SOURCE: Feeding the Machine
تاريخ التسجيل: Oct 2, 2023 المدة: 0:59:28تسجيل المساحة
فتح المساحة الأصلية
0:00
59:28
النص الكامل
Thank you so much for watching.
I'm good. How are you? Sorry, just I'm eating myself.
Oh, no. You're all good. You're all good. Where are you calling in from?
The studio in Berlin.
Oh, wonderful. Thank you. Thanks for making time. Is it, what, 6 p.m. there? Is that right?
Yeah, yeah, it is.
Nice. Well, thank you for joining us.
Where are you calling in from?
Oh, I'm in New York, Brooklyn.
Got it. Got it.
It's nice to finally chat. And hi, operator. Hi, Anya. How are you?
Oh, I wonder if she can hear me.
It does take a moment.
It might still be connecting.
And hi to everyone here. Thank you so much for coming.
I see Whitney, Casey, Bobby, Mikey. Thank you so much.
Do feel free to tweet about the space.
And then we can get started here as soon as we have everyone in the room.
Be wonderful.
Oh, here.
I'm trying to add you, Anya. I'm not sure.
I'm going to invite you to co-host and see if that helps.
Primavera, hello. I'm guiding you on stage now.
All right. Primavera, you should be good to go.
Hi, how are you?
Good, good. How about you?
Good, good.
It looks like Anya is connecting.
Let me see.
Elizabeth, can you send the co-host request again?
Sorry, I don't know what happened.
You're all good.
There, it should go through.
Oh, perfect.
I believe you're co-host now.
Hello, can you hear me?
Yes.
Wonderful.
I guess we're just looking for Lauren.
Yes, exactly.
Just waiting one more minute.
Thanks everyone so much for being here.
I see Casey and Deafbeef in the audience.
This is wonderful.
And Aria, hi.
How's everyone today?
I hope it's good weather where everyone is.
Where are you, Elizabeth?
I'm in New York.
Oh, cool.
Yeah.
What about you?
We just got to London.
Is that right?
Yes.
I'm in Gatwick Airport.
Reporting live.
Oh my God.
Airport Wi-Fi under test.
No, I know.
I'm a little, yeah.
Hopefully they don't decide to like clean all the coffee machines that I'm sitting next
to in the middle of my intro, but we'll see how it goes.
Oh, Lauren's here.
Hi, Lauren.
Great.
I'm inviting Lauren up right now.
Lauren, if you don't see an invitation, go ahead and request.
Oh, there you are.
Hey, Lauren, can you hear us?
Hey, yeah, I'm here.
How are you this morning?
I'm good.
How are you doing?
Good, good.
I believe you're in LA.
Is that right?
Yes.
Amazing.
So we're from Los Angeles to Berlin, I think is probably the British East, so I'm covering
quite a swath.
Well, I want to get started if that's okay.
We are starting a little bit late.
Thanks, everyone, for your patience and for adapting so well.
Let's go ahead and get started.
So hello and welcome to the Source Talk series.
My name is Elizabeth Sweet, and I'm the communications lead at Ferrofile.
I'm thrilled to be joined today by Lauren Lee McCarthy, Prima Verdi-Filippi, Sarah Friend,
and Anya Catherine from Operator for a conversation about feeding the machine as part of the Source Talk series.
Now, as most of you know, Source is a non-commercial exhibition on Ferrofile featuring artworks made in the last several years,
which use software as a medium.
The Source curators, Operator, Deafbeef, and Casey Reese spent hours discussing generative works that have impacted them over the years.
So here's an excerpt from the curator's statement to ground us.
This is not an attempt at a survey exhibition or defining a new canon.
This is simply a selection of work that the four of us are thinking about right now.
For those of us in the middle of art, code, and blockchains for the last few years,
there's been little to no time to pause and reflect on what has happened.
Source is our attempt to do that collaboratively.
Now, Anya Catherine and DGT from Operator, Deafbeef, and Casey Reese all wrote wonderfully thoughtful and super rich descriptions
of each of the 25 artworks exhibiting in Source, and I recommend that you go check those out.
And I have pinned to the top of the space three works by our artists joining us today,
Lauren Lee McCarthy, Prima Verdi-Filippi, and Sarah Friend.
And so each of these works require some responsibility by the collector in order to sustain its life,
and I'm sure we're going to jump into this in no time here.
And I'll just start by saying that for Good Morning by Lauren Lee McCarthy,
you must say hello to it, open it up, every 24 hours or it dies.
For Plantoid by Prima Verdi-Filippi, this piece feeds off of cryptocurrency,
and new forms of it can create its own art once it's funded enough.
And Life Forms by Sarah Friend are sustained by necessary transfer.
If they aren't given, if you aren't, if you aren't, sorry,
if you don't transfer your life form to someone else within 90 days, it dies.
So I'm super excited to have this conversation,
and I'm really grateful to introduce Anya Catherine, one of our Source curators.
Anya is one half of Operator, an experiential artist duo.
And I'm so excited for you to lead the discussion, and I'll pass it over to you, Anya.
Thank you for that intro and context, and I'm extremely excited to be speaking about all of these projects.
And I think I want to start, because I think definitions, while they're really annoying,
are also very interesting.
And thinking about generativity and, like, what the word generativity means in psychology,
which I thought was interesting for this discussion,
is it's the concern for the future, the need to nurture and guide younger people
to contribute to the next generation.
So thinking about how psychologists think about generativity in humans,
and then looking at all of these artworks that all kind of, I mean,
none of them feel or seem like they were created with, you know, a market in mind or profit in mind.
