---
title: "Steak Panel: RaaS | Запись Twitter Space | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Запись Twitter Space от 2024-02-23 с участием Steak Capital, andy, Hilmar X, Katz 🌌, Amrit Kumar, Carsten Munk | CTO @ Zippie"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/ru/spaces/steak-panel-raas"
---

# Steak Panel: RaaS

Записано: Feb 23, 2024 Длительность: 1:07:09

## Запись Space

[Открыть оригинальный Space](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1vAGRvzERQqGl)

0:00 1:07:09

### Полная расшифровка

I'm inviting now all the guests, and we're going to start really soon.

Alright, I'm ready, you should be able to speak now.

Well, thank you.

Awesome.

Nice to meet you, sir.

Very nice to meet you, too, and thank you for inviting me.

Thanks for joining us.

Okay, also, Caldera should be able to speak.

Gelato.

Okay, you guys should have the rights.

Perfect.

Let's wait for, so let's wait, first of all, for Cartesi.

Yeah, Cartesi and Andy from Derola.

Let me also invite our state capital community.

Let me ping everyone.

While we are waiting for our other guests and more listeners to join us,

what's your view on the current market, guys?

How is your portfolio performing?

It's never enough, you know.

Huh? What?

Did you say, sir?

I said it's never enough.

Oh, yeah, yeah.

It's just the beginning.

I think we all need more ETH in our wallet.

We also need more gelato in our wallets, right?

You should have that.

Yeah, market is doing well for me, so I'm pretty happy.

I'm a normal person.

I'm a really basic man.

Market is green, and I'm happy.

Jinjin to everyone who is joining us.

Thanks for being here.

We are waiting a few minutes for Cartesi and Andy from Derola to join us,

and then we're going to kickstart the panel.

All right, I see Andy.

Not so hard, sir.

Well, Jinjin and Andy.

What's up, guys? Happy Friday.

How is your day going, sir?

Pretty well, now that you're here, big dogs.

Just getting ready for Denver.

It's a full sprint here.

We're flying out on Sunday, so very excited.

How about you guys?

Doing fine.

On my side, I'm pretty good.

I guess I can speak also for the other guests.

Everyone is doing well.

Am I the only one who's not going to Denver?

Me too. I'm not going.

FOMO is real.

Jinjin and Cartesi.

Nice to meet you, sir.

All right, so we are all here.

We've got Gilata, Caldera, Cartesi, and Outlayer.

And also the roll-up.

So I guess we can kickstart the panel.

And in the meantime, we are recording it.

And if anyone else will join us, we will be glad to have them.

So I guess we can start in the first five to ten minutes

with a brief introduction about each one of the speakers.

So we can go with maybe...

Let's go with Caldera, since I haven't heard cats talking yet.

Sure. Hey.

I also just want to make sure.

Am I coming through clear?

Am I audible?

Yeah, perfect.

Your voice is perfect.

Awesome.

Good to meet you guys.

Good to see you again, Handy.

And Amrit.

Hi, everyone.

I'm Matt, co-founder, CEO of Caldera.

Caldera is a RAS provider, just like everyone else on this panel.

We help people launch dedicated roll-ups using the Opie Stack,

Arbitrum Orbit, and the Polygon CDK.

We've been around for two years now, or almost two years,

founded in Q1 of 2022.

Since then, you know, we've built out a ton of infrastructure,

our capabilities, you know, of running roll-ups.

We currently have around five or six chains on Mainnet,

the biggest one of which is Manta,

which is the third-largest L2 in the Ethereum space,

but also have a bunch of other teams that we're working with.

Some of the ones you guys might know are Rarry Chain,

so like the Rarible NFT chain, Kinto,

which is a regulated KYC chain, Lute,

which is, you know, like the Lute chain for the Adventure Gold DAO.

If people remember Lute from last cycle,

you know, we've got a bunch more that we're working with.

Caldera, we really focus on kind of like having a hands-on approach

with the teams that we work with.

So we are often doing a lot of customizations to the chain.

We've done all sorts of things like, you know,

pre-compile support for custom gas tokens into roll-ups, et cetera.

And really, like, we're just trying to accelerate the modular space

and adoption of roll-ups.

So really, really good to be here.

Awesome, sir. Thanks for your introduction.

We can go with Gerato, maybe.

Sure thing, hey, guys. Great to be here.

Hi, Andy.

Hi to the rest of the Rasp provider,

good to see you, and won't be in Denver,

so we'll only be on this space here.

But we have a big team there, so if you are around,

definitely say hi to our booth in East Denver next week.

Yeah, so Gerato is Web3's sweetest roller service platform.

And yeah, we've worked together with projects that are using us for the roll-ups,

such as like Asta, who will be the first Polygon 3K chain launching on the act layout.

I think actually today, I think we're going to a production with them today,

so quite exciting.

LISC is another example for the AP Super Chain and many more in the pipeline.

And in addition to just operating the roll-ups,

how we sort of differentiate ourselves is we believe that projects need

like a proper end-to-end infrastructure solution

where the roll-up is just one part.

And what we've been doing over the past four years

is we've been becoming one of the, sort of,

also widely used Web3 developer platforms in the space,

offering industry-leading solutions around smart contract automation,

accessing off-chain data on your L2s.

For example, if you want to build like price oracles for your DFA applications

or if you want to push randomness on-chain for your sort of gambling

or gaming applications, as well as if you want to provide a really cool UX

using our sort of account abstraction services.

And yeah, super eager to be here and looking forward to the panel.

Perfect. Let's go with Alt-Layer now.

Hi, my name is Amrit. I handle operations at Alt-Layer.

We started off in 2021 and at the same time as many of the other,

I guess, RAS providers.

And we started at the time when OPstack wasn't actually there.

And so we felt like it would be good to have a way to be able to spin

Cosmos-style chains, but in the theorem world.

And one way to do this was to do basically launch roll-ups, right?

