Cardano: Let's Talk About It

Recorded: Nov 19, 2026 Duration: 1:17:49

Space Recording

Open Original Space
0:00 1:17:49

Full Transcription

Oh,
oh.
Oh,
oh.
Oh,
oh.
Oh,
oh.
Oh,
oh.
Oh,
oh.
Oh, oh.
Oh,
oh.
Hello. Welcome to the Let's Talk About It space. My name is Nicholas Chani.
I'll be your moderator for today's session, and today we'll. Cover all of the questions
of the community that have been discussed recently, whether that is about Veridian,
whether about the treasury withdrawal that the Cardano Foundation submitted for
the global event strategy, and also how the community holds Cardano holds us in
the Cardano Foundation accountable. And really, no question is off the table. So. Before we dive in,
I also want to highlight there will be time at the end of this space,
the last fifteen to twenty minutes, for your questions. For you to come on this stage
and ask any of the speakers any questions that you might have. But if you're unable to do so,
you can also leave a question that you might have as a comment to the space,
or if it's not possible to the space, you can go to the post that announced the space
and put it there. The team is taking a look at that, and I'll make sure to address that question
as well. So today we have a. All-star lineup of speakers, and let me just quickly hand it over.
First and foremost, I think he's already on this stage, and if not, it's just a glitch in my UI.
But Fred, I think you're with us. Welcome. Thank you very much. Yeah, I was just kicked out
a few times, but I think I'm somehow surviving now in the app. I can hear you. I can hear you.
So great that you made it on time. So Fred. Five years ago, Cardano only had one node client,
or even until last year, and also no on-chain governance. And today we have on mainnet
the Haskell node, Amaru, Dingo. I also checked it, Bean and Sunagi who produced blocks already.
We have a community treasury, and things like CIP 113 all on mainnet. And I want your honest take on
what's working on Cardano and what isn't. Oh, that's a that's a nice open-ended question, huh?
I think a lot of things working on Cardano, and had the honor of just joining the ambassador
call a little bit earlier today to talk to the ambassadors about what I'm really excited about
at the moment. I think we definitely see that the threat landscape has changed dramatically
with the introduction of AI, but I think that's actually really an opportunity for Cardano.
But it also means that there's much more pressure on Cardano than there ever was before in terms
of operational resilience. And as you alluded to, I'm super excited to see that we not only have
one amazing node team with a node producing node and the Haskell team, but that Amaro Dingo
is also up running. And I see huge optimizations and maybe differentiations among them,
but also very good collaborative spirit, as we saw in London last week at
the Node Diversity Workshop. So I think that's working, you know, and starting really to pay off.
And this is specifically because of the threat landscape. I'm so excited about it because in order
for us to really stay relevant, Cardano was built in such a way that trusted as the forefront.
So we really need to stay up and always be up. So I'm very excited about that.
I'm also very excited about that we finally got Z113. So basically programmable tokens
over the line. For me, that means a lot because there's a big chunk of the tradfi business
and also a part of the DeFi business we were not able to do, even though we had
superior architecture. And this relates more to sort of what's You know what's required in the
in the real world outside blockchain, which some of us have to interact with from time to time
because we are human beings. But the fact that we now can you know we can have a blacklisting,
whitelisting, and and all those kind of you know things embedded not just in a smart contract
but directly in a canonical native asset. Plus, that we are getting fireblocks on live.
Here in the end of Q1 puts us in a really unique opportunity for actually countering this narrative
that has been that you know everything should just be tokenized for tokenization's sake.
Now what you now can tokenize on Cardano actually becomes a superior product,
which really makes us competitive around the world. And then if you look at operation resilience,
Cardano knock on wood not being down, the amazing work from stake pool operators,
the security council and others will ensure that we are keeping that promise.
I think we have a fantastic value proposition. Then I also think that the partnership program
grows from strength to bring to strength. So you know, not just to mention a few who is
really exciting is of course Petrobras, DFX Bar, the Syngenta Foundation, Trivolve Tech,
really changing. The social systems and the social fabric, Blockforce with a live DPP
you know implementation. But even bigger than that, what I think a lot of people have missed with
the Blockforce integration is that they're doing two really unique things.
One is they're connecting the whole world of Hyperledger to the Cardano blockchain
and using Cardano as it was built as a layer of trust. Where basically the business logic lies in
Hyperledger, but Cardano is the trust layer, but also the reporting layer to the regulator.
And the other part is that is using the Parisa Merkle trees, which came out of
the Cardano Foundation engineering teams a couple of years back, which is again something which,
for instance, the Ethereum ecosystem has been dreaming on for for ages to do something like that
and has not been able to execute. So and then of course Midnight is going strong
as you probably seen right. So very excited about privacy, and we now have
multiple privacy tracks right. So we have Midnight with complete privacy as a as a partner chain,
and then you know the Cardano native assets on chain with Cardano, but we also have a couple
of projects who's come really far in terms of you know native privacy on Cardano,
and that's of course not the same layer of privacy as Midnight, but really allows you to do
selective disclosure for instance or cloaked assets, but you still see the addresses right,
but you don't see the amounts and you don't see you know metadata and all those things.
And that opens up for you know some beautiful use cases. Then accelerations through
Draper University, UCLA, Anderson University of Nicosia. You know, yeah,
I'm just blown away that we see such big partners who really recognize this the Cardano technology,
the maturity of our blockchain, but also the community and how the community can scale to
also start bringing external assets, so external funding into Cardano.
So I think that's just to highlight a few things on top of my mind which works really well.
That's great, Fred. And and also maybe to to double click on the post that you mentioned
and that you wrote on Sunday. In there, I think one one of the things that you already addressed was
sort of this claim that midnight was left out. And but you just mentioned that,
so maybe you could you could quickly highlight also where midnight's midnight fits into the picture
of Cardano that you have. Yeah, so the way we look at it in the Cardano Foundation is
that after the introduction of Intersect as a membership-based organization to to represent
the whole community, we allowed ourselves to change slight focus from the original focus of
the Cardano Foundation, as the membership-based or sort of more like the the organization
who's covering everybody, to really looking at who is in the top twenty leaderboard.