They're more entities that you release into the world and you decide their fate in collaboration
with the collector or, in the plantoid's case, with the public, who's not really a collector
because the plantoid can't be owned, in determining their fate and kind of almost testing us
and testing humanity to see how much we care for things that have no market value.
And I think all of these are really interesting ways to look at and ask that question.
And another thing that came up before I asked some questions,
and I would love to hear more from the artist, is when also thinking about these,
I was thinking about kind of alternative currencies.
And, of course, all of these are using blockchain.
I mean, but I feel like alternative currencies of care, generosity, and attention are also activated
in all of these works.
So I would love to know, because, I mean, I see roots, for example,
I mentioned in the description for life forms that this seems very linked to maintenance art
and the Manifesto for Maintenance Art of 1969,
which, you know, is saying that everyone wants to move forward
and everyone wants to do the next big thing
and everyone wants to build the next shiny bridge.
But we need to also have people that just maintain the systems that exist
and nurture and care in ways that are not glamorous,
in ways that people don't put on a pedestal.
And so I think the questions and the kind of themes I wanted to have today be about
were these alternative currencies of care, generosity, attention.
Maybe if maintenance was something that you were thinking about,
if you see these as tests at all, to see what humans value
and what they think is worth giving their time to or not, to be kind of a mirror.
I mean, I definitely felt a kind of way when our good morning died,
which you can read all about in that description.
But also the question of incentives comes up a lot.
And what do we do when there's no, what kind of incentives drive us?
You know, does it do something for you if you allow the life form to survive?
Because not many are left.
And I think these are all things that I enjoy about these
and links that I see between the three.
But I would love to know if any of you have thoughts on those questions or themes
or just your intention in releasing this into the world.
What did you want to do?
What conversation did you want to start?
Yeah, I'll drop a few thoughts responding to what you said,
unless it's someone else who wants to go first.
Yeah, I mean, I loved that you brought up the conversation about maintenance art
in the context of life forms,
because it was absolutely something I was thinking about.
It's something I've thought about a lot in the context of open source software,
where it's a huge conversation.
And in so many areas of life,
one very personal one
is the work that I think
most people on this call
probably
have experienced a little bit,
which is caring for your own software projects.
So life forms is itself like a thing that I have to maintain.
I released the project two years ago,
and I still get
bug reports,
feature requests,
some service that I'm dependent on,
updates itself.
So it's definitely has this meta layer
also all the time.
And secondly,
I think it's really interesting
that you bring up
alternative currencies,
especially ones around care and attention,
because I actually worked on one for a long time.
Before
2019,
it was the main thing I was doing.
And a mechanic
from the world of alternative currencies
called Demirage,
which is decaying money,
was one of the main inspirations
for the project.
That's
I have a huge smile on my face.
I look like a
strange woman in the corner of Costa
right now with this smile.
Another thing
before going to Lauren and Primavera
that I forgot to mention at the beginning
was
the creation of a kind of
system that all of these artworks have
between
you as the artist,
the artwork,
and then
whoever is interacting with
or owning it
and introducing
not just a system,
but in a way,
a relationship
and like new dependencies
that I think
you kind of implicate
people into
the fate of the artwork.
I just read this great quote
in this book by Lauren Berlant
that I love
that maybe has also
some relevance.
They talk about
the familiar friction
of being in relation
and this idea of
suddenly,
if someone collects,
it's not like
I own this thing.
Ownership is not
really the point.
Owners,
you're kind of,
you purchase it
and you now
are in relation
to you as the artist
or the artwork itself.
And so another thing
I would love to maybe
hear about
is the idea
of dependency
or relationships
created through
releasing these works.
Yeah,
maybe I can go next.
Yeah,
so I think
it's interesting
because
I love being
on this panel
because it's like
super cool
to be surrounded
by people
that are creating
blockchain-based
platforms.
I think
like the plantoid
has a slightly
different approach
because
it's actually
not something
that needs
to be taken care of
but rather
it's something
that is trying
to evolve
so that it can
take care
of itself.
And the first
characteristic of this
is that the plantoid
doesn't die
because
in my
conceptualization,
in my cosmology
of blockchain-based
life forms,
a blockchain-based
life form
dies
whenever the
blockchain dies
but that's just
one of the many
species.
