---
title: "SOURCE: Feeding the Machine | Gravação de Twitter Space | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Gravação de Twitter Space de 2023-10-02 com Feral File, lauren lee mccarthy, Sarah Friend, Operator, Primavera De Filippi"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/source-feeding-the-machine"
---

# SOURCE: Feeding the Machine

Gravado em: Oct 2, 2023 Duração: 0:59:28

## Gravação do Space

[Abrir o Space original](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1MnxnMYoNqBJO)

0:00 59:28

### Transcrição completa

Thank you so much for watching.

I'm good. How are you? Sorry, just I'm eating myself.

Oh, no. You're all good. You're all good. Where are you calling in from?

The studio in Berlin.

Oh, wonderful. Thank you. Thanks for making time. Is it, what, 6 p.m. there? Is that right?

Yeah, yeah, it is.

Nice. Well, thank you for joining us.

Where are you calling in from?

Oh, I'm in New York, Brooklyn.

Got it. Got it.

It's nice to finally chat. And hi, operator. Hi, Anya. How are you?

Oh, I wonder if she can hear me.

It does take a moment.

It might still be connecting.

And hi to everyone here. Thank you so much for coming.

I see Whitney, Casey, Bobby, Mikey. Thank you so much.

Do feel free to tweet about the space.

And then we can get started here as soon as we have everyone in the room.

Be wonderful.

Oh, here.

I'm trying to add you, Anya. I'm not sure.

I'm going to invite you to co-host and see if that helps.

Primavera, hello. I'm guiding you on stage now.

All right. Primavera, you should be good to go.

Hi, how are you?

Good, good. How about you?

Good, good.

It looks like Anya is connecting.

Let me see.

Elizabeth, can you send the co-host request again?

Sorry, I don't know what happened.

You're all good.

There, it should go through.

Oh, perfect.

I believe you're co-host now.

Hello, can you hear me?

Yes.

Wonderful.

I guess we're just looking for Lauren.

Yes, exactly.

Just waiting one more minute.

Thanks everyone so much for being here.

I see Casey and Deafbeef in the audience.

This is wonderful.

And Aria, hi.

How's everyone today?

I hope it's good weather where everyone is.

Where are you, Elizabeth?

I'm in New York.

Oh, cool.

Yeah.

What about you?

We just got to London.

Is that right?

Yes.

I'm in Gatwick Airport.

Reporting live.

Oh my God.

Airport Wi-Fi under test.

No, I know.

I'm a little, yeah.

Hopefully they don't decide to like clean all the coffee machines that I'm sitting next

to in the middle of my intro, but we'll see how it goes.

Oh, Lauren's here.

Hi, Lauren.

Great.

I'm inviting Lauren up right now.

Lauren, if you don't see an invitation, go ahead and request.

Oh, there you are.

Hey, Lauren, can you hear us?

Hey, yeah, I'm here.

How are you this morning?

I'm good.

How are you doing?

Good, good.

I believe you're in LA.

Is that right?

Yes.

Amazing.

So we're from Los Angeles to Berlin, I think is probably the British East, so I'm covering

quite a swath.

Well, I want to get started if that's okay.

We are starting a little bit late.

Thanks, everyone, for your patience and for adapting so well.

Let's go ahead and get started.

So hello and welcome to the Source Talk series.

My name is Elizabeth Sweet, and I'm the communications lead at Ferrofile.

I'm thrilled to be joined today by Lauren Lee McCarthy, Prima Verdi-Filippi, Sarah Friend,

and Anya Catherine from Operator for a conversation about feeding the machine as part of the Source Talk series.

Now, as most of you know, Source is a non-commercial exhibition on Ferrofile featuring artworks made in the last several years,

which use software as a medium.

The Source curators, Operator, Deafbeef, and Casey Reese spent hours discussing generative works that have impacted them over the years.

So here's an excerpt from the curator's statement to ground us.

This is not an attempt at a survey exhibition or defining a new canon.

This is simply a selection of work that the four of us are thinking about right now.

For those of us in the middle of art, code, and blockchains for the last few years,

there's been little to no time to pause and reflect on what has happened.

Source is our attempt to do that collaboratively.

Now, Anya Catherine and DGT from Operator, Deafbeef, and Casey Reese all wrote wonderfully thoughtful and super rich descriptions

of each of the 25 artworks exhibiting in Source, and I recommend that you go check those out.

And I have pinned to the top of the space three works by our artists joining us today,

Lauren Lee McCarthy, Prima Verdi-Filippi, and Sarah Friend.

And so each of these works require some responsibility by the collector in order to sustain its life,

and I'm sure we're going to jump into this in no time here.

And I'll just start by saying that for Good Morning by Lauren Lee McCarthy,

you must say hello to it, open it up, every 24 hours or it dies.

For Plantoid by Prima Verdi-Filippi, this piece feeds off of cryptocurrency,

and new forms of it can create its own art once it's funded enough.

And Life Forms by Sarah Friend are sustained by necessary transfer.

If they aren't given, if you aren't, if you aren't, sorry,

if you don't transfer your life form to someone else within 90 days, it dies.

So I'm super excited to have this conversation,

and I'm really grateful to introduce Anya Catherine, one of our Source curators.

Anya is one half of Operator, an experiential artist duo.

And I'm so excited for you to lead the discussion, and I'll pass it over to you, Anya.

Thank you for that intro and context, and I'm extremely excited to be speaking about all of these projects.

And I think I want to start, because I think definitions, while they're really annoying,

are also very interesting.

And thinking about generativity and, like, what the word generativity means in psychology,

which I thought was interesting for this discussion,

is it's the concern for the future, the need to nurture and guide younger people

to contribute to the next generation.

