---
title: "Making crypto compliant without losing decentralization | Twitter Space Recording | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Twitter Space Recording from 2023-06-22 with Parcel, anubhav.eth - scaling treasury ops for DAOs, Kyle Smith | bestape.eth"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/making-crypto-compliant-without-losing-decentralization"
---

# Making crypto compliant without losing decentralization

Recorded: Jun 22, 2023 Duration: 1:00:48

## Space Recording

[Open Original Space](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1nAJErARLeXxL)

0:00 1:00:48

### Full Transcription

Thank you for listening.

Thank you, Kyle, for joining the space and welcome to this, this Twitter space for all

of us who don't know, Kyle is one of the contributors at LexDAO and LexDAO is, you know, just give

me a second.

So LexDAO is basically a cutting-edge decentralized collective of forward-thinking lawyers dedicated

to shaping the next generation of smart contracts.

And that's heavy.

So basically, my first question really is, what is it that LexDAO does?

And Kyle, welcome to the show.

Yeah.

Thanks for having me, thanks for having me, I'm happy to explain what LexDAO does.

One way that might make it just more complicated, but we're the first place that legal engineers

are developing a professional body.

So we're the kind of initial guilds and we're going to be able to supply things like licensing and certification to legal engineers.

We actually do have an early stage certification for legal engineers.

Legal engineers are lawyers who practice law through codes of computational law, law that is highly automated.

And so oftentimes we work with Solidity because Solidity smart contracts are directly plugged into the financial markets.

And very often Solidity does legal work as computational automated work.

So LexDAO itself is, right at this point, it's a business association.

It's a place where crypto lawyers, developers, people interested in this field, congregate to discuss topics, discover each other.

And then oftentimes that culminates in a spinoff project.

So Kali.gg, Kali DAO, it's a way to summon a DAO, is an example of one of our projects that has spun off.

And that one, those are some of the LexDAO legal engineers who also worked on the MOLIC framework that quite a few of these DAO summoners use.

And for instance, DAO house uses the MOLIC framework.

That concept called Rage Quit was developed by the MOLIC framework.

And that is an example of code is law, kind of legal engineering thinking.

And then another spinoff is Real World Asset Consortium.

And that has a few projects in it itself.

And that focuses on oftentimes real estate and how to tokenize real estate.

And one example is if you buy a boost property, how that works is that you buy an NFT.

And then so somebody just transfers an NFT to you and then that's how you purchase that property.

That's amazing.

That's quite fascinating to hear.

So to get started and begin things, Kali, what has been your journey like?

How did you end up contributing to the Web3 space?

What did you used to do in your yesteryears?

And what got you excited about Web3?

Yeah, well, I'm a legal engineer.

So after law school, I decided to get into computer science.

And my background, the reason I did that is I worked quite a bit in enterprise music publishing, music rights management.

And that one is a very information-rich area of practice.

So our contracts, when we signed, one deal I did, it was that comes to the top of mind.

And it was buying from one of the top music publishers in the world, buying one of the better-known catalogs that had decades and decades of contractual relationships and lots and lots of titles in it.

And so the deal we ended up signing was about as complex as an international trade agreement.

But there's only, say, like a dozen or so people that actually engage with it.

And I saw some information supply chain issues with those really complex agreements and then how the administrative departments were implementing those agreements.

As the lawyers, once they were done the deal, they just left.

And admin was kind of had to, on its own, figure out how to actually administer the agreements without the expertise of the lawyers.

So I thought, well, hey, we actually should, the lawyers should have an extra step and these agreements should have basically an API that admin can then push a button and that helps them.

So that started my journey into connecting law and computer science.

And then I saw that the blockchain world was dealing with a similar problem, but focused on where trust is an issue, so in open markets.

And that's the trustless nature of what we're enjoying in the Ethereum world and other world virtual machine, world virtual machine systems.

And so I continued to build alongside that, with my issue being that trust wasn't the problem.

The parties trusted each other at least enough, but it was how much legal information had to be processed that was the main issue.

And so I finished my journey on that three or four years ago, filed a patent for a new kind of database system.

And then I jumped into Web3.

I was onboarded by a group called Kernel, which is affiliated with Gitcoin, kernel.community, if you'd like to look it up.

And then from there, LexDow reached out to me.

And I was really excited, actually, because I didn't really know what to call myself as a professional.

I knew some people were doing things similar to what I was doing historically, like Nick Zabel, who created smart contracts.

But it was only until I found LexDow, where the name legal engineer, I went, oh, yeah, great.

Okay.

And, hey, there are other people like me.

And so since then, working in LexDow, I've been spending quite a bit of time with the problems that happened in this market, because it's already well built out.

And I mainly do business development in the community.

So I just got off a call doing some business development.

And that's pretty exciting.

Eventually, when the time is right, I'll bring in those inventions I did before joining this network.

So, yeah, so it's been a relatively long path, but it's also multiple technical skills, having to be an expert in law as well as computer science.

