---
title: "THORChain Spaces #79 | Twitter Space Recording | AlphaGrowth"
description: "Twitter Space Recording from 2024-01-18 with THORChain, Chad Barraford, logan shippy, Can Gurel, Pluto (9R) ⚡️🇺🇦, Olivier Leprohon, cryptofunded, Eric Culverson, FOX McCloud, Tunay, DrCrypto"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/thorchain-spaces-79"
---

# THORChain Spaces #79

Recorded: Jan 18, 2024 Duration: 1:50:21

## Space Recording

[Open Original Space](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1gqxvQDagrRJB)

0:00 1:50:21

### Full Transcription

hey hey, what's up everybody? Chad, ThorChadz, what's going on? Feeling like I'm out here?

What's up, Chad? Are we still getting settled? We could wait for

a minute. Do we want to get people in?

I can't hear you, Chad. I don't know if you're there or not.

Yeah, what's up, Logan? Uh, you there? Can you hear me? Not sure, Chad. Yeah, I can hear

you loud and clear. Can you hear me? Yep, I got you. Can you hear? Can anyone hear Chad,

by the way? Nah, can't hear him. Okay. What's up, dude? How you doing? I'm good, man. I'm

just watching my net worth dissolve right in front of my eyes. It's fucking exhilarating,

boys. Yeah, we're here for it. I love it. I feel alive. Let's go. Yeah, man. You know

what? Hey, pullbacks are just normal in a bull market, man. That's just what it is.

You want volatility up and down. Yeah, for sure. I mean, the way I think about this kind

of stuff with door chain, it just changes the incentives. Like before, there was over 75%

of fees going towards LPs and nodes were getting like, you know, two to 3% yields. Right now,

you know, node APRs are going up. So if you're bonding, it's definitely not a bad

time to be to be doing that, you know, like it just changes the incentives and it just

it just aligns everything, you know, make sure that we have enough security for liquidity.

So it's the natural flow of things the way I look at it. I also look at it like a month

ago, two months ago, with 10 bucks or seven bucks, I only would have got one rune. Now

I'm almost getting two. So that's all that matters accumulate. That's it. Everything

I mean, we're looking at the charts of people using the tech volumes keep going up. I mean,

I checked Twitter, the timeline and you know, saw people are kind of arguing back and forth

with the direction of development and whatnot. And I think, I mean, it's valid points in

the community's voicing, which is great. You know, I think it's it's awesome that

the community is speaking their minds. It's just these are these are complex things to

navigate, like what is the ultimate direction? And I'm sure you guys have some answers today.

And that's why partly this the spaces is happening. I'm very curious to hear the the pros and

cons of both directions, or if there's multiple directions, like what what those pros and

cons are.

Yeah, and yeah, so today, like, I think we could definitely talk about like, what's

going on in q1, what the short term priorities are. And yeah, there's been a lot of discussion

about like, what the long term is, just for, you know, door five, and like new feature

development in general. Obviously, there's been a ton of discussion on that. But all that

is kind of like, in the future, because there's still a lot of priorities that like, they

need to be done over the next, you know, three to three to five months, which are

going to take a lot of time to get shipped out, like more, more pressing things than,

you know, things like room vault 2.0, and, and things like that, which are going to be

obviously debated. And, you know, whether they even come to fruition one day, like there's

no even solid design or consensus around it yet. So it's like, I personally think it's

better to just focus on the things that are like, for sure, coming like around the corner.

And like, you know, everyone agrees that there's some kind of consensus on like, hey, we're

going to do these, we're going to like focus on these things right now. And then then we

move forward and decide like, where we go from there. And obviously, like safety, security,

and like protecting LPs and things like that need to

Well, can you explain to me real quick, the two different main routes. So there's like

one, one route or one vision where, from what I understand, it's purely cross chain

liquidity and swapping, basically stream swaps. And then the other vision or, or route

that you could take would be Thorify with lending and other kind of more like banking

style products, if you will. So I'm very curious to know, like, what, what is your, what is

your stance on things? When it comes to those two routes? Is there is there, you know,

is it kind of like, I haven't been a part of the Thor chain community long enough to

realize, was there an original ethos, if you will, and now we've migrated from that ethos,

or was this kind of all part of it? And I just I don't know enough, right? And so that's

why I'm tuning in here to learn. But that's just what I'm seeing. I'm almost seeing

people torn on like these two paths. And it's causing a little bit of fud. So I'm very

curious to get your perspective.

Yeah, well, first of all, let me see if Chad is your mic working now. Let's yeah, I just

got rid of the headphone. There we go. Sweet. So all right. I think we can let's dive in

first and say like, what the like, the core of Thor chain, there's, yeah, obviously,

there's some debate around like, you know, where to go. But everyone knows that the

core of Thor shame is around, you know, we're around nodes bonding rune, and then LPs that

provide rune and another asset for liquidity. And really, the debate is around how to scale

liquidity in in proportion to make sure that, you know, obviously, we're not over scaling

liquidity to be unsecured or anything. But there's just the difference in vision on like,

do we get to Valhalla from just dual liquidity, which has been the core of door chain

from from day one? Or do we get there through this, you know, through a combination of

dual liquidity, which is always the core of door chain, but then building things on top

of it, like, like savers, which which is obviously a great product, but, you know,

pushes risk around to the dual LPs, where they're more highly rune levered, and it

changes their risk appetite. So, and then there's things like lending, which are built

on top, which are completely separate, I think, I think the kind of the debate right now is

more around just where to go in the liquidity sphere, and mostly just making sure that

things are safe. Because I think everyone can agree that like savers are really awesome

products, but making sure that dual LPs, which is what the protocol is kind of built

around, like whether that is the is the core product, or whether that can kind of be

abstracted away, and be in the background as part of this, you know, Thorify design, or

yeah, I mean, it's just whether is that is that the core? And like, do we need to do

everything to protect the LPs? Or is the future more like savers plus protections to

make sure that savers is always solved?

Does that mean that so with people, it's like a lot of people fear change, right?

So it's just, is this just the natural progression of things, and people who have

been in the community a long time that were kind of sold on this original vision, they're

just not capable of modifying their stance and realizing, hey, this is just a better

vision overall. Or are they right, in the sense of, hey, we should stick to that

original ethos and not deal with defy because there's other risks with building

out defy, like other risk vectors, you know, if so that's kind of where I like, I

just don't know enough. And Chad, I'd be very curious to get your perspective on

those risk factors. And like, just overall, what you think about that situation?

Is this still maintaining kind of the original ethos just enhanced? Or is it

like, yeah, we're kind of switching it up with these Thorify style features?

Well, originally, Thorify was was not part of the original design, right? So if

you go back to the original white paper, right, you could either look at the

one that was from 2018, or you could look at the one from 2019 2020. But

like, the Thorify concepts weren't designed or, or considered at that time,

because at that time, we were just trying to like, solve the problem of like

cross chain liquidity, which in itself is obviously very complicated and

difficult and this often required a lot of time and research and coding time and

whatever else to get to actually work, right? It didn't make sense at that

time to start thinking about, you know, advanced features like savers and

lending, whatnot, because it just yet you got to walk before you can run. Do you

know what I mean? So it's pure, it is totally respectable. If people want to

stay true to the original AMM perspective, right? I get it. They're not

wrong, right? They're not this on a bad position. It makes complete sense in a

lot of ways, right? At the same time, I can also think about the value of what

savers does. It takes savers by itself just for one moment. The value of what

savers does, right? Offering, you know, especially like BDC yields on BDC. That

is incredibly valuable for the industry as a whole to do that in a

decentralized way, doesn't exist and has never existed until Thorchain really

did it. Do you know what I mean? And that in itself is how Celsius and BlockFi

and all those guys with tens of billions of dollars, you know, had grown in part

from that kind of earnings. Yeah, but they also exploded though, right? Or

imploded. Well, that's not a fair comparison because the reason why

they exploded is because they took people's Bitcoin and other assets and

just like started like throwing it to other locations, making it risky, risky

like, you know, motions with those things. It's not, it's not fair. I get

what you're saying. I'm just, I'm throwing it out there, right? That's what a lot

of normies are going to think though. Just like, Hey, this is, this is like

that. Therefore, that might prevent me from investing in room because the

perceived risk is higher than the actual risk. Yeah. And it'd be fair. That's

true. And that's also true with like Terra, right? Terra created a lot of

PTSD and a lot of people in the industry and a lot of it. And, and rightfully

so, they're, they're more, um, uh, skeptical, right? Of like projects in

general, which is, I think it's actually generally a positive thing for the

industry. But, um, if you wanted to build something like a savers, right? Or

lending for that matter, you, you have to do it with an AMM. You can't, you

can't have savers without the AMM. It doesn't make sense. Won't work, right? Same

thing with lending. You can't do lending without the AMM as well. So like, if you

wanted to go that direction to provide these extra services that in their own

right are just as important and as valuable as AMM, if not more so, you

have to do it with the AMM. Now you can, you can make arguments, right? And

we've had discussions in the past about like the conceptual idea of like

forking, forching, and have one of the two chains be like, you know, the, the

static, you know, uh, AMM basic, you know, base kind of model, if you want to call

it that. And then another one that's kind of like the more advanced DeFi

protocols that are, you know, breaking the mold in many respects, right? And

by doing a fork, you know, people who feel that one way can go on one side.

I don't want people to feel the other way. They can go the other side, blah, blah, blah.