But I think
the interesting
thing with the
plantoid
is that
it actually
has evolved
to become
so the goal
of the plantoid
is to
regenerate itself
or to create
multiple generations
and it has evolved
actually
since like
since the first
plantoid
of like
2014
which was
just
like a plant
that eats
bitcoins
and then
you know
of course
you get
donations
but that's
a very
that's a very
passive
way
you know
and then the
plantoid
says thanks
but that's it
you literally
just give money
away
in order to
see the
reproduction
but it's
more like
taking care
of the plant
and then
and then the
plantoid
has evolved
in order
to kind of
like get a
little bit
more fit
for the
environment
and realize
well actually
people are
more likely
to feed me
if they also
get something
in exchange
and so
the following
generation of
plantoid
moved into
ethereum
and started
providing
governance rights
to the people
that feed it
and so
obviously
then if you
want to be
somehow
influencing
the way
in which
the plantoid
will evolve
then you feed
it and then
you become
one of the
consultants
about the way
in which
it's going
to reproduce
itself
so that's
like a
little bit
of an
extra
benefit
and then
the latest
generation
of plantoid
realized
that that's
actually not
enough
because
as a
blockchain
based
life forms
you are
essentially
living in
a very
capitalistic
ecosystem
and in
order to
actually be
able to
sustain
yourself
you need
to play
the economic
game
and so
the newest
plantoids
are actually
creating
those seeds
which are
NFTs
so now
all of a sudden
people have
an incentive
to feed the
plantoid
not only
because they
want to
take care
of it
and not
only because
they want
to influence
its development
but also
because they
want to get
an NFT
in exchange
and potentially
monetize
this NFT
and sell
it and
speculate
it and
whatever
but the
more they
speculate
with the
NFT
the more
they feed
back into
the plantoid
and so
in this
sense
I think
the plantoid
is really
trying to
be as
independent
and as
autonomous
as possible
meaning that
it doesn't
want to
depend on
people
but rather
is trying
to create
an offer
that is
salient
enough
for the
humans
to actually
engage
with it
and pollinate
it with
crypto
as
as opposed
to
being
more
of a
pet
or a
little
plant
that
need
to
constantly
take care
of
and if
you don't
take care
of it
it might
die
so
there's a
slightly
I guess
more
proactive
approach
to
autonomy
and
self
sustainability
I completely
hear that
distinction
and you
know that
I think
that
plantoid
is
a
badass
independent
person
I actually
have a
major
crush
plantoid
14
you know
this
but I
think
what you
said
it is
like
you meant
I mean
why do
you think
that you
had to
introduce
incentives
to care
and I
understand
it's not
care
like it's
going to
die
because it
will live
even if
people
don't
feed
plantoid
but
if they
don't
feed
plantoid
then
plantoid
also
doesn't
evolve
so it's
not about
it dying
but it's
about it
not
continuing
and so
you did
introduce
incentives
for people
to do
that
because it's
almost like
maybe there
wasn't enough
of an
incentive
when it
was just
like I
know
that
plantoid
I'm
going to
have
some
rights
over
which
artist
creates
the next
one
like did
you reach
a moment
where you
were like
I'll never
have
plantoid
25
if I
don't
produce
incentives
because people
weren't
incentivized
by just
having a
role in
the story
and continuing
plantoid
and seeing
where it
goes
that you
needed to
introduce
outputs and
things that people
could own
and trade
need to
need to
need to
need to
need to
need to
need to
need to
I think
it's
more
in the
aesthetic
narrative
of the
thing
the goal
of the
plantoid
is to
evolve
in order
to become
the most
fit for
its own
environment
and as
the
plantoid
found
itself
into
an
environment
in which
all of
students
and everyone
wants
NFTs
the
natural
evolution
of the
plantoid
is that
it should
actually
provide
NFT
to
people
in order
to
maximize
its
chance
of
survival
and
its
chance
to
reproduce
itself
so
it's
more
like
an
exploration
of
the
evolutionary
Darwinism
and
of course
when I
created
the first
plantoid
it was
the most
fit
for its
environment
because
it was
a time
in which
you have
a lot
of people
with
Bitcoin
that
have
no
idea
how
to
spend
them
and
are
really
happy
to
donate
Bitcoins
to
a
plantoid
but
this
is
no
longer
the
case
today
so
things
need
to
evolve
the
environment
is
changing
and therefore
the
speciation
also needs
to
evolve
so
right now
it seems
that
the
dominant
strategy
is to
issue
NFTs
I don't
know
in a few
years
it might
be
something
different
but
I don't
know
and the
point
is
no one
knows
the
environment
will
decide
which
one
are
the
plantoids
that
have
actually
the
traits
that
are
the
most
appealing
and
the
most
salient
for
the
environment
and
which
therefore
will
actually
be able
to
acquire
enough
funds
to
reproduce
it's
really
fascinating
and this
idea also
that
plantoid
cannot be
owned
I think
is
really
interesting
it kind
of brings
me to
something
I wanted
to talk
to
Lauren
about
which
do
consider
the
people
that
have
good
mornings
to
be
collectors
of
good
morning
or do
you feel
like
they're
doing
something
else
what is
that