And then I also am working still with the music industry, and so having that background in the entertainment.

But, yeah, that's a bit about me.

Awesome.

That's good to hear.

And a big shout-out to Kernel Parcel is also, was also part of Kernel Batch 1.

And, you know, it's so exciting to meet a lot of people who have, you know, started their Web3 journey with Kernel and got the right platform that we can all, you know, get started on.

So it's always great to hear a big shout-out to Kernel.

Yeah, I'm excited to actually learn more about, you know, how we can make, you know, crypto compliant without losing decentralization.

And one of the questions that I have in mind, you know, essentially thinking about this is how can we make smart contracts as, you know, enforceable agreements in meatspace as well.

So I'm not sure, like, I'm trying to understand, like, the first step of what it actually means in Web3 to have, you know, first of all, everything runs on smart contracts.

But then there is the real world where you have to have, you know, contractual agreements.

And so what does it actually mean in Web3 to be compliant using smart contracts?

Yeah, that's a great question.

And from my background in music, I think one of the reasons I am enthusiastic about Parcel is that oftentimes when we negotiate with, the artist negotiates with a label, especially high level, auditing is a really important part of it.

And royalties move from one country to another country, and so auditing is incredibly complicated and, or pardon me, accounting is incredibly complicated, which is one of the reasons auditing is, the contractual rights for auditing is something that the industry spends a lot of time negotiating.

Blockchain, blockchain as a technology is very exciting for what's possible for accounting as well as auditing on an international level.

So long term, I think it's a fantastic fit for the music industry.

I just wanted to say that since Parcel is building up more and more expertise and being able to provide the tools so that we can do those kind of things.

As far as connecting traditional legalese with on-chain, one of the pioneers in the jurisprudential theory here is koala model law, koala with a C, and then otherwise it's spelled the same as the animal.

And they, their concepts, they've got two concepts, two important, very important concepts.

One is regulatory equivalence, and the other one is, I believe it's called technical equivalence.

While we're chatting, I'll share a link to some slides I made that explain koala's perspective.

And then something that LexPunkArmy and LexStyle have kind of co-built together is something called code deference.

And so in the legal contract with code deference, we mentioned the designated blockchain.

And so there's two parts to it.

One is that people are supposed to, when they read the legalese, they're supposed to look at what the designated blockchain is,

and that tends to include a aux address and see what's happening there and recognize that's part of the contractual relationship between the parties.

And then the other aspect of it, the deference, is that if there is some kind of disagreement between the natural language that's written

and what's actually happening on-chain, then what's happening on-chain, all else equal, is what wins the day.

It's important to make it so that there's hardly any conflict there, because it will still take time and energy to figure out if there is conflict.

But having it so that there's a choice between whether it's the natural language or what's actually happening on-chain,

which one should win out if there is some kind of disagreement there, that makes it easier.

And then there are groups like Klaros and Nation3 that are having it so that arbitration, when disputes inevitably arise,

those are run on-chain and disputes happen very quickly.

Those are continuing to build those projects.

There's also Q blockchain.

I was actually just doing a BizDev call with them before this Twitter space, and they are spending quite a bit of time with ICC,

which is an international court.

So that's due to full of – it's like the Delaware Chancellor Court or something like that,

so it's not supposed to be quick on-chain only.

And that probably makes a little more sense for these enterprise DAOs and blockchain.

But those are – yeah, so those are the kind of the two strategies when disputes do inevitably arise.

Either we can have a full on-chain solution, move fast, or we can have professional judicial bodies that are willing to handle these matters.

And so both of those are building out relatively quickly.

Yeah, so I know I've said a lot.

I'm happy to answer some questions.

Yeah, a lot of great stuff there.

So I kind of understand why – like what could be the benefits.

So initially you talked about music, and there's a lot of people actually doing music on-chain or trying to do it,

and I can understand what that would look like.

But are you excited about – like what are the other things that you're excited about that comes from real world

but actually solves a big, big pain point as it moves on-chain,

especially with regards to legal contracts and makes it very, very easy?

Is there anything apart from music that you're always excited about?

Yeah, and even though music is my background, so I'm focused on that quite a bit,

that's not the one that is making the most progress, I would say, actually.

A lot of that is because the traditional music industry – it doesn't –

many people in the traditional music industry don't want to shift.

It would mean a lot of disruption for jobs and major issues that –

also the way that the industry works is that the databases tend to often be not even online,

let alone on-chain.

We have successfully gotten DDEX, which is the standard organization for –

there's only one standard organization.

It's only a small part of the music industry, but it deals with digital aspects of the music industry.

So DDEX came about when iTunes and Spotify became popular.

DDEX has started a NFT working group for metadata.

So the parts of the music industry that can and are already willing to work with on-chain are doing so.

But yeah, I would say the music industry is a very small part of what's exciting about this space.

The one that's taking a lot of my time right now, because it is already a big business, is real estate.