But because OPstack wasn't there, we actually built out our own implementation

of optimism, essentially, with fraud proof and everything.

And then a month later or two months later, I think, OPstack came into being.

So the point was that we started off as a stack builder, per se.

And one cool thing that we started with in the initial days

was this idea of what we call disposable roll-ups.

Basically, you could spin up a roll-up and you could destroy them

when you don't need them anymore.

So imagine something like arbitrary optimism where when you put,

let's say, state commitment on Ethereum, at that point,

you basically shut down the system.

Then we expanded, obviously, to RAS

because it was kind of a natural extension to what we're doing

with OPstack coming into being. Arbitrum orbit was there.

We put almost every roll-up stack out there.

Very recently, we started CKStack as well,

which is the stack from the CKSync team.

And the one feedback that we're constantly getting from our clients was,

hey, it's good that you can manage and run node and host nodes for us.

But what if we wanted to bring this whole infrastructure clean house

at some point in the future?

Or what's the way in which we could get our community more involved

rather than having a closed RAS vendor offering these services to us?

So we felt like it would be good to expand that service

and that domain as well.

So we started working on this idea with the IGLA team

that we call restake roll-up, where basically,

the idea is to take a certain stack like OPstack

and build a framework around it that allows people,

or that allows roll-ups to build certain capabilities around,

let's say, decentralized sequencing, faster finality,

interoperability, and whatnot.

So far, we have, I would say, 25 clients.

And the idea is to hopefully convert them to use some of the services

that we're building now under this brand umbrella of restake roll-ups.

Perfect, perfect.

That was a comprehensive overview.

Let's go with the last guest, which is Karthasi.

So I'm Karthasi.

I'm from the Karthasi ecosystem.

And what Karthasi is, we're a little bit different

than some of the other participants in this space.

We are an LTM that's capable of running Linux

and applications running on Linux.

We are very viable.

We're also kind of like big believers in, let's say,

distributed roll-ups as a service because I believe that

Blockchain and anything that falls with it

basically creates marketplaces out of everything.

So my belief is in the future, just like we're seeing with storage

and, for example, in Filecoin, that yes, you can deliver services,

for example, for storage, roll-ups, and so on.

The margins are going to go really, really low.

There's going to be real competition.

And people are going to find login.

We'll have a billion app chains out there that need these kind of services.

And we really have to be competitive in this market

as kind of like different companies offering services

because in the end of the day, these chains can actually potentially move.

Let's say take their service, let's say take their work

for your roll-ups as a service provider elsewhere

and basically go where they can get the best pricing, the best offering,

and I am loving it.

I want to see what kind of like the big competition

on the roll-ups as a service space looks like.

And I think it's going to be in distributed roll-ups as a service.

Perfect, perfect. Thanks, everyone.

Maybe also, Andy, you want to introduce yourself

for those who don't know you since we are going to co-host this panel together.

Yeah, definitely not as gigabrain and cool as these lads,

but we do a lot of education in this space

and a lot of fun conversations like this.

I know I've spoken to all four of these guys before,

and been in kind of like the earlier development cycles of rasps,

but yeah, just honestly ready to kind of kick this off.

And I think if it's cool steak, I'm just going to ask the first question,

which is basically like I'm personally quite excited

about the addition of all these elements of your rasps,

which is like alternative DA solutions, VMs,

different interoperability ideas.

I'm just trying to figure out how we can expand all of these rasps offers

and designs to incorporate every possible option.

And so the question is,

how are you guys thinking about incorporating different parts

of like this roll up stack into your rasps

and like what kind of like technical capabilities are needed for that?

And then also I guess is like why is there a demand for this?

Are you seeing this?

So are you thinking about this?

Are you seeing this and like how would this kind of work?

Maybe we'll start with Matt and then kind of if you guys have some thoughts,

just feel free to piggyback off of Matt and we'll kind of fill in as we need.

Sure. Yeah.

So I think and I want to make sure I'm getting the question right,

but basically what you're asking about is like with all the new developments

happening in the space, like how are rasps providers

kind of like integrating new things as they get developed?

Yeah, that was like a five part question.

But yeah, like how are you guys thinking about integrating all these different

like parts of the roll up stack that are coming out?

And is there is there, you know, demand for it?

Got it. Got it.

Yeah. So this is something that like we've been highly opinionated about

from the beginning of being like one of the first folks

to kind of be like an early adopter of all these new roll up technologies.

You know, I, you know, I guess all da you mentioned that right.

We were actually one of the reasons why we started the company

was we read the Celestia white paper before it was even called Celestia.

It was called Basie Ledger.

And that actually inspired us to build what we're building right now.

We've always been really, really bullish about all these modular components

of the stack.

We've been one of the first to integrate espresso on the decentralized

sequencing side.

We're having conversations with other teams in that space.

We're quick to adopt new roll up stacks, right?

The operating principle for us.

I think it's just developer choice.

So you asked about demand.

Like, you know, I think one of the really cool things about the crypto space.

Builders are highly opinionated and builders, you know,

like these things tend to be, you know, multipolar.

Some people will want the CDK.

Some people will want orbit.

Some people want, want the OP stack, you know,

and same thing for all the other da layers sequencing layers, etc.

orbit. Some people want DOP stack, you know, and same thing

for all the other DA layers, sequencing layers, etc. So our

view is just like, we want to give folks the most choice, we

want to take signals from the market as to like where where

we want to create demand, right? Because we, in a sense, we are

offering a certain wrapper around a certain SDK, right? And

so in the end, the underlying SDK provider is the one that

creates demand for us. And we become like the distribution

partner or the implementation partner for the underlying SDK.