And maybe somebody can share that in the in the space here, right? But on Cardano.org, there's
and you know we have a leaderboard, right? And what we said is we want to focus really hard
on Who is in the top 20 in the leaderboard, and how do we get them to do more transactions?
And who could become a new top 20 in the leaderboard? And then we're looking also at the diversity
of those use cases. And I think I was in there looking today. I believe that Midnight was around
number eight, seven or eight in terms of transactions right now in the last 30 days on Cardano,
and that definitely means that there are focus area for the Cardano native assets called Night,
which is of course issued on Cardano. This has brought a lot of attention to Cadenas.
Brought a lot of opportunities. We've been helping in terms of exchange integration,
as you've probably seen. I've been talking a lot about it with in with newspaper articles,
journalists on stage, and so on. So we would love that they would do more transactions
and and so on, right? But there is a distinction here, right? So for instance,
as far as we can see with the current tech stack, right, so. When we look at things like TVL, right?
Night is counted as TVL on Cardano, right? But what's happening on the actual partner chain might be
different in terms of how that is connected. But again, Midnight is just in the launch phase, right?
They have a version of a main net which is out now, and I expect a lot more to come from
that technology. But it is definitely something we are very excited about.
But it also shows the path or one of the mega trends we are seeing right now,
and that is really well again. Documented, we see permission blockchains scaling down, Hyperledger,
R3 Corda, and so on. And there's actually a huge opportunity in trying to go after those ecosystems
because they spend a lot of resources in terms of cash out, but also in terms of money,
to to develop business logic and use cases, and it just Was not really profitable.
It was not better, smarter, cheaper. But the knowledge is there, the repos are there,
the people are there, the clients are there. And what we have now, for instance,
is we have a good connection through Blockforce, which basically allows you to move Hyperledger
into Cardano, but still having the business logic in the permission space. Right? We have
native privacy. Principles of cryptography on Cardano, so BLS signatures and so on.
And we actually did that in—we built on it, and it was Charles who basically introduced it
two years ago. So we have that now in Java. Then we have the opportunity
with the partner chain Bitnine to go complete private, right? And that gives us
a fantastic opportunity for commercialization. But I think that also kind of relates a little bit to
what I think is not going so well for Cardano, and that is that we build the best blockchain
and partner chains in the world, and now really need to look at you know commercialization
and adoption. And that was never the Cadano Foundation's role or the mandate.
But I don't really care about you know who should be doing what and why.
I care about who's doing something going forward, and I think we need to really agree on that.
We need to harvest and put a certain amount of resources as a community towards adoption
and towards commercialization, and we need to coordinate that better. So a shared
and coordinated commercial roadmap and a better budget allocation as an ecosystem is something
I would really like to see in order for us to get much more adoption on chain.
And there we also probably need to understand what that is. Sorry to cut you in,
but speaking about adoption, I would also like to hand it over to the other esteemed colleagues,
Andreas and Stephen. Maybe Andreas, for you, speaking about adoption catalysts, right?
The Catalyst pilot recently Danny shared that went from twelve selected teams down to seven,
and yeah, I would like also for you maybe to talk about the transition from Catalyst
and what the next phase for for them basically is. And welcome. Thank you. Absolutely. I mean,
as as you all know, we onboarded the Catalyst team earlier this year, and the major focus
in this transition was the stabilization of the running funds. So making sure
that all the currently selected funds by the community are executed and delivered according to
the plan. The team has done an amazing job. They have been so amazing that we were continuously
able to reduce the team further to actually a current strength of five people, and that team is.
Doing multiple things. First of all, continue the wind down and execution of the previous funds.
They have also managed to bring up a concept for a new Catalyst pilot program,
which you just mentioned has gone into quite a really nice and closer curation circle,
and listened a lot to the community feedback that we have received of what went wrong
and what went right in the previous Catalyst funds. And Danny and the team have done
a phenomenal job to bring a pilot out, to listen to the community, and to bring in a lot of change.
So today's pilot program is completely about that catalyst is paying for adoption
and not promises anymore. And we have gone through multiple curation phases now
with all the projects that have handed in purpose-driven projects, and then being selected through
different. Catalyst decision panels from the community, together with the Corano Foundation,
and we curated through the whole process. Selected twelve final catalyst candidates for the pilot,
and then during the onboarding phase, we went through a bit more scrutiny and due diligence,
and really highlighted what can really be delivered, what are potential challenges and potentials
slight mismatches between what is expected by the community to be delivered versus
what was promised initially. The good thing about it is, really, during this onboarding process,
we had a significant learning experience, and I think every single project understood what were
the challenges and why maybe the moment was not the right one to go into the catalyst program,
and maybe come back later with a few changes and improvements to have a higher success rate
in the delivery. So, what comes next? We are running this pilot now with the seven projects.
Along the line, we are already outlining how the next future catalyst program can look like.
And we are working on this hard, and the idea is to come out in early 2027 with a proposal
to the community to first sound it, vet it together with the community,
and then if we are in agreement, the catalyst team would then submit the proposal,
a treasury withdrawal to fund the next catalyst cycles. That's very exciting to hear. Thanks,
Andreas. And Stephen, I know you are—you very much care about
this entire onboarding funnel slash builder journey that exists on Cardano.
Maybe you would like to share more about that. Also, how the what the Cardano Foundation
does fits fits into that with the accelerator and the academy and all of these things. Absolutely.
So on the builder journey this year, when we spoke to builders and founders,
one question keeps coming up: Why Cardano? Why build here? And what support is there here?
And we've been building a lot of programs over the past few years, but this year was about
joining them up into one deliberate path, so that builders and founders are supported from one step
to the next through their journey. So we say learn, build, accelerate, and scale,
and wherever you are on the path, there's a way in and the next step. So let's just go through
them quickly. So on the learn side, we have the Cardano Academy. We have courses
on our own platform, but we also have partnerships with universities, which Fred touched on earlier.
Next up is Catalyst, which as a you know the project gets a little Further along,
the ideas get going, and Andres just covered that. Now, once a team becomes a company,
the idea gets more formal, and now needs some funding, and we think about the accelerate path
and to build up that team and get the product out. And that's where the Cardano accelerators come
in. We say accelerators as in plural because, as an ecosystem, we have four
that CFI is either running, supporting, or involved with right now. So we have
our own Cardano accelerator program with eight ventures currently happening. We have Drapers Orion.
