Music Ownership - Web3 Solves This
Recorded: Mar 7, 2024 Duration: 1:23:42Space Recording
Open Original Space
0:00
1:23:42
Full Transcription
A singer in a smoky room, a smell of wine and cheap perfume, for a smile they can share
the night. It goes on and on and on and on. Strangers waiting, up and down the boulevard, there's shadows, searching in the night, streetlights deeper, living just to find the most I'm
outing, somewhere to find.
I'm outing, somewhere to find.
Letting hard to get my fill
Everybody wants a thrill
Playing anything to roll the dice
Just one more time
Some will win, some will lose
Some of all just sing the blues
What a pussy never ends
Just on and on and on and on
Hey everyone
Good evening, hope everyone is doing well
I wasn't sure if the music was playing
So if someone can react with an emoji
Is there a thumbs down?
I don't know if there is a thumbs down
Good to have you all here
I see some familiar faces
So that's good
That's good
Guys
Today I had a parcel coming in
From Amazon
I bought a t-shirt
And on it says
I told you so
With the Bitcoin logo
So I'm going to wear this
To family gatherings
In the next couple of months
They definitely will be happy with that
I think
Let me see
Is everyone
We've got co-host here
Might have some issues technically
With inviting the co-host
Today we have Luke here
From PopX
CTO
Musician
Very good musician
He's also very good in design
Like
Today in the call
He blew my mind
Showing something
With AI
That I've never seen before
So
It's really cool
Okay
Let's get some speakers on
And start with a little round
How are you doing?
Layer
One
Hey
Can you hear me?
Yes
Yes
Can you hear you
Clearly
All right
Perfect
My name is Cody
I'm the
Chief Experience Officer
At Layer 1X
Thanks for having us
If you're not familiar
With Layer 1X
We're a Layer 1
Blockchain
That is fully decentralized
And
We're looking to help
Transform the Web3 experience
And
Particularly
In the music
Industry
So
We're definitely excited
To
To kind of jump in
Today's conversation
Thanks for having us
Good
Good
Good
Good to have you on
And
We pinned the post
Of the
The Twitter
Space
So
To this
To this space
And
If you haven't yet
I know
Jean-Marie
You did
You did like
Quote
Quote
Tweeted the Twitter space
Really appreciate that
So if others could
Could also share the love
That would be
Would be great
So let's see
Who else do we've got
We've got on here
Adam
I know Adam
You co-tweeted the Twitter space
As well
How are you doing buddy?
I'm good
Hello
And I've just realized
I spent three minutes
At the start
On my desktop
And you know when
Twitter just completely
Rugs you
And I'm just like
Why are these guys
Not saying anything
And then I realized
That I need to rejoin
And everyone is here
So yeah
Great to be here
My name's Adam
It's my second time
On PopX
Really enjoyed the first one
I'm co-founder of Spark
We're working on
Some of crypto's
Hardest payment problems
Basically helping players
And users
Get onto games
And products
Without worrying about
What chain they're on
Or what token they're using
We're most famous
For handling
The 28 million dollar
Portal coin
ICO
Who you may have seen
On Twitter
At some point
And we're also working
On their
Kind of wider
Payments infrastructure
But also 20 other games
Metaverses
And entertainment products
As well now
And previously
I've also founded
A gaming studio
Before this as well
So that's a bit about me
And look forward to
Chatting with you guys
Sounds great
Adam
Big moves you're making
In Web3
Creator Hoot
Good to see you buddy
Yeah it's good to be back
I really enjoy
You all spaces
So yeah we're
NFT Marketplace
And creator
Launchpad
Just announced our token
You know
Come earn some points
And also
I've been a music producer
For the last
I don't know
A little over a decade
So I think I have
Some good input
Here as well
And yeah we hope
You guys use our marketplace
Good
Yeah definitely
Check it out
Gemma Rhee
Nice to have you on again
As well
Hey y'all
It's Ben Marie
I am a
Recording artist
A songwriter
Also a digital artist
In the Web3 space
But I also own
A catalog
From a family member
That passed away
Years ago
So I understand
The importance
Of music ownership
And especially
Moving into the Web3 space
And how we can
You know
Create solutions
I'm totally
On board
To be at the front
Helping build out
Tooling for that
So I look forward
To the conversation
Good stuff
Good stuff
Gemma Rhee
Tropic
Nice to have you
On mate
How are you doing?
I'm doing great
Can you hear me?
A little mic issue there
Yes
Yes
Awesome
I can hear you
I podcast about the space
All the benefits
Cool things
That's happening
With an NFT
Blockchain technology
However
The music area
Really interests me
As more so
As a collector
Someone who just
Loves music
Supporting the various
Artists that are doing
Some cool things in there
And just the whole
Discoverability process
And sharing music
With friends
And that's sort of
Something
You know
I miss from the
Quote unquote
Olden days
Right when you had
Albums and CDs
And booklets
And all those things
Just a social aspect
Of it
So I'm more so here
As the fan of the music
The collector of the music
And those things
And that's what I love
About this space
We love that
We definitely love that
At PopX
You might have something
Cool for you later on
King Julian
Good to see you back
Hello
Hello
Thank you for
Having me on
Yes
I'm the founder
And co-founder
Of MassMap
We're a
Web3 Everything app
Yeah
I won't go too
Deep into it
Again today
But yeah
Happy to be here
Super excited
To talk about
Ownership
Good stuff
Spicy
Nice to
Have you on
Yo
What's up man
Thanks for having me
On The Space
Appreciate you guys
I think it's our
First time on PopX
This is Shibzy Baker
Behind here
I am the CMO
Of Spicy Capital
We're a VC fund
In The Space
And we are
Regularly investing
Into projects
You know
We're pretty much
On the streak
At the moment
And once we do
Partner with people
We like to
Offer marketing support
As well
And take it from there
And that's across
All platforms
Social media
On social media
So Telegram
Twitter
And what not
It's actually really cool
To be connected
With some people
In this space
As well
We're seeing
Layer 1x
Dope guys
Their spaces are sick
Man
I've joined a few of theirs
And it's cool
To see Jo Marie
As well man
She probably doesn't
Remember who this is
But we connected
At East Denver
Very briefly though
Very very briefly
I think you were
Introducing your friend
To the space
For the first time
Our partner was there
And everything as well
It was at the
L-Bank event
So yeah man
Cool to see some people
And it's dope
To always meet people
IRL as well
I love it
I love the community vibes
And last but not least
Luke
How are you doing Luke?
Yeah good
Hi everyone
Yeah so I'm Luke
I'm co-founder here
At PopX
And not CTO
As Robert introduced me
I head up kind of
Product and design here
And my background
Before getting involved
In this was
I was in a band
With Matt
The CEO
And we have been
For like 15 years
And then yeah
You know
Kind of just done
All of these things together
Been on a mad trip
In the music industry
From
You know
Being fans
And owning music
That way
To releasing music
And the advent
Of things like Napster
And then
You know
And all the way up
To this now
So it's kind of
Been
You know
In my time
Seeing
Like a kind of
Full cycle of
Ownership coming
Going
And starting to
Kind of come back
As well
So it's really exciting