So we kind of piggyback into less of the BD cycles or the BD

underlying SDK team might be doing. So for example, you know,

you could have a DAP builder that is very engaged in the

arbitrary ecosystem. And they want for example, certain, they

want arbitrary orbit with a certain configuration, for

example, let's say, the DAC committee that arbitrary office,

right? Similarly, for example, if you look at OP stack, they

have the own client base, or the DAP base that they track or push

towards us. So I think our role is one to facilitate, kind of

be a bridge between a DAP builder, and a certain SDK

provider, right? So we become then like a distribution partner

that helps those people who are building stacks to kind of take

off some of these, you know, requests and questions that may

come from these DAP. So imagine if you're building a DAP, and

you may have questions about how to set up a sequence, or I'm

not able to work this out, you kind of we become the partner to

help and solve these questions for them. Now, coming back to

the do the different conviction, yes, as men were saying, it all

comes from demand. So if someone wants, or if there's enough

demand for a certain configuration, so for example,

let's say, arbiter morbid with let's say, EigenDA, even though

they're not on, EigenDA is not on test many quite yet, we create

and we help in some cases actually build some of that

internally as well. So for example, we are closely working

with Eigen team on making sure that the end to end system

actually works. And we have tested that internally before we

can go and offer to our clients. So sometimes it's of course, the

underlying team understands the stack much better than we do. But

in many cases, we can provide a helping hand. Because we know,

in many cases, the demand that's coming from the clients, right?

So the answer is yes, we see all sorts of demands where people

asking for a certain VM, asking for a certain DLA asking for a

certain, you know, shared sequencer and whatnot. And our

goal is to kind of piece them together, you know, and then

together and provide them to them in life.

Awesome. I would like to take it up, take it up from here and ask

you since you said that RAS are not the are just the distributor

partners, so the bridge. Like my question is, when you are

developing your idea, right? When when is it like better? How

can I say it? Basically, let's let's say it like this. I have a

friend who wants to build a tokenization platform, right? And

he said, I want to build my own layer to and I reply to him.

Look, there are some rest solutions that make it easier

for you to build your own roll up. So my question is, when is

developing your own roll up a better solution than building

your idea on a constantly dated chain like Ethereum? Like when

is it better to go with RAS rather than building your idea on

established chain?

Yeah, maybe I can start it, but I don't want to take too much

time. So I'll let others speak as well. Very quickly, I think

it there are different factors that come into play, right? One

is, in many cases, you want strong composability with other

dApps, right? And at least at this point, interoperability

across roll ups is not that great, right? And so if let's

see if you're thinking about, let's say a DAP, email is I'm

like uniswarp, right? Which requires strong composability

requires strong liquidity that comes from different places you

you'd rather be and you should rather be on a general purpose

chain like Ethereum, Arbitrum, Optimism and others. The

scenarios where you would like to customize because, for

example, they're gaming applications where people have

built fully on chain games where the game contracts so complex or

let's say so heavy in the sense that even if you like it's so

big in the sense that you can't even go and deploy that on a

general purpose chain because of the limits. So you have to have

an infrastructure or platform where you can customize some of

those limits so that you can even deploy those contracts on a

chain that you that you have that you want to run on. So I

would say they're different because I think in some cases,

there are considerations on you know, I'm close to a certain

community and therefore I want to use that specific stack

because I want to have my own chain. So I think and then of

course, you know, the ability to let's say capture value and

mother is so I would say there are different considerations

that I get, but I'll stop here and let other people chime in as

well.

Yeah, maybe maybe from my side, I think it's all about how

mature the project is. If you're just starting out with an

idea, then you should definitely go to like an existing public

sort of general purpose chain such as like polygon POS or

arbitrum optimism mainnet. Why is that? Because, well, you just

have to write a smart contract, you deploy it. And most

importantly, you have all the infrastructure on these chains

that you need in order to get going, right, you have indexes,

you got oracles, you got funders, paymasters, all these

kind of things that are deployed on these chains. And you don't

have to rebuild or get these infrastructure providers onto

your L2 that you're spinning up, because they cost money to

support your chain. And as a figure just starting out, you

probably want to minimize cost, right. But as you grow, as you

get adoption, and as you might have raised some money, maybe

you even have some revenues in your in your app, then at some

point, it will make a ton of sense to move to your own L2,

you can have much more control over the throughput,

customizations, we had mentioned around like custom gas tokens,

you can think of token utility, all these kind of things come in

very handy. So I see it all as like kind of like evolution of

your project. And like the first sort of phase of the project is

probably not starting on an L2. Like maybe like our hope is that

in like a couple of years, you actually everyone can start on

their own L2 and you can have all the infrastructure deployed on

there from the get go something that we are very sort of focused

on on our side, we want to sort of make it as cheap and as easy

to spin these up so everyone can do it. But relatively right now

this is not the case. So we're still in the we're still in the

world where only more well funded projects can actually

afford to have their own L2.

For sure. On that note, some of the projects that you guys are

seeing like we don't really see and I say we like state capital,

the roll up people, traders, speculators, investors, etc. We

see things as they're like already, you know, like done in

past development stage, you guys kind of get these projects that

like some of the early stages. I'm curious what some of the

interesting innovations that you guys have seen that are like

coming to market soon. Is there like, like I've heard rumors of

something like of like infinite TPS or like a roll up that it

doesn't have gas or I can let or Emirates got these restaking

roll ups like like what are some of the innovative roll up team

ideas that you've seen recently? It that you know that you can

share that you feel comfortable sharing that like are exciting

that are a bit different than just kind of like the typical roll

up. And maybe I'll start with you, Hilmar, if you have an

answer.

Sure thing. So we are very bullish at gelato on zero gas

roll ups. So basically, finally getting to a user experience

where you don't have to deal with like holding native assets

anymore, you can just click buttons, you can just send

transactions without having to pay for gas like this, this is

an issue that we have been like dealing with or trying to solve

also on public blockchains for like, three years now, roughly.