Fund in the Apex cohort with another eight ventures. We have UNDP SDG blockchain
accelerator with four that's starting soon, and UCLA in 2027 will have five.
So that's just what's running now. Draper and our own program have both either run cohorts
in the past, which I was actually lucky enough to see at Draper University's pitch day,
the Draper Genesis cohort, and that was quite exciting to see how those projects are coming along.
So the culmination of accelerators is giving a boost to dozens of projects across the ecosystem,
and I believe you'll see the results of these ventures move down the builder and founder path
and get investment and scale. And then when we think about scale, we have
an enterprise enablement program, and it's we take established organizations
from a first conversation to a working pilot, and we have a few under NDA at the moment,
but we're excited to announce them towards the end of the year or in 2027. Thanks, Stephen.
And Fred, coming back to the mandate also of the Cardano Foundation. And while some people
say right, we're sort of moving very closely to the completion of the original Cardano roadmap.
Now also with the implementation of Linear Layers in the next hard fork, how is the mandate of
the Cardano Foundation changing? And also,
how do we measure whether what we in the foundation do is actually successful?
So if you So there's two types of mandates here. If you really want to sort of go back
into origination, right? So the first two entities were created, of course, as you know,
our Asian entity, they devolved to Immurgo, right, and then
Charles's amazing engineering company IOG had some very clear mandates around, you know,
building say the first version of Cardano in Charles's case, right, and then work around
the commercialization of Cardano. The Cardano Foundation is slightly different because it was not
about a set of contracts or stuff like that. It was actually put into what's called a deed,
and the foundation has a deed which really talks about the promotion of third-generation blockchains
such as Cardano, and it alludes to specifics around, for instance, regulation, policymaking,
and the fact that we are not for profit also indicates very strongly that this is about something
about time that we optimize towards a longer time horizon. As you probably
and I've been speaking a lot about before, we had three things really trying to nail.
One was operational resilience. So how do you know and how can you ensure
that Cardano also exists in ten years, twenty years, thirty years time? And this is it's not easy,
specifically not in a distributed, decentralized way. But I think here Cardano has made
huge progress, and also why I'm so thrilled about some of the things who's happening in that area.
The other part was really about the regulatory and policy work. As you probably saw,
we were one of the few, if not the only, who actually gave direct feedback
to the new MiCA consultation. But we also did it on the SEC. So there's consultations, right?
So we work very closely with policymakers and regulators around the world to ensure
that wherever you are, you can use Cardano technology in the use cases which makes the most sense
for you. And we can now measure that it becomes better, faster, and cheaper than normal technology,
right? Which means that we're now also starting to see some proof points to the regulators
and policymakers where we can talk about GDP growth, we can talk about job creation,
we can talk about doing things which is better for their constituency than before. And on that note,
I'm super proud of the achievement, specifically in India around three projects there,
two from Trivolve, right, with the police stations and the tracking trace of Grain,
but also Five AM, who's been doing amazingly. And the last note as I got was that they're close
to 200,000 farmers connecting the Syngenta with low orbit satellites, but giving you know
essentially education, digital identity to farmers, and giving them a job, giving them relevance,
and giving the community opportunities to get into digital finance.
And then the last was enabling adoption, and enabling adoption is not the same as adoption.
But this this was really about you know containers, language choice in terms of development.
You know, token models, standards, and those things. And as you saw, we made a huge push in terms
of the agenda of AI payment rails around the programmable tokens. We added
multiple programming languages, including building a complete new one with Icon,
who actually was accepted on GitHub as a true programming language. Which I think most people
don't really realize how big that is. But as we see now, that Imuco is is you know really doing
a lot of work in terms of paying back all the unfortunate souls who were hit by that hack.
And has really winded down operations, and IOG is going on to sort of the next phase,
which is you know building on top of Cardano. You know it leaves a wide open space
for who's actually going to coordinate and ensure adoption is happening.
And you know I think it's fair to say that in the earlier years or four years ago,
we we tried a couple of things to build a few products, which was not so revenue generating,
in order to see if we could position that in a gap and inspire people with the art of the possible.
And as you see now, we are working with the venture hub and acceleration programs and funding models
and trying to attract outside in capital. Such as you know Draper and the Orion Fund,
but also others. So we can make you know you know attract outside in capital to Cardano,
but the coordination and the adoption is where we need to put focus. And what we're doing now in
the Cardano Foundation is we are changing tech. So instead of you know using automation
to to fire people, we are actually using automation to make the organization more lean,
and then use the resources saved in commercialization and business development.
Now we have to be very clear, huh? The Cardano Foundation will never, ever be able alone to make
Cardano economically self-sustainable with the amount of resources we have available
for the foundation alone and the amount of people. This has to be done together
with the current community and the future community as we onboard more
and more people from other ecosystems but also from other industries to actually come into Cardano.
One of the things that often gets discussed are the visible and invisible contributions of
the Cardano Foundations. Right, and it is sometimes very difficult to exactly attribute what
we do with sort of what is perceived by the community. So, Fred, from your perspective,
maybe you could also highlight what is the work that the Cardano Foundation
is doing in the background that people maybe don't see on a day-to-day basis.
And another hard question, curveball: Are we doing enough? Do we spend enough on on these sort of
visible and invisible contributions to Cardano? Yeah. So. I think this is one of those questions
I'm struggling a little bit with, right? Because I do believe that with our activity report,
which we launch every year, with the amazing work from the marketing and comms team in terms
of what's happening on CardanoFoundation.org, but also what we're posting to Cardano.org
and through different channels, I think we are extremely transparent. Now,
are we exactly hitting your X feed or your LinkedIn feed or your Discord channel when you are awake?
And sometimes, as you probably have seen from me, I I tend to write very long things
and not sort of short, spicy stuff. Is a really good example. But when we kind of look deeper,
right? Things a lot of things that people don't realize is for instance when we talk policy work
and regulation, it's not everything we can disclose when we speak to politicians
and regulators around you know what should the new standards look like and how we do that.
Is I think a lot of people haven't noticed that we actually done active market making as I
as I wrote I wrote a blog post some half a year ago saying we put an eight digit amount of ADA
into market making DeFi and so on, right? And we've been market making actively.
