---
title: "✴️ Neutron Round 2 - AtomZone #04 | Twitter Space Recording | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Twitter Space Recording from 2023-04-04 with Cosmos Hub ⚛️, Røbb Stack ⚛️, Cryptocito | YouTuber ⚛️, D, Eat Healthy Get Rich, jehan, Spaydh 💧✴️ | Consensus 🇺🇸, søi2studio ₿, Erkan erdogan"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/neutron-round-2-atomzone-04"
---

# ✴️ Neutron Round 2 - AtomZone #04

Recorded: Apr 4, 2023 Duration: 1:34:00

## Space Recording

[Open Original Space](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1rmGPkmZZLmKN)

0:00 1:34:00

### Full Transcription

I have some kind of problem, but it looks fine so far, so all good.

Nice. Yeah, I know you must have crazy PTSD from the last time, but I think you have a lot of questions that last time you couldn't ask, and I had to lead the conversation. But I think today you can hopefully get all your questions answered as you wanted to get on the last time.

All right.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I hope so, too.

I think so.

I think so, he's still connecting a spade here. I don't see him yet.

I think it should be coming soon.

Yeah, hopefully we can also get some alpha on the NTRN tokenomics. I guess that's the final piece where I've seen a little bit of discussions on Twitter. I think Lavender5 put out a thread. So that's going to be interesting what the plan is there.

Yeah.

He dropped out.

He dropped out.

Yeah, it was for like five minutes. We still have hope for spade to come. And also Jeanne should

be coming soon.

Yeah. There we go. Sorry, does it work now? Doesn't seem to be the case, but it says that you're a speaker.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Maybe, sorry. Can you try to get in with the NTRN account? I think last time that was a

question. Maybe that's better.

Maybe, sorry, can you try to get in with the NTRN account? I think last time that worked.

Maybe that's better.

Yeah, he's messaging me that he's having some connectivity issue. So it is getting quite difficult to kind of have this Twitter space because it's just every time there is a new problem.

I mean, instead of changing the Twitter logo, maybe Elon should fix Twitter spaces.

Yeah. That should be definitely a priority.

Yeah.

Otherwise, we really should start to consider other kind of platforms because it's not possible every time the conversation can happen because of this issue.

That's true.

That's true. Yeah.

That's true. Yeah.

Okay. I'll try to find the Spade and Jeanne. So I will close the mic for a second to try to ping them.

Hey, folks.

Yes.

Yes.

I was hoping that you will be able to speak.

I'm sorry. It's an eventful night, let's say.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Don't worry. Don't worry. We are happy to have you here.

How's everyone doing?

So how's it going?

Yeah, I'm good. Are you?

Doing good. Yeah.

I'll just say I'm not sleeping a whole bunch these days with all the things that we're wrapping up at the moment, but it's also really exciting to see all of the projects kind of like starting announcing that they'll be on Neutron, seeing a lot more information being released.

There has been obviously like a lot of conversation on the forum prop. I think that's really interesting to see a whole, you know, a whole bunch of people are now kind of like talking about the issues that we've been highlighting for a whole while, basically.

But it's a good thing then that we have answers for them. So, you know, all of it is kind of really exciting, basically, from my perspective. And I guess the last most exciting thing is, I believe the tokenomics have just been released on the blog. So, you know, that may be interesting to folks. If we have a tweet coming out, I'll pin it to this column.

Great timing. So, we can talk about it.

Yeah, I know, right?

We can talk about it.

That gives us a topic, I guess, yes. That's fortunate.

I mean, we definitely have a lot of topics because I was also following the discussion on the forum and there were a lot of interesting questions. I also think that you're doing an amazing job just once where all the values are concerned because you're actually very, very informed about replicated security and

probably one of the best advocates and probably one of the best advocates right now for replicated security because you know the dynamics and

every concern I was following also the latest podcast with the Cosmos Club. You really answered very well on the concerns. So, it's great to have a team very informed about what's coming on the

on the on the Atom Economic Zone because it will be very important to start very well this new era on Cosmos Hub. So...

Yeah, definitely. I mean, you know, it's kind of just to quickly add something here. It's kind of one of the things that we signed up for when we were, when we decided to be the first team that, you know, publicly announced that we would be going through with replicated security, right? This is a new technology.

This is a new technology. None, like no one has ever done this before. There are maybe some things that we can get inspiration from with kind of like auctions on polka dots so that that may be interesting for us and the future projects to get some inspiration from as we refine the systems.

But beyond this, like, there is no template. We are pioneering this, this new thing. So we've, you know, we, we need to be doing the work to refining what is a consumer chain proposal? What is the process of onboarding and in the future, perhaps like onboarding a consumer chain? If like, if, you know, things change between the Cosmos Hub and that chain or whatever, we need to be thinking about like, how do we do MEV within the context of replicated security? How do we do? How do we ensure that the economic model works and all that kind of stuff?

And all that kind of stuff. So yeah, as, as, as, as, as you said, like, it's been, you know, on top of building a chain, there's, there has been a lot of thoughts and efforts invested in that because, you know, we, we like this technology, we like what it does to the hub and what it does to our project as well. And, and yeah, just making sure that we understand it properly is, is, is a whole significant part of the job, basically.

Yeah, and, and, and I was just, I just found the neutron economics article. I, I have it right now. I think that we will also share it soon in the comments of the discussion. So can you talk a little bit about the initial distribution?

Yeah, if Twitter allows me to unmute myself, I will be very happy to. So yeah, the whole point is that neutron needs to be able to, like neutron as a community and as a project needs to have the infrastructure and the means to steer itself towards its best.

best form, right? So that includes both its ecosystem as well as its kind of like technical features and implementation. And so as a result of this, the chain needs to be able to be upgradable, basically, it needs to be able to change over time. And in the context of open permission, permissionless, sorry, systems, we don't have any sort of like KYC or judges or whatever to ensure that people making changes or proposing to

make changes to the protocol are legit, that they're well intentioned and that kind of stuff. And so we need another mechanism. And the, you know, the token is that mechanism, it's a mechanism by which we can create economic incentives, that tie the participants together around an ecosystem, help guide their interactions, so that together, they contribute to the best of their ability to a given kind of like public good that there are or that their livelihood and that they're,

that they're, that they all benefit from the success of, I guess, and that they also get like the ability to steer that project together through that token as well. And so the initial distribution intends to, one, empower the DAO, so the common entity that is formed by the code and the kind of like the aggregation of code and participants within

of them all of them all, basically. So that's why the DAO has most of the tokens that will ever be created, unless the DAO decides to create more, of course. And then there's an allocation to the teams who develop the initial code, and then an allocation to the initial contributors, the early backers, as well as a larger allocation to the community, most of which is in the form of the airdrop to the Cosmos Hub community.

So, yeah, so that, that's kind of like the, the rough outline.

Okay, in the meantime, also, Gian just joined. Hey, Gian.

Oh, yeah, hello.

Hey, Gian.

Sorry, I just caught the end of that, so I don't have much to say. Sorry.

Okay, don't worry, don't worry. Okay, so, Spade just, just mentioned the secret word that everyone was waiting for, which is the airdrop. So I think we should definitely dig a little bit about that, because, because many community members were waiting for that, and also validators were interested in this initial allocation, because somehow it also covers some of the initial costs, because, in the end, I think that Neutron Tokenomics,

aims to be deflationary, so it, it will definitely focus more on the value of the token. So this initial distribution could be also important to solve some of the concerns. Maybe you can talk about a little bit about this airdrop for delegators and validators.