And, and maybe that happens. I have no idea. I'm not a future. I'm not a

predictor of the future, but it is the value of these things, the value of

thor-chain beams will accomplish cross-chain liquidity and having an AMM

is just one thing that it can do and how it can contribute to the industry

and contribute to the space. It's capable of doing much, much more. Now if

you want to keep things just to the AMM space and effectively doing what

Chainflip's doing, very Chainflip's in the, in the chat here, Chainflip's just

doing the AMM thing, right? And, and that's their choice. And that's a

respectable choice to be made, right? Now, do we want to sit in the same boat

as, as, as Chainflip and just try to compete with them in some sense and,

you know, uh, cross-chain liquidity, blah, blah, blah, swapping. Maybe, maybe

some people feel that way, right? But if there's a capability to do

something like a saver's or like a lending or something like this of

offering, um, um, decentralized, uh, finance primitives for arbitrarily

any chain or asset, especially for something as important as Bitcoin,

there's a lot of value there to be, to be, to be gained by the

industry, a lot, a lot of value. So, um, it is up to not me or, or

familiar cow or anybody else. It's up to the notes and the community to

decide which direction they want to go. And to be honest, neither

perspective is right or necessarily wrong. It's just how you feel about

things, right? So it's at some point in the future, we can talk about

these. Like, so for example, like, you know, lending is pretty close

to the cap, right? It's like nice, not 96.6 right now or something

like this, right? So we might be talking about in the near future

about what we want to do with lending. Now we could say, uh, we

don't like Thor 5 and we don't want to go further down this

road. So let's just, you know, sunset the feature and allow loans

to be closed, but not opened. And eventually lending would just

kind of, you know, die out on its own. Maybe that's the

thing that people want to do. Maybe people want to, you know, raise

the cap. But so why, so why is the community so split though?

Cause it seems a little bit polarizing when I go on Twitter and

some people are like, Oh, the devs, it's not decentralized because

the devs were already kind of moving in this direction without

approval. Like that's what I'm seeing. And I, I don't know if my

timeline is just like that or everyone's is like that, but like,

what is the polarization stemming from?

Well, first of all, devs can't do anything. Like literally they

don't have, they don't in the end, the nodes control anything

in and everything. So devs just can't just move forward with

anything without the nodes just either being complacent and just

like not doing anything or them just allowing it notes and

offers to allow any, any and all changes. Right. So that's one

thing to be clear. The, the difference is like, the reason

why people are so polarized is because some people are more

risk on and some people are more risk off. Right. And I think

for like people like Pluto and other people, like especially

on the nine realm side, they're coming from a more like,

let's just keep it simple and basic and, you know, do the

basic AMM thing. Whereas myself and Lena are more on

the mentality of there's a lot we can do with this, you

know, sky is a limit. Let's, you know, let's not just have

Thorchain be a 20 billion dollar protocol. Let's be a hundred

billion, 200 billion, right? Like whatever we can, we can,

my viewpoint, we can get there. That's in my, just my personal

two cents. Right. But if you want to keep in things, if

people like Pluto or others want to keep things more basic

and, you know, or whatever, I mean, that's perfectly fine.

But like, but people are polarized because people are

scared, in effect, like people are scared from, you know, to

use your, your Celsius BlockFi reference that you made

earlier, people are scared because of terror, terror, you

know, collapsible blah, right. And like, that's just the

state of the industry as a whole of just being more

reserved, right. And more, you know, afraid of death

spirals and things of such. So basically what you're

saying is you don't want rune to be a pussy coin. You want to

go for glory. That's what you're saying. That's funny

because like, and I say that it's like jokingly but

serious at the same time, because it's like, hey, man,

if you're here in crypto and you really want to change the

world of finance, you can play it safe and like not do

anything that's, I feel like there's so many of those

protocols and coins out there and it's like, they know

they can raise some money and they can get to a certain

market cap and then they become, you know, people

become extra liquidity for the founders, they're out,

they got rich, but they didn't really make a true

difference. And then it's just a fucking slow bleed all

the way back down to zero or 99% retracement over time.

And then it's gone, right. So I respect the fact

that you guys are definitely trying to, it sounds

like evolve and adapt based off of tech upgrades

that you guys are facilitating, right. It wasn't a

part of the original vision with what you're saying,

the Thorify, but it's like, as you guys improve tech

and then you view current market conditions and

what other people have done and you've learned,

you guys realize that you can also partake in,

you know, different feature builds and whatnot.

So I get it. I'm in the software world myself.

So I understand it's like, it's, there's a lot of

different directions to take and I, you're going

to upset, you can't please all the people all

the time is what it sounds like to me more so

than anything else. But there could be so like

one group of people could be upset the original

people who want to play it safe, but then you

bring in a whole new batch of people into this

ecosystem that want to use these other products.

And I'm assuming in your vision, Chad, like that

new group of people that gets onboarded is much

larger than the group that's bitching or complaining today.

Well, I don't know. I don't know. I really don't

have any sense of size, right? So you can make

an argument that people are not investing in

room because they don't like, you know,

Thorify features and you can make an argument

that people are investing in room because of

Thorify, Thorify features. And then to be honest,

I don't have a good sense of the size of

to be honest, right? Nor would I consider room to

be a quote, pussy coin or in it for the glory,

as you said earlier in your in your message there.

But like, it's not about it's just about

I see it from my perspective, I see there's a

lot of opportunity to do things that nobody else

in the industry is capable of even doing.

Most people in this industry aren't even have

the stack to accomplish the things that

we can accomplish. And what we can do

theoretically is we can provide services

that are critically important and critically

valuable and far exceed everything else in

the market, right? Let's just assume for a

moment that lending works as as designed

and just make the assumption for one second.

That would be one of the most important

advancements in D5 we've seen in fucking

five years. Like, and I don't think you

can reasonably argue with me on this,

right? But that's obviously making the

assumption that it works. And when I don't

know that it works, and we won't really

actually know whether it works or not

until the end of the next bear market,

which was, you know, four years away or

whatever the hell the number is, right? To

be fair. So it's perfectly valid for

people to have the viewpoints they have

and I understand what that is polarizing

and I don't want to drive a stake

on, you know, the things that are

important for Q1 that we've already kind

of talked about as a community and kind

of agreed generally agreed upon. It's not

really controversial or whatever, like

minimalist transactions and, you know,

getting, you know, a scalability like we

just did the swap our club, for example,

and that was like a significantly

improved the speed of which trades and

swaps are done on the network. So like

at some point we can talk about

those things and to be honest even much

like a room vault 2.0, I'm not even sure

I'm a fan of it. You know, I haven't even

read the issue personally. I know I kind

of understand it at like a general high

level, but there's questions and

concerns, legitimate questions, legitimate

concerns to have around it, and which

just requires more time of research

and understanding and vetting and blah

blah blah before we can actually like go

down that road, you know. But to be

honest, nobody's really pushing for it

to be done now or eating time soon for

that matter.

Probably not even Q2. I wouldn't

want to see it within, you know, Q2

time frame, right, if we see it at all,

right. But for right now I'm more

focused on just let's just

fix, you know, bugs, let's scale the

network, right, let's get

ARBs to be more efficient, let's get

minimalist transactions, maybe older books,

I don't know what, but there's a lot to

be done in the interim for sure.

Yeah, I definitely agree. The short-term

and mid-term alignment is all there and

like, I mean for myself personally, like

I really see the value in a lot of

Thorfied features. It's just making sure

that things are

are safe for the network and obviously

you're not blowing up LPs through

basically unhinged Savers

exposure where they're taking on their

own IL and Savers IL

essentially and not having the risk of

blowing up LPs or, you know, with

lending, minting rune, which is obviously

like a core part of the

mechanics behind it, which is why there's

been so much research that went into

like the design implementation of the

lending system. So it's like,

I don't know, I think the community is

kind of in the middle where it's not

just like, oh, like we only need to be the

AMM, which I'm sure there's some people

that truly believe that, but at the

same time there's definitely a ton of

room for innovation,

but it's just doing things in a safe and

scalable way where, you know, there aren't

going to be people that are completely

blown up in the protocol doing it,

especially with

with Savers or lending. Like given this,

the pure design of the protocol,

you know, with the AMM itself, the risk

that the LP takes is impermanent

loss, and it's changed a lot since

the first days of the protocol, where now

they're taking on their own IL risk, and

they take on

Savers' IL risk, and we introduce things

like protocol and liquidity

in order to decrease that risk, but

protocol and liquidity isn't infinitely

scalable, right? So it's just like,

it's all just trying to answer the

question, like, how do we

curtail all of the risks of DoorFi

and, you know, make this thing just a

incredibly powerful protocol, where

obviously you can do the swaps,

you can do Savers, you can do lending,

but do everything in a safe way, where

people still have access to the

features,

but in a way where, you know, things

aren't going to go

sideways given whatever kind of price

action, because

obviously if something can happen, then

it will happen, so it's just

protecting against all the risks that

could potentially come, and, you know, in

the next bear market, or

who knows, like it could come

whenever, so just making sure that

people are protected, especially, you

know, especially the liquidity providers,

which

everything on Thorchain is built around

dual LP and, you know, pairing asset

with Vroom.

So the question is just how to do

that safely?

Yeah, how to do that safely, obviously.

That's why we launch features, you know,

with CAPS,

that's why we have backstop

circuit breaker things that we have

been talking about for a long time, but

also, like,

one of the reasons why we started to go

down the Thorfire road in general,

which is just trying to address

what we saw to be, what myself and

at least Lina saw to be, like,

problematic problems with the

currently, really original design,

meaning that, like, can we grow

TVL to be a reasonably, you know, higher

amount? You can't be,

you're not going to become the biggest

exchange in the world with

200 million in TVL. Just, it's not

going to happen.

It's just, it's just not enough

liquidity,

and by kind of forcing everybody to be a

dual LP and ever being

exposed to rune, the amount of people who

are willing to be LPs is

a lot less than somebody who's willing

to do, you know, Ethereum and

USDC, for example,

right? And that's what Chainflip has

done. Chainflip has kind of opted

to say, you know what, we're not going

to force people to hold

flip tokens to become dual LPs. We're

going to have them be

holders of USDC, and we're going to have

them be holders of ETH or whatever.

And by doing so, they're making a

trade-off. They're saying,

we're going to make it easier for

people to be LPs in some sense, or be

exposed to the assets they want to be

exposed to.

But at the same time, they're just

going to say, we don't really care about

economic security.

So, and that's just the trade-off,

right? And we could theoretically do the

same thing if we really wanted to. Do you

want to

do a way with economic security and

start

coming with new designs that allow us

to scale

TVL more so than it is now through

that mechanism? I mean,

there's not much of a taste for that,

at least from my perspective, or

anybody that I've spoken to.

So, like, even like what we have, even

if you just

keep everything vanilla,

it remains to be seen that that is

enough

to accomplish the task of what this

protocol is trying to accomplish.