relationship
do you
see it
as a
thing
that
they
own
or
have
they
entered
into
a
world
a
relationship
with
a
relationship
with
the
art
what was
your
intention
and how
do you
imagine
or describe
that
relationship
I
I think
owning
something
is a
relationship
so
yes
they're
entering
a
relationship
and yes
they've
collected
something
and they
own
something
I guess
I wanted
to
question
our
impulse
to be
constantly
generating
more
to have
more
because
I think
at some
point
the more
things
you add
or collect
and take
into your
life
at some
point
you have
to make
some
decisions
about
what
you have
a limited
amount
of time
and
attention
so you
have to
make
some
decisions
about
what
you're
prioritizing
or you
risk
not really
paying
attention
to
anything
and so
the piece
is sort
of asking
for a
commitment
or
and
to see
it
every
day
and maybe
that's not
the thing
that you
want to
commit to
you realize
after collecting
but it's
in there
is a question
of what
are you
committing
to
what are
spending
your
time
on
what
are you
putting
your
attention
towards
and can
you do
that
intentionally
so that's
sort of
the relationship
I think
there's another
relationship
that I wanted
to speak
to
with this
work
also
which is
the
sort
of
expectation
of a
type
of
emotional
labor
that I
feel
is
expected
especially
of women
in a
much higher
degree
and so
here's a piece
that's
sort of asking
you every day
to perform
some social
labor
whether you
want to
or not
to kind
of ask
the question
of how
does that
feel
how does it
feel to be
asked
to perform
socially
even in
the times
that you
don't want
to
because I
think some
of us have
that experience
very frequently
and maybe
others
that's less
familiar
yeah I
think all
the artists
here know
the pressure
that you're
referring to
and I
hadn't
actually
thought
about
that
as
kind
of
mirroring
the social
and emotional
labor
of you
know
just being
being
present
all the
time
and I
think
what's
interesting
that came
up with
primavera
and plantoid
is kind
of
they all
have to
do with
like trying
to survive
in certain
environments
and I
think they
all speak
a lot
to
like
plantoid
realizing
what in
order to
continue
evolving
needs to
do this
or provide
this incentive
or give
NFTs
and
Lauren
your
commentary
on in
order to
survive
in this
environment
there's a
certain
degree of
presence
or social
labor
that is
required
to
continue
to
evolve
and
it
doesn't
mean
that
for
example
if we
draw
that
parallel
to
just
being
an
artist
in
web
three
it's
not
like
if you
stop
performing
that
emotional
labor
you're
going
to
literally
die
but
might
not
be
able
to
continue
to
evolve
and
might
lose
the
relationships
or
the
presence
that's
needed
for
to
continue
doing
your
craft
and
doing
what
want
to
do
so
I
think
they're
all
speaking
in
different
ways
to
kind
of
also
the
ways
that
artists
are
expected
to
evolve
and
adapt
and
survive
within
I
think
particularly
I think
a web
three
and crypto
art
ecosystem
any
thoughts
on that
well
one of
my
research
interests
this
past
year
has
been
I
guess
dynamics
in
areas
where
I
feel
like
there
is
a
closely
related
tension
between
sort
of
care
or
emotional
labor
and
speculative
market
or
just a
market
in
general
so
conversations
with
nurses
or
sex
workers
other
people
who
or
social
media
influencers
outside
of
the
arts
because
I
feel
like
there
are
a
lot
of
parallels
or
really
interesting
dynamics
in
these
other
locations
where
care
presence
an
emotional
connection
something
intangible
or
difficult
to
quantify
is
also
interacting
with
a
system
of
price
and
market
mechanisms
so
I guess
we
agree
that
that's
part
of
being
an
artist
now
is
being
sort
of
present
in
a way
that
is
difficult
to
quantify
and
how
have
people
this
is a
question
open
to
any
of
because
I
know
Sarah
I think
last time
we talked
like 19
life forms
were still
alive
which means
the vast
majority
have died
Lauren
I'm not
sure how
many good
mornings
are still
alive
or
Prima
I would
love to
hear
the
conversations
that have
spurred
between
people
who
have
participated
how
they
see
the
peace
I
know
I
felt
really
quite
sad
when
our
good
morning
died
because
I
felt
like
exactly
what
mentioned
Lauren
and I
think
a lot
of us
are
feeling
this
way
Anna
Maria
Carriera
I see
here
we
just
talked
about
this
last
week
we
have
such
limited
time
and
attention
and
it's
becoming
really
difficult
to keep
up
without
sacrificing
one
thing
for
another
whether
it's
health
for
an
opportunity
or
traveling
versus
staying
home
and
working
and
just
feeling
like
there's
constantly
conflicting
needs
and
desires
and
a sense
of
ambivalence
about
what
is the
right
thing
to
commit
to
and
how
do
we
do
that
amidst
feeling
like
there's
pressure
from
all
different
angles
and
being
able
to
argue
any
direction
so
how
have
conversations
been
with
people
who
have
had
a
life
form
or
had
a
good
morning
or
fed
plantoid
I would
love to
hear
how
that
response
has
been
any
particular
moments
that
stood
out
to
maybe
I can
jump
in
I
actually
just
wanted
to
say
something
that
during
the
exhibition
at
HEC
I think
Sarah
you said
something
that
was
super
interesting
of
like
the
idea
that
right
now
every
time
a
life