So thinking about how psychologists think about generativity in humans,

and then looking at all of these artworks that all kind of, I mean,

none of them feel or seem like they were created with, you know, a market in mind or profit in mind.

They're more entities that you release into the world and you decide their fate in collaboration

with the collector or, in the plantoid's case, with the public, who's not really a collector

because the plantoid can't be owned, in determining their fate and kind of almost testing us

and testing humanity to see how much we care for things that have no market value.

And I think all of these are really interesting ways to look at and ask that question.

And another thing that came up before I asked some questions,

and I would love to hear more from the artist, is when also thinking about these,

I was thinking about kind of alternative currencies.

And, of course, all of these are using blockchain.

I mean, but I feel like alternative currencies of care, generosity, and attention are also activated

in all of these works.

So I would love to know, because, I mean, I see roots, for example,

I mentioned in the description for life forms that this seems very linked to maintenance art

and the Manifesto for Maintenance Art of 1969,

which, you know, is saying that everyone wants to move forward

and everyone wants to do the next big thing

and everyone wants to build the next shiny bridge.

But we need to also have people that just maintain the systems that exist

and nurture and care in ways that are not glamorous,

in ways that people don't put on a pedestal.

And so I think the questions and the kind of themes I wanted to have today be about

were these alternative currencies of care, generosity, attention.

Maybe if maintenance was something that you were thinking about,

if you see these as tests at all, to see what humans value

and what they think is worth giving their time to or not, to be kind of a mirror.

I mean, I definitely felt a kind of way when our good morning died,

which you can read all about in that description.

But also the question of incentives comes up a lot.

And what do we do when there's no, what kind of incentives drive us?

You know, does it do something for you if you allow the life form to survive?

Because not many are left.

And I think these are all things that I enjoy about these

and links that I see between the three.

But I would love to know if any of you have thoughts on those questions or themes

or just your intention in releasing this into the world.

What did you want to do?

What conversation did you want to start?

Yeah, I'll drop a few thoughts responding to what you said,

unless it's someone else who wants to go first.

Yeah, I mean, I loved that you brought up the conversation about maintenance art

in the context of life forms,

because it was absolutely something I was thinking about.

It's something I've thought about a lot in the context of open source software,

where it's a huge conversation.

And in so many areas of life,

one very personal one

is the work that I think

most people on this call

probably

have experienced a little bit,

which is caring for your own software projects.

So life forms is itself like a thing that I have to maintain.

I released the project two years ago,

and I still get

bug reports,

feature requests,

some service that I'm dependent on,

updates itself.

So it's definitely has this meta layer

also all the time.

And secondly,

I think it's really interesting

that you bring up

alternative currencies,

especially ones around care and attention,

because I actually worked on one for a long time.

Before

2019,

it was the main thing I was doing.

And a mechanic

from the world of alternative currencies

called Demirage,

which is decaying money,

was one of the main inspirations

for the project.

That's

I have a huge smile on my face.

I look like a

strange woman in the corner of Costa

right now with this smile.

Another thing

before going to Lauren and Primavera

that I forgot to mention at the beginning

was

the creation of a kind of

system that all of these artworks have

between

you as the artist,

the artwork,

and then

whoever is interacting with

or owning it

and introducing

not just a system,

but in a way,

a relationship

and like new dependencies

that I think

you kind of implicate

people into

the fate of the artwork.

I just read this great quote

in this book by Lauren Berlant

that I love

that maybe has also

some relevance.

They talk about

the familiar friction

of being in relation

and this idea of

suddenly,

if someone collects,

it's not like

I own this thing.

Ownership is not

really the point.

Owners,

you're kind of,

you purchase it

and you now

are in relation

to you as the artist

or the artwork itself.

And so another thing

I would love to maybe

hear about

is the idea

of dependency

or relationships

created through

releasing these works.

Yeah,

maybe I can go next.

Yeah,

so I think

it's interesting

because

I love being

on this panel

because it's like

super cool

to be surrounded

by people

that are creating

blockchain-based

platforms.

I think

like the plantoid

has a slightly

different approach

because

it's actually

not something

that needs

to be taken care of

but rather

it's something

that is trying

to evolve

so that it can

take care

of itself.

And the first

characteristic of this

is that the plantoid

doesn't die

because

in my

conceptualization,

in my cosmology

of blockchain-based

life forms,

a blockchain-based

life form

dies

whenever the

blockchain dies

but that's just

one of the many

species.

