---
title: "ATOM Tokenomics: AEZ Growth & Alignment | Twitter Space Recording | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Twitter Space Recording from 2023-09-26 with ATOM Accelerator, Eat Healthy Get Rich, riley.stride 🦸, Noam Cohen, Zac Cheah, D, jehan, Spaydh 💧✴️ | Consensus 🇺🇸, Max Einhorn (🥧 , 📈)"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/atom-tokenomics-aez-growth-alignment"
---

# ATOM Tokenomics: AEZ Growth & Alignment

Recorded: Sep 26, 2023 Duration: 1:31:52

## Space Recording

[Open Original Space](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1BRJjPzYRMaKw)

0:00 1:31:52

### Full Transcription

It looks like we now have no remarks added to speakers.

I'm just going to give it a few minutes for people to join the space and then we'll dive

in with some introductions, et cetera.

I think perhaps if we kick off with some introductions now, it'll still give time for people to join the space and not miss too much.

Noam, would you mind just giving a quick introduction to yourself and also kind of what Binary Builders are doing in relation to the tokenomics grant that they're going to be doing?

Yes, absolutely.

Yes.

Yes, absolutely.

Hi, everyone.

My name is Noam.

I work at Binary Builders.

We're the primary maintainers of the Cosmos SDK and we run the interchain builders program and we have a company called Numia.

We do analytics.

And so, yeah, we've recently been awarded a grant from the AADAO to do some work on the future of the hub, the tokenomics specifically, and we're working on three modules.

One of them we'll be discussing today, the Atom Alignment Treasury, and the other two.

One of them is called the Developer Revenue Incentivization Program or the DRIP, which is a better way to do community funding basically, which I'm posting that on the forum this week.

By the way, for those interested.

The other thing we're designing is a stability reserve fund, which is basically a way of saying when Atom is doing well in USD value, we put some Atom aside.

When Atom is not doing so well in a bear market, we use that Atom to pay for some of these basic expenses that we hold very valuable, such as our validators and maybe some critical development costs.

Yeah, and so the Atom Alignment Treasury is a whole different thing, and we'll get to that once we're all here and ready to get started.

Max, I see you keep dropping up and down, so I don't know whether you will be able to speak, but it'd be great just to get a brief intro from you and also explain TimeWave in relation to some of this.

We can get into the details later, but just a quick intro would be great.

Hey, everyone. My name is Max. I'm one of the co-founders of TimeWave.

TimeWave is an offshoot of the Cosmos Hub white paper.

I was one of the co-authors of that paper and the lead architect of the itcher chain allocator from that paper.

With TimeWave, we wanted to make sure that we learned the right lessons from that Prop 82 note with veto and the ideas in there.

First of all, it was just a lot of ideas.

And second of all, they were pretty big and out there and they could have been more specific.

And so at TimeWave, what we're trying to do is create the most specific, the most actual things right now that allocate capital more efficiently within Cosmos and the broader interchain.

We are starting out with covenants, which are Dow to Dow, blockchain to blockchain, economic agreements.

We can get more into what that is. And so, yeah, that's TimeWave and myself.

I've been in crypto since 2017, and it was actually Cosmos that inspired me to YOLO into crypto in the first place.

I was really inspired by the ideas in it, in the original white paper, was re-reignited my passion once IBC shipped and I started to see what was happening.

And so for the past year and a half, I've been exploring how to be of most value to this community.

And Allocator, TimeWave is my and my team's best bet on how best to do that.

Awesome. Thank you both very much.

We are expecting both representatives of the Stride team and Neutron to join us.

However, I think that everyone knows them well enough that they can probably just join and dive in without an intro when they eventually get here.

I know that there may be reasons why they're running slightly late.

So I guess without too much more sort of stalling on my part, it would be really good just to get into sort of some of the nitty gritty.

So really looking at growth within the atom economics zone.

And I suppose it's kind of one of the key thoughts that's been doing the rounds recently is around protocol liquidity.

So I wondered if that would be a good sort of starting point in terms of what sort of why do we think that that why does it seem that that is playing a key role in what we anticipate will drive growth within the atom economics zone?

Yeah, sure.

So, you know, like historically, the hub has been, you know, sort of this credibly neutral platform that wasn't specifically opinionated on anything that's happening within Cosmos.

But then with energy and security, that sort of went away in the sense that, you know, now atom holders benefit from the success of Neutron and Stride and other consumer chains and projects that are launching on there.

And so this credible neutrality is sort of shifted.

And we are sort of like biased in some sense to the growth of what's happening within the AEZ.

And so, well, how can you facilitate growth?

Right.

And, you know, if you take a look at a project like Stride or take a look at a project like Astroport, what attracts users there, specifically a place like Astroport?

Well, if there's a lot of liquidity, there is going to be much more frictionless way to trade.

So let's be more interesting to trade there.

And in some sense, you know, we are invested in the success of these protocols and we want them actually to succeed more than we want, for example, Osmosis to succeed.

And so the hub has, you know, quite significant amounts of money in the community pool.

A lot of it's not being used.

And, you know, I guess I'm not necessarily talking about like investments or anything, but we're talking about the usage of this liquidity in safe means and safe ways to provide liquidity on other networks like Astroport.

And so the best example here is, again, the recent Stride proposal where 450,000 Atom was used, half of it was liquid stake benefiting Stride and the other half of it was kept in Atom.

And then it was used in Astroport to create a or to participate in the LP position there between the liquid stake Atom and Atom.

And now that's a much more frictionless sort of environment.

So that's generally, you know, one of the things you can do as a hub.

We have this protocol on liquidity available and we can do a lot of really interesting things with it.

And I know, Max, also you've thought about this topic maybe even a lot more than me.

You guys have been building this out with TimeWave.

So maybe you have some additional comments there.

Yeah, I'd be happy to share.

So POL is an acronym, Protocol on Liquidity, that a lot of people in crypto have heard.

It was especially popular with OlympusDAO a couple of years ago.

We're sharing a new meme called Liquidity as a Service.

The idea is basically that instead of just having protocol on liquidity, you can charge additional fees on that to choose where you allocate that liquidity.

And just to make sure that people are aware, a lot of this is stemming from a forum post in the forum that started with the Atom Alignment Treasury.

Within that forum post, I had a response about liquidity as a service.

And off the bat, I just want to help shape the relationship between these two because they are not competitive.

They are highly complementary.

No one can speak more to the Alignment Treasury, but the idea there being that there will be a pool of capital that is specific to the Cosmos Hub to allocate.

And the idea with Liquidity as a Service is that it is a strategy that the Cosmos Hub or any Internet native organization that has liquidity or wants liquidity could use.

And so what we posit in that forum post is that liquidity as a service would be the we posit that's the best north star for the Cosmos Hub.

And no, I'm alluded that we've been thinking about this for a while.

Well, we've been thinking about this for about a year and a half now.

A year and a half ago, when we were thinking about what to put in the Cosmos Hub white paper, I spent a lot of time reflecting on what is the Cosmos Hub the best at?

What are its strengths and how can we use those strengths to its best advantage?

And the first things that come to mind are one, the most liquid token to the strongest validator set.

Those are really the two biggest things.

And already we have replicated security that makes use of the validator set.

But we're not really doing that much to make use of the liquidity.

We could be doing a lot more.

And right now we're defining the atom economic zone as only blockchains that are secured by the hub's replicated security.

And we think that this definition could become much broader.

It could also include chains that borrow atom.

You could imagine a world where the first thing that a chain does is borrow atom from the hub before actually entering into an economic relationship with the hub.

And only if that chain wants to borrow more atoms and wants a higher limit or they want to lower interest rates.

At that point, they would choose to enter into the security relationship.

And this has the dual benefit of not only making the hub's replicated security offering more attractive because there is the potential for a race to the bottom here.

As mesh security comes online, as eigenlayer comes online, fees might compress and be a race to the bottom.

If you are able to also add liquidity in your economic package similar to what happened with Stride, it can really supercharge the replicated security offering as well.

So I already threw a lot out there.

So why don't I take a break and let people ask some questions?

Well, yeah, I think I was going to start with just a really basic one, which is like, why are protocols so obsessed with having deep liquidity?

But I appreciate that's probably a super basic question, but I think it's such a fundamental cornerstone of the ideas that are built from here.

I just want to make sure that we've covered why is depth of liquidity important.

Yeah. So, well, I mean, I just wanted to point out there was this thing on Twitter where we saw some whale, I think, sell or buy liquid stake out of.

And we saw like this huge spike in the prices. Right.

And and that's why you need liquidity.

So the more the more money is available on the AMM or in any sort of exchange, whatever version you have of it, the less the price moves when somebody wants to purchase or sell a large amount of assets.

So when you see that slippage number and you're trying to sell a bunch of stuff and that slippage number is high, it's because there's not enough liquidity.

That's a simple way of putting it. Yeah. And I think in the context of that, probably what's important to recognize is that the there was a sharp fall on the price of the staked atom and of the ST atom.

And then it made its way back to to sort of the soft peg, as it were, based on the redemption rate.

So I suppose what happened over a period of time is that you get kind of people are being et cetera, but it gets back there and actually were them deeper liquidity, the total fall wouldn't have been as sharp.