Stablecoins on Cardano and actually been able to decrease the slippage of USDT
and USDM transactions radically more than fifty percent. Right? We are also soon going to announce
that we started market making on Chicago Merchant Time, right for futures.
But we also got us listed with futures. So I think for me it's always a I'm always super curious
and always happy to hear when people tell me Hey, talk a little bit more about what you do in
one field." But when I look at what the organization does, what I try to measure is we have
a burn rate at the moment, which is close to twenty-seven, twenty-eight million Swiss francs a year.
So this is basically what we are spending, which is a lot, right? It's
nearly one hundred nine people. And I always try to kind of when I onboard new people,
like our new CFO who's been here for a year, I always ask him that question:
When they've been there for a while, are we punching hard enough for what we are spending?
And I'm trying to get to a situation that we at least you know are making an impact,
which is double the amount of what we are spending. And this is actually quite hard to measure,
right? Because you know there is good spending and bad spending, and there's perceptions.
And you know did you do the right thing at the right time? And we also did things where we thought
it was the right time and the right thing, and it didn't pan out. But other times we really need it,
right? And we support projects which I think a lot of people have never thought would be possible.
But the fact that Cardano now is a is a blockchain in the top tier, in the top ten
of the transaction makers on Cardano. We have, you know, farmers and low orbit satellites. You know,
really changing the social systems. We have police stations in India. We have track and trace.
We have privacy. You know, we have a lot of things which you don't necessarily see on
other blockchains. We do a lot in in. In DeFi, so this year or the past year,
we really set forward to do a lot more DeFi. I'm really happy with the work we got going with
Alpha Growth, but we also try to support a lot of the DeFi builders and found
some structural problems in the DeFi ecosystem, which we are now trying to solve and look at.
But lucky to say that we are working together with some experts in our own community
around these things. But I do think that the Cardano A DeFi kernel, if you can call it that.
I think there is some optimization opportunities, and I think it's important that Alpha Growth,
together with Draper, us, and many others, are keep pushing that forward.
We need to have a healthy balance between, you know, the different industries who can
who can benefit on Cardano. And because you were also just speaking about the funds of
the Cardano Foundation and how much resources we sort of spend on a yearly basis. Of course,
Stephen. I need to bring you in as the CFO and also ask you. At the moment,
there is a treasury withdrawal proposal for the Cardano Global Events strategy for 2027
for 12 different events all around the world where Cardano should have a presence.
The question came up: Why is that something that should be funded by the treasury
and not covered by the Cardano Foundation? Yeah, it's a good question,
and so this would not be the first time we've actually done it. And I just want to preface this
at the beginning to say that what we did last year for the 2025. Global marketing initiatives
we plan to have published before the end of the year on Reeve, which includes an attestation
from our auditor. So you'll see that full report that comes out. Now in terms of this year,
you know why is it not just the Cardinal Foundation? Well, the Cardinal Foundation
actually does spend money on marketing inside the foundation. We have events that
we support directly. In terms of this proposal, we also allocate a lot of time. Towards it,
several hundreds of thousands. Right now, I'm estimating on the budget front
above six hundred thousand just in time related to these marketing activities.
So there there is foundation resources put towards this, but this is a Cardano ecosystem effort.
It's not a Cardano Foundation specific item, and the booth is a Cardano branded booth
and shared with projects. And the the treasury is how the community funds shared work like this.
So a model, it's a model that D reps approved in 2025 with nearly seventy percent support. And yeah,
as I said, the foundation still puts its own money in. Thank you, and I think also, I mean,
one one thing that sort of stands out for me when I look at the proposal is that it's here
to promote the project building on Cardano. That it offers them now also valuable exposure all
around the world in these different markets with these different stakeholders, potential customers,
business partners, to actually yeah talk about their solution and the problems that they solve.
So this is also, I think, something that's really important. Andreas, maybe
because I think you you've been also part of the the event last year that happened in Nairobi.
So what what what what do you think about this whole global event strategy? Yeah,
I liked it very much. I mean, it was an amazing concept that we launched last year
or this year actually. We're still in twenty twenty six and the execution.
And I think from from the lessons we learned and the demands we received through
the various interactions with the community is. Actually, we need more events. We need to cover
more ground. We need to be present all around the globe. I mean, obviously, we cannot be everywhere.
Although we have this great, amazing community that is active worldwide,
but we need to be present at the right place in the right time. And I think this is something that
we came up with is a good compromise: are these twelve events that we have shared around the globe
during this next calendar year? And the importance is is that those are not,
as mentioned by Stephen, it's not Cardinal Foundation events at all. We are just a mere shadow
to organize these. We are not making any money. These are community events for our builders,
for our projects, to be able to present themselves to the world. And you outcalled,
or some people outcalled that the amount is just crazy. I mean, that's so much money.
I just want to give you a reference: other layer one presence at token this year in Singapore.
They spend the same amount we spend for twelve events at that single event token. So,
I think we are not spending enough. Now you might want to challenge: okay, is it the right way
or the right moment to spend? But again, this investment is an investment for the Cardano projects
to be visible, to be visible to the world, to be able to talk and present themselves,
and then be able to cater, bonding interested parties, customers. Partners,
whatever is needed to be successful. So that's the whole purpose of it. And as mentioned by Stephen,
on top of that, there will be very industry-specific events where the Cardano Foundation
is going again on behalf of Cardano, but where we do the funding directly from the money that
we received and that we manage. So it's going to be a plus. So it's not going to be just the twelve;
it's going to be the twelve plus many more to bring Cardano forward. Thank you, Andreas, and.
Before we move into the next set of questions, I also want to remind everyone here
that if you want to ask Fred, Stephen, Andreas a question, now is the chance to already raise
your hand because we're moving into the Q and A time of this space. Thanks for joining;
I really appreciate it. But Fred, now we talked about accountability in the beginning of the space,
and you also are always welcoming people and say accountability is necessary. So, from your opinion
or in your opinion, what mechanism does the community actually have to hold us in the foundation
accountable? Yeah, let's go with that. Well, the original founders of Cadana, right?