Fox McLeod, do you have something you want

to add, or

Tine?

Thank you for letting me speak. I have a

little question, guys,

with my appreciation to you.

Can Torchain and Torfy split

in two different paths? This is my

question.

Two different what?

Two different paths, two different ways.

I mean, it can be forked into two

different chains.

That's, you know, something we could

discuss as a community at some point

in the distant future, but

parts within the same chain, I don't

think so. The only way you could do that

is you would need to create, like, two

different tokens. It's like the rune

token, which is, like, the AMM, and then

there's a new token called

rune version,

rune, thorfy, I don't know, but then you

create a separation

of the collective value that the

protocol

is pulling in. So it's theoretically

possible, I suppose, but I'd have some

concerns around it.

Hello. Hey, what's up? How are you?

Mike, can you guys hear me?

Yep, go ahead. My question is, how do you

guys expect the

future advances in thorchain to affect

the price of rune?

Yeah, I don't really have an answer to that

question, to be honest.

It's kind of an arbitrary question with

no real answer to it.

I mean, I guess, like, if you think about

in terms of just the AMM side of

things,

rune's price would move with its

adoption, right, with its

volume, right? If you think about it in

terms of, like,

thorfy, it's a different mechanism, and

it has a different effect,

right? And

rune's price would clearly do

better.

Assuming that thorfy works, and there's

no, you know, calamities of any kind,

obviously, rune's price would do better

with thorfy than without it, because you

have

multiple demand centers

for the asset. The more demand centers

you have for an asset,

or the more significant, the size of

those dimensions are

clearly the price would be relative to

that.

So if you keep things simple on the AMM

side,

rune can still go to a hundred bucks,

theoretically. I'm not saying it's

no one quote me as I'm giving price

predictions or anything like this,

but even if you just leave the AMM by

itself, could rune go to a hundred bucks?

Yeah, that's totally possible, totally

possible.

If you added, you know, lending and

other things with it,

can it go higher than that? Yeah,

absolutely. You know, it's just,

rune can be successful without it,

without thorfy, possibly, likely.

I don't know, it's hard to say to be

honest, but like,

having more demand centers for an asset

makes it more, yeah, makes it more.

And those, and having legitimate demand

centers, obviously, like

Terry doing like fixed rate, 20%

will oblige, not legitimate, but

yeah, okay, perfect, thank you.

Hey guys, just joined here, this is Pluto.

I'm just curious, if we were to deploy

the

60 million rune that's in the standby

reserve into POL,

doesn't that remove 60 million rune

worth of organic demand?

Like, if the protocol is just

putting up all the rune side,

where's the demand coming from in

thorfy?

Sorry, I don't know, I don't know what you

mean by organic demand.

Like in a, in just a traditional vanilla

dual LP,

people need to buy rune in order to

provide the other side of the liquidity.

If the protocol reserve is putting up

all the rune and allowing savers to

just enter with

exogenous assets, where, how is thorfy

actually creating demand for

rune?

Oh, yeah, so the trade volume of the

protocol

is directly correlational, not

necessarily in a one-to-one kind of way

with its TVL.

So as you increase the TVL of a

protocol, generally speaking,

the volume goes with it, right?

And this volume goes with it, you

also get higher price execution, better

price execution,

right, because the pool is, has more

liquidity to it, and it's got, it's

more capital efficient in a lot of

ways.

And so it's beneficial to the asset in

general, because

you're going to have to naturally see a

higher volume of trading and better

price execution.

But savers was never really

necessarily designed for

causing rune price to go up,

necessarily. It's designed

primarily was to increase the TVL of

the network, in which case it's done

that quite successfully,

rather successfully. Lending was more

designed for the idea of like

creating a strong demand center for the

rune asset, like creating more buy and

burn pressure.

That's more of what it was designed,

it's a primary thing that it's trying

to achieve in the lending design.

But because lending has been very

subdued, in a sense, we've capped it a

very small cap, and

over a long period of time, it hasn't

had that effect,

which is not really surprising either,

because the goal of lending,

you know, over the last like few months,

whatever, is not about

trying to get rune's price to go to

experimentation, and understand if the

assumptions that are made in the design

pan out to the market. Thus far it's been

true, like everything,

everything about lending thus far has

been nothing but green flags. It hasn't

been a red flag

in lending that I can remember right

now. Everything's been green flags

so far. It's been doing very well

relative to what we expect it to do.

The only thing that hasn't happened is

some large market adoption of it, which

you know, that's not going to happen with

a 1% cap, which is

what we expected anyway.

Yeah, I just, with POL,

it's just like you're basically

replacing organic demand for room to,

for providing the other side of dual

sided liquidity,

and you're just basically saying, okay,

that'll come from reserve, that'll

come from

supply that is currently not circulating.

So I, what I feel like would be a better

way

to create organic demand for room, I'm

sure the word organic is not

maybe the correct word, but to create

actual demand for room people

other than the protocol buying it and

putting it into pools.

And if you, if you were to just take

that 60 million

in the standby reserve right now, like

because clearly the protocol works

without that today.

If you were to just take that and

just burn the whole thing and reduce

the supply of room from,

I don't know, whatever it is right now,

you know, total supply 484 million

and you were to make that 424 million,

like you're basically creating,

there's less room now in circulation

and then people have to buy it in

order to provide liquidity, like I just

don't,

I just don't see why like, like, like

dual LP will work if the yields are

high enough if there was enough

demand for

swapping, cross chain swapping, which is

like the bread and butter of this

protocol,

it just naturally follows that people

will provide liquidity, it will become

attractive enough to the point where

people will see it.

Like I just want to see dual LPs

making money again and then like if

they're making money again, it's

because

they don't have this like, there's not

like just

room being put into the pools by the

protocols, people are actually like

buying it to put it in there.

Yeah, but I think the thing you're

missing is that

it doesn't matter what the APYs are of

being a dual LP

if you just don't want to hold room,

like you could put it 300 fucking

percent,

doesn't matter, people, if you don't want

to hold room, you don't want to be

price exposed to room,

it doesn't matter if you're getting

300 percent,

just not worth the risk, right?

And by the way, burning 60 million out of

the standard reserve, A, does not reduce

circulation, circulation

reserved funds do not include in

circulation,

but B, it wouldn't create any kind of

long-term economic value, it just

create a

tweet thread and maybe a short-term pump,

which by the way we did that a long

time, we burnt,

originally the supply of ruin was

one billion tokens

and you know back in I think 2019,

I think it was, maybe early 2020,

we burned half the supply, right? And did

we see a massive

bump in price? Yeah, there was a

bump, but it wasn't, I don't

even think,

I don't even think that the price

doubled for memory, that was a long

time ago though, so maybe I'm

misremembering, but

it's not a, it's not a sustainable,

it doesn't create sustainable growth

in the protocol by burning 60

million

for whatever.

Yeah, I'd just rather see that never go

into circulation

in the first place.

Yeah, and the reason why you're saying

that is because you're looking at

ruin in terms of its monetary policy,

you know, and I get why you're

looking at things that way, and I think

you'd be probably in the commonality

in that sense,

but the reality is that ruin is not

a money, right? It's never been

designed to be a money, right? It's not

trying to compete against Bitcoin,

right, or anything like this. It's

barely even a fucking utility, it's

really,

they're primarily to offer security more

than any other thing, and

and offer more capital-efficient ways of

like, you know, not having a thousand

different Bitcoin pools with a thousand

different pairs or whatever,

so it has a role, but its role is not

primarily to be a money where it has a

good monetary policy like

Bitcoin does, or whatever else.

Like, there's a part of me that thinks

that like, if I were to do it all over

again, then like I wouldn't

maybe not even create a cap on ruin

supply just because it

distracts from what it's

actually trying to achieve,

right? You're investing into ruin not

because you think it's a good store of

value,

you're investing in because you believe

that it's going to be adopted into the

future and get more trade volume and

have more

demand for it, right? Because the

tokenomics of ruin is

designed in a way that

its growth moves with the growth of the

protocol,

unlike, you know, Unitoken or Sushi or

these other

DeFi tokens that are just governance

tokens.

But again, like I don't even, I haven't

even read that whole proposal of

the 60 million thing. That's an idea

that

somebody floated in that concept of it.

I haven't even read it, to be honest.

Hey, Mariano, what's up?

So I wanted to segment into the

roadmap and

couple that with the recent discussion

on

the dual LP and the 2.0

idea. I've seen

RapidSwap's stream and it seems like

we could do a lot of volume without much

TVL.

So first hand, I would put

the priority for us to, you know, discuss

how to get there faster instead of,

you know, thinking that TVL will mean

the world.

What do you say? How to get there

faster? What do you mean?

Instead of like wasting, I mean not

wasting, but instead of,

you know, picking fights over this dual

LP discussion,

see how the protocol works after

RapidSwap's. If

there will be a necessity,

you know, a necessity to give LPs

a

the non-roon option as the priority,

if that makes sense. You know what I

mean?

So once we deliver, you know,

once Devs deliver RapidSwap's,

we can do a cross,

you know, a cross check to see if

the TV, like the pros and cons are

still there for

for any big switch. I think, you know,

another, wait, so my question, let me

step back a little bit.

My question is, how did this discussion

start

and how

after this ADR, how will it evolve? Will it

eventually go to the, if it doesn't pass,

how does the governance

take this into account, you know, in the

back end

by the development teams? On the dual

LP

discussion, if we're going to eventually,

so my point I'm trying to make is first

that

I would prioritize, you know, RapidSwap's.

I think that that makes a huge

difference for

capital efficiency, execution, all the

good stuff, and then,

you know, segment that into how

governance works in a way that,

how would we do this even

before RapidSwap's, in a way?

Yeah, this stuff is definitely not put

in front of,

like all this new, like,

Roon vault and things like that are not

put in front of things like order books.

