---
title: "ArbitrumDAO | Plurality Labs highlights | Twitter Space Recording | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Twitter Space Recording from 2024-01-23 with Arbitrum (💙,🧡), Arbitrum Core (💙,🧡), DisruptionJoe.eth (🤖,💙), Popescu Razvan- ZER8🧠, shawn16400, AnaTech.eth, Feems"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/arbitrumdao-plurality-labs-highlights"
---

# ArbitrumDAO | Plurality Labs highlights

Recorded: Jan 23, 2024 Duration: 1:04:45

## Space Recording

[Open Original Space](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1gqGvQDrLzRKB)

0:00 1:04:45

### Full Transcription

We need to kind of step up our game

on how we professionalize those components of it.

And you mentioned using the Pareto Principle

and getting it close enough.

So in a past life,

when I worked in a pharmaceuticals division,

it's like, you had to have the period in the right place.

And if you didn't have the period in the right place

on the document, your operations could be shut down.

How do you manage the Dow world,

which is kind of like the wild, wild West,

and trying to get closer

to a professional sustainable organization

so that an investor might come in and say,

you know what, I see what you're trying to do.

I don't need accounting level details,

but I need to believe in what you're doing.

Joe, how do you think about where you go

from having that accounting level detail

to we're building this thing as we fly it.

How do you manage that?

And I'm asking that question a lot

for the people who are listening to us now.

And if they've got projects that they're trying to fund,

if they've got ideas that they wanna fund,

how do they balance getting the,

giving people the details and the,

versus just building the thing and making stuff happen?

You know, first, I think you have to look

at the reality of the situation.

Like we're not, you know, just like delivering another KPI

for like the middle of an organization

with a hundred thousand people.

We've all seen companies like Johnson & Johnson

or Proctor & Gamble or whoever,

go and try to buy innovation.

They'll buy a hundred startups

and they'll kill the innovation at every single one of them.

We know there's a fundamental trade-off

between like the innovation that is required for startups

and what is required for those types of organizations.

So when we think about the reality of this situation,

Arbitrum is a cutting edge technology

in one of the fastest growing markets that exists.

It's highly competitive and it moves fastest all get out.

So if we're gonna keep,

help and be a part of the solution

to keep Arbitrum in the lead,

if we're gonna keep fueling financial sovereignty

and spearheading this evolution

of decentralized technology and governance,

we are going to need to keep our foot on the gas

and be on the edge, right?

Innovating and bringing new solutions.

That's just fundamentally where we are

because there is nobody who can say

that for sure Arbitrum's going to be in the lead,

whether you're referring to against other L2s,

other L1s or even the technology like leader

for just scaling people's access

to digital public infrastructure

that is credibly neutral and not owned by one corporation.

That's where we wanna get to.

So the reality is we have to put our foot on the gas

and take the 80 20s

because anytime you're building a company

that's a startup and you have competitors

and you have other markets that are moving against you,

you have to keep your edge on the innovation side.

That is fundamentally why nobody else has been able to do it

is because you have that experimentation

and freedom to be able to do it.

And if what you do is you take your foot off the gas

and say, hey, we're gonna spend the majority of our time

dotting the I's and crossing the T's,

well, you're not looking at the big picture

and the field right then, right?

So it's a very delicate balance.

But what I would say is you have to keep your investors

happy, they have to be communicated too well

and understand why you're taking the risks

and trade-offs that you are.

So in the Dow case, that's your delegates.

One thing that we didn't do well was,

we didn't hire a dedicated communications person

with a nice cycle and cadence where delegates could know

every month, here's the decisions we're making,

here's why we're making them

and here's the outcomes we're expecting

and the impact we expected to have on the ecosystem

if we are successful.

And then here's where we were successful,

here's how successful it was, why, how we measured it

and what the impact actually was after each one.

So there's that little piece of advice

for like the startup people.

I am the one who's gonna keep the foot on the gas

and I'm always gonna select the bigger, go bigger.

Cause I think that's what like the startup side

of this needs and I think anybody looking at,

even plurality labs should be looking at,

okay, we gave them a seed investment.

They have given some 80, 20 solutions on some things,

but they've gone way over on a lot of other things here.

Just like a startup in your first investment,

you don't necessarily know, you could not write down,

these are the exact things we're gonna do

over the next six months.

And to your question, Sean, around like,

in that company, I was expected to dot every I

and every period must be perfect.

That's why those companies can't innovate, right?

So.

Yeah, it's, gosh, okay.

So we're covering so much Joe, this is such good stuff.