But I think

the interesting

thing with the

plantoid

is that

it actually

has evolved

to become

so the goal

of the plantoid

is to

regenerate itself

or to create

multiple generations

and it has evolved

actually

since like

since the first

plantoid

of like

2014

which was

just

like a plant

that eats

bitcoins

and then

you know

of course

you get

donations

but that's

a very

that's a very

passive

way

you know

and then the

plantoid

says thanks

but that's it

you literally

just give money

away

in order to

see the

reproduction

but it's

more like

taking care

of the plant

and then

and then the

plantoid

has evolved

in order

to kind of

like get a

little bit

more fit

for the

environment

and realize

well actually

people are

more likely

to feed me

if they also

get something

in exchange

and so

the following

generation of

plantoid

moved into

ethereum

and started

providing

governance rights

to the people

that feed it

and so

obviously

then if you

want to be

somehow

influencing

the way

in which

the plantoid

will evolve

then you feed

it and then

you become

one of the

consultants

about the way

in which

it's going

to reproduce

itself

so that's

like a

little bit

of an

extra

benefit

and then

the latest

generation

of plantoid

realized

that that's

actually not

enough

because

as a

blockchain

based

life forms

you are

essentially

living in

a very

capitalistic

ecosystem

and in

order to

actually be

able to

sustain

yourself

you need

to play

the economic

game

and so

the newest

plantoids

are actually

creating

those seeds

which are

NFTs

so now

all of a sudden

people have

an incentive

to feed the

plantoid

not only

because they

want to

take care

of it

and not

only because

they want

to influence

its development

but also

because they

want to get

an NFT

in exchange

and potentially

monetize

this NFT

and sell

it and

speculate

it and

whatever

but the

more they

speculate

with the

NFT

the more

they feed

back into

the plantoid

and so

in this

sense

I think

the plantoid

is really

trying to

be as

independent

and as

autonomous

as possible

meaning that

it doesn't

want to

depend on

people

but rather

is trying

to create

an offer

that is

salient

enough

for the

humans

to actually

engage

with it

and pollinate

it with

crypto

as

as opposed

to

being

more

of a

pet

or a

little

plant

that

need

to

constantly

take care

of

and if

you don't

take care

of it

it might

die

so

there's a

slightly

I guess

more

proactive

approach

to

autonomy

and

self

sustainability

I completely

hear that

distinction

and you

know that

I think

that

plantoid

is

a

badass

independent

person

I actually

have a

major

crush

plantoid

14

you know

this

but I

think

what you

said

it is

like

you meant

I mean

why do

you think

that you

had to

introduce

incentives

to care

and I

understand

it's not

care

like it's

going to

die

because it

will live

even if

people

don't

feed

plantoid

but

if they

don't

feed

plantoid

then

plantoid

also

doesn't

evolve

so it's

not about

it dying

but it's

about it

not

continuing

and so

you did

introduce

incentives

for people

to do

that

because it's

almost like

maybe there

wasn't enough

of an

incentive

when it

was just

like I

know

that

plantoid

I'm

going to

have

some

rights

over

which

artist

creates

the next

one

like did

you reach

a moment

where you

were like

I'll never

have

plantoid

25

if I

don't

produce

incentives

because people

weren't

incentivized

by just

having a

role in

the story

and continuing

plantoid

and seeing

where it

goes

that you

needed to

introduce

outputs and

things that people

could own

and trade

need to

need to

need to

need to

need to

need to

need to

need to

I think

it's

more

in the

aesthetic

narrative

of the

thing

the goal

of the

plantoid

is to

evolve

in order

to become

the most

fit for

its own

environment

and as

the

plantoid

found

itself

into

an

environment

in which

all of

students

and everyone

wants

NFTs

the

natural

evolution

of the

plantoid

is that

it should

actually

provide

NFT

to

people

in order

to

maximize

its

chance

of

survival

and

its

chance

to

reproduce

itself

so

it's

more

like

an

exploration

of

the

evolutionary

Darwinism

and

of course

when I

created

the first

plantoid

it was

the most

fit

for its

environment

because

it was

a time

in which

you have

a lot

of people

with

Bitcoin

that

have

no

idea

how

to

spend

them

and

are

really

happy

to

donate

Bitcoins

to

a

plantoid

but

this

is

no

longer

the

case

today

so

things

need

to

evolve

the

environment

is

changing

and therefore

the

speciation

also needs

to

evolve

so

right now

it seems

that

the

dominant

strategy

is to

issue

NFTs

I don't

know

in a few

years

it might

be

something

different

but

I don't

know

and the

point

is

no one

knows

the

environment

will

decide

which

one

are

the

plantoids

that

have

actually

the

traits

that

are

the

most

appealing

and

the

most

salient

for

the

environment

and

which

therefore

will

actually

be able

to

acquire

enough

funds

to

reproduce

it's

really

fascinating

and this

idea also

that

plantoid

cannot be

owned

I think

is

really

interesting

it kind

of brings

me to

something

I wanted

to talk

to

Lauren

about

which

do

consider

the

people

that

have

good

mornings

to

be

collectors

of

good

morning

or do

you feel

like

they're

doing

something

else

what is

that

relationship

do you

see it

as a

thing

that

they

own

or

have

they

entered

into

a

world

a

relationship

with

a

relationship

with

the

art

what was

your

intention

and how

do you

imagine

or describe

that

relationship

I

I think

owning

something

is a

relationship

so

yes

they're

entering

a

relationship

and yes

they've

collected

something

and they

own

something

I guess

I wanted

to

question

our