And yeah
Looking forward to it
Yeah you're right
You're right
There are those cycles
I remember Napster
Luke
That was my first time
Downloading
Or should I say that
Oh yeah
I think
I remember the
I remember the label
Calling us in
And being like
Oh you guys have had
You know
50,000 downloads
Of your album
On this new platform
Like oh amazing
What's the platform
Called
Napster
And then
We found out
What Napster was
So
Those kind of like
Imaginary
Or those kind of
Like flights of fancy
Of like
We can all get
Ferraris and stuff
Kind of quickly
Turn into
I mean we still got
Ferraris
They were just
Hot Wheels versions
Instead of
The proper one
Sounds like Spotify
No I'm joking guys
I'm joking
The topic of today
Music ownership
And
Raptory solves this
I mean
We don't have to
Stick with just music
Only I think in general
Like Raptory does
Solve some
Ownership
Issues
Or
Maybe even
Create some other
Kind of ways
Of having ownership
And things
So I would love to
Hear from anyone
What their view is
On Raptory
And ownership really
So maybe from
The music people
First kind of
If anyone wants
To join in
And also guys
Like you don't
Have to raise your hand
If you want to
You know
Jump into something
Just jump in something
People will shut up
In this space
You know
Haven't
Haven't had
An issue
Where I have to
Mute everyone
Like you know
It's not
It's not
It's not
It's not that type
Of vibe
In this space
So yeah
Just go ahead
Grab the mic
And do your thing
Really
So yeah
Ownership guys
What do we believe
About that
In
Raptory
I'll go ahead
I'll go ahead
And go
So I
Currently
Right now
I work
For a company
Called community
Labs
Which
They build
Is basically
A blockchain
Storage
Or data
On the
Arweave network
And one of
The things
That I was
Talking about
Was as a musician
What does this
Look like
For people
That have
Their music
On
On chain
Whether we're
Talking about
Optimism
Whether we're
Talking about
Sounds
Or whatever
One of the
Hardest things
Is to keep
Track of
Who's all
Collecting
Who's making
Like the most
You know
Who's spending
The most money
If you will
And we have
These
Different places
Where we can
Gather everybody's
You know
Wallets
But we all
Know
That anybody
Can get a
Wallet
Drain
Whatever
Switch
Wallet
So
I'm
Oftentimes
In meetings
Now
Wondering
Like how
Can we
All have
Like a
Centralized
Space
No matter
What happens
To your
Wallet
No matter
What wallet
You connect
The music
From
How can
We
Store that
Data to
Where we
Can actually
Get to
It
And it
Never
Expires
I think
Once we
Figure out
How to
Really
Do that
One
As a
One-stop
Shop
I feel
Like the
Rest of
The conversation
As far as
Onboarding
More music
Producers
And artists
In the
Space
As well
As collecting
Like publishing
And stuff
Like that
I feel
Like that
Might
Like be
More easier
Once we
Get the
Fundamentals
Down
Of how to
Gather the
Data that we
Already have
From collectors
As a musician
Yeah
Yeah that's
Nice
I'll
Jump in
I like
I like
What you
Said
Jen
You know
For us
When we
Look at
You know
Ownership
Of music
But
But even
Just ownership
Of nfts
Ownership
Of our
Own data
You know
Things like
That
That
That is
The true
Ethos
Of
Web3
Right
Is to
Own your
Data
Own your
Assets
And
You know
That's
Something that
We're
Working
Towards
At layer
One X
And one
Of the
Things that
We've
Built
Is
You know
A
Bridgeless
Interoperability
Experience
Which we
Call
Xtalk
And
The reason
Why we
Call it
Xtalk
Instead of
Using
Interoperability
Is because
It's such
A cliche
Word being
Thrown
Around
In
Crypto
And
Web3
Right
Now
And so
Xtalk
Goes a lot
Further
Than just
Being able
To transfer
Assets
Across
Chain
Bridgeless
But
It also
Allows you
To move
Data
And
As
Excuse me
Logic
And one
Of the
Things that
We've
Built
For
Our
Gaming
Platforms
Which can
Resonate
Over to
The
Musicians
To
Pretty much
Anything
Is
No matter
What chain
You're
Built
On
If you
Integrate
With
Like
Our
Blockchain
You'll
Basically
Be able
To
For an
Example
Let's
Just
Say
Had
A
Spotify
Type
Of
Project
That's
On
Ethereum
But
All
Of
Jen
Marie's
Music
Is
All
Over
On
Avalanche
Or
Or
You know
Binance
Or
Something
Like
That
Where
Where
Do
Go
Right
How
We've
Designed
It
Is
Is
That
If
Come
To
Layer
One
X
You'll
Basically
Be
Able
To
Play
That
Jen
Marie's
Music
Off
Of
Her
Chain
That
She's
Currently
On
Through
The
Platform
That
Is
On
Ethereum
And
Experience
It
All
Through
The
Layer
One
X
So
Basically
Lose
The
Agnostic
Feel
Of
Having
To
Know
Where
To
Put
Your
Content
Where
To
Where
To
Drive
Your
Users
To
Because
Now
It
Opens
Up
A
Borderless
Chain
Kind
Of
Experience
Where
To
Be
Honest
In
Our
Opinion
We
Feel
That
In
The
Future
Of
Web
Three
No
One
Will
Care
What
Chain
You're
On
Because
Everybody
Will
Be
United
And
That's
The
Vision
That
We're
Working
For
Love
It
Yeah
And
That's
Yeah
And
Just
To
Jump
In
On
That
That's
A
Really
That
That
Phrase
Like
No
One
Will
Care
It
Sounds
Like
A
Really
Negative
Way
To
Phrase
It
But
Whenever
Listen
To
Any
Songs
And
I
Sure
Kind
Of
Really
Into
The
Production
Side
Of
Things
Most
People
Won't
Know
What
Microphone
The
Vocal
Is
Done
Through
Or
What
The
Channel
Strip
Use
Or
The
Console
That
Was
Used
Or
Whether
The
Whether
The
Producer
Like
Coffee
Or
Tea
When
He
Mixed
In
Germany
So
It's
That
Thing
Of
Know
Focusing
On
As
Much
As
Getting
The
Artists
Over
It's
As
Well
As
Getting
The
Fans
Across
Is
The
Big
One
Know
Because
There's
Streaming
Platforms
Out
There
That
Pay
Better
Than
For
example
Spotify
But
Artists
Will
Have
To
Still
Use
Spotify
Because
That's
Where
The
Fans
Are
Predominantly
So
I
Think
It's
A
Case
Of
Creating
A
Way
Of
Fans
Being
To
Use
It
In
Intuitive
Way
And
That
Way
Of
It
Doesn't
Matter
What
Chain
The
Music
Is
On
If
The
Fan
Can
Access
It
And
It's
Seamless
Intuitive
Thing
For
Them
To
Do
That
That's
A
Huge
Part
Of
Being
Able
To
Bring
The
Whole
Know
Educating
People
On
The
Further
Benefits
Of
This
Can
Give
Yeah
I
Love
That
I
Think
Know
It
Kind
Of
Links
Accessibility
To
Ownership
As
Well
Right
Like
When
There
Is
More
Ownership
There
Is
More
Ways
To
Know
Allow
For
Accessibility
I
Guess
And
That's
Quite
Nice
Like
Layer
About
Know
When
Someone
Assets
Or
Someone
Content
Is
On
One
Chain
Someone
Else
Should
Be
Able
To
Access
That
No
Matter
Where
They
Behave
Behavior
Really
Is
Right
And
It
Reminds
Me
A
Little
Bit
About
Like
The
Web
To
Space
Where
Know
I
Don't
Have
Apple
Music
So
If
Something
Goes
On
There
First
I
Can't
Access
It
Right
So
Know
Web
3
Can
Definitely
Solve
For
That
I
Like
That
Angle
I
Didn't
Even
Think
About
That
Angle
But
That
That
Really
Interesting
I
Want
To
Know
A
Little
Bit
More
About
The
Musicians
Here
If
They
Believe
That
Music
NFTs
Is
Something
That
Really
Can
Improve
Ownership
In
Music
Because
When
I
Think
Yeah
Go
On
Cray
Do
Oh
So
Yeah
So
I'm
Torn
On
That
So
Obviously
I'm
Massively
Into
NFTs
In
Crypto
But
Like
I
Mentioned
Earlier
I've
Been
Know
I've
Been
Producing
My
Own
Music
For
A
Little
Over
A
Decade
Now
And
So
I
Love
The
Idea
Of
Ownership
And
How
Can
Truly
Own
Your
Music
With
The
Blockchain
The
Only
Problem
Is
I
Think
That
Would
Work
Really
Well
For
Very
Well
Established
Artists
But
It's
So
Difficult
For
A
Lot
Of
Smaller
Artists
To
Find
An
Audience
As
It
Is
So
Like
Spotify
For
In
So
One
Of
The
Reasons
Why
I
Think
It's
Great
Is
For
The
Discover
Ability
Know
Like
If
Can
Get
On
Discover
Weekly
Your
Music
Will
Automatically
Get
Sent
To
People
Who
Like
The
Genre
That
Create
And
It's
Really
Easy
For
To
Build
A
Fan
Base
And
They
Already
Have
That
Platform