Yeah, for sure. So the approach that the airdrop takes is that it airdrops to the stakeholders of the customer's hub through the stake. And there's, there's, there's a few reasons for this, that we, that we can go in detail, just to touch on the…

um the approach that the airdrop takes is that it airdrops to the stakeholders of the cosmos hub

through the stake and there's um there's there's a few reasons for this um that we that we can go

in detail just to touch on the specifically on the validator side of things airdropping to

so the idea of solving the cost of infrastructure through airdrop is simple in practice but in in

like simple in theory but actually pretty complex in practice because while the top of the set

remains somewhat stable um if you look at the bottom of the set the validators that are there

can be dropping out and in of the set pretty rapidly right and because this part of the set

is where the financial troubles are concentrated in the context of replicated security um the top

10 validators are probably not going to have any problem running an additional node but the bottom

10 probably um will have a much harder um time right and so you know making sure that we can

target these ones is very critical but it's also very difficult because it changes all the time and so

while technically it could be possible to um to target them um there's a lot of complexity around

the fact that for example we would have to commit to distributing to certain addresses um at least

two weeks up to three weeks before the actual distribution happens which means that there's a

lot of fences that by the time we distribute tokens some of these validators are not in the set anymore

and that there are new validators that are in the set and therefore have to pay for that additional

node but they don't actually get anything and so we um decided that because most validators um and

yes it is not mandatory and most validators don't use their um don't use the self stake because they

have literally zero incentive to do so and it's just more convenient to manage your delegations through

just a normal account that makes a delegation to your to your validator um it basically means that

you know if you have atom staked you'll be getting um the airdrop and like unless you're

um under some of the exclusions which are for example if you have less than one atom staked

um if you are um from the us or that kind of stuff unfortunately you won't be eligible to participate in

the airdrop um now the to come back to the to the validators what that means is that it's likely that

most validators will get um ntrn tokens and um we are working on something that we know will be

efficient at reducing cost for the validators which is the soft opt-out um jihan is definitely

one of the best person to um speak about it like from the technical point of view as well

we've discussed it um with him quite quite a bit and so we will be going forward with putting the

soft opt-out onto um the public rehearsals for the potential launch of neutron that will be organized

soon so that we can test the hell out of the feature make sure that it works and then if that's

the case that allows us to ensure that about 75 bottom validators don't have to run the node if

it's not sustainable for them to do so basically yeah do you want me to speak to how that works

yeah for sure actually i think that would be really useful and the trade-offs as well may be

interesting to discuss yeah it's a soft opt-out basically um it what it does is extremely simple

it's actually a very very small code modification too which is nice um what it does is when the

when the when the consumer chain so neutron um usually what it what it will do is it will send

when a validator's had downtime for the downtime period of uh you know it's around it'll be around

uh a little around three days it's gonna be the same as osmosis uses um

and um basically when um when that uh when that happens usually a packet sent to the hubs that they

will get jailed for downtime which is the same as happens they have downtime on the hub so what what

what the soft opt-out does is it just checks when that package is sent that packet is sent it just

checks uh what the validator's position is in the set it's extremely simple so it just looks is this

validator in the top 95 percent by power or is it in the bottom five percent by power if it's in the bottom

five percent um it just won't send the packet so what this means is that validators in the bottom five

five percent and and like like spig was saying it's it's actually a large number of that due to the

the way steak is distributed um the the large number of validators about 75 who are in the bottom five

percent and so um they don't have to run the consumer chain they they just don't have to run it and uh

they'll never be jailed for that and that's that's really it and so what this does uh to get technical

with it we're compromising on liveness and not on safety so the reason that is is because you still need

the same number of signatures the same amount of power to um approve blocks on the consumer chain

it's just that five percent of validators can optionally be persistently down and and not be

jailed for it so uh what that means is that the security is exactly the same it's still secured by

the exact same market cap as the hub itself uh but liveness is impacted so what that means is that

um let's say when you you can't have the chain run without more than 66 of the validators being

online and signing blocks and so the most um kind of the most prominent place that this comes to play

is during upgrades because that's where you know validators will install the new software and will

you know change cosmos chains will go down for a few minutes while that happens and so if you have

five percent of the validators that are always down anyway that means you're like five percent slower

to get back to the you know full set that you need um so that that'll be the impact um

um we've uh we've been testing this out in uh test nets it doesn't seem to affect much else um i i

don't think i think the effect on upgrades will also be very minor um so it's it's i think it's a

a good compromise to uh save money for the very small validators but still have the consumer chain

run so the exact same full security

and for the small validators one thing that is kind of nice and that is due to the fact that this is a very

small kind of like modification to the code of ics is that um it actually doesn't change the way that

the rewards are um distributed and so you know even if you opt out meaning that if you don't start

running a node and you're permanently down um you'll still get the equivalent um share of the revenue

generated by neutron as to your stake on on on the hub which means that that should provide you with the

means of properly evaluating whether or not um you would be able to run this sustainably in the future

so one of the advantage of of going for that technology if we can confirm um beyond the

internal test nets that we've had already um with the public rehearsal that this is safe to use

is that it will allow us to collect data without putting duress or any sort of centralizing force

onto the validator set um on you know just how much revenue is being distributed and that kind of stuff

yeah it's it's um it's so it does actually have a little bit of a benefit to the small validators

because they're getting rewards and and not not spending the money on the hardness so you also

want to mention that um the fact is though small validators will want if you're near the threshold

you're probably going to want to get ready to to run uh the consumer chains um because um you know if

you're number 70 uh you know 74 or something uh or number 76 i guess rather if you're number 76 you're

going to want to be prepared for when you go over to being number 75 um although it's not by number

exactly it's by percentage but you know what i mean so um so validators should probably be ready but

the thing is since the the downtime period is relatively long on on consumer chains so that's

what we're recommending um validators also who if they unexpectedly get a large delegation and cross

over the threshold they'll have enough time they shouldn't have time to get to get running in that case

yeah and i think that uh right now we can uh we are going extra careful especially with the bottom

validators but uh the reality is also that uh mostly right now we can make assumption about

what we expect to be uh the relation between consumer chain and uh cosmos sub especially for validators

because we don't know yet uh how all the economics will actually works and i think

it will be interesting to have this perspective now that we have uh both a representative from neutron and

the cosmos sub is basically the synergies that we can create between a consumer chain and a cosmos sub

because uh uh if we see uh probably the main difference between right now a proof of stake uh that is

sovereign and replicated securities that the proof of stake uh a sovereign chain has to really boost

inflation in the beginning to be profitable validators but even then most of validators are

not profitable especially because the current market condition so even in that situation there are

issues that are now represent a problem from a business perspective for our validators while the main

difference that i see on replicated security is basically that the consumer chain can actually

focus on produce value for the token which opens to a completely different dynamics because if a proof of

stake sovereignty basically has to focus on inflation actually uh the consumer chain can focus on the

value of the token and so bring a different form of revenue also for validators because if the token goes well

it will be also profitable for validators and for cosmos sub itself because it will bring value for atom directly

from the revenue generated so it's a different model and i this is basically my idea but it doesn't necessarily

can be true like uh we are i think that uh we have to realize that we are experimenting right now

so it would be interesting to see a different perspective about uh uh about the the idea of the relation

between cosmos sub and uh and the neutron maybe spade they can can start

hey just not to interrupt i just i i i do have to leave soon um so i wanted to see if there were any

more questions about the soft opt out or anything else on that i can answer while i'm here

yeah i think i think that uh d has a question so we will bring in let's see if we can connect

hey you guys hear me

yep awesome thanks um yeah i i i personally like internally have been battling with whether