And then people who are trying to sell post that can actually do so without kind of being penalized because of the actions of the people before.

So I think that that's kind of useful to recognize in terms of why that should come from a protocol.

I just wondered if either of you would be kind of able to speak to that.

Yeah, I'm happy to share. So what one of the things that we were thinking about was how the if the hub wants to use its capital more efficiently,

it faces structural disadvantages relative to other players.

For example, if it wants to make an investment, it has to wait two weeks.

If it thinks that because that's the length of the voting period, if it wants to exit a position, it also has to wait two weeks.

Both going in and coming out, the entire Internet can front run this trade.

And so the hub would be has these structural disadvantages.

And so if you're if it's going to have structural disadvantages in order for it to have any hope of getting a profit by allocating its capital, you need to give it structural advantages.

And so if we want to think about what sort of structural advantages we give it, making sure that those play to the strengths of the hub can help ensure that those are sustainable advantages.

And so in the forum post, I mentioned a few ways of of doing that, but liquidity is a really core way of of doing it like the it basically makes it such that the core product of the hub is Adam.

And since it controls Adam owns Adam, it's not necessarily even lending Adam, which is something I want to be clear, it's not lending Adam, it's lending Adam liquidity in this stride example, the 450,000 Adam.

Adam, this isn't 450,000 Adam that's going to some wallet that an individual is owning and that one individual can now do with that Adam, whatever they want, know that the hub still owns this Adam.

And the hub is ultimately what's in control of the printing or the burning of Adam, its own monetary policy.

And so by using liquidity as its means of entering and exiting into positions, it does something that a VC can't do, like most VCs don't have coins, at least not ones that I'm aware of.

And so using POL, using liquidity as a service, it's something that is uniquely possible and uniquely advantageous for blockchains like the hub.

Maps, could you just articulate, is there a difference between liquidity as a service and protocol owned liquidity or is this just a different framing?

So I would say that they are very similar.

Usually when people think about protocol owned liquidity, they are thinking about from the perspective of like their treasury and how they're going to deploy their treasury into various other things.

And it's, it's sort of like a, for the most part, it's usually like a one party idea.

Like I run this now, me and my friends run this now.

We want to use our liquidity to enter into another position.

Like it's, it's, it's usually that, that one, that first degree of thought.

Liquidity as a service takes that one step further to say, hey, I'm a member of a DAO or a blockchain, some sort of internet native organization, the token, and we're not sure where we want to allocate our liquidity.

We are open to allocating it to project A, B, C, D.

And we want to allocate it to who, whichever is the most strategic, but also who's willing to pay the highest fees.

And liquidity as a service is the idea that you can structure these incentives such that project A can like, yes, I will borrow at 1%, project B might borrow at half a percent.

And so liquidity as a service is that opportunity that you're giving to others to borrow your liquidity.

And there are all sorts of factors that can go into it, but that's, that's really the, the core of it.

POL is just that at first degree, you are unilaterally entering into position.

Liquidity as a service is that second degree of like, hey, I am open to entering into any of these positions.

Liquidity as a service is the market mechanism that will surface the demand that project A has for liquidity versus B and have that liquidity flow to the most profitable place.

So just to jump in here. So I think like going back to what Max was saying, and I don't want to take up too much time.

I want to make sure the floor is open for everyone else, but I think security, this isn't 2018 anymore.

Like shared security is going to be a commoditized trade that just, I know Max already said that is going to be a race to the bottom.

The next best thing we can do is like, there's not many assets out there in the crypto space today that I would say reached escape velocity to the point where people actually want to hold it.

And Adam, I personally think has kind of reached a social contract where people want to hold Adam in the cosmos ecosystem.

So what we're trying to think of is like security is not the only offering in the cosmos hub.

The product of the hub is Adam. How do you make Adam or how do you incentivize more of like a soft lock in to make other ecosystems, other chains and other projects in the atom economics on the wire interchange?

How do you make them more reliant on the hub outside of security?

Well, a lot of people want Adam, make Adam the base, you know, pairing in liquidity positions, make Adam the most, you know, I would say.

Yeah, I guess make like the largest pairing in liquidity positions and also, you know, kind of jumpstart the economic engine of the atom economic zone in the wider energy and economy leveraging out of liquidity.

I know there's obviously some people that don't believe in protocol and liquidity, don't believe in liquidity as a service narrative.

And they ultimately think, like, what is in it for Adam stakers?

One thing I think you can do is and this is something I'm kind of like ripping off right now, but the hub community can also kind of institute an option.

Like, look, if you want Adam liquidity, not only do you need to, you know, borrow at a certain rate, but you and not only do you actually need to like maybe start out on Neutron, for example, like let's actually incentivize people to launch on Neutron to drive more economic activity.

But maybe you also need to airdrop a certain percentage of your supply to Adam stakers.

I think early on in the Cosmos ecosystem lifecycle, a lot of projects that are launching the Cosmos ecosystem started airdropping because they want to have like a large base of initial users.

And they started airdropping a decent supply. Osmos is being a great example to the Cosmos hub community.

But you start to see that kind of that go away.

Nomada is a great example.

Nomada is, I think, a really promising project in the Cosmos ecosystem.

And only a portion of their supply was, I believe, airdropped to Osmosis.

None was airdropped to the Cosmos ecosystem.

And there's a bunch of reasons why, I think.

I think the Cosmos hub kind of got away from being like the large driver of public goods funding and actually, you know, driving innovation of the tech stack.

Osmosis, I think, did a really good job with that over the past couple of years with the Osmosis grants program, for example.

But you can start kind of creating other lock-in incentives to get people to leverage Adam liquidity and maybe do things that maybe more directly benefit Adam stakers and airdrops could be an option there.

I haven't really talked about that at length with any of the people here on this stage, something I was kind of thinking about.

But I think overall, like what we're trying to do is create other lock-ins to make Adam more in-demand asset in the ecosystem and drive like some of this money in this aspect that I think it already has.

But we're trying to reinforce it.

Great.

I noticed that Riley has managed to join us, which is fantastic.

I suspect it's not necessary to do an introduction, but Riley, at this stage, just as we're kind of discussing top level elements and strides, use of kind of the liquidity of the hub as part of its process in the AEZ has been referenced a couple of times.

I just want to know if you've got anything particularly you want to say about that or if we should start to move into the kind of nitty-gritty of some of the work that binary have been doing.

Hey, good morning, guys.

We can talk about the specifics of how Stride is using its Adam POL.

It's currently deployed on Neutron, supporting Mars only right now, but soon some other apps.

It might move around in the future if proposals go up to shift it, depending on what DeFi is deployed on Neutron.

But for now, it's sitting there supporting Mars and I think three or four more apps that are coming live in the next few months.

I think it's probably most useful to dive into the specifics of the binary proposal, and I would love to talk a little bit about a comment that Stride made on that proposal for some actionable next steps, but maybe once Noam gets an overview.

That's great. So that probably does mean, Noam, would you be able to just sort of start to take us through the, is it best to start with the alignment treasury? Is that probably the best place to start?

Yeah, why not? I'll try to keep it short and simple. The post itself is quite the opposite of that.

So the four posts that I did was more of a, you know, a lot of open ended questions and like, well, you know, how should we approach some of these things with definitely some suggestions.

Really just trying to solve for or like address three main objectives.

So again, we talked about AAC growth already. So, you know, providing liquidity.

The second thing that I think is very important, and we're seeing this now with the proposal coming up with to have the Neutron airdrop tokens be delivered to the Cosmos Hub community pool, is financial alignment with consumer chains.

So, you know, we have a very strong sort of alignment with all the other consumer chains and maybe also other protocols that exist on there, but it's not really formalized in the sense that we don't have any voting power on Neutron, for example.

And so when this, if the community agrees to this and they want this Neutron airdrop to be deposited in the community pool, then an interesting thing happens.

We have actually quite a significant, it would be 5% of the total supply of Neutron, but it would be 50% of the, or at least currently 50% of the voting power.

So that's quite significant. If Neutron would say, hey, we want to go leave and become an independent chain, hopefully they won't, but if that's the case, we should be able to vote on that, right?

We were considerable stakeholders in the ecosystem.

So, and then, you know, we're just thinking of like, how do we design the infrastructure for doing so? And what are sort of the use cases though? So again, like these like token swaps or token gifts, if you want to call it that, liquidity and that kind of stuff.

So how do we, how do we do this? Right. And at first, well, there's really three things here. You want to try to figure out like, well, how do we build up this treasury in the first place? Right.

And normally we have, we have this community pool. But if you look at sort of like your normal way of doing accounting, you don't have, you know, you don't put all your savings into your spending account. You generally have a separate account for that.

So the first step would be to like, enable the community pool to have two addresses, probably one that we could call the item alignment treasury, the other one, which is be the regular community pool.

And then we have to think about, well, how do we fund this item alignment treasury? Is this going to be a percentage of the money that's going to the community pool?

Or is this just going to be a one-time payment or something? Is it coming through a specific revenue stream, like energy and security or some other thing?

Okay. I'll have to talk about that. And then we have to sort of like figure out, well, how, how are we going to start expressing some of these things we want to do on the, in the AZ?

So like token swaps or just like liquidity as a service, or maybe we want to decide to, I mean, now that we have a bunch of neutron tokens, maybe we like those neutron tokens.