So there are – yeah, solutions are building out fairly quickly.

That also involves network states and network cities, which I don't know if you've read any of Balaji's work,

but he's helping move that forward quickly.

I'm right now actually staying at Cabindal, which is a network city.

And then Azuzulu in Montenegro in April and May was very successful, I hear, from my friends who went there.

And there will be another Azuzulu in Zanzibar at the end of July, if anyone is interested about that.

So really we can do – we can put anything on-chain because NFTs, a big use of NFTs, besides their own internal value,

but in the traditional world, is that they can be certificates of authenticity,

much more efficient than, say, if you have – I don't know if you've ever had, like, a diamond ring or something like that,

and you get a certificate of authenticity with it, and it's a piece of paper,

and it's got some security measures in it, but it's really a piece of paper.

Well, having that stuff fully digitalized and probably even better security,

that works for all certificates of authenticity.

So in some ways this is a library management, like really, really low-level information technologies

that can manage a variety of assets as well as legal entities.

Interesting.

And you mentioned CabinDAO and other DAOs, I think they're really great examples.

And for some of us who don't know about, like, CabinDAO and what they're trying to do,

could you please explain what does CabinDAO do and how is it beneficial to get that model on-chain versus keeping it off-chain?

Yeah.

Well, Cabin uses tokenomics, so that's one of the reasons it's good to have it on-chain.

So Cabin members vote on various measures, and they have Cabin tokens.

And so if you've interacted with DAOs that have token governance mechanisms, it's similar to that.

So somebody who has 10,000 Cabin has more voting power than somebody who has 25 Cabin,

but somebody who has 25 Cabin can still do things that someone who has zero Cabin can't do at all,

like, say, put up a proposal or something like that.

And then another aspect, which I guess could be used in traditional web,

but it's much more trustless and reliable than just traditional web systems,

is that it's a network of communities that are spread throughout the world.

So the city isn't, so in a traditional physical city, the neighborhoods are right next to each other.

The boroughs that are adjacent, New York, for instance, actually uses boroughs.

With Cabin and other network communities that are happening, it's, say, it's crypto nomads who want to be in next month.

They want to be in one place, and month after that, another place.

But they still want to be within the same social group.

So hopefully many of us have experienced how we get a, we spend a lot of our time working with our people remotely, right, on our computers.

And then when we go to these crypto conferences, we finally get to hang out and be physically around each other.

So these network cities, more so than the network states, that's probably one of the more important distinctions between the two,

is a way to have a city similar to a traditional city, but the actual different parts of the city are spread throughout the world.

And then, yeah, using blockchain just means that it's much more reliable what happens there.

And if, say, some government doesn't like what's happening for some reason, it can't also be shut down.

So if we start to, this is more probably on the network state side of things, but issue passports for ourselves,

and then petition the UN so that the passports have some kind of international recognition,

well, then we might get some pushback from a traditional government, and they might want to shut things down.

Well, on the blockchain, that's much more difficult to do than if everything was just running on Amazon web server.

Very interesting.

Yeah, one of the other reasons that I like, you know, something like Yevindau to be on-chain is probably transparency.

Like, you don't really get to see transparency in the real world among the community members.

Like, it can be forged, and, you know, we've seen many instances of, you know, people running a centralized organization,

and, you know, the financials are not right, or there have been some tamperings there,

but with everything being on-chain, I think this is one of the most underrated facets of it.

Yeah, exactly, and that gets back to what I was saying about how the music industry could benefit from this.

I mean, that's the reason why it's taking some time, but the ability to, you don't even need to put auditing rights into the contract.

You just look on-chain and do whatever forensics you need to do, and you know that it's correct.

Yeah, you can look at Cabin's treasury and see where the money is being spent and who made those decisions,

especially with something like Tally XYZ, where it's the entire Dow's decisions are, is how money is actually transferred,

as opposed to something like Snapshot, where you still need to have a trusted kind of centralized group that actually administers it.

And then also, yeah, it's also plugged into liquidity.

So Cabin token, I don't actually, I have to speak with John and all that about what the plans are with the Cabin token,

and we all know that there's major SEC issues with having tokens be evaluated in the open market.

But once we figure that out as a world community, that's also, I mean, that's one of the most exciting things about this blockchain space, digital assets, right?

That's the things that actually have, we've always had, for a long time we've had something like a Chuck E. Cheese token, right?

But that doesn't really have any, you can't stake a Chuck E. Cheese token or swap it out for USDC or something like that.

But all of those are quite possible with Uniswap.

And so there's a way to recognize equity that has not existed yet.

It's a genuine innovation.

I mean, we're able to have computational currency.

So not just computational law, but computational currency.

Yeah, I love that.

I think Chris Lickson talks about it a lot when he says read is for Web 1, write is for Web 2, and then own is for Web 3.

And that's, you know, exactly what we're all here for, a piece of the ownership of the projects that we make it work.

Awesome. I want to switch gears real quickly and talk about DAOs.