They they wrote the deed and did the maximum to ensure accountability,
meaning that they put it under Swiss law as a as a foundation. That means that the board
and the executives actually has unlimited private liability, right? Towards doing what the founders
instructed us to do, right? So from a from a legal perspective, I think this is
like you know it doesn't get much stronger than that, right? The other part is that we host all
of our spending. Every single transaction we post on the blockchain, we all love.
So we actually use the blockchain for the purpose of ensuring transparency
and ensuring that you can all go through the numbers. And we can even give you the the context files
if you need that for your agenda AI to ensure that that you can read it if you are non-accountant,
right? We also go out more and more clear every year because obviously we came from a place
of distrust due to some previous leadership, right? And so we every year we're trying to be more
and more articulate about what are we trying to do next year. So how it works is that we walk into
the board meeting. We have a external, independent board, right? Who who has been around for
for quite some time now. Most of them hold data as well, and we present them the budget
and the tactical implementation plan, and we hold that up to the ten year strategy,
which I made together with the previous leadership, but also got it verified by Ken Kodama San
and Charles, right? And then they basically, you know, say this is, you know, is
that all you can get out of your people? Is that all you can get out of the funds? Right.
Their job is really to supervise us and to hold us accountable, not just to the deed,
but also to our actions out there, right? And I think that's already quite a lot compared to
many blockchain projects or many engineering companies or many sort of like DAOs out there.
So we're really trying to use our own technology and those things,
and then we're moving even further. Right, so we're saying okay. We have options, right?
So one option would be that if you look at other blockchain foundations,
they have a very big say over the treasury spending, or they actually hold like
a double-digit amount of of the treasury, which they can then you know use in order
to to create you know a better blockchain or more operational resilience or more adoption
or more grants and those things. We received a very a smaller part,
and it was actually only supposed to hold for five years. Huh? We are now close to ten years in,
right? And we are still making it work. So I think we've been from a treasury perspective,
we've been You know, if you look back, we could have done better, but we're still here.
We are paying salaries and we're moving forward, right? And we're now looking at
how can we get as many as much money from the outside into the ecosystem. So we had options,
for instance, when we wanted to scale up the identity standard Veridian on Cardano.
Like one option would be to, like many other companies do, say, oh, we do a treasury withdrawal.
It's good for Cardano's technology. Another option would be: Is there can we do some fundraising
here, right? Can we make this interesting for other people to go in and actually look at it as a
as a business case, and then attract external funding, which of course is a is
a quite hard proposition to do. So we chose the hard proposition to get some learnings,
but also have the opportunity to have external funding coming in. And should there be any sort
of income or revenue based out of that construct, right, that goes back to the foundation
and is legally then founded so that we have to put that into the The promotion
of third-generation blockchains, right? So I think there's quite a lot of things we're doing on
the accountability track, and we're actually trying to be a you know a leader
or trailblazer in this space. And quite often, we're also being approached by
other blockchain foundations, but also other foundations in general and other associations,
and asking for the blueprint of some of the things we do. Perfect, Fred. Thank you so much.
And I think one one point is also important. Maybe you want to talk about Reef a little bit longer
or a little bit more about the accountability there and the audits we do on it,
and how that's also changing trust. Yes, I think it'd be helpful because you know I've been with
the foundation for almost one year now. And when I went into my interview,
I did my homework on the CF by looking at that transaction level data and coming into the interview
with those questions. And it's really easy to read on chain through Reev,
so you know I know firsthand that the the learning curve is quite fast. Now. On the audit side,
we've been talking about that story a lot lately. But maybe something that we didn't talk about is
how long it takes us. And a few months back, I asked the finance team,
"How long does it take you to get the financial statements from the accounting system
to the blockchain through Reef?" And the answer I got: four hours per quarter. Four hours.
So four hours a quarter is not a lot. This is pretty efficient, and the audit side is also
very efficient. So with that, we're moving ahead. With our audited half-year financial plan,
so we're going to present audited financial statements twice a year now instead of once.
Not a legal requirement, but just something that we think would be, you know, helpful.
It's the right thing to do. And Stephen, does that then mean basically that the community
can verify, as you said, every every half year how much we spend and on what?
Or how does that work for people that have never taken a look at the at the data that
we have published? Maybe you could give us a high level overview of what
people can actually see there. Yeah, the interesting thing is they can actually see it quarterly.
We publish quarterly, but in terms of the audit side, where you have somebody who's really checked
our financial statements, this will be able to be done every six months. And if anybody's, you know,
in the call up familiar with financial statement reporting, to have this at a transaction level is
quite unique. I've never seen it before, so it was very exciting for me when I first started to,
you know, be involved with it. All right, that's fantastic to know. Thank you so much. All right,
and again, I need to remind everyone: if you have a question, now is the time to request speaker,
so we can get you on the stage and you can ask your question directly.
Or if you don't have a question right now or you cannot speak publicly for whatever reason,
you can also just share that question as a comment to the post of this space,
and we'll try to to get it. So before we wait for any speakers, I think it's also a good time
to maybe quickly circle back to. Fireblocks and the Fireblocks integration that you mentioned, Fred.
Maybe you could quickly share what this integration unlocks and who will then actually use it.
Yeah, so Fireblocks is really about the merger of DeFi and TradFi, and really taking
the amazing learnings we had from the DeFi community on Cardano, but also other blockchains,
and and match that with the traditional finance rails. And there's a couple of large custodians,
but one stand out among others. And they're sort of the exact market share.
My guess will be that they probably have about 80% of market share in terms
of the large institutional players. So obviously we've been dancing with Fireblocks for many,
many years. And to luckily Phil, the CEO of Immuoco, had a really good connection stronger
than ours, and were able to reposition us to Fireblocks. So after the yeah,
they must have been we've been talking with them for years, right? And then we actually had a deal
on the table, which then didn't happen with the Pentad. And then yeah,
Phil got us in on the table again, and I was able with my team to go in
and close that deal with the backing of the Pentad. But we actually signed that against
the Cadano Foundation. And what it really unlocked is 70 to 80 percent
of the institutional custodian market. Now this doesn't bring us a lot without issuance on Cadano.
But for my point of view, this is what we're getting to, right? And what Fireblocks also has told us
is that they want to have a joint go-to market with the Calanna Foundation sales team
and our community to go out there and close some of these large opportunities. Huh? Perfect.