the soft opt out and i've said this i think on twitter and i've said this in a couple of group

chats with some people in in the cosmos eco i i struggle with whether the soft out is soft opt out

is the right method um obviously i understand uh the lower validator set having concerns whether

it makes economical sense for them to do it um i guess my first question is like how long do we think

we're gonna keep this soft opt out uh on for

um first first i guess babe may have a more nuanced answer to this um but i personally i don't see any

downside especially at five percent um i don't see any downside to having it but obviously once we run it

we'll see um but i i don't necessarily uh think we're working on other stuff so you know like um

opt-in security uh where it's it's a little bit more of a thing where any validator can join um

they used to call that icsv2 that's you know in the works um but i do think that replicated security will

always be a thing that is the right match for for some chains and so i think that soft opt out uh

could be a good tool to enable that um but yeah i can't say for sure it's always going to be around

forever or you know um but yeah there was the other another option we looked at as well was um

the idea of having a mechanism to um give a certain fixed amount uh of the of this of the stride token

over a consumer chain token to each validator um like a minimum income um it's a little bit harder to

implement but yeah that's my view i guess it's not very extremely conclusive but uh

yeah that's fair i i think again i'm probably i'm probably a minority uh in in this i in this

thought but i feel like validating of course we want the validator set to be decentralized we got

to create new ways of doing that right like liquid safety is one form of decentralizing uh or

distributing the the stake in in the hub um obviously better wallet uis to incentivize

people that are coming in to delegate towards uh lower people you know lower validators in the set

i just feel like if you were validating for the hub today should you continue to get inflation in atom

if you're not supporting replicated security which has always been the thesis for for the hub regardless

of economics right it's like should should they continue to get neutron should they continue to get

at them if they're like what purpose are they serving for the hub if they're not taking part

in replicated security again i'm probably a minority in this well we are we're talking about the bottom

five percent um so it's it's not extremely significant either way and what i would say is i think it's good

to have them because um it's it's it's a way for people to get started it's a way for organizations

for validators to get started to get into the set um you know contribute to the liveness and security

of the hub itself uh which is kind of you know safeguarding security of the consumer chains in

some ways um and not be hit with uh you know not be hit with like the full brunt of all the stuff

you have to run right away um yeah so that's that's how i would see it i i think that's definitely

fair i the only reason why i'm kind of on the fence too is like there's people that are or there's

validators they're at you know 174 173 in the ranking right now and they're running at half

percent commission and i'd be like i'd argue that maybe the hub needs to actually have a minimum

commission which i've been on the fence about personally for a while but i feel like if you're

if you're a struggling validator and i'll put that in quotes and you can't run a consumer chain

maybe you should consider not running at a half percent commission right like i feel like there's a game

theoretics here where if if we subsidize or if we allow validators to soft opt out then we're not

keep making an incentive for them to continue buying atom which creates like this self-reflexive

profits prophecy where if enough lower validators are buying atom to maintain in the validator set

uh then that makes validator that makes atom price go up which kind of allows them to stay profitable

uh by running multiple consumer chains over time and by doing this you're kind of incentivizing them

to not continue to buy atom per se and then maybe just like live off inflation but i see both points

i'm just kind of playing devil's advocate a little bit yeah it's an interesting question yeah okay i guess

i'm gonna bounce guys thanks uh thanks for having me yeah thank you sean yeah bye bye

bye bye one last thing on on kind of like neutron side like like so the first thing is what's really

convenient about this specific version of the soft opt out is that it's entirely implemented on the

consumer chain side um whether that should be a thing as we go forward is probably something that we want

to discuss my personal opinion is that in general things that are pertaining to replicated security and

and its core mechanism of like you know selecting like who are the validators running consumer chains

how are the rewards distributed all of this um i believe falls under the category of the things that

the consumer like the cosmos hub um actually has sovereignty over so i think in the future that should

be stuff that is implemented on the cosmos hub side because it really deals with the cosmos hubs

um validator set in the internal kind of like dynamics of it now in given the limited kind of like

time frames that we have now and the fact that the hub has already gone through um you know updates very

recently in order to simplify these things we are implementing it and we're implementing it in a way that

works and that only requires neutron's code itself to be modified um but what we will be doing is that we

will be making this feature um governed by uh the neutron dow meaning that if for example one of the

scenarios would be if the hub um has a similar feature in the in the future or something that

replaces soft up tout then the feature can be turned off on the neutron side or for example if neutron

starts generating um tremendous amounts of revenue for even the bottom of the validator set then it's not

required anymore and so we could gradually through governance proposals um to taper off how much of

the voting power is basically cons like has this option of opting out um i do agree that it is probably

not the best um feature to have but i think it it's a very direct answer to some of kind of like the

the the main concerns around replicated security and if that allows us to have a more united front as

we approach this kind of like gift um in the the hub's narrative and and technological kind of like

role in the ecosystem i think that that is um probably worth taking

yeah i mean as as we said before it's uh it's still an experimental phase and they also think that

that we don't have to look at neutron like uh all consumer chain will do what neutron is doing because

the reality is that any consumer chain will have a different approach and should have a different

approach because uh they will have a different uh kind of services and uh and even products because if

we if we see how how neutron is branding currently uh i think it's branding like ab execution layer which

means that it will provide all the needs for uh developers to build cross-chain application

uh and uh i was reading uh on the forum that uh also neutron will allow to use interchange account

interchange query so we are talking of of basically allowing developers to build the application that

will not only can be compatible with the hub but with all the interchange so i think that the value

accrual here is uh is massive not only because uh we are talking about uh extending the services to the

whole inter chain but i think that uh the team is solid and uh we already seeing some ongoing uh

implementation like can you speak uh uh maybe a little bit about the ongoing uh uh implementation

that we started to see on uh on neutron announcement like the the cosmos station integration the card

integration the astroport integration because i think it's it's very interesting because it actually shows

that we are bringing a consumer chain that will have already some level of adoption from the start

which is very important even for uh all the economics that we will build around

yeah for sure i mean it's you know neutron is a permissionless platform meaning that people don't

actually have to go through me or anyone else to actually launch from neutron once it's available but

um we have received like a lot of um we have had a lot of conversation and have received a lot of

interest from a lot of builders around the space a lot of them have applications that they already

deployed on other chains and they're looking at neutron for where to launch their token or where to launch

their uh governance or to expand to a new chain and perhaps use neutron as the platform on which they

deploy kind of like their the their cross chain hub which will allow them to kind of connect multiple

deployments that they may uh already have or be looking to have soon um so that they can drive

additional kind of like value and benefits from having not only multiple deployments on multiple

chains but also having them connected and communicating together so that for example they have one governance

system that you know controls all of the deployments or that they have fees going from all of the

deployments and and kind of like being managed together using some of the the infrastructure

for managing treasuries and daos that will exist on neutron um so i think there's a lot of cool stuff

that's going to be built um in in the next few months um i obviously don't control that it depends on

a whole ton of teams that will or will not decide to to launch on neutron but i'm very i'm personally

very optimistic about this i think um that like in you know very shortly newton will have a fairly

well-rounded uh defy ecosystem um which we haven't really seen too much of in cosmos for quite a while

and especially since the fall of terra i think it's going to be great to have a lot more options that

can compose together more like directly with you know not just one team building all of them like we've

we've seen we've seen uh sometimes which is very impressive but also limits the the speed at which

you can iterate on these and like and improve them over time so you know all of these things together

i think what we're going to see is that neutron is likely to play an interesting role in the ecosystem

where it's both kind of um a sort of matrix which brings a lot of the things that already exist outside

of neutron and in the cosmos ecosystem together that allows people to access these services with

