---
title: "XTalks: Interoperability in DeFi | Twitter Space Kaydı | AlphaGrowth"
description: "2024-01-16 tarihli Twitter Space Kaydı, katılanlar: LayerOneX, bryancolligan, Karnika E. Yashwant (Mr. KEY), ULTRADE, Pulsr, YE, Cohost, Anish Mohammed, SuperSight 🥽, Margaret Rosenfeld, Abrayadh, Andrew Lubahn, CryptoNaut22, Jonathan"
url: "https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/xtalks-interoperability-in-defi"
---

# XTalks: Interoperability in DeFi

Kaydedildi: Jan 16, 2024 Süre: 1:16:10

## Space kaydı

[Orijinal Space’i aç](https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1MnxnMOaanjJO)

0:00 1:16:10

### Tam transkript

good morning

good afternoon

depending on whichever part of the world you are in

we are going to start this event very soon

and we are just waiting on a few of our guests

and then we'll soon kick this one off

just a quick sound check can everyone hear me

I can hear you

awesome

I can hear you as well loud and clear

perfect

while we're waiting I'll go ahead and just kind of introduce ourselves

welcome everybody to episode 10 of XTalks powered by Layer One X blockchain

thank you for listening in and being here

we're excited to have you

my name is Cody I'm the chief experience officer at Layer One X

a Layer One blockchain and I will be your host for today's episode

while we while we're waiting I just want to remind everybody that

to mark your calendars we have an episode 11 of XTalks coming up on the 19th of January at 1am UTC

so you don't want to miss that one as we're going to be diving into the web3 gaming space

in regards to interoperability current problems and solutions that may come from implementing interoperability in there

so like we mentioned let's just wait for a few minutes to make sure we've got everybody on board

and then we'll get going

I think while we wait for our guests to hop in

I'll just share a few details regarding us Layer One X

and the things that are going over at our discord

we do have a few competitions some marketing campaigns and stuff like that

where you can win amazing prizes such as Layer One X tokens and stuff like that

so if you are keen or interested on checking us out

we have the link to our discord in our bio

so make sure you check that out hop into our server and say hi

Cody, would you like to give us any opening statements before we dive deep into the questions?

Yeah, for sure

so I think this is going to be a great topic today

just because of the technology that we're talking about

you know, Bridgeless Interoperability and its potential to rewrite the finance rules as we know them

I think that it'll be a great discussion on whether or not it'll become truly

DeFi will become truly decentralized

or it could basically help power entities in the current space capitalize on

and grow their control

so I think that that'll be a couple of good questions to go down

you know, I think it's going to be good to kind of see if there's some kind of a reputation that DeFi has

if we're going to be able to overcome that

if interoperability will play a part in that

so yeah, I say let's dive in and let's get going

so before we do, let's do some quick little introductions

thanks everybody that's on our panel today

we're excited to have you

if you wouldn't mind please just taking a second to introduce yourselves

and give us your 30 second elevator pitch, that would be great

Brian Culligan, Alpha Growth founder

basically deployed over 200 grants in the crypto space

connecting projects and chains and bridging interoperability is a rad topic

got heavily into DeFi with Sushi

and currently running the BD and marketing for the compound protocol

Hello everyone, this is Abraiad from NaBloFi

I'm the community manager at NaBlo

very much interested in DeFi and real world assets

thanks for having me on the stage

Hey guys, this is Henry

we're from Composable Finance

we also have a protocol called Picasso

that is doing restaking and bringing IBC to Solana

and has already brought IBC to Polkadot, to Kusama, to Cosmos

and now we're in testnet for Ethereum to Cosmos and then soon to Solana

I also wear another hat as a partner of Fundamental Labs

which is a well-known VC based out of Singapore

we've been around since 2016

Hey guys, I am Ki here and I live in Dubai

I am the founder of Forward Protocol

which is a drag and drop no code solution for DAP deployment

that works across 800 chains and it's salary revenue positive

and we are soon hitting the market, the product is live

apart from that, we are running an accelerator

and a fund in Dubai, Key Difference Labs and Key Difference Capital

so our whole ecosystem is focused on bringing web 2 businesses to web 3

I've been 10 years in the world of blockchain

played multiple roles across the space

from leading crypto news media giants as CMO

to helping founders market and go live and so on and so forth

so super excited to be in the space today

Hey guys, it's Andrew Lubon

I'm joining from Pulsar.ai

We're the business development hire there

business development executive

I've been in space for a long time

some angel investing, was CEO of an NFT marketplace

before that was professional athlete

but now I'm in the space for a long time

I've been in the space for a long time

I've been in the space for a long time

before that was professional athlete

but now I'm bringing out and growing the ecosystem at Pulsar

we scrape all of the NFT marketplaces and all the chains

and then make it searchable using our AI for keyword search and personalized search

Hey everyone, can you hear me?

Yes sir, louder here

All right, it's finally working

Sorry, I've been having a little issues as always with the Twitter spaces

I'll jump in with a quick intro

I'm Dan Goldman, founder and CEO of AllTrade

In a nutshell, AllTrade is one of the world's first

bridge-less cross-chain order book DEXs

It's a new trading technology that's coming finally to the market

to enable you to trade like you would in a centralized exchange

with all the capabilities and UX

but completely non-custodially

with shared liquidity across all 12 plus chains

that we support with no bridging

which I believe is relevant to what we're going to be talking about today

and not only that, AllTrade is what we call DeFi as a service infrastructure

which means anyone, any project can actually launch the entire platform

and provide branded cross-chain trading services to their users

self-list their own token for trading

reducing their reliance on centralized exchanges for listings

and basically create a global network of exchanges that work together

but each of them actually has its own brand

earns their own trading fees, self-lists their token

and create a new way for trading in the market

that is non-custodial with order books across many, many chains

I'll take the opportunity

Hey everyone, this is Jonathan

I'm a guardian of nabla.fi

nabla is a upcoming next generation AMM

we're doing away with impermanent loss and a lot of other cool things

so hopefully that is interesting

and yeah, I've been involved with crypto a lot

going way back over 10 years

yeah, I've been browsing a lot of ecosystems

have been coming from the polka.ecosystem

and now back in the EVM space

so yeah, excited to be here today

thanks for having me

Hey guys, I'll take the opportunity here

my name is Jay, I'm one of the co-founders of SuperSight

we're building crypto-specific large language models

so on the on-chain side we firstly let you search

you can search things like

who bought X and Y NFT, who are the top 10 traders

and somewhere like GMX, who bought LIDAR between these prices in the last 30 days

