually follow with another question.

You just said we don't need to follow questions.

But it's in a connection. It's in a connection with what we are discussing. So we discussed that the privacy of like blockchain and crypto projects was added a little bit later.

And maybe it's added as an option layer, maybe something which is used toggle in wallet or via mixer, etc.

So we discussed this wasn't like before really focused on.

So the question is like, what are actually the risks of when it's not like being added as default as part of the layer, but it's just used like optional layer?

Can you like share more about the risk of this approach? Or do you disagree?

I think it's totally okay to build something on top of already existing system instead of of like trying to invent the system from the very beginning with the new approach because

it's like to solve to solve to the people.

And I think it's all about the questions about trying to expand the ecosystem or how to scale

something.

So, for example, you cannot just build Ethereum

because there is a lot of liquidity on Ethereum

and nobody will use Ethereum for your new form of Ethereum.

But if you just move forward,

from one day to another, from one month to another,

you try to build something already integrated

in the solution everybody used to i don't see any

particular risks here except like common uh common stuff from building any products or if you

or if you just didn't pay attention on some security concern, but not from the architecture perspective.

What do you think?

I missed the initial question.

What's the point?

Oh my God, Vadim, that's perfect.

I mean, so the point is, basically, did you even listen to what Dima said or didn't as well?

Yeah, yeah, I was listening to that.

So it's just like, if you think it's actually risky to implement privacy as an optional layer something which is

like inside maybe wallet or via mixer but it's not added there as the default

so I think it is the same as I said before if you add privacy as an optional

layer some people will use it, some people not.

And it will be much easier to track people that use privacy.

And there is some kind of risk, I think.

Because if you build your application like Monero coin with the privacy as default option, everyone who uses it

they are all some kind of like anonymous so they use privacy by default and you

cannot just track everyone and that's the main point. Like if you enable privacy as an option and like an optional layer,

there will be some risks.

So can you share like more information about what does it exactly mean in practice

when you are building something or when you're saying you're adding layer or you're adding

feature what does it actually could do this privacy feature

why people would turn on this or turn off

for some from some new projects to me yeah i mean I mean, if you put a privacy feature

I don't know,

maybe in transactions or

protocol or whatever,

what exactly

this means in practice when you are

building this?

What it could do or

how you build this?

Yeah, I think there is a lot of approaches for it.

Most simple and obvious is some ZK-based ones

because you can do a lot of things within a circuit

and do not reveal anything except input and output.

You don't need to reveal any state like at all for example how how that

catch works they they work in the same way and I think yeah it depends on this on the exact

protocols but I would like to say that if you're building something uh the privacy option i think the privacy isn't like some killer

feature for most of them but you need you need to build some like good and interesting and usable

protocol and if you will be compared to other usable protocols your privacy feature like is

is like is the key decision maker for choosing between you and somebody else but

by default private features for some protocols that nobody uses and nobody wants it's like

some usual stuff from my point of view

okay so let's move on I actually I'm just wondering so I've seen that now you can

actually create our like wallet by your face ID in a phone and stuff like that

have you guys have a look so compare so it's 100% for

adoption right it's much easier you can use just your phone you get a random

random address public key or whatever you don't even have have it you just use

it sign with your face ID and you have an address and you can use it. How would you compare this with safety, privacy, stuff,

compare when you have or own Ledger or you actually use Wallet?

Vadim, it's your turn now.

Sorry, you can start.

I'm just thinking about what Face ID enables and how it helps.

And I don't think there is anything about privacy.

I also think it's some unrelated stuff, but still interesting one.

Because as far as we guys know and uh maybe not everybody else

know uh we had like a retreat for for our company and we have been seeing each other and we had like

internal hackathon for us so we just for fun trying to we're trying to implement something

and it's our like competition you say uh and the point is, my team was building the approach of some account abstraction

inside the smart contracts on VARA and VARA ATH.

And the point is, we have been building the passkey verification system inside

this contract account abstraction.

And this one, which thing is exactly the same

because Face ID only enables your access

to some passkey mechanism.

For example, 1Password, for example, Apple Keychain,

for example, Google Keychain and stuff.

So it's all the same.

It's all about the adoption.