Like, order books is on the

near-term priority list, so like Q1,

Q2

list of priorities to go out, and

RapidSwap's is, I believe, part of the

order book design, so that's something

that's already,

like, coming in the short to mid-term

over the next couple months, so that's

already something that's

that's like in motion and happening

right now, and like, as for how we kind

of got here,

it's just a, like, proposal from,

you know, from one of the devs for

for this thing, which I believe it was

originally presented as, like, this is

what's happening, and then,

like, you know, and then it kind of got

into, like, well not everyone really

agrees with

this direction, so now it's kind of just,

like, here's this proposal, and

eventually there's probably gonna,

there'll be some kind of

vote on this, probably an ADR happening

over the next,

you know, couple weeks or months, but

definitely not

trying to distract from the short to

mid-term priorities of,

you know, shipping things like order books,

which includes rapid swaps,

memo-less transactions, batched outbounds,

and

all the things that are, like, actual

priorities that can

present an improvement over the entire

design right now,

that are entirely non-controversial

and

already determined to be an area of

focus for the next couple months.

Makes sense. Makes a lot of sense.

Yeah, I just think that the rapid swap

is going to be the,

one of the major impacts on

how much volume can go through.

Streaming swaps was probably the first

step there,

but streaming swaps in combination with

normal speed,

synth speed swaps is definitely a

game changer,

and I think Lina talked about how

synths, mints, are actually positive

for rune, supposed to meant to pump rune,

which kind of contradicts what Chad

recently said, that synths weren't

really meant to pump rune,

the landing was,

but synth burns actually dumps rune,

so what she said, I don't know,

she, or he, that we should all stop

with the P.O.L. matching

synth mints, and let Saver's TVL

increase,

which Thorchain makes money with TVL,

which

is something I kind of disagree with

once we have rapid swaps,

because it's kind of like a

just-in-time liquidity, if you will,

for arbitrage, which will

kind of sandwich with the order books,

if, you know, they don't order a book,

they will,

as they will make,

they will do synth, and if synths

are gone, they will do

L1 arbing, so it kind of still

extracts the way

the value that LPs get,

and that's a good thing, that means we

can process a lot of water golf.

I just want to make sure there that,

I made my point about how much volume

can go through,

and thank god that we'll have

rapid swaps before any of this,

you know, potentially goes through.

Yeah, I mean, the thing I'd say to that

is that,

if you have a car, right, and you want

to upgrade your car,

make it faster, you know,

as a race car, or whatever, you can't

just focus on

one component of the car, right, like the

muffler,

right, or the humming, whatever, like

you have to think holistically, and so

as you upgrade, you know, one component,

you know, you probably want to upgrade a

different component,

right, because the other component

becomes

the bottleneck of the speed of the car,

or the performance of the car.

You don't just want to keep on focusing

on,

you know, upgrading the engine, but never

touch

the wheels, or its aerodynamics, or

other things, right, and so like,

what we've always said for many years

now is that the three kind of important

pillars of the protocol is that we

always want to be scaling security,

we want to be scaling TVL, we want to

be

scaling volume, right, and we

do this through

many mechanisms, or many ways of

competence things, but we're constantly

kind of like shifting a position on

what thing we're focusing on, right, we

used to focus on

security during the bear market when

security was a problem,

we focused on, you know, TVL with

savers until savers launch, and we

haven't focused on that for,

you know, a while now, and ever since

that we've been focusing mostly on

swaps,

which is what streaming swaps came, and

and, you know, maybe rapid swaps,

another example of that, you know, so

forth and so on, so it's just like

we have to think holistically, and think

about what is the bottleneck of the

protocol,

and how do we improve that, right, that

whatever that thing might be, and it's

kind of shifting, it's going to change,

it's going to be like whack-a-mole,

as soon as you, you know, improve the

volume,

you're going to want to improve the

the effectiveness of the TVL, the

effectiveness of the ARBs,

and so we're constantly kind of shifting

positions, or

shifting focus more accurately, to

improve one component, so that

because it's the largest bottleneck of the

protocol.

Largely, I've been focused on not

volume,

ever since streaming swaps, I've been

not focused on TVL, I've been not to

focus on security,

I've actually been mostly focusing on

ARBs myself over the last,

you know, month or two, to make them

faster,

more efficient, more, you know, be able to

get their

their confirmation counts done,

put into the network quicker, to get

their

output, their outbound transactions, out

faster by

software cloud, you know, trader counts,

another thing to increase capital

efficiency of ARBs, so they can ARB

with 2x more efficiency than they're

currently doing

with synthetics, and

again, even with the rapid swaps,

another thing to make arbitrage plots

more effective, to make them, to scale the

protocol,

and that methodology, that perspective,

but we're going to always just be like

every, you know, few months, or six

months, or whatever it is, to be like,

alright, we've now maxed out the

the efficiency of ARBs, we've added

four new features,

to make ARBs faster, better, so we have

better

prosecution,

better volume, that kind of thing, and

maybe you want to focus on something

else at that point.

Yeah, it makes sense. Just to wrap that up,

for us investors of Roon, it would be

much better to have

higher TVL that would correlate with

price, due to the deterministic pricing

and incentive pendulum, and

a speculative multiple on top of the

deterministic price.

So, you know, all gears towards that for

sure.

Thank you guys.

And one thing that I guess we should

address real quick, is a lot of people, I

see a lot of comments on this, and

obviously on Discord too,

just about Twitter comms, so like

obviously there's a lot of

contributors, there's a couple different

contributors to the Thorchain Twitter

account,

and, you know, people post

things on here, like, you know,

I post things, others do too,

and, you know, no one should take

anything that's posted on this account

as a fact,

but at the same time, we definitely need

to do better,

just making sure that, you know, the

mouthpiece of the protocol, which

obviously, this is not an official

account, it doesn't speak for the

protocol, only the nodes can

speak for the protocol,

but at the same time, a lot of people

look towards, you know, this account, and

obviously, like, the community to,

for the signal of, like, what's going on,

and when the Twitter account says,

like, this thing is happening,

or this is what is going to happen,

when that's not, like, an agreed upon

decision, or, you know, that is not the

clear direction

that things are moving in, or it's a

controversial decision, or whatever.

Like, I mean, I believe that the

Twitter account should only be posting

things that are

in the will of the node operators

and the devs at that time,

so it's like, if things can change,

things will change over time, inevitably,

but obviously, we just need to do

better as a community to make sure that

people understand that, you know,

there's always going to be these

proposals, like, hey, we should do

this, we should do that,

but just, you know, having clear

communications, because this is where

of, like, what's happening,

and it only, it confuses people

when they see things that, like,

oh, this is happening, like,

I don't understand what this is,

or what, you know, it's so sudden,

when in reality, you know,

it changes where to take place,

they'd be many months from now

after a lot of discussion and decision,

but, you know, it's just not the

place of the Twitter to be,

you know, saying things to happen

as they could be in the future

without some kind of, like, clear signal

of that is the direction which

everyone agrees to go down.

So, yeah, I mean, that's something

that I, you know, I take upon myself,

too, just to, like, make sure

that Twitter comms are, you know,

clean and factual and professional,

but obviously, there's other

contributors, too, so I just want

everyone to keep that in mind,

but I'm going to continue to do my best

to, you know, provide good comms

for the community and make sure

there's clear signal on, like,

what people agree upon and what

I interpret as the direction

of the protocol, you know,

as agreed upon by the nodes

and the devs and the greater community.

So, I just wanted to call that out

because I see a lot of people

that are just confused about things

that this account tweets out

when maybe not all of it will,

you know, come to fruition one day, so, yep.

Yeah, I would just say that, like,

you know, for better or for worse,

like, when you operate a truly

decentralized network,

these types of hiccups happen,

you know, solely due to the fact

that there is not some centralized

figure or authority who's kind

of calling the shots, like,

it does consist of multiple

stakeholders, each that have

their own preferences that sometimes

pull in different directions,

except the part that we can do better

on is sort of aligning internally

on those things first.

And so, like, ideally, like,

the Twitter should not be a place

where other devs learn about

other devs' ideas and proposals.

Those conversations should happen

outside of the view of the public,

and then once the idea is fully formed

and ready to be taken to

sort of the next tier of feedback,

it should be taken within, you know,

the Discord dev community,

which contains long-time contributors,

nodes, investors, LPs,

and then once all of that sort

of semi-public discussion happens,

which, yeah, that discussion

is completely public,

but it's still, like,

not as public as Twitter.

Only once there's, like,

full consensus within the community

should things be happening

on the actual public Twitter.

Public Twitter should just be, like,

honestly, you know,

discussing things that either

already have consensus

and will certainly happen

in the near-term future,

or things that already have happened.

Like, you know, for example,

I would love to see us

talking about Swapper Cloud, for example,

and I did join a little bit late,

but that was a major thing

that went out this week,

which I'm sure you guys

already touched on,

but it's always going to be better

to just keep this forum to,

like, factual, you know,

looking into the past

or into the very near future

of things that absolutely

will be happening.

Yeah, 100% it looks chaotic

because, you know,

obviously there's a lot of contributors

that do their own thing

and have their own, like,

idea of the way to do things,

but I totally agree.

Like, the full of information

should always be, you know,

fit into a proposal,

and that goes to GitLab,

someone makes an issue,

and then people start talking

about it on Discord

and Twitter Spaces

and things like that.

Like, I feel like

that's a good discussion,

a good place to talk about things

that are, you know,

maybe just proposals,

but they're, you know,

slightly formed

or more fully formed

than just, like, an original idea.

And then once there's

some kind of consensus on, like,

this is a good idea,

or, like, did this seem solid enough

where there's at least

going to be a vote on it,

then that kind of moves

to the public forum of Twitter

where there's, like, you know,

there's so many eyes here

and what people see

is just kind of chaos

or they think

that something's happening

when in reality

it's just like a proposal

or something that may not

ever come to fruition

or it's just one person's idea.

So, yeah, that's my thoughts on that.

But yeah, we'll continue to,

you know, try and strive

for the great standard of comms

that I think we all want.

So keep pushing in that direction.

Well, let's hear from Ken

and then after Ken,

we can move on to Swabber Club

because we actually haven't

really talked about that quite yet.

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Let's do, well, let's do Eric first

and then Ken, Eric's been waiting

and then, yeah, let's talk

about Swabber Club

and some other things.

Are you there, Eric?