You've alluded to DAOs a little.

We've talked about that somewhat with Cabin DAO.

But, you know, DAOs actually became a rage in 21.

And then, you know, it's slightly now going down in 22 and 23.

What do you think is the state of the DAOs, especially with regards to, you know, having a legal entity or not having a legal entity?

And then, you know, what's the current state?

Where is it headed?

Are you seeing that a lot of DAOs will have legal rappers or they won't have?

I think it's, you know, the answer is more nuanced.

So I'll let you, you know, talk about the nuances as well.

Yeah. I'm also president of DAO Coalition, so I'm spending quite a bit of time helping lobby to make sure that DAOs on the government side, specifically the U.S. federal, that's mainly what DAO Coalition right now is focusing on, that regulation is done in a way that supports the evolution of DAOs rather than tries to quash them or something like that.

It seems like, I'm optimistic about it.

I know there are certain different groups that are adversarial, but ultimately, I think the movement is heading in a way that's going to be going to have some consumer protection or just, you know, retail protection,

while also taking advantage of the exciting possibilities in this space.

Gabe Shapiro and Delphi, they've got a concept called Borg.

It's probably helpful for DAOs.

On the legislative level, the DAO word has been a bit watered down, and it is being already implemented in bills like Tennessee's law and Wyoming's law, and it's using the word DAO.

It's not using the word Borg, but just quickly to say a Borg is where it is a traditional entity.

It has traditional entity elements, but it also has DAO elements, so oftentimes when people think of DAO, they're thinking of something that's just completely on-chain,

and something like Uniswap can fit that, where it is really just a pure protocol, but a lot of the area were just thinking about how,

now using a more liberal sense of the word DAO, how it's beneficial, just how groups can organize themselves anyway.

Then, yeah, there'll be more and more of these entities that are using DAO tooling, in the very least,

even if they are large part acting like a traditional organization, and a real property kind of necessitates that,

and that is one of the areas that is being built out relatively quickly.

It's kind of by definition, it's territorial.

So, one thing that seems a lot of groups are in agreement on is that co-ops are already,

they've got a lot of values that the DAO space has, stuff that is owned by the members,

rather than a very hierarchical ownership structure like traditional corporations have.

But I've also worked with, we've worked with FIRM, FIRM.org, and that one is using traditional C-Corps,

but NOSA is safe, so shares are completely on-chain, and there's value out for that as well.

So, yeah, so I would say there's a full spectrum from something that's a pure DAO, like MakerDAO,

and the ones that we pioneered this space, all the way over to something like a traditional C-Corporation,

Delaware C-Corporation, with very clear, here's the CEO, and then here's the employee type of dynamics we're all used to,

but it just runs a bit smoother, and then people can trust each other a little bit more.

It's a little bit more transparent, because it's using these blockchain technologies.

Perhaps, maybe I should have a chat with them a little bit more before I say this,

but it seems like Kevin Milwaukee, his path, he's got Gitcoin going,

and then Gitcoin then went into a full-on DAO owned by the community.

So then he exited it, so instead of exiting to an IPO onto something like NASDAQ,

it's exited it to member-owned, and now he's doing super modular,

and that one, when he described that, when I was on panel with him at the ReFi conference,

he's the CEO, and he's kind of enjoying having that very clear relationship between him

and the people he's co-working with.

So I personally, I like in certain instances where there's a clearer hierarchy,

and then other instances where it's much more community-orientated.

So like, for instance, here at Cabin, it's about co-living,

so it would be pretty funky if the people were co-living with each other,

one person is on top, and other people have to kind of listen to them.

But in a kind of wild-oiled machine where people are trying to get work done quickly,

and there's obviously the expert who should be dictating what's going on,

then in that case, I would probably prefer having a more hierarchical relationship.

So it tends to be, you know, what you want to get done, what tool is right for the job,

and then also it's good to remind oneself that composite materials are really helpful.

So like thinking about a really nice winter jacket or something like that,

it doesn't just have one aspect to it.

It has, if you look at different layers, they have different performance requirements,

but together as a whole, that that's kind of the whole, the full solution.

Even just thinking about the body corpus like a person, the brain works a lot different than the gut, right?

And if you had the gut directly interact with the brain, it would start eating the brain up.

And I know that sounds kind of weird what I just said there,

but hopefully that helps us kind of think a little bit more creatively about what DAOs are

and what DAOs can be and not necessarily get so dogmatic.

It's really great to sometimes be a maxi to build out kind of a newness in the world,

but we can maybe occasionally take a step back and see whether or not that is serving us ultimately.

An example of maybe a little bit more just baseline is Code is Law.

Well, when Ethereum got hacked, that really big hack that had the fork of Ethereum Classic,

was that the right move?

Because that then prioritized that we as a community wanted to succeed

rather than whatever happened with the code, tough luck, that's what we have to go with.

I personally am on the side of all this stuff is in service of humanity.