We want to make sure we always have a certain percentage of neutron tokens in our treasury, right?

And maybe we want to actively manage our portfolio in some ways.

I think the interesting stuff comes to when, when we start thinking about how to actually execute on some of these desires or these expressions.

So, and this is sort of where a time wave also comes in because they build out a lot of the infrastructure there on that other side.

But so let's say you were talking about this, let's take the stride example, right?

Right now, the 450, yeah, 450,000 Atom had to be sent to a multi-signature wallet, which was in this case, the Atom Accelerator DAO.

And they had to then, you know, liquid stake half a fit manually, and then transfer that to AstroPort, and then put it in the LP, in the pool, basically.

And that's a lot of steps, and it's a lot of trust.

And of course, we all trust the Atom Accelerator DAO, but in a decentralized future, we need to think of better solutions for this.

And so what really the Atom Alignment Treasury really does then, in this case, would be trying to see if there's an automated way to execute these things,

where really it comes down to a simple proposal on-chain that says, like, hey, we want to put, you know, 450,000 Atom onto AstroPort, liquid staked via stride.

And then in the background, everything just magically happens, basically, through the use of probably something similar to Covenants, or whatever else TimeWave is building, maybe some other functionality.

I can also imagine that some chains or some protocols build out this sort of API layer that we can plug into.

But on the hub itself, a few rudimentary changes have to be made in terms of, like, the community pool, making it sort of, like, more flexible, having this separate address,

improving the governance system so that we can, like, express ourselves effectively.

And then also, and this is the second part, which is kind of interesting, when we talk about these Neutron tokens that are coming to the hub.

Well, that's great that we have these tokens and we have this voting power, but how do we actually execute on that?

And in my mind, if the hub has protocol-owned liquidity and its assets that are in the community, sorry, in the AEZ,

we should be able to use our Atom token to vote on what happens on Neutron.

So in my mind, if we have 50% of Neutron's network, then my Atom, if I have 5% worth of Atom, that should be worth 2.5% of voting power on Neutron.

And so we're thinking about how do we build a governance mechanism where you can do this, where we can actually say,

hey, this is a very important proposal on Neutron.

We think everyone should vote on this, so we'll move it to the hub, and now I can use my Atom tokens to basically weigh in on that decision.

And that's, I'll stop there because I can keep going, but that's, I think, a decent summary.

I think what's really interesting with this, and it explains probably why the forum post was quite so mammoth,

is that there's this kind of mixture of financial relationship and political relationship,

and that the two are kind of very inseparably interlinked, and that you kind of start looking at tokenomics,

and you immediately move into political alignment, and how does voting work, and how does governance work,

and then you move into, okay, and how would that ever be executable within the hub?

And obviously there's a huge amount to unpack here, and I kind of know that both Macs as TimeWave have a number of ways that they think we can execute.

I know that Stride wrote a very practical set of steps that they think we could take pretty much immediately.

But before we get into the detail of those, I just wondered whether anyone who's on stage at the moment,

and I see that Spade's here as well,

like whether there's anything that's sort of at that top kind of conceptual level,

either on the financial side or on the political side,

that people want to say before we kind of get into the more practical responses that there were to Gnome's post.

Absolutely deafening silence.

So that's either a good thing or a bad thing.

So this isn't a direct response to that question,

but maybe a good transition into what you were referring to.

We kicked this conversation off by introducing liquidity as a service pretty early.

Something that I want to emphasize is that this liquidity as a service idea,

especially the part about it that is the charging of interest,

and also giving blockchains greater security guarantees,

similar to like senior secured debt in a capital stack.

I think these are really good for the hub long term.

This should be the way we think about it.

But in the short term, I think that the top priority for the hub should be distribution of atom liquidity,

really making sure that the entire interchain thinks of atom as that base asset,

that trading pair, maybe it's ST atom.

But point being is really prioritizing atom distribution and not letting interest rates

or onerous security guarantees get in the way,

so long as you are deploying it into positions that have high strategic value.

So that could be a good segue for Riley and Stride,

because they came up with some short-term next steps that could be good to discuss.

Yeah, happy to jump in and discuss some of those.

So we posted a short reply to the forum post that outlines some immediate steps

that could be taken to improve the liquidity conditions in the cosmos.

And I think these are actionable on the one to three-month timescale.

And thereafter, we could roll into something that's more elaborate and long-term sustainable for the hub.

But these are kind of – think of them as baby steps,

some initial governance-gated actions that could be taken now.

And the high-level idea is to solidify the AEZ by providing lots of liquidity on the AEZ's main decks,

which is today Astroport, not Neutron, and promote Atom by making it the common base pair on that decks,

kind of like you see Osmo as the main base pair on Osmosis.

It would be a great way to ease the Cosmos hub into using the AAT,

and it's, I think, easily actionable right now.

It's an elegant solution.

In addition, you really only need one USDC Atom pool to support basically unlimited liquidity between Atom and any token,

because to get to USDC, you route through the Atom USDC pool.

And given that pool would be supported on Neutron,

Neutron would have the responsibility to maintain the USDC pool,

so the Cosmos hub wouldn't have to sell any Atom to raise USDC to LP that pool.

So there would be no controversy around having to sell Atom in order to LP.

Further, the solution we outlined introduces the concept of deploying non-Atom POL

using some of the Neutron that's already in the community pool.

It introduces the practice of balancing,

since liquidity pools automatically balance between their two constituent assets.

So you don't have to build any complicated logic on-chain to do that.

You just LP the pool and let it balance based on the prices automatically.

It introduces the concept of a token swap with the stride Atom swap and the liquidity deployment there.

And it builds on the STAtom process already established by adding more liquidity to STAtom Atom,

which has more favorable IL properties than some of the other pools.

It increases Atom's relevance by making it the common base pair.

We've seen this work for osmosis in certain ways.

And most importantly than all, it hugely increases TVL,

and presumably also economic activity in the AEZ,

excuse me, in the AEZ,

and it prepares the Cosmos Hub for more advanced things in the future,

like what Noam described.

So the actionable short-term plan is to provide liquidity on Astroport Neutron.

We proposed some amounts and some pairs.

Those aren't super important,

but the main detail is that they're all paired with Atom,

and the Cosmos Hub wouldn't have to sell any Atom in order to LP the pools.

I think just to sort of like expand on this,

hey everyone, by the way,

I think in general I'm like a huge supporter of the sort of like initial steps

that are proposed by like the stride folks as well as,

you know, outlined in Noam's post.

I do think that like the beauty of them is that we can iteratively build,

you know, further alignment on these steps.

Like for example, you know,

say the hub was to deploy NTRN as liquidity on Neutron.

Neutron does have this like very elegant solution called Voiding Vaults,

which allow the Neutron DAO to basically allow NTRN in a variety of forms,

right, whether it's like deposited as collateral on the money market

or provided as liquidity to be recognized and counted in governance.

And so like we can use this system for enabling the hub

to just like deploy NTRN into Voting Vaults

so that it is able to vote like similarly to what Noam was describing,

right, so like your share of Atom state

would represent your share of the hub's NTRN voting power,

or we can also essentially do the same,

but with the hub's liquidity, right?

So even if the hub was to,

and especially if the hub was to deploy liquidity

in the way sort of like depicted,

like there could be a technical solution,

which of course would have to be like rigorously audited and tested and such,

but there is a technical solution to allow that,

that, you know, Cosmos Hub owned liquidity

to basically also generate voting power

for the Cosmos Hub community as a whole, basically.

So I think like these things feel like they're starting to fall into places,

and I think it's like a very, like a super exciting kind of direction

that we're headed towards as a community, basically.

Yeah, just my two cents.

Thank you, Spade.

Jihan, I know you just asked to speak,

so let me hear your thoughts.

I wanted to ask, I don't know if I came in, you know, 10, 15 minutes ago,

maybe this has been covered,

but on these positions that Stride is proposing,

they, as I understand it,

the Hub community pool would put in Atom

and then the counterparty asset

would be coming out of that counterparty's chain's treasury.

So for matching as the Stride,

you know, against Stride, Stride would be coming out of the Stride treasury

or Neutron out of Neutron treasury, right?

Is that correct?

Yeah, that's basically the idea,

with the exception that for the proposal that was made,

some of those assets would be provided via a token swap.

Okay.

Some would be provided outright from the community pool.

I see.

Okay, so...

Yeah, so for example,

for the potential like NTR and Atom liquidity

that the Hub could provide,

like the Hub just so happens to have,

or like soon to have,

like something like $18 million of NTR.

And so if it wanted to pair some of that with Atom,

then it would have the, you know,

the sovereign ability to do so.

Other assets,

like the Stride proposal includes the idea that like,

oh, well, go first, Jihan,

and then we can touch on this one later.

Oh, I was going to say that's interesting.

I've really thought about that.

If the community pool owns both assets,

that's interesting.

How it compares having them in an LP position

versus holding both of them outright.

I assume that in a change,

if the price of the assets changed a lot against each other,

the Hub would be seeing some impermanent loss

versus if the hedge has held those,

but maybe the liquidity provided is worth it

for it's kind of, you know, enhancing the ecosystem.