impulse

to be

constantly

generating

more

to have

more

because

I think

at some

point

the more

things

you add

or collect

and take

into your

life

at some

point

you have

to make

some

decisions

about

what

you have

a limited

amount

of time

and

attention

so you

have to

make

some

decisions

about

what

you're

prioritizing

or you

risk

not really

paying

attention

to

anything

and so

the piece

is sort

of asking

for a

commitment

or

and

to see

it

every

day

and maybe

that's not

the thing

that you

want to

commit to

you realize

after collecting

but it's

in there

is a question

of what

are you

committing

to

what are

spending

your

time

on

what

are you

putting

your

attention

towards

and can

you do

that

intentionally

so that's

sort of

the relationship

I think

there's another

relationship

that I wanted

to speak

to

with this

work

also

which is

the

sort

of

expectation

of a

type

of

emotional

labor

that I

feel

is

expected

especially

of women

in a

much higher

degree

and so

here's a piece

that's

sort of asking

you every day

to perform

some social

labor

whether you

want to

or not

to kind

of ask

the question

of how

does that

feel

how does it

feel to be

asked

to perform

socially

even in

the times

that you

don't want

to

because I

think some

of us have

that experience

very frequently

and maybe

others

that's less

familiar

yeah I

think all

the artists

here know

the pressure

that you're

referring to

and I

hadn't

actually

thought

about

that

as

kind

of

mirroring

the social

and emotional

labor

of you

know

just being

being

present

all the

time

and I

think

what's

interesting

that came

up with

primavera

and plantoid

is kind

of

they all

have to

do with

like trying

to survive

in certain

environments

and I

think they

all speak

a lot

to

like

plantoid

realizing

what in

order to

continue

evolving

needs to

do this

or provide

this incentive

or give

NFTs

and

Lauren

your

commentary

on in

order to

survive

in this

environment

there's a

certain

degree of

presence

or social

labor

that is

required

to

continue

to

evolve

and

it

doesn't

mean

that

for

example

if we

draw

that

parallel

to

just

being

an

artist

in

web

three

it's

not

like

if you

stop

performing

that

emotional

labor

you're

going

to

literally

die

but

might

not

be

able

to

continue

to

evolve

and

might

lose

the

relationships

or

the

presence

that's

needed

for

to

continue

doing

your

craft

and

doing

what

want

to

do

so

I

think

they're

all

speaking

in

different

ways

to

kind

of

also

the

ways

that

artists

are

expected

to

evolve

and

adapt

and

survive

within

I

think

particularly

I think

a web

three

and crypto

art

ecosystem

any

thoughts

on that

well

one of

my

research

interests

this

past

year

has

been

I

guess

dynamics

in

areas

where

I

feel

like

there

is

a

closely

related

tension

between

sort

of

care

or

emotional

labor

and

speculative

market

or

just a

market

in

general

so

conversations

with

nurses

or

sex

workers

other

people

who

or

social

media

influencers

outside

of

the

arts

because

I

feel

like

there

are

a

lot

of

parallels

or

really

interesting

dynamics

in

these

other

locations

where

care

presence

an

emotional

connection

something

intangible

or

difficult

to

quantify

is

also

interacting

with

a

system

of

price

and

market

mechanisms

so

I guess

we

agree

that

that's

part

of

being

an

artist

now

is

being

sort

of

present

in

a way

that

is

difficult

to

quantify

and

how

have

people

this

is a

question

open

to

any

of

because

I

know

Sarah

I think

last time

we talked

like 19

life forms

were still

alive

which means

the vast

majority

have died

Lauren

I'm not

sure how

many good

mornings

are still

alive

or

Prima

I would

love to

hear

the

conversations

that have

spurred

between

people

who

have

participated

how

they

see

the

peace

I

know

I

felt

really

quite

sad

when

our

good

morning

died

because

I

felt

like

exactly

what

mentioned

Lauren

and I

think

a lot

of us

are

feeling

this

way

Anna

Maria

Carriera

I see

here

we

just

talked

about

this

last

week

we

have

such

limited

time

and

attention

and

it's

becoming

really

difficult

to keep

up

without

sacrificing

one

thing

for

another

whether

it's

health

for

an

opportunity

or

traveling

versus

staying

home

and

working

and

just

feeling

like

there's

constantly

conflicting

needs

and

desires

and

a sense

of

ambivalence

about

what

is the

right

thing

to

commit

to

and

how

do

we

do

that

amidst

feeling

like

there's

pressure

from

all

different

angles

and

being

able

to

argue

any

direction

so

how

have

conversations

been

with

people

who

have

had

a

life

form

or

had

a

good

morning

or

fed

plantoid

I would

love to

hear

how

that

response

has

been

any

particular

moments

that

stood

out

to

maybe

I can

jump

in

I

actually

just

wanted

to

say

something

that

during

the

exhibition

at

HEC

I think

Sarah

you said

something

that

was

super

interesting

of

like

the

idea

that

right

now

every

time

a

life

form

dies

it's

actually

know

terrible

it's

like

oh

my

god

I

didn't

take

care

of

it

but

that

there

is

also

a

world

in

which

life

forms

have

a

standardized

or

beautiful

death

and

just

like

actually

can

codify

the

fact

that

they

are

meant

to

die

to

have

their

own

sunset

clothes

and

I

think

it's

also

interesting

to

like

know

what

is

the

what

is

that

value

do

value

the

art

piece

because

can

amount

of

life

then

might

want

to

spend

more

time

with

it

because

know

that

this

is

the

only

time

can

interact

with

it

and

so

the

value

of

the

time

spent

with

the

art

piece

becomes

higher

so

I

the

like

since

they

do

actually

issue