form
dies
it's
actually
know
terrible
it's
like
oh
my
god
I
didn't
take
care
of
it
but
that
there
is
also
a
world
in
which
life
forms
have
a
standardized
or
beautiful
death
and
just
like
actually
can
codify
the
fact
that
they
are
meant
to
die
to
have
their
own
sunset
clothes
and
I
think
it's
also
interesting
to
like
know
what
is
the
what
is
that
value
do
value
the
art
piece
because
can
amount
of
life
then
might
want
to
spend
more
time
with
it
because
know
that
this
is
the
only
time
can
interact
with
it
and
so
the
value
of
the
time
spent
with
the
art
piece
becomes
higher
so
I
the
like
since
they
do
actually
issue
NFTs
I
think
that
the
people
that
feed
them
all
of
a
sudden
they
really
like
become
a
little
pollinator
know
it's
like
all
of
a
sudden
also
become
a
little
bit
like
feel
like
a
mom
not
a
mom
like
a
parent
or
something
of
like
know
that
have
this
little
seed
in
your
hand
and
that
this
ownership
because
don't
really
own
the
plantoid
but
there
is
this
sense
that
I
have
collected
that
thing
that
seed
and
I
know
that
this
seed
is
part
of
the
plantoid
and
I
know
that
it
seed
is
something
that
enable
another
planter
to
live
and
I
think
being
able
to
have
this
little
artifact
actually
brings
people
to
feel
much
more
to
have
a
much
stronger
relation
with
the
plant
then
if
it's
just
I
gave
the
money
and
I
get
governance
right
or
if
it's
just
I
gave
money
so
in
some
way
like
I
think
in the
evolutionary
Darwinism
perspective
the
strategy
of
issuing
NFT
is
but
a
good
economic
value
strategy
because
it
increased
obviously
the
funds
that
will
be
given
because
of
the
speculative
dynamics
but
I
think
it
also
increased
somehow
the
emotional
or
relational
value
that
people
feel
they
have
created
with
Plantoid
Do you
think
it's
because
the
output
has
that
do you
think
it's
because
for
example
the
poems
that
Plantoid
is
writing
are
based
on
the
interaction
of
the
collector
and
Plantoid
like
I
wonder
if
it
was
more
of
a
simple
exchange
of
like
money
here's
a
thing
versus
something
that
feel
was
caused
by
a
word
that
said
makes
it
also
feel
a bit
more
personal
and
like
have
you're
more
invested
or
in
a
relationship
or
part
of
its
growth
and
part
of
Plantoid's
story
because
what
reflected
in
what
Plantoid
makes
I think
there's a
relationship
with the
NFT
because
the
NFT
is
personalized
it's
a
co-creation
created
it
with
Plantoid
and
so
in
this
sense
it's
like
feel
a
sense
of
authorship
and
paternity
in the
copyright
sense
but
I
think
it
also
provides
an
additional
sense
of
relational
value
with
the
Plantoid
itself
because
feel
that
are
this
little
pollinator
that
is
helping
it
reproduce
and
that
even
if
sell
the
NFT
you're
separating
yourself
from
the
NFT
but
it's
still
a
little
bit
your
DNA
that
is
now
traveling
and
being
disseminated
and
actually
feeding
back
into
the
Plantoid
treasury
so
there
seems
to be
from
my
experience
there
seems
to be
a
very
strong
connection
both
with
the
NFT
but
also
with
the
plant
that
has
issued
the
NFT
because
it
is
this
tangible
way
in
which
know
that
can
in
this
sense
care
for
it
but
actually
you're
caring
for
yourself
first
because
really
just
sell
it
for
making
money
but
actually
as
do
that
know
that
you're
somehow
supporting
the
reproduction
of
Plantoid
which
gives
a
double
satisfaction
yeah
it's
a little
bit
like
conscious
consumerism
right
now
with
the
coffee
shop
I'm
in
and
it's
like
if
buy
this
water
the
earth
is
going
to
be
saved
it's
like
I
got
hydrated
and
I'm
saving
the
planet
yeah
kind
of
logic
one
thing
I
want
to
bring
up
and
I
see
there's
a
request
I
don't
know
if
we're
doing
questions
Elizabeth
that
was
planned
or
not
but
I'm
I'm
open
to
it
if
the
artists
are
since
Plantoid
doesn't
die
and
I
feel
like
it's
it's
definitely
a
major
decision
to
decide
that
the
work
will
die
like
even
to
use
the
word
die
and
death
and
I
felt
away
when
Good
Morning
died
and
we
currently
have
a
life
form
and
I
feel
like
I'm
going
to
try
to
redeem
myself
by
not
letting
the
life
form
die
to
try
to
get
rid
of
some
of
the
guilt
so
I
wanted
to
talk
to
about
the
use
of
death
in
the
artwork
and
also
the
feelings
of
guilt
that
might
be
caused
and
whether
that
guilt
can
be
productive
in
a
way
to
evoke
people
asking
what
else
around
them
might
be
dying
because
of
neglect
or
them
not
committing
enough
time
whether
it's
health
or
relationship
or
whatever
the
use
of
basically
the
question
is
the
decision
to
have
the
work
die
and
whether
guilt
is
part
of
the
artwork
well
I
will
say
Anya
not only
do
have
a
life
form
actually
have
the
first
life
form
so
if
kill
it
friendship
ended
can
tell
by
how
old
it
is
which
is
maybe
not
the
most
superficially
obvious
feature
but
your
life
form
is
more
than
700
days
old
but
I
won't
let
kill
it
because
I
personally
care
for
the
first
three
life
forms
and
by
that
I
mean
that
other
people
care
for
them
too
but
I
am
really
naggy
and
obnoxious
about
it
around
the
time
that
they
need
to be
transferred
sort
of
an
assistive
function
so
yeah
but I
guess
just to
speak more
generally
about
death
the
life
forms
absolutely
have this
dynamic
where
they die
and it's
presented
as sad
or a
bad
thing
and of
course
we have
attitudes