And one of the reasons why we excited about that too, this is

because it gives you superpowers as an application developer to

actually finally have these sort of gas, zero gas roll ups or

zero gas blockchains or applications. And this, of

course, opens up a lot of possibilities, it greatly

enhances UX, but it also sort of introduces challenges, right?

Because like the holes, like these public blockchains that

everyone can access were actually built in a way where

hey, gas is a sort of spam protection mechanism, how can

you actually avoid just people going crazy, you know, with

airdrop farming, people just love to spam networks, and not

pay for them, right? So you have to kind of get creative here and

try to solve these issues. But it is really worth it. And yeah,

we are we are just super bullish on this, because you can

imagine, if you think about like a deck, so like a perp decks,

right, that will, we have one that will soon launch on our

Aeroplastic Service platform. And it can really get very, very

close to a centralized exchange like trading experience, right?

You go there, you click a button, you place a trade, it's

like sub second latency, no gas has to be paid. But it has all

the goodness of an L2, self custody, you can exit. If it's

a ZK roll up, right, you actually can have sort of

economical exit to the L1 very quickly. And yeah, all these

kind of goodies come come to you and your in your customers. And

yeah, this is, I think, one of the really cool ones. And there

are many others. But yeah, I'll let the other guys here also.

Maybe I can add an observation that I mean, it's probably

visible, but not that visible quite yet. Which is especially in

the context of Eigenle and restaking, you could see that,

you know, you have, I don't know, at least five, if not more

LRT projects out there. For those who don't know, you

basically stake your Ether or you mistake your LST and you get

this token that's called LRT. Essentially, it's a token that

represents your position. And so basically, basically, what

we're seeing is a trend of people, people, people building

a new roll ups for those that are not specifically. So my

feeling is that every LRT project will have its own role.

We have another guest, right? Yeah, my son is no worries. No

worries. All right. I'm curious to hear Caldera and Cartesi

about this topic. If you guys have any opinion?

Yeah, I think basically, the fact that that we can use

Ethereum as a trust anchor and kind of like do all these

different LVM opens up completely different

possibilities of what we consider applications today,

like, like, one of the most famous things I'm most

excited about that's kind of going on at the moment is that

that is essentially possible to run a bunch of parallel with

five machines in this particular case, run actual calculations

of LVM making kind of like AI like style stuff. And I also

like to touch just a little bit on the zero gas thing just for

the moment that zero gas is amazing, but there's always a

cost to be paid. And because there's a cost to be paid, in

this particular case, I think it will end up with very quickly

that the chains are paying their service providers a little bit

like, let's say an association plays their lawyers or their

bank, in this particular case, and they can also fire their

service providers. So I think that as more of these kind of

things where the chain is kind of like the one paying for what

the app in this particular case paying for the users

activities, we'll see more and more that let's say, that

change will act more sovereign in this particular way and not

care particularly about let's say what a role of a service

that may be attached to, because it will be close to

associations, there will be more closer to governance, more

closer to upgradability. Because even if we're looking at stuff

like average from today, I mean, it's basically a governed role

up in this particular case, and stuff like with the stylus has

made it to mainnet yet because still passing through governance

in this particular case. So I think we'll see many innovations

not just to carry technology, because I mean, there's lots

of technology out there. But there's also a lot of innovation

we need to do around governance, because we end up very

quickly and why should I trust your role up as a service

company around my services?

Yeah, I don't have too much to add to what was already said. I

think, in general, like, we're also just very excited about

execution layer changes. I think, you know, people when we when

we started the company a couple of years ago, we were very

bullish about the idea of people making little

modifications to the roll up, you know, custom pre compiles,

changing, yeah, the gas logic, as mentioned, maybe using a

different token for gas. And like now it's starting to, you

know, I think people are becoming more comfortable with

those types of modifications. And we're starting to see that

come into fruition with some really, really cool designs. I

think like one thing to highlight as well is is sort of

like native yield generating assets, blast has kind of really

opened up the floodgates there. And we're seeing a lot of folks

building sort of like similar constructions on top of the

roll ups that that we're launching.

All right, sounds good. Sounds good. I will throw at you a more

specific question right now, which is about the next

Ethereum upgrade, the IP 4844 or Duncan upgrade? That was more

of a personal question, because I was really curious about it.

So I have basically read that even after this upgrade, I'll

do layer tools will have lower gas fees, and etc. Posting data

on Ethereum in general will keep being too expensive, or at

least it will keep being too expensive, compared to other data

availability solutions. So my my doubt was, is Ethereum

automatically out of the discussion when it comes to data

availability layers and scalability? Or what do you guys

think?

I think that I think that the next Ethereum upgrade is

fantastic, because we get the point evaluation pre compile,

which basically opens up ability to evaluate KCT

commitments, which is what this whole prototype sharing kind of

like helping in this particular case. But I think that because

the aging P2P network of the Ethereum, the data availability

of things like espresso and Celestia and so on, for most,

let's say roll ups, I have chains out there, it's just

going to be much better for them to kind of use that directly.

And, and I think that there will be a fight, let's say

between, let's say the bigger roll ups that are posted to

Ethereum to basically occupy these blocks, blocks that are

being posted to Ethereum space. So I don't think it's going to

make a big difference from, let's say, relevant service

point of view, because many different teams will probably

make a small difference for, let's say, bigger roll ups. But

it just makes some things like, let's say optimistic data

availability evaluation easier, but I don't see it as much of a

benefit otherwise.

And I believe that I think whatever space comes becomes

available, it will be taken away quite quickly. I think every

single time we have seen that when Ethereum gives a little

bit more scalability to dApps, that gets consumed quite

quickly. So I believe that, you know, of course, there are more

upgrades that needs to be done to Ethereum. But my my thinking

is that whatever comes after the upgrade, I think that will

completely get absorbed quite quickly.

So will you guys just automatically support that

upgraded version? Like, is there anything that you guys have to

do on your code base or like just update some? Like, yeah,

like, honestly, above my head, but like, how does that work for

you guys, after the upgrade work goes through?