Thank you for explaining that. I don't see any hands yet, so you just have to bear with me
and my questions. Sorry about that, but. Since we are now also moving into a sort
of decentralized development process for Cardano, we've seen all of the different spinouts
and new companies that take over a lot of the responsibilities from IOG. Whether it's Block PQR
or ICN or Midgard Labs, what is the role of the Cardano Foundation in this new environment?
So my view has always been very strong, right? So IOG is the best position to build blockchains.
But as they are now transitioning into their to building upon blockchains and building
other blockchains, right? We see some of these companies now emerging as let's call it being
the the resilience layer or the maintenance layer of Cardano, but also getting hopefully some
of the development for future features and future upgrades of Cardano.
So I'm really looking forward to seeing how these new committees from Intersect is going to
you know distribute some of that work. But even more, I'm looking forward to seeing
how the new node teams are going to ensure that we all stay in sync with each other, right?
And how we get to a situation that potentially we can turn the business model upside down.
So we had a business model before, which was research first, then engineering,
and then potentially adoption, depending if there was an opportunity for adoption of what
we actually built. And I think this was amazing because it allowed us to build something which is
safe and secure, is you know, is so well documented, right? And to a situation
that we might have gotten not gotten everything right, but we got a lot of the things right.
Now we have the opportunity to turn this upside down, and instead of having research first,
thinking about commercial first or thinking business-driven first. So basically,
look at the business needs, which allows us to get maximum adoption. Then give that to research,
and then to engineering. So I'm looking forward to seeing how we can sort of do a pivot
that we become business or commercial first. Whether that is for retail needs,
or whether that is for B2B to C clients, or whether that is B2B. When I say commercial,
and everybody always thinks about large companies, it doesn't necessarily have to be
large companies. But we need to have more users. I can see we already have the first speaker here
on stage. Welcome, Jonah! Great to see you. Please go ahead and ask your question.
Thank you so much, Nicholas. Thank you, Fred, and thank you, Stephen, for joining the AMA.
And I love—I love this format. I would love to see more of them. Maybe once a quarter would be
kind of awesome, or twice a year even. But my—I have a large question,
and it revolves around sort of: Will the CF or does the CF have any appetite
or plan to broaden your global offices or reach out to other areas? Regions of the globe,
because right now you're primarily focused on the European sector. And I don't know if it's
financially viable, but I feel like now that the other FE founding entities
have sort of stepped away, and the CF is picking up the mantle, you know,
is their budget is is it a possibility to have offices in other nation capitals around the globe?
Thinking New York, San Francisco, Tokyo, you know, Latam, that sort of expansion. Yeah,
I think that's a fair question to have, and it's something that was kind of worrisome. First,
I want to sort of emphasize one thing: our offices are not meant as distribution offices;
is meant more as administrative offices. So, as you know, we are incorporated in Switzerland,
which basically means that we need to have a quite strong presence there from a regulatory
and legal perspective. And we were looking at a world where IOG also had
really good commercial teams, and they were covering the the US right, and Imoco were covering Asia.
And I think there is a big need to be around the world where action is happening.
And what I'm observing right now is that, as I said before, I don't think we would ever win by using
the Cardano Foundation's balance sheet or the community appetite for treasury withdrawals
by building up a thousand people sales force. It just doesn't—it just—it doesn't scale.
So we have two people in Brazil, which is doing amazingly well there. So you've probably seen
quite a lot of adoption from, you know, Petrobras to Blockforce from our master tag team down there.
But we also saw India was really moving, and as you probably know, we don't have any physical people
in India, right? But we have Rahul and his team, you know, more than you know,
tens of people there who's really good contact with the government and can get
governmental contracts. And we have Yoram and his team, which is also partly on the ground there.
And my hope was always that the community would be able to create business
by actually distributing Cardano in many different countries. So for me, it's always a bit of a:
how do we show that this can happen in all countries without actually having an office there?
But on the other hand, how do we support the people who is actually on the ground there
in the best possible way? And sometimes, you know, it could be that that we simply need to open
a small support office or at least have some people on the ground more stationary.
But I think what you are going to see, you're going to see some more salespeople from
the Cardano Foundation in more different countries. And we are specifically,
we are definitely not just focused on Europe. I want to be very clear about that.
And I'm not so sure that that Europe is going to be the largest adoption we're going to see in
the next three to five years in terms of transactions. They might be quite large in terms
of blockchain usage, but might not be in terms of transactions. Thank you so much, Fred.
Just one little quick follow up on that. I mean, Europe is leading the way in sort
of the regulatory landscape, and and so that makes a lot of sense. Is there any way
to sort of You know, can the Cardano Foundation help port that sort of regulatory schemas, you know,
into broader environments? Like, can you bring that sort of pragmatic, you know, professionalism to
the United States per se, and you know, help influence policies and regulations in this country,
or is that kind of way out of scope? No, not at all. And we are doing that.
We actually this week we had three people on the ground in Utah at the state- endorsed
digital identity conference. They were on stage presenting Cardano and our identity platform,
and they spoke with more than twenty different politicians, regulators,
policy makers from different states. I will try and do. I think I tried to type something in on X.
I'm sorry, I'm really bad on X. I probably need some help there from somebody who's better than me.
But yeah, so we had a team over there, really talking to the regulators,
and we were actually a part of changing the the constitution of Utah. I don't know
if you're actually aware of that. So we've been working so close to through the Utah government,
right, around privacy and protecting kids specifically around guardianship, right,
and showing them what you're able to do on Cardano, but also off chain using what's called
the Carry standard. Which is interoperable now with Cardano due to the work from
the Cardano Foundation, right? And that actually led to this huge opportunity about state-endorse
digital identity. So if you if you go on X or on LinkedIn, if you can't find something now,
I will certainly ensure that you find something. And I've also been on the Hill.
I was been talking to the agriculture and commodities. People there, right? Plus,
we're also working, you know, and in other countries, we've been part of giving advice,
but also co-writing the digital asset regulation for some African countries, etc.
So we have a quite large legal team, and we are trying our best. But we we cannot cover
all countries. But the U.S. Needs to be covered. I think there's a lot of things going to be
very beautiful and happening in the U.S. In the next, you know, couple of years.