and then there's the off-chain side as well

you know, what is account structure and what are ZK proofs

and then both of those worlds come together

when you search something like

why did the price of board apes go down

and on the on-chain side it might be that two people sold 15

on the off-chain side it might be that

there was a negative news piece around the founders

so that's what we're doing

been in the space since 2017

super pumped for this

thank you for bringing us on layer one

so I think those are all of the introductions

or am I missing someone, Cody?

I'm just going down through the list

I think that's everyone

we might have a few stragglers here and there

but as they come on just kind of watch for them

and we'll give them an opportunity

to give us our 30 second elevator pitch

but in the meantime for the sake of time

let's just jump in and start talking about today's topic

so interoperability and DeFi

can they go hand in hand together

that's the questions that we're going to be proposing

and it sounds like we've got a lot of great experts

in the DeFi space joining us today

and yeah so let's get going

if you do have any questions for our panelists

just make sure that you drop those in the comments

Sam will be looking for those

and he'll get those promoted to us

so that we can answer those questions for you

so the first topic kind of breaking them down

into a couple of different sections

the first section I want to talk about today is

DeFi's future and the power dynamics behind what you view

will be happening in 2024 and beyond with DeFi

and the first question I guess is based around

decentralization versus control

will interoperability help basically

democratize the DeFi space

or will it empower existing entities

to basically grow their control

and they're capitalized on new opportunities

to control their user base

not directed towards anybody

so if you want to jump in on that question go ahead

can you maybe clarify what you mean by control

in other words since you're mentioning decentralization

and DeFi etc are we thinking about control

in terms of market share, walled gardens,

keeping the users in a specific application

versus the decentralization of certain apps versus not

yeah exactly that's exactly what I'm talking about

just gain in market share, gain over regulatory control

it could be government, it could be specific individuals

it could be different projects

just kind of seeing where the conversation will go from there

well let's say what

the gorillas in the market

the 10,000 pound gorillas

once they have a new technology they can utilize

it is certainly easier for them to further grow

they can utilize these new technologies

and they have a huge user base

so it's easy for them to utilize a new technology

and gain more market share

or cement their grasp on the market

so a Uniswap or whatever

one of the big boys can certainly find ways to utilize these new technologies

and keep a grasp on their user base

and for newcomers obviously things are more difficult

to penetrate the market

so I'm trying to think where do you want to go with this

because that's a pretty clear thing

if they find a way to utilize a new technology to improve their offerings

they will probably do so

I think to jump in here

the moment we talk about this we need to divide this into two layers

I can see those two layers emerging in the world of DeFi

so one obviously as you said

we would have more and more big players trying to use the existing products

improvise and consolidate

but DeFi to me is not products

DeFi to me is a layer of yield generation

or layer of opportunities, financial opportunities

so I'm thinking about more and more new innovative products coming on

the layer of DeFi

which works across multiple chains

or not it's up to them

but they're creating different interesting financial models

of earning higher returns, higher yields and so on

and the second layer which is emerging layer

which I can only notice from quarter 3 of 2023 to be prominent

is the application layer which is focused on traditional or general users

public who are not on the crypto side

who don't fully understand or can use our way directly

I mean if they can use our way directly they would rather use it

but they don't

it's similar to how you have liquids taking coins

instead of just going and running your own node

so it's having further layers of simplicity that groups things

like if you are using Binance and you're part of Binance Earn

you see that a lot of DeFi products are grouped there

you don't know what products they are

you just go put your money in, it's simple

you park the money there, it's even automatic

but then they go around, use various DeFi products out there

to make it work and you don't know what other chains they're using out there as well

so I can see that layer coming in

more and more of those wallets, simplified solutions

alternative saving solutions and real world assets

playing a key role towards this

people launching RWA based products

which uses a way to park the ideal capital on DeFi

on a safe way, simple lending and borrowing protocols

but they also do have their own asset classes

and their own internal DeFi based on the asset classes

based on validated liquidity and so on

so it's a new layer or new sub-sectors because DeFi is growing

it's growing with on one side permission, blockchains

and serious government business, regulated business on the other side

innovative mechanisms, yield mechanisms on the third

it's a combination, new ways of leveraging yields based on existing tools

so these apps are a beautiful layer that's up and coming

they're purely a connector, like a middleware

that connects DeFi to a user who needs simplicity

and I think we need to take into consideration all these different layers and angles as well

Perfect, thanks for sharing

I see we've got a couple of hands up

just feel free to jump in into the conversation

Sure, I think the biggest...

Go ahead, Brian, you were before me

You got it, you got it

Yeah, I would just add

I think the interesting way and interesting way to frame this

is the monsters, the big players, the gorillas

is just the amount of capital

whether it's the Boomer capital or Web2 capital

or those who have not really entered the space yet

it's still a massive group, right?

So I think the fascinating thing is how DeFi protocols

how new ways of generating new products

kind of interact with this massive group

if we can bridge all of this, let's call it Boomer capital

or traditional capital that hasn't entered Web3 yet

I think there's a lot to be said about how it's going to be regulated

is what is DeFi?