But on the ones, okay,

so on the ones,

let's say we take an example where,

let's say the entirety of the other,

of the counterparty token

came from that counterparty chain's treasury,

and the entirety of the Atom

comes from the community pool.

I still feel like the Hub is taking a position

on the price of that asset.

So I think that needs to be,

and that might be worth it,

but I think that always needs to be considered.

Would you agree with that?

The Hub would be taking position then?

Sort of kind of making an investment in a way?

I think it depends on,

I think it depends on how it's actually implemented,

but like given the current technologies,

I think what most likely would happen

is that assuming that like the,

you know,

the two sides that are being provided

are of equal value,

you'd probably see something

whereby half of the LP tokens

are sent to the Cosmos Hub

and half of the other LPs

are sent to whatever the counterparty DAO or chain is.

And so, yeah,

as a result of this,

the net exposure of both parties

is actually like half each asset.

So yeah,

there is like permanent loss risk

and there is like price risk and such as well.

I think this is why it's important

that this is seen through the lens of alignment

rather than investment

because the risk of IL is high,

you know,

for either party.

But the value,

I think if I've read

Noam's post correctly

is that that sort of strategic relationship

makes that alignment critical

to the success of the AEZ

and therefore the sort of,

while there is a financial position

that's taken,

it's kind of outweighed

by the political alignment.

Forgive me if I'm making an absolute hash

of your very well-worded post Noam,

but is that broadly kind of correct?

Yeah, I mean,

I think,

yeah,

again,

it's definitely more about alignment

than anything else.

Alignment for the reasons of,

you know,

maintaining voting power

and just for growth as well,

like being able to use this

as liquidity as a service.

On the topic of like

a permanent loss though,

like,

you know,

this is something,

I don't recall who said this.

Actually,

maybe it was you,

Jahan,

but that there's this risk

where technically,

you know,

if we have a sufficient amount

of neutron atom

in a pool,

neutron could just go ahead

and dump basically on the market

and then take all this atom

and walk away.

No offense,

I don't think that's ever going to happen,

obviously,

but we need to protect ourselves

for something like this,

right?

And so you could use

concentrated liquidity for this,

right?

You just set some,

some,

some parameter that says like,

well,

below this,

we'll,

we'll leave the,

we'll leave the situation.

So, you know,

Astroports support this environment,

correctly.

And,

and so,

so there's like an emergency stop there

where you say like,

hey,

if the price is going down rapidly,

let's get the hell out of here.

That's,

I mean,

that seems like a great thing to add.

Forget the whole situation.

That way the LP stops below a certain price.

So,

so yeah,

that makes a lot of sense.

Another thing that has been discussed,

I think,

was the concept of,

and maybe the soft topic,

we're getting too far afield,

you know,

let me know,

but there would be the topic,

maybe we,

you know,

obviously we want to do these kinds of things

like we're talking about here,

but also there's the,

maybe there's a possibility of a protocol,

basically like borrowing Adam.

So using,

so let's say this counterparty chain,

Foo chain,

it uses its Foo tokens in the treasury

to like borrow Adam

with a collateralized loan

using collateralized by Foo tokens.

And then,

and then could set up an LP position

both sides of that with their,

with other Foo tokens.

And then there are Foo token collateralized atoms

on the other side.

Would that like,

I mean,

you know,

that,

that would maybe be another option.

You think that's something that,

that would make sense for,

for,

for people or is that not a good idea?

Yeah.

Jihan,

I,

I,

I love that idea.

That's actually exactly the direction

that we're hoping for liquidity as a service.

We,

we mentioned in,

in our apply that the amount of collateral

that a chain puts up could play a factor

in like how much Adam liquidity

is lent to that chain,

what interest rate is provided.

So I think that collateral

will eventually play a really big role.

Interest rates play a really big role.

Borrowing limits playing a really big role.

But I also think that those

probably shouldn't be the first step.

I think the first step should be

as,

as simple as possible

through some proofs of concept.

And then once,

once you really,

once the community gets comfortable with this,

once we prove that machinery works,

we then add features on top.

And I think collateral is absolutely direction

you would go.

And,

and just to hit on some earlier points

that were mentioned,

something that came up a lot

when replicate security

was first introduced

was the idea of bootstrapping

a chain's security

where they can go from zero

to like having a really,

trustworthy amount of security.

We can think of some of this liquidity

as a service

as complementing that security bootstrap

by also having an economic bootstrap.

Liquidity begets liquidity.

And so you have a cold start problem.

And so if from day one,

you have the security

and you have the liquidity,

the chances of your project succeeding

are much higher.

And so even though there is

impermanent loss risk,

if you enter into a position,

there's also just like existential risk

if the hub is entering

into the security relationships

with Neutron,

with Stride,

with others,

and those projects don't succeed.

And so providing security

and also providing liquidity

helps increase the chances

of that succeeding,

increases the,

improves the narrative,

the mobility of all of this.

And so I just wanted to

really highlight that

when we're talking about

the strategic value

of these economic partnerships.

I'm really conscious

that I've had a few people

requesting to speak

and then they've dropped back down

just because the conversation

is really flowing,

but it's fantastic

to see people requesting to speak.

I can see that

Zach is asking to speak.

So I'm going to bring him up now

just to see if we get

some sort of further thing.

Zach, did you have a question

for the people on stage?

Hi, guys.

Can you guys hear me?

Yeah.

Hey, so I actually have a question, right?

Is it proposed that

when a token that wants to join

the liquidity as a service,

so they want to pair with Atom, right?

Is it a suggested idea

that that particular token

has to provide collateral

in order to borrow the Atom?

So if the answer is yes,

would Cosmos Hub

actually consider

waiving the collateral?

The reason why I'm suggesting this

is because I think

the strategic benefit

of aligning

the liquidity

as someone said,

liquidity begets liquidity.

I think

that position

is much more important

than requiring

a collateral

to borrow Atom

because

after all,

providing the liquidity

into, say,

Astropod,

the hub

actually still owns

the LP pair.

So I think

in that sense,

there's no

outright

huge risk

involved.

But

the fact that

we can bootstrap

the liquidity

very quickly

if there's no

collateral

required

would

really help.

And also,

I think

when it comes

to liquidity

LP losses,

it goes

both ways,

right?

So there might

actually be instances

that

the hub,

you know,

the community

actually make

money from it

even though

that's not

the end point.

So I think

my point being

I think

liquidity

as a service

is very important

and

there might be

certain

criterias

that

maybe we

can consider

foregoing

such as

collateral

or

things like

that

to really

get things

going

at a

faster pace.

I just

want to say

really quickly

just thinking

about what

Noam was

saying

about limiting

the,

you know,

not what,

I forget

the technical

term,

but you know,

not LPing

below a certain

price,

the concentrated

liquidity,

that might

actually,

if you

say the

counterparty

can't go

lower than

this,

you know,

before the

LPing stops,

I feel like

that would

actually limit

the downside

risk for

the counterparty

token's price

for the

hub,

maybe in a

better way.

Any thoughts

on that?

Yeah.

Yeah.

So,

Zach,

I think you

are totally

right and

I just want

to address

Jihan's point

real quick

and then get

back to

yours.

So,

Jihan,

yeah,

I think

concentrated

liquidity

is a

great idea.

Another

feature you

can have

is basically

create a

covenant

between the

two parties

that prevents

either party

from doing

anything with

those tokens

including selling

them within

X period of

time,

like six

months,

one year,

whatever it

is.

And so,

even if you

do have

that concentrated

liquidity

position,

it gives

more of that

position to

the broader

market and

not the

counterparty to

the trade.

So,

that's just

one additional

mechanism to

think about.

And,

yeah.

Oh,

just one more

thing I was

going to ask.

Is it possible,

I know we're

trying to keep

it really simple

for the first

one here,

so maybe

I'll ask Riley

if I can answer,

but is it

possible to do

the concentrated

liquidity right

now on

Astroport?

Would that be a

viable thing to

do in this

existing proposal?

Max,

maybe I'll take

this one quickly.

So,

concentrated

liquidity on

Astroport is

not live on

Neutron today.

It should be

live within

approximately

two to three

weeks.

The reason for

that being that

it's being

deployed,

it has been

deployed on Terra,

it is being

tested currently,

has been

audited as well,

assuming that

everything goes

well there,

we should see

a proposal on

the Astroport

governance within

I think a week

or so that

will basically

lead to the

deployment of

the PCL

pools.

One thing,

just a quick

note as well,

is that you

might have seen

this end of

fragmentation

blog post we

released recently

with Astroport

and Duality,

but basically

Astroport's PCL

itself is already

very powerful,

and then it

becomes a whole

different level

of customizability

once that

becomes integrated

with Duality

itself,

because you

get to a

place where

you have

essentially

app-specific

level of

control over

the way that

the liquidity

is structured,

and so I

think what

we're going

to see is

that we

can even

get to a

point where

specific types

of pools can

be deployed

for the purpose

of these

covenants so

that even

the parameters

of how the

liquidity is

structured can

be customized

as part of

the deals

between the

protocols and

without fragmenting

liquidity because

at the end of

the day,

since it's the

same pair,

it's provided

on the same

book as

other more

mainstream types

of pools like

vanilla PCL

or such,

which allows

one,

both to

really contribute

to the

economic growth

of the

ecosystems,

but also do

so in a way

whereby the

agreements themselves

can be very

deeply customizable,

which I think

is fairly

super exciting.