Yeah, hi, give me one.

Oh, no, yeah, no.

So, hey, sorry about that, guys.

So, appreciate you letting me,

let me talk.

I have, like, two questions.

One, because I remember hearing

someone say that the lending part

was kind of like a test,

like, kind of we were

testing the lending.

So one question was for that,

is did, was it considered

for, like, physical assets,

like, for example,

how banks can provide

or title loans, right?

So a physical asset

is collateral as well.

Did you guys possibly take that

or think about that

for an option as well

for investors?

No, we don't deal

with any kind of physical assets.

We're purely in the crypto space.

If you try to get into

the physical world,

it just becomes points

of centralization

and against the ethos

of the project.

Understood, understood.

Okay, okay.

Okay, no, then that kind of

eliminates my next question.

I appreciate it.

The one thing I did want

to know was actually,

if, because I want to be

a part of this project

and I want to contribute to it

a whole lot.

However, I don't have

any type of coding experience.

I don't know how to,

any of this, the talents

and skills that you guys hold.

But I do have knowledge

and resources in the real estate world.

And even though you guys said

you as the project

doesn't take part in it,

if I were to have started a company

and I wanted to be a part of it,

would that something like that?

Because I want to get,

I want to get housing

and the profits and benefits

to the housing markets

into the project,

at least the money,

the money-wise revenue into it.

I want to start generating money

from housing into Thorchain.

And if that would be the only way

that I would be able to contribute,

would something like that

also have to be as a proposal

or would we talk basically

at the Rare Evo event

because I ended up buying

my ticket there too.

Yeah, I've actually thought

about a lot about this as well

and how Thorchain lending

can displace the need

for people to sell off their Bitcoin,

to make investments

in other asset classes.

So you can, for example,

I don't think anything

that you're talking about

is going to get added

into the core protocol of Thorchain.

But you could potentially create

some sort of package

of real estate assets,

refinance them using Bitcoin loans

from Thorchain lending.

So basically collect Bitcoin from LPs,

then take out loans on Thorchain

using LPs Bitcoin,

and then use those assets

to refinance mortgages

on real world assets

or just buy assets outright

and then basically pay back your LPs

as you pay off those loans

from the actual revenue

that you make from them.

There's tons of businesses

that can be built

on top of Thorchain,

but there's no chance whatsoever

that there's going to be

real estate assets

added to Thorchain.

And I can probably say

pretty definitively

that that's just not

to Chad's point,

it goes against the ethos

of the protocol.

Okay, no, understood.

And I totally love

your point

and everything that you just said,

like the plan.

I'm going to have to go over that

and research it a little bit more,

but I love the process

that you just explained.

So I'm going to dig deeper

and then reach back out

on the next one.

Appreciate you guys.

Much love.

Thanks, man.

What's up, Kent?

What's up, guys?

Been a very interesting week

for Thorchain.

I'm glad to feel

I feel like the project

is the real thing.

Like people are arguing

over the roadmap and everything.

So the way I understand

is like when we look

at the near term upgrades,

I kind of summarized them

in three buckets.

It's like Memos transactions,

Swapper Cloud,

which you guys are going

to talk about next.

And then there's the order books.

Out of those three,

the one that kind of

excites me the most

is the order books.

I kind of want to hear more about

where the consensus is at

regarding its design

and implementation,

whether there's like

an agreement to a certain level

between like nine realms

and the core team

with regards to

its details.

Like some of the things

I'm curious to learn about

is basically like

I saw a proposal about

this, quote unquote,

a new asset type

known as like trade assets,

which would be a more

capital efficient asset

to use relative to cents

to do ARBs

and place order,

place limit orders.

So like how confident we are

in terms of adopting

like trade assets.

That would be like one question.

And the reason like

just for context,

like the reason I'm interested

in this is because I think

I want to like underscore

like Mariana's point here.

I feel like, you know,

with streaming swaps, like

they really unlocked

a big opportunity for Torchain.

Like before streaming swaps,

it was like, in my mind,

it was like TVL

was one of the top

priorities, right?

Like the pool sizes.

However, like with streaming swaps,

if you break down a swap

into 10,

the pools, like the effect

of pools is almost

it's like 10 times bigger.

And if you break it down

to the 200,

you can like treat pools

as if like they're 100

deeper.

And like with order books,

like there's a very plausible

plan to make streaming swaps

like shorter.

So I feel like, you know,

like double clicking

on what Mariana said.

I feel like, you know,

once it's out there

and we experienced

the results out there,

we're quickly going to realize

that like the Torchain

like doesn't need

that larger pools in order

to get where it wants to be.

But yeah, that's just my two cents.

Well, I think the design

of order books

was pretty much established

at this point.

It's already been coded

and there hasn't really been

any pushback

from any of the other devs

or community members about

its implementation details.

It's already it's actually

been in the code

for a long time.

There's some new things

to be added to support

streaming swaps within order books.

And I kind of like some work

to be done around that.

But you're right in the sense

that streaming swaps

kind of allows you to have

the price execution of,

you know, pools

that are 10 times deeper

and getting it to that,

getting it now in a sense.

And that's fair.

And that's an accurate thing to say.

But you also get like

if the pools were 10 times

two times deeper right now,

streaming swaps would be

executed twice as fast, right?

Now, rapid swaps might be,

you know, to have execute even faster.

And that's kind of what the idea

of the idea behind them.

But it also requires arbitrage

bots to be like mature enough

to support such a thing, right?

It doesn't guarantee

that every swap will be executed

in a single block.

It requires arbitrage bots

to be, you know, to show up,

you know, and do their job,

right, in a sense?

Yeah, that's fair.

But like, I think there's

the very real chance

that they will be

because that they're just

dollar to be made, right?

And like, in my mind,

it's just like,

I almost see it as like,

not AMM, but it is liquidity

that organic swaps

will trade against, right?

So like, there's going to be orders,

limit orders,

and then there's going to be

organic swaps.

The organic swap

is going to execute

against the pool.

Immediately after,

if the price satisfies

the limit order,

the limit order is going to

execute against the same pool,

but in the different direction.

And so like, it's just going

to increase the liquidity

and make swaps faster.

And because you can update

your limit order,

perhaps like every block,

like, you can be very sophisticated

with that, like you're not

going to necessarily,

like, you're not going

to experience the IL for sure

that you're experiencing an AMM.

And I feel like that plan

is like a very real,

very, very plausible

and like, it's a very exciting plan

with regards to like,

how Torchang can become

like the big project

that we all want it to be.

Yeah, that's absolutely true.

Yeah, that's not true,

but you can like,

here's the bear case for that, right?

Chainflips in the audience,

and so Chainflips has

a different model.

Instead of using stream and swaps,

they're using JIT,

which is another legitimate way

of approaching the same problem

in some ways.

And like, it's possible

that Chainflips could have

better price execution

than Torchang

if it has deep enough pools, right?

So we could have more shallow

pools than Chainflip,

but still a better price execution.

But that's probably not true

if Chainflip has 10 times

the pool depth that we do,

to be honest with you, right?

Depending upon a bunch

of different kind of variables

that'd be taken into account.

But I think like, I mean,

I definitely agree with you

in the sense that I find

rapid swaps or the concept

of rapid swaps to be pretty valuable.

And I'm excited to see that happen

and something I'd love to see

happen in Q1, maybe Q2.

And I definitely want to do that

before making any changes

that, you know, room vault

or anything like this.

Like, I'm not interested

in those things.

Much rather to limit orders

in rapid swaps

before we touch anything like that.

I'm with you.

Yeah, if anyone doesn't know

what rapid swaps are,

it's doing a streaming swap,

but using the order book

or people that place limit orders

or ARBs that place limit orders

on ThorChain,

basically filling a streaming swap

all entirely within one block.

So instead of needing to wait

for ARBs to come in

after you make the swap,

the ARBs have already placed their,

you know, have already

placed limit orders

where they can make a profit

ARBing to, you know,

the other exchanges

or decentralized exchanges.

So you can essentially

just fill in your streaming swap

in one block so you can get

guaranteed execution

and instant execution

for your streaming swap.

So you're still paying

those five basis points of slippage,

but you have that guaranteed

and instant execution.

So it's kind of the best

of both worlds for streaming.

And a quick question

on the implementation

of limit orders slash order books,

is that still on top

of synthetic assets

or like are those built

on top of derived assets

or trade assets

or like what's the primitive

that order books are built

on top of?

Because it seems like

we're kind of moving away

from synthetic assets

besides, you know,

in the context of savers.

So, you know,

what's the basis

of order books right now?

At the time the order

book code was written,

the thought process

there was going to be

around synthetics.

And the reason why that is,

if you do it

you have unsecured assets

on the network,

you could do it.

Like there's something

technically stopping

from doing so.

But now you're holding Bitcoin

outside of the context

of the AMM itself.

And therefore it's not

like properly secured

unless you have

additional mechanisms

to secure it.

So, but I think

that the intention now

is to use trade accounts

instead of synthetics.

And so we're going to be launching

trade accounts

probably fairly soon

as a project.

I haven't seen it.

Everybody seems to be for it.

There hasn't been much pushback

at all.

Probably the next, you know,

few weeks or a month or so

will play out of trade accounts.

That won't obviously support

order books off the bat.

But, you know,

initially it would just be

for ARBs to use primarily.

But at some point,

you know,

downstream another month or two,

whatever hell it's going to be,

we'll open it up

so that you can use order books

with trade accounts.

I'll just offer my view on it.

You know, I love order books.

I want to see order books

in door chain, of course.

It's a trading primitive

that a lot of people

are familiar with.

And it does unlock things

like rapid swaps

and, you know, just it brings us

closer to parity

with centralized exchanges,

which I think we can all agree

is, you know,

what we're trying to disrupt.

It does, you know,

it does give me pause

that like they are built

on top of synths now

because we're actively

trying to move things

away from synths.

Like there's, you know,

somewhat of a sentiment

in the community held by myself

and others that, you know,

synth leverage

is already too high.

And that by introducing

order books as a feature,

it just adds more demand for synths.

And, you know, I just it

doesn't seem like it

like launching a feature

that relies on synth capacity

while simultaneously

trying to scale back

synth utilization.