Should be pretty seamless, at least on our end. I mean, one of

the great things about using, you know, existing roll up

stacks is like, you know, the OP team and the polygon team and

the arbitrary team, they they've all kind of handled, you

know, making sure that that their stacks are compatible with

the upgrades. So for our customers, it's going to be a

pretty quick upgrade.

Nice, cool. Yes, it's interesting. And for the

listeners, and also for everyone here, there's been some rumors

about like, Ethereum L1 fees being reduced in some capacity

because of Dancun, but from my understanding, it's just Ethereum

L2 fees is like the key recipient of the lower fees. Is

that correct? There's nothing to do with the L1 here, right? Or

kind of, is there?

Well, probably, and maybe there are some sort of gas changes in

this new update, which I'm not aware of, but I guess what they

could be referring to is that all the like, if you look at the

sort of gas guzzlers on L1, most of them are actually like L2

sequences, right? So Avogem, optimism and all the other L2s,

they're spamming Ethereum with a ton of transactions and using

sort of like the regular block space for data availability,

which is just crazy expensive, right? And basically, what

happens now, there's this new plot market coming up new space.

And these L2s are planned to move to that new sort of new

space that gets available for them. And this means that the

demand for block space will be greatly reduced on Ethereum. And

obviously, usually what happens is that they sort of get eaten up

again, to an extent, but like, since L2s have been consuming a

lot of space on Ethereum, fees in general should go down for

the foreseeable future until like, bigger apps come out there

that sort of consume them again. So I think maybe that's what

they're referring to.

Yeah, makes sense. Cool. Stik, do you have another question? I

know that you had a couple.

Yes, yes, yes, absolutely. So the next one was more about near

near the layer one, which I have seen again, that is competing

with Celestia and Ethereum for the leader in the data

availability sector. So I just wanted to hear from you guys.

What's your view on near Celestia? And how do they

compare to themselves? Since I'm not a technical person, so I

was just curious to know your your opinion about them.

I haven't dug deeper into near but I think near DA is is

basically near L1.

They've had it live for a long time.

Yeah, so I have a bit of contrarian opinion here,

probably that that I don't really see, let's say, the DA as

relevant, especially as things like icon layers coming out,

because the data availability space changes so completely.

Celestia got to some extent, lucky that they're kind of like

pre restaking in this particular case, but they're not actually

at security going into data availability, just be so much

more intensive as restaking and EBS has kind of come along. And

I think it's worth noting that quite a lot of kind of like

projects actually that are doing data availability at the moment

kind of started out a little bit as a layer one. Like for

example, especially was doing something that basically where

they found out that it had extremely good properties for

data availability. And then combined with restaking, basically

you get the security that you need. But I think that basically

that it's, it's maybe a little bit late to the game, say to

maybe a little unfairly.

But I have a theory on, you know, the, the, the usage of DA, I

believe that when a DAP, like from a DAP perspective, the entry

point is usually an execution layer, right, so stacks. And my

theory is that eventually many of these stacks will be, and by

the way, if you look around almost every single stack, it

already has some sort of a DA, I mean, it's not maybe a celestial

idea, but everyone has some sort of a DAC built in, right. My

theory is that a lot of DAPs, their entry point will be an

essential layer, so basically a roll up stack. And they will

eventually decide where or which DLA gets used. So if let's say

for example, if I'm arbitrary orbit, or let's say OP stack, or

whichever stack you pick, there's very little, I mean, of

course, there's, you know, importance to be more important

to be modular and whatnot, and giving people flexibility and

whatnot. But from a business standpoint, it feels to me that

from a roll up stack perspective, there will be, if

they do end up building their own DAC, or some some version of

DA that captures value for the token, or some some some sort of

value capture, it'd be difficult for the roll up stacks

to push a certain DLA. But what I mean, a certain DLA, like an

alternative DLA that's not a part of their, their inherent

stack per se. So I'm not sure how the whole thing will play

out, maybe Celestia will win, and you know, along with other

DLS. But from business perspective, it feels like a

stack, a roll up stack is the entry point, and they end up

deciding a lot of other things that goes down the line.

Yeah. Yeah, it's an interesting take. Um, yeah. So do you, do

you think that that, like, do you think it's gonna be a

political game? Like, or is it like a who's in like, like, who's

lobbying who or who's kind of supporting you, like, like, in

I don't know if there'd be that, but I mean, I mean, at least you

can see that, for example, Celestia has its own roll kit,

which is, which is basically an execution layer, I think avail

is building its own some sort of execution layer as well. So it

does feel like, you know, DLS are building something on the

side, you know, to bring execution, or to capture that

brings the dApps eventually. Because in the end, both

exhibition layers, and let's say, DLS, they both have the

common, I guess, client or user base, which is basically dApps.

And my feeling is that almost every single DLA will end up

building some version of stack or be aligned with some stack.

And the other will will happen where the stack provider will

potentially be aligned with some specific DLA because they like

them or whatever, and they will promote it. So there will be

something of that kind, even though, of course, everything

more modular, you can still go and use or be stacked with any

any DLA you want. There'll be some some, I think, game or

business game that will get played eventually.

Yeah, I think I agree with that. There's an incentive for

execution there. And framework developers to sort of push their

favorite data availability layer if it's like their own one, or

if it's just like another one they're part of with, I think,

I think that will probably happen. I think also, I think

what's important is like the whole point of like, the A is to

make it very, very cheap, right? So I don't think the A layers

from just like a sort of revenue or fee generation point of view.

So much like settlement layers are like interesting businesses

per se. And obviously, they're very important. And they're

hyped up. But you I think you need to, like, create a more

end to end solution in order to actually service customers and

then sort of have recurring revenues that makes sense. And

in general, like what what is happening and what should happen

right is that sequencing fees will go down dramatically, data

availability costs will go down dramatically. And why is that

because well, we are sort of commoditizing block space and

making it very, very cheap to build scalable secure by free

application, which is great, right? This is the whole point

of why we're doing this. And where the real sort of value

lies at the end of the day, is it wasn't like the only scarce

resource in this industry, which is liquidity, right? So people

will want to fight over this already happening, right?