I wanna take a pause here and say that if there's anybody

that have any questions that's related to the grants

programs at Arbitrum, and that could be the foundation

program, we can try and field any questions there,

how to get a grant at Arbitrum.

We can talk a little bit about that, but more specifically,

if you've got questions about how Plurati Labs has executed

any of the challenges that we've run across,

go ahead and feel free to raise up your hand

and I'll ask Fiends and Anna to help pull you

into the conversation and we'll have some time

for some questions, some Q and A.

So if you got a question, go ahead and raise your hand up,

ask to be a speaker and Fiends and Anna

will help pull you up.

But in the meantime, Joe, I told you

I was gonna ask some hard questions.

And Joe, let's say then, right?

One of the hard questions that I've heard

or one of the things that I've heard is that

Plurati Labs or Joe has captured the Dow.

And what that means is like people would say,

hey, if you want a grant, you gotta go talk to Joe.

And if you can talk to Joe, you can get a grant.

How do you respond to that Joe?

I think it's hilarious because let me tell you

a quick story about this.

There's a grant that went out to a company called Sidechain

and Sidechain was just giving out NFTs

to every attendee of New York City's Winter Jazz Festival.

This is a huge win for arbitrary being used

in the real world, right?

You know, there's word on the street

that they're gonna be doing some of the major festivals

this summer as well, which could be really cool.

Now, Sidechain is somebody who was pushed over

to talk to me about grants.

Why did the person send them to me?

Well, they sent them to me because I'm out there

talking to people in the ecosystem.

I'm leading workshops consistently.

I'm communicating with people in the Dow

and the delegates and have a pulse

and mostly because I'm willing to.

Like when you refer somebody to go talk to somebody,

are you gonna refer them to the person that never responds

or are you gonna refer them to the person

that you know will take that time, right?

And so people send them to me

and then I try to figure out what is best

for them to be successful in our ecosystem.

And Sidechain got that grant after two months of me

making introductions with the Offchain Labs,

partnerships and technology team.

You know, when they came to me,

they were thinking they were gonna build on optimism.

And I told them why not?

I introduced them to a partnerships person from Offchain.

They showed them technology reasons

why they would wanna build there.

They said, okay, well, what kind of support would we have?

And I introduced them to the foundation

and the grant they got was from the foundation.

And I ping the foundation every two weeks,

hey, what about that Sidechain?

They look really cool.

Are we gonna get them?

And finally, I was super happy

when I saw that grant came through.

So the reason I'm telling this story

is people are sending them to us

because we're some of the only full-time people

that are paid by the doubt

that are 100% invested in Arbiturum

and have the time to work with everybody.

And we have the name recognition that people can say,

hey, go talk to them.

In addition to that, like I said,

we had 12 programs that we ran

and only two of them were managed by us.

And those two were very specifically needed

and caused outsized impact.

The STIP likely wouldn't have happened

if the Firestarter program wasn't there.

And the open block labs work,

monitoring STIP likely wouldn't have happened.

There's a lot of little pieces where we saw gaps

and we're able to help out.

And we just figured,

whether it's doubt building or granting or whatever,

we're allocating resources to this ecosystem.

And I can't find one good explanation

that says we shouldn't allocate the funds

or try to find grant programs

that will allocate funds towards the most immediate

and dire needs of the doubt.

So whatever that need is,

that's where our programs should be funding.

That's what a pluralist program should double down on

is solving the most impactful problems, whatever they are.

Joe, I'm glad that you brought up that example

for Gavin and Sajjan,

because the other piece of this is that

it doesn't matter kind of which meeting that we go into,

it's like the,

I think there's a lot of goodwill around the work

that Clarity Labs have done, right?

But I think a lot of that goodwill comes around to the fact

that there are examples of Gavin and the Sajjan, right?

And Sajjan, how much, I don't know,

I don't even know how to add it,

but how much extracurricular work did you really do

that was not related to delivering

the Clarity Labs promise?

It's like, if you could point to a couple of the work

that got underway, what else did you do?

Because at some point in time, Joe, I'm like,

what are you doing when you're focusing on this?

But what are the conversations that you pulled into?

Joe, you're on mute.

Joe, you're on mute.

Maybe I'm on mute.

Bean, am I on mute?

No, I can hear you.

Let's see.

Oh, there you go.

I got muted.

Yeah.

Go for it, buddy.

No worries.

That was weird.

Yeah, in December, I took a week

and met for a full hour with 20 different delegates.

And then have probably done that again this month.

But I've also spent a good number of time,

you can look through the crowd here

and there's Klaus, there's Miggy out there,

there's Alex, there's Jordan on the analytics.