I think the law, unfortunately, at the moment

doesn't really have a clear way to say

who can custody what, how do we frame it, how do we package it,

how do we interpret it

I think this is really the key innovation

now the bigger players and gorillas in the crypto space

have to figure out and they have to find a way to bring

a lot of those players into the space

but DeFi still is kind of run by some of these bigger players

some degens and it's still being

productized in a palatable way that then can bring

a lot of this capital into the space

but it will be fascinating to watch

and I think there's still plenty of room for innovation

it's the class of innovators dilemma of

who is going to productize these

and then how are we going to make it palatable

for these bigger players into the space

Totally, it's a giant question on decentralization versus centralization

Two key points that I think are kind of a little bit counterparty

to what most people talk about in crypto

is a lot of people say, hey, we need a better UI UX for

to bring the next million users, next billion users

and I think that you have security

and you have rational self-control

and really in a good UX

and the easier it is to access something

and the better UX it has, the less security it has

so when you're talking centralization versus decentralization

what you're talking about is the blend of security and UX

at the core because the easier it is to use

the easier it is to ape in and supply liquidity

the easier it is for somebody to take it from you

the harder, the more security that you have

and the harder it is for somebody to hack your wallet

I think that's kind of one of the conversations

on centralization versus decentralization

the whole point of decentralization is that nobody can take it

as soon as you get to more centralized interfaces

you don't have radical self-reliance and total control over your assets

and so I think that's one point around centralization versus decentralization

the other thing coming from the compound angle

what I've seen in the markets

we're going to these other centralized exchanges

and yield-bearing constructs

from more traditional financial centralized exchanges

and saying, hey, what can we do with you together at Compound

and saying, hey, bro, we don't need you anymore

your code's been out there in open source for almost four years

we're going to launch our own protocol and internalize it

and just use the code that you guys built

unless you have something more for us

we already have all the distribution

we already have all the TVL

we don't need you in your protocol anymore

so there's another angle here of who has the distribution pipeline of users

whoever has the distribution pipeline of users

can streamline and verticalize what protocols that they use

and how centralized or decentralized they want to have it

so I think those are the two balances between centralization and decentralization

is one, security, and then the second part is

whoever owns the users owns the flow, owns the trade flow

and whoever owns the trade flow owns the yield

yeah, I think from this security standpoint

I would say we already have a bunch of products that are already coming out

to help with the security in the DeFi space

we have products like WalletGuard

and Revolt.Cache and a bunch of other security products

products that are coming

but the most important thing is

trying to make sure that during the onboarding process

of people to the DeFi space

they tend to go through this part of the security first

before they can even think of interacting with these protocols

and from the interoperability standpoint

I would look at it in terms of the liquidity providing

since I work with an AMM project

and what I see interoperability doing in AMMs is

it's going to allow creation of cross-chain liquidity poles

which can increase the efficiency of trading

and reducing transaction cost in general

Perfect, I saw a couple of extra hands up

if you want to jump up

if not I'm moving on to kind of a follow-up question

Thanks everybody, those are some great insights to think about

when it comes to how interoperability can play

how DeFi, what's facing DeFi

some problems and some solutions as well

One of the things that we were kind of battling with with DeFi

is that it's unfortunately earned a negative reputation

for being full of scammers, pump and dump schemes, developer rug pulls

and these are coming from the eyes of many new crypto investors

as well as non-crypto investors

Do you think that we can overcome the security issues

basically this negative connotation that has kind of started building around DeFi

do you feel that we can overcome this reputation?

I personally believe that overcoming the reputation is not

there's no one straight answer to this because it's a community developed one

everyone complained about not having the freedom

well you have a freedom right now but it comes with responsibility

and that responsibility means education

does it require everyone to learn the code to be able to read and function

well that's what blockchain is made for with the smart contracts

we call it smart contracts, it's transparent

it's not transparent unless someone cannot read and understand it

but that's the fact

this is the language it speaks and this is the nature of how it works

which is why you have tools out there which are crowdsourcing security

where multiple entities test something and they can display ratings

to show what is safe, what is not safe

but there's a lot of complexity you could say something is safe

but it's not the same contract linked on the application when you're using it

the issues will exist and the only way to circumvent that

is to have that layer that deals with the challenges

by removing it away from the users like those centralized applications

or user focused applications even if it's non-custodial

but still its app that simplifies the journey on behalf of the user

where the application is responsible to choosing the right

DeFi protocol, the right contract and right interaction and so on

so someone has to do the job

the freedom was asked and the freedom was given

but someone has to still take care it's the right thing

and they need to choose the ones with the right liquidity

constantly be aware if some new vulnerability is released and deal with it

so unless that is taken care of I mean it's not that easy

it's not just about DeFi applications

we know that stablecoins can go crazy at times

so it's not just about okay I have a great amount of USDC

parked in this particular place is it safe no USDC, USDT, BUSD

none of those matter end of the day what you use

can all be subject to troubles

so being that cautious full-time focused on managing these assets

there's a job and someone has to do that if you want that full freedom

otherwise you do use other tools

middlewares or applications that simplify that for you

but someone has to do that it's not going to happen by itself

and the scams and the challenges I don't think they will go away

and I don't think blockchain is even meant for them to go away

because it's about freedom right you could go deploy something yourself tomorrow

and delete it I mean remove it or stop take the liquidity out of it

it's your choice it's your wallet it's a public blockchain

you can deploy anything in any name and do whatever you want with it

it's called as a scam or rug pull from the perspective of the other player

maybe someone was just playing with it

there's been so many different apps out there

where they did say things along the lines

it's completely a alpha software and there's no guarantee

warranty use it if you like with the risk

so I believe the solution is that new layers of products being developed

someone dealing with that to ensure that the end user are protected

and if the end user go ahead to a point where they want the highest level of protection

probably there'll be banking products out there

which will leverage DeFi in the future

and help with the lending borrowing yields

it's not too far I mean if you have Bitcoin and Ethereum

starting to trade on all those NASDAQ and exchanges

it's not going to be too far for DeFi products integrated into banking

sure it could be probably the safest one if you can wait for another few years

perfect thanks for sharing

so I kind of want to jump back to something that I believe it was Brian that mentioned