Everyone's fighting over liquidity in the space. Because

if you have liquidity, then you have network effects. And this

is what people really want. It's why theorem is still the

kingmaker, even though it's very inefficient, and it's it's very

expensive. But it has all the liquidity and liquidity attracts

other liquidity, and we're still building the internal value here.

So yeah, I think that's, that's probably and yeah, and you have

to figure out as a project how to be close to that.

I think it's also very interesting to see that that

let's say the different data bill, both layers to some

extent have a different problem in differentiating as it very

close easily go gets down to kind of like cost of data

publishing, let's say the amount of bandwidth, the settlement

times and so on. I mean, I mean, it's fantastic from a competition

point of view, because I mean, I'm all here for the gigabit per

second, kind of like data availability for applications.

But we have seen already that let's say the difference

between let's say, I can do a and let's say, for example,

on a stack level is actually not that different. Because

basically, people can almost use the exact same software and

just change on the sequence on this particular case, how we

deal with it, and it's going to play out very, very

interesting in the overtime as well, I think.

I mean, if I may add one little thing to this, when I guess

conversation is, as far as I can see, almost every single

integration that has happened between, let's say, DALA and

certain, let's say, Rolex stack has been on the fork of that

stack. So far, it has not been integral part of the stack,

right? So the stack doesn't offer that natively, is what I

mean, right? It's always a part of a fork of OPstack that

offers, let's say, some other DALA, right? So I think that's

also important to basically see how that evolves over time

where how OPstack offers a more generic interface that

allows people to integrate but stays in the kind of mainnet

setting, not a kind of fork setting so that the main OPstack

framework. And in a way, to be modular and to be much more

open, to be much more transparent, to be much more

neutral, they have to offer, all these Rolex stacks have to

offer that common interface that other people, other DALA

providers can plug in. But at the moment, at least, it's

not the case, as far as I can see.

All right, all right. Let's go with, so thanks for your

comprehensive overviews and opinions. It's pretty

interesting to hear you talk about this topic. And

my next question is actually about, I'm not sure if you

have any opinion about this, but I would like to throw it and

see it. So it's about the Bitcoin ecosystem, right? There

is stacks, you know, the protocol, which is making its

Nakamoto upgrade in, if I'm not wrong, either in March, so in a

month from now, or either in April. And yeah, my general

question was, what do you think about the DeFi ecosystem on the

Bitcoin chain? Could we see our development similar to what we

had with Ethereum in 2020, with the DeFi summer and all that

development on Ethereum? And eventually, I'm not sure also,

if you guys have ever planned to integrate somehow Stacks SDK,

I'm not sure if Stacks has its own SDK, but if they do have it,

have you ever considered to integrate it? And yeah, in

general, what do you think about the Bitcoin ecosystem and how

it's developing since it has grown pretty, pretty much over

the last year with ordinals and all these, all the many

updates? Maybe, yeah, Kurt, I see that you want to.

Yeah, I know. So I've actually been dabbling around with things

like bit.vm. I can't speak to Stacks in this particular case.

But basically, let's say off-chain computation is pretty

much coming to Bitcoin, but there's a lot of restrictions

because of Bitcoin script that kind of makes things difficult.

But because of things like that, basically, it can take almost

up to 35 weeks for, let's say, a verification game to kind of

like proceed on Bitcoin. And it kind of like hinders quite a lot

of useful applications. But it has become possible as of, I

think, 14 days ago, something like that, that people were

actually running with the verification with zero

knowledge proof. And I think that will allow a lot of very

interesting applications combined with, for example, data

development players, or let's say on-chain posting of

Bitcoin. But there's very little amount of teams out there

that are actually doing something actual practical on,

let's say, Bitcoin roll-ups. There's some very excellent

Telegram channels called roll-ups of Bitcoin that I

recommend people can attempt. And I think that it will be an

interesting space, but the bottom line kind of like Bitcoin

script is really hindering quite a lot of things. And the

good work that for example, as doing a random op-cat is quite

important also to make famous solutions in this space. But

it's a, I mean, there's a lot of interest because obviously,

like let's say the payment fees and transaction fees and

Bitcoin are going down and people want to kind of like have

something that actually let's say make use of this Bitcoin

network as well. So let's see how it turns out.

Yeah, I'm also quite bullish and interested in like the

Bitcoin L2 space. I haven't looked at anything in

particular, but like from a thesis kind of level, it seems

to make a lot of sense. And in a lot of the sort of like builder

founder communities I'm in, I'm seeing like more and more folks

building on Bitcoin, you know, things like ordinals, NFTs,

stacks, etc. I think like the thing that we're seeing and one

of the bets we made, you know, early on as a company is like

to be very, very strongly tied in with the EVM just because

that's where, you know, a lot of the developer activity is.

And I think like that's sort of played out, you know,

the cycle like a lot of the innovation is still happening

on the EVM. Of course, we'll have all PMs, but it's very hard

to like get an all PM to critical mass. You have, you

know, maybe like, you know, you have Solana and then you have

like the MOOC ecosystems to some extent. Cartisi might be a

special case because you guys, you know, support existing

programming languages. So I think that's really cool too.

But the thing that gives me a lot of pause in the Bitcoin

space is it seems like a lot of these developments are

happening. They're trying to kind of make their own thing

and they're happening separately from a lot of the

developments that are happening in the Ethereum space.