So
What
Makes
For
Them
To
Support
Because
Maybe
They
Don't
Have
A
Wallet
They
Don't
Really
Understand
What
An
NFT
Is
And
So
In
Addition
To
Worrying
About
Gaining
Your
Audience
And
Finding
Your
Voice
And
Getting
Your
Music
Out
There
Now
Have
This
Extra
Friction
That's
Created
With
Having
To
Adopt
These
People
Into
The
Web
World
So
I'm
Torn
On
It
Because
I
Want
To
Believe
In
And
I
Want
It
To
Work
But
I
Don't
Think
That
It's
Realistic
For
Smaller
Artists
Now
When
Have
Grimes
And
Blau
And
A few
Of
These
Other
Artists
That
Already
Have
A
Massive
Established
Fan
Base
It's
Great
For
Them
They
Can
Make
More
Money
From
Their
Music
But
For
Smaller
Artists
I'm
Just
Not
Sure
It's
Going
To
Work
Not
Yet
Anyways
It's
An
Interesting
Take
Yes
As
Somebody
That
Has
Music
On
Chain
It's
Great
To
Build
Fans
That
Are
Already
Crypto
Native
Or
Are
Interested
In
The
Space
But
If
I
Have
Like
I
Do
A
Bunch
Of
Fans
That
Are
Not
On
Chain
Have
No
Idea
What
A
Wallet
Is
Don't
Know
What
A
C
Phrase
Is
It
Is
Really
They
Much
Rather
Go
On
To
Spotify
Or
Apple
Music
To
Listen
To
My
Music
Or
Buy
Merch
From
My
Shop
Then
Get
On
Chain
And
Support
Me
Via
That
Way
And
I
Think
And
I
Will
Always
Go
Back
To
It
One
The
Mass
I
Looked
I
Don't
Know
If
All
Saw
The
Forbes
Web
Three
That
They
Did
The
Rollout
But
It
Was
Only
Like
Two
Or
Three
Music
Or
Artists
That
Were
In
The
Space
That
They
Even
Highlighted
So
Even
In
Web
Three
Music
NFTs
Are
Kind
Of
Like
Oh
That's
Cool
But
It's
Not
Art
Because
Essentially
People
Are
Still
Like
What
NFT
Can
Pump
My
Bag
As
Opposed
To
Saying
Hey
Me
Buying
This
Person's
NFT
As
A
Musician
I'm
Supporting
Them
Know
Sustaining
Their
Livelihood
To
Create
More
Music
To
Go
On
Tour
What
Have
But
I
Just
Think
People
In
General
Unless
Are
The
Technology
Are
Really
Not
Checking
For
Music
NFTs
Which
Makes
It
That
Much
Harder
For
Us
As
Artists
To
Onboard
Fans
Into
This
Space
As
Well
As
Even
Be
In
The
Conversation
Amongst
Know
Other
Crypto
Artists
Or
Digital
Artists
That
Are
In
This
Space
That
Are
Building
So
It's
Just
Like
It's
A
Double
Edged
Sword
I
Collect
Music
NFTs
But
If
I
Go
Outside
To
Ask
My
Neighbour
She
Is
Like
I
Don't
Know
What
That
Is
So
We
Have
A
Disconnect
To
Where
It's
Like
If
Know
Know
But
For
The
Most
Part
Most
People
Just
Don't
Know
And
That's
Their
Life's
A
Problem
I
Think
I
Was
Going to
Say
I
Think
It's
Kind
Of
A
Waste
This
Is
In
My
Opinion
This
Is
In
My
Opinion
And
Also
Seeing
It
From
An
Investor
Standpoint
Obviously
Music
Art aren't
Asking
For
Investment
But
I
See
It
From
A
Way
Of
Investment
Because
Your
Investors
Are
The
Community
They're
Buying
Your
Music
They're
Buying
Your
NFTs
I
Think
It's
A waste
Of
Time
And
A waste
Of
Resources
If
Are
Focusing
On
Building
A
Music
Brand
In
Web3
And
Just
Trying
To
Build
Over
There
Because
Whilst
Web3
And
NFTs
Have
This
Really
Cool
Technology
It's
Amazing
We
Have
This
Tech
And
All
This
Great
Stuff
But
Come on
Let's
Be
Realistic
You're
Going
To
Grind
And
Grind
To
Do
All
That
Stuff
At
The
End
Of
If
Can
Put
Your
Artwork
Up
At
An
Event
The
Easiest
Thing
Could
Probably
Do
Is
To
Say
If
Like
Especially
If
You're
Trying
To
Build
In
Web3
Especially
Web2
If
Someone
Attends
Your
Event
Give
Them
Something
For
Attending
I
Think
Artists
Especially
In
This
Industry
In
Web3
Have
This
What's
It
This
God
Complex
That
They
Deserve
Coming
Let's
Slow
Down
For
A
Second
Yesterday
We're
Here
Because
We're
Not
Just
Supporting
But
We're
Supporting
The
Potential
That
Music
And
Art
Has
In
This
Industry
The
Potential
Of
What
The
Blockchain
Tech
Can
Do
For
In
The
Future
So
I
Think
If
Artists
Started
To
Look
At
It
From
Okay
Cool
I'm
A
Music
Artist
I
Might
Be
Performing
At
NFT
Beards
Or
NFT
Whatever
It
May
Be
NFC
Lisbon
It
Might
Be
A
Side
Event
15
Minute
Set
Doesn't
Even
Need
To
Be
An
Hour
15
Minute
Set
Rap
Two
Songs
Or
Sing
Two
Songs
Say
Thank
Very
Much
Get
Everyone
To
Scan
A
QR
Code
And
The
QR
Code
Drops
In
A
Po
App
And
Say
Everyone
That
Has
This
Po
App
You're
Going
To
Get
Something
In
The
Future
Whatever
It
Is
It
Might
Not
Be
Remember
When
Po-Ups
Got
Released
Through
Decentraland
The
Hype
Behind
Po-Ups
Was
Insane
They
Were
Freaking
Free
We
Didn't
Use
Them
For
Anything
I'm
Still
Looking
On
My
Po-Ups
Today
And
It's
Been
Two
Years
I
Have
Them
I
Have
Over
70
Or
Something
I
Still
Look
At
Them
Today
And
I'm
Still
Like
This
Is
So
Sick
Because
These
Are
My
Badges
For
Joining
The
Event
Can
Literally
Go
On
To
Po-App
And
See
The
Amount
Of
People
That
Collected
Your
Po-App
Then
Can
Go
To
Someone
That
Want
To
Back
Like
A
Sponsor
For
An
Event
And
Say
Look
These
Are
My
Numbers
This
Isn't
People
That
Listen
To
My
Music
No
This
Is
People
That
Attended
My
Event
Look
How
Many
And
Each
Wallet
Address
Is
Like
A
Unique
One
Look
At
The
End
Of
The
Day
A
Backer
Is
A
Backer
Need
To
Explain
To
Them
That
One
Person
Might
Have
Three
Wallet
Dresses
Fuck
All
That
Shit
Right
Just
Say
To
Them
That
This
Is
The
Amount
Of
Wallet
Dresses
These
Amount
People
That
Attended
My
Events
Look
How
Many
People
Attended
I
Had
100
In
The
First
One
I
Had
12
In
The
One
I
Had
50
That
Scanned
The
Second
One
I
Had
100
That
Scanned
This
One
And
Before
Know
Have
Hundreds
That
Scanned
Your
Po
App
Again
Goes
The
Same
For
People
That
Create
Physical
Artwork
Or
Digital
Artwork
Put
In
A
Gallery
Do
The
Same
Thing
It's
A
Great
Way
To
Track
Your
Progress
Over
Time
But
It's
Also
A
Great
Way
To
Track
Your
Community
And
What
You're
Building
And
Just
Duplicate
It
Into
Web
2
Just
Do
The
Same
Thing
In
Web
2
And
Build
Both
And
Eventually
It's
Going
To
Overlap
But
I
Get
Why
People
Are
Building
On
It
But
I
Don't
See
The
Point
Of
All
Results
Into
It
Find
A
Free
Way
To
Build
A
Community
And
Just
Do
That
Because
It's
Going
To
Be
A
Long
Journey
Until
The
Day
Where
We
Have
An
Actual
Music
Artist
From
Web
3
That's
Got
NFTs
And
Whatever
That
Has
Millions
Of
Listens
On
Platforms
We're
Out
We're
A long
Way
Away
From
That
We're
Just
Getting
Into
RWAs
We're
A long
Way
From
The
Music
Scene
Really
Taking
Off
So
Yeah
That's
What
I
Would
Say
I'm
Going
To
Say
One
Little
Thing
And
Then
I'm
Going
To
That
Is
An
Amazing
Point
I
Don't
Know
If
Any
Of
All
Know
Jaden
Violet
But
He
Did
Like
A
Poe
App
For
His
Daily
Weekly
Spaces
For
Like
A
Year
Straight
Now
Mind
He's
A
Web
2
Artist
Or
Whatever
But
In
His
Quest
To
Onboard
More
Art
Like
More
People
Into
The
Crypto
Space
All
Have
To
Do
Is
Have
A
Secret
Word
Mention
A
Poe
App
And
Call
It
A
Day
Like
Two
Different
Nights
Because
He
Utilized
The
Technology
As
An
Example
Of
This
Is
Like
A
Way
To
Start
In
The
Web
Three
Space
To
Onboard
Consumers
Whereas
Artists
Like
Myself
Could
Do
The
Poe
App
Message
Could
Do
That
Other
Artists
Like
Myself
We're
Know
Working
On
Different
Art
Projects
We're
Learning
New
Skills
Because
The
Ultimate
Goal
Is
To
Know
Be
In
A
Place
To
Where
We
Can
Make
Our
Full
Time
Job
But
In
Order
For
Us
To
Do
That
We're
Having
To
Know
Expand
Our
Skill
Sets
We're
Having
To
Learn
How
To
Use
AI
We're
Having
To
Learn
How
To
Animate
Music
Videos
Because
We
Don't
Want
To
Shoot
Them
Or
We're
Learning
How
To
Go
Into
The
Gaming
Industry
To
Figure
How
To
Get
Our
Music
Out
There
And
Building
Fan
Bases
Yes
We
Are
A
Long
Way
From
Math
Adoption
But
I
Think
The
Skills
That
We're
Learning
Along
The
Way
Will
Help
Curate
A
Bigger
Fan
Base
So
Once
Math
Adoption
Happens
Like
Everybody
Can
Feel
Like
They
Have
A
Piece
Of
The
Pie
But
Artists
Especially
Smaller
Independent
Artists
Have
Got
To
Start
Getting
More
Creative
In
Their
Hustle
And
Just
Think
Like
No
I'm
Just