perhaps less friction because they don't need to think about crushing um transactions anymore they

don't need to be bridging back and forth anymore they can just access them by kind of like the same

interfaces and um and abstract the complexity of dealing with you know 50 plus chains um and two i think

the ecosystem on neutron itself is likely to be very interesting to um to to use and and interact

with um i'm yeah i'm feeling really good about it because i feel like it's going to it's going to be

time soon again to go a little bit degen despite the fact that it's arguably still bear market and start

you know playing around with like liquidity positions like borrowing and whatever um to to try and and find

good strategies i think you know what i'm kind of like excited about is seeing all of the smart

peoples that hang out around cosmos twitter starting to like look into these these applications and

start making like strategies and stuff um so you know we'll we'll see how it turns out but i'm

personally um pretty enthusiastic about what's gonna be happening in the next few months but you know time

will tail and it all depends on um governance and mostly the the cosmos sub governance basically

also i see many validators today in the goal so if anyone want to jump in and ask questions i think

that's the perfect time because it's important also addressing any validator concern right now

and beside that i was reading actually right now the the token economics and i'm actually interested to

know a little bit more about the dow on neutron and uh what kind of dynamics will create for a token

holder if a token holder of neutron will be able to participate directly in the dow so how to look

how basically it will work the governance dynamics on neutron yeah so neutrons governance is a bit

different from a lot of other cosmos chains because instead of using the gov module

um it is actually implemented as a set of small contracts and that allows us to um have a lot of

modularity and flexibility um in in how the um dow is is structured on the technical level um these

contracts are actually based off of dow dow shout out to them for the awesome work that they've done

creating this suite of small contract um we created a few modules that we added to it to serve the the

neutron dow specifically as best as possible and so what that means is that you have a few differences

on um how people may be able to get voting power in the first place as well as how decisions can be

made so to dive a bit deeper first is like okay how do you actually get voting power to participate in

making decisions for the network um for this you will need um to deposit something into what we call a

voting vault a voting vault a voting vault is a um smart contract that will look at whatever you

deposited um and and basically be able to calculate voting power based on based on it the initial voting

vaults that we're expecting to be live at launch are you know a very basic enterain vault which you can

deposit enter and inside of it you don't have any bonding um like period or or anything because it's

not actually required to be safe um and you can you know that gives you voting power one point per

ntrn and that allows you to participate in governance another vault that is very very very likely to be

live at launch is um lp token vault so for example let's say you provided ntrn and atom to a liquidity

pool you now have a lp token which gives you some rewards some trading fees but you can now take this

token and deposit it into a voting vault and the voting vault itself will calculate how much of like

how much ntrn your lp token represents and it will give you just like the other vault it will give you

one point of voting power per ntrn represented by this lp token basically and this architecture

is very flexible so that in the future the dow may decide to add or remove a whole variety of

vaults um what seems very likely to me is that the dow will continue to list vaults that are somehow

related to the ntrn token so for example if you take ntrn token you provide them as a deposit to a

a money market application or if you have some kind of an nft that can be redeemed for ntrn or that was

minted using ntrn all these sorts of things could technically have their own specific voting vault and

therefore be able to participate in the governance of neutron but the dow may also decide to go another

way and if the neutron dow thinks that it's best to for example um let's say there was this og nft

project um that was launched and people are like really fun of it let's say it's the bad kids of

neutron people are fun of it um they um they really want it to be you know part of of the zone and how it

works technically you can make a voting vault that allows you to deposit your neutron bat kit whatever

to that vault and get some degree of voting power based on it now of course you would have to find

a calculation for how these things are valued and maybe it's the price or maybe it's another mechanism

so that the whole system remains secure um but but you can see that there's a lot of flexibility and

the other side of this coin is that it allows you to participate in governance and in defy at the

same time that's the problem that was already identified in cosmos right where if you're staking

you can't be using these tokens anywhere else osmosis is a very interesting solution to this problem

with superfluid staking well neutron basically allows you to do superfluid staking that's the voting

vaults for lp tokens but it allows you to do xx staking for any sort of other kind of like activity

right so money markets um or other sorts of of deposits um can be can get voting power so that's

the first thing um you can participate in governance without losing your rights your ability to participate

in the the ecosystem that exists on the platform itself the second thing is the way that the neutron

dao itself functions is um a bit more flexible as well because it relies on small contracts and so

we can um you know we can add functionality to that dao through governance very easily um and the the

whole infrastructure was designed to be able to to be very modular so that applies to the decision

making process so for example at launch the small contracts that are in the genesis file allowed the

dow to have single option votes like we are accustomed to so like yes no abstain um or to

have multiple choice voting so for example we could have a vote about um you know is like should don

kryptonium's face be um the only legal profile picture to have on twitter and then you could have

yes no or i think we should have whoever else's face instead and then people could vote for any of

these outcomes and the one that would get actually executed is the one that has the most vote so you

know single choice voting multiple choice voting in the future other types of voting systems could be

um could be implemented like for example um you could have something where it's like quadratic voting

which favors um popularity over uh wealth essentially um and you know any sort of curve any sort of voting

system gauges and and whatever can be implemented as well it just depends on um you know having somebody in

the community that will decide we actually need this for neutrons governance um ecosystem and

infrastructure i'll build it and i'll propose it to the dow and then the dow votes to have it and then

that's it um so that that's the first layer of flexibility the second layer of flexibility is

how how decisions can be um shared and allocated to you know the whole governance um ecosystem or to

specific committees basically so in cosmos we mostly have uh token voting meaning that when we want to

change the incentives on on a poll or when we want to um upgrade the network everybody has to vote and

sometimes that can be a problem in terms of how many proposals on in terms of i as a like as just someone

in the community may not have insight or a very deep opinion on absolutely every matter and so technical

matter maybe i just don't want to vote on them um and it can like be exhausting basically to have to

to deal with this all the time so to avoid um having to vote on everything and anything at all times

we like the the the neutron that has a mechanism called well sub daos which you know was also

implemented by dow dow but will be available from day one on neutron which allows governance to create

subcommittees that are kind of like multi-sig for example but the main difference is that they remain

accountable to the main dow so the main dow is the admin of the contracts of that multi-sig and so

if the dow wants to revoke it or take the funds or fire someone from the committee it has the ultimate

power over it right um the second thing is that having these committees allow neutron's governance

infrastructure to be much more efficient because instead of having to you know require the

participation of everybody have to wait two weeks for every decision to to work we could for example

have a dow dedicated to making grants or to managing an incentive program or similar things and when they

make a proposal you know they have their own budget which is granted by the main dow they can manage that

budget independently they probably will be reporting to the dow and and a lot of things that can be

constructed around but when they make a decision what they can do is they can have their own

proposal type they make the decision they vote for it they approve it before it actually gets executed

by the code it becomes time locked meaning that the code is basically frozen for three days during these

three days anyone who is a voter in the main dow anyone who has voting power on neutron can check that

proposal and if they think that that's a really really bad idea they can try and veto it and as soon as we

reach one or two percent of the voting power on the main dow then that proposal from the committee from the

sub dow gets cancelled automatically so what that setup does is that it allows us to as a community decide to

trust some individuals which we think are very qualified for a specific role uh to perform their um their their

operations um with authority autonomously but if they breach our trust if they try to go against

the dow or if they're incompetent then the dow has the power to take over the power and basically force any

decision to be made through the main governance track where everybody votes basically um so that that's another

um layer of flexibility and in in kind of the initial iterations we expect that this will most likely be

kind of like committees that look like multi-sig where you have you know up to 10 people uh on that

committee doing something specific but actually each of these sub-dows can have their own voting systems

they can have their own membership systems meaning that you could have a sub-dow where the members are

are whoever gets whatever percent of the voting power delegated to them so you can have a liquid

democratic kind of like system if we want so there's a lot of flexibility within within the the sub-dows

themselves as well and then the last layer of flexibility in the governance system is how