And I think it might be hard to, you know, convince

developers to switch onto an entirely new platform with

entirely new language. I think that's one of the limiting

factors for stacks. But regardless, like I'm very

interested in it and it does seem like things are starting

to coalesce there. I just want to add one thing about that

over the VM. In, let's say in the bit VM community, and let's

say roll up space, people are more interested in what has

kind of like been good in the Ethereum space as well as they

are, let's say, so much at the Ethereum. So that's, for

example, Chainway, which is kind of like built the EVM Bitcoin

roll up with that. So there's definitely groups that I like

pushing in that direction for developer adoption.

Awesome.

Well, since Kat's told, you have just mentioned

old VMs and said how Cartesi is like a special case apart

since they allow for existing programming languages. Like I

wanted to understand from Cartesi, why does having a

Linux virtual machine, if I'm not wrong, gives you a

competitive advantage somehow, like I'm not a developer, right?

So yeah, I just want to.

So it's both an advantage and disadvantage, right? Because

that's, that's, from one point of view, I mean, everybody here

is kind of like begging the same 23,000 EVM developers to

basically get to a solution, right? But the thing is, the

pie of developers is not growing growing anymore. And my stance,

at least, is that why does this have this space has to be so

completely different from computing? I mean, why can't it

be more like actually, let's say, using the last 60 years of

let's say, let's say, computer science understanding,

compilers tooling languages, instead of, let's say, the last

what, seven years of almost high priest like languages like

Solidity and EVM, why people can't just at this particular

point in time, write things in Rust, or C++, or the

JavaScript, etc. Because we really need more developers

with more data, more innovation, because now we have no excuse

for execution environments, we have no excuse for data

availability, we have no excuse for costs. So if blockchain is

anything worth, we should be able to get these developers in

and Solidity and EVM is not it.

Well, I missed the last five seconds. Sorry.

Yeah, sorry, my interconnection was bit off. But I was basically

saying that that if we want to kind of grow the pie of

developers, basically, I don't think that Solidity and EVM is

it anymore. Like, we are trying and we are trying to push, but

it doesn't happen anymore. And that's where we think we have an

interesting, let's say, advantage in that regard.

Okay, okay, I got it. So the Linux VM is like a solution to

grow the pie of developers. Yes. Understood, understood.

Interesting. I think if you know, the whole point of the

rule of centric roadmap in the team context is that it allows

people to move execution out of it. The moment execution moves

out of it, it gives you the liberty and flexibility to

experiment with other things, right? So I think it's it's it's

natural for us to say, okay, well, Solidity is something that

maybe not the best language out there in the world, but this is

something that people have gotten used to. But now that

you're moving the execution out of it, you can actually

experiment. And that's kind of the reason why we are seeing,

you know, people building, you know, different kinds of VM,

and potentially could be attached to with him. For

example, there was this EOSM project, you know, back in the

day, that was completely scrapped. No one did anything.

And now, it wasn't based on getting a new revival. So I

think that rule of centric roadmap has also pushed some of

that, you know, hidden, I guess, I guess, you know, idea that

you should have different kinds of VMs. And I think that has

definitely been enabled by that.

Yeah, I mean, I thought this tweet the other day, yesterday

was like, let's onboard 50,000 or more new non crypto native

developers to the space by the end of this year by by the

beginning of 2025. And through I wrote it, I was like, hmm, that

seems a little bit unfeasible. But then I was like, we have so

many people that are building the space. And, you know, we've

been kind of in the dumps a bit with the last bear market, as

well as just lack of different technologies outside of

Solidity and EVM. I mean, I don't want to count out all the

other ones that have done a fair job of paying and incentivizing

developers and using non solidity languages. But for the

most part, this EVM, EVM centered conversation, I think

generally speaking, it's, it's a, it's a feat that the broader

space should aim to get to whether it's your project that

does its part or another project is able to onboard a ton

I think for the broader idea outside of all the

technicalities, the core reason for why this this this

conversation about Bitcoin roll ups about non EVM about, you

know, DA and all these things, I generally think that it's for

the core focus of onboarding more developers into crypto, I

think that we're like very focused on like new users and

new consumers, which I think is great. But I think that

onboarding more developers through these technologies,

kind of like what Carson saying with their specifics, as well

as all the other options, and then getting these, these

developers, the tooling that each of your projects are

working on, and being like, hey, like, build cool shit, like,

like build something that people will want to use with the

infrastructure that we provided. And so it's it's if you think

about it as a numbers game, if the goal here is to make some

really, really hit consumer applications and to really grow

the space forward, each rest provider is effectively could

be thought about being valued or having value if the roll ups

that are launched on the rest succeed in, you know, a big way,

right, whether it's a direct monetary, whether it's a brand

association or all the above, and a combination of other

factors. So how do we kind of take the amount of shots on

goal, we we increase the developer capacity, bring them

into these rest providers, and then let them build cool shit.

And so to kind of bring this full circle, I think a lot of

this non EDM capability outside of all the technical

parallel parallelization, formal verification, op codes, all

these things, it's, it's like, okay, let's bring more non

crypto native devs into crypto, and let's give them a shot.

And let's let's take more chances with more manpower. And

so that's kind of like my non technical bullish thesis on

like, why non EDM is is important. And, and I think a

lot of projects should focus on that developer kind of looking

front. So, and rant.

All right, that was a great explanation and opinion. So yeah,

thanks also to you and I really liked your perspective.

So now I guess we are pretty down with my questions, at least

from my side, I don't have any, the thing else to ask. I'm not

sure you and if you have anything.

Yeah, I mean, like, what's the most exciting thing that's

happening in each of your projects right now that you guys

are super excited about? And if you can't share like direct

alpha, like what's something in the space that you're very

excited about? Or both maybe Hilmar, Matt, Amrit and Carson,

let's end on some optimism.

Yeah, let's start let's start the we like to call it the rest

battle or the pitching session. So each one of you guys, if you

want to share any alpha development, bullish metrics,

whatever you want about your project in like, two to three

minutes.