So if it's not, if it's doing the opposite of that,

then we should be more flexible and maybe make concessions

and not let perfect be the enemy of good type of mentality.

Very interesting.

Yeah, we were just internally discussing about the DAO has that happen

and you just alluded to that.

So, yeah, as I said, you know, there's lots of types of DAOs.

There's protocol DAOs, there's social DAOs, collector DAOs,

investment DAOs, and so I believe like different types of DAOs

require different legal wrappers as well.

And, you know, we're seeing, you know, from our experience,

you know, working with a lot of DAOs at Parcel,

we see that protocol DAOs tend to have payments foundation usually

and, you know, other investment DAOs or, you know, collector DAOs

still likely have an LLC in the U.S. or a C-Corp.

And do you see that this is going to be the way that it's going to be

where you have different types of DAOs and different types of DAOs

have different legal structures?

Or do you think since, you know, also bringing in the situation

in the U.S. with respect to them suing Binance and Coinbase

and now we don't know what's going to happen in the U.S.?

Are they going to still support, you know, the way that they did DAOs earlier?

Are they still going to support them?

Or is it going to be the other way around?

And if that happens, like, how do you see from here

what DAOs could be in terms of having legal entity?

And for all these different types of DAOs that I just talked about,

do you see a different legal entity framework coming up?

Or do you see that this is probably going to be the norm from here?

Yeah, well, already different legal entities are happening.

So Utah actually did adopt QALA model law.

That's the first state that has done that.

I've heard some concerns from experts in the U.S.

that the liabilities of QALA are more European liabilities.

And so Utah isn't going to have to deal with that case law

that is going to try to find a translation

between common law liability philosophy

and civil law liability philosophy.

But right there, though, that is the fact that there's common law out there

and civil law out there, and those are the two systems

that have a huge amount of the world's GDP.

There's going to have to be different legal entities for different issues.

What I mentioned before with the composite,

maybe a little bit more kind of concrete example of that,

is what's called a Cayman sandwich.

And in a Cayman sandwich, there's to have Latin American founders

that they get funded by U.S. VCs.

It requires, I think, three different legal entities for that to work.

There has to be the Cayman Foundation.

There has to be wherever the Latin country,

the company is actually operating in.

And then there has to be a U.S. Delaware C-Corp.

So the VCs are comfortable putting their capital into that.

So I was spending quite a bit of time the past couple of days with Prospera.

They're one of those network states

developing a product that is like the Cayman sandwich,

but it's using Prospera.

So it'll be a lot cheaper and a lot easier to use

than the Cayman sandwich.

And so, yes, I would classify that as one of those composite solutions.

I shared a link just now, what I was mentioning before,

about the Koala system.

I started a few slides there, but, yeah, it goes over code as law,

code difference, and all that.

Have a look at that.

And then I'm going to share, I'll find it, something I,

basically a Venn diagram that explains how we can kind of think about

how DAOs and legal entities can, they're, in a sense,

they're different layers of thinking.

The DAO itself can be, include multiple legal entities within it,

and also can have legal entities that are partially the DAO

and partially just their own thing.

So we can think quite flexibly about it,

but there's not going to be a one-size-fit-all.

It's just going to get more and more diversified as we go,

plurality of solutions, depending on what the underlying problem is.

And that makes sense since we're saying that the Web3 is,

in some ways, a panacea.

Well, practically, if that's going to, in practice,

that's going to mean that it's going to have many, many faces.

If we're actually able to use Web3 for something as different

as just an investment club or a community of people sharing resources

in an intentional living environment, I mean, the list goes on.

I'm actually not being very creative here on all the different ways

that we can use Web3.

I mean, ultimately, Web3 is a ledger system,

and so ledgers are used for all types of things already,

and we can really, we're just expanding the possibilities

of what ledgers can do.

Math came out of ledgers accounting back in ancient Egypt,

and so how much has math and accounting changed humanity

since that time?

I suspect we'll see that much, if not more, diversification.

So I bring up Milwaukee again.

He talks about kind of like Cambrian explosion, right?

But I think that we'll see that with legal entities as well.

But the governments,

at least I'm focusing mainly on the U.S. government,

I think there's just a dialogue going on.

And even people like Eric Gensler,

who are very much against this,

looking at the response to those types of decisions,

I'm confident in the end that,

sure, it's a bit of trial by combat,

but law oftentimes is a blood sport.

Ultimately, the right path will win the day.

Yeah, for sure.

Yeah, I think I completely agree with what you said.

I think it would require like a bunch of entities

to get the work done for DAOs

if the right frameworks don't exist.

And I think we'll see more experimentation with DAOs,

so it's going to get a lot more weird

and a lot more different use cases that are going to come up.

So pretty excited about that as well.

And that reminds me of actually bringing in more talent for DAOs, right?

So who's going to build more DAOs

if you don't have enough talent?

And this is a question that I keep asking myself

and a lot of people ask me as well

as someone who contributes to the DAO ecosystem,

is that there are a lot of contributors

who are attracted towards DAOs,

but they also have like a very secure, high-paying job.