Yeah,

thanks for

that,

Everall.

So just to

close some

of the loops

here,

so these

sorts of

deals,

like the

customization

of it in

terms of

how to

enter into

that consecrated

liquidity

position,

how much

collateral,

what sort

of interest

rate,

what are

the borrowing

limits,

what are the

hold terms,

all of these

things,

these are all

things that

we're building

a time wave

into the

covenants.

These are

very highly

customizable

things,

and for the

first period

of time,

these will be

pretty tailor-made

situations.

But to make

sure we're

answering Zach's

question,

Zach, I think

you are

exactly right.

We're talking

about collateral,

we're talking

about interest

rates and all

these things

that could

be barriers

in these

negotiations

that slow

down the

distribution

of Adam,

and I agree

with you that

we should

not be asking

for these

onerous

terms,

maybe these

terms at

all,

we really

should be

prioritizing

distribution,

and just

to put

this in

a larger

context of

why we

think liquidity

as a service

should be

the north

star for

the hub or

at least

the Adam

alignment

treasury,

Bitcoin does

not have

on-chain

governance.

Ethereum does

not have

on-chain

governance.

Both of

them have

more liquidity.

If they

did, the

hub would

not be the

best position

to do

this.

But the

hub does

have on-chain

governance,

obviously,

and it

also has a

very liquid

token, and

because of

that, it

is uniquely

well-positioned

to make

this happen.

I really

want to

stress this

because there

is a

pattern of

ideas starting

in Cosmos and

getting popularized

elsewhere, and

if we put

hurdles in the

way of these

deals, like

onerous

collateral, like

onerous

interest rate,

we might miss

the boat on

this.

It's one of the

reasons why

we're so

supportive of

Riley's and

Stride's ideas

of just

getting these

deals out

there quickly,

relatively simple,

that are just

clear next

steps, and

we're sharing

these other

ideas to

give food for

thought for

the community

to think about,

okay, once we

get these baby

steps under

our belt,

what is

possible in

the future?

So a lot of

this stuff is

longer-term

thinking, and

in the short

term, we

should just

really get

some deals

done quickly

with

strategically

relevant

players.

I just want

to say,

though, really

quickly, if

we had done

an LP

position like

this with

Juno last

year, the

entire

Adam's

team would

have gone.

Max and

guys, so

I really

appreciate...

Exactly.

Jahan was

speaking.

I don't know

if you can

hear him.

Sorry,

sorry, yeah.

That was all

I wanted to

say.

So I just

think it's

essential to

limit the

downside

somehow.

And, yeah,

that's just my

point.

I agree, but

also Juno

isn't

strategically

important to

the hub the

way that

Neutron or

Stride is.

If the

hub had

entered into

a replicate

security

relationship with

Juno and

it just

immediately

died, that

would look

really bad

for replicate

security.

It would

look really

bad for

the hub's

judgment.

And so

I'm not

saying that

anyone should

be able to

show up to

the hub and

borrow liquidity.

That's

absolutely not

what I'm

saying.

But what I

am saying

is that for

highly strategic

partners,

we should

get that

liquidity

flowing in

reasonably

intelligent

ways.

What I

would like to

do for the

moment is

just part

this little

bit of the

conversation

because I

feel this is

connected to

some of the

stuff that

probably we

want to talk

about, about

governance

changes that

might be

necessary to

make this

happen.

And I just

want to make

sure that we've

closed off the

questions that

Zach was asking

and then we

could move to

talking about

how governance

might need to

adapt for the

hub to act in

this way.

Zach, was

there something

you wanted to

add at this

point?

No, I just

wanted to say

I'm very

appreciative of

what Max

has said because

I think the

larger picture is

really to get

things moving

forward.

So really

appreciate on

that comment.

That's great.

I don't know

what everyone,

I'd sort of

imagine the

space with less

now, but

conversation is

really great.

So I'm

happy to

keep rolling

as long as

other people

are.

In terms of

because as

you were

talking and

obviously taking

Sheehan's point

about trying to

limit downsides,

it feels to me

like there's

far more

sophisticated

governance that's

probably needed

in terms of

agreeing what's

a strategic

pair, working

out a kind

of range of

liquidity that

we're looking

to do, how

you manage

those positions,

sort of

known, where

do you

think the

beginnings of

these kind

of changes

that might

be needed

starts?

Yeah, exactly.

I've been

thinking about

this the last

couple of

weeks, like

what is

phase one

of the

Adam and

Lyman treasury,

right?

And my

initial thinking

here is that

well, firstly,

it's this

community pool

change.

So it's like

let's make

sure that the

community pool

has two

addresses, right?

It's spending

account for

grants and

whatnot and

the things

that we're

doing right

now is

community

spends and

then the

investment in

alignment address

or something

let's call it

that's the

AAT.

And then

there needs

to be some

kind of it.

So this is

something that

I think

should happen

on all

SDK chains

anyway.

So for

those who

don't know,

governance has

changed in

SDK version 46

and above.

And basically

now instead

of just like

these four or

five different

specific governance

proposals, you

can execute any

sort of message.

So you can

say, I want

to do an

IBC transfer.

Can we vote

yes or no?

Or I want

to, I don't

know, create

this vesting

account or

whatever.

We can do

all these

things now.

But the

problem is

that the

governance

module, the

governance

module itself

within the

hub or any

SDK chain

doesn't actually

own the

community pool.

There's a

weird little

hack basically

that's built

to enable you

to do a

community spend

basically.

So it's like

a little hack

that says when

we do a

community spend

proposal, then

and only then

is the

governance

module authorized

to do

something from

the community

pool.

So this is a

bit annoying

and there's

the simple way

to go around

this is using

all C, but

that's a kind

of a hack

as well.

So ideally

what I'd like

to do is it

is not a

trivial problem

to solve, but

basically I want

to make sure

that the

governance

module actually

owns the

community pool

address or

addresses.

We have to

think about

how to do

this.

This is like

going to be

a design

process, but

it will enable

us to do a

lot more.

It will enable

us to say

like, hey, I

want to now

do, what's the

word again?

Is it autopilot

stride?

Is it

called autopilot

to do like a

liquid stake and

then get your

tokens straight

away back?

Yeah, yeah,

autopilot.

Yeah, exactly

cool.

So for example,

you would have

a governance

proposal that

says, okay,

well, let's

create an

interchain account

or maybe not

even, you

don't need that

for stride, but

it would say

like, hey, we

want to do an

autopilot thing

and get our

liquid stake

tokens back.

Or if

time wave has

built out stuff

that we can

plug into, we

can say, hey, I

want to plug into

that smart contract

over there and do

this with this

amount of tokens.

So this will

enable us to

plug into all

these other

things that are

being built

outside of the

AEZ.

So that's

one of the

first changes.

So that's

changes to the

community pool

slash governance.

And the other

changes that

will be necessary

really is this

part about voting

on other

networks with

Atom.

So this is

just like, you

know, the

stuff we talked

about, like,

now that we

have these

Neutron tokens

either here or

on Neutron,

on Astroport or

somewhere else,

but we're able

to vote, how

do we vote with

them?

And what does

that structure

look like?

I think that

is generally

phase one.

The first one

being maybe

really the

community pool

stuff, and

we'll have to

see if it's

in scope to

work on that

governance part,

but I'd like

to have all

of that sort

of sorted

in V1.

And then, you

know, then

we'll see what

the rest of

the community,

how they think

about, you

know, plugging

into sort of

like all these

modular pieces

that exist out

there, you

know, the

Covenant

system, the

TimeWave is

building, autopilot

on Stride, and

whatever else is

there at that

point.

But I think

this is a good

starting point.

And so my

plan is to,

you know, do

another forum

post with

basically a

description of

what this

phase one looks

like, and

then have that

proposal on

chain, but

also super

eager to get

feedback from,

you know, the

speakers on

this Twitter

space right now

about whether

or not this

is the right

priority.

I think the

priority as you

outlined them

makes sense to

me, focusing

on, you

know, just

preparing the

community pool

and these

mechanisms for,

you know, to

be ready for

and convenient

for these

things to

happen.

On the

governance

side, I

think like

there's a

lot more

like work and

thinking to be

done because

due to the

fact that

like virus

consumer

chains have

various

different like

voting model.

Like for

example, Stride

I think has

the governator

system, whereas

Neutron has

like a custom

admin module

plus like

smart contracts.

So I think

that's probably

where we

should like

kind of like

fuck around

and find out

a little bit

more.

Like for

example, you

know, I

think on the

Neutron side,

it will most

likely be like

fairly easy to

roll this out

due to the

fact that like

as long as

we can transfer

the tokens into

a contract that's

owned by the

Cosmos Hub via

an interesting

account, then

the hub can

retain ownership

and have voting

power and we

can, you know,

instead of like

changing the

version of the

Cosmos SDK on

like both chains

and, you know,

which could be a

bit like heavier,

we can, you

know, like try

these mechanisms

out with, you

know, just like

iteration on small

contracts, which I

think is a lot more

realistic in the

short term at

least.

so yeah, like I

think from that

perspective, it's

it seems very

reasonable to me.