NTRN and voting power is allocated in the future so most of the um most of the supply is going to be in the

um treasury of the dow meaning you know the community pool essentially um the dow will have voting like

will have the power to decide how this gets allocated in the future and it can do so by one-off spends

meaning we make a proposal to send x amount of x token to whatever address or it can do so through

something that we call the distribution schedule the distribution schedule is a bit of an experiment but

i think it's kind of interesting because it's a form of ongoing payment um so for example let's say

there's a piece of infrastructure that is really important to neutralize an ecosystem and the dow

decides that it wants to reward it right to support it over time and to make sure that this piece of

infrastructure can be maintained well the dow may decide to register a share in the distribution schedule

for an address that's controlled by the entity that maintained that that that piece of software for

for example let's say you know cosmosm is really important to neutron um let's fund confio to

develop cosmosm for a long period of time by giving them 10 of all the tokens that are received over time

by the distribution schedule the distribution schedule will receive tokens from the reserve we

can talk about this in a second it will receive tokens over time and make them available according to

you know like regularly to that specific address that was registered as the address for conclio basically

and so that allows you potentially to do stuff like public good funding pretty efficiently another

use for that distribution schedule is imagine we have um an incentives program running on neutron right

well we may not want that program to be handled by people but instead to be handled by code and so what

we can do is we can create a simple small contract that receives tokens and at every regular interval

let's say every week it takes these tokens it breaks them according to the weights that the dow

decided let's say um five percent goes to decks one number one five percent goes to that pool on deck

number two whatever and it you know at every regular interval it takes the tokens that it received

distributes them according to the parameters set by the dow and directly to the pools right so now we

have automated kind of distributions of tokens as well um and that's something that's that becomes even

more convenient using some of the well like one of the feature of neutron which is the neutron cron

right when you build an app chain you can use begin and end blockers to execute things at regular

interval through the beginning or the end of the blocks of the blockchain for a small contract that was

for a long time a big problem because you can't really do that you can't rely on end blockers

so usually you rely on um either bots that you run yourself or that are run by like a decentralized

bot system um or kind of like other sort of like more mystical implementations we've implemented a

system that allows governance to say hey this contract should have access to the end blockers every x block

basically and so the distribution schedule for example in this example can you know every five blocks

distribute whatever it receives for example um and we don't need any bots to run like the blockchain

actually makes this work on on its own um yeah i mean so and obviously it can also be used to

distribute budgets to the sub to the various sub daos that have been created right um so we can say okay

i want the grants dow to have 10 of the tokens that are being released and i want the um incentives

dow to get five percent whatever you can set the weights um and then the last element of this is

well most of the tokens will be liquid in the dow's treasury from the get-go some of them will be

vesting long term in what we call the reserve the reserve is a smart contract that holds ntrn tokens

they cannot be transferred not even the governance has power over it but they vest

conditionally based on the activity of the network meaning that the more activity there is on neutron

the faster these token uh released it's a bit of an experiment but what we think will happen is that

if we use the distribution schedule properly it will allow the ecosystem of um like the governance

system on neutron to essentially adjust how much it spends or invests over time based on how on the

market circumstances basically so you know during the bear uh during the bear market we probably

don't want to have very high incentives and so because the activity on the platform is low it

doesn't release a lot of tokens so not a lot of tokens are being distributed as incentives during the

bull market that that's when we want to be um you know using our added economic strength to be

incentivizing liquidity incentivizing whatever providing grants funding uh public goods and that kind of

stuff and so up it kicks up and then this distribution happens so yeah we'll see how these plays play out we

try to make a system that would be as flexible as possible so that it could adapt to whatever the

community will make of neutron in the future and of the platform in the future but also provided kind of

like new tools to explore both how we make decisions um as kind of like participants of a decentralized network

how this network can handle and automate a lot of these processes itself and how voting power and and

and tokens are allocated um to these various participants uh essentially

yeah i think that your last point is very important because um you actually mentioned how it is

important to handle the bear bull market cycle because if we see right now the cosmos landscape there is a

lot of uh re-tokenomics going on many projects are revisiting the tokenomics because uh mostly of them

was uh was designed during a bull market while it's not actually completely sustainable in a bear market so

i think it's very interesting that uh actually you guys are already thinking uh to uh this kind of

transition to adapt to market cycle and i actually think this is one of the advantages that is bringing

the replicated security because uh you're basically implementing all these dynamics which is quite

a lot for a token i mean i think this is kind of uh it's supposed to the theory that uh a consumer

chain token is a farming token i think it's quite the opposite actually because uh it can be a farming token

if it has so many applications and utility that can be built upon i think cryptos it also has a question about this

yeah i wanted to jump in here because i also see matt crypto just joined and he left a comment under

the tokenomics paper basically asking um why a token at all right like why not just use atom for everything

so maybe spade you can um explain a little bit um yeah yeah that was a very like that was a very

significant decision um and we didn't take it lightly to be honest we we actually spent um i mean like

we're talking here about like months and months ago like we're talking about last year but we spend a lot

of time thinking about this basically the idea is if you like having only atom was very appealing because

one it reduces the amount of work on the initial implementation of the chain it provides pretty good

incentives alignment to between the consumer chain and the hub and the hope is that because atom is

you know not a new asset it is pretty well distributed and it has a community and everything

then that community would then seize the project and and be able to guide it to some something pretty

cool and something very aligned to to the hub all of these points are valid we ended up deciding

against it for a few reasons the first one is managing the hub and managing the the consumer chain

especially neutron is not exactly the same thing um and it doesn't require kind of like the same

mindset per se and so we thought that it would probably be best for a community of people who are

very dedicated to neutron to emerge and have the power to actually make changes to kind of like fulfill

a vision that is that is its its own vision that is really oriented to what the platform is capable of

and what is its appeal inside the kind of like larger web 3 industry and so the idea is that

the replicated security basically creates a frame of alignment whereby if there's no alignment the chain is

just going to be cut down essentially so we know that it can't really get too hard of hands otherwise

it will just like you know neutron will just self-destruct itself basically and so that keeps

that is likely to keep neutron's governance aligned with the hub in in any case and so based on this

we thought the probably the best way to ensure that neutron is as successful as possible is to make

sure that there are people who feel committed to the project are um you know have authority over the

project because they are participants in its governance they have the power to uh participate

in the in the decisions they are rewarded for doing so uh all of these kind of things like they have

skin in the game in terms of of time of commitment um all of this right that's the first point the

second point is that it also it's also like kind of like difficult to you know like we're having all

these conversations about like the economics of ics and stuff like this and it didn't seem to us

like going to the hub and saying hey can you allocate millions of atom to bootstrap this ecosystem

was going to be something that the community would necessarily be very happy about because

it seemed like a very big risk that it was taking on behalf of a project that wasn't the hub itself

right and so at the time having another token that can be used as as a way to say hey look if you

come and join this ecosystem and help make it awesome um you'll get a say in this ecosystem

basically um so that that was um another one now if you actually look into like closely into how we've

designed neutron what you realize is that you know adam like if you do not want to contribute to the

decision making of neutron itself if you only want to use neutron as a platform that hosts services that

you want to use well you're able to use neutron without ever touching the ntrn token um and that

is fine you can come in with your atom you can use applications there pay you transaction fees in atom