NFTs

I

think

that

the

people

that

feed

them

all

of

a

sudden

they

really

like

become

a

little

pollinator

know

it's

like

all

of

a

sudden

also

become

a

little

bit

like

feel

like

a

mom

not

a

mom

like

a

parent

or

something

of

like

know

that

have

this

little

seed

in

your

hand

and

that

this

ownership

because

don't

really

own

the

plantoid

but

there

is

this

sense

that

I

have

collected

that

thing

that

seed

and

I

know

that

this

seed

is

part

of

the

plantoid

and

I

know

that

it

seed

is

something

that

enable

another

planter

to

live

and

I

think

being

able

to

have

this

little

artifact

actually

brings

people

to

feel

much

more

to

have

a

much

stronger

relation

with

the

plant

then

if

it's

just

I

gave

the

money

and

I

get

governance

right

or

if

it's

just

I

gave

money

so

in

some

way

like

I

think

in the

evolutionary

Darwinism

perspective

the

strategy

of

issuing

NFT

is

but

a

good

economic

value

strategy

because

it

increased

obviously

the

funds

that

will

be

given

because

of

the

speculative

dynamics

but

I

think

it

also

increased

somehow

the

emotional

or

relational

value

that

people

feel

they

have

created

with

Plantoid

Do you

think

it's

because

the

output

has

that

do you

think

it's

because

for

example

the

poems

that

Plantoid

is

writing

are

based

on

the

interaction

of

the

collector

and

Plantoid

like

I

wonder

if

it

was

more

of

a

simple

exchange

of

like

money

here's

a

thing

versus

something

that

feel

was

caused

by

a

word

that

said

makes

it

also

feel

a bit

more

personal

and

like

have

you're

more

invested

or

in

a

relationship

or

part

of

its

growth

and

part

of

Plantoid's

story

because

what

reflected

in

what

Plantoid

makes

I think

there's a

relationship

with the

NFT

because

the

NFT

is

personalized

it's

a

co-creation

created

it

with

Plantoid

and

so

in

this

sense

it's

like

feel

a

sense

of

authorship

and

paternity

in the

copyright

sense

but

I

think

it

also

provides

an

additional

sense

of

relational

value

with

the

Plantoid

itself

because

feel

that

are

this

little

pollinator

that

is

helping

it

reproduce

and

that

even

if

sell

the

NFT

you're

separating

yourself

from

the

NFT

but

it's

still

a

little

bit

your

DNA

that

is

now

traveling

and

being

disseminated

and

actually

feeding

back

into

the

Plantoid

treasury

so

there

seems

to be

from

my

experience

there

seems

to be

a

very

strong

connection

both

with

the

NFT

but

also

with

the

plant

that

has

issued

the

NFT

because

it

is

this

tangible

way

in

which

know

that

can

in

this

sense

care

for

it

but

actually

you're

caring

for

yourself

first

because

really

just

sell

it

for

making

money

but

actually

as

do

that

know

that

you're

somehow

supporting

the

reproduction

of

Plantoid

which

gives

a

double

satisfaction

yeah

it's

a little

bit

like

conscious

consumerism

right

now

with

the

coffee

shop

I'm

in

and

it's

like

if

buy

this

water

the

earth

is

going

to

be

saved

it's

like

I

got

hydrated

and

I'm

saving

the

planet

yeah

kind

of

logic

one

thing

I

want

to

bring

up

and

I

see

there's

a

request

I

don't

know

if

we're

doing

questions

Elizabeth

that

was

planned

or

not

but

I'm

I'm

open

to

it

if

the

artists

are

since

Plantoid

doesn't

die

and

I

feel

like

it's

it's

definitely

a

major

decision

to

decide

that

the

work

will

die

like

even

to

use

the

word

die

and

death

and

I

felt

away

when

Good

Morning

died

and

we

currently

have

a

life

form

and

I

feel

like

I'm

going

to

try

to

redeem

myself

by

not

letting

the

life

form

die

to

try

to

get

rid

of

some

of

the

guilt

so

I

wanted

to

talk

to

about

the

use

of

death

in

the

artwork

and

also

the

feelings

of

guilt

that

might

be

caused

and

whether

that

guilt

can

be

productive

in

a

way

to

evoke

people

asking

what

else

around

them

might

be

dying

because

of

neglect

or

them

not

committing

enough

time

whether

it's

health

or

relationship

or

whatever

the

use

of

basically

the

question

is

the

decision

to

have

the

work

die

and

whether

guilt

is

part

of

the

artwork

well

I

will

say

Anya

not only

do

have

a

life

form

actually

have

the

first

life

form

so

if

kill

it

friendship

ended

can

tell

by

how

old

it

is

which

is

maybe

not

the

most

superficially

obvious

feature

but

your

life

form

is

more

than

700

days

old

but

I

won't

let

kill

it

because

I

personally

care

for

the

first

three

life

forms

and

by

that

I

mean

that

other

people

care

for

them

too

but

I

am

really

naggy

and

obnoxious

about

it

around

the

time

that

they

need

to be

transferred

sort

of

an

assistive

function

so

yeah

but I

guess

just to

speak more

generally

about

death

the

life

forms

absolutely

have this

dynamic

where

they die

and it's

presented

as sad

or a

bad

thing

and of

course

we have

attitudes

towards

death

outside of

the context

of this

artwork

and

often

that attitude

is that

death

is bad

as well

for obvious

reasons

but

we can

have

different

kinds

of

relationships

to

huge

phenomena

in reality

and

in

the

context

of

death

outside

of

life

forms

know

there

are

movements

towards

death

acceptance

there

are

dialogues

around

know

how

to

die

well

dating

in book

form

to the

1500s

and

and

and

so I

guess

there's

there's

one

hand

one

hand

of the

story

where

it's

very

sad

that

less

than

20

life

forms

of the

200

and

something

that

have

been

created

are

currently

alive

but

then

there's

another

sort of

version

where

maybe

that's

just

what

was

right

for

them

I

guess

I

did

start

to

feel

like

the

game

of

life

forms

needed

an