towards
death
outside of
the context
of this
artwork
and
often
that attitude
is that
death
is bad
as well
for obvious
reasons
but
we can
have
different
kinds
of
relationships
to
huge
phenomena
in reality
and
in
the
context
of
death
outside
of
life
forms
know
there
are
movements
towards
death
acceptance
there
are
dialogues
around
know
how
to
die
well
dating
in book
form
to the
1500s
and
and
and
so I
guess
there's
there's
one
hand
one
hand
of the
story
where
it's
very
sad
that
less
than
20
life
forms
of the
200
and
something
that
have
been
created
are
currently
alive
but
then
there's
another
sort of
version
where
maybe
that's
just
what
was
right
for
them
I
guess
I
did
start
to
feel
like
the
game
of
life
forms
needed
an
alternate
ending
though
because
some
of
these
life
forms
are
very
cared
for
and
so for
example
I was
in Toronto
a couple
weeks ago
and I
had a
conversation
with a
friend
there
who
has
been
caring
for
life
form
with
some
other
people
at
his
company
almost
since
the
project
launch
and
I
hinted
that I
was
going
to do
something
around
life
form
stuff
and he
got
really
mad
at
me
he
was
like
you're
going
to
care
about
life
form
so
people
have
all
kinds
of
feelings
about
it
but
I
started
to
feel
like
the
project
needed
a
second
ending
has
had
a
good
life
this
life
form
has
passed
through
the
wallets
of
so
many
of
my
close
friends
and
respected
peers
I'm
ready
to say
goodbye
to
this
life
form
this
life
form
is
the
equivalent
of
a
110
year
old
person
in
a
hospital
room
filled
with
their
great
grandchildren
and
there's
no
way
to
distinguish
that
death
from
the
death
of
neglect
in
the
case
of
a
life
form
where
just
forgot
to
transfer
it
so
I
am
actively
working
on
a
sort
of
state
change
that
is
available
to
life
forms
after
a
certain
age
I've
been
meaning
to
drop
the
announcement
actually
already
I'm
just
waiting
on
some
where
I
need
to
do
some
CSS
fixes
actually
to
make
the
page
look a
little
cuter
but
coming
soon
some
more
info
about
that
sort
of
extension
of
the
project
I
really
love
that
and
I
was
going
to
say
before
said
that
holding
this
life
form
comes
with
assistance
and
remembering
I
was
going
to
say
right
after
this
call
like
please
can
we
schedule
a
meeting
and
do
this
together
over
Zoom
just
so
I
don't
fuck
it
up
so
I'm
really
happy
about
that
makes
me
feel
better
and
Lauren
I
know
have
a
heart
out
at
10
I'd
love
to
hear
your
thinking
behind
having
the
good
mornings
dying
what
it
means
what
it
means
to
I'm
sorry
can
repeat
that
I
just
lost
no
worries
just
the
thinking
around
the
choice
to
have
the
good
mornings
die
and
also
I
was
curious
are
there
other
iterations
were
thinking
other
than
opening
the
browser
window
like
how
I
would
love
to
hear
if
there
were
any
other
ways
that
were
thinking
that
could
be
attended
to
every
day
I
guess
the
choice
to
make
it
die
I
really
appreciate
endings
I
think
sometimes
things
need
to
end
so
I
was
happy
with
the
decision
that
this
is
a
performance
that
I
guess
I'm
also
interested
in
performances
that
exist
over
a
duration
but
kind
of
for
as long
as
want
them
to
and
so
I
thought
of
this
as
a
performance
that
perform
that
lasts
as long
as you
want
to
or
you're
able
to
this
is
actually
a
variation
or
sort
of
a
sister
piece
to
another
piece
that
I
did
in
2021
called
good
night
and
in
that
piece
it's
a
single
NFT
and
whoever
owns
it
I
text
that
person
good
night
every
night
before
I
go
to
sleep
so
this
is
not
automated
or
anything
it's
just
me
making
that
commitment
and
then
performing
that
ritual
for
that
person
so
then
if
that
NFT
transfers
to
someone
else
then
the
good
night
text
would
transfer
as well
and
this
is
a
performance
that
will
continue
as
long
as
I'm
alive
so
I
guess
in
addition
to
thinking
about
endings
of
NFTs
or
endings
of
activities
or
rituals
that
we
participate
in
it's
also
thinking
about
just
the
finite
amount
of
time
that
we
have
to
live
and
I
think
sometimes
we
feel
more
in
touch
with
that
than
others
but
definitely
over
the
course
of
the
pandemic
I
felt
much
more
connected
to
the
idea
of
mortality
and
I
got
thinking
about
what
we
want
to
spend
the
limit
of
time
we
have
doing
what
we
want
to
spend
it
on
yeah
that's
really
powerful
and
I
love
the
good
night
piece
a lot
so
Elizabeth
did
want
to
take
was
there
a
question
or
no
so
that
person
took
out
their
request
it
might
have
just
been
yeah
not
a
not
a
real
question
but
happy
to
take
questions
if
if
the
artists
are
if
if
that's
something
that
you're
interested
in
also
if
want
to
ask
each
other
questions
I
could
ask
a
question
if
that's
not
if
that's
okay
if
that's
not
opposed
to
of
course
and
I
guess
so
this
question
is
for
Lauren
although
it
does
apply
to
everyone
but
in
thinking
about
what
said
about
expectations
and
emotional
labor
and
also
how
we
started
the
conversation
kind
of
talking
about
values
and
currency
I
was
wondering
how
do
think
about
altruism
or
the
selfless
concern
for
the
well-being
of
others
with
good
morning
when
commit
to
a
routine
with
an
artwork
or
someone
else
is
there
altruism
involved
can
it
be
selfless
or
what
are
we
serving
here
I
guess
is
my
question
well
I
guess
in
this
case
are
serving
a
few
things
one