And Cadano has to be maximum positioned in order to take benefit from that. Perfect. Thank you.
Thank you so much, Jonah. Also for the questions. I can see we already have another speaker,
and it's great to see you again, Jenny. How are you doing? Please ask your question. Hi, Nico.
Nice to see you too. Nice to see everybody as always. Love the spaces.
Love the open format for questions. As well as taking questions in advance is always good for
for organization purposes and making sure that you cover everything. But you know,
having this like open open forum is super important for building trust and all that.
So great to see it. Um, my question goes. This is regarding. Kind of like synergy,
and how can we like find ways to work together better? Right. Like if you look at the timelines,
and this is of course like we've we've been famous for like the discourse and Cardano and whatnot.
It's something to whatever it means. Something that is part of who we are,
but something that I've been seeing a lot, and this is going on for many many months.
And I've tried to address it. I am an ambassador for for Cardano. I'm a Cardano ambassador.
I've been part of the ambassador program for quite some time. And I also joined
the ambassador program for midnight, so then I can get more educated and understand
what exactly was happening there, and how does that really like work and with for Corano?
What what happens there and whatnot? So a few months ago, I tried to address some things
on the other side, on the midnight side. But I didn't quite get to where I wanted to get.
So maybe with you guys, you guys can give me some perspective. I feel like we have
these ambassador programs, right? And I see a lot of people kind of talking about whether this.
You know, having Midnight does it help Cardano? Does it not help Cardano?
Having something like Veridian, right? Does it help spinning up on his own company?
Does it help Cardano? Does it not help Cardano? And and the roles of ambassadors, right? So
if you have ambassadors for like Cardano, we have ambassadors. Midnight has ambassadors. I have,
I've, you know, there's several different. Companies that have been building on Cardano,
they also have ambassadorship programs. How can we find a way to get ambassadors to collaborate?
We had this this collaboration, this this meeting with ambassadors for the first time last year in
in Germany, and it was amazing. Right? It was a really good way to like get us to work together,
which we haven't done in all the many years that we've been doing this. So what I'm thinking is,
would it be possible for us to have some sort of programs where ambassadors of different things,
different projects, different blockchains building or companies they're building,
someone collaborating with Cardano to connect to have like some sort of workshops
and things where everybody can learn from what everybody's building.
So then we can better help filling the gaps. As ambassadors, and and kind of like really have
an understanding and finding a way to communicate whether something works one way or another,
and you know just avoid a little bit of the discourse and be a little bit more educated.
Does does that make sense to you guys? I wasn't prepared to speak, so I didn't know
how to put this together. But absolutely makes sense, right? How can ambassadors also sort of first
of all, how can we share? And collaborate better within the ambassador program, and then maybe also
how can ambassadors help with actually being the sort of entrance into new markets
or into new into new opportunities for Cardano. And well, and communicate like amongst communities,
right? You have like different projects that might bring their own communities
from other blockchains, and how can they actually integrate better with Cardano?
Something that I've noticed, for example, there's a lot of people. That came to during midnight.
They don't know much about Cardano, right? So when we talk about all this discord, it's like, oh,
is it good for Cardano? Is not good for Cardano? I mean, couldn't we make it better for Cardano
if we actually like integrated the communities as well and kind of like teach the people
that come to other block blockchains that might just touch with Cardano,
might not necessarily be just a Cardano project, but they're using Cardano one way or another
and have find ways to kind of like open the avenues to really working together, right?
Yeah, no, I completely agree with that. Maybe Fred, from your perspective, what what do you think?
How can ambassadors better sort of collaborate or even help with the adoption initiatives of CF
or of the Carano ecosystem in general? Yeah, I think that's the that's the number one question
in terms of how do you get to a global sales force, right, who doesn't work for one entity
and takes order for one person, right? As in reality, what we really want to get to on this journey.
Um, I think. I'm not close enough to sort of ambassadors for many other ecosystems,
but I was quite close to a set of ambassadors who who actually contacted us
and ran some programs together with the Polkadot ambassador system. Right?
And I think that brought some really good perspectives and some really good things over the line.
But in general, I think blockchain has an adoption problem, and that's also a huge opportunity
which is changing right now due to the way AI agents work. And you can see we have, you know,
several hundred companies live in Masumi now using the security and collaboration of Cardano
as a stack. So I think the three things I would sort of hone in on, Jenny, to kind of answer this is
Cadano Academy. I still see a lot of people who actually love Cadano have
sort of a high level feeling about it, but they haven't really tried to express a business model
or a business idea. On Cardano, and luckily today we actually don't need engineers to do a pilot
anymore. And there's a really cool program on the Cardano Academy who helps you get to a level
where you can use your favorite AI agent to try and solve your business problem on Cardano.
The second thing is target operating models. So how can you actually solve a problem
which not is not just a nice-to-have problem, but something which is you know
either Something who cost a lot of money, so by solving it you you basically save money.
Something who can make more sticky clients, or something who can make something go better
or more smooth in terms of the business model you're in. And when I speak to ambassadors from
around the world, I see they have all this business knowledge and they have this really big passion,
and they tend to be inspired by looking on blockchains and other blockchains.
And I think where they should be really inspired is the business knowledge they have from
their normal day job or from the people in the community they live in, right?
And that really you know creates fantastic opportunities. So I think that's the two advices
I would give, and then in general I think among blockchains there's a bit too much competition.
You know, if you like one blockchain, then you cannot be seen liking another, right?
And I think here there is actually you've probably seen me on stage a few times also giving
some some kudos to to some other blockchains who's doing something well.
And I think Cardano is actually well positioned to that because a lot of the research
Cardano has been doing has led to other blockchains the you know technology choices
and architectural choices. And Cadano has always been about interoperability. It's not been about
how do Cadano take over the world. It's about how do we create a better world,
both from a financial system perspective and from social systems. Thank you, Fred. Yeah,
to that real quick. I guess something what I have in mind is like kind of like. Inviting
other other blockchains to collaborate, like you just mentioned the Cardano Academy, right? So
if we were to say maybe I mean we have an ambassador call later. I'll probably talk about
this there, but maybe if there is like a way for us to do like an open invitation and be like, hey,
we have a special Cardano Academy program for midnight ambassadors to understand more
how Cardano works. So then when they're they see more of the where we meet, right?