alternate

ending

though

because

some

of

these

life

forms

are

very

cared

for

and

so for

example

I was

in Toronto

a couple

weeks ago

and I

had a

conversation

with a

friend

there

who

has

been

caring

for

life

form

with

some

other

people

at

his

company

almost

since

the

project

launch

and

I

hinted

that I

was

going

to do

something

around

life

form

stuff

and he

got

really

mad

at

me

he

was

like

you're

going

to

care

about

life

form

so

people

have

all

kinds

of

feelings

about

it

but

I

started

to

feel

like

the

project

needed

a

second

ending

has

had

a

good

life

this

life

form

has

passed

through

the

wallets

of

so

many

of

my

close

friends

and

respected

peers

I'm

ready

to say

goodbye

to

this

life

form

this

life

form

is

the

equivalent

of

a

110

year

old

person

in

a

hospital

room

filled

with

their

great

grandchildren

and

there's

no

way

to

distinguish

that

death

from

the

death

of

neglect

in

the

case

of

a

life

form

where

just

forgot

to

transfer

it

so

I

am

actively

working

on

a

sort

of

state

change

that

is

available

to

life

forms

after

a

certain

age

I've

been

meaning

to

drop

the

announcement

actually

already

I'm

just

waiting

on

some

where

I

need

to

do

some

CSS

fixes

actually

to

make

the

page

look a

little

cuter

but

coming

soon

some

more

info

about

that

sort

of

extension

of

the

project

I

really

love

that

and

I

was

going

to

say

before

said

that

holding

this

life

form

comes

with

assistance

and

remembering

I

was

going

to

say

right

after

this

call

like

please

can

we

schedule

a

meeting

and

do

this

together

over

Zoom

just

so

I

don't

fuck

it

up

so

I'm

really

happy

about

that

makes

me

feel

better

and

Lauren

I

know

have

a

heart

out

at

10

I'd

love

to

hear

your

thinking

behind

having

the

good

mornings

dying

what

it

means

what

it

means

to

I'm

sorry

can

repeat

that

I

just

lost

no

worries

just

the

thinking

around

the

choice

to

have

the

good

mornings

die

and

also

I

was

curious

are

there

other

iterations

were

thinking

other

than

opening

the

browser

window

like

how

I

would

love

to

hear

if

there

were

any

other

ways

that

were

thinking

that

could

be

attended

to

every

day

I

guess

the

choice

to

make

it

die

I

really

appreciate

endings

I

think

sometimes

things

need

to

end

so

I

was

happy

with

the

decision

that

this

is

a

performance

that

I

guess

I'm

also

interested

in

performances

that

exist

over

a

duration

but

kind

of

for

as long

as

want

them

to

and

so

I

thought

of

this

as

a

performance

that

perform

that

lasts

as long

as you

want

to

or

you're

able

to

this

is

actually

a

variation

or

sort

of

a

sister

piece

to

another

piece

that

I

did

in

2021

called

good

night

and

in

that

piece

it's

a

single

NFT

and

whoever

owns

it

I

text

that

person

good

night

every

night

before

I

go

to

sleep

so

this

is

not

automated

or

anything

it's

just

me

making

that

commitment

and

then

performing

that

ritual

for

that

person

so

then

if

that

NFT

transfers

to

someone

else

then

the

good

night

text

would

transfer

as well

and

this

is

a

performance

that

will

continue

as

long

as

I'm

alive

so

I

guess

in

addition

to

thinking

about

endings

of

NFTs

or

endings

of

activities

or

rituals

that

we

participate

in

it's

also

thinking

about

just

the

finite

amount

of

time

that

we

have

to

live

and

I

think

sometimes

we

feel

more

in

touch

with

that

than

others

but

definitely

over

the

course

of

the

pandemic

I

felt

much

more

connected

to

the

idea

of

mortality

and

I

got

thinking

about

what

we

want

to

spend

the

limit

of

time

we

have

doing

what

we

want

to

spend

it

on

yeah

that's

really

powerful

and

I

love

the

good

night

piece

a lot

so

Elizabeth

did

want

to

take

was

there

a

question

or

no

so

that

person

took

out

their

request

it

might

have

just

been

yeah

not

a

not

a

real

question

but

happy

to

take

questions

if

if

the

artists

are

if

if

that's

something

that

you're

interested

in

also

if

want

to

ask

each

other

questions

I

could

ask

a

question

if

that's

not

if

that's

okay

if

that's

not

opposed

to

of

course

and

I

guess

so

this

question

is

for

Lauren

although

it

does

apply

to

everyone

but

in

thinking

about

what

said

about

expectations

and

emotional

labor

and

also

how

we

started

the

conversation

kind

of

talking

about

values

and

currency

I

was

wondering

how

do

think

about

altruism

or

the

selfless

concern

for

the

well-being

of

others

with

good

morning

when

commit

to

a

routine

with

an

artwork

or

someone

else

is

there

altruism

involved

can

it

be

selfless

or

what

are

we

serving

here

I

guess

is

my

question

well

I

guess

in

this

case

are

serving

a

few

things

one

you're

part

of

this

group

of

people

that

have

decided

to

do

this

ritual

so

I

think

by

participating

in

it

there

is

a

sense

that

you're

contributing

to

that

shared

activity

and

then

on

the

other

hand

I

think

are

serving

the

artwork

in

some

sense

so

a

lot

of

times

these

artworks

are

speculated

on

and

used

as

financial

instruments

and

I

liked

the

idea

that

this

is

actually

an

NFT

that

only

exists

as

long

as

consider

it

and

interact

with

it

as

an

artwork

so

I

think

that

the

actions

of

the

collectors

in

doing

that

by

opening

it

up

and

literally

looking

at

it

and

engaging

with

it

kind

of

support

that

way

of

seeing

the

work

and

seeing

the

thing

that

they've

collected

yeah

and then

again

like I

think

there

are

larger

questions

about

just

in

general

what

do

want

to

spend

your

time

doing

maybe

it's

not