it's a balance between security and UX and blending it at its core

do you feel that we can have our cake and eat it too in the sense of providing good user experience

and keep our users safe when it comes to security

so I'm not a security expert so I can't really kind of totally answer that question

but I know building other kind of payment apps and web 2

and what we found was the easier it's access to the capital

the easier it is to get the capital out the easier it is to kind of become hackable

so I think it's a feature and not a bug

so people think like the UX and DeFi and wallets right now is a bug

and I actually think it's a feature

the more levels of security and keys and ledger that you have

the harder it is to get in and out of your capital

it's annoying as heck to have OP positions and voting on OP positions with a multi-sig

but at some certain point you have to have that layer of security at some value

so no then the opposite is true too

we're working with a client that has a wallet integrated in with Telegram

and that wallet that's integrated with Telegram

if you get your Telegram hacked they basically have access to your wallet

so obviously I'm not going to put anything more than a couple thousand dollars in that wallet

but now I have a Telegram wallet with pocket change kind of walking around with

so I think there's different use cases for different aspects of this

where you need a lot of security

and when you don't need a lot of security depending upon those use cases

the right level of security kind of makes sense

I think it's... go ahead

Sorry, I'm going to have to jump real quick

but I just wanted to kind of share some of the work in the Cosmos ecosystem

with the audience so that everyone can kind of start doing a little bit of research

on the inter-blockchain communication

in terms of I guess cross ecosystem communication protocol

IBC has been driving the most volume out of all

and has been the most stable

and particularly it does not have any trust in multi-sig

and uses like client technology for both chains that they're interacting

and just trusting the consensus and validators on the both chains at the chain level

so we decided to adopt that

and building DeFi on top of the IBC is on the roadmap for us

for both Composable and Picasso

so without understanding kind of the brilliance of the inter-blockchain communication

it's difficult to understand how much better it is

than any other sort of multi-sig solutions for DeFi

so I think in terms of securities it has to be trust minimized

and there's really no other option out there in the market today besides IBC

that is the most battle-tested

and that is the core component of the Cosmos ecosystem

which has been getting a lot of attention in the last several months or so

so just want to encourage everyone to take a look at that

and yeah I'd love to chat more

so thank you for having me, I appreciate it guys

Yeah, thanks for coming by, I appreciate it

so it looks like we just had a person join the stage

I believe it's Margaret

Margaret, do you want to introduce yourself

and just give us your quick 30 second elevator pitch for your project

Hey, hi, I'm Margaret Rosenfeld

and I am with Cube Exchange

we are a platform that combines a DEX with a SEX together

so you have a centralized user experience on the trading platform

but when it comes to custody we have a NPC technology that we built from Xero

and that is a non-custodial vault that we use for it

Perfect, perfect, thank you

Just to kind of take a quick check here real quick

for those that are just joining us

my name is Cody and I'm the host of XTalks AMA today, episode 10

and we're talking about interoperability

and how it will change DeFi forever

so let's continue the conversation

and let's move on to a different kind of area of questions

regarding regulation and user experience

and so one of the questions that I have around that is

as projects begin to develop interoperability into their platforms ecosystems

as we'll just call it, country regulations start taking hold in the DeFi space

and specifically trying to regulate specific chains that projects might be built on

as interoperability gets introduced

do you feel that this is going to be harder for them to regulate

or is it something that will be welcomed and easier for regulators to come in and take hold of?

Yeah, I'm not seeing a whole lot of demand for regulation from the actual user base

I feel like this is much more orchestrated from

well, let's say the political cast to actually get a hold of the web free space

so I don't really feel like anybody is actually in favor of more regulation or added regulation

I feel like most of the things that are already illegal, theft, etc.

would perhaps be covered, I'm not an expert here

but in my mind it should be very similar if you're stealing a digital asset or somebody's car tires

so yeah, I don't really feel like this is going to do the industry good as a whole

and of course, especially with interoperability

if you rely on some messaging from the Ethereum chain to output data on another chain

and regulation is getting in the way of that

well, it kind of messes up your interoperability protocol

but I'm kind of hopeful that regulators will give up rather soon

if Ethereum is getting regulated and therefore is becoming unfeasible to use

well, you might as well fork the chain, use Ethereum Classic

there's of course drawbacks to migrating

but yeah, there is no real final solution for regulators to really put a hold on it

and I'm very hopeful that this will hopefully turn out true

I think they'll just go after the big, the documentaries around this

around the big cases where people did wrong and it was kind of public

they'll carry on going after those people to make an example of them

and obviously the blockchain is very public, there's a history behind there

so anyone who's done a reasonably serious level of crime might be chased after

but equally, if they really wanted to, they could

you're already seeing this in some countries, on-ramps, off-ramps are being affected

but as the industry matures, I think we'll be fine

I think a lot of people will still be able to do what they want

things like ZKs are going to come, they're going to be privacy chains as well

so there's always going to be this use case for people who truly want to be

a bit private, a bit anonymized and not really in the public eye, so to speak

I'm the Chief Legal Officer for Cube Exchange

so I spend a lot of time globally interacting with regulators

and it's only been within the last 18 months

that regulators have wrapped their head around what is Web3

the difference between centralized, decentralized

so throwing into the mix concepts of interoperability when talking with them

they're not even yet at that education level on the technology

at least some places are, and some people within regulators are

but it's just like when we went through the experiences in the late 1990s

through now educating on Web1 and Web2

we had to spend a lot of time going into global regulators

talking to them about what the technologies can do, what they had to be concerned about