There's plenty of people who are contributors

in one way or another who I will take the time with

and try to find a way to get them paid,

get them involved, get them whatever it is

to be a part of this ecosystem.

And there's hurdles to it.

And it sometimes, you see people doing good work out there.

Like for example, when Joseph was working

on the ARC proposal or the ARDC proposal,

the procurement committee,

he's putting a ton of hours

and maybe when he goes into a forum and shares a DAAP,

people might put a thumb up on it, like one thumb up.

And I'm seeing he's putting like 10 hours a week

to make a fair thing and progress the DAO.

That's somebody we need to get paid.

So sitting there and talking to the different people

who are in the ecosystem and making sure

that we're not losing talent,

before trying to attract the top talent,

we got to not lose the talent that we have today.

And we lost top talent already

and talent that we had today,

they had to go and find another job somewhere,

that they've gotten burnt out

because of the requirements of how much it takes.

It's almost too much.

And this is part of the reason,

people don't understand that building this framework,

it's not being the program manager.

We don't want to be operators in the DAO.

We wanna facilitate the DAO

in helping it to build itself

in ways that will sustainably decentralized

and create value and be efficient.

So when we're thinking about like how this works,

I said there was a lot of complexity

around the 12 programs that we did.

And what we wanna do is narrow down

and find somebody who can maintain context

around specific high level like priorities.

We all know bringing builders and developers to Arbitrum

is a priority.

And we've done countless workshops

and different things on calls and telegrams

where people say, hey, here's a great idea,

here's a great idea.

But who actually is paid full time by the DAO

to call it all of those ideas and prioritize them

and present them and let us vote on if there's a need.

Like right now, we have to rely on somebody

who obviously has self-interest

thinking up a proposal,

doing all the discovery work in four months for free

and risking like reputational damage and personal attacks

to go and be able to give value to the DAO.

Why can't they just show up to a Dwork space or a GitHub

and see that there's these things that they can do

and get paid a fair value if they do it well today?

Why can't they do that and double down and participate,

get paid and level up with their skill right away?

It's because we don't have somebody

holding context in between.

So that's when we talk about like work streams,

it's like we need to actually relinquish the role

of being the program provider

and even being the program manager

in the two programs that we were

and continue being the facilitator of the framework

and have these work streams be the allocators.

Because this won't scale if it's just us, right?

We need those work streams to take the lessons that we learned

and now there's four groups that are scaling.

But what if they wanna fund the same things?

Well, you need a framework and a governance process

that says, well, this work should come over here

and be allocated to this work stream

and the credit to go to them

so that we don't have redundant work

both at a grantee level and at a program level.

That's what the framework for the pluralist framework does

is make sure that at every level,

the grantee, the grant programs themselves

and the program providers are all equipped

and coached to scale and not have those redundancies.

So I think that that makes sense

and I recognize that like the process

that we've been trying to do is to like

create a pluralistic mechanism

so that we can allocate money in as fair a way as possible

and using many different mechanisms

so that we get the best ideas out of people.

Let me stop here as like, if there's any questions,

have anybody have questions about the proposal

or a question about what we're trying to do,

please go ahead and raise your hand.

We've got time for a question or two.

But Joe, before we do that,

I think it was 11 days ago,

you dropped the proposal on the forum

that was ultimately asking for 30 million ARB.

And actually, let me take that.

It's like the outline of the proposal with 30 million ARB,

but you even put in a temp check to say,

hey, how big should this be?

And people could go into the forum

and discuss that like a different ideas, right?

And we had a ton of traction on it

and a lot of people participating in that.

Where do we go from here, right?

And I know it's a 30 million ARB proposal.

But where do we go from here?

I mean, how do we get this thing across the line

or what are some of the next steps

to get a decision on this?

It's a big proposal and it takes time

because we have a very sophisticated

and thoughtful group of delegates.

The power is pretty well spread

that there's no one delegate

who really makes that decision.

It could be better spread,

but compared to most hours,

you have to get 10 or more people

to really endorse this

before you can even think about moving forward, right?

And part of that comes from talking to those people

and part of that comes from the community speaking up

and sharing their sentiments as well.

Our next step is really to make a decision

on what we should put to Snapshot,

which is either letting the community decide

how much we should allocate

or putting one idea up there

that is best interpreting and combining

and creating compromise of what we've heard.

We have to make that decision.

We've definitely gotten a lot of feedback

and there are some things we can change

and some things that we just didn't communicate

the way that we want to.

But fundamentally, we can't move this forward

as just us doing a small grants program,

which is where one side of your delegates wants us to go.