It just seems like

you're introducing one feature

that cannibalizes

the capacity of another.

You're going to have people

who are, you know,

trying to add savers

simultaneously taking away

from the capacity

available for order books

and vice versa.

So it just does seem

like a bit of like

a cannibalization effort there.

I personally, I mean,

I would love to see

if there was, you know,

I think there's other designs

have been floated.

For example, the idea of like

a liquidating order book,

like where your part of your order

can get partially liquidated

if like the price of some asset

falls below a certain amount.

We obviously scrapped that idea

and it's like your limit order

didn't get filled,

but you now have less

than you put in.

But I think one area

that we could potentially explore

is just the idea of like

an expiring limit order

where we allow limit orders

and we just allow people

to post just the exogenous asset

without actually having to swap

it to a synth

or affect the synth utilization

up to the security limit,

which we have plenty

of security right now

where we're currently

very overbonded.

And so that would shift

the incentive pendulum back towards.

If we just allow people

to post exogenous assets,

we could just use

the existing overbonded rune

to secure that.

So limit orders would really

just be capped at the amount

of excess security

at any given moment.

And then as we start to approach

that amount of the security cap,

we could just start expiring

limit orders to basically

kick them back out.

So I mean, because limit orders

are naturally a short-lived thing,

at least in, you know,

I've seen some people

just like throw on

a bunch of orders

at like a really, really low price

and they never get executed

but people want to have them there

so that, you know,

if the price of an asset does dip,

they can fill it a low amount.

But I think it would be more,

it would encourage people.

So I guess what I'm saying

is that you could eject

or expire a limit order

if it's far away

from the spot price

as we approach that security cap.

And then that way,

you know, you wouldn't have to do anything.

You wouldn't have to change

this into utilization

in order to allow people

to place limit orders.

And I think it wouldn't be

a terrible user experience

if someone paid a fee

to basically place a limit order

or rather, you know what it could be,

you wouldn't even have to

put the fee to place a limit order.

It's just that if your limit order expired

due to not being filled

after a certain amount of time,

all you basically having to be doing

is paying the outbound fee

to send you back your asset.

Is there any reason

why something like that

wouldn't work, Chad?

Because I just,

I would love if we could avoid

having to lean on SINTS

for any more features.

Yeah, like I said,

trade accounts will be used

for ARBs and for order books.

I don't think we're going to be using SINTS

for that was the original design

like back when we first talked

about order books

like over a year ago.

But I think today,

we wouldn't use SINTS at all for this.

So you could actually

just deposit some Bitcoin,

which basically gets automatically

traded into a trade account,

which is a one-to-one.

There's no fee for that.

And then it just sits

as a trade asset on the network

waiting for execution of some price

that you're looking,

you're waiting for the Bitcoin ETH price

to hit some ratio,

whatever the hell it is.

And then it just has an execute.

And we can also have

like a just like global expiry,

like you can't have an order

longer than three days.

I don't know.

I'm making up kind of a random example.

But in that way,

if security does become an issue

within a few short days,

all that kind of exits

and maybe you won't be able

to build new order book items

just because of the security concerns.

I don't know.

We didn't think more of the details

the weeds of that.

But yeah,

I don't think we're going to be using

sets for order books.

Yeah, I mean,

the problem with trade accounts

is that like,

they can be the asset

in your trade account

can be liquidated

if the price of ruin

drops relative to the asset

that it's securing correct.

Yeah, that is correct.

But when we discussed

the original like implementation

of trade accounts,

we said that that's an acceptable thing

because ARBs are relatively advanced.

They're very advanced actually.

They're probably the most advanced actor

in the ecosystem,

certainly more so than savers,

which is kind of just like

I said it and forget it.

Trade accounts actually have to like

monitor the sort of that point

at which they get liquidated.

But it's fine because

trade accounts and synths

that are held by ARBs

are meant to be

relatively short-lived.

They're only purpose of holding them

is to like rebalance the pools.

But if you have,

basically we want to avoid

building any product

that requires someone

who sets like a limit order

to actually have to like

monitor whether the capital

that they posted in their limit order

might get liquidated.

So that's why I was just thinking

like instead of even ever getting them,

if there was some like special mechanism

that prevented that from ever happening,

like it just ejected their order

and basically refunded it,

less the outbound fee back to the user

if they were ever anywhere remotely in danger

of getting to that point.

Like and then like potentially

not allowing new limit orders

when you're like below 10% or whatever

from like the security cap,

then that would at least provide

a user experience that like prevents people

who place limit orders

from being liquidated.

And I do like the idea of

essentially ejecting the people

who are furthest from the spot price first,

because they're the ones

who are least likely

to get their order filled.

And so most best eligible

for having their order ejected.

Yeah, I do think there's

some implementation details

to be ironed out.

And to be honest,

I haven't really thought about

it in any kind of depth quite yet

because I haven't been focused

on trade accounts,

the union of trade accounts

and order books.

That's just like where a ways

away from that from that mentality.

But you're right.

One thing to clarify though,

there's no like liquidation.

It's more accurate to call it

like a negative interest

is applied to the trade account.

Not like you

we hit some number

then all of a sudden

you lose all your trade accounts

you get zeroed or anything like that.

Sorry. Yeah, like a partial

like a partial liquidation.

You're losing some of the principle

that you put in.

We don't want people

to put a one Bitcoin order

and then we say,

oh, sorry, you only have like 0.9 Bitcoin

because trade accounts.

That's like not an acceptable explanation

from a UX perspective.

Right. And that's partially

why I was talking a moment ago

about if we have a cap

on the number of days

that an order item can be

on the decks, right?

Which is what a lot of other

decks have done in the past.

That's pretty common.

Then the because the the math

of how the negative interest works,

it's not aggressive at all.

It's actually quite quite weak

and it's in its way

that it approaches it for the most part.

So it's it's pretty fairly small

and so the the order would expire

within a day or two days

or three days or how the number might be.

And if you do get some kind of

negative interest

you're not going to lose like half

of your fucking position, whatever.

That would be pretty extreme,

but it would be rather quite small.

I think it's going to be designed

to be quite small.

Doesn't need to be harsh

to achieve its goal.

Yeah, totally.

I mean, at this point,

it feels like we're just kind of going

back and forth

on the implementation details.

I think for anyone

like joining late,

you know, this is kind of

goes to show that like, you know,

until a design is sort of agreed upon,

things are still very much fluid

at all times.

And so, you know, the introduction

of new primitives like trade accounts

kind of changes the implementation

of order books.

And and so like, you know,

it's also like not the kind of thing

where we have one chance

to get it right.

I think order books

and their users will be sort

of highly experimental

and ARBs and advanced people,

you know, will be advanced actors

will be sort of the beta users

of those.

So as with every feature

that we launched on Thorchain,

it'll be a, you know,

a staggered rollout

and we'll monitor the behavior

and see how people react

and respond before, you know,

before, before at least trying

to like roll it out to UIs and stuff.

We'll certainly see how,

you know, other users use the feature.

Oh, like, what's up, man?

Sorry to keep you waiting up here.

Hi, guys. Hi, everyone.

Yeah, I have a few questions

on a few topics.

So if you want to just continue,

Kao, I'll just ask my questions

as we touch the topics.

I know you mentioned going

to Swapper Cloud next.

Yeah, we've couple of people

that are question too.

So let's talk about Swapper Cloud.

And then if people have related

questions, like I don't want to go back

to like the previous topics

of like door five and stuff like that.

So let's just keep it kind

of moving forward here.

Let's talk about Swapper Cloud

a little bit because we finally

turned on Swapper Cloud

earlier this week.

And so Swapper Cloud is live.

So let's kind of dive into

like what Swapper Cloud is

and what kind of improvement

that should make over

this swap experience,

you know, how to get Swapper Cloud

and like, you know,

just what that means

to the protocol in general

and then what the plan is

for scaling up Swapper Cloud.

Yeah, I would love to talk about just,

I mean, Chad was the one

that wrote the code for it.

But it's probably the feature

that I'm most excited about

other than streaming swaps.

Because again, it's one of those things

that, you know, just enhances

the core product offering of Thorchain,

which is of course,

cross chain swaps.

So anybody who's swapped through

Thorchain, you know,

in the last couple months

has probably experienced

a pretty long delay

between when their swap

actually completes

and when they receive their funds.

And that's due to the scheduled

outbound queue,

which is basically a defensive measure

that was introduced as a result of

a number of security enhancements

that were made over the last few years.

But basically the idea behind

the scheduled queue

is that if anyone were ever

to try to attack Thorchain in any way,

we would basically have up to

one hour to detect those

and allow the community to flag it

and basically pause trading

during that time

while an investigation takes place.

So the only reason why,

like swapping isn't super fast

on Thorchain already today

is because of the decentralized nature

of the protocol.

And in wanting to constantly

improve the user experience of swappers,

we're constantly looking at ways

to balance the trade-off

between that user experience

and security of the network.

And because we are a decentralized network

and because we can't just,

you know, pause things instantaneously

or roll out patches quickly,

we want to take an overly defensive

network posture to security

that, you know, for better or for worse,

centralized exchanges

don't really have that limitation.

So basically Swapper Cloud

was built as a feature to counteract

the negative effects of a different feature.

It just so happens that those two features

have opposite but both equally relevant

standing for the protocol,

which is again, you know,

balancing the user experience

with the security of the network.

So what Swapper Cloud does

is it basically keeps track

of all of the liquidity fees paid

by each from and to asset addresses

for every asset

that's ever taken place on Thorchain.

So this even includes transactions

that happened in the past.

We backfilled all of the,

you know, liquidity fees

and applied those retroactively

to every address

that's ever transacted on Thorchain.

So if you've already paid,

you know, a million,

$2 million worth of liquidity fees,

it's likely that you're,

you know, you're a legitimate user.

It increases the bar

for what an attacker would have to do.

They basically have to like

swap tens of millions of dollars

through the network

in order to, you know,

get this discount.

But, and so this discount

doesn't apply to the majority of Swappers.

But importantly, what it does do

is it excludes the volume

from those transactions

from the security feature.