so as long as you talk to regulators in their language as much as possible

and know what regulators' missions are

the securities regulator in every country has essentially the same mission

they want to protect the retail investors mainly

they don't worry as much about the institutional, the moms and pops

and so they want to make sure that whatever you're putting out there

is not going to be put out without full disclosure about what it's about

they also are concerned about the financial stability of their geographic market

so they don't want to let something into their market that could harm that stability

and then you have some countries that beyond that are concerned about

non-country entities coming into their market

and it's kind of a nativistic sort of geographic approach

so if you go towards the regulators and you are addressing those things

in how you talk, I think it's helpful but also just be aware that

the technology education and using lots of terms that we

interoperability, centralized, decentralized, consensus, proof of reserves

all of these terms, it's a whole new lexicon to them

and so be aware of that when you walk into them

Thanks for sharing, I think you bring up a lot of good points

in that sense, for us over here at Layer 1X

one of the things that we are definitely trying to do

because we are a bridge-less, true, native interoperability

for not only access to be able to trade, access to TVL

but we're able to basically transact with the passing of logic and data across

meaning that we can have a contract on Ethereum, speak with a contract on Binance

and interact with each other through a single click

and so I think that for us it's all about raising the standard

in the projects that build on us and trying to foster a level of quality

and something that we can try to get behind with the regulatory

as they step in trying to understand the different chains and what they do

our goal is that we don't want to compete with other chains

we definitely want to try to unite them

because I feel like it definitely opens the horizons of opportunity

not only for the blockchains but for the projects that build on them

to be able to tap into new resources, new audiences, new users, that kind of stuff

so with that being said, would regulatory hinder some projects, DeFi projects

using interoperability to tap into other chains

if those chains are being heavily regulated

by government entities or even by the chain itself

would you feel like that would hinder your decision to move to that chain and partake

or do you feel like it is something that you would want to build into your protocol

to help sustain the quality and security of it?

Yeah, I think at Pulsar we're using AI generated search to make an upstream Google search for NFTs

where product ties for different type of DeFi applications

we want to be chain agnostic, so something that we have to be cognizant of

is if we are bridging or sending search results to a specific chain

the fact is, and Margaret pointed it out, the regulators don't even have lexicon

in many cases to say, yes this is legal, no it's not

it's just something that you have to be super wary of

it's a grey area, you can get an opinion from 10 different white shoe law firms

and you can get 10 different opinions

so I think it's still a grey area, it's something that we're trying to navigate

but it's something to be aware of as if your company wants to be involved in this space

You can buy an opinion anywhere

I'd be wary of even the white shoe ones

I was in law firms working in crypto for a long time before I went in house here

and we all know the firms that you can go and get the opinions from

but opinion doesn't protect you from if the regulator comes calling

and it doesn't at all

usually those opinions also have so many caveats and assumptions

they again don't protect you

I think you have to know what you're doing

and do really good diligence on the chains that you are going to interact with

for us, we act as a centralized interoperability layer between chains

kind of like the same function as proofers, reserves, but better

because we never take custody

but the chains that we're going to integrate

and we're in the process, we had our early access launch in November

so we're in the process of integrating chains

we're going through those chains that we are going to integrate with

and we're doing the careful review and diligence on what are they doing

what is the view of them globally

and there are a lot of great chains, the great thing is

there are amazing chains out there that have incredible management

great, great staff that support it in the foundations

and then there are a lot of chains that pop up and we all know them

and you're like, this is going to be a, this is where all the rugs are going to go

come on, and we know it

so I think you have to be aware of that

so one big question I always have is

do you just have interoperability with every single chain

or do we have a responsibility to kind of police ourselves somewhat?

Yeah, I think definitely as you've already said

in terms of being interoperable with every chain

you would have to be very careful with the kinds of chains

you want to have on your protocol or on your project

because definitely as you already said, some chains we already know

the kind of things happening on those chains

those are the chains you don't want to get yourself connected with

because it might also bring the attention of these legal entities

to your product as well since you are interacting with this chain

that has a lot of these rugs

and all these negative stuffs in the blockchain space

and I think it's also not like you want to have this approach

and diligence of who you're interacting with

not just because of the regulatory concerns

but just the concerns of reputation of your own project

and what you're doing as well

Yeah, I would agree with that

I think we have a fiduciary responsibility

you mentioned Margaret before

of basically kind of, I forgot the term you used

but just self-regulation of our own protocol

of our own ecosystem that we develop

and I agree 100%

I think that it starts with the project, individual projects

and then it kind of goes out from there, right?

If we look at that

I think there's also the security risk

going back to what Brian was talking about earlier

with the security and the UX side of it

I think that as we start tapping into these other blockchains

for growth purposes, let's just go down that avenue

we need more users to keep the protocols going

and to have that influx of capital

and with that raises a lot of security risks too

because we've been talking about reputation

but also is that blockchain up to standard

with what kind of level of programming you're doing, right?

And we've seen quite a few different projects

at least I have over my experience of six years in crypto

of just when it comes to DeFi projects

it just seems like a lot of people are

a lot of developers are just taking senior type protocols

and basically forking them and making a copy of them

and taking all the exploits with them

and just being lazy when it comes to that kind of stuff

throwing a new skin on it

and it's a new project, right?

Even though it's the same fork of something else

how do you feel that

how do you feel like we can help change the mentality

of just forking and actually trying to re

or I should say innovate in the space?

I would say the protocols that are building on those chains

it will be their responsibility to really dive deep

when they're doing research on the chains

they want to build on

to ensure that this issue is not associated

with those particular chains

and then when those kind of developers

that are into just forking the chains

and using them when they start seeing that

people are not interested in building on their chains

because of this and this reasons

they would definitely be working towards fixing that up

or the new ones that are building

they would work towards ensuring

they have optimized their chains

to the level where it will be very interesting

and eye catching for all those protocols

and projects to build on.

I also think, are we talking hard forks or soft forks?

We've seen some good hard forks occur

Ethereum back in 2016

but with a soft fork

for the users it's backward compatible, right?