Not
Making
Music
I'm
Actually
Creating
An
Experience
For
Fans
To
Want
To
Be
A
Part
Of
And
I
Think
That's
Know
What
We
Need
To
Get
To
In
Order
For
Mass
Adoption
To
Happen
But
Yeah
Totally
Agree
Totally
Agree
Yeah
That's
That's
Really
Good
Like
The
Word
Experience
And
I
Think
There's
Certain
Kind
Of
Genres
Out
There
That
Have
Historically
Been
Better
Before
The
Advent
Of
Web
3
Or
Digital
Trace
It
Back
To
Kiss
Is
Probably
The
Best
Example
A band
That
Is
Music
But
They
Create
An
Entire
Experience
Around
Them
To
The
Point
Where
It's
Bordering
On
Ridiculous
The
Merch
And
Things
That
They're
Selling
But
A
Couple
Of
Things
Like
There's
Something
Say
Earlier
Essentially
It
Comes
Down
To
A
Lot
Of
The
Accessibility
And
People
Like
The
Word
Grinding
And
Struggling
To
Get
Involved
In
The
Space
Or
Use
It
That's
A
Big
Thing
That
Is
Going
To
Be
A
Driver
Of
When
This
Starts
To
Really
Propel
Into
Mass
Adoption
Parallels
With
The
Advent
Of
Napster
And
Morpheus
And
All
Those
Download
Insights
Is
That
They
Were
Not
Particularly
Intuitive
So
I've
Heard
Before
I
Get
Myself
In
My
Show
It
Wasn't
Really
Until
The
iPod
Come
Out
And
The
User
Experience
Was
Really
Easy
To
Get
And
Understand
For
People
And
I
Think
That's
The
We're
At
The
Advent
Of
Those
Kind
Of
Things
Where
Like
Said
If
Know
Know
How
Good
This
Is
Or
How
Revolutionary
It
Can
Be
It
Just
Needs
To
Be
Put
In
Musicians
And
Fans
Like
They
Kind
Of
Put
In
The
Center
Of
The
Thinking
Around
That
Experience
And
How
They
Can
Interact
With
It
Because
Speaking
From
An
Artist
Point
Of
View
We
Would
Merch
Things
Online
Through
Big
Cartel
Or
Whatever
But
We
Were
Only
Able
To
Do
That
Because
The
Experience
Of
Being
Of
Going
To
The
Stores
Was
Simple
Enough
For
People
To
Grasp
A
Couple
Of
Clicks
And
They
Were
Done
So
I
Don't
Think
It's
Necessary
Until
The
Kind
Of
Ability
To
Do
That
Whether
It's
With
NFTs
Or
With
Any
Other
Kind
Of
New
Product
Or
Whatever
Is
That
Simple
Artists
Aren't
Going
To
Mind
Whether
They've
Built
Their
Fan
Base
On
Platform
Like
Spotify
Or
They've
Built
It
On
Some
Other
Platform
They
Will
That
Audience
Will
Know
Of
That
Band
And
That
Band
Uses
Whatever
They
Feel
Is
Their
Best
With
Communicating
To
Their
Fans
Whether
That
Is
Through
You know
Some
Fans
Mailing
List
Is
Probably
Their
Biggest
Collection
Of
Their
Fans
They
Can
Get
Hold
Or
Probably
More
Effective
Than
Facebook
Or
Twitter
Or
Anything
Else
Like
But
They're
Still
Not
Going
To
Be
Against
Driving
Fans
To
Say
An
NFT
Sale
If
They
Know
The
Experience
Their
Fans
Is
Simple
And
And
Intuitive
And
There's
Parallels
Between
Them
Sending
Them
To
A
Big
Cartel
Store
So
I
Think
That's
A
Big
Challenge
And
That's
Going
To
Help
Bring
Artists
Over
Who
Will
Bring
Fans
Over
And
Everybody
Comes
Over
To
This
Kind
Of
Distinction
Between
A
Web
2
Or
A
Web
3
Artist
Or
Musician
I
Think
It's
Just
You're
Describing
More
So
The
Tools
That
You're
Deploying
To
Try
And
Gain
Fans
Rather
Than
Know
It's
I
Know
It
Just
Feels
Like
That's
The
Kind
Of
Thing
I
Think
If
Start
Making
That
Split
It
Just
Kind
Of
Blurs
It
Just
Kind
Of
Confuses
The
Matter
In
My
Opinion
I
Think
Like
At
What
Point
Does
Somebody
Turn
From
A
Web
2
To
Web
3
Artist
Making
Music
Creating
Art
That
Want
To
Share
With
The
World
And
Generally
You're
Really
Great
Example
Of
Somebody
Who's
Learning
All
Of
These
New
Tools
And
Amazing
Things
To
Be
Able
To
Maximize
Your ability
To reach
Fans
One
Thing
Was
Just
Said
A
Second
Ago
Which
Know
I
Want
To
Jump
In
On
Which
I
Thought
Was
Really
Cool
Like
The
Experience
As
The
Fan
And
Connecting
All
Of
These
Different
Things
Because
Know
Like
Luke
Just
Said
Honestly
It
Doesn't
Matter
Where
The
Music
Is
If
The
Music
Is
Good
I'm
Going
Find
It
As
Far
As
Know
It
Gets
Before
My
Face
I'm
Going
To
Listen
To
It
And
Even
Just
This
Morning
I
Was
In
The
Creator
Head
Discord
Just
Speaking
To
Some
People
And
I
Was
Like
Hey
Have
Heard
About
Marty
Ray
Project
He
Is
Best
Known
For
This
Mix
Of
Our
Cover
For
Vanilla
Ice
Ice
Baby
Blew
Up
On
YouTube
My
Friend
Sent
It
To
Me
All
That
Stuff
That
Experience
Is
Cool
However
One
Of
My
Biggest
Goals
In
Web
3
As
Far
As
Music
Goes
Is
To
Have
A
Collaboration
Between
Him
And
Sammy
Ariega
I
Found
Him
Through
Strictly
Through
Web
3
During
Lockdowns
And
Pandemics
He
Was
Going
From
Room
To
Room
With
All
The
NFT
Communities
And
He
Was
Singing
Right
Through
The
Night
And
That
He
Grew
His
Fan
Base
So
Both
Of
These
Guys
Don't
Really
Fit
Into
A
Particular
Genre
Right
Marty
He's
Kind
Of
Soul
He's
Kind
Of
Country
He's
Kind
Of
Blues
And
He's
Got
A
Little
Bit
Of
Gospel
And
Hip
Hop
Sprinkled
In
Now
Have
Sammy
Ariega
Who
Is
A
Cuban
Country
Singer
From
Miami
That
Moved
To
Nashville
Got
Kicked
Off
Of
Sony
Because
He
Just
Doesn't
Fit
The
Mole
Right
So
Have
These
Two
Groups
Of
These
Like
Things
Of
The
People
That
Are
Not
Fitting
Into
The
Box
Of
The
Music
Industry
Right
Independent
Artists
And
Regardless
Of
If
They're
On
Spotify
Or
If
They're
Having
NFTs
On
These
Various
Platforms
Or
Whatever
I
Think
They're
Amazing
Music
Artists
And
Me
As
A
Fan
Now
Collecting
Sammy's
NFTs
And
Just
Listening
to
Marty
On
Spotify
And
All
These
Different
Things
I
Just
See
The
Opportunity
As
A
Fan
To
Have
The
Communication
Between
Both
Ends
And
Just
Kind
Of
Bridge
The
Gap
Now
It
Was
Easier
For
Sammy
Because
He
Was
In
Web3
And
A lot
Of
Artists
Who
Are
Web3
Natives
And
Such
Yeah
It
Makes
Sense
To
Build
There
Have
The
Opportunity
For
Communities
And
So
Find
us
But
Someone
Who
Has
No
Knowledge
Whatsoever
Of
Web3
It
Is
Hard
Sell
Because
It
Is
Hard
For
Me
To
Now
Approach
Marty
Like
Hey
I
See
That
Responded
To
A
Couple
Of
My
DMS
And
So
For
And
I
Want
To
Tell
About
NFTs
That's
A
Hard
Sell
However
I
Just
Said
Hey
Here's
This
Artist
That
Doesn't
Fit
A
Just
Like
That
Would
Be
Awesome
To
Have
A
Collab
And
Surprisingly
He
Just
Responded
He
Was
Like
Yeah
I
Be
Down
For
It
So
Now
It's
Like
One
Of
My
Goals
In
Life
Is
To
Just
Get
These
Two
To
Collab
I
Don't
Care
If
It's
On
Spotify
Or
If
It's
It's
For
Sale
The
Old
Fashioned
Way
If
It's
A
CD
I
I
Don't
Care
They're
Getting
My
Money
I'm
Spending
It
Because
I
Think
That
That
Is
One
Things
Is
Being
Bridged
Together
And
I
Don't
Care
Where
The
Music
Is
I
Just
Want
Good
Music
To
Happen
I
I
Agree
With
That
I
Definitely
Agree
With
That
Good
Music
That's
What
It's
All
About
Know
Just
Kind
Of
Listening
To
A
Couple
Of
The
Speakers
Share
Their
Thoughts
And
Insights
Two
Things
Really
Are
Starting
Patterns
Are
Starting
To
Form
For
Me
In
My
Mind
And
I'm
Going
To
Talk
About
It
From
More
Of
A
Developer
Kind
Of
Layer
One
Strategy
From
An
Infrastructure
Strategy
I'm
Going
To
First
Ask
Jen
Marie
What
Kind
Of
Genre
Of
Music
Do
Sing
Because
I'm
Going
To
Use
As
A
Use
Case
So
I
Actually
Sing
A
Lot
Of
Pop
In
R&B
But
I'm
Oklahoma
Gal
So
I've
Dabbled
In
The
Country
Way
Before
Beyonce
No
Shade
But
Mainly
Pop
In
R&B
Perfect
All
Right
Well
I
Hope
Don't
Mind
Me
Picking
On
But
I
Am
So
Know
Everybody
Everybody
Has
Been
Talking
About
Spreading
And
Splitting
Web
Two
And
Web
Three
Know
It's
It's
It's
Interesting
Being
A
UI
UX
Designer
For
Over
Two
Decades
And
Bringing
My
Talents
And
Experience
Over
To
Web
Three
Has
Been
Phenomenal
Because
It's
Been
A
Real
Eye
Opener
And
However
I
Think
That
A lot
Of
People
In
Web
Two
Space
User
Wise
Don't
Really
Realize
That
There
Are
Big
Companies
That
Use
Blockchain
Technology
Helping
Helping
These
Companies
Make
That
Transition
Has
Been
Kind
Of
My
Gateway
Into
This
System
As
Well
Into
The
Crypto
Into
Web
Three
And
It's
Primarily