And because half of the,

half of the volume

that takes place on Thorchain

is arbitrage volume,

formerly arbitrage volume

and just like organic Swapper volume,

like say, you know,

Joe Swapper from Trust Wallet,

their volumes would both

count equally towards engaging

that security measure,

the scheduled outbound delay.

And so basically what this does

is this kind of looks at it

and says, okay, this,

this, our bot has been swapping

back and forth on the network

and they've generated

millions of dollars of liquidity fees.

And so they're receiving

tons of utility from the protocol.

And so basically,

we're not going to count

their volume towards that,

that scheduled outbound queue.

So in that sense, like,

both the ARB is getting a better,

you know, they're,

they're basically getting better execution

because they're not waiting as long,

but also everyday swappers

who are just swapping through wallets

are getting better or faster execution

because the total amount of

volume that's being looked at

is lower due to the ARB volume

being excluded

from the security feature.

So it's really,

it really kind of like a novel concept.

Like most people

don't need to know about this at all.

But it's just something that

everyday swappers

are going to get much faster.

You know, it's not

actually execution time.

You know, the swaps

actually execute quite quickly.

Even on an unbounded streaming swap,

you know, the most I've seen,

you know, certain swaps go for

like under millions of dollars

is around 30 blocks or so,

which is like three, four minutes.

So the swap itself

actually executes after

three or four minutes,

but it sits in this queue

waiting to be flagged

if it is a suspicious transaction

by anyone in the community.

And if, you know, if,

but if not,

there's no reason that

it needs to be sitting there that long.

And so what this feature does

is it basically allows us to,

you know, get things moving faster.

And the last point I'll make on that

is that, you know, there's ways

that we can, you know, we could just

get rid of the scheduled

outbound delay today.

But that wouldn't be like

a very prudent security posture.

That said, as the protocol

continues to ossify,

and you'll hear me talk about

a lot about this, because it's,

I think, like where we should

eventually try to get to where

we're not releasing new features.

We're just, you know, letting things run

because that allows us

to actually scale back

these security measures to allow

things to move through the network

more quickly and process more volume.

So basically, you know, this entire journey

has been a balancing act

between security and user experience.

And we're just now starting

to feel comfortable enough

and, you know, shipping features

like SwapperCloud to be able

to start to pair back

some of those things

to provide a better UX.

So right now it's rolled out

and to a smaller value

than the final value is.

So I believe we rolled it out

to a SwapperCloud maximum value

of 50k rune, which means

it would apply up to a swap

with the value being 50,000 rune.

Or how exactly do these caps work

in relation to like the rollout

of SwapperCloud and scaling it up

to what the bug bounty is?

Yeah, so the, on any particular

outbound, you can, you have

like a clout number.

Say your clout number is 200k rune,

just for the sake of discussion.

Any one particular outbound

could only use 50k of that 200k.

So you can use the full 200k,

you know, in a short period of time

if you had, you know, four transactions,

four outbound transactions,

but you couldn't use it all

in one transaction.

And so the original intention,

at least how I was thinking about

was just to have the outbound,

this kind of cap be the same

as the bug bounty,

which makes logical sense.

But I think like once we've launched,

now we will launch

the SwapperCloud concept,

we can now look on chain

to see like are we even using the 50k?

Or even like, does it make even,

are we actually getting anything

50 or whatever it is?

And so I think what I'm just doing is,

and I think Orion,

who's also in the audience here,

will help me with is that,

you know, maybe in about a week's time

or two weeks time,

we'll do an analysis

and we'll do two things.

One is to figure out how often,

how frequently are we hitting

that 50k cap

and out of, you know,

that's percentage wise.

And then the second thing we want

to analyze is how much,

how much effect is SwapperCloud

having on the upbound queue?

How much is it reducing on average

or either as an average or as a median?

How is it reducing the time delay

of the delayed outbound?

And so we can compare like,

you know, last week to this week

and, you know, see the differences,

like see how much of an improvement

on the average time that swaps

are waiting to be sent out.

I'm just going to wait like a week or two

and just kind of let the network

collect some data

and then I'll probably work with Orion

to do some analysis around it.

Yeah, but so far,

just based on the swaps

that we've looked at,

the majority of the ones

that are getting stuck for,

you know, up to an hour

in the scheduled outbound queue

are ones that would not

have benefited from any higher

of a cloud limit.

Meaning those are just like new wallets

making large swaps through,

you know, they basically haven't

transacted before

so they're not even eligible

for the Swapper cloud.

So, yeah, I mean,

we'll just have to collect some data

and see whether it even needs

to be raised higher than it is.

Correct, it may not need it,

but we'll make that decision

based upon what the data tells us.

I have two quick questions

around the Swapper cloud.

Just so we can get some perspective,

if I'm doing a $1,000 swap,

$1,000 rune, say, of value in a swap,

how much cloud am I getting?

Is it just depending on the volume

that I sent through

or is it strictly depending on?

Chad, I think a good way

to answer the question would be,

how much do you need

to have swapped through

store chain for your transaction

to bypass the security measure

for a $1,000 swap?

Maybe that's a good way to phrase it.

Well, the Swapper cloud number

increases with the amount of fees

you're paying in the trader swap.

So if you're doing a $1,000 swap

and you're paying five bips,

it's that five bips

that's increasing your number.

So in order to get to that point

where you're doing a $1,000,

whatever, you'd have to make

that trade, what is it?

50 times or something?

What is that?

Not 50 times, it's 400 times?

Is that the number is?

Something like this?

About 400 times?

Something like that.

$100,000 through store chain

from an address

that we've seen before.

We don't follow your outbound.

Is that fair?

Yes, that's fair.

But it also matters

what the fees you pay.

Because if you do a streaming swap,

obviously you'll pay less than fees.

And by doing so,

you get less of a swap.

You get less cloud for that.

If you did a non-streaming swap,

you did like a regular swap.

Obviously, you'll pay more in fees,

in which case your swap or cloud is greater.

So you could do it.

Instead of doing 400 times,

you could do it maybe 200 times

if you just paid more in fees.

Yeah, I'll be right back here.

Continue on.

Also brought up Alfonso here.

Are you there?

Hello, yes.

How are you, my friends?

Two questions.

The first one is,

when Thor USD will be available for everyone?

The second one is,

what is the possibility to put Luna and USD

again in the protocol?

So for the first question,

my intention is to,

it's not called Thor USD,

it's called Tor, by the way, T-O-R.

But my personal intention,

this is my personal opinion,

is to let Tor kind of operate

for six to 12 months,

which has already been about

six months so far.

But let it operate for six to 12 months,

let it kind of show how effective the peg is

so we can kind of,

as much as we can,

prove to the community of its viability.

And then we'll do an ADR vote on it,

right, and the community will vote it down

or vote it up,

whichever direction it chooses to vote it.

Yeah, before we even get to that point,

I would like to see more chains,

more reliable chains,

with more USD-based assets on Thor chain

before we even consider that.

And also, we should make some tweaks,

like, for example,

we should pause minting

or redeeming of Tor

when there's any less than

two or three pools in the Tor peg,

and sorry, in the Tor anchor pool.

I think one thing we noticed recently

when there was a number of chain halts,

we had both Ethereum and Avax halted,

and so the only USD anchor asset

that was available

was a single pool,

and people were still able to mint and redeem Tor

using just a single pool

to provide that peg.

So I think obviously that's undesirable.

I would like to see at least six stable coins

across four different unique chains

with proven reliability

before we release Tor.

I think Tor is one of those things

that can greatly benefit the network,

but it should only be launched

once we're certain that we can keep all the chains live

constantly.

It's good that we recently went through

a lot of these growing pains,

which were the result of record transactions

we put on chains like Avax and BSC,

because those kind of forced us

to meet those scaling challenges.

So right now we're once again

in a hardening phase

where the work we're doing now

around stability

will actually impact our ability

to ship features like Tor in the future.

I think I agree with Pluto

in the sense of adding more chains would be good.

The more anchors we have to Tor,

the stronger the peg is,

the stronger the token is,

the more reliable it is.

I'm not sure I'd agree with the thing

of like having a minimum of two or three.

It's actually, at least in my view,

it's perfectly fine to have it down to one.

We had the BSC the other day

because Avax and ETH were both paused.

Whenever you pause trading,

those get dropped from the kind of calculation

for obvious reasons.

But also what happens

is the depth of the Tor pool also goes down.

So usually it's around 6 million in depth.

And during that time,

it was down close to two,

which means that the fees

are going to be higher, right?

It's harder to price manipulate

because the fees are going to be much higher.

And in the calculation of the depth of that,

even the sub-calculation

of that depth of starting at two,

and it can be one and a half

or one or less than one million

based upon the volume

relative to the depth of the pool.

So it should be fine and safe

even to do a single asset.

Obviously, you don't want to sustain

that for long periods of time

for obvious reasons

because you don't want that one token

to be like BSC to suddenly de-peg

for it's on its own

and cause an issue.

But even if that did happen,

you would just have the community

come together

and use operational amirs

to just pause that particular anchor

as well until it's recovered.

So I think it's fine

to have one or two assets in general,

but not for a long term.

It's healthier for the protocol

to have more anchors.

Oh, and the other question,

yeah, second question too.

The second question about

when do we get Luna UST

back on Thorching?

I mean, I don't,

there's not much talk about that

and it doesn't seem to be there

might be much demand or interest

to add it back,

to be honest with you.

So I'm open to any chain

more or less,

but there has to be a demand for it.

I certainly wouldn't put that

in front of like Solana

or something like this,

but I don't know.

I'm open to pretty much any chain

as long as it's going to contribute

value to the protocol.

Cool, let's keep it moving

because I got a cop here pretty soon.

But if I would just say one thing

before we continue on any further,

you know, there was,

there's obviously probably

a lot of you joining here today

because you've seen a lot of stuff

on Twitter, etc.

Just want to catch everyone up

who's just joining

basically on the current state of things

right now in the Thorchain community

is basically to say that

the devs agree that

all of the proposals to Thorify

and Savers and POL

and Thorchain economics in general

are still all in early draft.

So, you know,

there's going to be plenty

of other discussion that happens

before those are taken to a vote

for the node operators.