you can do whatever you would want to do on that chain without having to touch the token so if you

only want to use atom and be aligned with atom you can do so that's not a problem um if you want to

go further and be part of that kind of like extension of the hub that is also its own thing well you can

understand um so yeah that's kind of the approach that we've taken yeah i think this is important

for user adoption because uh it will it will make uh the whole onboarding more easily if they can use atom

and i think this is uh something that uh can be extended to the whole atom economic zone because i mean if

if we create this atom economic zone atom should be applied and be possible to use in any of the

applications that will be will be built around this uh this zone and uh i think that will be also

interesting to see uh yeah do you have uh some talk about it a quick comment about this i completely

agree i think it's very likely to happen i think the one thing that's exciting about it is that it may

allow atom to bring back the atom liquidity towards the atom economic zone which i think is going to be

a major strategic plus for atom as a project and as a token as well uh yeah that that's just side

comment sorry for interrupting yeah don't worry you said thread my point so uh it's more than welcome

no i was saying uh i was interesting to know what is the focus on neutron like uh in the in the beginning

like it will be a focus on product so in the adoption and onboarding of application it will be a

focus on user so to make easy for user to navigate neutron like uh like right now even already using

atom it will be already a simplification but it will be also important to have all this uh interface that

will make the the whole process to you to perform every application that will be on neutron easy

or it will be a focus on generating real revenue because the main relation with the cosmos sub right

now it's real revenue so it's the revenue generated on neutron

i don't think focusing on quote-unquote real revenue from the get-go is necessarily the right approach i think

you know while we invested a lot of work into making neutron the best platform possible to launch

applications like crossnet applications and small contracts in cosmos it's arguably like it's it's going

to be a new blockchain right and so there may not be all of the tooling all of the interfaces all of the

infrastructure that is required for it to really really shine and be um you know by by far the best place

that you could be building on and so i think what makes the most sense is to take this as as it is

it's a piece of infrastructure the value of that thing existing is whether or not it makes our lives

better basically and so what i would focus on for at least the initial period is to make sure that

that piece of infrastructure actually suit um suits the the the needs of the ecosystem of the users of

the builders of the cosmos hub and everything like right there's a ton of things that there's a ton of

primitives that can be built to solve problems that we're seeing currently right like the fact that it's

really complicated for a lot of the kind of like agreements between dows and or protocols um to

exist because of the lack of infrastructure um to enable this to happen trustlessly that's something

that we can solve by building simple small contracts on top of neutron um there's a ton of you know

limitations to the crushing experience in in in cosmos if we can come together and improve this um that's

definitely going to be a major advancement for the ecosystem as a whole so all these things are where

i would personally focus um but as a result of this it's also likely that you know the better the

infrastructure is the more um the more builders decide that hey that's where i want to be building

the more activity there will be and therefore the more connect transactions the more opportunities for

mev and stuff like this will happen as well so in the end it also ends up achieving that goal as well

as a kind of like um yeah no no i mean it's uh it's definitely interesting and you actually are

following the branding of neutron which is up execution layer so actually the synergies with the

hub will be very important especially in uh in coordinating also the community to uh to kind of have this

double relation because uh it's also interesting uh uh all the this whole lot of economic zone that

will soon start to get traction it's also interesting to see it from a community perspective

so like uh how the cosmonaut will feel a consumer chain and uh how they will interact with the consumer

chain because it's all a new dynamics and i think that actually replicated security specifically

it's actually creating a new economic model that will require experimentation and i think neutron it's uh

maybe already more of an experiment because uh i think that following your discussion you guys have

actually the idea very clear of what will be the platform and what are the plans so i think that's

actually a great start for a first consumer chain and uh the the idea and the economic models with the

hub is definitely interesting uh i saw that there was some concern over validators for the inflation

but i also think that inflation is something more related to uh the model of a sovereign proof of stake

chains that uh on replicated security because uh if uh consumer chain will only focus on generating

inflation actually replicate the security will not have that uh differentiation from the old model to this

model of a shared uh or shared security of course inflation will be important in the case of a specific

consumer chain that will not uh aiming for a product that has uh all this application like can have cosmos

cosmos because cosmos allow you allow will allow neutron to have many applications so it could generate

a good amount of fees so in the end any any consumer chain uh will have to choose their own path

will have to choose their own economic model and it's interesting to see how they will develop their

synergies with hub which is probably the most unique uh unique innovation uh in this model

so is uh is anyone that has uh any last question or to want to join the conversation feel free to do it

now cryptosito or d do you have anything to add um i mean i wanted to because i think that came a little bit

short i mean everybody can uh read the article about the initial distribution of ntrn tokens um snapshots i think

it's november 19 i think november yeah 19 and for the atom community um so there's all the details in there

but just in general space like if you can you know comment a little bit on the initial distribution

um it mentions in the document 54 percent neutron dow um 23 percent uh founders 11 percent early backers

and then 12 percent community of which seven percent of the total supply is airdropped to the atom

community which initially makes 58 58.3 percent of the initial supply circulating supply for ntrn so can you

comment a little bit on that and like maybe some of the um factors that went into defining and on like

also like the airdrop and distribution and these kind of things

yeah so um one of the first thing is that we we looked at what happened in the ecosystem to kind of like

get a get a get a get a sense of what like how how these things work and what we've done is we've

made sure that because this is going to be like like our intention is is to make sure that the

community can can own this thing and guide it in the future right so two things went into this process

the first thing is we one allocated less tokens to the founders than the um kind of like majority or average

um is is present like is in general because of the fact that this is a platform not just like an

application or a business this is a platform a piece of infrastructure um so that's the first thing

the second thing is we made sure that people who aren't um founders so like all of the other

allocations had at least from the get-go as many uh tokens to ensure that um you know the there is a

counter balance in in in how people are able to um take over the doubt we've also removed our ability

to participate in governance meaning that we won't be able to for example like bribe anybody or make

like pass the governance like whatever single-handedly we don't have power in governance at all actually

or if we do it's because we went um ahead and we bought it from somebody else basically um so that's

the first thing and then the second thing is we wanted to make sure that the community itself had

more power than anything that could be considered kind of like more like insider types of profiles

and so we made sure that the allocation for the community is higher and especially within the

allocation that the hub had the lion's share essentially and so what that means is that at

the get-go 60 of all the voting power in existence that's available to make decisions is going to

already be controlled by the community and especially by the hub which means then that

because the control is in the hand of the community and the hub any future allocation of voting power

can only be made with the consent of the community and the hub so what that what that does is that it

ensures that today and in the future the distribution of ntrn and the voting power attached to it

um will be conformed to the wishes and to the intentions of of the community and the hub essentially

so we won't have an arbitrom-like scenario

well that that was uh yeah i mean i'm not going to come out on it but it was interesting to see this

whole thing that was nuts that was nuts um but you know um like neutron doesn't come pre-packaged

with any sort of grants already being paid out right so anything that um we have been in chat with

a ton of projects that came to us and and and said like look what you're building is interesting it's

all some of the problems that we've had uh in building applications um can we get grants right

well no because we don't control it like that's a decision for our governance what we can do is we can

tell you all about how um the the system works how the infrastructure works how the governance will work

work so that you can have a good idea of how you should structure your proposal to the dow when

it's when it's live when it exists when it's a thing and it can actually review um whatever proposal

you want to make to it um so that's another part of of the process that we've taken um we haven't

baked any sort of application specific logic into the code itself um we haven't extended any grants on

behalf of the dow because we're not the dow and the dow should have that power and so you know once the