And the first question for them

after they're convinced that, you know,

they want to join DAO is,

how am I going to get my health benefits, right?

How am I going to get, you know,

all the benefits that come up,

that come with a, you know, very secure FANG job?

And is it really legal or not, right?

So there are a lot of concerns

from contributors all around the world,

especially with DAOs that are not,

you know, legally registered anywhere.

What do you think can we do about that?

How can we ask more contributors

the next time I have a conversation with them

to join the DAO

and still not, like,

not feel the risk of being insecure all the time?

And where do you see this going as well?

Do you think the contributors have to,

you know, legally registered as a business

to make sure that the liability

is limited towards them?

Or do you think DAOs will get registered eventually?

And so that will restrict the liability itself.

Yeah.

That's very case by case.

And one of the things we do

at the clinic at LexDAO,

and the clinic is an apprenticeship DAO

where we, on the job,

teach law students

how to be crypto lawyers and legal engineers.

We have a checklist.

We go through a questionnaire

that was developed at ECC.

And we go over the business model

that people that are starting

from zero to one on DAOs

are thinking about.

It can even be kind of useful

for a mid-sized DAO or something like that.

But it's especially useful

for these really early-stage DAOs

and see if there's just too much

of a legal hard problem

that the DAO doesn't necessarily want to take on.

So, for instance, Uber, right?

Uber took on one of the areas

that Uber had to deal with

was legal hard problems.

So it wasn't just using the app

and all that innovation

that Uber had to do.

It also had to deal with regulators

and how CABs worked and such.

And so DAOs,

because they have so many applications,

one of them is crowdsourcing.

So a motivation to get DAO Coalition running

actually was because

the crowdfunding lobby group

sent a letter to Congress

concerned how the DAO space

is doing its own crowdfunding.

So, yeah, so each person

really should think about

what their own,

what kind of risks they want to assume

and be realistic about

the legal hard problems.

At this really early stage,

it's very rare that DAOs

have zero legal hard problems.

Down the road,

there will be DAOs

that can form that

really only have to deal

with their own technical hard problems

and not take on the legal.

But, yeah, we're so early on

that almost all of them

have to take on legal hard problems.

One of the main reasons

LexDAO exists

and is building out

is so that we can help solve that.

So fewer and fewer DAOs

have to take on

the legal hard problem.

As far as getting,

like, especially in the U.S.,

health insurance,

because the state

doesn't provide that,

there's Opolis that's around

and then there's also Toku.

And Toku worked great for,

it also deals with paying contributors.

So Toku has special purpose vehicles

around the world.

So legal entities

in different territories

that then directly pay their contributors.

So a lot of legal headaches

are being solved by Toku.

Toku itself is not a DAO.

So one of the ways

that DAO contributors

can avoid certain legal hard problems

is to accept that

their overall solution stack,

a good chunk of it,

will be traditional methods

and maybe down the road

they can diversify a bit more,

decentralize a bit more.

So one of the concepts

that the DAO world is accepting

is progressive decentralization.

So don't try to start out

at 100 miles an hour,

you know, build it out slowly.

Initially, when you're the core team,

it really is just a centralized team

and maybe not, yeah,

deal with those legal hard problems initially

because it is a central core team.

And I mentioned in Gitcoin again,

or Gitcoin,

which is to,

believe it was just a,

yeah, we actually worked with them

when they switched to foundation.

So it is,

it was a Delaware holding company,

very, very traditional.

And then when it exited the community,

it had enough success

that it could actually pay the lawyers

for the Cayman Foundation,

which is really expensive.

Cayman's always expensive, whatever,

but especially because

this is legal innovation,

it's legal innovation.

It's quite costly.

And, but Gitcoin could take that on

because it had enough success.

So I was able to do that

and API3 did that before Gitcoin

and I think Dash did that before API3.

So there was already

a precedent that helped lower cost.

And as the space matures more and more,

people will be able to kind of stand

on the shoulders of giants

as, yeah,

so to help deal with that a bit.

But as far as people

that really want the same exact thing

and as they enjoy

in traditional web too,

I don't know if we were 100% there.

Again, we have something like Toku

that can help us get there.

And that wasn't even really around last year

or it was just starting out.

So we're moving quite quick.

But I would just say that

you might not be a good fit

for the space

at the super early stage

if you aren't willing

to take on that entrepreneurial risk.

But of course,

the point of the risk

is that you can be very successful

if you're an early adopter.

And then also,

if you don't really believe

in things like decentralization

and such.

So if you don't have

an underlying

kind of more philosophical reason

to be in this

and you really just want a paycheck,

then yeah,

there might be more headaches

than you really actually want to deal with

at this super early stage.

But just check back in

a few years later

and you might really enjoy it.

So, you know,

onboard at the right time

for yourself.

And I personally waited

until a certain point.