I think the vast majority want us

to just go with the full amount

and it goes to a multisig with a bunch of delegates anyway,

so it makes it slightly more accessible.

It's not like it all goes into a lab's pocket.

But the fundamental problem that Arbiturum's having right now

that could cost them everything in the Dow at least

is that they have one decision-making modality.

And we've seen that when somebody goes to the Dow

to put up a proposal,

the politics and the culture as it is,

it takes that when they say

we need another decision-making modality

for governing X thing,

it pops out the same answer of this council

plus a paid multisig and all these things.

What it doesn't do is come up with novel

and different on-chain ways

of selecting what should be allocated,

creating different allocation strategies

and different accountability strategies.

Ideally, the Dow should be set up

kind of like a chess board

where every piece is protected.

There's an accountability behind each one

and there's an X move like planned.

And we absolutely don't have that on-chain yet.

And there's no way to design that

where you need like constant,

small iterative design changes

without someone having the freedom

and flexibility to experiment.

And that's really what Ferrari Labs role

as this framework architect

is that we actually have many different decision-making

modalities that we can experiment with.

And when one of them is successful,

the Dow can choose to use it in other things.

Like for example, if we decide to fund a program,

let's say we want to fund applications

that are on NoSIS safe.

Like I always get pissed off

that CowSwap isn't on NoSIS safe.

If you look at my tweets like once a week,

I'm like, hey, CowSwap,

how can we get you to deploy on Arbitrum?

But imagine there's like 30 or so apps that are there

that other people probably wanna use.

And we said, we're gonna put 10K per application

that's not on in a pot.

And then we're gonna use quadratic voting

where all the delegates can put their conviction

on which one they want the most.

And so maybe some of them like CowSwap

end up getting 50K and others get like 2K.

Have you seen that done before?

If you've seen that done before, put a thumb up.

Like has any ecosystem done that to attract applications?

Now, the thing is, that's a novel way of doing it

that also could be potentially applied

to step or other future grant incentive programs.

There's data-driven techniques and so forth.

And none of these are accessible to the Dow right now

because that one decision-making modality that they have

keeps popping out this council.

And we have the opportunity to provide the access

to these different ways of doing things

that can provide better outcomes.

I love it.

And Joe, I think kind of to your point earlier

is like there's so many of these different modalities

that we're trying to execute.

And I think the license is to try and continue

going down this path, continue with the execution,

doubling down on what we know is working well.

And I think what you said

as far as the proposal goes is the next steps for now

are to decide how big is the scope

that we take to Snapshot, get it on the Snapshot,

get community, some sort of community consensus on it.

And then from there, go on to take it to Tally

for an agreement with the community.

Does that sound right?

Yeah, and this should happen in the next week.

Hopefully by the end of the week,

we have something up on Snapshot

because right now we're kind of at the point

where we've had all the conversations we can have.

And there are some people, some delegates

who are on one side of the spectrum

and some who are on the other side of the spectrum.

And we're trying to catch up and make sure

that we have that at every I across every T.

But there's also like the reality of,

we are about as long as to the end of this month

and that's what we have payments for.

So like the Arbitrum ecosystem,

they also deserve us to put something up

and make sure that we keep active

and are funded to continue working

if that's what they choose.

So it has to happen this week.

Yeah.

Cool, okay, so we're gonna wrap up here

in just a minute or two.

Let me do a quick pause.

Themes, are you connected?

Because I knew you had a bit of a,

you had a bit of a rough connection earlier.

Do you wanna do kind of quick summary

of like what action steps we're asking people to take

in terms of what I think joke race is coming up.

We've got more on thank ARB.

Anything that people in the community should be aware of

and be looking out for in terms of the execution

for our grants programs.

Yeah, absolutely.

So as you mentioned, there is a joke race contest

for this week on Play to Earn Reimagined.

You don't have very much time to apply and submit.

I'd also like to thank our decentralized council

for participating and providing valuable feedback

to our program manager, Diana, who's leading the program.

Along with that, we have a thank ARB contributions

listed to the active initiatives

such as completing a survey on CARMA

from the grants that are already there.

Kind of one that would maybe be best

is that if you wanna review CARMA itself,

CARMA also has a profile

that has been completely completed.

On Thursdays, we will do an onboarding on CARMA gap

for grantees and reviewers.

And of course, we would love a request for comment

on our current milestone to proposals

so that we could reiterate and also provide something

that is valuable to the Dow.

Oh my gosh, thank you very much for that.

So plenty to do, plenty of ways to get engaged

in the arbitrary ecosystem.