you're
part
of
this
group
of
people
that
have
decided
to
do
this
ritual
so
I
think
by
participating
in
it
there
is
a
sense
that
you're
contributing
to
that
shared
activity
and
then
on
the
other
hand
I
think
are
serving
the
artwork
in
some
sense
so
a
lot
of
times
these
artworks
are
speculated
on
and
used
as
financial
instruments
and
I
liked
the
idea
that
this
is
actually
an
NFT
that
only
exists
as
long
as
consider
it
and
interact
with
it
as
an
artwork
so
I
think
that
the
actions
of
the
collectors
in
doing
that
by
opening
it
up
and
literally
looking
at
it
and
engaging
with
it
kind
of
support
that
way
of
seeing
the
work
and
seeing
the
thing
that
they've
collected
yeah
and then
again
like I
think
there
are
larger
questions
about
just
in
general
what
do
want
to
spend
your
time
doing
maybe
it's
not
opening
an
artwork
every
day
maybe
it's
talking
to
someone
else
in
your
life
and
so
I'm
hoping
that
it
can
kind
of
provoke
those
questions
and
maybe
there's
a
different
sense
of
altruism
that
comes
in
that
thank
it
spurred
that
it
made
me
actually
have
this
huge
revelation
of
neglect
in
multiple
areas
of
my
life
from
that
piece
time
because
it
kind
of
it's
so
simple
it's
such
an
easy
thing
especially
you know
I'm
on my
laptop
every
single
day
that
opening
this
one
browser
window
it
just
felt
like
when
I
couldn't
manage
to
do
that
and
then
the
piece
died
I
realized
kind
of
like
how
ungrounded
I
must
be
that
something
so
simple
slipped
through
the
cracks
that
I
couldn't
manage
to
do
it
like
on
a
device
that
I'm
on
for
most
of
my
day
and
so
I
think
it
kind
of
made
me
realize
that
there's
probably
a lot
of
really
important
things
that
even
if
I'm
right
next
to
the
person
maybe
or
maybe
it's
someone
who
I
think
about
a lot
but
I
don't
like
send
the
message
like
know
my
grandmother
is
getting
old
and
like
these
kinds
of
questions
and
I
think
also
the
fact
that
this
is
a
source
conversation
and
we're
talking
about
things
like
care
and
neglect
and
death
and guilt
and
time
and
ritual
makes
me
really
happy
and
I
think
it's
really
important
anything
between
the
artists
like
do
have
questions
or
thoughts
generally
that
I
missed
or
didn't
come
up
that
you'd
like
to
share
about
your
artwork
or
ask
anyone
else
I
would
love
to
think
about
how
we
can
have
blockchain
based
life
forms
interacting
with
one
another
right
now
I
feel
like
the
whole
human
to
life
form
interaction
I
think
it
would
be
really
nice
to
create
little
life
forms
that
have
their
own
capacity
to
recognize
each
other
and
interact
with
one
another
maybe
like
just
as
a
little
taste
I
don't
know
so
the
sublantoid
was like
the first
attempt
of
mine
to
create
a
blockchain
based
life
form
now
there
is
a
new
blockchain
based
life
form
that
is
coming
in
which
is
similar
in the
sense
of
it
is
also
some
blockchain
based
creature
that
is
trying
to
evolve
and
that
also
cannot
be
owned
even
though
it's
purely
it's
a purely
digital
creature
but
just
cannot
own
it
but
can
interact
with
it
and
the
way
interact
with
it
is
can
feed
it
of
course
and
the
more
feed
it
the
more
it
loves
and
the
more
it
loves
the
more
can
ask
the
life
form
to
do
things
including
mate
with
another
life
forms
and
the
only
way
in
which
can
extract
any
of
the
funds
so
essentially
it's
a
black
hole
for
crypto
all
get
is
some
love
but
the
crypto
never
leaves
the
little
they're
called
aminals
so
the
crypto
never
leaves
the
aminals
belly
with
the
exception
of
if
manage
to
convince
two
aminals
to
reproduce
themselves
and
then
they
will
give
a
little
bit
of
their
treasury
to
the
kid
to
the
new
aminal
and
during
the
pregnancy
there
is
a
possibility
for
people
to
inject
new
genetic
traits
which
are
essentially
like
visuals
so
can
inject
a
new
SVG
code
and
then
people
that
the
aminals
parents
love
they
can
vote
on
the
traits
that
the
kid
will
inherit
and
then
once
the
kid
receives
the
treasury
from
the
parents
the
kid
will
redistribute
that
treasury
to
all
the
genetic
engineers
that
have
contributed
to
its
genetic
code
and
so
the
nice
thing
is
actually
have
sexual
reproduction
so
it's
not
just
one
blockchain
based
life
form
cloning
into
something
else
but
actually
need
to
find
two
aminals
that
will
reproduce
themselves
but
also
it
has
a little
bit
again
like
the
idea
of
care
like
actually
feed
them
because
want
them
to
love
but
then
of
course
there
are
ways
in
which
can
monetize
this
love
which
is
not
at
all
cannot
speculate
there
is
no
speculative
dynamics
possible
in
the
sense
that
cannot
use
the
love
in
order
to
inject
the
genes
that
created
then
can
get
a lot
of
money
because
if
those
genes
become
very
prolific
in
the
species
of
aminals
because
they
are
nice
genes
then
can
actually
make
a lot
of
money
because
whenever
that
gene
is
being
reproduced
get
a
portion
of
those
shares
so
what
I'm
really
interested
is
looking
at
the
dynamics
of
the
market
of
the
blockchain
ecosystem
which
is
essentially
a
money
or
economic
based
ecosystem
how do
actually
create
life forms
that
get
cared
for
they
actually
get
fed
they
actually
get
cuddled
and
they
also
get
genetic
improvements
but
it's
not
gonna
happen
if
just
wait
and
see
just
because
need
to
design
something
that
is