Yeah, I will start I have to bounce now as well. I've got

another call. But yeah, I think what I'm bullish on is, we are

seeing enterprises starting to adopt L2s. And not like only

web-renator projects, we are onboarding the first couple

right now. And these are really just like big companies in a

traditional space that are now seeing roll-ups as a technology

that could actually leverage to build their first web free

application. So super bullish on this. Also on like compliance

point of views, L2s are very interesting for them. So yeah,

that's kind of like my bull case right now. And thanks a lot

again for having me on the on the panel here. I need to

unfortunate to bounce. So thanks, guys.

Yep. Thanks. Thanks, sir.

Yeah, maybe I'll go as well. Because I also have a meeting

that's starting right now. Yeah, for us, as I mentioned

previously, the most bullish thing is just the level of

experimentation that's happening. I think like developers

are getting more and more comfortable with a stack,

they're getting more and more comfortable with making

execution level changes. And we're, you know, we're seeing

it with blast, we're seeing it with, you know, teams that are

trying to integrate like native randomness functions, or native

account abstraction, or, you know, like native, native yield.

And it's just like, there's, you know, that one of the

questions I think people had, like, you know, three to four

quarters ago was just like, with all these L2s, are they all

going to be carbon copies of each other? What is there going

to be any technical differentiation at all? And I

think what we're seeing is like, we're going to, you know, very

quickly move into a world where like, you know, credibly, there

will be hundreds of roll ups, and those roll ups themselves

will all have like different technical selling points that

like users can then choose, choose between. So very, very,

very excited for how the space is heading. And yeah, I got

around as well. But thanks for having me on. This is really

great. For us, we are very excited about, you know, the

IKLA ecosystem, I think it has just started. And recently,

it was yesterday that they announced the, the ACCC fundraise.

So we are building in that space. So we are definitely

excited about what's happening in the IKLA ecosystem. And we

also are very bullish on kind of open ras. So ras where you

don't have vendor lock-ins, ras where anyone can come and

become your sequencer and whatnot. So we definitely are

very bullish on IKLA and how that changes role of landscape.

Yeah, so just to kind of like finish off, like, like, like, I

remember what I'm going to say about like, really excited

about what we stick to IKLA enables. I also look forward to

seeing what one of the first things we're working on is

basically a Linux VM co processor in this particular case,

because if you can stick a real, general purpose virtual

machine in pretty much anything on L1 or L2, a similar kind of

pillow places, it really changed about, let's say, the

speed of which we can make these kind of like fantastic

experiments. I'm also excited about the fact that that with

things like espresso and Eigen DA, and so on, so let's just

like, like, we get this kind of like massive amount of block

space. And then like, we actually now we have a problem

that we actually need to figure out what we actually want to

fill it up with. And yeah, just in general, kind of like really

bullish about that, that this is a place where I think

especially I'll be able to really especially shine because

we get these properties that we wish we had from the start.

All right, all right. Maybe Amrit you wanted to finish?

Or you wanted to add anything else?

Okay, I suppose no. So I think we are done for our panel was a

really interesting one. A lot of insights and alpha. Andy, do you

want to ask anything else add anything? Can you hear me guys?

Is it is my mic functioning? We can hear you. Okay. I thought

I was talking with myself. So I guess we are we are done.

That's it. So thanks for caldera and I forgot the name.

Who was the other guest? Actually, caldera and gelato. Yeah.

They actually are not here, but thanks for them joining us.

Thanks for Cartes in our layer to join us. Thanks for Andy

as a representative of the Rolak for joining us. Thanks for all

the listeners. I hope you enjoyed this panel. And before

closing, I will just pitch briefly what state capital is. So

basically, state capital is both an alpha community, an alpha

gated community, and marketing and advisory agency. We run

these panels every week or every two weeks where we invite

the leaders in every sector of the DeFi space to come and

discuss the their relative sector with us. We have we have

the last panel. Today we had the LRT fighter is taking the

perpetual decks and many others and we run also AMAs with

individual projects. And as I said, we are a marketing and

advisory agency. We are pretty vertical and focused on

chaos management marketing advisory in terms of go to

market strategy, narrative creation. And yeah, that's it

about us. If you want to join our community, if you're

interested in discussing with like minded deejans, investors,

traders, builders, we have any kind of person inside of our

community also Andy is in our community. So if you want to

join us, just fill out the form that you can find in our

website. And yeah, that's it about state capital. That's who

we are. And thanks again for everyone to join for everyone to

to be here. And yeah, I hope you have a great morning or

afternoon or evening or night, whatever you are in the world.

Also stay safe, don't get clapped by the market and see

you around. Thank you very much for inviting by the way. Thank

you everyone for listening in. Alright, have a great evening

night day afternoon to everyone. See you.

### Ведущий

- [Steak Capital](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/spaces/participant/steakcapital.md)
  [Профиль в X](https://twitter.com/SteakCapital)

### Спикер

- [andy](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/spaces/participant/ayyyeandy.md)
  [Профиль в X](https://twitter.com/ayyyeandy)
- [Hilmar X](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/spaces/participant/hilmarxo.md)
  [Профиль в X](https://twitter.com/hilmarxo)
- [Katz 🌌](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/spaces/participant/0xkatz.md)
  [Профиль в X](https://twitter.com/0xkatz)
- [Amrit Kumar](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/spaces/participant/maqstik.md)
  [Профиль в X](https://twitter.com/maqstik)
- [Carsten Munk | CTO @ Zippie](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/spaces/participant/stskeeps.md)
  [Профиль в X](https://twitter.com/stskeeps)

## Нужно больше TVL для вашего протокола или блокчейна?

AlphaGrowth наращивает TVL протоколов и блокчейнов за счёт привлечения и интеграции активов, грантов, стимулов и LP-сделок. Мы собрали эти данные и держим их бесплатными.

[Как мы увеличиваем TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/defi/index.md) [Поговорите с AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/ru/contact-us/index.md)