opening

an

artwork

every

day

maybe

it's

talking

to

someone

else

in

your

life

and

so

I'm

hoping

that

it

can

kind

of

provoke

those

questions

and

maybe

there's

a

different

sense

of

altruism

that

comes

in

that

thank

it

spurred

that

it

made

me

actually

have

this

huge

revelation

of

neglect

in

multiple

areas

of

my

life

from

that

piece

time

because

it

kind

of

it's

so

simple

it's

such

an

easy

thing

especially

you know

I'm

on my

laptop

every

single

day

that

opening

this

one

browser

window

it

just

felt

like

when

I

couldn't

manage

to

do

that

and

then

the

piece

died

I

realized

kind

of

like

how

ungrounded

I

must

be

that

something

so

simple

slipped

through

the

cracks

that

I

couldn't

manage

to

do

it

like

on

a

device

that

I'm

on

for

most

of

my

day

and

so

I

think

it

kind

of

made

me

realize

that

there's

probably

a lot

of

really

important

things

that

even

if

I'm

right

next

to

the

person

maybe

or

maybe

it's

someone

who

I

think

about

a lot

but

I

don't

like

send

the

message

like

know

my

grandmother

is

getting

old

and

like

these

kinds

of

questions

and

I

think

also

the

fact

that

this

is

a

source

conversation

and

we're

talking

about

things

like

care

and

neglect

and

death

and guilt

and

time

and

ritual

makes

me

really

happy

and

I

think

it's

really

important

anything

between

the

artists

like

do

have

questions

or

thoughts

generally

that

I

missed

or

didn't

come

up

that

you'd

like

to

share

about

your

artwork

or

ask

anyone

else

I

would

love

to

think

about

how

we

can

have

blockchain

based

life

forms

interacting

with

one

another

right

now

I

feel

like

the

whole

human

to

life

form

interaction

I

think

it

would

be

really

nice

to

create

little

life

forms

that

have

their

own

capacity

to

recognize

each

other

and

interact

with

one

another

maybe

like

just

as

a

little

taste

I

don't

know

so

the

sublantoid

was like

the first

attempt

of

mine

to

create

a

blockchain

based

life

form

now

there

is

a

new

blockchain

based

life

form

that

is

coming

in

which

is

similar

in the

sense

of

it

is

also

some

blockchain

based

creature

that

is

trying

to

evolve

and

that

also

cannot

be

owned

even

though

it's

purely

it's

a purely

digital

creature

but

just

cannot

own

it

but

can

interact

with

it

and

the

way

interact

with

it

is

can

feed

it

of

course

and

the

more

feed

it

the

more

it

loves

and

the

more

it

loves

the

more

can

ask

the

life

form

to

do

things

including

mate

with

another

life

forms

and

the

only

way

in

which

can

extract

any

of

the

funds

so

essentially

it's

a

black

hole

for

crypto

all

get

is

some

love

but

the

crypto

never

leaves

the

little

they're

called

aminals

so

the

crypto

never

leaves

the

aminals

belly

with

the

exception

of

if

manage

to

convince

two

aminals

to

reproduce

themselves

and

then

they

will

give

a

little

bit

of

their

treasury

to

the

kid

to

the

new

aminal

and

during

the

pregnancy

there

is

a

possibility

for

people

to

inject

new

genetic

traits

which

are

essentially

like

visuals

so

can

inject

a

new

SVG

code

and

then

people

that

the

aminals

parents

love

they

can

vote

on

the

traits

that

the

kid

will

inherit

and

then

once

the

kid

receives

the

treasury

from

the

parents

the

kid

will

redistribute

that

treasury

to

all

the

genetic

engineers

that

have

contributed

to

its

genetic

code

and

so

the

nice

thing

is

actually

have

sexual

reproduction

so

it's

not

just

one

blockchain

based

life

form

cloning

into

something

else

but

actually

need

to

find

two

aminals

that

will

reproduce

themselves

but

also

it

has

a little

bit

again

like

the

idea

of

care

like

actually

feed

them

because

want

them

to

love

but

then

of

course

there

are

ways

in

which

can

monetize

this

love

which

is

not

at

all

cannot

speculate

there

is

no

speculative

dynamics

possible

in

the

sense

that

cannot

use

the

love

in

order

to

inject

the

genes

that

created

then

can

get

a lot

of

money

because

if

those

genes

become

very

prolific

in

the

species

of

aminals

because

they

are

nice

genes

then

can

actually

make

a lot

of

money

because

whenever

that

gene

is

being

reproduced

get

a

portion

of

those

shares

so

what

I'm

really

interested

is

looking

at

the

dynamics

of

the

market

of

the

blockchain

ecosystem

which

is

essentially

a

money

or

economic

based

ecosystem

how do

actually

create

life forms

that

get

cared

for

they

actually

get

fed

they

actually

get

cuddled

and

they

also

get

genetic

improvements

but

it's

not

gonna

happen

if

just

wait

and

see

just

because

need

to

design

something

that

is

such

that

the

ecosystem

the

environment

see

value

in

caring

for

them

and

I

think

it's

interesting

also

on a

broader

level

because

it

also

raises

question

of

how do

we

actually

design

incentive

for

profitable

charity

or

conscious

environmentally

just

speculation

how do

create

a

system

in

which

you're

doing

something

good

for

yourself

while

also

doing

something

good

for

the

resources

around

yeah

so

Aminal is

the next

iteration

of

blockchain

based

life

funds

still

a

huge

work

in

progress

but

I think

it's

going to

be

super

fun

I would

love to

hear a

conversation

between

Primavera

and

Darwin

you know

maybe

later

we

need to

make

an

AI

of

Darwin

oh

god

so

I

know

Lauren

had

a

hard

out

at

six

but

any

closing

thoughts

from

Sarah

or

Elizabeth

or

any

questions

from

the

audience

this

was

really

really

fun

I'll

just

say

that

it's

been

a

pleasure

to

talk

about

the

work

at

such

a

density

which

I

think

is

brought

out