I was watching it

so I was paying attention

so you can get updates

and then when you feel

the time for you,

jump in.

And Colonel was the way

that I felt

that was the right time

when I saw Colonel

and the kinds of teachings

Colonel had.

I went,

okay,

this is now my moment.

This is brilliant.

Yeah,

this is probably

the best response

of God

and I've asked this

to about five,

six people

on this Twitter space

is amazing.

So, yeah,

I mean,

just to stretch on that,

you know,

Caymans Foundation thing,

I really understand now

what I could answer

probably to anyone

who's trying to ask me

the question next time.

With regards

to the Caymans Foundation,

I know a lot of people

actually go towards that.

You said Gitcoin,

you mentioned API3.

I know ENS

is also Caymans Foundation,

so is DeveloperDAO.

And one of the things

that happens

with Caymans

is that,

you know,

now the liability

comes back

to the contributors

and you mentioned

Toku,

which is pretty interesting

and how that can help.

So just to understand

it correctly,

if Gitcoin has

a Caymans Foundation,

using Toku,

it can still

employ legally

all the employees

in the respective

countries

the contributors

reside in.

and so,

could you explain

how does that work?

Yeah,

well,

I mean,

and it might be good

to reach out to Toku.

I can connect you,

at least one member of Toku.

Jeff,

he's a really good friend.

He helped me out

one time.

Yeah,

so he's a close friend,

Jeff.

But anyway,

Toku,

yeah,

the special purpose vehicle

thing that I mentioned earlier,

that's just a fancy way

to say a legal entity

that is supposed

to do one thing

for the overall organization

and they're usually used

when the organization

is a multinational

and so the organization

might be based in the U.S.,

but it needs to do business

in Germany

and so it has a German

special purpose vehicle

that they can then

do that business

within Germany

and so Cayman foundations

are even more likely

to have to do

a special purpose vehicle.

We had

a really great conversation

and one of our

study groups

every Friday

in Lextel server

we have study groups

and we had one

parcel just last Friday.

It was a great study group

and I think it was

the beginning of January.

Hopefully,

we do have the recording

somewhere.

We've got to

make it more accessible

to the public.

But anyways,

this one was with ApeCoin

and in that conversation

with ApeCoin,

they were furthering

their decentralization

with their Cayman foundation.

Yeah,

we discussed

in more detail

what special purpose

vehicles are

and Jonathan,

he's done,

he kind of led

that dialogue

and he's done

I think over

a hundred Cayman foundations

for various groups

in this space

and so he was,

you know,

basically said,

yeah,

the special purpose vehicle

is another aspect

of having a fully functional

Cayman foundation

and again,

those are,

really,

they're just legal entities

but they're

for one particular purpose

and usually it's

so that the main organization

can operate

within multiple jurisdictions.

And so Toku,

just real quick,

Toku has spent

a lot of time

and energy

doing this purpose vehicle thing.

so they've got quite a few lawyers

on their team

and yeah,

that's why

they're a legitimate value add

for our space.

Yeah,

awesome.

You know,

always good to see,

you know,

people solving

legal issues

that can bring

an onward

millions of people

in the space

so that's always great to see.

Yeah,

I want to,

you know,

really touch base

with regards

to what LexTao does

and for our listeners,

we talked about

what LexTao is

but for someone

who's wanting to,

you know,

learn more about

what legal compliance

mean

in Web3

or want to start a Tao

but does not really know

what legal and compliance

would come

with forming a Tao.

could you talk about

how LexTao

could really help

someone who's trying

to form

their own Tao?