I think the

other two things

that I would

sort of like

gesture towards in

terms of things

that we should

consider on the

hub as well, and

especially with

regards to the

community pool is

the first one is

like it's currently

fairly unwieldy to

send tokens to the

community pool because

like, like as I'm

sure a lot of our

like the folks on

the panels, but

also in the

audience are aware

like the community

pool is not like

just a normal

account, it's a

module account.

And so you can't

just IBC transfer

tokens into them,

you have to have

some account on

the hub make a

fun community

pool message,

right?

So you have to

execute a specific

message that's

doable via ICA,

right?

So for example,

for the purpose of

transferring the

tokens from the

Neutron airdrop,

like the 42

million in

Ethereum to the

Cosmos community

pool, it's

possible to have a

contract on Neutron

that registers an

intrusion account

on the hub,

transfer the tokens

to that intrusion

account, then do

an execute, like

execute a fun

community pool

message to actually

transfer the tokens

to the hub's

community pool, but

that process itself

is not super

streamlined and

efficient.

And so potentially

there's ways to

make it like a

little bit more

accessible to

facilitate these

kind of like

crushing

interactions.

Yeah, that

should really just

be an address like

any other address

so you can just

deposit tokens like

anything else.

Well, I think

there's a trade-off

space, right?

Like do you want

people to be able

to just like drop

tokens into this?

Might be a great

thing, might be a

vector of like

you know, like

denominations that

are kind of like

spam denoms and

then how do you

handle them as

part of like the

selections in the

other modules to

ensure that you're

not, you know,

surprised to be

providing like

doku on tokens to

the liquidity pair

that you meant to

have with Atom

instead or

something.

But yeah, no, I

agree.

Like making this

like a lot more

accessible is probably

a good idea.

I think on like

not on the

community pool part

but just like

general SDK

stuff, I think it

should be considered

a priority to get

the ICA controller

functionality on the

hub enabled.

I'm not sure if

there's any like

technical blockers

or such but I

think having the

hub be able not

just to have

accounts being

registered on

onto the hub by

consumer chains but

also having the

hub be able to own

things on consumer

chains and control

accounts and sub

DAOs and stuff is

like something that's

like going to be

required to really

further this alignment

right and it would

unlock stuff like

you know, having

DAODAO for example

be like, sorry,

having a DAO for

example have its own

customizable structure

of DAOs on

Neutron, having the

hub have like, you

know, like the

sub-treasuries for

various purposes that

he could manage

like trustlessly.

I think all of these

are like super, super

interesting like

directions that would

be unlocked by this.

Yeah, thanks for

that on the

on the ICA

host, I forgot

about that one.

It's actually kind

of strange that we

haven't enabled this

yet because that's

a no-brainer.

I think it kind of

made sense while

there was no like

direct use case for

it but now that

you know, replicated

security is a thing,

the AZ exists, I

think like that's the

right time to turn it

on basically.

Exactly and then we

can already preload

basically we can

always start creating

accounts on the

networks that are

within the AZ and

then have those set

up and then we

know what they are

and put the LP

tokens there, etc.

One of the things

that had occurred to

me around some of

this conversation was

some of the tooling

that I think Wind

had on it around

gauges so that

there's a kind of

ongoing vote

where you as a

atom staker are able

to say I want, I

think that we should

allocate liquidity in

this sort of structure

seemed interesting to me

as opposed to things

being like one vote

and it's done and

then you have to

come back with

another and I

recognise that that's

a very radical change

from the kind of

very, forgive the

slight pun here,

binary voting

structure that we

have where things

either pass or fail

and then that's it

until we vote again.

I think that we're

heading to a period

of almost like

ongoing continuous

governance where if

we have positions they

need to be in some

ways actively managed

and actively evaluated

thinking about the

things Jihan was

saying about if the

hub had had this

kind of relationship

with Juno then the

hub might have got

wrecked based on the

price action.

Voter sentiment could

change over time and

I'm just interested in

kind of how governance

evolves from kind of

quite this linear thing

and I know Spagey've

got kind of more

sophisticated governance

within Neutron,

right?

Yeah, I mean,

I guess we do.

But the, yeah, I

have a couple of

thoughts.

Like first, like I

completely agree.

Like once you have

like kind of like

life positioned,

probably makes sense

to have some way to

manage them like more

actively, right?

Like a lot of like

the, like some of

like Max's and

time wave, like most

valuable insight to me

were, you know,

realizing like, like I

think he puts it very

well when he says like

there are structural

disadvantages to

DAOs and protocols

participating in the

economy because of the

way that they can

actually like make

decisions and react,

right?

If you have to, you

know, take two weeks

before you can do

anything and you have

an active position in

the market, then you're

potentially opening

yourself to being

front run on a number

of these like situations.

And so I think there's

two things, right?

There's on the one

hand, and we can

discuss this like further

like evolving the

governance system, but

you know, the like

decentralization and

security of this

process will always be

something that like has

to be taken into

account.

So I don't think

that, you know, we'll

ever sort of like match

necessarily the like

speed of decision

making of like one

person that owns the

keys, right?

And I don't think that

should be an objective

either.

But like to

counterbalance this

though, we can

structure the

agreements, the

pools, the

positions, the

contracts themselves,

right?

We can encode into

the markets the

things that will

protect the DAOs and

the protocols

participating in them,

right?

So like the PCL and

the fact that it sort

of like, you know,

like has kind of

like limits to the

impermanent loss that

it will accept, for

example, is one

example of such

things.

I think like the

timeway folks propose

other mechanisms as

well, whereby like the

position would be

scaled back or up

based on like the

evolution of like the

ratio and the

balances between

prices so that, you

know, the more

impermanent loss can

like increases, the

less there is of a

position to suffer

that impermanent loss

anyway.

There's like a

variety of mechanisms

that we can consider in

this regard.

And so I think like

the combination of

both these things,

like evolving the

market structure and

evolving the

governance structure is

what actually ultimately

will make this like

kind of like endeavor

and like train of

thoughts like successful

on like very briefly,

just on the governance

side.

I think like, you

know, you mentioned

gauges, there's like

conviction voting, there's

like optimistic decision

making.

There's a number of ways

that we can approach

this, which, you

know, all fall onto

this like security to

decentralization to

like efficiency of

decision making kind

of like spectrum.

And I don't think

there's like a one

size fit all sort of

like mechanisms for,

you know, for

governance in general,

but also for like

specific types of

decisions.

And so I think this

will most likely require

a lot of like

iteration.

And so what I think

is likely the most

like reasonable path

here is that like use

the more flexible kind

of like stack that are

like smart contracts.

And especially given

the fact that a lot of

these systems have

already been built,

right, Dowdao, for

example, has worked

on gauges for

neutron related

purposes and that

tech can be reused

for the hub, right?

And so like use these

as experimentation

layers, right?

Try to figure out

what works best.

And then eventually

that can then be

brought into the

SDK if we want to

really bring it as

part of the Cosmos

hub.

But then perhaps it's

also fine to just

control this like

remotely by interesting

accounts and stuff and

have this kind of like

mycelium of governance

of the hub around the

entire AZ.

Yeah, just a couple

of thoughts.

I think Max, you

wanted to interact as

well, perhaps on the

market structure points.

Yeah, I was just

going to add, we've

been, I kicked off this

conversation mentioning

that the allocator and

we've only been talking

about the covenants

since then.

And so just to be clear

on the relationship that

we're seeing here and

thank you, Spade, for

those words.

we view the covenant

system as an initiator

of economic

relationships.

So you will use a

covenant to kick off

to start a

relationship and then

the rebalancer would

be that piece of

technology that would

manage that

relationship over time.

So all those things

that Avril was

saying, those are all

things that we have

been thinking about

for a while.

And once we have the

covenants live, once

we have the rebalancer

live, like we will be

bringing the allocator.

So just wanted people to

be aware of that.

If anyone listening to

the call would like to

ask questions, now would

be a good time to do so.

But I kind of just want to

loop back to Noam because

I'm thinking that, you

know, this all started

with the binaries,

incredibly detailed

post.

So really, I

suppose, A, do you have

any responses to the

kind of bit of

conversation we've just

been having, but also

in terms of next

steps in the process,

what can the kind of

community expect next

from you and

Binary?

Sorry, I forgot to

put this on mute.

Yeah, specifically on

the topic that we're

mentioning governance,

I mean, I have no

much to add.

I mean, I'm a big fan of

sort of the neutron

governance model.

I'm not sure if it

applies to, you know,

all of the things that

we're doing within the

hub.

And I think I'm

mostly just very curious

to see how also RMIT is

like researching this

specific topic.

I don't think, I guess

like what's interesting

here is that Binary

takes a very, you

know, we're an

engineering company

mostly and somewhat a

business company, but

we take a very

engineering heavy

approach to a lot of

this stuff.

You know, some of you

might notice that in

the rest of the

proposals that are

coming out, like the

stuff that we do is

very focused on like,

well, you know, this

is how we practically

do X, Y, Z, you

know, to Marko

basically.

And this is something

that, you know, we

are focused and, you

know, eager to work

on basically.