And then I would like to see the same for. Midnight ambassadors, the Cardano ambassadors
can get invited to understand more about how Midnight works and how they that meets with Cardano.
Right? I think these are the precisely for what you were talking about, like
how to to avoid a little bit of that competition and more like the really working together
and kind of like see how we all solve different problems and how can we get creative
and mesh those those solutions together, right? I think from a business perspective,
I would then focus on the ambassador programs around the Hyperledger, around the R3 Corda,
around the sort of permission blockchain space. I think there's a lot of opportunity
if you can excite some of them to come over to Cardano. You can use the business knowledge
and the architecture they've been doing, and really bring it live with the trust
and the coordination and security layer of Cardano. That would be a really low-hanging fruit.
I love that, yeah, for sure. But I guess we got to try with the ones that are here too right now.
So yeah, I agree. Thank you, Fred. Great question, great comments, Jenny.
I think you definitely we should also talk with Sebastian, who's managing the ambassador program.
I think he also has some ideas on on how to improve it. But given that we're almost at the end
of this space, I also want to give our panelists one last chance to say some final words. Well, no,
that sounds horrible. But Fred, maybe from your perspective, also if we look back in 10 years,
what do you think a successful Cardano looks like? And also, what is the role that the CF plays in
us getting there? So maybe if I start with the ladder, right? It was never foreseen that
the Cardano Foundation should stay forever, right? And as I said, the first initial you know
budget ideas were you know five years and then it should sort of leave the ecosystem.
So I don't know if the Cardano Foundation will be here in ten years' time.
We're definitely out of money in ten years' time, I can tell you that.
And we want to give it a big shot now to create adoption and to ensure
that Cardano really can get utilized and we can fill those blocks. But for me personally,
there is two things I would like to see looking back in ten years. The first and foremost is that.
We actually were true to the vision of Charles that we can change the social systems
and the financial systems for the better of everybody who calls this spaceship,
the whole Earth home, right? And I think there's if there's ever been more insecurity,
more you know like big. Technology trends towards dehumanizing the world is now right,
and if there's ever been a clearer value proposition for this, if you are a little bit techy
and a little bit nerdy about how social science work, you know, Cardano
and blockchain is knocking on the door as it never been before to actually play a role in there.
So I really have big hopes that blockchains in general, but of course Cardano is specifically,
is going to help society for the better. The second part is we really need to make
Cardano economically self sustainable today. If you look at it right. You know,
we simply do not have enough transactions on Cardano, right? And we don't need just one type
of transactions. You know, like a bot who's trading against each other. We need
diverse transactions. Who solving the first part where I was just explaining about
how we can change society, right? And and you know, it's unbelievable how many X we need to get to.
And so what we have right now is we have a huge pressure on ADA due to the fact that that the system
basically is is overheated, right? And you can think about the market.
You can think about treasury draws. You can think about lack of transaction.
There can be many reasons, right? But in order for us to succeed, the transactions generate
or generates an income. To Cardano needs to match the cost for for stake pool operators, delegators,
and research going forward. That piece has to be there, right? Because then you are into
economic self sustainability. Thanks, Fred. And then question to you, Stephen:
Successful Cardano in ten years, what does it look like, and what role does CCF play to get Cardano
there? So I like math, so I do the math on this one, and so I align with Fred's mentioning the
how many X we have to do, and trying to see what we can do inside of Cardano perimeters
or whatever we can do to make this a reality is is really what I'm excited to look at in
the coming years. Now, in 10 years, absolutely need to push towards a sustainable Cardano,
and those. Pushing towards that direction and looking at the numbers along the way is really,
you know, what I'm thinking about. Now I'm I'm newer than the rest of the EC team
from the foundation, and something that I've been learning a lot about
the last year is with from within the CF. I've learned a lot from the people within the CF,
but I've been learning a lot from the community as well. You know, recently
when we were at Token in Singapore. A lot of people came up to me and talked about their struggles
or you know projects they've been working on, and some of them were very exciting,
and some of them you know we have to figure out solutions for. But I think I'm also excited
to you know keep being involved with the community, learning from you, and you know onward
and upward together. Very well said, thanks Stephen. Andreas, what do you think about
that successful Cardano in ten years? What do we do to get us there? Yeah,
I mean there's two elements that I see. I mean, COO is always very boring and operationally driven.
For me, it's really Cardano should become a key piece of critical infrastructure
in the different industries, covering multiple use cases in multiple areas, bridging
new tech with old tech, but also replacing old tech and bringing and being part
of the critical infrastructure of an enterprise. Are we there yet? No. Are we closer? Yes.
And as mentioned by Fred, we are working on the operational assurance that we get the trust
that these enterprises rely upon Cardano being the critical infrastructure. If we get there,
that's that's the major goal achieved. And then the second part obviously is that.
We have so many enthusiastic people in our community, and that's just amazing. And I love the energy
and and and the the whole spirit that goes into it—that to be successful and to challenge
and to to scream at each other. That if something is not going well, and often CF is is at
the one end of the receiving end, which I understand. Somebody needs to be it,
and we are here for that as well. But what I really would like to hope is that. Each
and every single priority gets aligned together because we cannot just have DeFi, tradeFi,
have liquidity. We we need we need a combination of everything.
So security can never be jeopardized. So we need to have a safe, stable Cardano infrastructure.
We need to have vibrating, running projects, and we need to have liquidity that goes into in
from outside and inside. So we need to look at each other and see what is needed to be successful,
and not just focus on a single case. It needs everything together. And if that happens,
we're gonna win it. We're definitely gonna win it. Thank you so much, everyone,
for joining today's session. Let's talk about it. Great questions from the audience.
Really appreciate Jonah for joining, Jenny for joining, asking great questions, and of course,
everyone that participated in the AMA by listening, by asking questions to our to our post.
Thank you so much also to Andreas, Stephen, and of course Fred for being here today.
I hope you have a wonderful rest of your day.
Take care and see you on the next AMA. Take care. Bye bye.

Want more TVL for your protocol or chain?

AlphaGrowth grows TVL for protocols and chains through asset acquisition and integration, grants, incentives and LP deals. We built this data and keep it free.