It's all about the usability and ease

to come to the ecosystem. But it's nothing about the adoption it's all about the usability and ease to to come to the ecosystem

but it's nothing about privacy and moreover you cannot even like try to um to track the initial

like face uh or something like this because the bus key is just it's just something uh that like is stored somewhere from from your side and it's just some

some cryptography key player keychain that you will be very fine on chain to be able to interact

with with other uh blockchain entities i would say that yeah passkey and face ID is more comparable to passwords. Like if you use

some kind of password on your phone for example, face ID just can replace it and

it's the same. Like if you put your password it will unlock your phone or

unlock your data and the same thing with just an ID is some kind of input or

just password replacement and yeah it can be used to secure your data

but there is I think no connection to like privacy itself. It is private as far as you just have your face, for example, your fingerprints as a password.

Do you have some recipes how to lose your fingerprints or something?

Have you ever been in jail, Vadim, for example?

Well, Vadim, you don't have to answer this question from Dima.

I will step in.

Because we all know.

Okay, thanks guys for answering.

So I will continue with the questions which we have prepared.

prepared and since we also mentioned CKA proofs we discussed that they are very like common and

And since we also mentioned CKA proofs,

favorite use case in privacy or their use for privacy it's their main purpose VARA actually

supports CKA capabilities from anonymous voting to private defy so can you give us

some real examples of how a developer would actually

use ZK on Vara?

It's not a big deal, to be honest, because what is ZK? Basically, it's some set of mathematical

functions and there is a lot of libraries written in rust for example for the key so it's narcs

it's plonky it's starts it's like a lot of algorithms a lot of things uh for example

even dls uh and the point of war in this model uh in this like topic uh that one allows like

huge computationals it allows like a lot of mathematics to be solved.

It allows like everything to be computed on chain because it's by design like this.

And it's the same for VAR ATH.

And we have some built-in actors.

It's some entities that allow you to speed up the process of

verification of something, but basically you can avoid it. You can just calculate everything,

use common like, libraries for the industry, not for blockchains, not for some smart contracts,

but like for common ZK ones. And you just start using it and realize that it's like,

ones, and you just start using it and realize that it's great to be on VAR, it's great to

have such computer power, it's great to have such transparent and native to common programming

language experience building something on Web3 while you're still thinking like in Web2.

tool.

Okay, if Vadim you don't want to add anything?

Just the same as Dimas said, but if I get all the ZK technicalities right,

so you can build an app that acts on chain and do some kind of private stuff and you can verify

also or pay payloads so the

computation done for this payload right demo

this payload right demo yeah there is a lot of cases like private actor that talks to on chain

talks to on chain messages like in by encryption and you can verify that these encrypted messages means mean something like yeah so so basically using zk you could build

like still transparent actor with its state by this state will be some uh some edge for example

you can cipher inputs you can cipher outputs and it all will work but only for those who realize and know what they

should like be doing yeah so yeah this is a very cool technology and i just thought about

we have on our network uh isolated state like no no other actor can access your state but is observable of chain you can load

you can load like any program of chain and see what's inside its memory for example

and is there a thing to encrypt your state and be private on chain by zk maybe yeah yeah but it depends on what you want

to build because zk is still uh limited with its power because there is not like a lot of things

that you could fit in uh but for example if someday we're gonna move to some hybrid model of execution,

for example, enable X0 or something like this, it will be much more powerful, but it's still

on very early stage from my point of view. And it's like non-production ready because

on VAR you can calculate anything you could calculate in like real life using the case like super limited it will like assume a huge

gravitational powers and stuff yeah and also related to this I just researched

a topic about drastic execution environments so for example why why we cannot enable

privacy on consensus layer for example is because validators can see everything

was going on inside consensus layer and inside transactions, actor states, etc.

And these trusted execution environments

are just a hardware thing, like computational device,

for example, that programs, contracts

can use to manipulate private data.

And validators are not able to see what's inside what's

what's happened they just can prove something happened this is just private

transaction for example private and I see this is a trend recently to enable trusted execution environments in different blockchains or layers of layer one blockchains.

And I think I will research this topic after this same way.

Yeah, I do love TE just because it's not that high P as like AIs, it's not that high P as ZK,

but it's also about the future.

It's also about visionary how we're going to like be calculating something, for example, in clouds and future.

So it's all about this, but i disagree with the approach of some

blockchains or some protocols to be starting like doing it right now uh because they are trying to

build something decentralized but they require uh for validator hardware something that costs like Это как 100 000 долларов. Да, это очень ограничено для людей, ты знаешь?

Это как вы проводите модель AI на вашем устройстве.