once the chain is is there um it will own itself basically

t i think you animated yourself do you have any comment uh no i mean i'm i'm really the only thing

i was gonna say i'm really excited to see neutron launch uh i think the the combined uh reserve

allocation to the dow plus the distribution module can be really interesting um i mean we've talked about

inflation ad nauseum at this point especially in the cosmos ego right like using the the governance

token to incentivize liquidity incentivize staking it creates essentially like a forever downward

pressure uh downward pressure selling pressure on on the asset we've seen that with every single

cosmos project at this point um and i think this really can create like a flywheel of like protocol

protocol owned liquidity where the dow can actually direct uh neutron tokens and then other tokens that

that the dow itself um receives in in other forms of assets like adam or usdc depending on what how

transaction fees are paid to the train so over time it creates like this deflationary neutron while the

reserve and the dow is collecting other ibc assets uh and at the same time it can actually use those

assets as well as neutron tokens to incentivize liquidity for the defy different defy protocols

that launch on neutron so this is this is a really interesting model i'm excited to see how it launches

and and how it works i guess over the next couple years yeah i think another thing that's kind of like

interesting and like it's you know just an idea that the dow may or may not decide to play around

with in the future but i think what could potentially make sense is to um allow users to pay fee in any

other uh denomination than ntrn and then give them a rebate um in ntrn right so you you pay in some

denomination and then you get ntrn corresponding to the value um of that transaction fee and what that

does is that it actually distributes voting power to the users of the chain right so i'm using this

daily and now i get the tokens through it i'm still paying and maybe i'm like maybe you you know the

rebate is only 50 so that you like or whatever like the economic model can be adjusted to to make it

work and generate revenue or whatever is the priority but what what i mean is what's really

interesting is that that kind of flexibility allows you to to develop systems that for example

can be tailored to really ensure that the users are well represented within the system and its

decision-making abilities and there's a whole bunch of like there's a very wide space of

experimentations and and and parametrization of neutron that that we can explore um over the next couple of

years so go ahead d yeah i'm just gonna say this is i i'm not mad i was gonna say this is exciting

stuff i'm really excited to see neutron launch and um i think this you know as much as the neutron needs

the hub right now just for security purposes i think the hub needs neutron um this is the really the

the the new hopefully like the next generation or the next phase of the hub in the atom economic zone

um and i i really hope the community supports neutron um and hopefully you know if it succeeds i think

overall the atom tokens get to succeed regardless of the short-term replicated security economics uh for

for validators so just this is awesome yeah i think well said um d and um final question from my side and then

maybe we can get some people on also to ask questions um spade so now that the tokenomics is out um

what's the game plan in terms of going on chain so the last remaining bit is we want to make sure

that the soft opt-out as a feature is safe to use battle tested well encoded controllable controllable by

governance um before we add this to the mix right because that's that's not part of the kind of like

initial ics repose so before we put anything in production we tend to try and value security a

lot and be very careful about what what we're doing there so um we upgraded barion testnet today we

will be conducting an internal rehearsal of launching neutron and in in a in a replicated secured um kind

of like environment internally uh tomorrow and then next week there is a public rehearsal that's

organized by hypha which is the team in charge of the replicated security testnets so what we'll be

doing there is that is basically fulfilling two objectives the first one is to ensure that the

soft opt-out works and that we can bake it into the proposal that will be submitted on chain and to

ensure that every validator that wants to participate to this whole um kind of like story this whole new

thing for the hub has the knowledge and confidence that they can do so properly because they've done

it before by enabling all the participants to essentially launch the code that will be proposed

to the hub into a testnet environment first before we go to the main course and the main net launch basically

and so that's going to happen on the 11th assuming all goes well and i don't see why it wouldn't but

assuming all goes well uh the proposal will be on train the next day and then that's the start of

the voting period and then um the launch would then happen between the 25 or 28 most probably

because afterwards is a weekend so i don't expect a lot of validators to be working on the weekend at

least i don't wish for a lot of people to be working on the on the weekends um so worst case scenario

if it doesn't launch within the first three days which i think is unlikely would be that it launches

um before the third of of of may basically so that's if um yeah so yeah it's going to be a busy

month for for a ton of people including um you know me our team and probably most importantly the

validators themselves rehearsing and then actually launching it if the cosmos hub community votes for it

yeah hopefully we will have a chill voting period

especially because uh i think it's important if a validator has any concern please say it now the

forum is open uh because uh on change voting period uh it's uh always brings something some discussion

but uh actually it's important to bring discussion before the launch about the period because if we

can do some modification can still happen if we discover some specific concern so bring concern before

and not and not during your champion period and uh i also want to add that uh uh maybe in this

discussion uh uh can uh replicate security can be seen like uh a better model of uh sovereign uh up

chains but uh this is not actually correct i mean they believe the security complement uh the up chain

thesis it's not uh meant to substitute the up the up chain thesis because uh uh it just had another

layer of option for launching a blockchain in the cosmos ecosystem and this is also add variety and

more opportunity for developers to enter cosmos so option is very important and that's basically all the

cosmos cities replicated security will add this new layer of opportunity and i think this is very important

because uh i think that uh how the replicated security and cosmos sub is moving is to have this

specific consumer chain that will bring value to the whole inter chain so it's not something that uh

even if we call it atom economic zone will benefit only atom i think that it's very important that atom as

as i always said the central position inside the ecosystem will keep doing uh growing the entire

inter chain ecosystem and uh it will be very important also for uh the inter chain as a whole and i

think we are in the right direction because a neutron can bring a lot of value in uh in the for the cosmos sub

and the ecosystem wide we have some community member also that is bringing some questions so i will put them

up if they have a specific question for spade or any of the guests

in the meantime i might i might drop out because i have to go but um yeah thanks wait for all the

insights and yeah hopefully we get some some good questions from the community thanks a lot cito

okay uh do you have any questions hi can you hear me yeah very well fantastic so yeah it's just a

question as a cosmonaut uh about the snapshot so i read the tokenomics um i think tokenomics is brilliant

uh and the fact that people who voted on the proposal and it doesn't matter whether they voted no

uh still 30 million tokens will be dropped to them and then uh 40 million to uh atoms takers and also

good to see that even if you have one atom staked uh you you still will get a neutron uh airdrop so all

fantastic uh as a cosmonaut as a person who supports cosmos ecosystem a question is uh why just

a single snapshot um one thing which i which i think uh is important is also to uh carry the new uh

blood that we bring in to the cosmos ecosystem so again you have done it it's fine question is as

as a cosmonaut and then question is is to the wider uh cosmos team and neutron uh what what do you guys

think about average snapshots so let's say spread over a period of uh four to five months that includes

news takers without gaming the system so so you you still do it but don't announce so so just just

few thoughts on that from the neutron team and then from cosmos hub uh people thank you

yeah that's that's a really good question i think there's basically two reasons why that's not

um what we went for the first one is is just very hard to plan for this timeline perfectly and you need

to do quite a bit bit of work to actually get the snapshots parse the data turn this into the actual

calculations and and everything so that process is not instantaneous and especially when you have

kind of like dependencies on other teams like for example we um we thought that it would be just to

exclude liquid stakers who had supported liquid staking from the get-go because they are adam stakers

they just do it through a defy protocol and so we also had to work with other teams and we can't just

like change our instructions every five days and we can't force them to do it instantly either so you

know the the plans can be ready early on but then the rest of the process takes more time or moves around

in terms of timeline and we end up with a snapshot that is a bit farther away than it was initially

when we made the plan and started working on it so that that's the first element just like the

you know how things actually end up working and then the second element is um especially when you're

dealing with airdrop the like more is less the least complexity you can have the better because