In
The
Healthcare
Industry
That's
Doing
It
And
Know
If
If
We
Look
At
How
We
Can
Make
Tools
I
Think
It
Was
Luke
That
Brought
Up
The
Tools
That
Need
To
Be
Developed
That
Needs
To
Start
In
My
Opinion
At
The
Blockchain
Level
That's
What's
Going
To
Be
Scalable
For
Layer
2s
Layer
3s
As
They
Start
Building
On
A
Blockchain
To
Have
The
Infrastructure
For
Them
To
Be
Able
To
Create
That
Discover
That
Seems
To
Come
Up
Quite
A
Bit
In
A
Lot
Of
The
Speakers
Comments
And
Know
One
Thing
That
We're
Doing
That
We've
Been
Working
On
For
Quite
A
Few
Almost
A
Year
Now
Is
What
We
Call
Comment
It's
A
Content
Media
Tag
That
Automatically
Gets
Baked
Into
NFTs
That
Get
Minted
And
It's
Almost
Like
Metadata
Labels
Right
And
Those
Things
Are
Discoverable
Regardless
Of
The
You're
On
So
As
I
Mentioned
Before
Know
It'll
Help
With
The
Discovery
Of
New
Artists
That
Are
Coming
In
Versus
The
Well
Established
Ones
That
Are
On
Various
Platforms
The
The
The
Reason
The
Tool
Is
To
Help
The
Smaller
People
But
Likewise
If
Go
To
Social
Media
If
Go
To
Spotify
Apple
Know
And
Allow
Their
Algorithms
To
Influence
What
To
Play
Next
If
Haven't
Built
Your
Own
List
At
Their
Mercy
By
Implementing
This
Comment
Tag
Thing
It
Allows
People
To
Really
Create
Their
Own
Algorithms
And
Be
Able
To
For
An
Example
Tap
Into
Jen
Marie
Genres
That
She
Sings
With
Pop
I'll
Just
Use
The
Hashtag
Analogy
Of
Pop
Right
I
Can
Pull
In
Like
On
Twitter
Or
X
I
Can
Pull
In
All
The
Conversations
Around
That
Specific
Hashtag
And
It
Allows
Me
To
Discover
New
Things
As
Well
And
So
Really
People
Don't
Understand
The
Power
Of
That
And
How
Twitter
Has
Always
Been
That
Way
Sorry
X
I'm
An
Old
School
Twitter
Guy
But
Can
See
How
Can
Actually
Create
Your
Own
Algorithms
And
Listen
To
The
People
That
Want
To
Listen
Consume
The
Data
That
Want
To
Consume
In
A
Way
That
Want
To
Experience
It
And
That
Is
All
About
And
So
Like
I
Was
Know
Just
To
Wrap
This
Up
Is
It
All
Coming
Down
To
Artists
Like
Yourself
Jen
Talking
About
What
Need
As
An
Artist
To
Survive
Allow
Us
To
Make
Those
Products
For
So
That
Can
Focus
On
Being
What
Do
Best
An
Artist
Being
A
Singer
I'm
A
I'm
An
Artist
As
Well
And
I
Love
Doing
Art
And
I'm
A
Firm
Believer
That
Art
Comes
In
So
Many
Different
Forms
Not
Just
Music
Not
Just
Art
Know
I
Even
Like
To
Say
There
Are
Some
Real
Artists
Out
There
When
It
Comes
To
Crafting
Good
Quality
Twitter
Means
Know
That
Is
An
Art
In
Itself
So
Definitely
Open
Your
Mouth
Jump
Into
These
Groups
Because
There's
People
That
Like
Myself
That
Are
Developing
For
The
Future
And
We
Love
To
Hear
This
Feedback
Because
It
Helps
Drive
Us
And
Allows
Us
To
Know
Where
To
Go
Next
That's
Great
I mean
Yeah
Like
What
Would
Just
Explained
Sounded
A bit
Like
The
Community
Feature
On
Twitter
X
I
Mean
I'm
Also
Twitter
The
Guy
I
Like
To
Say
Twitter
Instead
Of
X
But
Within
That
Community
Group
Then
Kind
Of
Decide
How
The
Algorithm
Works
Is
That
Do I
Understand
It
Correct
So
Basically
Your
Audience
Will
See
Whatever
Think
Is
More
Important
Instead
Of
That
It's
Based
On
The
Likes
And
Clicks
Because
Someone
Know
Hands
Up
Clicking
A bit
Way
More
Than
Someone
Else
Basically
100%
Regardless
Of
Power
Of
What
We're
Trying
To
Build
100%
That
Sounds
Great
I
Mean
It
Sounds
Like
To
Keep
Drawing
Analogies
To
Where
We
Are
At
The
Moment
It's
Know
I
Know
I'm
Sure
Most
People
Won't
On
Say
For
Spotify
Check
What
Label
The
Tracks
Released
On
But
It's
All
Gathered
There
For
Them
To
Discover
So
We
Just
To
Be
To
Do
That
And
Kind
Of
Fragmentation
Of
Different
Chains
And
People
Being
Able
To
Deploy
Different
Things
In
Different
Places
It
At
The
End
Of
The
It's
Amazing
To
Open
Up
Those
Kind
Of
Opportunities
And
Choices
And
That's
Another
Byword
For
The
Ownership
Of
The
Music
Of
Where
Want
It
To
Be
And
How
Know
Whether
That's
One
Part
Of
It
But
That
Kind
Of
It
Also
Creates
That
Fragmentation
Of
The
User
Experience
Know
If
Somebody
Wants
To
Listen
To
Say
One
Band
They
Love
And
They
Want
To
The
Next
One
Are
They
Realistically
Going
To
Jump
Between
Different
Places
With
Different
User
Experiences
And
Different
They're
Not
Going
To
Do
It
Like
That's
The
One
Thing
As
Much
As
Know
The
Streaming
Services
From
An
Artist
Point
Of
Have
Been
Good
In
Building
The
Exposure
They've
Been
Detrimental
In
The
Financial
Sense
Potentially
They
Have
Created
That
Unified
Experience
For
Fans
Who
Are
The
Most
Important
Ones
Anyone
Could
Be
A
Musician
Or
Artist
But
It's
Almost
Pointless
If
You've
Not
Got
Fans
To
A
Certain
Degree
If
That's
What
You're
Looking
To
Do
In
Life
And
That's
Why
Fans
Have
Always
Got
To
Be
Kept
At
The
Forefront
Of
The
Thinking
Around
All
Of
This
All
The
Time
Yeah
I
Mean
Also
To
Touch
Up
On
The
Point
That
I
Mean
Spicy
And
Layer
One
X
Have
Been
Putting
Out
Is
Really
Like
Know
The
Infrastructure
Layer
Of
The
Business
Models
Really
Need
To
Be
Set
Here
Right
Like
If
We
Think
About
Know
Early
2000s
Like
And
We
Kind
Of
See
Where
We
Are
Today
Know
We're
Right
Now
We
We're
Grinding
We're
Putting
Our
You're
Putting
Your
Content
In
Terms
Of
Music
Right
Now
Everywhere
You're
Trying
All
These
New
Different
Things
People
Doing
The
Same
Thing
Early
2000s
They're
Ripping
Off
Their
CDs
Or
Mixtapes
And
Just
Like
Going
Everywhere
To
Try
To
Put
Their
Places
Using
The
Newest
Technologies
Which
Was
Know
For
Mixtapes
And
Figuring
Out
How
To
Rip
CDs
But
Then
Comes
I
Want
To
Make
Music
Accessible
To
Everybody
Like
I'm
Not
Sure
If
Everyone
Watched
The
Spotify
Movie
Right
Because
During
That
Time
If
One
Was
Pirating
Move
Music
And
Then
Pirate
It
From
Your
Computer
And
Then
Download
It
Into
Your
MP3
Or
Your
iPod
Or
Whatever
And
Then
Spotify
Comes
Out
Simplifies
That
Whole
Process
Makes
The
User
Experience
Very
Beautiful
It's
The
It's
The
Business
Models
Right
And
Somebody
Basically
Leading
The
Space
So
Know
I
Think
That
Is
Going
To
Be
Very
Important
For
Us
To
Find
These
People
Who
Are
Looking
To
Change
The
World
Right
Can
Have
And
It's
Usually
Just
One
Person
Just
Need
Somebody
Who
Really
Wants
To
Create
A
Platform
For
People
To
Utilize
This
New
Technology
To
Have
This
X
Y
Z
Benefits
Know
So
It's
The
Same
Thing
Same
Thing
With
Instagram
Right
Like
Instagram
Created
A
Platform
Now
We
All
Use
It
Twitter
Created
A
Platform
We
All
Use
It
And
Those
Of
Us
Who
Benefit
From
It
Right
Like
Your
Creator
Or
Your
X
Y
Z
It's
The
Platforms
That
Or
I guess
Business
Models
That
Are
Going
To
Know
Enable
This
For
The
Common
Person
Right
Same
Thing
With
McDonald's
Like
McDonald's
I mean
McDonald's
Is a
Kind of
Weird
Example
But
You know
They
Have
Systems
Put
In
Place
That
Enable
14
Year
Olds
17
Year
Olds
To
Run
A
Whole
Operating
Crazy
Business
So
And
That's
Going
To
Create
You know
New
Jobs
I
Don't
Know
I
Think
We
Should
Really
Be
Trying
To
Support
People
Who
Have
This
Vision
So
If
We
Have
If
Hear
Somebody
In
Your
Network
Hey
We
Want To
Do
X
Y
And
Z
Really
Right
Now
Spending
Your
Time
Maybe
10%
Of
Your
Time
To
Actually
Join
Their
Twitter
Join
Their
Discord
Really
Talk
To
The
Founders
And
Give
Them
That
Leg
Up
So
That
They
Can
Actually
Bring
This
Vision
There's
A lot
Of
People
Can
Try
Thousands
Of
Business
Models
Not
All
Of
Them
Are
Going
To
Work
But
If
We
Dog
Food
All
Those
Business
Models
We're
Going
To
Find
One
And
That
One
Is
Going
To
Enable
All
Of
The
Musicians
To
Actually
Succeed
In
This
Space
Won't
Be
Able
Do
It
By
Yourself
Right
So
We
Have
To
Kind
Of
Know
One
Artist
Is
Not
Going
To
Change
The
Whole
Entire
Space
Unless
You're
Like
Beyonce
Or
Taylor
Swift
Actually
She's
Propping
Up
The
U.S.