So in terms of next

steps, which is

something I always

love to talk about,

I think the next

thing is, well, I

have to think for

the atom alignment

treasury, the next

steps would be

probably a follow-up

in the same form

both that we have

outlining phase one

and two on a high

level, and then soon

followed by, and it

depends on the

timeline here, with

the rest of the stuff

that's happening with

the AADAO RFP for

BlockWorks and RMIT,

but soon followed by a,

you know, an official

proposal in the forum

for phase one, basically.

And then we'll have

to see how the

funding gets done

there, because Binary

would love to build

this out.

We'd have to

collaborate with

Informal Systems, of

course, and Informal

has their own

roadmap.

But yeah, so that

would be on the

atom alignment

treasury, and then

hopefully we get to

build this next year

or sooner, who

knows.

And then on our

end, of course, like

we have the drip

coming this week, the

forum post at least,

that is a bit more

opinionated on what to

do, and it's quite

specific, actually, and

I think it should be

a really interesting

conversation starter,

especially with some

of the proposals coming

up soon.

And then the

Stability Reserve

Fund, right?

So that's coming

out.

Also, not sure if I

can make that before

Cosmo first, but

hopefully around that

time, that will go

online as well.

That'll be a great

conversation point.

That will follow the

same trajectory as the

atom alignment

treasury, where it's

first just like a

high level, can we

talk about this, and

then probably like a

phase one, phase two

kind of like on-chain

proposals.

That sounds

fantastic, and it's

great, I'm sure, for

everyone to be hearing

what's coming up.

I haven't had any

further requests for

people to speak, so I

assume that everyone

is just trying to

absorb, but is there

some, sorry, no, go

on, is there something

you want to ask?

Well, there's some

spicy questions from

Jim in the chat, so

maybe we can go over

some of those.

That's always fun.

I don't know if

anyone specifically

sticks out, but I

think it's important

to address some of

these things, even

though they're quite

spicy.

Let me try, sorry,

with where I'm

viewing this from, I'm

not seeing them, but

let me just, sorry, I

know what, and I need

to open the space up in

a different way to see

it.

I'll pick a couple.

The first question is,

well, the most recent

one, at least, is like,

are covenants

enforceable?

To which the answer

is like, yeah, that's

the whole point.

So, like, covenants are

like small contracts,

which can be designed

to basically only

execute messages that

are, you know, only

behave, let's say,

according to the rules

of the agreement that

have been programmed

into the small contracts

themselves.

So, yeah, they're

enforceable.

They're not like social

agreements, they're small

contract, they're code

agreements.

And I'll also take,

like, how deep was

Terra Liquidity?

I think it was pretty

damn deep, because it

was a pretty big,

valuable chain.

At the peak, it was

like $60 billion

of liquidity, of TVL,

sorry.

It had liquidity, like,

across multiple chains

and such.

So, yeah, Terra was

pretty massive in this

regard.

Yeah, I think that was

a response to some of

the early discussion

about why does depth

of liquidity matter.

I think what my

personal take is, is

that it really doesn't

matter how deep your

liquidity is if your

protocol is built on

sand.

So, exactly.

That's what I was

going to say.

That is the major

difference, for sure.

One of the questions

for Jim is, sorry, just

to jump in, I know Jim

is a pretty vocal

naysayer for a lot of

things that we've been

proposing, and honestly

this kind of discussion

is good.

Like, we want differing

opinions, we want

people to push our

buttons or push and ask

why we're proposing

these things.

So, one of the

questions they ask is

like, what part of

your proposals would

incentivize anyone to

buy Atom?

So, I think it's

really, this is a

really important

question, right?

Because at the end

of the day, like,

we're trying to create

demand for Atom, we're

trying to make Atom the

asset that people want

to hold, and the way

I envision, the way I

think about this

anyways is, the hub,

in order for the Atom

Economic Zone to

thrive, we need to have

a strong Atom.

And in order for it to

have a strong Atom, you

need a strong Atom

Economic Zone, in my

opinion.

And obviously, it can

expand beyond the Atom

Economic Zone.

Liquidity as a service,

like what Max was

saying earlier, like,

we actually see a

world where Atom starts

lending liquidity out to

other chains outside of

the security zone of the

hub.

But I think in order to

jumpstart the economy

around the hub, the hub

needs to kind of, like,

be that, I guess, the

one that jumpstarts the

engine.

And there's a cold

start problem with

on-chain, with on-chain,

the on-chain economy in

general.

I think if the hub is

able to enter these

agreements with chains in

the Atom Economic Zone,

with protocols that are

launching specifically on

Neutron, I think you're

going to see, like, a

jumpstart of liquidity

that's going to create

more economic activity

that's going to lead to

more fee revenue for the

hub over time with the

revenue share agreements

that we're seeing.

So I think, like, it's

going to take time.

Like, and I think that's

one thing everyone has to

understand.

Like, we're not going to

see a large amount of fee

revenue happen tomorrow.

It's not going to happen

overnight.

These types of things will

take years to happen.

But in order to jumpstart

that, in order to

hopefully, like, shorten

the time frame it takes

to actually see, like,

sustainable revenue for

Atom Stakers, I think the

hub's going to have to

play, like, a major role

in jumpstarting the

economy around it.

So I also think, like,

the Atom alignment

treasury that Noah's

proposing is now that

instead of the treasury

just holding Atom, it's

now going to have, it's

going to be, I'm sorry,

I'm blanking on the word,

but you're actually going

to see, like, the Atom

treasury actually hold

multiple assets, which I

think is important because

I think that actually raises,

like, the fundamental

floor for what Atom is.

As soon as you start

seeing, like, more

productive assets being

held in its treasury, that

should generate more

revenue for Hub Stakers

over time, and

ultimately, like, it

makes Atom, like, the

shelling point of the

ecosystem, it makes

the Atom the asset

that people want to

hold.

So there's, like, a lot

of indirect benefits,

but there's also going

to be a lot of direct

benefits that you're

going to see over time,

but again, it's not, to

be realistic, it's not

going to happen tomorrow

overnight, it is going

to take some time.

I think, you know, as a

sort of short form, I

think that a lot of the

work that's happened

here is around fixing the

economics associated with

interchain security, so

that Atom benefits from

it.

I think that what

Informal have done in

terms of shipping

interchain security on a

technical side has been

phenomenal, but the

economic side of it

doesn't yet deliver on to

the same level, and it

doesn't return for Atom

stakers in the same way,

but as we create better

alignment and create these

flywheels within the AEC,

that should start to pay

off on the economic side

of it, is sort of

broadly where I think

this is going from.

Max, do you want to

chip in?

Yeah, just wanted to

check in.

Jim, I saw your comment

about just trust us,

bro, right?

So I want to address

that.

So the whole point about

covenants is that you

don't have to trust us.

Right now, with the 450k

Atom, that's being

managed by a multi-sig.

That is the trust us,

bro situation of the

multi-sig.

With covenants, these are

smart contracts.

So all you need to do is

look at the code, trust

the code.

And so I guess, like,

okay, you need to trust

that we have the ability

to build these contracts

and just to give you guys

a little teaser of what

we'll probably be posting

in the next few weeks or

months, but TimeWave has

already built Covenant

V1.

The Covenant V1 is the

set of smart contracts that

will enable the Atom

Accelerator DAO to migrate

away from a multi-sig

and start using smart

contracts.

And we got these

contracts audited by

Informal.

There were zero critical

issues, zero high issues,

zero medium issues.

There were only, like,

two small ones and, like,

three informational.

Like, it was a very

successful audit.

So the whole point that

we're trying to really

stress here is that it is

not trust us, bro.

It is let's make these

agreements crypto-native.

I think there's another

good point that's raised

in these comments, which

is, like, hey, what

happens to Atom if now

suddenly the hub is doing

all of the actions and

taking all of the

opportunities that generally

motivate, like, owning

and, like, having exposure

to Atom, right?

So the idea that, like,

hey, maybe I can LP it or

something, right?

I think, like, the first

thing is, like, currently I

don't think that's such a

driver of, like, having

exposure to Atom.

I think, like, you know,

staking is generally

preferable to being an LP.

But beyond this, I still

think it's a good question.

And, like, in my sort of,

like, frame of reference,

these things should be used

kind of, like, strategically

in two ways.

Like, first, they're really

good at bootstrapping

things.

If you bootstrap a pool,

that doesn't mean that

there's no, like, opportunity

for other organic liquidity

to, like, from users to

come in and also contribute

to that pool, not that it

gets necessarily too

diluted.

And especially since

when you do these

deployments, you have,

like, some tools that you

can leverage.

E.g., if the goal is to

really maximize revenue

for the hub, you could

argue that the LPs

should be staked in what

are called, like, on

AstroPort, at least,

like, generators, which

are, like, the contracts

that are used to

distribute incentives.

I think in most cases,

it makes sense not to do

that because, like, at the

end of the day, given

sort of, like, the size of

the hub, the revenue is

actually kind of

meaningless because it's

so diluted.

But if you don't stake it

into the generators, what

happens is that the pool

stills, like, the liquidity

position still accrues

trading fees.

It just doesn't accrue

additional incentives.

And so what, like, the,

you know, the additional

tokens that can be slapped

on top of the pool.

And so then what happens is

that you can have the pool

be bootstrapped and stable

by having this, like,

layer of protocol on

liquidity that, like,

ensures that regardless of

the conditions, kind of,

like, there's a liquid pool

and liquid market for, like,

Atom and all of its

pairs.