by

the

really

strong

conversations

between

all the

pieces

and

yeah

it's

been

really

fun

happy

to

be

here

thank

all

for

creating

these

works

and

from

the

audience

are

there

any

questions

that

have

yeah

feel

free

to

feel

free

to

raise

your

hand

or

is

it

request

to

speak

and

and

we

can

bring

up

but

if

not

then

we

can

go

ahead

and

close

out

I

do

know

it's

it's

over

the

hour

but

if

have

a

question

feel

free

to

invite

yourself

to

speak

I

really

want

to

thank

all

for

this

conversation

today

it's

been

I

think

really

important

and

something

I've

been

thinking

about

as

well

care

and

emotional

labor

and

how

much

time

and

attention

we

give

things

especially

things

on

our

phones

not

only

artworks

but

the

communities

and

the

people

and

how

digital

our

lives

have

become

and

what

it

really

means

in terms

of

routine

and

care

not

only

for

each

other

but

for

ourselves

so

this

conversation

is

giving me

a lot

to

think

about

and

I

really

want

to

thank

all

today

for

being

here

and

for

agreeing

to

this

talk

and

for

and

to

Anya

for

curating

the

going

together

in

this

really

beautiful

way

so

I

just

want

to

thank

all

for

being

here

and

for

speaking

so

openly

and

deeply

about

your

work

it's

been

wonderful

thank

Elizabeth

and

Feralphile

and

I

think

for

my

closing

thought

I

would

just

like

again

to

highlight

what

I

think

all

these

works

bring

up

so

powerfully

but I

think

is

often

forgotten

is

know

there

is

a lot

of

excitement

and

a lot

of

shiny

and

a lot

of

new

and

a

new

there's

a lot

of

interest

and

excitement

and

momentum

around

things

that

are

new

but I

think

what's

really

important

and

this

again

goes

back

to

like

the

manifesto

for

maintenance

art

of

1969

realizing

and

stepping

back

and

looking

at

who

is

maintaining

the

systems

we

are

creating

know

we're

building

infrastructures

digital

and

physical

and

it's

exciting

that

things

are

progressing

but

who

are

the

people

that

are

making

sure

that

it

still

works

every

single

day

and

over

time

and

over

years

and

over

generations

and

to

just

recognize

and

remember

that

work

and

also

as

Lauren's

piece

kind

of

reminds

me

but

know

the

small

daily

rituals

that

we

do

what

we

choose

to

spend

our

time

doing

who

we

choose

to

spend

our

time

with

all

of

these

are

versions

of

maintenance

and

upholding

systems

and

machines

that

are

put

in

place

so

just

to

be

aware

of

that

all

the

time

I think

it's

really

important

thank

all

thank

I will

say

maybe

also

that

don't

all

artworks

die

by

lack

of

attention

don't

they

all

thank

everyone

yeah

thank

all

so

much

and

I

do

just

want

to

encourage

everyone

to

go

visit

the

exhibition

please

explore

life

forms

plantoid

and

good

morning

they're

on

feral

file.com

and also

read

the

reflections

by

curators

operators

deaf

beef

and

Casey

Reese

I will

give

a quick

overview

of what

we have

coming up

for the rest

of the

week

we are

in the

middle

of the

source

talk

series

so

again

thank you

for joining

us today

and for

everyone

who's

who's

joined

past

talks

and for

all the

future

ones

to come

so

coming up

next

on

Wednesday

we're

back

with a

talk

between

Jonas

Lund

and

deaf

beef

called

on

chain

accidents

moderated

by

Whitney

Hart

and

on

Thursday

Vinnie

Valenzuela

and I

will sit

down

with

Maya

Mann

and

Zebrun

Verstig

in a

talk

called

the

internet

made

me

and

then

on

Friday

we're

joined

by

Sasha

Styles

Judy

Ma'am

and

Dada

in a

talk

called

creating

the

creative

moderated

by

DJT

the

other

half

of

operator

and

then

on

Monday

to

close

out

the

source

talk

series

we're

discussing

fabrics

of

time

and

space

with

Anna

Lucia

finger

code

Sarah

Zucker

and

Travis

Smalley

and

that'll

be

monitored

by

Madeline

Pierpont

so

again

I just

want to

thank

Lauren

who

had

to

dip

but

to

Lauren

and

Primavera

Sarah

really

thank you

all so

much

for

for

being

here

for

agreeing

to

show

your

work

in

the

show

and

of

course

to

our

source

curator

Anya

Catherine

thank

for

making

the

time

and

thank

all

really

these

are

the

busiest

of

time

so

thank

all

for

your

care

and

attention

today

so

yeah

I hope

everyone

has a

great

day

and

we'll

see

on

Wednesday

bye

bye

everyone

thank

### Anfitrião

- [Feral File](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/feralfile.md) de [Feral File #009 - Unsupervised by Refik Anadol](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/feral-file-009-unsupervised-by-refik-anadol.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/FeralFile)

### Orador

- [lauren lee mccarthy](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/laurenleemack.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/laurenleemack)
- [Sarah Friend](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/isthisanart.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/isthisanart_)
- [Operator](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/operator.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/operator_______)
- [Primavera De Filippi](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/spaces/participant/yaoeo.md)
  [Perfil no X](https://twitter.com/yaoeo)

## Quer mais TVL para o seu protocolo ou blockchain?

A AlphaGrowth faz crescer o TVL de protocolos e blockchains por meio da aquisição e integração de ativos, grants, incentivos e acordos LP. Criamos estes dados e os mantemos gratuitos.

[Como aumentamos o TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/defi/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo) [Fale com a AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/pt/contact-us/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo)