Вы не можете это ниже.

Вы просто нужны много денег, space, энергии.

И это же самое происходит в ТЕ.

Потому что вы должны получить это, эти валидатели. И это не об этом интервала. You need to get this thing and you need to get these validators and it's not about this interrelation right now.

So the question I gave you guys was actually regarding like examples of zk so as you know as we know uh we recently or you recently uh launched uh zk poker

on varamaynet and the cards stay private while the game proves fairness without revealing the deck

can you maybe explain those who are not very technical and maybe explain how this works?

It's some kind of magic, you know, and it will be kept the same

because two magicians never reveal their secrets, you know.

But yeah, to be honest, it's not that hard.

It's kind of a limited approach, but there is like a lot of algorithms.

It's a super old like concept based on Vilead's algorithm.

And the point is that everybody who is like joining and playing the same game,

they all shuffle the deck and they are shuffling, shuffling, shuffling some way.

And by the end, they all reveal it and submit proofs how they shuffled.

And it somehow results in some end position of the deck.

And then you like separate cards between users, between players and stuff.

separate cards between like users between players and stuff so it's all about submitting in time

your proof of uh shuffling the deck like in real life so i shuffle you shuffle and you cannot

like know how exactly did i shuffle or if they all like malicious there is one non-malicious user,

which should be, at least because if everyone is malicious,

it doesn't make any sense to play anything because you all know everything.

So yeah, I think it's kind of a simple explanation.

All right, so I think we've been here for 40 minutes, guys. So I want to give you some last chance.

If you think there is something we should mention regarding privacy architecture,

so if you can, each of you, maybe share something we didn't mention yet,

or if you have some other additional comment you think we should say before we will end.

I heard the news recently about US government can allow private transactions.

And the next day they again challenged the TornadoCache developer with some charges.

This was very funny.

But maybe this is how the privacy will go in the future.

Like government can allow private things in certain ways for businesses, for users maybe.

So this is not, this is just started to be more clear maybe.

So the privacy is the way to go.

yeah my side i would say uh that if you're building something related to privacy tooling

privacy and don'ts for existing ecosystem or something like new i think um from the developer

perspective you need to focus on the like your primary ideas what and why are you building and not try to make your ux like as

smooth as it could be in future because otherwise you could face some challenges or you could face

some bugs uh as as we also um maybe maybe it was three months ago or something like this with monero uh on solana

uh because there was like some guy on twitter on x i'm so sorry uh and uh this guy was like

uh investigating uh how do how to crack them uh how to reveal the transfer and uh the primary key to solving who has performed some transfer was in some gas refunds

or something like this which is like maybe less than one cent USD but anyway it's something you

don't need to think of when you build something like for a future something for private future, something for privacy. You don't need to build it from scratch perfectly.

And I think it's related to all of the topics

when you build something.

Do you guys want to comment on, Vadim,

do you have some comments?

I don't have any comments I can say that come build

in water network and enable privacy if you wish and you can build anything not about

not just about privacy just come and build we can enable privacy for you.

All right. So if no one from the audience has any other questions,

I feel like today's session was very different than usual sessions.

usual sessions. But I think we still share, you guys still share quite a lot of interesting

information. This session is recorded, so for anyone who couldn't join, there will be recording

and also there will be a recap thread posted in a few days. thank you guys so much for joining and thanks everyone who joined

as well today yeah thank you guys thanks claire thank you dima it was really interesting to talk

about it because i don't think about privacy like in my day-to-day life but it is really a topic that

about privacy like in my day-to-day life but it is really a topic that anyone should care

i think and decide for yourself what's what is privacy for you

keep moving on stories that needs to be told yeah thank you guys see you next time thank you guys

bye Yeah, thank you guys. See you next time. Thank you guys. Bye. Bye.

### Anfitrião

- [Vara Network](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/varanetwork.md) de [Vara Network](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/vara-network.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/VaraNetwork)

### Orador

- [Vadim](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/ukint_vs.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/ukint_vs)
- [Dmitrii Novikov](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/breathx_rs.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/breathx_rs)

## Quer mais TVL para o seu protocolo ou blockchain?

A AlphaGrowth faz crescer o TVL de protocolos e blockchains por meio da aquisição e integração de ativos, grants, incentivos e acordos LP. Criamos estes dados e os mantemos gratuitos.

[Como aumentamos o TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/defi/index.md) [Fale com a AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/contact-us/index.md)