And then you can still

slap additional tokens,

like, for example, the

consumer chain tokens

or the DEX protocols tokens

on top of this to

incentivize, like,

organic liquidity and just,

like, you know, like you

and me to basically join the

pool as well.

But because the LPs are

in stake, the incentives

aren't diluted.

They're only distributed to,

like, to actual LPs,

right, not to the

protocols.

And so what that does is

that it allows you to

basically granularly

control and make sure

that you're preserving

the opportunities for

people to actually use

these assets in DeFi

without having necessarily

all the yields or

rewards being kind of,

like, you know,

captured by protocols

themselves, right,

which would probably

hinder the velocity,

the churn in the market

and wouldn't be such a

great outcome at the

end of the day.

That's an excellent

point.

CryptoGuru,

after you had your hand

up to speed,

so it just brought you

up.

Can you hear me?

Yep.

Fantastic.

So, yeah, guys,

thank you very much for

a wonderful space here.

Just in terms of

alignment to Adam

Economic Zone,

I think what is

important is not to

lose the retail

perspective,

not, yes,

you know,

dynamic liquids taking

tax with all the

graphs and stuff,

I think it's really,

really important to

dump it down to the

level of ordinary

people who not

necessarily have the

same vision as

you guys.

For example,

part of the

fees is accruing

to Adam Stakers,

but the reality is

it's just dust.

Same is true for

Stride, same is true

for Neutron.

So, it really is

not any value to,

let's say, a normal

retail staker.

So, I think the

point number one here

is obviously what

can we do as

users, as

supporters of

Cosmos to

think cleverly

around it.

One of the ideas I've

been putting forward

is rather than

giving the dust

to the

stakers,

there is an

opportunity here

actually to give

all the dust back

to actually Adam

community pool.

So, the community

pool in future

doesn't need to

sell Adam

and then have

the sell pressure

and boot,

like Spade was

saying, bootstrap

liquidity.

I understand

that if

the hub

starts selling

Neutron, for

example, or

starts selling

Stride, instead

of Adam, that

might actually have

a downward

pressure on

the Neutron,

on Stride, and

others,

tokens, but

maybe there

has, we can

reach a

balance.

So, that's my

point number one.

Point number two,

obviously, as I

have hinted,

we are talking

about Adam

tokenomics here,

I think we

really need to

make an effort

to speak to

common man, and

then explain

things in way

they understand

why these

three labs

that are working

on improving

tokenomics, what

are they doing,

and explain it

to retail as

well, because

let me tell

you something,

for you guys

might not be

important if the

price goes up,

but for retail,

to bring massive

amount of users,

I think

positive price

action goes a

long way.

Thank you,

folks.

Really

appreciate it.

These are some

great questions,

and to your

first point,

and in general,

just a really good

feedback, actually.

To your first

point, I'm

personally of the

opinion that,

yes, that should

probably happen.

I understand that

other people might

look at it

differently, but I

do think it makes

a lot of sense

for the dust of

inter-chain security

to go to,

for example,

the atom

alignment treasury

or the community

pool in some

way, especially

exactly for the

usage of liquidity

as a service and

all these other

things that we

talked about today.

So I'm a fan of

that.

I think that's a

separate sort of

proposal that also

the consumer

chains need to

ratify this

internally.

But yeah, I'm a

big fan of that

idea.

But as to your

second point of

basically dumbing

what we do

down, which I

think is a

really valid

point, you

know, it

shouldn't be

that atom

holders have

to read like

a 10-page

essay to keep

track of what's

happening, right?

It needs to be

digestible.

It needs to be

simple.

To that point, I

do think we are

currently just still

at the research

stage.

And so we will

speak in research

language, if you

will.

And, you know,

the conversations

are going to be

rather in-depth

because we have to

work out a lot of

these kinks and

details.

However, you know,

when we get to

that stage, we're

these things go

on-chain or, you

know, on the

forum where it's

like an official

proposal, yes, the

language needs to

be much simpler

and, you know, the

motivations need to

be very clear as

to why we're

doing what we're

doing.

I think Cosmo

First will be a

really good place

for this as well.

I know, Effort

Capital, David,

you're doing a

keynote talk, if I

remember correctly.

I'm going to be

on the panel on

day three together

with Chris from

RMIT to discuss

this specific

topic.

I'm sure there

will be plenty of

opportunities to

discuss this also

in person with

all the people.

I think I really

encourage people to

just, you know, walk

up to any of the

people that are

working on this and

to just, you know,

start a conversation.

But yeah, we've got to

do a better job also

online in terms of

like, you know, these

Twitter spaces are here

for that.

But I think we would

do well with, you

know, partnering also

with some of the

people who are good

at explaining these

things in very simple

terms, like Crypto

Cito, for example, and

so many other

influencers in the

space.

So, yeah, definitely

point taken and

noted and we'll do

our best, of course,

to make this as

palatable as we can.

Yeah, just to chime

in here, I think

ultimately what we're

trying to do is we're

trying to show the

wider interchain and

other projects I want

to launch in the

Cosmos ecosystem that

one, the Cosmos hub is

open for business, not

just as a security

provider, but potentially

as a liquidity

provider as well.

And what you're

getting in the hub, if

you take part in this

like this new vision, is

like you're getting a

long-term partner.

You're getting a

partner that actually

wants to see you

succeed because there's

like skin in the game

now.

I think what you're

seeing like with, I've

said this on a handful

of other spaces at this

point, but the, and I

think Max alluded to it

very eloquently, like

not only is the hub a

shared security provider

now, when you leverage

on-chain governance with

those two, with the

shared security property,

you're actually getting

like bilateral or

multilateral like

alignment.

L2s align with

Ethereum, but Ethereum

is not aligned with

L2s.

And I think this

special superpower that

the hub has with

on-chain governance is

like you're allowed to

create like opinionated

agreements with, with

chains and other

products that want to

launch in the Adam

Economics Zone.

I think that's super

powerful.

So I think when it

comes, when it comes

back to like the

original question, it's

like how do you, how

does this create demand

for Adam?

I think the vision is

if the hub is able to

leverage its on-chain

governance, leverage its

shared security properties

to align with other

chains and other

projects that also

want to align back with

the hub, you're getting

like a long-term

partner, you're not

getting mercenary

capital, you're, you're

getting like a

partnership that we

think is going to

hopefully stand the

test of time.

And we think like

through those long-term

alignments, you're

actually aligning

agreements politically,

socially, economically,

and from a security

perspective, that's going

to naturally create a

demand for Adam over

time.

And then ultimately

what it's going to

hopefully create is

such a large on-chain

economy that's going

to create like actual

revenue for the hub

that, and for its

staker, so it's no

longer, it's no

longer dust.

It's actually like a

legitimate yield

bearing asset.

So that's why I think

it's really important

that the dust that

we're getting today,

or even like treasury

swaps that we

ultimately do with

Neutron and Stride

and other consumer

chains and projects,

is like we're not

using those assets to

just dump it.

Because the moment

that we start selling

Neutron and Stride,

like to me that

alignment is gone.

Like we want to see

them succeed as a

project, and vice

versa, they want to see

the hub succeed.

So we're kind of

trying to balance

out, we're trying to

balance it out, long

story short.

I think unless there

are any further

questions, I feel like

that's a really great

sort of position to end

on.

It is worth me saying

we're going to try and

do more of these spaces

with BlockWorks and

with RMIT.

We've also got some

scheduled live from

Cosmoverse at the end

of each day from there.

So there are plenty of

opportunities for people

to continue to listen

to these conversations,

take time to digest

things, reread forum

posts, come back with

your questions.

This is going to be a

very iterative process

and we really value

everyone's input.

I'd like to thank

everyone that's spoken

today and asked

questions, whether that

was by coming up on

stage or asking them

in the chat or between

the panelists themselves.

I think this has been

a super useful space.

I'm really looking

forward to us doing

more of these and

getting as much input

into the process as

we possibly can because

as I think the

conversations have shown,

it's all very complex,

but there's some really

big opportunities here

for the hub and the

more input we get at

this point, the more

useful that can be.

Thank you very much

everyone and we will

catch you soon.

Bye.

Bye guys.

Thanks everyone.

Bye bye.

Bye.

### Host

- [ATOM Accelerator](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/atomaccelerator.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/ATOMAccelerator)

### Speaker

- [Eat Healthy Get Rich](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/eathealthygetr1.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/EatHealthyGetR1)
- [riley.stride 🦸](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/interchainriley.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/interchainriley)
- [Noam Cohen](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/noamwithveto.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/noamwithveto)
- [Zac Cheah](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/zibin.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/zibin)
- [D](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/effortcapital.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/EffortCapital)
- [jehan](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/jtremback.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/JTremback)
- [Spaydh 💧✴️ | Consensus 🇺🇸](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/spaydh-consensus.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/0xSpaydh)
- [Max Einhorn (🥧 , 📈)](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/max_einhorn.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/max_einhorn)

## Want more TVL for your protocol or chain?

AlphaGrowth grows TVL for protocols and chains through asset acquisition and integration, grants, incentives and LP deals. We built this data and keep it free.

[How we grow TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/defi/index.md) [Talk to AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/contact-us/index.md)