So how do you encourage this?

There are different reasons forks occur

and sometimes it's just management project disagreement

other times there's really good reasons for it happening

so I don't think you can come up with a general philosophy

towards that you have to look at the facts and circumstances

of why a particular fork might be occurring.

So living in the DC area

I think there's two stories I can tell

I was once at a kid's birthday party

and I started talking to somebody

and I was like, yeah, I work in crypto

and they're like, oh, cool

I'm writing the rules and regulations

for the CD VC or whatever

the Central Bank Digital Currency

and I'm like, oh, really? Yeah

and she's like, this is amazing

I never talked to one of you

I was like, what do you mean?

She's like, I never talked to a crypto entrepreneur before

so I think a lot of this stuff on the rules and regulation

it kind of turns out that they're kind of building in a vacuum unfortunately

and I was like really shocked

and we talked for about like an hour

about the different opportunities that were available

and what kind of her take was like

oh, a lot of this stuff is just like scams

and the permissionless nature of things

like allows for too much potential scams and stuff like that

and kind of like where we kind of both agreed and landed on

at the end of the conversation was like

hey, if you want the regulated token

and the regulated chain, cool

like everybody wants to play safe space

great, you can play over here

but at the end of the day

like this is a permissionless protocol

for like 50 bucks, 100 bucks worth of ETH

that can like launch a contract

and I can have like a new financial primitive launched

and maybe it'll work and maybe it won't

so you kind of, regulation definitely does stifle innovation

but you kind of need both, right?

You don't want the grandmas of the world

or people with their entire pension get lost in a rug

but you also need a place where you can have financial innovation

and new DeFi primitives created

without kind of regulatory constriction of it

because the regulatory constriction creates too much capital

it requires too much capital to comply

so you want the Vegas where it's like YOLO

and everybody can go play in a rug

and invent new financial primitives

and you also want kind of like the stable conservative types of DeFi

and that's my opinion and hopefully

and if you kind of constrict everything to regulation

you're not going to get as much financial innovation

so I think there's always a place for both

If I may, I'll give you like a quick summary of what I've observed

I've been in this ecosystem for 12 years now, coming around 12 years

and prior to that I had a day job in normal finance

so regulation I would agree does have a place

and there's a cost of regulation

that's like you could think of two sets of a coin

so regulation increases the cost

and it also suppresses innovation in one sense

so if you were to compare like a typical very large bank

if you look at the fines they pay

the total amount of the gross they spend on complying

by all the compliance regulations is quite high

like you could have like 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 startups

just the amount they spend paying fines

so there's that bit of it

and the other side of it is like how does one get the right kind of behaviors

without going to this rigmarole of

the key I would say is like always regulation catches up with innovation

day one what happens is like whatever innovation happens it happens

and the people in regulation they just wait for it to get to a steady state

and they have enough of time for them to respond

so they would go back to it and kind of come up with a bunch of regulations

that might or might not help

and hopefully if it works it'll be very good

I just wanted to add one other point

that somebody else was speaking about just before me

about forking there is a prime reason

the economic reason why folks seems to always happen

you know a fork whenever it happens irrespective of the outcome on the long run

produces a lot of liquidity for everybody

both on their protocol and the full protocol

and this is definitely an incentive misaligned

this is two things I just wanted to mention

thanks

yes thanks for providing your insight I appreciate it

so just a couple more questions

and then we'll kind of wrap things up here

one of the main focuses as we all know in web 3 is to move to

more decentralization and giving the power back to the users

one of the focuses that we're focused on at layer 1x is also

decentralized digital identities

and being able to provide the power

empowering the user to control their own data

to no matter the chain that they're on

building their digital identities

is this something that you feel is important to implement

in 2024 into DeFi

is the ability to tap into these decentralized identities

that people are trying to establish

I can jump in on this

I believe this is crucial right now

because we are no longer in the early early stage

this is going to be very helpful for people who are hardcore crypto enthusiasts

yes people who are already in there for a couple of years or more

if you go back to 2017 to 2021

yeah sure you had one, two, three, four wallets disposable

you had transactions in them

but you always had one primary wallet

you had a bunch of different applications you interacted with

when I say bunch of them probably it's two dApps that you interacted with

life is simple

but right now every one of us

we not only have few dozens of wallets

because of the history over the period of time

we ended up with more wallets

not every wallet is in MetaMask or the like

there are many which are dedicated

they have their own version

their own way to access it

you have certain things on your mobile app

and then you have a lot of dApps

it's not just one version of the dApp

like take an example of Avi

you have version 2

you have some money there

you have version 3

you have some money there

and on top of a 10 different chains for each of those things

so it's an extremely complex situation

even something as simple as an adsense portfolio

is very helpful where it brings all the different dApps

from all the different chains and consolidates it

to give a perspective

although I don't agree on the user experience of that at this point in time

so with digital identities

it is important to bring that along

in one place combined

so a user at least for a record keeping purpose

knows what they are, who they are

what actually still belongs to them

and their digital footprint in the blockchain space

and the way they want to represent it

because right now it's still fragmented

members with multiple open sea wallets

and different chains where they're participating

it's just very hard for them to represent themselves in a unified way

and these digital identities are a need at this point

not because it's fancy

not because it's a trend

not because it has a major application

it does have a major application moving forward 20, 25 and beyond

but right now it's a matter of necessity

it's a matter of comfort

and something I believe just makes user experience of people

who are in the space long enough much better

May I allow you to talk about the U.S.

Thank you

The concept of digital identity has been around for a while

of we should have that and just in banking

so if you look at banks need to have corresponding bank relationships

with other banks in order to operate throughout the world

and if they don't and you see that issue in the U.S.

for example related to banks that deal in crypto

have trouble getting corresponding banks in the U.S.

and that means therefore they can't really get access

to our payment system in the U.S.