Economy
As
It's
A funny
Joke
Everyone
Know
If
You're
A
Creator
Know
Really
Go
Out
Of
Your
Out
Of
You're
Looking
To
Kind
Of
Know
Get
Involved
In
The
Space
Be
An
Early
Adopter
In
The
Space
Continue
To
Try
New
Things
Right
It's
Really
Important
It's
Not
Just
For
Yourself
It's
For
It's
For
Everybody
Other
People
Are
Going
To
The
Space
That
Don't
Have
To
Go
Through
The
Shit
That's
Kind
Of
Interesting
That
Said
That
Mentioned
The
Business
Models
Because
That's
One
Of
The
Things
That
Most
People
Throw
Back
At
The
Space
And
Say
It
Doesn't
Make
Any
Sense
Because
The
Business
Models
Aren't
Really
There
But
Those
Two
Examples
That
Use
Is
Kind
Of
Interesting
Because
Number
One
Spotify
Is
Profitable
For
The
Record
Companies
But
Spotify
Hasn't
Figured
Out
How
To
Make
And
Of
Course
We
Know
How
The
Artists
Are
Being
Treated
On
The
Platform
That's
Why
They
Dove
Into
Podcasting
So
Much
Is
Because
They're
Like
All right
There's
Less
People
To
Pay
If
We
Bring
On
Joe
Rogan
Right
We
Just
Cut
One
Big
Check
And
Everything
With
Ads
Is
On
Top
Of
That's
Profit
So
They're
Trying
A
Dabbling
All
Over
These
Different
Places
So
Even
The
Big
Average
Artist
But
Also
Even
McDonald's
Right
McDonald's
Had
That
Issue
When
They
Weren't
Really
Making
The
Money
From
The
Burgers
They
Had
To
Actually
Make
Money
From
Real
Estate
Most
People
Don't
Know
That
McDonald's
Corporation
Is
Really
A
Real
Estate
Company
And
The
People
That
Are
Running
The
Restaurants
Are
Making
The
Money
From
Selling
The
Food
But
That's
Another
Topic
In
Itself
So
Going
To
This
Whole
Thing
With
Music
Right
The
Gold
Goal
Of
It
Is
To
Get
Music
In
The
Ears
And
As
A
Fan
I
Know
It
Sucks
To
Hear
Artists
That
Are
Pouring
Their
Heart
Out
Into
Their
Their
Work
And
They're
Not
Being
Compensated
From
It
And
It
Really
Sucks
And
I
Would
Just
Say
That
People
That
Are
Exploring
To
Solve
These
Problems
Might
Think
Of
Something
Absolutely
Crazy
And
If
Ray
Kroc
Listened
To
People
And
Said
Hey
Become
A
Real
Estate
Company
And
Only
Focused
On
Burgers
And
Milkshakes
McDonald's
Wouldn't
Be
What
It
Would
Be
Today
Right
Or
With
In
The
Case
Of
Spotify
Well
Guys
Aren't
Making
Any
Money
Shut
Down
So
Just
Keep
Exploring
And
I
Think
It's
Really
Cool
And
Eventually
The
Music
Will
Find
Ears
And
I
Believe
I
Hope
That
Things
Will
Work
Itself
Out
Know
Yeah
I
Think
So
I
Think
A
Very
Interesting
Point
That
Made
There
About
How
The
Big
Companies
Are
Still
Figuring
Out
Themselves
Know
And
See
That
Like
Even
Something
Very
Successful
As
Starbucks
Is
Eventually
Experimenting
With
Web3
So
And
That's
Only
Because
Of
Us
Really
Right
It's
Only
Because
Of
The
What's
Going
On
About
Three
And
They
Kind
Second
Something
Is
Going
On
There
That
Is
Actually
Maybe
Valuable
To
Our
Customers
So
I'm
Quite
Interested
To
See
How
Like
Yeah
The
Big
Labels
And
Such
Will
Actually
Adapt
To
What's
Coming
Because
They
Have
To
Adapt
At
Some
Point
Right
Yeah
I
Just
Want
To
Add
One
More
Point
On
To
What
Tropic
Was
Saying
Especially
With
Spotify
I
Mean
With
That
Specific
Business
Model
That
Worked
I
That
They're
Currently
Using
Is
That
In
Web
Two
A
Lot
Of
It
The
Value
Does
Get
Placed
On
The
End
User
Like
Who
Actually
Is
The
Consumer
And
Then
Because
It's
Web
Two
The
Businesses
Obviously
Because
They
Own
All
The
Servers
They
Own
Obviously
Then
The
Emphasis
On
The
Customer
Is
Right
Customer
Know
The
Customer
Is
Always
Right
But
Now
What's
Cool
With
Web
Three
Is
That
The
Business
Model
Now
That
We
Can
Figure
Out
Is
Like
It
Actually
Now
Provides
Value
Back
To
The
People
Who
Own
It
Right
Because
That's
Obviously
Like
Know
Web
Own
It
Now
But
Yeah
And
Going
Back
Business
Model
Is
Everything
McDonald's
Would
Have
Failed
If
They
Didn't
Do
The
If
They
Didn't
Pivot
Into
The
The
Real
Estate
Business
Because
Obviously
Scaling
A
Business
Is
Really
Really
Difficult
And
So
For
Them
It
Was
Like
In
California
That's
Where
McDonald's
Started
It
Was
Very
Profitable
Very
Good
But
Like
Know
They
Couldn't
Scale
It
Because
The
The
Issue
Was
The
Quality
The
Consistency
Which
Is
Why
They
Had
To
Create
That
System
And
Then
Basically
They
Created
The
System
And
Their
Customer
Was
Actually
Selling
Entrepreneurs
The
Ability
To
Replicate
This
Business
But
They
Would
Actually
Own
The
Establishments
So
They
Made
Money
Off
The
Real
Estate
And
The
End
User
Set
Up
All
These
McDonald's
Because
Now
Have
Hundreds
Of
Thousands
Of
People
Want
McDonald's
So
The
Business
Model
Is
Very
Key
Here
Yeah
And
Just
To
Just
To
Follow
Up
On
That
I
Think
There's
Not
There
Was
The fear
With
The
Advent of
The
Streaming
Platforms
That
They
Like
Somebody
Was
Going
To
Lose
Out
Somewhere
Along
The
Line
Financially
And
Okay
Like
The
Scales
Kind of
Tipped
Against
The
Artist
If
Just
Look at
It
Purely
From
Streaming
Revenue
But
The
Upshot
For
An
Artist
Is
The
Ability
To
Get
To
More
People
Quicker
With
Much
Lower
Spend
Know
Can
Put
Stuff
On
Spotify
For
Know
Whatever
It
Cost
To
Put
Stuff
Through
Distro
Kid
Or
Whatever
And
Then
It's
On
Like
There's
A bit
Of
Like
A
Responsibility
On
The
Artist
As
Well
To
Adapt
Know
That
That's
The
Thing
Not
To
Be
To
Sit
In
Your
Bedroom
Play
Some
Stuff
And
The
World
Is
So
We
Built
A
Bigger
We've
Got
A
Bigger
Set
Of
Years
Listening
To
Us
We
Can't
Generate
The
Revenue
For
Ourselves
Here
So
We'll
We'll
Direct
Fans
To
Go
To
Merch
Or
Know
Which
Is
Still
Going
To
Be
An
Amazing
It's
Still
Really
Important
For
Artists
And
I
Imagine
We'll
Be
Forever
more
But
Then
They
Can
They
Got
That
Bigger
Audience
Or
Potential
Customer
Base
About
Artists
Being
Inventive
And
Adapting
They're
The
Ones
Who
Are
Going
To
See
The
Potential
Or
They're
Going
To
Think
Of
Uses
For
This
Stuff
That
Nobody
Has
Imagined
Yet
That's
Always
Going
To
Be
A
Really
Good
Thing
For
It
So
When
Somebody
First
Approached
Matt
And
I
A
And
Said
About
Doing
An
NFT
Drop
We
Didn't
At
The
View
Of
Them
At
The
Time
From
What
We
Understood
Them
To
Be
Just
Really
Expensive
JPEGs
And
Then
We
Saw
The
Underlying
Technology
Was
The
Important
Bit
Really
And
We
Started
To
See
The
Potential
Of
How
We
Could
Use
That
And
That
Is
Where
The
Really
Big
Innovations
Are
Going
To
Come
In
This
Space
Is
Somebody
Looking
at
It
From
A
Bit
Of
A
Skewed
Angle
That
Nobody
Else
Ever
Thought
Of
And
It's
Probably
It's
Going
To
Be
An
Artist
Somewhere
Along
The
Line
Who
Is
Going
To
Think
Of
That
Because
There's
Like
A
Certain
Type
Of
Screw
Have
To
Have
Loose
To
Want
To
Be
An
Artist
Anyway
So
Yeah
That's
That's
My
Take
On
That
Yeah
And
That's
A
Great
Point
I
Mean
That's
What
I'm
Saying
Have
To
Be
It's
Interesting
Because
Right
Now
We
Got
To
Understand
That
It's
Only
I
Think
It's
Only
Like
2.5
Or
5%
Of
All
Global
Engineers
Actually
In
Web3
It's
Very
Like
Web3
Engineers
Like
The
Engineers
In
The
Space
Is
So
Tiny
Compared
To
The
Actual
World
Right
And
If
Look
At
The
The
Just
Like
The
Power
Rule
Right
Know
The
More
People
In
The
Space
You're
Going
To
Have
More
People
With
Know
Screws
Loose
To
Actually
Want
To
Try
Something
Crazy
The
Cool
Part
Is
That
We
Are
All
Here
Building
The
Infrastructure
Right
We're
Building
D-Pens
Or
Know
D-Rens
And
All
This
Crap
Right
The
Cool
Part
Is
That
Once
We
Do
Hit
We
Start
Moving
More
Into
Mass
Adoption
Right
So
About
Two
Years
Bitcoin
Is
Over
100,000
It
Becomes
More
Legitimate
All
This
Blah
Blah
Blah
You're
Going
To
Have
Now
All
The
Engineers
That
Have
Never
Want
Like
Oh
Man
Web3
Is
Bullshit
Right
Because
Know
Sometimes
A lot
Of
Engineers
Think
That
Way
A lot
Of
Engineers
Are
More
They
Don't
Like
Know
They're
Very
Like
Not
All
The
Time
Multifaceted
Like
They're
Just
Like
They
Love
To
Just
Look
At
One
Problem
And
Just
Do
That
So
Know
Once
That
Happens
You're
Going
To
Start
Pouring
In
From
Two
To
Five
Percent
And
That
Fifteen
Percent
Twenty
Percent
Twenty
Five
Maybe
At
Twenty
Percent
Right
You're
Just
Going
To
Unlock
That
One
Engineer
And
Now
He
Comes
In
The
Space
He
Really
Understand
All
And
He
Might
Be
Someone
Who's
Actually
In
The
Music
Industry
And
Engineer
In
The
Music
Industry
Probably
Spotify
He's
Like
Oh
Yeah
I
See
All
He
Knows
How
To
Build
All
The
Infrastructure
Which
Is
Interesting
Because
My
CTO
Actually
Was
A
Staff
Engineer
At
Spotify
But
Is
That
They're
Going
To
Come
In
They
Automatically
Just
Be
Like
Oh
Wow
Like
Everyone
Knows
How
To
Use
Deep
Ends
Everybody
Knows
How
To
Use
X
Y
And
Z
There
There
There
There
This
API
There
This
Infrastructure
They
Just
Put
It
All
Together
Try
It
And
Boom
Now
There's
That
The
Solutions
Out
There
I
Love
That
I
Think
It's
Well
Like
Know
Like
Said
Like
That
Share
Of
Engineers
Developers
Is
Going
To
Grow
And
People
Are
Going
To
See
More
And
More
Opportunity
With
The
Technology
While
They
Can
And
On
What
Luke
Touched
On
The
Artist
It's
Also
Their
Responsibility
Right
Like
Know
It's
It's
Not
Enough
To
Just
Be
Like
I'm
A
Really
Good
Artist
I
Make
Music
In
My
In
My
Batroom
And
No
One
Listen
To
It
Right
So
It's
Also
Up to
Them
To
Experiment
With
Whatever
Is
Available
To
See
What
Connect
Next
But
Also
I
Think
Very
Importantly
Like
What
Converts
Because
If
Have
A
Platform
Spotify
Where
Can
Get
A
Lot
Of
Streams
That's
Just
Eyeballs
So
That
Doesn't
Necessarily
Have
To
Convert
Into
Know
A
Certain
Amount
Of
Dollar
Value
But
If
Have
Those
Eyeballs
It's
Up
To
To
Then
Convert
It
Into
Value
Right
And
Whether
That
Is
Know
With
Other
Things
Like
Merge
Whether
It's
With
Things
Like
Know
NFTs
It
Could
Be
It
Could
Be
That
Create
Something
Very
Simple
Very
Accessible
That
Fans
Can
Can
Actually
Access
And
Own
And
Then
Back
Into
This
Like
Music
Ownership
And
Maybe
Hand
Over
Some
Of
Your
Ownership
Of
The
Music
To
Fans
And
In
That
Way
Might
Be
Able
To
Increase
That
Value
Not
Of
Your
Own
Music
Piece
Initially
But
Of
That
Customer
Or
That
User
There's
A
Lot
Of
Way
Where
Could
Utilize
Web3
To
Solve
Ownership
Or
The
Other
Issues
That
Music
Might
Face
Katie
I
See
Got
Your
Hand
Up
Just
Want
To
Add
Something
Oh
Hi
And
Thank
So
Much
For
Having
Me
As
A
Speaker
I
Believe
That
Spicy
Had
The
Hand
To
Me
So
If
They
Want
To
Speak
I
Happy
To
Wait
My
Turn
I
Appreciate
That
Man
Thank
So
Much
Katie
Yeah