Yeah,

so right now

the main offering

we have for that,

I mean,

people can just

do their own research

and we've got projects

like an interactive

chat AI

that people can,

yeah,

on their own time

do that type of thing

but right now

what we've got

that is focused

on helping

early stage

Taos with that

is what I mentioned

earlier with the clinic

so with the clinic

the way it works

is those people

are interested

they become a patron

to the clinic

and that's a $300

contribution

and then we

we have a questionnaire

that they fill out

and that questionnaire

was developed

by really sophisticated

lawyers in this space

at ECC

and that goes over

and so it's basically

a liability checklist

all the different kinds

of compliance concerns

people just have

at the back of their mind

and then we have

a two one-hour calls

with the team

after they fill out

the questionnaire

and we ask them questions

and kind of

once we understand

what they want to do

we can kind of

more tailor

our suggestions to them

and oftentimes

what comes out of that

is

they now

we basically go

oh okay

I could use

an unincorporated

non-profit association

or I could use

an LLC

or it was

two or three

different options

that are

a relatively good

fits for them

and then that's

kind of

where they

end up

and also recognizing

oh if I have it

say for instance

I have

if I want my tokens

to be transferable

then there's this

whole extra

compliance burden

I have to keep

back in my mind

but if I have them

as non-transferable

that's less of an issue

and then

for instance

Kelly

I mentioned earlier

that DAO Summoner

on the Moloch

framework

it's possible

to actually have

a token be

non-transferable

and then

just do a

proposal in the DAO

and switch it to transferable

so

those solutions

are really good

because

whatever choice

is made

at an early stage

isn't

written in stone

forever

it can be modified

when the DAO

gets a little bit

more sophisticated

but yeah

so that's basically

what we're

offering at this point

you'd be working

with law students

and those law students

down the road

will be

hopefully

really well known

or at least

highly capable

crypto lawyers

so you'll be able

to build those

relationships

with the legal community

that's relatively

necessary in this space

by going through

the clinic

and the clinic

is

a

charity

so

well it's not yet

we're in the process

but eventually

at least within US

that 300

should be tax deductible

but yeah

as far as

kind of white glove

that's the only thing

we really have

right now

we're continuing

to grow

so we'll be able

to offer more

sophistication

down the road

but if you're

interested in

working with the

clinic

you can

just send me

a DM

and we can get

the ball rolling

that way

and then if there's

any kind of

special work

that needs to be

done

we do a minimum

around

3k worth of work

but then yeah

you can work

with law students

and that also

helps lower

the legal costs

quite a bit

we're not a law firm

so we can only

help to a certain

extent

and then

you still have

to hire a law firm

for everything

you need

but considering

how expensive

lawyers are

especially in this

field

if you use it

strategically

you can

really lower

your legal costs

and the law firms

enjoy it as well

because

when you ask

some questions

they don't have

to kind of

educate you

you already

know what

you want

and so

then they

can do

their job

easier

so yeah

so just

DM me

if you're

interested

in a

working clinic

otherwise

LexDAO

is totally

anyone's

welcome

to join

LexDAO

and hang

out

if you want

to become

a member

of LexDAO

that's also

300

that one's

300

per year

it's not

you can get

a lot of

the benefits

as a non

crypto lawyer

within LexDAO

without being

a member

and if

you can go

to LexDAO's

discord

at LexDAO

dot chat

HTTP

so just

don't

don't put

the S

in there

I'll just

move you

over to

the discord

invite

so yeah

LexDAO

dot chat

and you're

welcome

to say

hi

I mentioned

earlier

every Friday

we've got

study group

so that's

a way

to kind

of

engage

and start

to learn

about

this

space

and then

we have

put it

down

took it

down

for now

because we

had

some

issues

with somebody

misusing

it

but we

have a

directory

that when

it's back

up you

can search

through that

directory

and find

professionals

to answer

your questions

awesome

this is

great

yeah I

can I

can speak

from first

hand

experience

that lawyers

are really

really expensive

and this

is this

is a great

strategic move

that you

can do

for yourself

we're frankly

really tired

of you

know

refilling

the

retainers

that come

with expensive

lawyers

so I

completely

understand

what you're

saying

all right

cool I

think

we're about

to wrap

up but

before that

I have

one last

question for

you Kyle

you know

Web3 is

about communities

and about

belongingness

and I think

you found it

first with

Cornel and

then with

LexTower and

all the other

subsidiaries

my question

is apart

from the

communities

that you're

already a

part of

which is

your next

favorite

community

and why

it's

interesting

because usually

if I really

like that

community

then I

try to

join it

I guess

yeah it's

the communities

that I

just didn't

have enough

bandwidth to

continue to

spend time

with them

I've already

mentioned it

before but

yeah GetCoin

I had to

not spend

so much

time

with my

friends at

GetCoin

and occasionally

I get an

excuse to

say hello

to them

but otherwise

I don't

get to

and then I

probably

NFT

communities

I don't

get to

I am a

musician

myself

and I'm

a very

creative

person

and it'd

be fun

to hang

out with

those

creative

groups

within

NFT

communities

say like

one of

a marketplace

but

something that

like really

clearly comes

to mind

yeah I don't

actually have

an answer

it's a good

question

though so

I'll think

about it

awesome no

worries we'll

get this

question again

to you next

time we do

a Twitter

space

awesome all

right thank

you so much

Kyle for

joining this

Twitter space

it's a wrap

this time it's

been a pleasure

talking to you

I'm looking

forward to

many more

conversations

and again

thank you so

much for being

a sport and

explaining

everything to

all of our

listeners have

a good day

you too

thank you

very much

you too

thank you

very much

thank you

thank you

very much

thank you

very much

thank you

thank you

for being

thank you

### Host

- [Parcel](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/parcel.md) from [Parcel](https://alphagrowth.io/parcel.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/parcelHQ)

### Speaker

- [anubhav.eth - scaling treasury ops for DAOs](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/anubhaveth-scaling-treasury-ops-for-daos.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/0xAnubhav)
- [Kyle Smith | bestape.eth](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/bestape.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/bestape)

## Want more TVL for your protocol or chain?

AlphaGrowth grows TVL for protocols and chains through asset acquisition and integration, grants, incentives and LP deals. We built this data and keep it free.

[How we grow TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/defi/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo) [Talk to AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/contact-us/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo)