Savings and lending are,

you know, here to stay

for the time being.

And we acknowledge that

there's a community sentiment

towards gradually scaling

those features

and managing the risk of Thorify

and our top priorities

in terms of like new things are

just anything that really

can result in more stability

or a better swapping experience.

So we just recently spoke

about Swapper Cloud.

We have memo list transactions

coming down the pipe

and order books as well.

So those things are obviously

taking precedent right now

because those are the things that

benefit the core functionality

of the project,

which is, of course,

cross-chain swaps.

But as always,

performance and stability

remain as the top priority.

So just felt the need to,

you know, clarify that

since there's been

a lot of question as to,

you know, what the future

of Thorchain is

and the answer is always

it will continue to evolve

as devs and the community

engage in passioned

and heated debate.

But in the immediate thing,

we remain laser focused

on all of the things

I just mentioned.

Let me ask you a question,

Pluto, because I'm curious

to hear your perspective.

What are your,

what's your feelings

on the idea of perpetuals?

Not that I'm saying

we're going to do this or whatever,

but I'm just curious

to your high-level viewpoint on it.

Yeah, I mean,

I think it's hard to deny

like what it does

for the economics of the project.

And, you know,

we're all seeing the headlines

right now about DYDX,

you know, surpassing volume

of Uniswap.

But I think those comparisons

are kind of silly

because perpetuals

don't create spot volume,

which is what everyone else

is measuring

and what, you know,

creates the most fees.

They're capturing

leveraged volume.

So, you know,

it's kind of like apples to oranges.

I don't think that perps,

like, as in the same way,

I don't think that

any of the four or five features

are needed

for the success of door chain.

I don't think perps

would be crucial.

But I do think if they're designed

in smart ways,

I think all of these things

like tour and perps

can have really outsize impacts

for the protocol.

So I know I like them.

I know that, you know,

I mean, I trade them.

I'm a DJEN as well.

Like, I think it's fun to,

you know,

or long things in size sometimes,

even when I don't actually have

my size is not size,

but it makes the purpose

make me feel like I have size.

So I think they're just fun.

I think they create

a lot of engagement

and they obviously generate

a lot of fees.

And that's, you know,

anything that we can build

that can generate more fees

for the protocol

is obviously a plus.

We just have to make sure

we just have to figure out

how to do them, you know,

in a smart way.

Like, DYDX works

because their matching

and liquidation engine

happens off-chain.

And I haven't seen any way

that they're going to be able to

basically, it's just very complex.

Like, perps, I think,

is computationally

just very intensive.

Like, you have to look

at a lot of different things.

So I would love to just

kind of see how the DYDX story

unfolds and, you know,

see if it's even possible

to do those efficiently

on Thorchain

and not have the possibility

for, you know,

liquidations happening

out of a band.

Because things happen faster than,

things happen faster

in crypto markets

than in the actual

Thorchain blockchain,

block time itself.

So, like, I don't,

I think it still remains

to be clear

as to whether there's anyone

that can even do, like,

cross-chain perps

without, like, a separate oracle,

like, a separate

off-chain oracle engine.

Yeah, I think

perps would create

more fees on the protocol,

which is obviously

a positive thing,

more trade volume,

which is obviously

a positive thing.

Most likely, and we haven't really,

we don't really have a design

for perps.

We have some ideas

we've kind of thrown out,

but we don't really have an

actual fully articulated

concept quite yet.

But there's been talk

about how the base asset

of perpetual is to be

basically Tor, right?

So you're always against

going against a stablecoin

in one direction or the other.

And by doing that,

you're creating a demand center

for Tor, right?

And by doing that,

you're creating a demand

center for buying

and burning room,

which is similar to what

lending does.

So it's an interesting concept,

and I don't really know

how I feel about it.

I mean, I feel very mixed

about it myself in some ways,

and I wouldn't really have

a strong opinion to do it

or to not to do it

until I've seen a proposal,

a detailed proposal

of how that would be done

or implemented

before I can actually

make any final decisions

or viewpoints on that.

But of course,

I'm not even going to be thinking

about that personally for,

you know, maybe not until

the second half of 2024.

So it's not even on my radar

at the current one,

but it's an interesting concept

and I was curious

to get your viewpoint on it.

Yeah, totally.

I think it's one of those things

that like, you know,

if we can get months of,

you know, up time

and 100% availability

of all the connected chains

of the chain

and we can add more chains

and we can ship

all the other features

that we've talked about.

I think that would then

be a good time

to start those discussions

up again.

But I think at the moment

discussing it just feels

like, you know,

there's better things

to spend our time on.

What do you think,

Ken?

I'm so curious.

This scenario,

I have absolutely no idea

about like I don't,

I'm not a user of perps.

I know very little about them.

So no comment.

All right, anything else

to talk about?

I think we could be,

we could be good for today.

So I mean, it's good

having good having everyone on.

And yeah, it's important

to keep the flow of information

going in the right direction.

So I like, I like coming

on doing these spaces

and talking with the community

because then we can kind of like,

I don't know,

I feel like everyone gets

kind of out of whack

when everyone just like

talks in discord

and it seems chaotic

because everyone's kind of

talking out of band

but we have these like

organized things

and we kind of

put things into a structure

a little bit

and we can realign

around what's important

which is like the near term

priorities of stabilization

and the things that we want

to do in the near term

like order books,

swap or clout,

trade accounts,

that kind of stuff.

So that's going to take up

a couple months of time.

And then before we know,

we'll be thinking about this stuff

and we'll hopefully,

we'll have some better ideas

and a better picture

of where we want to take things

and to keep making this protocol

safe and keep scaling things up,

scaling up volume.

Things have been going crazy

for the last couple of months.

So I mean,

no big complaints over here

seeing how many million dollar

swaps come through

on a daily and weekly basis

with that would have been

the biggest swap in our history

just about six months ago

and now it's like a daily thing.

So I think it's going to

get even better

with rapid swaps

and limit orders and things.

But yeah, man.

I'll just take them a moment

to just plug like,

I think what could be

the most bullish thing,

the most bullish signal

in the entire time

that I've been with this project,

which is that one affiliate

in particular

is about to cross $1 million

in affiliate fees generated

in less than a month.

And that is just I think

a crazy thing that

we always knew affiliate volume

was going to be a major driver

of new integrations

to the platform.

But ever since that got turned on,

the amount of interest we've seen

in integrating Thorchain

has been very, very positive.

So I just think that

as more integrations come online

and as real dollars

start to flow to these businesses

and they continue to provide

the useful utility

of cross-chain swaps

that we're going to see

a ton of more positive metrics

heading in the right direction.

So it seems like

this is kind of just the beginning.

And when that particular affiliate,

it was really this time last year

that they turned on swaps

and it's really been

almost a year in the making

getting their affiliates turned on.

But now that they are

and the money is flowing,

a lot of people are starting to notice.

So it's a really, really awesome thing to see.

Yeah, that's actually a fantastic marker

and it's going to motivate

other integration partners

to get going

and get integrated

because it's very profitable.

Yeah, if we're not doing

10x the daily volume

that we're doing today

by this time next year,

I will go on livestream

and eat an entire shoe.

See, I was hoping you were going to go

the, you know, John McAfee wrote

and say you're going to eat your own dick, but

I'll settle for a shoe, I guess.

As long as it's seasoned

with your tears, Chad.

Nice and salty.

I think you got enough salt

in there already, to be honest.

Think about it.

Oh, yeah.

Nice.

All right.

Well, this has been really fun, guys.

I'm glad we all jumped on

and, you know,

as tight as tensions can run sometimes,

you guys can obviously tell

that we're, you know,

we're generally aligned on everything

and we are just a very passionate

group of people who love

discussing DeFi

and the all things store chain.

So thanks to everyone

who joined today

and, you know, got to hear

a little bit more about, you know,

what the plans are

and the state of play of things.

Yes, sir.

So our biggest space in a while.

I think I saw like 250 people

on here at one point,

which is like pretty crazy.

So let's keep doing it.

Oh, by the way,

a couple of us are going to be

at EAT Denver.

I know I'll be there.

Chad will be there.

I'm sure some other

thrower Chads will be there.

So we should definitely,

you know, be looking forward

to some kind of meetup

or just something at EAT Denver

because I'm sure a lot of people

from the community will be there.

So if you're in town,

then just look out for some tweets

about where people are going to be

because we'll definitely,

you know, have to make

some kind of appearance there.

Yeah, 100%.

I'll be there.

Let's do it.

All right, sounds good.

I'll post this on RSS

and you know, Apple podcast,

Spotify, wherever you get your podcast,

you can you can sign up to,

you know, subscribe to

door chain weekly live

is the name of it.

So if you search that

or your podcast,

you should see it.

And sounds good.

Well, see you guys

whenever we do the next base.

Base.

There you guys.

### Host

- [THORChain](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/thorchain.md) from [Thorchain](https://alphagrowth.io/thorchain.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/THORChain)

### Speaker

- [Chad Barraford](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/chad-barraford.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/CBarraford)
- [logan shippy](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/itsloganshippy.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/itsloganshippy)
- [Can Gurel](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/can-gurel.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/CannnGurel)
- [Pluto (9R) ⚡️🇺🇦](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/pluto9r.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/Pluto9r)
- [Olivier Leprohon](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/olivier-leprohon.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/ol3gpetrov)
- [cryptofunded](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/fundedcrypto.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/FundedCrypto)
- [Eric Culverson](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/ericdanks2.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/EricDanks2)
- [FOX McCloud](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/foxy_mcfoxface.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/FOXY_McFOXface)
- [Tunay](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/tuchkata.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/tuchkata)
- [DrCrypto](https://alphagrowth.io/spaces/participant/dr_cryp.md)
  [X profile](https://twitter.com/dr_cryp)

## Want more TVL for your protocol or chain?

AlphaGrowth grows TVL for protocols and chains through asset acquisition and integration, grants, incentives and LP deals. We built this data and keep it free.

[How we grow TVL](https://alphagrowth.io/defi/index.md) [Talk to AlphaGrowth](https://alphagrowth.io/contact-us/index.md)