No
I
Just
Wanted
To
Say
I
Didn't
Want
To
Drop
Out
The
Space
But
I
Do
Have
To
Go
I
Got
Another
Call
And
I
Got
Another
Space
In
15
Minutes
But
This
Was
A
Dope
Space
I
I
Will
Definitely
Follow
Everyone
Here
Thanks
For
Having
Us
As
A
Guest
But
Yeah
Definitely
Look out
For
More
Pop
X
Spaces
In
The
Future
Man
This
Is
A
Really
Cool
One
I
Haven't
Dabbled
A
Lot
Into
The
Music
Spaces
But
I'm
Definitely
Going to
Utilise
Pop
X
As
One
Of
Those
For
Sure
I
Feel
Like
I
Got
A
Lot
Of
Value
From
This
Thank
So
Much
Spaces
Yeah
Like
Your
Contribution
Was
Really
Appreciated
I
Think
Yeah
Dropped
A
Few
Good
Things
And
If
You're
If
You're
Dropping
Off
Now
Join
Our
Discord
We're
Dropping
Some
Announcements
Which
Might
Like
Yeah
Pop
X
Thanks
For
Thanks
For
Having
Us
Thanks
Okay
Katie
Thank
So
Much
And
I'm
So
Pleased
That
Spicy
Again
I'm
Just
Calling
Out
By
Your
Username
Spicy
But
I'm
So
Pleased
That
They
Got
To
Speak
And
Give
Their
Thanks
And
Say
Bye
But
This
Is
A
Really
Interesting
Topic
And
Obviously
I've
Already
Just
Jumped
On
And
I
Appreciate
Having
Me
Up
Here
As
A
Speaker
But
It's
Something
I'm
Incredibly
Passionate
About
Especially
With
The
Future
Of
Music
And
The
Trajectory
Of
Where
It's
It's
Almost
Foreseeable
Where
It's
Going
To
Go
In
That
Digital
Space
Especially
With
The
Project
Such
As
Stems
NFTs
And
So
On
And
So
Forth
And
One
Of
The
Big
Questions
I
Often
Find
Myself
Asking
Is
Know
In
The
Music
Industry
There
Are
The
Likes
Of
ASCAP
BMI
That
In
The
USA
Are
Well
What
Would
I
Describe
Them
As
They're
The
No
They're
Not
Publishers
But
Somewhat
Of
The
Facilitators
For
The
Royalties
To
Be
Collected
Well
Facilities
For
The
Royalties
To
Be
Collected
And
Also
Have
PRS
And
MCPS
So
When
Write
Your
Song
Copyright
That
And
Almost
Digitally
Stamp
It
In
So
Which
Shape
Or
Form
I
Speak
From
Experience
Just
Those
That
Don't
Know
I'm
As
Historically
A
Songwriter
I've
Been
With
PRS
And
MCPS
Well
Like
From
The
Beginning
Many
Many
Years
But
Prior
To
Them
I
Used
To
Put
My
CD
Into
An
Envelope
And
Send
It
To
Myself
Recorded
Delivery
And
That's
How
One
Would
Copyright
It
And
The
Song
Splits
Etc
But
Now
That
The
Music
Is
Now
That
Music
Is
Being
So
Like
Split
And
Broken
Apart
Which
Is
Not
Necessarily
A
Bad
Thing
It's
Very
Very
Very
Important
For
The
Creators
Or
The
Creatives
Be
It
The
Writers
The
Musicians
The
Vocalists
So
On
And
So
Forth
To
To
Rightfully
Be
Paid
And
Have
Some
Type
Of
Licensing
To
Use
Those
Stems
So
I
Had
Spoken
To
The
Guys
That
Are
Currently
Building
Out
My
Company
Owl
OWHL
Platform
We're
Here
To
Oversee
The
Welfare
Human
Rights
And
Liberty
For
All
Those
In
The
Creative
Industry
Sector
And
I
Said
How
Can
There
Be
A
Digital
Way
A
Web
Three
Way
Shout
Out
Pop
X
To
Almost
Blockchain
This
So
That
People
Feel
That
There
Is
Legitimacy
And
Know
A
Clear
Channel
Of
Ownership
Over
What's
Rightfully
Yours
But
Then
The
Ability
To
Independently
License
That
So
Everybody
Can
Benefit
Know
From
A
Monetary
Standpoint
As
Well
As
A
Usage
Standpoint
So
How
Do
Track
That
So
I
Find
This
Incredibly
Fascinating
I'm
Again
New
To
The
Space
And
Loving
Listening
Thank
For
Letting
Me
Speak
I
Will
Continue
To
Listen
And
I'm
Having
Been
In
The
Music
Industry
For
Decades
Wow
I'm
So
Old
I
Really
Am
Oh
My
God
I'm
More
Than
Happy
To
Answer
Any
Questions
That
Anyone
May
Have
Also
So
Thank
For
Letting
Me
Share
Share
Share
With
100%
Katie
No
Are
Yeah
And
Yeah
Just
To
Kind
Of
To
Talk
About
What
Katie
Was
Saying
About
The
PRS
The
MCPS
They
Do
Amazing
Work
For
Artists
They
They're
On
The
Artist
Side
They
Make
Sure
That
People
Are
Paying
They
Even
Down
To
The
Local
Salon
Who
Has
Got
The
Radio
Play
And
They
Make
Sure
They
Pay
Their
Memberships
Because
That
Money
Will
Feedback
To
Artists
And
Support
Artists
That
Way
And
Them
And
All
The
Around
The
World
They've
Been
Able
To
That
With
Web
2
Technology
So
I
See
Web
Technology
As
Something
That's
Going
To
Make
It
Even
Easier
For
Them
To
Do
And
I
Know
There
Are
People
In
This
Space
Already
Working
On
That
Where
They
Can
Almost
Provide
Real
Time
Data
About
Where
A
Particular
Song
Is
Being
Played
Luke
I'm
So
Sorry
To
Jump
In
Here
Don't
Mute
Yourself
Please
Be
Up
Here
With
Me
I
Think
That
The
Way
That
Web
Three
Is
Going
To
One
Million
Percent
Benefit
People
Or
Creators
Or
Creatives
Musicians
Artists
Is
That
It
Eliminates
The
Record
Labels
And
Publishing
People
And
Platforms
That
Know
Have
The
Deals
With
Them
To
Take
Oh
What
Do
Call
It
Know
When
Somebody
Takes
An
Old
School
Track
And
They
Sample
It
It
Puts
The
Power
Or
The
Rightful
Ownership
Back
Into
The
Creator
Or
Creatives
Hands
Where
It's
It's
Not
Necessarily
Coming
From
The
Industry
And
You're
Right
ASCAP
BMI
PRS
MCPS
PPL
All
Of
The
Shout
Out
To
All
Of
The
Acronyms
But
They
Are
On
The
Artist
Side
Absolutely
However
It's
A
Very
It's
A
Difficult
Situation
When
The
Actual
Creator
Or
The
Artist
It
Has
Either
A
Session
With
When
They
Are
Have
They've
Got
A
Contract
With
The
Record
Label
And
Perhaps
That
Is
Sneakily
Put
In
There
That
The
Record
Label
Owns
Copyright
For
NFTs
Or
Stems
And
You're
Basically
Signing
Where
Your
Licensing
Right
So
Nobody
Wants
To
Do
That
Ever
It's
A
Bigger
Systemic
Problem
But
I
Think
That
The
Way
That
Web3
Can
Fix
This
Is
By
Putting
The
Ownership
Back
Into
The
Creators
Or
Creatives
Hands
help break that artist which historically with an artist would get that funding from otherwise
is you know it just wouldn't be there so they they still have their place they're still part
of the music community because it's one of the very few kind of endeavors that humans go around
that the word community is often kind of put straight after the kind of thing of music so
they they do have a part to play i think but i think they've also as you know as well as
artists being caught out with the advert of streaming and downloading all that kind of
labels got caught out by it and got terrified by it and they reacted in a certain way to make deals
with the kind of streaming places to kind of protect their business model which you can completely
understand but the before like the artists going forward now they're yeah there's going to be
the ability for you know when you go into a session you do the songwriting or whatever that
the contracts around that are kind of done and dusted and dealt with and minted on the blockchain
while the session's happening so that everyone in the room's comfortable everyone's just everyone
knows that they're being looked after and being paid and everyone go off and do the bit they really
enjoy because you know artists probably the last thing they want to do is talk legals and stuff but
it is very very important i think having the ability to kind of have technology underpinning this that
again it comes back to the experience of being able to use the technology the moment that that
that kind of moment comes is when artists will use it and then they once they understand the use case for
this kind of thing and how it can help them whether it's protecting them legally financially creatively or
however else then they will start to use it but for the moment it's for an artist who isn't in the
space doesn't you know understand it potentially to make that leap between them writing a song in a
room with a load of people and an nft or any kind of other web3 based product that would
help facilitate that kind of agreement it's such a leap for them to make that they're not necessarily
going to make that at the moment and it's a part of the job of people who are in the space and
at the forefront of this to kind of do that education piece i'm a bit confused because i
understand what i'm so sorry but i i understand and i know i see you real um and king and you guys
got your hands up i i'll land my plane i promise i uh listen i understand when it comes to record labels
um historically back in the day prior to this whole deconstruction of uh a record um you only have
to put into your your web browser and search what's going on in in the music industry in the future of
um concerts music festivals i see this music music festivals and entertainment the digitization of
everything that's the future so the record labels and publishers they're not okay i can't say that
um not everybody that works for these companies are big bad wolves but at the end of the day they are
businesses and they have um uh you know a company where they also want to make a profit unfortunately
there is such a lack of transparency with artists i've been there myself um and i'm not resentful if
anything i want to make it better just as much as you do so i guess the question i have for you
is if you're stating that this technology is going to be great for you know educating people then even
um as to what you guys provide and so on and so forth in the studios really isn't it shouldn't you be
speaking to the record labels and and and presenting it to them um because i get when somebody is not
and they are not signed or to either a record label or a publisher and you can just go and do a writing
session with your friend um you know turn up someone's house sure and then you're like okay
it's a 50 50 split but you know if that's in an email even that still stands in the court floor
from a copyright standpoint but when that person then further maybe is signed to a publisher and
then that publisher has done a deal with whomever to to take some of the stems from the track that
you've written and then yet that person's on your blockchain but the other person isn't like how
does this all work in the grand scheme of things or do you think that you you might be best seen
doing a deal with say for example prs and mcps that you can provide them the service so they can
onboard your services to then advance forward because i don't believe they're doing this yet
no i mean so i mean we've we've spoken to and we we have done stuff with labels directly um
because obviously with different artists of different levels the artist may want to do it