Remember, we're on our way to let 3 billion crypto users

and we think ARB is one of the ways to help us get there.

Joe Feeney, Anna, is there anything I forgot to ask?

You guys hit me up, let me know if the guy's missing.

Yes, there is one thing,

and it wasn't you forgot to ask,

but I just wanna really clarify this.

We've been pretty effective and efficient

at distributing funds specifically

because we've been highly targeting Dow needs.

We're not funding just whatever happens

to get through AIP vote.

We're looking at needs and assessing the needs

and then funding things based on that.

So we've talked about the friction of somebody

being able to bring a vote to the Dow.

So how many great builders are just scared away

by that process?

And what we're able to do is sensitive the needs

and actually fund those things.

So I think we're like a super important R&D partner

in the way of both like optimizing for speed

and learning in the ecosystem.

And we're like a partner to the governance process,

but we don't wanna be the governance process.

We can move fast, we can experiment,

we can acquire data and decentralize

our terms contributor pool in ways that are possible

for the current governance mechanism to do,

but that do make it possible for voters

to have a much better sense of our needs,

what's working, how we should grow.

And therefore we can find the competency at the edges

and get them involved and get the community involved

in ways that unlock potential.

There isn't another equivalent option right now.

And I think it's really important for us

to continue this work.

I mean, it's a good point if you look at,

there's only been a handful of proposals

that have actually passed on Snapchat.

And if you look at the number of proposals that have passed,

the even fewer of those are actually related to

treasury disbursement, so it's a good point.

Cool, okay, hey, Joe, Annie from your side,

thank you so much for allowing us the time

to come into your space and your time

and to talk about the work that Plurality Labs is doing.

We do have more Twitter spaces planned,

especially to talk about some of the great grantees

that we have underway.

But, Anna, we really appreciate the time

and everything that you and Patrick and Cliff Clifton

and also Andrea and the entire team at the foundation.

So thank you for all the work

and being such great partners as we've gone through this.

I think we've all learned a lot

and you guys, the foundation,

has been a great partner to help us learn through this.

So I really appreciate that.

Okay, I think that's it for us, back to you.

Yeah, of course, I totally wanna thank you all too

because you've been doing a lot of stuff

in the Arbiturm now helping to get,

at the end, building Arbiturm together.

So yeah, it's very cool to see you and have you here.

And yeah, thank you, Fims, Sean, Joe,

here, Sarah, as well, for coming and talk

about all the impact that you've done

and for sure all your learnings.

For everyone, I just want to share this team,

the Prairie Labs team, they shared a proposal

in the Arbiturm now since months ago,

like in June, 2023 to build this grant program.

And they have a lot of initiatives there.

So yeah, now they have a new proposal.

So it's time for you, the community,

to go have a look in the proposal,

give your feedback when it's time to vote as well.

And for sure, if you have other ideas

to create a grant platform, a grant framework,

you can go to the Arbiturm now and suggest it.

There is actually a proposal

where the Arbiturm Foundation can help you

to fund it, and let me put it here.

But yeah, thank you everyone for joining us today.

It was a great conversation, to be honest.

And yeah, hope to see you in a new AMA for sure.

And thank you for building the Arbiturm now

and Arbiturm together with us.

It's been a blast.

Let's freaking go.

Thanks, guys.

Thank you, everyone.

Thank you, Paul.

We'll see you next week.

Thank you, Josh.

Bye, everyone.

Thanks, Josh.

Bye.

Thank you, everyone.

Do you have any questions?

I don't have any questions.

I will call the police.

I know.

I do.

Do you have any questions?

Do you have any questions?

Do you have any questions?

Do you have any questions?

### Host

- [Arbitrum (💙,🧡)](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/arbitrum.md) from [Arbitrum IOU](https://alphagrowth.io/arbitrum-iou.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/arbitrum)

### Speaker

- [Arbitrum Core (💙,🧡)](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/arbitrumcore.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/arbitrumcore)
- [DisruptionJoe.eth (🤖,💙)](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/disruptionjoe.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/DisruptionJoe)
- [Popescu Razvan- ZER8🧠](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/zer8_future.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/zer8_future)
- [shawn16400](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/shawnlgrubb.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/shawnlgrubb)
- [AnaTech.eth](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/anatech_eth.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/AnaTech_eth)
- [Feems](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/feemschats.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/feemschats)

## Want more TVL for your protocol or chain?

AlphaGrowth grows TVL for protocols and chains through asset acquisition and integration, grants, incentives and LP deals. We built this data and keep it free.

[How we grow TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/defi/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo) [Talk to AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/contact-us/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo)