That was the result

and so if you even just take it from a

not even looking at the decentralized digital asset

just like the concept of a digital asset

that can be passported and used by smaller banks etc.

that gets rid of this corresponding bank idea

that would be just one simple step

that would be amazing and change a lot of things

but I do think decentralized identity overall

or digital identity and decentralized

is going to be a major theme for us in 24 and 25

this is how we get to the place of fully decentralized finance

eventually but we can't do that without this decentralized identity

infrastructure being built up

If I may, I just wanted to add a couple of things

As I was saying, I've been a researcher prior to getting into crypto

so in my research days I've done some work on identity schemes

and I've sat on my subcommittee for Group 3 and Group 4

and being in crypto all this year is one of the things I noticed

is that we are going through the same process

we went through in Web 2 for identity schemes

and identity standards

and if you go on Google over a back machine

and see the number of failed identity schemes

it will tell us how much of energy, time and resources were wasted

in trying to get in one sense acceptable identity

and the other part of this thing that we need to recognize is

even though identity schemes were there

there was always some effort spent on having privacy

and I am kind of not sure that the current set of all layer 1s

have the construct of privacy in the right place

in the right order with the right priority

that one needs to understand

it's like in the machine learning world

where there's an arbitrage between people who have access to data

who could run machine learning pipelines

versus people who don't have access to data who could run pipelines

you know who is going to win

and if you were to have an identity scheme

and if you were able to map this back to all the public chains

that is a very interesting scenario

and so whenever we think about identity schemes

we definitely need to rethink the way in which we would create one

how it would interoperate

and what would be the criteria for accepting an identity

so identity in general is like a composition of claims that somebody makes

you can have some fancy cryptographic mechanisms like ZK to create them

but I guess this bridge between the real world and the virtual world

is a challenging one and as far as I can see

we haven't really thought this through

we've had a whole bunch of projects that's coming in

that some of them have succeeded and some have disappeared

if we go forward and we have some schemes

we probably need to spend some time understanding lessons learned

both from web 2 and web 3 and like incorporate those lessons

so we don't end up having more failures and more cycles

where all the data that we have is in public

and all the things like all the upsets and downsides of that sense

Yeah I think you bring up a couple of good points

I know that as we've been educating our communities

on the importance of digital identity

especially evolving into the web 3 space

and taking control of their data

taking control of their web 3 experience and in essence

you know there's been a little bit of pushback

because it's all about the anonymous kind of atmosphere that crypto brings

and so by building out an identity

it does make people feel a little uncomfortable

that they're going to be putting their information out

but I believe that it really boils down to being able to control

being able to in that sense of being able to

having a user be able to share the certain information

that they want to share with specific people

and being able to revoke that access as needed

is going to be paramount

and so with that being said

one of my follow-up questions to that is

I come from a space of the SaaS development world

so software development

and I've seen big companies have absolute control over their user data

and in today's world data is king

it's the currency of web 2

and so as we kind of move towards web 3

do you think that projects, chains, things like that

do you think that we can share the data

and come together in a universal form to form this digital identity

or do you feel that the change will happen as users

begin to take control of their data

and begin allowing different projects, devices, things like that

to utilize their data?

If I may add my two cents

just to be completely clear

I've actually given a talk a very, very long while ago

the title of the talk was

My Identity, Your Service

and literally this is in 2010

you can just google it and find it

and this isn't the identity as a service thing

when the previous speaker was talking about software as a service

this was the kind of thing we had at that point in time

and what has effectively happened is

firstly there has to be incentive alignment

so typically any identity provider

the identity provider bootstrapping

is like the most expensive thing for identity schemes

and somebody has to put their money down

it's a long term game

and the second part is once this is set up

then there's a network effect

the virus that has highest ability to infect people

and don't kill people survives the most

talking of comparing identity schemes to viruses

so this is effectively what's going to happen

so there could be different scenarios

and I don't have a crystal ball

but I've seen what has happened over the years

in various identity schemes

so given you were talking about identities and enterprises

one of the reasons why identities and enterprises

were really, you know

they can lay down what they want

is because first the identity store is completely

owned by the enterprise

if you were to look at your contract

they actually own your data

so then they have the ability to say whatever they want

and then there's this predominance of MS stack

so that could be directory plus other rubbish

plus other people have now started then

so there's Google and their services

all of that they exist

because of this network effect

once you are in this ecosystem

it's easy for you to run federation

so if you are in a Microsoft stack

if you want to interoperate with somebody else

you can turn on federation

and then you can make it work

so the way I'm thinking is like

something similar might happen in the web3 world

one or two of the protocols might gain enough of attraction

so that's a high chance that randomly

if you had to pick one format or a protocol

this would be one of the many

and then because interoperability adds value to everybody

there's some sort of a federation

or bridging or something like that might happen as well

this is my two cents worth

I don't know how it's going to be

no those are some great insights

thanks for sharing

so we are over by about seven minutes

so we'll wrap things up here

thank you for everybody that has joined us today

one last question if you want to jump in

great if not after that we'll just kind of wrap things up

but the question for you guys is

how or what do you feel is going to be

some of the challenges that will need to be overcome in DeFi in 2024

and yeah so if you want to jump in and give your last kind of comments that would be great