but they have to get the labels agreement so we've we've done that piece of kind of speaking to labels
and i'm sure a lot of people here have had the same kind of thing where you you approach uh somebody
who hasn't kind of interacted with the technology yet you say nft blockchain smart contract or any of
the kind of words that they've seen on the news and they just put the barriers up straight away
the job that we've had then and our responsibility is to kind of say right
strip strip that away a minute this is what it enables so you know we've done a couple of drops
where bands or artists have released nfts that have also come with a copy of the album
completely owns no kind of thing around it like you know you you own it but you only as long as we say
you do kind of thing but the fans actually own the music once they they've got it they've got a copy
of it it's like they bought the cd but it also was one-to-one counted as a sale for the official uk charts
so the same as somebody so somebody buying that nft essentially added one album sale to that artist
and we had like you know skin dreads at number two and sleep token at number three so that then and
they're both on like labels who you know we had to speak to labels and the labels then saw actually
okay so there is a a use case to this where the artist can do something innovative the fans can get
something new and exciting and i'm idea so the label made some money as well and you know so there's
everybody's everybody's a stakeholder in this in some way or another and you know we you know as an
artist obviously want artists to be looked after massively from this as a fan and remembering being
like in the shop buying the cd again it's signed by the for the band i love i can i want to make
sure that experience is saxophone and somebody right at the top said about you know owning a cd and like
you know that experience like opening the cd and reading the album sleeve back to back and oh that's
nice he thanked his mum or he thanked his dad that kind of stuff like that's an experience so we just
need to create those kind of feelings and those experiences but for every stakeholder in music
and i'm going to stop talking now because i see a few people got their hands up
yeah great conversation
katie and luke um really because you've got your hand up for a while and
after that we go to king julian
hey how you guys doing um thanks for inviting me up uh just a tiny bit of background i've been i've
been producing um my company's been producing concerts in virtual reality for about six or seven
years and i've worked with um billy eilish post malone paul mccartney kanye offset young thug sort
of a a large list of the of the music industry and we clear we clear all our own rights um so i have
i have a i have a a pretty deep knowledge base um i'm not a music supervisor but i have a pretty deep
knowledge base in in how to clear how to clear music for um unusual platforms and we have done
we have cleared rights for blockchain streaming concerts with uh we did one of the angels and
airwaves where we where we issued nfts during the concert and cleared them and cleared the streaming
rights so you know i i love the concept of of web3 and of web3 and blockchain rights and nft rights
and being able to do that i can see very clearly the path that it takes um i also have a very very
realistic um idea of the hurdles that it faces in becoming truly accepted for an artist that is a new
artist that is coming onto the scene now it's it is it is easier but it is still very much not
straightforward if you want to be both if you wanted to be part of the performer if you want to
if you want to do bmi ascap um you have to first of all do you have to deal with that and then if you
want to do publishing rights then you have to deal with the publishing rights organizations and to be
able to get your and to be able to register there and be able to do everything there and also um every
you know take hip-hop is a good example um we did a we did a show with post malone and post malone
has there was one song i remember that had 23 writer 23 writer credits um every single one is
is a publishing distribution and every single one has to be tracked down by a music supervisor and most
of those people most of the rights holders most of the people that are listed as rights holders
are not technical people they are not people that are going to be on a that are going to be on a
block chain or know how to access uh or know how to how to access that so if you have single songwriter
if you have songwriters or bands where the rights are fairly straightforward then you can put those
on a chain and have those distributed and you can create sort of a new ecosystem of how to deal with
rights management um across web3 but as soon as you talk about anything that that becomes legacy
or honestly as soon as those artists get to the point where they are dealing with labels and
they are dealing with um some kind of a worldwide distribution network and you at a certain point
as a big artist you kind of have to deal with labels and you have to deal with the infrastructure
that exists because there's too much work to do to keep your career going as an artist for you and
your small team to handle it the business of being a big artist is a big business it's it requires a team
of dedicated professionals to make sure that your career is continuing to move forward so that you can
focus on being a creative so you know i i do love it and i want to and i'm i'm trying to help solve
those problems we have done a lot of a lot of work in clearing rights in in a web3 world at a very
realistic level with big artists but my god it was it's it is it is difficult and the existing
infrastructure really needs to be ripped down and rebuilt um everybody anybody who's dealt with
large-scale publishing and has cleared rights for distribution like i have everybody knows that
that especially publishing rights is a giant rickety cluster of a system but it is the only one
we've got and nobody has yet come up with a good way to to replace things that has buy-in from the
label side management side and artist side so it's it is it is a very very it's a hard problem
it's not a hard problem technically it's a it's a hard problem at a human level it is a hard problem
technically when you start thinking about the sheer amount of transactions that would have to take
place um for the music industry writ large to to move into some kind of a web3 infrastructure so
thanks guys i i like i love the conversation i love hearing solutions and trying to figure this out
because i do think it's important because publishing is is creaky and rickety and deserves
to be replaced but uh how to do it is going to be hard lovely guys a great contribution there um
king julian do you want to add something enough that i'm going to wrap it up for tonight
yeah yeah i mean definitely should wrap it up but uh yeah that was a beautiful uh explanation there
um real luck um yeah i completely agree with you i mean the technical side of it is um not the problem
it's the human side and it probably goes in line with that you know music is um by nature very human
right there's not much there's not a lot of technical stuff that goes into music like we like to enjoy
music just as humans it's it's quite uh native to um you know every culture um and uh going back with
like the you know the label i just wanted to add just for you know just a small snippet that um
um even in web 3 on the d5 side um obviously it moves a lot faster because it's more technology
driven and um a lot of uh money as well um is that you you we still have it's the same thing as
when you're looking at the the wall street and you're looking at um you know decentralized finance
or there's always going to be the centralized element there um and then the decent and then
the decentralized element and you basically split the world into like there's two different worlds
there right um you can't be on fiat and and on chain at the same time so people do have to make
a cross there um so probably with the publishing i'm not i'm not i'm not in the music space i'm in
defy but um is that you're going to start finding more native label um publishers right they're more
like web 3 native um and uh so a lot of the maybe the the artists that uh want to go on web 3 they're
going to have to deal more with the native artists versus traditional because there is a whole
infrastructure there that everything needs to be re um redone right for that actually to work which
is basically what we're building right now in web 3 you're rebuilding all the infrastructure for web 3
but then all the people who actually you know have all the connections they're all already um you
know used to a specific uh infrastructure so um yeah that's that's one my only point there but
like yeah that's a good point you know i think i think yeah like the it's different segments really
uh what i hear and um that will be there for a while you know and who knows maybe maybe we'll
have a centralized and a decentralized uh a second for forever now um it's it's interesting
a really really really good conversation i think we need to keep uh we need to bring this topic back
about music and ownership um i don't think the last word has been sad about it um yeah this space
has been running over more than an hour so i'm gonna wrap it up for tonight but every week um same
time we'll be back next week we'll be back and if anyone is interested in owning a piece of music
uh we'll drop something tomorrow so just join our discord and we'll be
an announcement tomorrow and um yeah like for music fans and collectors
you will like it i think so um hope to see everyone next week
thank you so much thanks everyone
Want more TVL for your protocol or chain?
AlphaGrowth grows TVL for protocols and chains through asset acquisition and integration, grants, incentives and LP deals. We built this data and keep it free.