every bit of complexity that you're introducing to your calculation is an opportunity for a mistake

a typo a fat finger occurrence what like whatever um to happen and that can have very very bad uh

consequences down the line we're dealing with the voting power of the chain and the majority of the

the voting power in the chain initially and that will control and condition what happens in the

future as well and so if we're not careful with um with these parameters then we always have a risk

that um you know something will go wrong somebody will end up with a majority stake um or something

of the sort and that can create like very very big problems for the projects before so there's a

lot of things that could have been done in the airdrop um in an ideal world and in a world where for

example we have um like civil resistance or a few other features um there are really awesome ways to

do airdrops um but what we prioritized in the decisions that we've made was simplicity and security

to ensure that you know we start on the right foot it may not be perfect but at least we have a very

high degree of confidence that this part of this crucial part of neutron's early life doesn't get

fucked up and that the project can basically you know just start with confidence and and a clean state

thank you

okay i think that if we don't have any other question we can wrap it up just no just a quick yes so i i

kind of know the answer uh why just atom why not give new babies also a chance like fmos and others

so just i know i know the answer but but still would love to hear from you thank you and and you

can drop me down rob thanks well there's there's a few things right simplicity as i mentioned um but

also the fact that you know neutron is replicated security so that the community that it makes the

most sense um having the initial allocation for is the cosmos hub and then the the last element as

well is that you know anytime you add a criteria you're splitting how much everyone gets basically

and so you have to compromise between having an initial allocation that people are going to be

happy about and feel like that actually empowers them to be part of that piece of infrastructure

its governance and the project as a whole um or to reward more people but reward them perhaps

less meaningfully and therefore either create frustration backlash or just indifference

basically so that's another kind of like dimension of airdrops that is fairly hard tonight to navigate it

thank you

uh i have a few questions in the pin tweets as well okay this one above you mean

yeah yeah brian mori if you were still listening to us the way that we know

that like which validators are not going to be jailed for not running consumer chains is by the

percentage of voting power so that is a parameter we would like this parameter to be able to be set

by governance it wouldn't change frequently at all in my opinion but the initial parameter that

we think makes the most sense is five percent and so if you are in the bottom five percent of the

the voting power um then you are not going to be jailed for not running a node and and um and

missing blocks on on neutron that being said if you're at the very border between you know like the

the the the the limit between the five percent which don't have to do it and the rest of the set

you probably still want to start running a node because there because you may get into the portion that has to

run a node let's say overnight and you wouldn't want to wake up and realize that you've been jailed

for for a while right so it you should probably have a margin of error there but other than that

for example if you're validator 150 you can be pretty confidently not running a node because you are

firmly into the the five percent um at the bottom of the validator set and so that allows you to not have

this additional cost perfect and i think also that uh uh the downtime window should be higher on uh

consumer chain i think three plus days correct me if i'm wrong oh yeah yeah yeah um so i think in

general that will be the case the as gian explained though um the soft opt-out compromises liveness right

so it takes longer um to get the voting power required to restart the chain um and so as a result

of this the longer downtime period which also compromises liveness is something that one is

in this case because we also have the soft opt-out probably not going to be required at all probably

not going to be reducing cost as efficiently as the soft opt-out will be um and it's also something

that has a negative influence on liveness and so because we're already kind of um pulling on the

liveness of the chain to you know to minimize the risk that will have any sort of holds or that will

have struggle like struggles during like chain upgrades or uh the like that kind of stuff um we

probably will have a more normal um downtime window um it may still still be extended i i don't know if the

parameter has been set in stone at this point but just keep in mind that both of these parameters

compromise on the same aspect of the chain and so as a result we probably will just go for the

most efficient solution rather than stack them on top so as to avoid having potential problems down the

line yeah i think this is important to address because uh also delegator can sleep well at night

not risking slashing uh during uh any any block time and it's important to address also this concern

because uh we are being very focused on validators but also delegators uh we we always forget that uh

there is always a risk of slashing which is a minimized uh because uh tombstone and this kind of

event that brings a bigger slashing risk are very very rare like uh history of cosmos we had only

probably two three example so i think it's important to address this concern do you want to add the

something space yeah well um i mean i i agree with you right as a delegator it's it's not great um

knowing that potentially if your delegator is not doing a good job you could get slashed

arguably that's part of the setup that is intended to keep the the chain secure you know you have this

risk and so you want to minimize this risk by valid by delegating to validators that you are

confident will do a good job in the specific case of of neutron and consumer chains though um the

slashing upgrades to replicated security mean that unless your validator doubles signs and then

there is a proposal on the hub to slash your validator you will not get slashed consumer chains like

neutron will not at least initially have the ability to slash you in any way shape or form unless there

is a consumer unless sorry there is a proposal on the cosmos hub itself to verify that yes your validator

misbehaved and therefore should be punished so the i think because it's quite rare in general and because

there is this additional layer of security the chances of you being slashed because of your validator

missing blocks on neutron and especially with the soft up doubt are really minimal um it's possible

but it's really unlikely in my opinion at least

okay uh if anyone has a one last question on or spade as a last off i think we can close it we are well

above one hour and uh we are all waiting for for the onchain voting period right now i think it's coming

very soon so very very looking forward for that spade do you have any last off or do you think that

we haven't addressed any uh question or uh or stuff that you might have

no i think actually we discussed like quite a bunch of thing of things so that was it was a pleasure i

apologize to our like to everyone here for um any rents that i may have embarked upon and i hope this

was useful informative to a lot of people if you have any questions feel free to hop into our community

channels on discord and telegram and and whatever uh because that's where we are um available basically

to chat we do focus a lot on our work so we're not available all the time but we try to uh be there and

we we frequently have a lot of conversations with people so come and hang out basically um and yeah

guys thank you for for having us on on on this chat and inviting us um especially after can like

the internet fuck up of of the last time so thanks a lot yeah yeah thankfully we lost so in the beginning

but uh we got you last time was a sewing and you were having some problems so sometimes twitter space

speak uh one person and uh hopefully yeah hopefully even the next twitter space will proceed well like

this one i think that uh we we talked about a lot and a lot of many community concerns that we have

been addressed and especially used by i think you are very very great to explaining all the dynamics so

thank you for coming here and uh bring your knowledge has been very important thank you for all the

the people that participated in the discussion and uh we see you in the next atom zone episode and

hopefully we will see soon the on-chain voting proposal because uh it will be an historic moment and uh

i personally can't wait to make that vote all right guys thank you bye cheers

### Host

- [Cosmos Hub ⚛️](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/cosmoshub.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/cosmoshub)
- [Røbb Stack ⚛️](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/0xrobbstack.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/0xRobbStack)

### Speaker

- [Cryptocito | YouTuber ⚛️](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/cryptocito.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/Cryptocito)
- [D](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/effortcapital.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/EffortCapital)
- [Eat Healthy Get Rich](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/eathealthygetr1.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/EatHealthyGetR1)
- [jehan](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/jtremback.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/JTremback)
- [Spaydh 💧✴️ | Consensus 🇺🇸](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/spaydh-consensus.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/0xSpaydh)
- [søi2studio ₿](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/soi2studio-btc.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/soi2studio)
- [Erkan erdogan](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/erkan202020.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/Erkan202020)

## Want more TVL for your protocol or chain?

AlphaGrowth grows TVL for protocols and chains through asset acquisition and integration, grants, incentives and LP deals. We built this data and keep it free.

[How we grow TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/defi/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo) [Talk to AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/contact-us/index.md?utm_source=markdown&utm_medium=ai_agent&utm_campaign=aeo)