such
that
the
ecosystem
the
environment
see
value
in
caring
for
them
and
I
think
it's
interesting
also
on a
broader
level
because
it
also
raises
question
of
how do
we
actually
design
incentive
for
profitable
charity
or
conscious
environmentally
just
speculation
how do
create
a
system
in
which
you're
doing
something
good
for
yourself
while
also
doing
something
good
for
the
resources
around
yeah
so
Aminal is
the next
iteration
of
blockchain
based
life
funds
still
a
huge
work
in
progress
but
I think
it's
going to
be
super
fun
I would
love to
hear a
conversation
between
Primavera
and
Darwin
you know
maybe
later
we
need to
make
an
AI
of
Darwin
oh
god
so
I
know
Lauren
had
a
hard
out
at
six
but
any
closing
thoughts
from
Sarah
or
Elizabeth
or
any
questions
from
the
audience
this
was
really
really
fun
I'll
just
say
that
it's
been
a
pleasure
to
talk
about
the
work
at
such
a
density
which
I
think
is
brought
out
by
the
really
strong
conversations
between
all the
pieces
and
yeah
it's
been
really
fun
happy
to
be
here
thank
all
for
creating
these
works
and
from
the
audience
are
there
any
questions
that
have
yeah
feel
free
to
feel
free
to
raise
your
hand
or
is
it
request
to
speak
and
and
we
can
bring
up
but
if
not
then
we
can
go
ahead
and
close
out
I
do
know
it's
it's
over
the
hour
but
if
have
a
question
feel
free
to
invite
yourself
to
speak
I
really
want
to
thank
all
for
this
conversation
today
it's
been
I
think
really
important
and
something
I've
been
thinking
about
as
well
care
and
emotional
labor
and
how
much
time
and
attention
we
give
things
especially
things
on
our
phones
not
only
artworks
but
the
communities
and
the
people
and
how
digital
our
lives
have
become
and
what
it
really
means
in terms
of
routine
and
care
not
only
for
each
other
but
for
ourselves
so
this
conversation
is
giving me
a lot
to
think
about
and
I
really
want
to
thank
all
today
for
being
here
and
for
agreeing
to
this
talk
and
for
and
to
Anya
for
curating
the
going
together
in
this
really
beautiful
way
so
I
just
want
to
thank
all
for
being
here
and
for
speaking
so
openly
and
deeply
about
your
work
it's
been
wonderful
thank
Elizabeth
and
Feralphile
and
I
think
for
my
closing
thought
I
would
just
like
again
to
highlight
what
I
think
all
these
works
bring
up
so
powerfully
but I
think
is
often
forgotten
is
know
there
is
a lot
of
excitement
and
a lot
of
shiny
and
a lot
of
new
and
a
new
there's
a lot
of
interest
and
excitement
and
momentum
around
things
that
are
new
but I
think
what's
really
important
and
this
again
goes
back
to
like
the
manifesto
for
maintenance
art
of
1969
realizing
and
stepping
back
and
looking
at
who
is
maintaining
the
systems
we
are
creating
know
we're
building
infrastructures
digital
and
physical
and
it's
exciting
that
things
are
progressing
but
who
are
the
people
that
are
making
sure
that
it
still
works
every
single
day
and
over
time
and
over
years
and
over
generations
and
to
just
recognize
and
remember
that
work
and
also
as
Lauren's
piece
kind
of
reminds
me
but
know
the
small
daily
rituals
that
we
do
what
we
choose
to
spend
our
time
doing
who
we
choose
to
spend
our
time
with
all
of
these
are
versions
of
maintenance
and
upholding
systems
and
machines
that
are
put
in
place
so
just
to
be
aware
of
that
all
the
time
I think
it's
really
important
thank
all
thank
I will
say
maybe
also
that
don't
all
artworks
die
by
lack
of
attention
don't
they
all
thank
everyone
yeah
thank
all
so
much
and
I
do
just
want
to
encourage
everyone
to
go
visit
the
exhibition
please
explore
life
forms
plantoid
and
good
morning
they're
on
feral
file.com
and also
read
the
reflections
by
curators
operators
deaf
beef
and
Casey
Reese
I will
give
a quick
overview
of what
we have
coming up
for the rest
of the
week
we are
in the
middle
of the
source
talk
series
so
again
thank you
for joining
us today
and for
everyone
who's
who's
joined
past
talks
and for
all the
future
ones
to come
so
coming up
next
on
Wednesday
we're
back
with a
talk
between
Jonas
Lund
and
deaf
beef
called
on
chain
accidents
moderated
by
Whitney
Hart
and
on
Thursday
Vinnie
Valenzuela
and I
will sit
down
with
Maya
Mann
and
Zebrun
Verstig
in a
talk
called
the
internet
made
me
and
then
on
Friday
we're
joined
by
Sasha
Styles
Judy
Ma'am
and
Dada
in a
talk
called
creating
the
creative
moderated
by
DJT
the
other
half
of
operator
and
then
on
Monday
to
close
out
the
source
talk
series
we're
discussing
fabrics
of
time
and
space
with
Anna
Lucia
finger
code
Sarah
Zucker
and
Travis
Smalley
and
that'll
be
monitored
by
Madeline
Pierpont
so
again
I just
want to
thank
Lauren
who
had
to
dip
but
to
Lauren
and
Primavera
Sarah
really
thank you
all so
much
for
for
being
here
for
agreeing
to
show
your
work
in
the
show
and
of
course
to
our
source
curator
Anya
Catherine
thank
for
making
the
time
and
thank
all
really
these
are
the
busiest
of
time
so
thank
all
for
your
care
and
attention
today
so
yeah
I hope
everyone
has a
great
day
and
we'll
see
on
Wednesday
bye
bye
everyone
thank
هل تريد مزيدًا من TVL لبروتوكولك أو سلسلتك؟
تنمّي AlphaGrowth قيمة TVL للبروتوكولات والسلاسل من خلال استقطاب الأصول ودمجها، والمنح، والحوافز، وصفقات LP. نحن من بنى هذه البيانات ونبقيها مجانية.