yeah I think I'll tack on to the identity in DeFi in 2024

and Segway there

the big conversation that I'm having is really around identity

KYC AML RWAs access because the on-ramps and on-ramps of these things

will require KYC AML and different types of new identity schemes

particularly around RWAs

there's a whole lot of interested parties in getting things on chains

because the concept is if we get these RWAs on chains

more access to capital there's more liquidity in the markets

there's more liquidity in the markets

there's more fun new DeFi primitives that we can build

so in terms of interoperability identity

I think they're absolutely required for real-world assets coming on chain

and I'm excited to hear more solutions around that

and also looking for real-world assets from the context of compound protocol

so if you have a real-world asset and you want to get it listed on compound

please feel free to contact me

we are actively looking as part of our mandate in 2024

I think if you look at the vast majority of DeFi projects

they actually have elements of some centralized control

yeah I would say the biggest challenge is being selective

as an organization, as a startup, as a company

into what chains you're going to work with

how you're going to kind of ensure that those chains are secure

what those bridging protocols are like

and what ultimately you feel comfortable maintaining as a brand for your users

it was a great conversation about the legal ramifications

but the reality is as innovators in this space

we are upstream of the regulators

so the decisions we're going to make have to be vetted internally

have to be self-governed as an industry

and first as a leader of your company

and from there you can make a decision that you feel good about your end users

so I think it's going to be vitally important

and certainly for all of us in this room to hopefully be cognizant of

so we can help to grow the space and legitimize it in a really meaningful way

Perfect, thanks Andrew

Margaret you were saying something

Sure, no problem

I think the majority of DeFi products actually have certain elements of centralized control in them

and so I'd like to see more of a focus on transparency

about what projects really are doing

not what they hope to do for their users out there

you know we all have what we're planning towards

but like being really transparent

here's where we are right now

and here is where we're going

because we are

and I also think 24 is sort of a bridge period

where we will see a lot of hybrids

and the hybrids are going to help us move to the eventual decentralized concept

that Web3 promises us

so that's a lot of what I would say

and as that happens

I also think it's going to be just another huge trend

is RWAs and the tokenization of everything is going to be driving a lot of this

which is going to be a great driver for DeFi to start to take hold

Hi there

So I just wanted to add two lines

just to be sure that everybody gets their views across

so in Europe, Mika is going to happen by December

it is going to be an interesting

I'm not a regulator, I'm not a lawyer

I've been a cryptographer but build protocols

so my understanding of law is limited

but I've actually talked to the regulators multiple times

and advised regulators at times

so that to me is an interesting construct

and similarly everybody that spoke before me also mentioned regulation

so the requirement of KYC, KYT is going to be very very interesting

I know someone else was saying that we as decentralized projects

should think through what we do

have consensus, then publish what is happening

I want to add a couple of things so that everybody understands what we are talking about

if you were to look at Ethereum

for possibly the largest chain which we have right now

and look at all the L2s that are there

pretty much all of them have some sort of a mechanism of a multi-sig underlying

with less than 15 people having the key shares

so if that is the gold standard for decentralization

well we can all reach decentralization

but again as I said I'm not a lawyer

I don't know how to define decentralization by legal means

there are definitely interesting trade-offs that we as DeFi have to come to terms with

because the trilemma is real

unless you can spend space and time

there is no way in hell that we can actually create trade-offs

where people claim they can make

which I find ridiculous

because it's like simply second law of thermodynamics is thrown out of the window

people with no understanding of cryptography or consensus

or basic physics talks very interesting stuff

and the regulators who have no ability to understand any of this

looks at the worst case and then make a pass-loss

and then makes it very difficult for people who are fair and honest

and say what they do and explain everything they do to everybody else to operate

and that's something I think we all need to answer

100%

100%

does anybody else have anything they would like to add?

okay if not

before we close out this episode thanks

let's give a big thanks to everybody that was on our panelists today

as a panelist and for their participation

sounds like you guys have got some great projects that you're working on

can't wait to see what you guys do

agree with a lot of the things that were mentioned today of coming together

and us forming the standard of raising the bar in an essence for projects

to help users feel secure, safe

and basically be able to participate in the decentralization

and financial opportunities of DeFi

so again please mark your calendars for episode number 11 of X-Talks

on the 19th of January at 1am UTC

again we'll be discussing web 3 gaming and interoperability

current problems and solutions

so until next time keep pushing the boundaries of innovation

and to unite all of crypto and everybody have a good day and thanks for coming

thank you Cody and just before we wrap up I wanted to add that we do have

many competitions and stuff like that running in our layer 1x discord

so if you aren't in yet the link is on our bio

and thank you for joining see you again in the next episode of X-Talks

bye-bye everyone

thanks guys thanks everybody bye-bye

thank you thank you have a great day everyone

thank you

### Sunucu

- [LayerOneX](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/layeronex.md) şuradan: [Layer One X](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/layer-one-x.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/LayerOneX)

### Konuşmacı

- [bryancolligan](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/bryancolligan.md) şuradan: [AG Product](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/alphagrowth.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/bryancolligan)
- [Karnika E. Yashwant (Mr. KEY)](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/karnikayashwant.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/KarnikaYashwant)
- [ULTRADE](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/ultrade_org.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/ULTRADE_org)
- [Pulsr](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/pulsr_ai.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/pulsr_ai)
- [YE](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/yeknowlove.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/yeknowlove)
- [Cohost](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/deg3ns.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/XCohost)
- [Anish Mohammed](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/anishmohammed.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/anishmohammed)
- [SuperSight 🥽](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/supersightxyz.md) şuradan: [SuperSight](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/supersight.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/supersightxyz)
- [Margaret Rosenfeld](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/rosenfeldm.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/RosenfeldM)
- [Abrayadh](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/abrayadh.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/abrayadh)
- [Andrew Lubahn](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/andrewlubahn.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/AndrewLubahn)
- [CryptoNaut22](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/cryptonaut22.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/CryptoNaut22)
- [Jonathan](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/spaces/participant/eclip0x.md)
  [X profili](https://twitter.com/eclip0x)

## Protokolünüz veya zinciriniz için daha fazla TVL mi istiyorsunuz?

AlphaGrowth, protokollerin ve zincirlerin TVL'sini varlık edinimi ve entegrasyonu, hibeler, teşvikler ve LP anlaşmaları ile büyütür. Bu verileri biz oluşturduk ve ücretsiz tutuyoruz.

[TVL'yi nasıl büyütüyoruz](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/defi/index.md) [AlphaGrowth ile konuşun](https://alphagrowth.io/tr/contact-us/index.md)
